Ashley Paxton
Non-Executive Director and Chair at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED
Replay available
Interim Results hosted by TwentyFour Select Monthly Income Fund (LSE:SMIF) on Investor Meet Company, held 2026-06-10.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/twentyfour-select-monthly-income-fund-limited-smif-interim-results
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Good morning, and welcome to the twenty four SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND Limited interim results investor presentation. Throughout this recorded presentation, investors will be in listen only mode. Questions are encouraged, and they can be submitted at any time using the Q and A tab situated on the right hand corner of your screen. Just simply type in your questions and press set. Before we begin, I would like to submit the following poll. And I would now like to hand you over to Ashley Paxton, chair. Good morning to you. Thank you, Alex, and good morning, everybody, and welcome to, Smith's interim results presentation.
0:35 I'm Ashley Paxton. As Alex introduced me, I'm the chair of twenty four SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND and delighted to be joined by Felipe Villaroyale, the portfolio manager at twenty four Asset Management. As you know, SMIF published its results today for the six months ended March 31, and I'm delighted to provide you with an update on the company's performance for that period. First, I just wanted to recap, and those of you that have, attended this before will be familiar with this. This is the history of SMIF, and, it's grown since 2014 from a 100,000,000, sterling company to around 300,000,000 now, and that's through a combination of share issuance and performance.
1:25 And you can see it's had steady growth in NAV and market caps since launch, which, save for the recent events in Iran, has continued very much over the last six months, and I will come back to that point in a minute. Company has continued to issue shares through tap issuance and at the end of the period had just over 350,000,000 shares in issue compared to around $280,000,000 a year ago. That's again from strong invested in our demand, particularly from our retail shareholders. So a very, very strong year and and indeed the last six months from continuing interest in in in share issuance. And that's continued since the period end, and we've issued another 3,700,000 shares since March 31.
2:17 And all this time, I'm pleased to say that the company continues to, have an average credit rating of double b, its highest. And just finally on this slide, the... During the year, the companies continue to trade at a premium with its shares trading at approximately 1.6% premium over the period. It's slightly dipped at the at the period end, but, again, I will come back to that in a minute. This chart shows Smith's consistent track record and has delivered 109.5% return since inception, average of 6.32% on an annualized basis.
3:05 For the first half of this financial year, the return was naught point 24%, which reflected the impact of a more uncertain geopolitical and economic environment. Whilst Felipe will come back to the geopolitical theme shortly, it's worth highlighting that because of the market volatility by the end of March, our NAV per share had fallen to 82.51p per share. And you can see that as a dip on the far right of this graph. But I'm pleased to say that NAV per share has actually recovered again in April and by June 3 was again back up to 84.3p, and that's really because of the volatility around what's been happening in Iran. I should also mention that not only was our NAV impacted at the period end, but so too was our share price and recorded a discount of 4.5% at the third of... 03/31/2026.
4:02 And, again, I'm pleased to say that subsequently recovered and at the June 3 was trading once again at just over a 2% premium, and that positions it well for further tap issuances accretive to the company. Again, this is a familiar slide, but this demonstrates how, our track record, and, we've consistently as a company exceeded our target, minimum dividend, target of 6p per share, and even whilst interest rates were at historic lows. You will note that the last three years, we actually had really a very strong performance of dividends of over 7 or approximately 7p
4:46 per share for for each of those three years. I don't think we're expecting total dividends to be quite that high this year, but we are still very, very optimistic. And certainly, we've reiterated today our confidence in the company's ability to deliver stable income to investors, and despite the broader economic environment. So we still expect the full year dividend to be in excess of 6 p, and indeed, it will be above 6.5p per ordinary share, we believe. And consistent with the the last couple of years, as a board, we've taken the decision to try where we can to distribute excess income to shareholders more evenly during the year rather than wait for that final month's balancing dividend, which hopefully gives shareholders greater visibility on the level of income they can expect to receive throughout the year.
5:36 For this reason, we announced paying an additional 0.25p per share in addition to the regular monthly 0.5p per share for the March monthly dividend taking total dividends proposed for the period to 3.25p.
