Aaron Graff
Vice Chairman & CEO
Replay available
Triumph Financial (NYSE:TFIN) Q2 2022 earnings call, held 2022-07-21. Watch the replay and read the transcript on 6ix.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/triumph-financial-inc-tfin-q2-2022-earnings-call
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Good morning. Welcome to the Triumph Bancorp conference call to discuss our second quarter 2022 financial results. Before we get started, I would like to remind you that this call may include forward-looking statements. Good morning. Welcome to the Triumph Bancorp conference call to discuss our second quarter 2022 financial results. Before we get started, I would like to remind you that this call may include forward-looking statements. Those statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual and anticipated results to differ. The company undertakes no obligation to publicly revise any forward-looking statement. For details, please refer to the Safe Harbor Statement in our shareholder letter and earnings release published last evening. All comments made during today's call are subject to that Safe Harbor Statement. I'm joined this morning by Triumph's Vice Chairman and CEO, Aaron Graff, our Chief Financial Officer, Brad Voss, Todd Ritterbush, President of TBK Bank, Jeff Brenner, our CEO of Triumph Business Capital, and Melissa Foreman, our President of Triumph Pay. With that housekeeping out of the way, I'd like to turn the call over to Aaron.
1:03 Good morning, everyone. We hope that the shareholder letter we published last evening was helpful for you in preparing for this call. At this time, we're ready to open the call up for any questions. All right, if you have any questions, feel free to use the raise hand feature and activate your camera. Our first question comes from Michael Rose from Raymond James. Michael, feel free to ask your question.
1:28 Hey, thanks. Good morning, everyone. Thanks for taking my questions. Obviously, a lot of moving parts this quarter, a lot of repositioning efforts. We'd love to get some context there, but first just wanted to dig into the average invoice size. It definitely held up better than I think we were modeling, and I think there's been a lot of chatter in the trucking space about invoice prices and freight costs and things like that. Can you just kind of walk us through kind of the dynamics and maybe what you might expect for invoice prices as we move forward? It doesn't seem like they're going to get back down to where they had been kind of pre-COVID, just given structurally higher fuel prices and labor costs, but we'd just love any insights.
2:14 into kind of the nearer term direction of TBC. Thanks.
2:21 Hey, Michael, this is Jeff. I'll take that one. I think we've benefited from heightened diesel prices. And as you know, that factors into the average invoice size. And we think the imputed higher diesel prices in these invoices has held them up from what we had called for, which is a gradual return to normal. So that dynamic certainly occurred in Q2. And looking into Q3, if diesel prices stay at or about their current levels and if utilization stays at or about its current level, which is about 96%, we would anticipate cautiously optimistic return or holding flat and then an eventual return back to what you'd seen several years ago.
3:09 Okay, thanks. And then maybe as a follow-up, just on the network side, I think the trends there may be a little bit weaker than what we've modeled, but just as we think about kind of the intermediate term, are there any updates to when you guys expect for the network to really become break-even and then begin to generate some profitability? It does look like the ramp is perhaps a little bit slower than You know, at least I was expecting, but we just love any updated color there. Thanks.
3:42 Yeah, great question. I'll take that. And if I say anything wrong, Melissa will correct it. But as we've tried to focus the market on, there is a steady drip every quarter of clients coming into the Triumph Pay ecosystem. It's just that the ones that really move the needle are the ones we describe as tier ones because they control such a large amount of business, each one of them individually and certainly collectively. We pointed out in the letter, we have over $15 billion in volume in the pipeline, and those are chunky because they come associated with large names.
4:28 That's just the identifiable pipeline. So given where we are in the year, where we are in the integration schedule, I would actually expect for Q3 the gross payment volume to be flat to perhaps down slightly, just if invoice prices do moderate even more. We expect there to be a big increase Spike upwards in Q4 when we go live with the first part of this group of new clients who are in the pipeline and it's going to be chunky from there or it'll be a step function each time a new one comes on just because of their size. And so revenue will move right along with that. And ultimately, we believe we are on track to exit 2024 with a business that's doing over $75 billion in payment volume, an ever-growing portion of that being conforming transactions upon which we charge network fees. And we think at that pace or at that sort of scaled size, that gross revenues will be $100 million and this will be a business that generates positive EBITDA. So that timing is still intact.
