Anja Balfour
Chairman at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Replay available
Annual General Meeting hosted by Global Smaller Companies Trust (LSE:GSCT) on Investor Meet Company, held 2024-08-13.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/the-global-smaller-companies-trust-plc-gsct-annual-general-meeting-1
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:01 Good afternoon, and welcome to the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC Annual General Meeting. Throughout the recorded meeting, attendees will be in listen only mode. The meeting will commence shortly. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen,
1:55 and welcome to the Chartered Accountants Hall.
1:58 It's now twelve noon and time to commence our hundred and thirty fifth Annual General Meeting, and a very welcome to those in the room and those also joining us online. Can I check? Just check first, can you all hear me? Yes. Good. If at any time you can't hear me or any other speaker, please let us know, and we'll get it sorted. The company secretary has advised that a quorum of members is present, and accordingly, I declare the meeting open. First of all, I'd like to introduce you to the board, and you can find brief details relating to each director on page 45 of the annual report. On my right is Nick Bannerman.
2:44 Next to him, Graham Aldroyd and Randeep Gral. On my left, Ian Ridge, the company secretary, Joe Dixon, senior independent director and chairman of the Audit and Management Engagement Committee, and Bulbul Barrett. Before the formal business of the meeting, I'd like to begin by explaining the format of the meeting. In a moment, our lead fund manager, Nish Patel, will give you an update on the company's performance and talk about prospects in more detail. You'll then have the chance to answer questions on his presentations, the annual report and financial statements, the resolutions in the notice of the meeting, and any other relevant matters, shareholders wish to raise.
3:35 As you will know, Nish took over the lead manager role from Peter Ewins at the start of May, and Peter has now retired. Peter had been the lead manager since 2005, and we are extremely grateful for his contribution and wish him a long and happy retirement. On completion of the meeting, I would like to invite those here in person to join the directors for refreshments when you'll have the opportunity to meet with us and and Nish and discuss, issues more informally. Now I'd like to invite Nish to come up and take... Make his presentation. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.
4:38 It's a real honor to talk to you for the first time as lead manager of the... Of your company, the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST. I have met some of you in the past, but for those of you that I haven't met, I think it might be useful if I give you a bit of detail about my background, and then we can talk about the financial results of the year just ended. As many of you know and as the chair pointed out, Peter Ewins very successfully ran the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST for nineteen years. And I actually worked with Peter really closely for sixteen of those nineteen years. What's always been the case about the management of the investment portfolio for the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST is it's very much been a team endeavor.
5:27 And I'm very happy that my colleagues have sat here in the front row here today, and I've worked with most of my colleagues for a really long time. So for you as shareholders, you can be assured that the investment philosophy and process will largely stay the same. And just to recap what that investment philosophy and process is, we are long term conservative investors, and we look to invest in good quality growing businesses. And we buy into these businesses when they become available at an attractive valuation.
6:07 The philosophy in process works really well over the long term. It has a track record of delivering strong returns in in absolute terms and relative terms, and this is done with lower levels of risk and volatility. Now with a change in lead manager, there's always opportunity to make improvements, and that is something that I intend to do in the coming years. And I'll be more than happy to go into more detail on what those changes might be in the question and answer session. So let's now turn to the financial year just ended 2024. There are six areas to cover. First of all, the market environment, the results for the year ended, the performance record, activity on the portfolio and how we're positioned, how we're doing in the New Year to date, and what we think the outlook is.
7:14 To give you some context, I think it's always good to discuss what the market environment was like over the financial year just ended. It was a challenging period for smaller companies in general. North America and the technology sector were really strong parts of the market, whilst other parts of the market lagged. And what that meant was that there was significant dis... Differences in in valuations across the different geographies and sectors with North America and technology valuations expanding significantly. Inflation's been a real problem for the last three years or so. But pleasingly, during the financial year, it looked like, excuse me, inflation had peaked.
8:01 Services inflation has been particularly stubborn, and the labor market has been stronger than expected. And that meant the interest rate cuts were delayed. Many thought that at the beginning of the financial year that there would be interest rate cuts, but they were delayed because of these two factors. The economy was was surprisingly resilient. At the beginning of 2023, many people thought that we would slip into a recession. But, actually, growth was better than expected, and it was very bifurcated. So the lower income consumers, they appeared to struggle, but the higher income consumers did better because they own as... They owned assets that went up in value, and they also had bank accounts that were earning more in interest income because of higher interest rates.