5:53 This, I just wanted to just highlight two points on here, which was really around our gross purchase yield and gross mark to market yield. And again, this is still very, very attractive for the fund. And they are, as you can see, just over 8% and nearly 10% for the mark to market. And, again, this is consistent with the last couple of years, but again, underlines the sustainability of meeting our dividend target. In terms of financial highlights for the year, the company has delivered a NAV per ordinary share of GBP82.51p, and that's a return total return on the NAV of just 0.24 and total assets increased to GBP289 million.
6:44 Before handing over to Felipe, I just wanted to update you on how the portfolio is positioned and the outlook for the asset class. I want to take this opportunity to remind investors that Smith's portfolio is actively managed and invests across the spectrum of less liquid fixed income credit products. This is particularly important in the current geopolitical and economic environment where sentiment can change quickly and have notable impacts on investment. In the case of Smith, the manager has maintained a selective approach to investing and is allocated to higher quality assets that can be underwritten throughout the cycle and still deliver an attractive yield in line with our target. The portfolios therefore minimize risk while still delivering income. Furthermore, a combination of active management, the size, and diversified allocation of portfolio mean that the manager can rotate between sectors to take advantage of market volatility.
7:39 So thank you just for listening to me, and I will now hand over to Felipe. Thanks very much, Ashley. So I'm gonna start with with a brief recap of the of the macro picture, and then we'll we'll have a look at the at the allocation of the... Of SMIF. So as as I'm sure you all know, the macro risks remain elevated. This is due to... Mostly due to the conflict in in Iran, which shows no sign of a of a proper resolution even if some steps have been taken to... Towards that. And I think the main point though is that even with this conflict, GDP... Global GDP is expected to be positive this year in 2026.
8:26 And in fact, the revisions downwards to growth have not been too large. So in the case of The UK and Europe, at the beginning of the year, the expectation measured as Bloomberg consensus was for growth to be just over 1%, and now the expectation is for it to be around naught point 7% for 2026. And in The US, the expectation at the beginning of the year was around 2.3% growth for 2026. Now we're looking at closer to 2%. So this is obviously worse... A worse growth picture than at the beginning of the year, but it's nowhere near a recession at this stage. Of course, this this could change. But we... In our in our forecasts and our expectations, we are not expecting a recession in either Europe, The UK, or or The US, which are the main geographies in which Smith invests.
9:19 So just going through some of these bullet points, we are in a no war, no peace scenario. So the... And and I think what's important to keep in mind is that beyond the humanitarian toll and the redrawing, let's say, of the balance of power in The Middle East, which are definitely very, very, very true and very concrete. For the purposes of the market, what matters the most is oil prices. And to that extent, if you have this sort of conflict where it's no war, no peace, but the strait is more or less open, more or less, or or at least it's not completely closed, which allows oil prices to be in the region of, let's say, very broadly 80 to $100 per barrel, then I think the world can live with that. And I think that's kind of what we're seeing at the moment. This is maybe, maybe turning into a Middle East conflict in the end rather than a global sort of oil being at $150 per barrel sort of scenario.
10:19 And if and if that's the case, if if if oil stays in the 80 to $100 per barrel range, I think the markets will move on. In fact, that's kind of what they're doing at the moment. The the consequences of this have been present in in many aspects of of the global economy and financial markets, But I'd say that the two areas where the pressure has been more sustained, let's say, because equities continued rallying, spreads continued tightening after a short hiatus. The two areas where price where price action has remained different, let's say, than pre conflict are commodities and government bonds. And government bonds have, in particular, yield curves have moved upwards as inflation expect... Inflation... Spot inflation has moved upwards.
11:09 And there is now the expectation that the ECB, in particular, will raise rates this week and that maybe the Fed and the Bank of England will do so as well in in the in the near future. So that has put some pressure on on government bond curves, which has put pressure on fixed income. And and that's the main reason really why fixed income has delivered maybe results that were... That are a bit underwhelming in the in the first half of the of the year. The... Another consequence of this conflict, which has which has to do with inflation, is that governments have responded by helping out consumers and and voters with with different degrees of subsidies and... Which have taken different shapes and forms. But the the the bottom line, I think, for markets is that budget deficits might be slightly higher than where...
