Ashley Paxton
Non-Executive Director and Chair at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED
Replay available
Full Year Results hosted by TwentyFour Select Monthly Income Fund (LSE:SMIF) on Investor Meet Company, held 2025-12-11.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/twentyfour-select-monthly-income-fund-limited-smif-full-year-results-1
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Good morning and welcome to the twenty four SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND Limited Investor Presentation. Throughout the quarter presentation, investors will be in listen only mode. Questions are encouraged and they can be submitted at any time by the Q and A tab situated in the right corner of your screen. Simply type in your questions and press send. The company may not be in a position to answer every question received in the meeting itself, but the company can review the questions for today and publish responses where it's appropriate to do so. Before we begin, I'd like to submit the following poll.
0:26 I'd now like to hand you over to chair Ashley Paxton. Good morning to you, sir. Thanks, Alessandro, and welcome, everybody. Good morning. And this is twenty four SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED's full year results presentation. SMIF as we more eloquently like to call it. And I am Ashlie Paxson, I chair the Board of Directors and I'm pleased that I'm joined by George Curtis, our Portfolio Manager at twenty four Asset Management. We published our results today for the year ended September 30 and delighted to provide you with a summary update on our progress over the past twelve months. By way of a quick recap on the company, we've now been trading for eleven years having launched in 2014.
1:17 And you can see from the graph that we've seen steady growth in our market cap since launch continuing over the last year and we've actually grown to terms of NAV nearly £273,000,000 is at September 30 and that grew from £220,000,000 a year earlier. The graph actually shows our market cap which is slightly higher mainly because we're trading at a premium of two percent to NAV and that the graph shows it at nearly £278,000,000 at September 30. So the growth in the company is actually from a mixture between positive performance, which I'll come back to, but also having issued 54,000,000 new ordinary shares during the year.
2:11 Subsequent to the year end, the company grown further principally from ongoing TAP issues by nearly 14,000,000 new shares. And much of the growth that we've seen is coming from our retail investors typically looking for regular income. And so that brings Smith's total share capital and issue to approximately $330,000,000 shares. So both its high level share tap issuances and its ongoing trading premium to NAV, bearing in that the company traded at an average premium to NAV of approximately 2.1% throughout the period makes SMIF a standout performer in the investment company community, many of which are trading at steep discounts and unable to issue new shares.
3:00 I said I'd come back to performance. During the past year, the company continued to perform very well with a NAV total return of just over 12%. And all key investment sectors that Smith invests in contributed positively to its performance. This included a dividend per share of 7.3p and comfortably exceeding our stated dividend target of 6p per share. And that's actually the third consecutive year where dividends have been 7.3p or higher and worth emphasising that this has not been at the expense of a worsening credit quality in our portfolio. Actually, on the contrary, the average credit quality in our portfolio increased to BB at September 30 from BB minus a year earlier, and that's the highest average credit rating since the company's inception.
3:57 Worth noting that the company's NAV per share grew from 83.07p to 86.06p, a rise of 2.82%. I would also draw your attention to SMIF's consistent track record since inception, which you can see on this slide. SMIF has delivered a total return of almost 109% since inception, averaging 6.58% on an annualized basis. And SMIF, as you know, distributes all of its excess income arising. And so consistent with last year, as a board, we took the decision to try where we could to distribute that excess income to shareholders more evenly during the year, rather than just wait for a big bulk payment at the end of the year.
4:48 This hopefully provides shareholders better visibility on the level of income that they could expect to receive throughout the year.
4:55 And this was based on yield projections, balance obviously against the risks that the board considered. And we as a board estimated that dividends payable in respect to the year were likely to be in excess of that target 6p, and consequently decided it was appropriate to pay additional nought points or a quarter of a pence per share in addition to the regular monthly 0.5p per share for the periods ended 03/31/2025 and 06/30/2025 as well. And additionally, the final dividend declared for September 2025 was 1.3p per share. And as I noted earlier, that produced a total annual dividend for the financial year of 7.3p.