5:41 You're just seeing the first quarter in a while where we didn't bring someone live onto the system, but that pause won't last very long.
5:55 Okay, helpful. And then maybe just finally for me, Any updates on, you know, you talked about the potential for the contract, you know, shipper market at some point. I didn't see much in the shareholder letter about that. I mean, I know there were some, but we just love an update. You know, there you previously had slides, and I think you were, you know, kind of two to three percent, you know, by your math of kind of the volume there. What's kind of the outlook there, and should we be thinking about that? And then Just with the repositioning efforts, I mean, a lot of moves this quarter. Could we expect, moving forward, much cleaner results? Because I think there has been a lot of noise in the numbers. Thanks, guys. Shipper?
6:41 Yeah, I think on the shipper market, we did have one tier one shipper come onto the platform in Q2. And so we've seen some growth in that business. We also made an additional investment in Intelligent Audit, which is a freight audit company in that space to further our initiatives in that segment of the market. And so there's significant total addressable market available in the shipper space. You know, when you look at the contract shipping, it's about a $250 billion opportunity. So we're continuing to invest there. And the additional investment with IA has allowed us to really reposition our relationship there and then our Our strategy within the market to be more in line with our open network that we're building out for Triumph Pay.
7:35 So you'll see more coming soon on that side.
7:38 Yeah, Mike, I wouldn't overlook that intelligent audit investment as being consistent with what we've always said. There is another market yet to go get more of. We have a couple billion of it, but there's a lot more to go get. And so things are happening. And then in response to your last question about expecting clean quarters, I can never predict quarter to quarter what opportunities are going to present themselves. But I think it is likely that the next few quarters won't have anywhere near this amount of noise. But as you said, we want everyone to understand we are still in a period of strategically turning this business towards where we want it to go. And as a result, there's going to be things along the way where we reallocate parts of what we're doing to things that are consistent with our future strategy. So there may be noise in quarters to come, but I don't expect it to be anything like this one.
8:37 Appreciate all the color. Thanks for taking my questions. Got it. And our next question comes from Matt Olney from Stevens.
8:54 Hey, guys. Good morning. Good morning, Matt. I also want to dig more into T-PAY. I thought most of the two Q metrics showed some improvement or at least were similar to what I was forecasting. We saw a higher number of invoices, higher dollar amount of invoices, but the dollar amount of receivables was down a quarter. I'm not clear if the turn times increased or the discount rates declined. Any comment you can give us on why the average dollar amount of the receivable declined in Triumph today?
9:31 Yeah, that would be in direct alignment with the average invoice price going down. The receivables themselves are tied to the amount of the invoice, and so as that has softened within the portfolio, we'll see that revenue drop.
9:48 Okay. Yeah. And then within Triumph Pay, also curious about the investment spend there. I appreciate that it's vital what you're trying to achieve, but help us appreciate the ramp of the expense in that Triumph Pay segment. When do you expect that ramp to moderate? How close are we to that?
10:12 So right now, our investment is primarily in our operations folks. So as we continue volume on the platform that requires support and contact center support for the customer service side of that. As we look at our future growth and what's in our pipeline, as Aaron mentioned, we have $15 billion that's kind of stacked up, ready to come onto the platform. that is a significant increase. And so we are in preparation of that volume, staffing our teams up so that we're prepared for it and have the training, et cetera, in place to be able to handle that smoothly for our customers. So you'll continue to see us invest operationally to support the growth and that will continue to go out through 2024.
11:03 Yeah, I think Matt, to your question on whether The glide slope is probably flattening a little bit. We did a significant amount of hiring and building with TriumphX, bringing in some very expensive but very valuable team members to help us shape this strategy. So the go-forward investments are always to update the software ecosystem. I mean, that's a living, breathing thing. But most of the ads are in operational support, so it won't have – It'll be a flatter growth from here.