12:06 What we expected at the beginning of the year, which was already a level that was a little bit uncomfortable, which... And this has put further pressure, let's say, on the government bond curves. In particular, in The UK, there is a... An added uncertainty element with regards to the prime minister, Kirstjarman. It's likely. It's not a done deal, but it's likely that there is a change in prime minister in the second half of the year, and markets have made very clear what they think about what the new prime minister should do when it comes to government debt and and deficits. And so this has added a little bit of pressure on on guilt compared to bonds or or treasuries, and volatility in in the in The UK government market has been higher than in other g seven government bonds.
12:59 If we look at the fears of private credit and AI, this is obviously another driver that actually started last year. Last year, if we if you remember, there was this issue with Tricolor and First Brands in The US, which sort of sparked a little bit of concern with the private credit space. People had fears that they had this had grown significantly and exponentially through the years, so there were doubts about what the lending criteria was and whether or not the lending standards have been sufficient... Sufficiently robust, let's say. And with that sort of slightly nervous environment, on came the AI situation where all of a sudden AI turned into a massive threat for all software companies around the world, and there was a very large sell off in that space.
13:54 And that hit CLOs in in particular, just talking about what the direct impact on the on the on the portfolio was because CLOs have an exposure to software, which is definitely not as high as private equity... As a private credit funds, but it... It's higher than in high yield. So in high yield indices, software is typically around three to 4% if you look at the at Europe and The US high yield indices. In the loan market, we're looking at eight to 10% roughly. So CLOs naturally have more exposure to software than high yield. And therefore, for a period of time, which wasn't that long really, I'd say, CLOs underperformed high yield. I think afterwards, that has reversed, but that was a... An impact that we... That that the portfolio felt for for for some months while the software situation was was on on the tapes, let's say.
14:48 We don't see this as a as a a systemic issue, the private credit situation as a whole, And we don't have necessarily a negative opinion of software companies. Of course, some companies will suffer, others won't. For the most part, software companies will use AI to reduce their costs is is what we think. And that means that if a software company doesn't adapt quickly enough, then they might suffer, but that is not gonna be the case necessarily for everyone out there. So we don't see this necessarily as a major issue, although headlines will continue, and we don't see the private credit situation to evolving into a massive sort of systemic issue. And this, let's say, worse than previously expected macro environment has been met by strong fundamentals from the corporate side.
15:41 If we look at ratios such as net debt to EBITDA as such as interest coverage ratios, both in investment grade and in high yield, the ratios do not look bad at all. In fact, in high yield, which is the part of the market where most of the defaults come from as opposed to investment grade, net debt to EBITDA, for example, is actually lower than pre COVID. And so we don't don't think there is an issue with with the... With corporates. We think ratios look quite healthy. And that's... That is part of the reason why in spite of this, let's say, negative macro outlook, spreads are actually... Have tightened quite significantly from this volatility that we experienced in March.
16:30 Banks, very importantly, continue to report stellar results. Capital levels are very healthy. Margins are healthy. Nonperforming loans are low for the most part. And that means not only that we believe that banks are a solid credit proposition, I e, to invest in maybe subordinated bonds issued by banks, but also from a macroeconomic point of view, the access to credit is... To the economy is actually quite healthy. So what that means is that corporates and consumers have access to to credit in a in a in an easy easy way. What I mean by easy way is not that standards are are loose. They aren't. But if you have a good credit profile, the banks...
17:16 The banking sector doors are open to lend, which is a good thing for the economy. And if we look at earnings going forwards, there... The the impact of this conflict, of of course, has some ramifications for certain sectors while has less ramifications for other sectors. But broadly speaking, we do not see a massive revision downwards in earnings. Some sectors will see more margin compression as they use oil or jet fuel, for example. Airlines is an obvious example. But for the most part, we don't... We haven't seen a massive revision downwards in corporate earnings. And the tone in earnings releases by management teams has generally speaking been quite reasonable as in there is definitely not a feeling of panic when when you listen to CEOs or CFOs of companies even if they will be impacted to some degree by by this conflict.