8:53 It's been four years since the start of the COVID pandemic, and it's really surprising because even though it's been four years since the start, some of the companies are still feeling the effects from this. Namely, they are still being impacted by distortions in trading patterns because of stocking up and then destocking. Geopolitical risks still remain very elevated. And during the year, very sadly, the war in Ukraine continued, war broke out in The Middle East, and, of course, we had several elections. Towards the end of the financial year, what we did notice was that some complacency did enter into the markets. Some of the companies that we typically don't really invest in, such as speculative businesses or loss making businesses, they started to do quite well during the end of the financial year.
9:48 So in summary, there were plenty of crosscurrents to navigate. It was a challenging year for smaller companies in general.
10:01 Returning to the financial highlights for the twelve months ended the April 30. The NAV of the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST was up by 9%, and this was slightly behind the benchmark increase of 11.3%. And I'll talk a bit about why that was from a stock specific level. Encouragingly, performance really did pick up in the second half of the financial year after a difficult start. The share price of the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST was up by 12.7%, And what this implies is that the discount of the trust narrowed from 13% at the start of the year to 10% at the end of the year. Part of the reason why the discount narrowed over the financial year was we were much more active on share repurchases.
10:53 We indeed bought back 30,000,000 shares during the financial year just ended. That compares to just under 25,000,000 shares in the prior year. You can see on the chart here on the slide that the discount this shows the discount over ten years. And the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST, which is the dark blue line, it's seen its discount narrow significantly, especially towards the end of the financial year, and it has narrowed more than the wider investment trust universe as shown by the gray line. We do take our responsibility to shareholders very seriously when it comes to the discount. We do have a goal of trying to achieve a 5% discount in normal market conditions.
11:41 We are still short of that goal, so we will continue to buy back shares, and we will continue our efforts on marketing and other initiatives in order to narrow the discount further till we reach our goal.
12:00 Turning to performance by region, it really did vary. North America and The UK were behind, but Europe and Japan were ahead. The rest of the world was behind, but it is worth noting that we do hold two investment trusts within the rest of the world part of the... Of of the global smaller companies trust. And those two investment trusts did see a widening in their discounts, which did hinder performance.
12:29 On a stock specific level, here are the, the major winners and losers. The themes to point out here are that infrastructure had another good year. Eagle Materials and Martin Marietta Materials in The US and KIR Group in The UK, all of them benefited from a robust spending environment for infrastructure in general, especially in The US. Energy had an... Had a good year as well. Our holdings in Kirby Group, which is a, owner and operator of inland tank barges in The US, and Ashtead Technology in The UK, which is a rental services... Rental business for oilfield services equipment.
13:15 Those companies did really well during the financial year. And it was another year of progression for our growth businesses. These are businesses that deliver high returns on invested capital and have plenty of runway for future growth, and they really do span a whole host of different sectors. So for example, Boot Barn Holdings in The US is trying to roll out stores across the nation. In The UK, Kitwave Group is trying to consolidate a very fragmented food distribution market. 4imprint in The UK is a low cost producer of promotional products, and it is continuing to take market share. Lotus Bakeries in Europe is the producer of the Biscoff cookie, which I'm sure you're all familiar with, and they are trying to take their brand global.
14:10 All of those businesses delivered a very good year of growth, and we are confident that many of these businesses will be instrumental in driving future performance for this trust. We also had seven takeover bids in the financial year, and that included the Restaurant Group, which is the owner of the Wagamama's chain, which was bid for by private equity at a 35% premium. As ever, not everything worked out to plan, and we did have negative performers in in the year, and that included several businesses that traded really well during the COVID period, but then they gave up some of their gains during this financial year.
14:56 And that included Team seventeen, which is a developer of video games, MIPS, which is a maker of helmet technology for for for the biking industry. And another point to note is that there was a lot of destocking as well across several different sectors. Destocking occurred in the crop protection chemicals market, and that affected American Vanguard. In the steel industry, we have seen destocking, and that hurt GrafTech Industries. And Interpump, which is an Italian industrial business, also suffered from destocking.
15:32 Of course, there were stock specific issues as well. For example, LKQ was affected by weakness in the recreational vehicle market in The US. Cab payments had an unsuccessful debut on The UK stock market when it lost access to two of its largest regions because of negative regulatory developments. And Remy Cointreau, the French cognac maker, suffered from weakening demand. Performance over the last five years does include some good years and bad years as you do expect. The last twelve months have been more difficult, but pleasingly, performance has picked up in the second half of the year. And performance has picked up in The UK and in The US, which are the two largest parts of this investment trust.