11:43 Okay, that's helpful. Thank you for that. And then just, I guess, lastly, we've talked in the past about eventually doing some syndications within Triumph Pay. Just remind us, how close are we to seeing these syndications? Is this something we could see towards the end of this year, or is this more of an initiative that we'll see more impactfully in 2023?
12:05 I think it's going to be more of a 2023 issue, Matt. We're not balance sheet constrained, as you know from everything that we've – all the repositioning that has been done. And so we're not in a position where we need to be selling those assets to make room for the balance sheet allocation we have for it. We think that's a future state problem when we have significantly more volume coming across the system. But nevertheless, just like we wanted to create the plumbing for equipment finance syndication opportunities, the syndication inside of Triumph Pay, it would be wise of us to do one in 2023 just to demonstrate that the plumbing works for ourselves and our counterparties and investors. So I think even if we have the balance sheet room to hold it all, you'll see us do the first one of those next year.
12:59 Okay. Thanks. I'll step back in the queue. Our next question comes from Steve Moss from B Reilly.
13:11 Sorry about that, guys. Morning. Good morning. You know, on the pipeline here, you guys mentioned that there's 15 billion in annualized payment volume here online. Is it, you know, is all that just what is in integration or some of that also like contract contracted but not yet started in terms of API integration?
13:39 Yeah, it's a both in right when this is this is. Volume that is in the contracting phase, and we have already started integration, but we haven't signed the final contract or completed the integration. Okay. It's not as linear of a process as you would expect. These are long. By the time you get into the point where you're working on the contract, that means you're also working on integrations.
14:13 And then in terms of just the conforming volumes here, just conforming transactions, you know, your end of quarter numbers imply a healthy step up. Just kind of how do we think about conforming transaction growth as we go here over maybe the second half of the year?
14:31 Yeah, so as we step up that volume on the payments network, the payment volume where we have those short ones come in, they will be conforming enabled brokers. And then as in the last quarter, we spent a lot of time re-engineering the plumbing for our existing clients to get them to a conforming level as well. So fully integrated conforming capable. So there's still a lot of work to do with our existing clients to get them there. Those take re-engineering and re-integrating existing plumbing for them. But the team has spent a significant amount of time making that happen. So you'll see us to continue to grow that.
15:16 We're continuing to add factors into that network as well so that they can receive that data. So we have a team that is completely focused on just re-engineering the existing clients to get them there. It does take some development efforts on our customer side as well. So we're kind of a little bit at the mercy of their availability to make those changes. But we're making significant progress.
15:40 And Steve, just to take it from just that to a more granular level, it's kind of which side goes first. You need a certain number of large freight brokers to be on the ecosystem for this to make sense for the factoring universe, right? They have to believe that they're going to see 20% of their payments come through as conforming transactions in order to change their business models and take advantage of the network. On the flip side, the large freight brokers want to see more factors on this system because that creates a more efficient way for them to work together. If you look at the market right now, 15% of the payments that Triumph Business Capital receives, they receive from Triumph Pay.
16:27 So that's our penetration of the market as it's going to factors. About 6%, 5% of that volume is coming through as conforming because there's a lag in making sure all of those freight brokers are fully integrated. When you add the $15 billion that's in the pipeline, plus what other things we're working on, The day is going to be here before the end of 2024 when we make far more than 20% of all payments to the factoring industry, and we can deliver almost that same amount in conforming transactions, at which point, if you don't join the network for conforming transactions, your business model is going to struggle to compete with the efficiencies that the other players will have.
17:17 That's helpful. Appreciate that color. And then just one question on expenses here. I hear you guys on the stable expense side, quarter over quarter, but maybe just kind of curious, are you seeing any additional inflationary pressures? There's more about beyond the third quarter.