18:13 And lastly, the technical bid for yield continues. This also explains why the spread products have been well bid this year. Yields are very high if you compare them to to previous... To to the previous cycle pre COVID. And that means that in spite of spreads being tight, if you think, as we think, that this inflation spike is is going to be temporary, then real yields are quite attractive. And if corporate fundamentals are are good, then that means that there is a constant bid for for yield, and that is another part of the reason another reason why spreads have been well contained in this period of volatility. So I have a few graphs here that basically show what I've what I've just mentioned.
19:04 But after... Long story short, I think after a relatively brief increase in spreads during March, we are back towards the lows in investment grade and in high yield as well in AT ones or COCO bonds as well. CLOs, maybe slightly over. I'd note that this graph is is longer. So this starts in 2019, while the other three just showed the the the period of volatility that we experienced since the beginning of March. So spreads are some... Somewhat slightly above the the pre... The the preconflict levels in in CLOs, but they are close. So spread products have recovered.
19:50 This is just to put into into a graph what I was talking about regarding government bonds. So the dark green line here is the policy... Sorry, the the expected path of monetary policy rates in The US as of February bego... Before the conflict started, and this is what the curve is telling us now. So a very significant shift similar with the with the with the euro policy rates. We were expecting sort of flat curves. Now the curve is anticipating some rate hikes, and in The UK, a similar sort of picture. I should highlight that these expectations in the curve are a weighted average. So it's not necessarily what the market is expecting, but it's just extracted...
20:39 It's information we extract from the from the curve as as it is at the moment. And this has had a consequence amongst other things amongst the... Including also the fact that there's been more issuance and and the term premium is increasing. This has resulted in ten year yields also increasing from the from from the beginning of the year.
21:00 And and this is just to show a couple of economic data that we look at. Inflation has increased, as I'm sure you all know, but inflation expectations have increased somewhat, but not necessarily hugely. And this is part of the reason why there is this uncertainty about what central banks are are going to do in the in the future. And policy rates, this is, of course, doesn't... We we are about to see, I I think, on the market things as well, the first hike by the ECB this this week. Consumer fundamentals are also strong. This just shows a couple of indicators. Two to highlight would be the savings rate. This is...
21:45 We show The US and and Europe here. This is the percentage of disposable income that consumers save each month. And, yes, you can see in The US, this is much lower than than what it is in Europe. This is another... Or or another another way of of reading this is that, of course, if you save less, you spend more, growth is higher. So that's part of what's going on in The US versus Europe. In Europe... And in The UK, if if I had The UK here, it would be similar to Europe. People save more. That means that they spend less. That means that growth is slower. But at the same time, for me as a fixed income manager and credit manager, I have a... An additional cushion that consumers can can can go to if the economy turns out to be worse than they expected. So it's not a bad thing even if growth is slower than in The US.
22:39 And the unemployment rate is another important indicator to to highlight. This... The unemployment rate is the main driver usually of defaults in mortgages, which, in turn, are a main driver of how banks' balance sheets look. And unemployment rate has increased from the very lows, from multi decade lows. It probably will continue increasing slightly in in The UK, in particular, in The US seems to be... Seems to have reached a bit of a peak, but it's it's not at at very worrisome levels, I would say, the unemployment rate. And that has translated into relatively low non performing loan ratios in the portfolios of of banks. And in corporate fundamentals, just... I'm just going to refer to this graph, net leverage, as I was saying earlier. This is US high yield and European high yield, these two. And as you can see, leverage is measured as net debt to EBITDA is lower than pre COVID in 2019.
23:36 This along... Amongst other indicators tells tells us that the corporate fundamentals are actually quite healthy, and default rates in high yield have actually been relatively relatively contained. In The US, we're looking at 2%. In Europe, it's declining, and it's likely to reach two and a half percent this this year.
23:59 And lastly, when we talk about fundamentals, I did mention banks. This graph very simply shows... The graph on the top hand... Top left hand side shows common equity tier one versus non performing loan ratios. The dark green line on the left hand side shows the common equity tier one ratio. This is the basic capital of the banking sector that is at ten year highs. The light green line on the right hand side shows the nonperforming loan as a percentage of the overall book of the European banking sector. And as you can see, this is at ten year lows. So more capital and less problem assets basically results in higher margins amongst other things.