16:23 This is very much a longer term strategy, and long term performance is strong with the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST growing its share price tenfold over the last twenty five years, and that is well ahead of its smaller companies' benchmarks and some larger company indices as well. The GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST is also ahead of its closest investment trust peers over one, three, and five years as well. So what have we been doing on the portfolio over the last twelve months? I would characterize our activity in three different areas. First of all, we have been buying quality businesses that we think can grow very reliably over the long term.
17:13 The reason why we think these businesses can grow reliably over the long term are, first of all, some of them are backed by very strong secular tailwinds, or they just have very stable end markets, or they have a high degree of recurring revenues within their revenue base. So examples of this would be Domino's Pizza, which is a very resilient business. It actually grew its same store sales and earnings even in the financial crisis. Healthcare Realty Trust in in The US, which is an owner of medical office buildings. That business is is supported by very favorable long term demographics, and Acceleron in Switzerland, where 75% of this company's revenues are recurring in nature.
18:00 The second area of focus is cyclical businesses where the expectations and valuations are extremely low. In all these cases, we think the share price has discounted a lot of bad news. And if there is any surprise on the upside, then the... Then these companies have a lot of appreciation potential. Examples here would be Frontdoor in The US, which is a provider of home warranty plans where the company's revenues are strongly linked to the number of housing transactions.
18:35 We also, bought into Marshalls, which is a producer of UK landscaping products. And clearly, that industry at the moment is in the middle of a downturn, but we think the shares can bounce back quite strongly over the medium to long term. And then finally, we have invested in commodities during the financial year. When we've met with management teams in the commodities sector, something that has become really apparent is that the industry has been starved of capital over the last ten years. Management teams in the commodities sector have not been exploring the new assets. Instead, they have been returning cash to shareholders. And as a result of the supply being constrained, we think that returns for these businesses within this sector will improve because of this declining supply situation.
19:28 At the same time, we think demand might actually be better than people think because of long term tailwinds such as energy efficiency.
19:38 So we added during the year to Ithaca Energy, TGS, and Vitesse Energy, all of which operate in the oil industry, for example. On the sell side, our activity really focused on three areas. First of all, we have to hold our hands up and admit that we got some things wrong and that the investment thesis did break for some of our holdings. For example, for Merlin Properties, which is a Spanish real estate business, we lost confidence in management because we think that their view of of the value of their office properties is too optimistic and that the transition from office properties into data centers will be more difficult than management are laying out.
20:28 Secondly, Alliance Pharma was the subject of a CMA investigation, and we think that the comp... It will it will be really difficult for the company to attract a new management team, so the investment thesis did break for that company as well. Of the seven takeover bids that we had during the financial year, we did monetize some of them, and we used them as a source of cash to start new holdings. And then finally, we were not afraid to take profits or to sell businesses that we think became overvalued or where the valuation became fair in the case of cyclical businesses. So how are we positioned at the moment?
21:12 So it is worth mentioning initially that asset allocation is very much the result of bottom up stock selection, and it is a result of where we are finding good ideas. And today, we are finding many more ideas in The UK and Europe than other parts of the world, and that's why we are over indexed to those two regions. And amazingly, The UK is actually... Looks like it's politically stable at the moment, and we can't say that. In recent past, it's been very unstable. And when you compare it to rest... To other parts of the world, the situation is looking a lot better. And with interest rates being cut, we think that that will be really helpful for the growth outlook for The UK economy.
22:00 And as the new government does enact and put into place its agenda to grow, that will be helpful for the companies within The UK market. In North America, we are finding the valuations more demanding. We are finding less companies, fewer companies to invest in that meet our criteria. And at the same time, the economy does look like it's coming off the boil after a lot of stimulus that was put in place. From a sector perspective, we are different to other funds in the sense that we are more diversified by sector. A lot of funds that you see out there in the marketplace today have heavy weightings in technology and health care, but we have found ideas, good ideas in a whole host of different sectors.
