Malvern Bancorp — Merger or Acquisition (December 2022)
15 slides from Malvern Bancorp's merger presentation, Dec 14, 2022

Slide 1: First Bank Announces Strategic Combination with Malvern Bancorp
FIRSTBA Personal Bankers. Real Relationships. First Bank Announces Strategic Combination MALVERN Bancorp Inc. December 14, 2022 FIRSTBANK Pensonal Bankers. Real Relationships.

Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statement
Forward-Looking Statement Certain statements contained in this communication are “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of Section 27A of the curities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. These forward- looking statements may be identi

Slide 3: Important Additional Information
Important Additional Informat In connection with the proposed merger, First Bank will file with the FDIC and mail to shareholders of First Bank and Malvern Bancorp, Inc. a joint proxy statement/offering circular, which will include a joint proxy of Malvern Bancorp, Inc, and First Bank and an offerin

Slide 4: Compelling Strategic Combination
a Compelling Strategic Combination nd ———— Complementary Enhancement to Our New Jersey / Pennsylvania Platform ith otal Financial Benefits ets Generates critical mass in highly desirable Southeastern Pennsylvania. ™ Significant acceleration of time frame to achieve strategic goal of scale in the Sou

Slide 5: Malvern Bancorp Company Profile
Company = NASDAQ Listed: MLVF * Headquarters: Paoli, Pennsylvania = Locations: 7 branches in PA, 1 branch in Morris County, NJ and 1 branch in Palm Beach County, FL + Profile: Malvern Bancorp, Inc. is the holding company for Malvern Bank, National Association ("Malvern Bank”), an institution that wa

Slide 6: Eastern Pennsylvania & New Jersey Pro Forma Franchise
Eastern Pennsylvania & New Jersey $3.0 Billion Gross Loans 1 Hackeiis Aton oo Pottsville eee 102.5% Loans-to-Deposits e inswick © new Brunswick Lote $387.9 Million Market Capitalization® Nf Yorshanr Sore or King okPrusie =) ea Cec, 7 ss $3.7 Billion Total Assets(*! —_— $3.0 Billion Total Deposits hi

Slide 7: Key Pro Forma Financial Results
Key Pro Forma Financial Resul FIRSTBANK / [-MALVERN Real Relationships. * Bancorp Inc. Ti saction ing) 21.5x (aes Price-to-LTM Eamings : (seis ese : arnings+Cost Savin, 102.1% Price-to- Tangible Book Value 0.47% Premium-to- Core Deposits Key Financial Results Key Financial Results®) (Including AOCI

Slide 8: Transaction Summary
Transaction Summary Transaction n Mix Fixed Exchange Ratio Fixed Cash Per Share EEE Per Share Merger Consideration VC Merger Consideration) Pro Forma Ownership a Timing & Approval ® First Bank will acquire 100% of Malvern Bancorp, Inc.’s common stock ™ 60% Stock / 40% Cash ™ 0.7733 shares of FRBA st

Slide 9: Key Transaction Assumptions
Merger Costs Synergies LD (ne Loan Credit Marks ——— Interest Rate Marks EE Other Assumptions Due Diligence Corporate Governance Key Transaction Assumptions i One-time merger expenses: $9.9 million (pre-tax) Cost savings estimated at 50% of MLVF's estimated noninterest expense ™ Phased in 50% in 2023

Slide 10: Our Story: Track Record of Profitable, Accretive M&A
Our story: track record of profitable « accretive M&A rg ‘Announces Acquisition of Malvern Bancorp, Inc. $4,000 $3,700 $3,500 Completes Acquisition of two NJ Branches Sues $3,000 F $2,500 | $2,000 $4,714 iPO * $1,500 $1,452 Central New Jersey $2,625 , Organic Expansion $1,073 1.000 Change in a $856

Slide 11: Malvern Acquisition vs. Prior Transactions
Malvern (Ex. AOCI & Rate Combined Marks)" Estimated (Total or Drekereiam 3/7/2014 | 9/15/2017 | 4/30/2018 9/30/19 Gaya Average) eerCuome $134,542 | $212,325 $128,179 $190,004 | $1,044,360 | $1,709,410 P/TBV (%) 50% 124% 99% 94% 100% 94% EPS Accretion a ~9% ~8% ~5% ~8% ~9% 8% TBV Dilution 6% (%) Accr

Slide 12: Pro Forma Deposit Composition
Pro Forma Deposit Co: FiRSTEANX P FirstBank 3.0% 15.4% npositio —-MALVERN = Bancorp Inc. Malvern Bank 79% “4 Pro Forma Company 43% 149% \ a — 50.5% \ 30.4% a, 36.0% Deposit (0003) Deposits ($00) Deposits (1003) TB Tensaction Assos 3 S708 Bam | Torsactin Accounts 3 TER [BBD Tensacton Accomm 7 1ST O [

Slide 13: Pro Forma Loan Composition
eF Pro Forma Loan Compositi aia MA uae ie FIRSTBANX px MALVERN | First Bank | Malvern Bank Pro Forma Company rary te Son 6.8% i > 67% aN 41.7% Loans ($008) Loans ($0005) Loans S000) Hl Corsinicton & Land + 220 El coretcton & Lona 20912 90% BP Consinicton& Lane Twa 40% Bian » Hiram nao; 6% i ram 1180

Slide 14: Financial Impact Reconciliation
Financial Impact Reconciliation % s ‘TBV Dilution (8.17%) ($1.36) Loan Interest Rate Mark 4.33% $0.64 ‘Securities Interest Rate Mark 1.20% $0.18 Recapture of AOC! 0.85% $0.13 BV Dituton Adjusted (2.79%) ($0.41) EPS Accretion (GAAP) 20.5% $0.44 Loan Interest Rate Mark Accretion (9.23%) ($0.20) ‘Secur

Slide 15: First Bank
FIRSTBANK Pensenal Bankers. Real Relationships.
Source: SEC EDGAR · DEFA14A filed Dec 14, 2022