5:43 As you note... As you will note from the slide, SMIF has consistently exceeded its dividend... Its target minimum dividend of 6p per share, even when interest rates were at historic lows. Before I hand over to George, I just wanted to highlight that the company still has a healthy gross purchase yield of 8.3% and a gross mark to market yield, the total return expected based on current market price of 8.5%. Looking forward and considering current expectations of yields, we think it is entirely possible that the next financial year ending December 30... September 26 may also produce an excess income above the target 6p dividend, and where we feel able, the board will again consider trying to spread any payments or evenly throughout the years we have over the last two years.
6:33 So I will now hand over to George. I'll come back at the the end for for q and a, but George will now present an overview of the asset class and how the portfolio is positioned. Thank you. Hello, everyone. It's good to speak to you all again after what has been another pretty decent year for for Smith. And it has to be said in a pretty complex macro environment, tricky macro environment, you know, sitting here twelve months ago. Obviously, Donald Trump had just been inaugurated. We were kinda questioning what that would look like for US policy in 2026... In 2025 rather. And also, of course, what that means for the rest of the world. And, you know, no doubt we've, I think, been surprised a a number of times over the last twelve months, not least the trade policy enacted by The US in April, which was much worse than people were expecting at the beginning of the year. Obviously, of that has reversed.
7:33 But, you know, the the the kind of trends from a macro perspective, you know, have have been for kind of deglobalization, have been for, you know, onshoring of supply chains or at least that is the intent of The US. I don't know how successful they will be in doing that. And it... You know, there are consequences on on this from a macro perspective. You know, we have seen weaker growth, in The US mainly. Right? You know, trade policy is, you know, first and foremost, a tax on The US consumer ultimately, you know, because we don't think corporates are gonna pay it. And we've seen higher inflation, but it's worth saying that growth in The US was coming from a very strong base, 3% plus real GDP growth last year.
8:24 And so far the inflationary impacts from a trade perspective have been fairly limited. We have seen an impact, but it's been offset by improving underlying inflation on the services side. You know, I suppose a trend over the last few months has been some softness in the labor market, in The US, but also in The U... In The UK. I think part of this is, you know, due to trade uncertainty that we've seen, of course, and we've discussed. Part of this is also due to the fact that, you know, immigration growth has slowed down meaningfully. So this doesn't necessarily, we think, you know, imply something more spurious, I. E, you know, the kind of reflexivity you might see in the unemployment market or the employment market going into recessions, but it's definitely something that the central banks are keeping a very close eye on. And indeed, you know, Jerome Powell spoke about it again yesterday during the FOMC meeting.
9:24 Over in the The Eurozone and in the The UK, you know, and and I suppose across the developed markets that we've tracked, you know, even given the kind of macro volatility that we've had this year, you know, it's worth reiterating a point that we've made before. You know, the pillars that underpin the macro have... And we think will continue to to remain very resilient. Right? Corporate balance sheets are in a good place. Consumer balance sheets are in a good place. Bank balance sheets are in a good place. And in The Eurozone specifically, we've had some pretty positive growth tailwinds this year with the release of the debt break in Germany. So potential GDP growth estimates for Germany over the next couple of years have increased meaningfully, which is important because the laggard in Europe over the last few years has not been the periphery like it was ten years ago, but it has been at the core. And indeed the periphery continues to be operating very strongly, particularly likes of Spain and Portugal.
10:29 And at the same time in Europe, we have seen a pretty positive inflation dynamic. The trade policy in The US is negative for inflation obviously in The US. It's potentially even positive for inflation in Europe as you have excess supply that comes out of Asia and is sold into the... Into Europe rather than rather than The US. So, you know, the BECB are expecting base rates... Sorry, are expecting inflation both at core and headline level to be below their 2% target, this next year. We expect the Fed and the Bank of England, to continue cutting. We expect this to be very slow, very cautious.
11:16 The closer you get to the estimate of the mutual rate, which is that kind of level of real level of interest rate that neither stimulates or constrains demands when, you know, the unemployment rate and inflation are at target. The balance of risks become more two sided. You know, yes, labor has been a bit weaker both in in The UK and The US, but inflation still remains above above target. So, you know, we think both central banks do wanna get down to their estimate of neutral, which is around 3%, we think. But that path is gonna be a bit stop start y, you know, and they're gonna do it and they're gonna do it cautiously. So ultimately, you know, uncertainty from a macro perspective has been quite high, but the pillars underpinning the macro remain pretty resilient and actually growth projections for next year have have improved over the last three or four months.