22:49 Over the last twelve months, our weighting in industrials has gone up. And part of the reason why that is is that we have found really good ideas there because the sector is is quite out of favor. A lot of the destocking that I talked about earlier has impacted the share prices of many industrial businesses, and the valuations look attractive there. Over the long term, we think that the industrial sector can benefit from a number of different tailwinds behind it. For example, energy efficiency, spending on infrastructure and reshoring are all helpful trends for the industrial sector. In the real estate sector, we have increased our weighting there. We have bought businesses that we think will be beneficiaries of lower interest rates.
23:41 So looking at the portfolio today and how it compares to the benchmark, we think that the portfolio is well positioned. And I'm sure you'll appreciate that the data in smaller companies can be very messy. There are many smaller companies that are loss making. But when you compare on a like for like basis, we do have better quality and valuation metrics when you compare it to the benchmark. Quality as measured by gross margin, operating margin, return on equity and leverage and valuation as measured by price earnings ratio and dividend yield. So we can look forward with confidence that we have got the right portfolio. When it comes to the new financial year to date, it is still early, and the data here runs from the end of April till last week.
24:33 The NAV of the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST is down by about 0.9%, which is roughly in line with the benchmark. And the share price is up by point 8%. So again, that theme of narrowing of discount has continued. So what what do we think is the outlook for smaller companies and for the economy and markets in general? So let me start by saying that we find predicting and forecasting extremely difficult. It's not our area of expertise. Our strengths really lie in trying to understand businesses and valuing those businesses and buying into them at opportune moments.
25:18 But, however, I will give you my own opinion, and and and you can take it for what it's worth, and I'm sure you would all have your own opinions yourselves. But for me, the market environment will probably remain volatile, and it will probably be driven by the outlook for interest rates, the economy, inflation, and geopolitical developments. When we talk to management teams, it does seem apparent that higher interest rates are starting to affect the consumers, particularly at the lower end, and we think that that trend really needs to be watched quite carefully. Valuations are very bifurcated by sector and by region, and we think that this makes it much more of an active stock pickers market, which actually suits us.
26:08 Over the longer term, smaller companies have a history of doing really well and outperforming larger companies. But what's been really apparent in recent past, in recent years, is smaller companies have underperformed significantly. But we are excited about the smaller companies' asset class coming back into favor and that you as shareholders will benefit from that, and I wanted to give you a bit more color on that. So this is the smaller companies market in context of the overall stock market. The top chart is showing you the smaller companies market as a percentage of the overall total stock market. Historically, smaller companies have been between 78% of the overall stock market.
26:56 Today, that level is around the 4% level. And historically, 4% has been the cyclical low of of where this waiting has been, and it's normally been the start of a recovery cycle. So we should be optimistic that maybe the pain is behind us. And the recovery cycles can be quite long. So for example, in the nineteen seventies, the recovery cycle lasted about ten years. After the dot com bubble burst in 2000, the recovery cycle was eight years long. The valuation chart at the bottom, this is the relative valuation chart, the PE ratio of smaller companies versus larger companies, is telling you a similar story where the valuation of smaller companies relative to larger ones is at an almost twenty year low and historically been the point at which we have seen a recovery.
27:53 If we look at the regions, in this chart, we can see all the major regions and smaller company valuations and larger company valuations within those regions. What is very apparent is that in absolute terms, smaller companies are undervalued relative to larger companies, and they are undervalued relative relative to their own histories as well. It's pretty clear that The UK and the Europe market... European markets are the most undervalued, and The US is the least attractive smaller companies market. So the top down data is supporting what we are seeing from a bottom up perspective, And it... We are well positioned given that we are over indexed to The UK and Europe, and we are under indexed to North America.
28:45 So I think the merits of smaller companies is really well known. The question that we get asked a lot is what will cause smaller companies to catch up with large companies, and what will cause the recovery? What is the catalyst? So we think that there might be three reasons that could help spur the recovery. First of all, larger companies have done incredibly well. Some of these businesses are enormous now. Six of them have a a market cap over $1,000,000,000,000. And when you look at history and when you look at the fact that when companies become really big, they do find it difficult to maintain the same level of growth. And, unfortunately, for these businesses, they are not priced for a slowdown in growth.
29:32 And if there is a reassessment of growth prospects, maybe if competition starts to emerge or if these companies start to come across bottlenecks, then there may be an allocation switch out of these larger companies into other parts of the market, and that would include smaller companies. And smaller companies would really benefit from that. Secondly, we have seen a pickup in m and a activity and share repurchases amongst smaller companies, and that is really helpful in closing the gap between where these companies are trading at in terms of share price and what they are intrinsically worth. And then finally, we have the prospect of interest rate cuts. We've already had our first interest rate cut in The UK and in Europe.