17:44 Steve, I lost the second half of your question, but I think you were asking about just inflationary pressures on our expense base overall. We have definitely seen... wage competition as we're bringing new people aboard. That's clearly been happening and is continuing. It feels as though it may be moderating a little bit at this point, especially on the technical side. We tell our team all the time that we're in a very good position relative to a lot of other folks who would be bringing on technical talent because we're not beholden to that next round of venture funding and a lot are pulling back in a pretty material way, just given market conditions, and we don't have to do that. But I wouldn't say that it's anything accelerating or anything like that, but we're definitely feeling it to an extent.
18:49 All right. Thank you very much. Appreciate the time. Thanks, Steve. And our next question comes from Brad Millsaps from Piper Sandler.
19:02 Hey, good morning, guys. Morning, Brad. Aaron, thanks for the shareholder letter. That was very helpful. Just kind of wanted to ask around the timing of some of the actions that you took this quarter. I think the factory sale was at the end of the quarter and then was unsure of the timing on to sell the equipment loans. But just curious how both, you know, impacted maybe Q2 results. I know you got us on there. You know, if you don't deploy some of that, you know, kind of what it means for earnings. But just wanted to talk about your ability to kind of replace those lost assets. It looks like you were sitting on more than $700 million in cash at the end of the quarter. So just kind of wanted to think through some of those moving parts.
19:49 Yeah, Brett. Both of those transactions closed in the back half of June. So that cash balance that you see is definitely inflated relative to where we would normally have it be. As far as the opportunities to reinvest, there are several ways that we could go with that. We've already started to some of that. The market has given us an opportunity to invest in some more liquid market investments. I think top of the stack CLO securities, liquid loans, things like that. We'll continue to do that, but we're going to do it at a measured pace. We kind of have to think about our excess capital in a few different buckets, and relevering is one of those buckets.
20:34 Looking at our own shares is another, and holding capital back for another day for a variety of purposes is another. So we look at all of that in totality. As far as what we're giving up, I think we mentioned in our shareholder letter that the net interest margin given up on the equipment portfolio. And as a reminder, that is a fully amortizing set of loans that's a bit of a melting ice cube. And we retain those customer relationships and will continue to originate more assets with those same customers. But we're giving up about a little over $3 million in net interest margin over the balance of this year, another $4 million over the totality of 2023 from the equipment sale.
21:21 General factoring is a little bit harder to pin down because those balances fluctuate quite a bit more and they're not quite as scheduled out, so to speak. But just rough numbers, we're probably looking at about $7.5 million of net interest margin that we'll not receive on those assets.
21:48 And Brad, it's probably... a safe and conservative assumption to assume that we will replace a portion of that revenue over the next few quarters. I think the balance sheet will stay roughly around the size it is, so you'll see some loan growth to the extent we believe in opportunities. But there's going to be a period, certainly this period and next period, where there's some margin that hasn't been backfilled. If we backfill it, when we backfill it, it's going to be consistent with the strategy. So it's very likely going to be either quick pay balances that come from this additional volume coming into Triumph Pay or the continued growth of Triumph Business Capital in its core transportation markets. Everything else around the edges in the community bank and otherwise will do if it's appropriate and as it makes sense.
22:41 So it's okay for us to have the excess capital during this period of time when we are evaluating other ways to invest in Triumph Pay to accelerate its growth in freight audit and pay. When we're looking at the opportunity to buy our own stock back, should the market pull back to a level where we believe that the Triumph Pay call option is priced close to zero, then we think that's a good use of that excess capital. So we're not going to be led to do a less than excellent decision just to protect margin over the next two quarters? I mean, if we give back a few cents in earnings because we maintain optionality, we are very comfortable with that.
23:25 That's helpful. So kind of in the interim, you might see a step back in traditional factoring revenue. But then over the years, you start to kind of backfill that with more TV revenue towards the end of the year and the next quarter. Correct. And I know it's not cool to talk about the bank on these calls, but I'll ask the question. Just curious, you're probably more asset-sensitive at the bank than you ever have been, just given the improvements in your deposit base. How much lift sort of X the impact of the assets that you sold? Do you expect to see a net interest income at the banking segment as you move through 2023 and 2024?