24:46 Of course, you need to account for the fact that rates have increased from 2022 onwards, and that has had a very positive effect on net interest margins as the graph on the right hand side shows. And this has been rewarded by rating agencies in the bottom left hand side, the 81 space, which I'm talking about here, is is is close to... It's not yet, but it's close to an average investment grade rating now. It's double b plus because most banks have recorded quite a few upgrades in rating as credit metrics have continued to improve. So this is a sector that we like from a credit point of view. Fundamentals continue to improve, and profitability is is very strong.
25:31 So looking at the portfolio positioning, the AT one component of the fund is about 33% in total, while the second largest is CLOs. And then you can see the rest of the of the portfolio. We've got insurance, high yield European, asset backed securities, non non CLO asset backed securities. That is what we call banks is tier two bonds, US high yield, a a very small allocation to to EM and and then cash. And you can see also the rating breakdown here and the geographical breakdown with the most of the portfolio located the underlying assets with risk allocated to UK and Europe with an an interest rate duration here of three three twenty one.
26:21 As as Ashley was saying at the beginning, we we we have increased the average rating of the investments in the in the company. And in the end, we are achieving the objective of the of the income that we are proposing to investors with a lower level of risk than than previously, which is which leaves us in a in a very favorable position as an active manager to achieve the the objectives of the fund.
26:51 And having a look at the at the yield, so this is the mark to market yield of the of the of the investments in Smith. As interest rates have declined, the... And the spread volatility, as you can see here in March, has also declined. The mark to market yield has naturally decreased a bit, but we are looking at a yield that is still very attractive from a mark to market point of view.
27:15 And if we look at the purchase yield, and I know just to highlight that the axis is is quite different from the previous graph, we're looking at a purchase yield that is in the high sevens. Again, declined because the monetary policy rates have declined, and we... And spreads have tightened over the over the period, but still very comfortably achieving the objectives of the of the fund. And just to summarize the performance, this is the NAV per share year to date and and for the different periods and the annualized data since inception 654. This is as of the end of May of twenty twenty six.
28:09 And looking at the performance contribution, as you can see here, CLOs, and this is again at the end of May, CLOs have delivered after a period of maybe slight underperformance versus high yield. They have recovered, and they are now a positive contribute... Contributor to the total return of the of the NAV. So almost a percent of the of the total return of the fund has been contributed by by CLOs on a year to date on a year to date basis.
28:42 I think that's it from me. Thank you, Felipe. We we are privileged to have a number of questions that people have been posting. I'll... If it's okay with you, I'll probably take the first one whilst you catch your breath. But given the testing environment and the reduced return on the portfolio, how can you be so confident in the company's ability to beat the target dividend this year? Well, hopefully, both Felipe and myself have have answered that. I think what I would say is that we did have a dip. I'm probably just
29:18 reiterating what I said earlier, but we did have a dip in our NAV and our share price at the period end, but that has since recovered. But actually, what more importantly, we've got quite elevated mark to market yield and purchase yield within the portfolio, and that's still yielding. And certainly in an environment where we're not seeing many defaults, if any, we are still yielding healthily within the portfolio. We we very much hope and anticipate that we will be exceeding our target dividend this year. And indeed, it will be over the 6.5 p that we mentioned at the at the at the half year. But more on that, that the board will make more announcements on that as we progress through the rest of this year.
30:05 We've got a question, maybe one more for you, Felipe. Note that the main driver of returns during the period was income rather than capital appreciation. Looking ahead, where do you see the best opportunities to sustain that income stream? And if future returns continue to be driven primarily by income, how should shareholders think about the fund's long term return potential and prospects for NAV growth? Yes. Of course. I think the... If we look at the fixed income space at the moment,
30:36 the the view we are taking is that we can achieve the objectives that we set ourselves at the at the launch of SMIF with a lower level of credit risk. So, alternatively, we could have we we could we could have still had the... A lower average rating and achieve an even greater income, but we are being a little bit more conservative given that spreads are... Have tightened.