12:12 More specifically with fixed income and kind of including, you know, other dynamics that we've seen this year. I think a common theme has not been leveraged in the corporate space, which was, you know, the fee... The theme, you know, ten, fifteen years ago, at least in the banking space. But, you know, the questions for the market for the market now are about leveraging the... In in the government bond space, public space. You know, we don't think these fiscal concerns are going to go away anytime soon. You know, ultimately, the solution for governments, for developed market governments is not on the tax side, which is, you know, how some governments are trying to solve it. It's on the spending side, you know, post COVID.
12:57 We had a huge amount of fiscal stimulus
12:59 injected into the system and that acts like a bit of a drug. Right? It is quite difficult to get, to take out, and there needs to be political will to do that. So, you know, whilst we don't, you know, we wouldn't expect a 2022 type event in government bond curves next year, we do think the fiscal situation will continue to weigh particularly on the longer end of government bond curves. Know, how does this manifest? When it manifests, we think primarily in increasing the risk premium further out the government bond curve, you know, particularly in The US and The UK, you know, government bond curves will remain, we think relatively volatile, particularly versus credit.
13:44 And of course, you've got, you know, other things layering on top of that, including discussions about fed independence, which, you know, we think is a... Is an interesting topic. But one that we don't think is likely gonna drive, short end rates too materially, given the fact that, you know, even if you put a Trump loyalist like Hassett in charge of the feds, you know, has to persuade the 11 other voters to to vote his way. And as we've seen yesterday, we've already got dissenters that are looking for for for no cuts. You know, I go back to the point earlier.
14:22 Companies, consumers, and banks are in a in a pretty good shape. You know, the banking system in Europe is in probably the best shape it has ever been. Yeah. And this is a story that we have discussed with you many times before, but, you know, capital ratio are the highest they've ever been. Non performing loans are, you know, less than 2% of total assets.
14:46 And I think, you know, the shift change we've seen over the last three years in particular is that, you know, return on equity in the banking space in Europe has improved meaningfully because, you know, ultimately, the ECB has left negative rates, which is not great for for bank profitability. You know, so so this has implications from a macro perspective because having, you know, a sound bank... Banking sector is important for, you know, banks to lend through difficult times in the economy, but also from an allocation perspective for us given our allocation to banks. And, you know, corporates have managed this higher interest rate environment extraordinarily well. You know, defaults have remained, you know, under control. There are some sectoral specific softness, know, chems in in Europe, for example, maybe maybe autos across across developed markets.
15:40 But generally in aggregate, credit metrics have remained very healthy. And, you know, within fixed income specifically and within credit, you know, it's worth saying that spreads are tight or at least on the tighter end of of historical averages, but but yields are high. You know, we go back to kind of the number one rule in fixed income or in credit, you know, you earn your yield.
16:07 Longer term returns are highly correlated to starting yield. So if you can build a portfolio of assets that are fairly short dated, are giving you lots of yields and that you can have conviction in holding through the cycle, you know, even in a downside scenario, which is of course what we are modeling when we are buying different businesses, then you can have high conviction on returns. So technical remains very strong because of that of that yield, and we think that continues into 2026. And it's, you know, probably obvious, pointing out that, you know, carry is is likely to be the biggest driver of of returns next year, given where spreads are. Just looking at, the fund in more detail, know, said earlier your purchase yields continue to be well in excess of of 8%. Mark to market yields continue to be above 8% too.
17:05 Our core allocations remain in financials and ABS. You know, as you know, we've kind of been looking... We always kinda look to, from a top down perspective, combine, you know, longer term sectoral tailwinds with, you know, attractive bottom up relative value. You know, we've spoken about the tailwinds in the banking sector, CLOs, you know, again, one of our favorite sectors allows us to get strong structural subordination, you know, essentially in a product that is taking, you know, high yield risk at the asset level, but offering, you know, a significant premium under the... Over the underlying high yield market and in a floating rate product.