24:08 I think that just looking at the rate environment and our deposit base, about 85% of our deposit base now is what I would consider to be very high quality, non-maturity deposits that are not particularly rate sensitive. We've not really seen any Intense price competition for those deposits so far. Other banks remain fairly liquid as well. We are responding to specific situations as we feel is appropriate. But as far as what the impact of rate changes would be, we're looking at about probably about $3 or $4 million, if I recall, relative to what The net interest market would be over the balance of this year in a flat rate environment.
25:13 So we're projecting another 175 basis points or so of increases on the short end of the curve, and that should produce $3 or $4 million over the balance of this year. And then looking at it beyond that, over the next six months after that, I think another $8 or $10 million, if I recall what the modeling would suggest. Okay, great. Thank you, guys.
25:40 I'll have that continued. And our final question comes from Gary Tenner from DA Davidson.
25:47 Thanks, Morgan, everybody. I'm going to ask another mundane bank question. Noticed in the quarter, the provision was up quite a bit, obviously a tiny bit related to cancellation of the plan to sell the branches. And it looks like the Provision was mostly in the bank segment. So just wondering if you could talk about changes you may have made to your ACL model or otherwise. The ACL is the highest it's been since probably early stages of COVID. Thanks.
26:17 Yes, we did recalibrate our economic model that drives a lot of those ACL changes. results, and we've got a higher probability of a recessionary type environment and higher unemployment, and that's what drove the increase in this period.
26:41 Thank you. All right, we'll take one more question on this line, and then we'll go to the phone line. This one comes from Matt Olney from Stevens.
26:52 Thanks for the follow-up. I want to dig more into the equipment lending portfolio. You know, equipment lending is an asset class I think a lot of investors are becoming more cautious on due to some of the economic headwinds. But you guys announced a loan sale that resulted in a nice premium, and you hinted that it could be more such sales in this asset class. So we'd just love to dig in more into this portfolio and kind of what else you have planned for the future for this.
27:21 I'll take this one. Thanks, Matt, for the question. Yeah, so we definitely intend to do more of these sales in the future. This is completely consistent with our desire to continue to serve our transportation clients with equipment finance solutions without necessarily growing our overall balance sheet. And so, you know, the plan would be for us to continue to originate at at least our current pace and maybe a faster pace going forward. And then as we accumulate balance to continue to either sell to other banks or securitize whatever the best execution would be. In this case, the execution was a sale to another bank. And that bank was just very eager for earning assets. So they were willing to pay a higher price than anyone else. It was a competitive process.
28:07 And so we thought it was a really good move for us to be able to take that gain, basically reload the equipment finance sales team, send them back out to originate more, which allows us to stay within our internal credit limits for our existing clients, and also potentially go out to market for other clients that we haven't pursued in the past. We have pretty high hurdle rates and expectations for what we make for the assets that we keep on our own balance sheet. But we could go after higher quality, lower rate clients with the idea that we would sell those assets in the future and that would open up new markets for us as well. So we're just as committed to equipment finance as a tool to serve transportation clients as we ever were. And with the way we structured this and our ability to retain the relationships with this being completely transparent to the borrower, I think positions us really well to do so.
29:00 And Matt, it should probably... Just so that you have clarity, the equipment finance obviously for us is largely in and around Class A trucking, over-the-road trucking, whether it's trucks, trailers, any type of that equipment. There is construction lending in there for heavy construction equipment, and there is also for waste hauling. And We don't do subprime lending in our equipment finance portfolio, and that means many of the smallest independent owner operators are not our borrowers in that portfolio. It's more of a small to medium-sized fleet product. If you get into large fleet, we're not going to be competitive because, as you know, we try to have pricing discipline. So you're talking about small The actual trucking companies who produce financials and all the things you would expect, which is why the credit quality has performed well enough that we have regional banks who would like to be our counterparty in that. Because it's difficult to produce that many loans as it takes, and they amortize down so quickly because they're made on a fully amortizing basis.