30:19 We've also had an interest rate cut in Canada as well. Expectations are that we will have our first rate cut in in The US in September. Smaller companies have historically been very sensitive to interest rates, more sensitive than larger companies because more of these smaller companies have floating rate debt, and many of them are very dependent on financial conditions being loose. What you see typically in the past is when you've had the rate cuts, you've had a change in leadership of the market because smaller companies tend to benefit more from rate cuts than larger companies do. If you look at the data going back to the nineteen fifties, in the first twelve months after the first interest rate cut, we have seen smaller companies outperform larger companies by about 10 percentage point in the first twelve months.
31:11 So we think that there are genuine reasons for optimism that the asset class can come back. So in summary, it was a difficult investment environment in the year just ended. There were lots of crosscurrents. The movement in the NAV is slightly behind the benchmark, but the share price is ahead because the discount has narrowed. And we've raised the dividend significantly. We've raised dividend by 22% this year, and that makes the fifty fourth consecutive year of raising the dividend, which is a record that we are really proud of. Long term performance is strong, and the portfolio is really well positioned at the moment, and we think the asset class can come back into favor.
31:58 We appreciate that the recovery might be uneven, but we're optimistic that after a really long winter, the smaller companies market is showing signs of life and that it can sustainably recover over the longer term and that you as shareholders will benefit from that. And with that, I'll hand it back to the chair. Thank you very much, Nish. Now we can move on to questions on Nish's presentation. A microphone will be brought to you. And may I ask you to stand and just state the capacity which you are attending, whether it be shareholder proxy or corporate representative? So can I take the first question?
32:49 Thanks very much for the informative presentation. Can I ask you to define what secular tailwinds are? And further to that, how do you spot them? And can you take advantage of them in the portfolio ahead of your competitors?
33:10 I think we can define secular tailwinds as long term advantageous trends in the marketplace that will help to propel some of these businesses and the earnings of these businesses. So for example, demographics is a secular tailwind where an aging population will perhaps increase the earnings prospects of companies that are related to aging populations such as health care. So that's a definition of a secular tailwind. How do we spot them? Well, I think it's the same way that, I guess, most of our spot trends in general is just by reading through industry press and the news and seeing what the companies tell us.
33:59 We don't have a particular edge in investing in these secular tailwinds ahead of our competitors, but we are aware of them. And it is important to incorporate the valuations of the businesses that we're looking at and whether they have perhaps been a bit too optimistic about the secular tailwind that might be driving that particular industry or company because we don't want to invest in a company that has got fabulous growth prospects, but maybe the valuation has already taken that into account. Thank you. Next question. Helen Beaumont, Private Shareholder.
34:46 So I've got three questions.
34:49 One of which, yes, I enjoyed coming to the Annual Meeting but a bit disappointed to see that all the figures were based on 04/30/2024, so the same as in the Annual Report. So I think we'd definitely usually expect to get an update a bit more current. That's the point. Perhaps you could answer. The other thing is you keep talking to us as if we're shareholders. So I'm just asking, are you also a shareholder? And my third one is very much to the board.
35:27 One of the things that I find really disturbing and unnecessary is all this self registration as a UK tax person. And it says you will have to self register. And I'm very happy to say, yes, I'm a UK registered tax holder. But I am feel very reluctant to give them my NI number, what with all these data things. And I don't see why they need it. Anyway, it's an issue that is becoming more prevalent. So maybe you could make some comments on that, please. Okay. Shall I answer the last question first? Yes. You could bring us up to do with the up to date figures. Well, the last, I'm afraid we have no powers to change the tax regulation and the reporting.
36:13 We're very much
36:16 bound by it. And I do apologize for the added bureaucracy that shareholders have to go through with added legislation. And yeah, we all complain, but I'm afraid we can't change the law basically.
36:40 I believe so. Obviously, we try and make it as easy as possible, but we have to follow the law by the letter and it's all about reporting to the authorities. So, yeah. And and we appreciate the time you take and, you know, we're very grateful that you are shareholders. And to your second question, we all are shareholders, as is Nish, absolutely, and we absolutely believe in this fund. And then, yes, I think has some numbers on that bring us up to date. So I don't know if you've got them at So your we did go through the financial year to date. So this is as of the end of April till last week.