17:53 The... And a product that's generated, you know, probably the best risk return in any fixed income market over the past, you know, five to seven years. You know, outside of the banking space, we we also like insurance, you know, many of these names are investment grade even at the most subordinated level
18:12 and are giving us, you know, still sterling yields of 7%. Our 81 bucket sterling yields of of seven and a half percent. And, you know, that's for an average rating now at sector level, at index level, there's almost investment grade. Right? You know, six... And we talked about the longer term tailwinds in the sector six years ago,
18:32 you know, your 81... Your average 81 was fully high yield. Now your average 81 has at least one investment grade rating. So those two things I talked about earlier, profitability and capital. These are the two defenses for for bondholders, and and they are both as as as as strong as they've ever been.
18:56 I I won't go, you know, line by line. You can see the various sectors that we invest in. You know, we still, hold more financials and CLOs relative to high yields because we see a better relative value in those two sectors. Geographically, UK and Europe continues to be where we tend to, you know, go kind of credit picking because we see better currency adjusted yields. Remember, we are currency agnostic. We hedge everything back to the base currency of the fund and, you know, on a currency adjusted basis, we still see better better value in Europe and The UK and actually longer term returns have been superior versus dollar markets.
19:46 And the final thing I'll point to on this chart is just the ratings breakdown. Yeah. This is a point I made last year as well, but, know, I just highlight the increase in in triple c and triple b risk we've seen over the past few years relative to single b's. You know, three or four years ago, we probably had 30 plus percent of single b's and, you know, sub 20% of triple b's. Now that has flipped. We have, you know, 30 plus percent, a third of the fund in triple triple b, investment grade rated credit, and less than 20% in single b. And we've got negligible amount of of triple c. So, you know, I'll I'll go back to the point that Ash made earlier, you know, purchase yields, mark to market yields continue to be much higher than the longer term average on the funds, but with the highest average credit quality that we've that we've ever had of double b.
20:41 Mark to market yields, it's just depicting what I've already said, 8% plus, and the purchase yields of just below eight and a half percent. And this is, of course, the most important graph for for the dividend. Lastly, I'll just highlight performance. It's been a it's been a pretty decent year again. Of course, you know, we weren't kind of expecting the same sort of returns we saw in '23 and '24. You know, you're coming out of 2022 and spreads were significantly wider. So you had both that kind of sharp spread contraction plus some of the rate rally. And this year, you know, starting spreads were lower. So we were expecting carry to be a bigger driver of returns. That's essentially what we saw. And we've been, you know, earning the yields that we had at the beginning of this of this year. I think this year has been a good showcase for what credit is all about. Right?
21:41 Macro volatility has been high. We've had pockets of volatility, obviously, April, October to a certain degree. But, you know, credit has continued to spit out, you know, the the the coupon, the the the the income that you're looking for very steadily. And volatility in the credit space has been much lower than other areas of the fixed income market like rates, not least equity markets. So risk adjusted returns have been have been very strong.
22:13 And this just shows the contribution of total returns by sector. Of course, ABS... Sorry, CLOs and 80 ones continue to be the the primary driver of returns given the allocations we have to each of those sectors. So I think, I will leave it there and we can have a, q and a. Thanks, George. Well, if I kick off, on the q and a, there is one question that comes in, that's come in and, it's, I think it typically does come up, every time we've we've we've held this. Are there any plans to review the dividend target given the track record of always beating it and considering the higher rate environment?
23:04 Well, we do look at it, and we do look at it every year as a board and in discussion with our manager. There is no plans to change our dividend target of 6p per share, bearing in mind that over the last eleven years, the last three years have been record years of dividends, but actually we've had years that have been a lot tighter, especially when there's been lower interest rate environment. And we feel that the 6p target dividend is actually right, and, you know, we'd we'd like to be able to pay 7.3p every year, but realistically, that's probably not likely.