30:18 that there's value in the team, the relationships the team have built, but we've always made sure that we were focusing on the higher end of that universe, and we will continue to do so. And so I think investors are right to have concerns about equipment finance portfolios. I think you're right to have those concerns in any given market. Thank you. We know them well enough to judge credit well, and I hope that this loan sale that we did, you can imagine that the buyer would have looked through that with a fine-tooth comb to understand the risk, and I hope it demonstrates to you and the market the quality of that equipment finance portfolio.
31:20 Yeah, that's helpful, and that all makes sense. And just lastly, I want to ask about capital and capital constraints at the company. It seems like you've got plenty of excess capital today. I think your CET1 is still over 11%. I'm assuming continued capital build because there's no dividend. You talk about freeing up capital. You've done some loan sales. I guess help me appreciate your big picture what the capital constraint is today as you see it.
31:50 Well, on an organic basis, Matt, I don't think there is a capital constraint. I mean, as you watched, we hold our balance sheet relatively at its current level and have done so for several quarters, and we've been far more focused on the mix shift of assets underneath to take us into the transportation-centric future that we envision for ourselves. So the capital constraint is Then comes down to the only other two uses of capital which are on our radar. Number one would be to buy back shares, and we've executed on that. We're not executing on it right at this moment, but that is a tool that we will not hesitate to use if we see our shares pull back to, as we've said, if you're intrinsically pricing Triumph Pay at zero, we'll buy all of it we can because we see the long-term value proposition.
32:45 And the second option would be the use of that capital to buy and invest in technology companies that would support our growth in freight audit and pay, much like we did with intelligent audit. As you would expect, many of those investments, even if the underlying company is profitable, creates a significant intangible, which becomes a use for the capital base we have. So that would be where I would see the constraints to show up, which would be adding additional intangibles. to the balance sheet if the opportunity presented itself, and then ultimately buying back our own shares because we believe in the long-term value of what we're doing, also given where we trade, still create an intangible. That's helpful. Thanks, guys.
33:33 Thank you. All right, I'll hand things over to Chelsea for any questions from the phone line. Thank you. Thank you. At this time, if you would like to ask a question via the telephone, you may do so by pressing star one on your telephone keypad. Once again, that is star one to ask a question. And we'll pause for a moment to allow questions to queue. Our first question will come from Adam Herrick with Ulysses.
34:11 Term restraint in the balance sheet? Medium to longer term, is there any growth that you'd expect to see on the balance sheet?
34:23 No, Adam, I think we're always going to be opportunistic. There is, I would say, no or an extremely small chance we would ever consider going over $10 billion in assets. That's not part of our roadmap here. We want to be more nimble than that. And so between now and the end state, and if the end state is we are the ubiquitous payments network for the trucking industry, and we allow parties to own the receivables that are generated in that structure through syndications, then I think We would say to you over the long term, if we are being successful at the play we have called for ourselves, our balance sheet will shrink from here.
35:17 So just to try to understand how you think about it, and I don't need any guidance, but just directionally, your gap EPS approximates your free capital generation, which means that your optionality going forward vis-a-vis whether you buy strategic technologies or return the capital to shareholders really approximates your earnings and whatever excess capital you generate.
35:47 We would agree.
35:50 Fine. Thank you. Thank you. Once again, that is star one to ask a question. All right, there are no further questions in the queue via the telephone. Thank you all for joining us.
36:19 Sorry. Thank you all for joining us today. We look forward to speaking with you soon. Have a great day.
Follow Triumph Financial, Inc. into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Vice Chairman & CEO
Chief Financial Officer
President of TBK Bank
CEO of Triumph Business Capital
President of Triumph Pay
Analyst, Stephens
Analyst, B. Riley
Analyst, Raymond James
Analyst, Ulysses
Analyst, Piper Sandler
Analyst, DA Davidson