37:25 So the NAV of the trust is down 0.9%, which is in line with its benchmark, and the share price is ahead by 0.8%. So that will take you till the end of last week. So we do report at April and October because that's our year end. So as this is for the year end, that's why we've given you the April numbers. And to the question about the shareholding, yes, I am a shareholder. And this is through a regular investment plan. And my compensation and the team's compensation is very much linked to the performance of how the trust does and any products that we manage.
38:10 So rest assured that our interests are all aligned. John Burke, private shareholder and former financial journalist. You have twice mentioned, I quote, geopolitical risks, and you are not the first investment trust to do this. This may be a silly question, but because I think this is overriding, would you like to elaborate? Would you like to be specific what those geopolitical risks are? Yeah. So sadly, we do live in an uncertain world, and we have seen conflict break out in The Ukraine a few years ago and in The Middle East as well.
39:06 And those conflicts have potential to develop further in in a negative way. So these are risks that we are... We worry about. We worry about election results. We've, of course, you know, this year, I think almost half of the world's voting populations had an election this year, and that creates uncertainty. And we obviously have an election in in November in The US. So these are things that we generally do concern ourselves with.
39:38 We do focus a lot on the small... On the companies themselves and how they will do in a variety of different environments because we can't really predict, what way that geopolitics is going to trend, but it's something that we are very wary of. K. Henry Chua, Private Shareholder. Thank you for the presentation, Nish. I'd like to pick up on your introduction that you've been working with Peter, your predecessor for a while, and the team has been working with you also for a while. And the process is very well established investment.
40:27 But if I were to look at the performance, on page four or page nine of the report, we have very, very good long term performance, twenty five years.
40:40 If I look at the one, three, five, and 10, our performance has been pretty average, if not poor because we... By and large, whether it's in total share return or even by regions, most regions, we are behind. So what I'm trying to ask you, Nish, is are you going to bring some slight change in the, process so that we can hopefully get out of this circular, decline in the last ten or so years? Yeah. Thank you. Sure.
41:24 No doubt it has been a difficult and challenging environment. I think we're not the only ones who found it difficult. Active managers in general have found it a difficult investment environment to navigate. What I would say to you, what we're doing about it, because we can only control what we do, is that following the acquisition of BMO Global Asset Management by Columbia Threadneedle, that deal closed in November 2021. We are exploring what additional resources there are within Columbia Threadneedle to improve the investment proposition and to also lower costs for our clients. So for example, last year, after a lot of analysis and deliberation, we did decide that the Japanese equities team within Columbia Threadneedle, who have a really good track record investing in that market, would do a good job of investing the trusts, Japanese equities part of it. So half of it. So we decided we would move half of our allocation to them because they had a good track record and a similar philosophy and process.
42:41 Not only was this good from an investment proposition point of view, but it actually lowers cost view as well. And we are exploring other opportunities that we have within Columbia Threadneedle to make more use of the additional resources that that they have. It is an organization that is very intense on research, and it has a lot of additional know how and and and people that we can call upon. So so that that that is something that we are exploring.
43:11 Of course, the shape of the portfolios may change a little as well over the coming years. We do recognize that we do have a lot of holdings within the trust, although we do have a very high active share and our investment universe is actually really big. We think that by concentrating some parts of our portfolio, that can lead to an improvement in performance as well. And it is also worth mentioning that when you compare this trust versus its closest investment trust peers, it is ahead of them over one, three and five years. So we are finding it difficult as a whole active management community given all the headwinds that we have been facing, but we can look forward with optimism that we are taking the right steps. Can I can I just add as as a board?
43:59 I think you're doing the fund managers a slight disservice in that they're behind the benchmark. And as a board, we we give the fund manager a benchmark to perform against. But there are only really three investment trusts that offer truly global smaller companies exposure, and, this trust has outperformed the others. And over three years, I believe, it's the only trust that actually has a plus in in front of the net asset value return. So the the board are actually very satisfied with the performance, over the periods you mentioned, given the market circumstances. The the benchmark is smaller companies' benchmarks are always very difficult to follow.
44:47 They're really a reference rather than an absolute target.
44:58 Thank you. I've just got two questions. On your graph, you showed the historical composition of small caps of the stock market, which you said has been an average of 7% and now presently at 4%. How much of that do you think has been affected by the growth in private equity and the sheer volumes of takeovers and mergers? That's the first question. Do you want the second? Yes. Go ahead. The second is, presently we've got huge amounts, record amounts of global debts, which means it's very unlikely that interest rates will drop down to previous levels or anywhere close to that. Where do you expect interest rates to to stabilize?