31:00 And we can definitely achieve the objectives of the of of the of the fund with a more contained, let... Let's say, level of credit risk. So I would say that going forward, income will continue to be the main driver of of returns... Of total returns. That's what we have in mind a 100% of the time when we include a position in the in the portfolio is the income that it will generate not only in the next few months or quarters, but through the cycle. We... The the the ability of Smith to invest in maybe bonds that are slightly off the run or that are maybe slightly smaller in size, that adds alpha to the to the portfolio, adds income on top of what the credit risk would imply because we're getting compensated as well partly because of the liquidity risk as... That that some positions might have.
31:56 And in order to collect that income, we are very happy to underwrite a position through the cycle. And when we have periods of instability or volatility as we did in March, we we are happy to keep those. They keep generating income based on our, you know, assessment of the credit profile of of these investments. So I think the the the prospect for the for the medium term is that SMIF will continue doing what what it's been doing, which is to to generate that level of income. And as Ashley said, if that level of income allows, we would... Or the board will increase the the dividends. There... There's a related question actually, which I'll read to you, which was, can you talk about the sustainability and quality of SMIF's dividend generation?
32:45 To what extent is income currently being earned organically from portfolio cash flows versus relying on capital gains, refinancing benefits, or temporary market conditions? Yes. So the the the income that Smith distributes is is generated by the yield of the positions that we hold. And the the way in which we can add value on top of that is, for example, through primary markets. So when primary markets offer attractive opportunities, we can rotate taking advantage of our active management approach. We can rotate some positions and
33:22 and and and take advantage of attractive market conditions in in the primary market. But we... The the the the the main engine of the of the of the distributions that's that Smith makes is the income that the position generates. So that... That's unlikely to change. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Should there be a housing mortgage
33:47 crash, how will this affect your fund, and what are you doing to prepare or cushion the fund against such a possible event? I asked this at the time that property repossessions are rising in The US, the source of the two thousand and eight financial crisis... Crash. Sorry. Yeah. That's that's an an interesting question. The nonperforming loans on banks' balance sheets continue to be very low. I think what we're seeing at the moment is is is this k shaped economy as as it's as it's called, where US and UK, by the way, and European prime mortgages
34:28 continue to exhibit very low non performing ratios. So arrears continue to be pretty much at the bottom. However, if you look at nonconforming mortgages by... To let... To a to a lesser degree, but also through credit cards, auto loans, those arrears have started to increase post 2022 with rates being higher, which which is something that, you know, to to be expected in a in a way. So the the thing is that most of the more of the books of of banks at the moment is is to do with prime mortgages
35:05 when you look at the mortgage book. And so that results in the overall mortgage nonperforming loan ratio being still very low. In other words, the fact that buy to let and non conforming arrears have increased is not necessarily on average at least or for the big banks. It's definitely not enough to move the dial too much. Non performing loans continue to be very low. So I I I don't think that we are seeing anywhere near that level of of stress in in the system just to put The U... Because The US was mentioned in the in the question. Just to put this into context, The... From a system point of view, arrears in The US, ninety plus day arrears in The US are about 1% of the book.
35:50 This number was close to 9% at the peak in 2010 q one, I think it was, or maybe q four two thousand and nine. So we are very, very far away from that, and that is partly to do with the fact that the banking sector as as we've shown as as we've shown in the in the slides previously is in very good shape. And the Basel III regulations that came after the the crash in 2009 basically have meant that amongst other things that banks find it less profitable to have riskier biz... Business lines. So in in technical terms, the risk weighted assets of certain riskier business lines has increased, and that means that the profitability of having a lot of subprime mortgages, for example, is just not as attractive as it used to be.
36:38 Same with private credit, by the way. And so that means that banks are naturally safer, capital levels are much higher, and nonperforming loans are are much lower. So, however, if that happened, what would we do? We would... We have an active management approach, so we would reduce the exposure to subordinated banking debt in certain pockets. But I I don't anticipate that to be
37:06 a major issue, or I don't anticipate that to be part of of a of of a base case scenario. Thank you. So somebody's asked what the difference between SMIF and TFIF is, our sister fund. Yes. So, the twenty four INCOME FUND or or TFIF is a, a fund that is managed by the, asset backed securities team that sits right, right by me, here in the office.