23:53 But we feel that 6p is the the right level, for us to to continue to target. And indeed, where we got to as a board and with TFAM is in the trying to spread any excess income
24:07 more evenly throughout the year. So that's really where we've got to, but there's no no plans as yet to change the target of 6p per share. If I could ask the next question perhaps for you, George. Yep. I'll ask the the the one that I think is probably easiest. Can you explain ECB is at its terminal rate? And I think that was on slide seven. It's the last comment on the last box on the right. Yes. Sorry. So I should have explained that. So the terminal rate is essentially where interest rates end up in a cutting cycle or a hiking cycle. So the ECB have cut down to 2%.
24:53 This is their estimate of neutral. So they don't think they are stimulating or constraining the economy at this level of interest rate. So 0% real interest rate, a 2% nominal interest rate. And so we think the ECB is comfortable remaining at 2%. You know, there has been talk about them potentially doing another cut next year, you know, based on what I discussed earlier, I. E. Inflation that could well be below target. But, you know, equally, last week or earlier this week, we had, Isabelle Schnabel come out and say, that she's comfortable with the market pricing in the potential for a hike next year. So, you know, the balance of risks here feels fairly balanced, and we think the ECB stay at 2%.
25:38 That's what I mean. Thanks George. We have another question here which is a little bit longer than the last one.
25:46 How have c l... CLO refinancing and reset opportunities affected the portfolio's expected cash flows during the past year, and how resilient are these cash flows to potential loan defaults compared with historical recession scenarios? For retail investors holding a concentrated position in SMIF, how do you view the role of complementary investments, such as short term government securities or other low risk instruments, in offsetting potential drawdowns? And can you provide guidance or tools to help investors consider this type of portfolio risk? CLO cash flows are increasingly modelled using AI for tranche assessment, loan level covenants, default correlations, market pricing. How does SMIF balance AI assisted analytics with human judgment in generating alpha?
26:33 And how do you maintain a competitive edge compared with larger managers such as AXA I'm VOLTA Finance who have greater resources and infrastructure? Probably one for you, George. Okay. I think there are about seven questions in there, so I'll I'll try and, take them one by one. So in terms of refinancings on the CLO side and, you know, how resilient these cash flows are to defaults, You know, it's worth saying that, you know, when you when you buy a CLO CLO, you are stressing on the downside in the same way that you're doing it on the corporate side. Right? So you are, looking for buffer below you, depending on which tranche you are in, and you are modeling out IRR on a kind of base case, you know, I e, we expect x percent of defaults over the next three or four years, call it 3%.
27:23 And you are saying, what would your rate of return be if defaults were to spike meaningfully? You know, how much can we stress these structures before you take... Start taking principal losses as CLO investor? And we look, really for tier one managers, you know, tier one managers of a track record of of of investing through the cycle in structures, that we think are extremely strong and in with underlying pools, of of high yield loans that are clean, right, that don't have a load of names that we think could potentially default. But in any case, you know, we are stressing, for the downside and we will only go into a new refinancing if we think, you know, the the spread that we get on the new deal compensates compensates us, you know, both for the base case, but also but also on the downside.
28:20 And there's another question about CLO cash flows. I'll come back to the the Govee one. So we don't use AI to model tranches, you know, low level covenants because we have a very in-depth long standing process. We do a lot of deep modeling and, you know, we use other systems. And so I think I think the AI question we are, you know, looking at in-depth, there will be areas where we use it extensively. You know, particularly, I think for doing the kind of work of a of a junior analyst. You know, I'm I'm a high yield analyst. So a lot of what I look at from a corporate perspective is on is on the high yield side.
29:10 And, you know, where we'd be using AI, for example, is, you know, getting up to speed on an industry, getting up to speed on a on a sector, doing the legwork very quickly of a junior analyst that would potentially take a week previously. But, you know, AI won't be won't be decision making. It's just it's just an input. But, you know, I think the question is an important one because if you are behind on this, then, you know, you you you will be you will be missing out. So we are certainly looking at this in detail. And then the other question about,
29:49 maintaining a competitive edge. We are, you know, Smith is is, you know, only 270,000,000. We are one of the larger ABS investors in Europe. So our ABS team, you know, manages,
30:05 you know, over 10,000,000,000. We've been, you know, one of the longest standing investors in European CLOs. We started as an ABS house in 2008. So it's a sector that we know back to front and our resources. We've got one of the larger teams. Our infrastructure is is is, you know, I think, you know, the best in Europe. And then the last question on on govies, we we tend to be fully invested within Smith on the credit side. So we will... On an ad hoc basis, you use hedges generally to hedge, you know, catalyst driven events. So, for example, we had currency options on crossover options on during the Brexit vote, really just for that weekend, which was obviously very helpful given the move in sterling and crossover.