45:47 It's very unlikely they're gonna go back to the ultra low rates post 2008, which were propped up by central banks around the world? On the first point, I think we're to have to provide you with the data on that one because you're right. You're 100% right in the sense that private equity has many companies have have decided to stay away from the public markets, they're actually in private hands. But we we would have to come back to you on on on that one. On your second point, calling the direction of interest rates is really not our strength. But what what I would say to you is that, yes, the debt levels are very high.
46:29 And historically, when you've had really high debt levels, there are a limited number of ways of reducing the debt. First of all, you can go down the path of austerity, which is never really popular with the electorate. Secondly, you can default on your debt, which again is not really an option that most governments go for. Or the third way is you can try and inflate the debt away. So there is a school of thought out there that we might have some period of financial repression where perhaps keeping interest rates at a certain level, but letting debt naturally deflate away through higher inflation could be a possible outcome for for many governments across the world.
47:14 So that's just some food for thought. But I think we were living in an abnormal world since the financial crisis where interest rates were too low. And then once we had this period of inflation, interest rates really did normalize back to what we call longer term levels. So, you know, I think the answer probably lies not as low as it was before, but maybe, you know, a little bit higher. Okay. As time is moving on, yeah, we'll take one or two more questions.
47:54 Victor Silk, shareholder. I've been a shareholder in this trust for four and a half years now, having bought the... My holding in January 2020. It's been a pretty unexciting ride. The share price has just gone up and down with the market, generally in a range between $1.30 and $1.60. Though last few weeks with small companies getting a little bit more into favor, I've seen it manage to edge up a bit on that. But the yield, the dividend yield over that time has only averaged about 2%. Now the cost of living over that period, four and a half years, has been above 2%, sometimes quite substantially.
48:46 So in terms of dividend yield, I'm losing money.
48:50 My cost of acquisition is about $14.08. So I do have, at the moment, a small capital profit, but a very small one. Generally The, speaking, the share price of a company tends to depend on what you can expect as a return on them. Now I think, really, you do need to start looking for some higher yielding shares to try and bring in some more resources. I know the dividend went up a little bit this year, but it needs to go up somewhat more. If you speak to me afterwards, I can point you in a direction of a couple of higher yielding smaller companies, which are pretty reliable or dividend ones, but I won't won't spout on about them now.
49:45 I... In addition to that, for the chair for the chair, last year, I hope that we modified this year by having some wine with our buffet, which we didn't...... Lowered the yield a little bit more perhaps. Which you didn't which you didn't serve last year, but you did the year before. So it makes us a little happier. Right. Can I just? This is not a yielding fund. That is not our aim. Although we have a good track record of raising the dividend, you know, it's a deliberate decision to to not be a high yielding fund. So the returns, you know, you should expect capital returns over dividend returns. Anyway, Nish, do you want to... Yeah.
50:34 I'd I'd I'd that point. Yeah. That that we look at total returns, and this is not just a pure dividend fund. But I would highlight that the growth of the dividend has been pretty significant over the last few years and that your initial yield will probably go up over time as the dividend continues to rise.
50:58 Well, I like your description of unexciting. I think that's a positive description in the investment world. Okay. Any more quest... Yes. One more question. Hi. I I I see 18% of our trust is invested in other trusts. Yeah. Can you tell me how you go about selecting and rejecting those trusts? Of course, we pay a fee on a fee owning shares in other trusts. Yeah. I...
51:33 Can you tell me how much of that is invested in India's Yeah. Smaller companies of that... Those investments? Yeah. So we do have collective investments for the rest of the world, part of the trust. And the reason why we do this is that that's a very specialist area of of the financial markets. And you really do need infrastructure to do well in... From a stock picking perspective. You need to have presence on the ground. You need to understand the conventions, the accounting, and really know the management teams very well and be able to travel to those parts
52:10 of the world. And we don't have that in house for smaller companies. So we want to find the best managers who can do a good job in those particular regions, which is why we use collective funds. And the way the way that we select them is that we meet the managers. We understand their philosophy and process, and we want a philosophy and process that makes sense to us and that resonates with us that's similar to other parts of of of this investment trust and a long track record of performance and a well resourced team as well. So these are the sorts of things, that we do. We also have help within, Columbia Threadneedle, in picking these funds from our multi manager funds.
53:00 And we even have... We can also ask, for example, the Asian equities team on what they think of holdings within these trusts and open ended funds. We do own trusts and open ended funds in in in the collective's part. We do have exposure to India within those collectives. And that part of the world is growing very quickly because of demographics and spending on infrastructure. And so we do have exposure to that part of the world as well.
53:32 Thank you. As there are no more questions, if I have your permission to continue with the formal business of the meeting. Thank you. A quorum is present, and the notice calling the meeting is set out on pages 92 to 96 of the annual report and financial statements and has been in shareholders', hands for the statutory period. May I take this notice as read? Thank you. The report of the auditor, which was unqualified, is set out on pages 66 to 71 of the annual report and financial statement. May I take this report as read? Thank you. I would now turn to the twenty twenty four annual report and financial statements.
54:22 I have nothing further to add to the statements, and therefore, before proposing the annual report, to the room, I would like to take any further questions from shareholders. No further questions? Thank you very much. I'll continue with the formal business of the meeting, therefore. The resolutions are set out in the notice of the annual general meeting on pages 92 to 96. May I take this notice as read? Thank you again. If you have any questions in relation to any of the 15 resolutions, can you please raise your hand now? No questions.
55:09 Thank you. We will now proceed to, the vote on the resolutions. As stated in the annual report and in accordance with the company's articles, voting will be conducted by way of a poll, which ensures that the votes of all shareholders are counted, whether or not they are able to attend the meeting today. I'm appointing Computershare, the company's registrar, to act as scrutineer. All of the resolutions and explanations are set out in the notice of annual general meeting and within the annual report. On a poll, each shareholder present in person by proxy or corporate representative has one vote for every share held. If you have already voted by appointing the chairman of the meeting as your proxy, then unless you wish to change your vote, you need not vote again in the poll as your existing vote will be counted.
56:06 If you have not voted and you wish to, please complete the poll card, which was given to you when you arrived, by writing your full name and address in block letters, making the appropriate cross next to each resolution and signing the poll card where indicated. Please then return the card to the registrar at the end of the meeting. If you are here as a proxy for a shareholder, you should insert the name and address of the shareholder you represent and sign as proxy, adding below your signature and your own name in block letters. Corporate representatives should complete the poll card with the full details of the name of the company they represent and provide the registrar with a form of identification.
56:56 I now propose formally that each of the resolutions set out in the notice of annual general meeting are put to the meeting. Resolutions one to 12 are ordinary resolutions requiring a simple majority of the votes cast to be passed, and resolutions 13 to 15 are special resolutions which require 75% of the votes cast to be passed. I now declare the poll formally open. The poll will close ten minutes after the end of the meeting, which should allow sufficient time to complete your poll cards. If you have any questions or require any assistance, please speak to the registrar's representative who is at the back of the room.
57:42 Shareholder proxies, either to me as chairman or other proxies in the room, are empowered to cast their votes on behalf of the shareholders who appointed them in the way they chose... The those shareholders instructed. It is a requirement to show the voting position on each resolution. Therefore, on the screen, you will see, hopefully, the proxy position as at two business days before the time of the meeting. Those figures will be revised to reflect any votes that are cast on the poll now. The results of the poll will be announced to the London Stock Exchange later today and a copy uploaded to the company's website. Now I'd like to mention that Joe Dixon will retire as a director at the close of today's meeting.
58:35 Jo was appointed in 2015, and I would like to take this opportunity to thank her for her service, contribution, and insights, which have been invaluable. We wish her well in the future.
58:56 Thank you for taking the time to join us today, whether in person, in the hall, or online. We appreciate your comments, observations, and your participation and, your very good insightful questions and any concerns you have, and, we'll con... Consider any concerns at our next board meeting and any issues that you've raised today. That concludes the formal meeting... Formal business of the meeting today. Before you join us for refreshments, I'd be grateful if you could remain seated until the registrar has collected your poll cards. Thank you very much indeed.
59:41 Thank you for updating investors today. On behalf of the board of the GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST, we'd like to thank you for attending today's annual general meeting, and good afternoon to you all.
Follow Global Smaller Companies Trust PLC into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Chairman at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Senior Independent Director at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Senior Independent Director at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Independent Non-Executive Director at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Independent Non-Executive Director at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Independent Non-Executive Director at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC
Portfolio Manager at THE GLOBAL SMALLER COMPANIES TRUST PLC