37:32 They... This is a... Also a closed ended fund. It's larger in size. It's it's just under 1,000,000,000 at the moment in in size, and it invests in asset backed securities only as opposed to SMIF that has AT ones and has insurance, has high yield... Corporate high yield, I mean, the TFIF portfolio is asset backed securities only. So there are a few differences. The the yield is slightly higher. The the allocation to nonrated assets is also quite significantly higher than than in the case of SMIF. So it's it's a similar sort of vehicle, but the underlying assets are are are different. There are some... There is some crossover. They do have CLOs, same as as we do in in SMIF, but it's it's a it's a separate vehicle with similar objectives, but different underlying assets for the most part.
38:28 Thank you.
38:30 You're taking a rather sanguine view on the outlook for the oil price and the economic outlook. This is at odds with many oil sector experts who believe the lagged effect of the significant cut in oil flows is yet to be reflected in oil prices. What would make you change your view? What do you consider to be the worst case scenario, and how would you adjust the portfolio if you believe the chance of this occurring increased?
38:54 Yes. So the... If if we look at the forward curves in in oil prices, they they have they have been quite volatile. But at the moment, I I think there is a feeling in markets and not just feeling, pricing, actual price action that tells you that most people expect oil prices to not climb significantly higher from here. The... What could change your mind if... I'm going to say something that that looks pretty obvious, and it is, but what would make us change your mind is that this conflict actually resurges, like, in in in a in a more powerful way as in more war, more missiles flying over the the The Middle East, and this basically peace deal... Peace deal or temporary peace is broken in earnest, let's say, because it it has been broken, you could say, actually today and yesterday.
39:50 But the... To to... The crucial point, as as you point out... As the person who asked the question points out, is really the oil price. And it's very difficult to know how much oil is flowing through the Strait Of Hormuz at the moment. There is anecdotal evidence that this is not entirely closed. It's pretty clear and obvious that the flows are much lower than what they were in in February, but it's difficult to know with exactitude what exactly is the oil that's flowing through the strait. And the... Just to... One example to this morning, there was a a Bloomberg headline that the Kuwaiti petroleum company was actually selling oil in Asia. That means that oil has left the the Strait Of Hormuz from... Produced by Kuwait.
40:39 But there isn't an official... Necessarily an official account of that. So some ships are turning off their radar system so that they go unnoticed, so it's very difficult to get a proper picture. And in the same sense, it's difficult to know to what extent there there has been demand destruction, which also puts downward pressure on oil prices. So what would change our mind if if this... If there is evidence that the Strait Of Hormuz is completely closed for a very long period of time onwards and there is no sign of resolution with accompanied by a massive spike in the war in Iran and in The Middle East, then that could make us change our minds. If that happened, I don't think we would necessarily sell many positions, but we would look at hedging opportunities.
41:26 So maybe by protection in CDS in... CDS indices or or other hedges. And the reason I say that is that we do not have direct exposure to to this area. We do not have direct exposure to companies that are directly related to this or oil prices as such. For example, chemicals is a sector we have been avoiding for the for the most part of the last couple of years. And we don't... We wouldn't... I wouldn't personally foresee a massive spike in nonperforming loans on banks' balance sheets
41:57 if this conflict turns out to be to... The result is a is a mild recession. So, again, we're underwriting credit through the cycle, and we are comfortable with the banks that we hold. We're comfortable with the CLOs that we hold. And therefore, if there's some... If there is some some sort of temporary slowdown that we didn't foresee, we would probably look at hedging alternatives. Thanks, Felipe. I think, I mean, I'm looking at the other questions. I think we've kind of covered most of them, but one that sticks out is what activity did you take in 2022 to reduce the minus 13% NAV decline? Yes. So I think the the first line of defense is the underwriting, as as we as as we mentioned.
42:46 In terms of of the of of the trades that that we did, SMIF usually doesn't have a lot of cash. It's it's obviously a drag in terms of the of the NAV. So I I would say that the the the vast majority of the job, especially for a fund like this that has the income target or the dividend target and doesn't therefore carry a lot of cash, doesn't carry government bonds either, most of the of the work in terms of protecting a portfolio is done by the underwriting through the cycle. So companies that can withstand a level of, you know, stress in the economic picture and still pay their their income as their coupons, I mean, and and refinance or pay down principal at the end.