31:01 We had crossover options on in the back end of last year. We were expecting, you know, potentially volatility post Trump. You know, we had an interest rate swap on the portfolio in 2022, you know, even though interest rate duration has been so low to allow us to profit from rising rising rates, which is, of course, also profitable. So we can build in hedges, on an ad hoc basis. The number one risk management tool within the the t... Within the the fund is,
31:32 you know, rigorous bottom up credit work, you know, stressing credits to the downside, making sure that you are comfortable holding these names through the cycle. Right? This is number one in income product, and capital preservation is is is the most important aspect of aspect of that. So tend to be fully invested, don't really hold, government bonds, within within SMIF.
31:56 Thanks, George. Somebody's asked, whether we can clarify if the financial year end highlights on screen are to the March 30 or to the September 30. Both dates are referred to on screen. I'm not quite sure which slide that is, but everything should be reported to September 30. But we will obviously double check that following this presentation and and clarify where necessary if if if if we put something incorrectly on there. But it should be September 30 for all reports on there. Some... Somebody has asked, total return performance is great, but can you say something about why the share price has declined over time?
32:46 Is that something, George, you'd like to comment on? So I'm just looking at market cap cap here. So presumably, you're talking about talking about NAV. We look at... We tend to look at at NAV plus plus dividends. Right? You know, this is an income product, and this is what we offer what we offer our investors. You know, I'd say that the NAV move primarily happened in 2022. You know, we had, some outflows when, the market really was trading at deep, deep discounts apart. So it's... This hasn't... The main point is it hasn't been driven by, you know, loss of capital. You know, the default rate through the cycle has been in Smith very, very low, much lower than the, default rate in the underlying high yield market. So I think the result of that is really more technical given where flows happened and at what points, particularly in 2022 when, as I mentioned, bonds are trading at a steep discount, but we've of course seen quite a sharp tick up in the NAV since then, and we would continue to expect it to kind of tick up as we go forward.
34:01 Okay. With a high yield on dividends, currently the divs look covered. If there's no cover on divs, would capital suffer suffer to help pay a dividend... A targeted dividend? So that's a good question. I mean, potentially, you could eat into capital. Don't think it would be our, in that scenario, would be our preference as a board. It is quite sacrosanct paying out 6p per share, but I think you'll find that in all the eleven years that we've traded, that we've actually generated sufficient income to at least cover that 6p. I would hope that that would be our intention going forward. It it is in our arsenal to to to to pay something out of capital if we so wish, but it wouldn't be our preference, I think.
34:55 I think I think that is all the questions. Unless there's any others, I think that's everything that's been answered. So thank you. Probably back to Alessandro. That's great. Well well thank you very much for answering those questions from investors. Of course the company can review all the questions submitted today and we will publish out the responses on the Investor Beat company platform. But just before redirecting investors to provide you with their feedback, you know, it's particularly important to the company. Ashley, could I just ask you for a few closing comments? Just to just to, summarize that it's been a a very good year again. We... We're in a great place as a fund, and thank you for all of your support, and thank you for attending this morning and listening to George and myself. Thanks, everyone. That's great. Well, thank you once again for updating investors today. Can I please ask investors not to close this session? As you now be automatically redirected to provide your feedback in order the management team can better understand your views and expectations.
35:53 I'm part the management team of TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED. We'd like to thank you for attending today's presentation, and good morning to you all.
Follow TwentyFour Select Monthly Income Fund Ltd into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Non-Executive Director and Chair at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED
Portfolio Manager at TWENTYFOUR SELECT MONTHLY INCOME FUND LIMITED