43:32 We did have some hedging in 2022. We'd have to go back to to provide exactly what what we what we did, But there there was some activity with with regards to to hedging. But I... As... But as I say, most of the work was done by the underwriting of the of the portfolio.
43:51 And and then, of course, when we can take advantage of wider spreads, which we we did when CLOs were trading at 15% yields, we we did did some rotation in there. Maybe we sold some shorter dated bonds and and maybe just invested proceeds in in CLOs that were yielding a a significant amount. Okay. Thank you. I think that,
44:21 no. Actually, we have had one... Well, I do one more question. We've had, we've had a couple more come in. AI has touched every part of The US economy. When CapEx cutbacks inevitably begin, isn't this the next credit crisis? Banks already refusing loans to SoftBank on ridiculous open AI valuation.
44:42 Yeah. So this is a very interesting topic. The capital that's being deployed in AI is huge. It's in the trillions of dollars. I I personally don't think that every single one of those dollars is going to have the return on equity that some people expect. Now that doesn't necessarily mean that you're gonna have a massive sort of credit event in the market or in banks' balance sheets, But it it does mean to me that some of those investments are maybe not going to be as profitable as as some people expect. So some people will lose money on this. AI is a great technology. It's amazing. I'm sure we'll use it. That doesn't mean you can't lose money by investing in it. So the the underwriting that banks do is
45:33 is crucial. So what I mean by that is the the investing in AI can take many different forms from a creditor's point of view. So if, for example, you find... Lend money to a company to build a data center and you have recourse to the fixed assets or the property. That is very different than lending money on an unsecured basis to someone like OpenAI. The credit risk can be lessened by the collateral, by what's the entity that's being lent money to, by what's the seniority. So maybe the senior debt, there might be a lot of junior debt beneath the the senior tranches. So I don't think that banks are necessarily taking an outsized risk in the in the AI space.
46:26 But, of course, we we would need to do a careful analysis before investing in a US bank. We don't have US... We have US high yield, but we don't have US bank exposure. But from a from a macro point of view, it seems to me that on an aggregated level, banks are not taking outsized risks in in AI or or technology. Maybe some private credit funds have more exposure to this, and and it sounds like I'm saying, well, that... That's much worse because private credit funds are not as strong a credit as banks. Although that's true, it's important to underline that private credit funds that have exposure to software and and and have been in in the news, let's say, and the redemptions and all these BDC and all all of those headlines.
47:15 It's important to keep in mind that those structures usually have a relatively low leverage. So BDCs typically have, roughly speaking, one to one debt to equity. So that allows for a lot of stress on the asset side of the balance sheet before there are losses on the creditors' EBIT. So in other words, the equity holders would would actually take take a hit, but not necessarily debt holders. That's great, Felipe. Ashley, if I may just jump back in there, thank you for addressing those questions for investors today. But, Ashley, before we direct investors to provide you with their feedback, which one is particularly important to yourself and the company, could I please just ask you for a few closing comments? Yes. I mean, I'll just summarize. Thank you, Alex, and thank you, Felipe, for all of your hard work, especially on all those questions, which I direct to to you to answer.
48:00 But SMIF is very, well positioned. We had a dip, in in in performance at the end of March because of problems, geopolitical issues, but that's since recovered within the, for the fund. And, you know, we will we will continue to meet our... We we do... We very much expect to continue to meet our dividend target, and and indeed, we're hoping to exceed
48:28 at least 6.5p this year, but we're in pretty good shape for that. Fantastic. Ashley, Felipe, thank you once again for updating investors today. Could I please ask investors not to close this session? As you now will automatically redirected to provide your feedback, which will help the company better understand your views and expectations. On behalf of the management team, we would like to thank you for attending today's presentation, and good morning to you.
Follow TwentyFour Select Monthly Income Fund Ltd into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Non-Executive Director and Chair at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED
Portfolio Manager at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED