Jeff Lawrence
Chief Financial Officer
Replay available
Domino's Pizza (NASDAQ:DPZ) Q1 2020 earnings call, held 2020-04-23. Watch the replay and read the transcript on 6ix.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/dominos-pizza-inc-dpz-q1-2020-earnings-call
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Domino's Pizza first quarter 2020 earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker presentation, there will be a question and answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star 1 on your telephone. Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. If you require any further assistance, please press star then 0. I would now like to turn the conference over to your speaker today, Jeff Lawrence, Chief Financial Officer. Please go ahead, sir.
0:32 Thanks, Sonia, and hello, everyone. This is Jeff Lawrence, Chief Financial Officer of Domino's Pizza. Thank you for joining the call today about the results of our first quarter of 2020. Given the unique circumstances created by the COVID-19 crisis throughout the world, in addition to discussing our first quarter results, we are also going to share with you some preliminary estimated results We will start with comments from Chief Executive Officer Rich Allison, followed by an update from me, Rich, for closing remarks before taking analyst questions.
1:26 We ask that our analysts limit themselves to one question during this call. With that, I'd like to turn the call over to Rich.
1:34 Thanks, Jeff, and thanks to all of you for joining us this morning. Given the extraordinary circumstances, we are going to take a different approach to the call this morning. I'm going to speak first to share some perspective on the business, and how we're responding to the COVID-19 crisis both here in the U.S. and around the world. I'll then talk about some of the investments that we're making in our team members and in the communities that we serve. I'll then hand it over to Jeff who will walk you through the details around our Q1 performance and Jeff will also share some preliminary estimated results from the first few weeks of our second quarter. I'll then come back to discuss some of the things that we're focused on as we look forward to the remainder of 2020.
2:24 And then following that, as we always do, we'll be happy to take some of your questions. So with that as a roadmap for our call this morning, let's get started. And I'll begin with some perspectives on the business and how we're responding to this COVID-19 crisis. On the 30th of March, we released a preliminary first quarter business update. We pride ourselves on being transparent with our stakeholders, and we hope that information was helpful to you. So I won't spend much time on Q1 in my comments this morning, as I've already shared some of my perspective on the quarter in that release. The reality is that the world is changing very rapidly, and we are much more focused The restaurant industry is facing an existential crisis and no one knows how many restaurants will survive or what form the industry will take as this crisis eventually abates.
3:31 We also don't know how consumer behaviors and purchasing patterns may evolve during and then after this COVID-19 crisis. We were fortunate to enter the year in this crisis in what we believe to be a very strong financial position, both at the brand and at the franchisee levels. Our US franchisees averaged an estimated $143,000 in EBITDA per store and over $1 million in average EBITDA at the enterprise level in 2019. Both of those figures are increases over the 2018 levels.
4:18 Now we know that profit levels vary significantly across the country based on wage levels and a number of other factors, but we're pleased that our franchisees remained healthy and strong throughout 2019. Looking forward here into 2020, we know our business, along with our franchisees and stores, will face new costs as we respond to COVID-19 with new service methods and a number of investments in items such as masks, gloves, and thermometers, both for corporate and franchisee team members. We are well positioned as a brand with a delivery and carry out business model, and this has allowed us to continue serving our customers and employing our team members in the sizable majority Our first two values at Domino's are, number one, do the right thing, and second, put our people first. And for us, that means prioritizing the health and well-being of store team members.
5:40 and the communities that we serve. During this extraordinary time, we take our responsibility for continuing to provide convenient, reliable delivery and carry out experiences to the communities where those services have been deemed essential. We take it very seriously. Fewer than 20 stores in our U.S. business are currently facing temporary closures. All others remain open and our serving customers. Now with that said, our U.S. business model has adapted to this new environment and our standard operating procedures have changed considerably over the last two months. I say to folks here inside Domino's, we're a 60-year-old brand that has rewritten most of our standard operating procedures in the last six weeks.
6:35 We've moved to a 100% contactless delivery model across the country. We have made our contactless drive-up carryout technology available to all US stores. We have temporarily banned customers from sitting and eating in our stores. We're asking our customers to practice social distancing when they visit us to pick up their carryout orders. We have implemented social distancing protocols in our store and supply chain for our team members there. And in addition to thermometers, we are supplying them with masks and gloves to protect our teams and our customers. At Domino's, food safety and cleanliness have always been top priorities, but recently we've devoted additional resources toward our efforts and our procedures there.
7:29 I'm incredibly proud of our U.S. franchisees. Thank you for joining us today. Through the remarkable efforts of our supply chain team, we successfully opened our newest supply chain center in Columbia, South Carolina on March 29. We're working very closely with our suppliers to maintain a safe and stable flow of product into our stores.
8:16 I'm so proud of our supply chain team. They've done just a tremendous job of continuing our core operations Thank you for joining us. This morning we released our preliminary estimated U.S. sales results for the first four weeks of this second quarter. Sales have improved relative to the last two periods of the first quarter as detailed in our March 30th business update. And Jeff is going to share more details around this later this morning in our call.
9:14 We continue to observe and analyze the rapidly changing trends in consumer purchasing behavior. Across delivery and carryout service methods, day parts, days of the week, the U.S. will continue to be impacted by many factors, such as shelter-in-place orders, business and school closings, and event cancellations, which vary in magnitude across the cities and towns in the U.S. that we serve. Thank you for joining us. At our peak, we had almost 2,400 international stores closed, and as of April 21st, that number was approximately 1,750.
10:29 This morning, we also released our preliminary estimated international sales results for the first three weeks of the second quarter. The sales impact stemming from COVID-19 varies quite dramatically across our international markets. Some markets where we have significant service method and operating hour restrictions, we have seen major declines in same-store sales. In other markets, we've seen strong recovery and steady gains in same-store sales over the recent weeks. China was our first market to be significantly impacted by COVID-19, and we are pleased to see our sales there recover and accelerate in the last few weeks of the first quarter and to remain strong early in Q2.
11:19 I'm very proud of our international master franchisees and their resiliency as they manage through this crisis in their markets around the world. I'm also grateful for the best practice sharing and rapid adoption of new ideas across the globe. Much of what we're doing today right here in the U.S. has been informed and inspired by our international markets Thank you for joining us today. We have committed to pay additional bonuses to our corporate store and supply chain hourly team members over a 10-week period from mid-March through at least the last pay period in May. We're also providing enhanced sick pay benefits to our hourly corporate store and supply chain team members through at least the remainder of the year.
12:36 At Domino's, we don't want anyone to have to choose between their health and their paycheck. Now most of you probably are not familiar with the Domino's Pizza Partners Foundation. It's a registered 501c3 that was established to help Domino's team members in need during a time of crisis. Its mission is summed up in the phrase, team members helping team members. And its primary source of funding is through payroll deduction from corporate and franchisee employees. I'm very proud to say that our company is making a significant donation to the Partners Foundation to help team members at this particular time of need across the globe.
13:21 We're grateful as a brand that we're in a position to be able to make these investments, and we are very proud of our independent franchise business owners, many of whom are making similar investments in their team members. Our supply chain centers, corporate stores, and franchisees are also hiring and have been looking to add more than 10,000 employees across the U.S. With so many Americans newly unemployed, we feel privileged to be in a position to offer employment and a career opportunity within the Domino's Pizza system. We're also committed to supporting the communities around the U.S. where we live and work. We recently launched our Feed the Need program This is in partnership with our franchisees to provide 10 million slices of pizza across the U.S. We're making a significant investment as a brand by supplying the food for this program while our franchisees and corporate stores are being generous in providing the labor.
14:24 We've empowered our franchisees and stores across the country to identify the needs specific in their communities. In some places, it's school children who are no longer receiving free or reduced lunch. In others, it's hospital workers and first responders. In some places, it's essential workers in grocery and retail and many other areas. This isn't new because Domino's has always given back in times of crisis. This isn't an exception. While these are some highlights from the U.S., I would be remiss this morning if I didn't also thank our international master franchisees, many of whom are doing similar things in their markets. From the UK to India to Australia and really all over the world, the Domino's system is stepping up to support our communities.
15:17 As a system, we are happy to make these investments in both our teams and our communities, and we'll continue to search for ways to invest and to feed the need Thank you for joining us today. and then after that I'll come back and share a few more thoughts with you before we move to Q&A. So Jeff, over to you.
16:05 Thank you, Rich, and good morning again, everyone. I'll cover off the first quarter financial results as well as provide a brief preliminary financial update for the business for the first few weeks of the second quarter. Starting with the first quarter results, we continue to lead the broader restaurant industry with 36 straight quarters of positive U.S. comparable sales, and 105 consecutive quarters of positive international comps. We also continue to increase our global store count as we opened 178 gross new stores and 69 net new stores in Q1. This net store growth number includes the closure of the 71 stores comprising our South Africa market during the quarter that was unrelated to the COVID-19 pandemic.
16:52 Thank you for joining us. Global retail sales grew by 5.9%. This global retail sales growth was driven by both an increase in the average number of stores open during the quarter and higher same-store sales. Same-store sales for the U.S. grew 1.6%, lapping a prior-year increase of 3.9%.
17:41 And same-store sales for our international business grew 1.5%, rolling over a prior-year increase of 1.8%. Breaking down the U.S. comp, Thank you for joining us. Thank you for joining us. The closure of the 71 stores comprising our South Africa market.
18:53 Turning to revenues, total revenues for the first quarter were up 4.4% from the prior year, driven primarily by higher global retail sales, which drove higher supply chain and global franchise revenues. These increases were partially offset by lower company-owned store revenues resulting from the New York store sale in Q2 of 2019. International royalty revenues were pressured by $1.4 million during the quarter by foreign currency exchange rates. Moving now to operating margin. As a percentage of revenues, consolidated operating margin for the quarter increased to 39% from 38.6% in the prior year quarter and was positively impacted by the New York store sale and higher revenues from our global franchise business.
19:43 Thank you for joining us. Down 18.8 percentage points from the prior year quarter. The reported effective tax rate in the quarter included a 26 percentage point positive impact from tax benefits on equity-based compensation. We do expect to see continued volatility in our effective tax rate related to these tax benefits.
20:32 When you add it all up, our first quarter net income was up $29 million or 31.2% over the prior year quarter. Our first quarter diluted EPS was $3.07 versus $2.20 in the prior year, which was a 39.5% increase. Here is how that 87 cent increase breaks down for the quarter. Our lower effective tax rate, resulting primarily from higher tax benefits on equity-based compensation, positively impacted us by 58 cents. Lower diluted share count, resulting primarily from share repurchases over the past 12 months, Thank you for joining us. All in all, a good quarter for the business in Q1.
22:05 As we now move away from our Q1 financial discussions, I'd like to remind folks that we did issue a business update on March 30, which contained preliminary estimates of selected Q1 information, including comps, store growth, and global retail sales information. We also informed the market that due to the uncertainty surrounding the global economy and our business operations considering COVID-19, we withdrew our 2020 guidance measures related to G&A, CapEx, store food basket pricing, and and the impact of foreign currency on royalty revenues. We also announced that as a precautionary measure, we borrowed the remaining funds available to us under our outstanding variable funding notes to further strengthen our already strong financial position.
22:52 I'd like to now switch gears and give a financial update on the business for the first few weeks of the second quarter for which we have available results. This information contains preliminary unaudited estimates, and is being provided to assist our stakeholders with a high level understanding of how the business is performing during these extraordinary times. In the U.S. business, comps were up 7.1% during the first four weeks of Q2. U.S. retail sales were up 10.7% over the same time period. Sales trended up significantly over this four week period. as it relates to U.S. customer behavior during this crisis, this is what we are generally seeing thus far. Delivery and carryout mix are holding relatively steady on average.
23:44 Weekday sales have been significantly up while weekends have generally been more pressured. Lunch and dinner day parts are up while late night has been more pressured. And we are seeing larger order sizes throughout the week. Again, These are initial observations regarding consumer behavior and we may experience volatility in our sales going forward as a result of this dynamic environment. In our international business, comps were down 3.2% during the first three weeks of Q2. Important to note here that we are only reporting three weeks of international sales information due to the normal reporting lag in that business.
24:30 To be very clear, The international same-store sales comp for the last two weeks of Q1 and the first three weeks of Q2 was negatively impacted by COVID-19. The negative impact primarily occurred from stores that had sales in a week but were limited due to a service restriction, carryout and or delivery, and in some markets even dine-in restrictions, a part of the week temporary closure, and or a change in store hours. If a store was closed the entire week and had zero sales for that week, however, it is not included in same-store sales definition or results. Moving on to retail sales for international, retail sales excluding FX were down 13.2% over the same time period, reflecting the many stores internationally that have been temporarily closed or have some other operating restriction impacting sales.
25:30 We have not provided widespread economic relief to our franchisees globally. While we acknowledge that this could change depending on the time period that this crisis persists and its overall impact on our results, we attribute our current situation to the underlying strength of our business model and the overall economics that our franchise partners have earned alongside of us over the past many years. The strength and resiliency of the Domino's brand has never been more evident. As Rich discussed earlier, we are making significant investments in our team members and our communities during this time of crisis, including frontline bonuses, enhanced sick pay policies, community giving and partnership with our franchisees, and investments in supplies such as face coverings and gloves.
26:17 We anticipate pressure on our Q2 earnings related to these investments of approximately $15 million. Based on trends we've seen to date, we also anticipate pressure on our Q2 earnings related of an additional approximately $5 million related to lost revenues from our international franchise stores due to those temporary store closures. These are current estimates and they're preliminary and it could very likely change. We would also be remiss if we didn't comment on what we're seeing in the FX markets. If FX rates hold for the remainder of the year, we believe it could be a substantial headwind to 2020 cash flows and earnings of approximately $10 million. Thank you for joining us. and the available cash balance I just mentioned.
27:31 We continue to invest in our strategic initiatives and we paid our shareholders our previously declared dividend on March the 30th. Additionally, earlier this week, our Board of Directors declared a 78 cent per share dividend to be paid on June the 30th. Separately, we have not repurchased any shares under our authorized share repurchase program since the first week of January. As a reminder, we currently have $327 million remaining under our board authorization for future repurchases. In closing, we remain in good shape financially, and we will continue to closely monitor all aspects of our business as we operate in these uncertain times. We will continue to focus on doing the right thing for our team members and our communities today while ensuring that we not only survive but are best positioned to thrive coming out of this crisis tomorrow.
28:26 Thank you, Jeff.
28:28 I would now like to turn everyone's attention to our focus looking forward. Across the globe, Domino's will remain steadfastly focused on the health and safety of our franchisees, team members, and our customers. That is always priority one. We'll also remain focused on execution, service, and value as we continue to navigate through these headwinds created by COVID-19. 2020 will continue to bring more uncertainty to the restaurant industry than any of us have ever experienced. And we do not have clear visibility into the duration and magnitude of the impact of this pandemic on our industry or our business and continue to assess each on an ongoing basis.
29:19 We do expect that the sales impact will continue to vary greatly across the cities and communities in the U.S. and in our 90 markets around the world. Given general economic conditions along with uncertain timing of the infection curve, the shelter-in-place orders, business interruptions, school and university closings, and so many other factors make forecasting sales more difficult than ever. We do expect to see a significant impact on our store openings this year as construction and municipal permitting have slowed down dramatically during the crisis. We should have better visibility around unit growth in the months ahead.
30:05 So given all of this, as noted in this morning's release, we are withdrawing our two to three year outlook for global retail sales growth, U.S. same store sales growth, international same store sales growth, and global net unit growth. I want to be clear. Do not mistake that as a lack of optimism about the Domino's brand and our business looking forward. I remain very optimistic about the long-term growth and success of our brand. There is just too much uncertainty in the current operating and economic environment for us to provide an outlook at this time. In this uncertain environment, you can rest assured that we are carefully managing our balance sheet We are committed as a brand and as a system to managing through COVID-19 and to emerging even stronger in the future.
30:55 I have extraordinary confidence in our franchisees and in our teams around the world. There is simply no group of people that I would rather stand beside than the approximately 350,000 individuals that wear the Domino's logo. I am proud and I am grateful to serve them each and every day. And now, Jeff and I will be happy to take some of your questions. Thank you. As a reminder, to ask a question, you will need to press star 1 on your telephone.
31:42 To wish all your questions, press the pound key. In the interest of time, you actually limit yourself to one question. Our first question comes from Brian Pittenger of Oppenheimer and Company. Your line is now open.
31:55 Hi, good morning. Thanks for the question, guys. I know that there's a lot of moving pieces when we look at short windows on your comps, but your trends to Star 2Q have clearly seen this measurable improvement versus 1Q, and I appreciate the color that you gave, Jeff, and your prepared remarks on what you're seeing from a day part perspective, etc., But can you unpack this recent improvement just a little more for us? What do you think has clearly changed recently that's driving the positive impact on your business? I know the underlying restaurant industry has gotten a little better the last several weeks, but I just wouldn't expect that to be a huge factor for you guys. So any additional color like maybe stimulus impacts or anything else that you can provide on recent trends would be helpful.
32:46 Hey, Brian, it's Rich. Thanks for the question. I think there are several things that we're seeing in recent weeks, and again, it is a very dynamic situation that we're all living in. But certainly, I think some of the improvement results from the fact that there was a lot of pantry loading that consumers did as the pandemic really first started to come to the U.S., and I think as we've seen in some of our Asian markets in particular that we're more on the front end of this, as time goes forward, people start to get a bit tired of cooking and eating the same things. Some of the pantry loading that they've done, it starts to bleed down a bit over time. I also think we and I suspect the rest of the industry probably are seeing some near-term impact here from some of the stimulus dollars. that have gone out.
33:45 So there are some factors that I would characterize as being more outside of our control. But then I think there are some things that are inside of our control. And if you've taken a look at what we've done as a brand over the course of the last three or four weeks, we have pivoted very quickly to implement contactless delivery and carryout procedures across our system to ensure to protect our team members and also to give our customers confidence in the experience that they will have with us. We've pivoted our advertising quite significantly to focus on those important cues, which are very important to customers right now to have a safe and pleasurable food experience for their families. Brian, I think a combination of some factors outside of our control, but I think also some things that we're doing here at Domino's as well.
34:49 Thank you, Rich. Thank you. And our next question comes from Matt DeFrisco of Guggenheim. Your line is now open.
34:58 Thank you. Jeff, can you speak a little bit about those charges, I guess, or the $15 million and the $5 million? I just want to understand how you're coming about with those. The math would suggest about 1,700 stores or so is closer to 15%, but you're lower than 10% on that sales hit. So is it correct to assume that you're expecting these to continue to open and not be closed for the full quarter in that estimation? and then also the $15 million. I guess can you just sort of bracket that? I want to better understand that in the new normal that these costs wouldn't necessarily be an ongoing quarterly charge, that it's mostly front line stuff and the bonuses, not necessarily new investments that are required in what maybe investors might perceive as a new normal.
35:48 Thanks, Matt. I hope you're well and appreciate the question. The first thing I would just caution everyone on is we don't know what the new normal is going to be. The information that we've shared with you today is preliminary, it's estimated, and it's the best that we can give you right now, but we wanted to give you our best shot at what we're seeing kind of live. I'll break it down in kind of the three big buckets that I talked about during my prepared remarks. The biggest bucket that we expect, again, we don't know yet. We're only four weeks into a 12-week quarter here, so a lot still to happen in an uncertain environment, is the $15 million related to doing the right thing for the safety and well-being of our team members, our customers, and our communities.
36:34 This is the 10 million slices of pizza. This is masks and gloves. This is bonus pay for our frontline team members and our stores. and in our supply chain centers and it's just stuff that we're proud to be able to do and it's going to have a pretty significant impact and we're okay with that. It's the right thing to do. I then kind of get into the next bucket which is the international business has been clearly impacted more on the whole than our singular market of the U.S. business. It's an average. There are 90 markets there. There are lots of different things going on but as we look at the first Four weeks in the quarter, quarter two, and knowing that we have, again, eight weeks to go, our best guess is that we're going to take a haircut of about $5 million in royalties.
37:25 It could be higher. It could be lower. It's preliminary. But it's super dynamic, and that's what we're seeing today. The last thing, you know, we could argue it's COVID-related or maybe indirectly COVID-related, but it's just the impact of FX. In that one, I gave you at least a preliminary view for the whole year. You know, $10 million kind of year over year of a bad guy there. Again, preliminary estimated. Don't know if that's going to be the number. But when you add all three of those up, you know, as we look today, it's a $30 million headwind. Some of it was in our control and we're proud to do. Some of it kind of happening to us. So that's the best we can give you, you know, right now. We'll continue to assess. Whether we give any additional business updates between now and July, we're not promising anything today.
38:15 But for sure, you'll hear more detail from us in July. And by then, I'll tell you and Rich will tell you exactly what happened for the 412 weeks of Q2.
38:25 Excellent. Thank you so much. Glad you're all well.
38:28 Thank you. Thanks for the question. Thank you. And our next question comes from Chris Opal of C4. Your line is now open.
38:37 Yeah, thanks. Good morning, guys. Rich, does the company still plan to launch a new product in 2020? And if so, has the timing changed at all?
38:49 Hey, Chris, thanks for the question. Yes, we are still planning to launch a new product in 2020 and still anticipating to do that in the summertime. Obviously, managing through, you know, a different operating environment today as we work to make that happen. But we are still targeting summer for that launch.
39:15 Great. Thanks. Thank you. And our next question comes from Sarah Senatore, Bernstein. Your line is now open.
39:24 Hi. Thank you. I wanted to follow up on the business patterns you were seeing in the The Stronger Weekday vs. Weekends. or maybe talk about in the past the resilience of your category to when income's low. It's a little tricky because I know you're in the midst of a turnaround back in 2009, but just try to understand to parse out what role is sort of lower income playing versus more of the sort of stay-at-home shelter in place.
40:17 Thanks.
40:19 Hey, Sarah, it's Rich. Thanks for the question. We are still assessing this literally day by day as these patterns continue to evolve quite rapidly. Jeff highlighted some of them. Higher sales growth during the week than on the weekends. I think a lot of that is driven by the fact that there are more families at home during the week eating together. and then by day part our late night business is down significantly while lunch and dinner are much better and there just aren't evening gatherings of people or sporting events to watch and things like that so certainly those are having some impact.
41:09 We haven't seen any discernible patterns across income categories as you asked but interestingly enough Order sizes are up significantly, and I think that's because more people are at home eating together. But also, we're finding at Domino's, and I think some of our peers in the restaurant industry are finding, people are ordering extra food to have leftovers around also, which is a really interesting dynamic in the market today. But it's really early. Sarah, one of the things about this pandemic Thank you. And the next question comes from Alex Blagel of Jeffery's. Your line is now open.
42:19 Thanks for the question. I wanted to get your perspective on operations and restaurants and discuss any potential issues with delays in delivery times or longer carryout turnaround times and inventory management, stuff like that, that has demand likely been a bit less predictable and more volatile.
42:40 Sure. I'm really proud, Alex, of Our corporate stores and our franchisees who I think have just done a tremendous job with their operations in responding to this crisis. As I mentioned earlier in my prepared remarks, we've taken 60 years worth of standard operating procedures and we've had to rewrite a good many of them in just the last six weeks around contactless delivery and carry out, no sitting down and dining in our stores, Our drive-up carry-out feature, which we've now been rolling out aggressively across the country. And our franchisees and corporate stores have responded and done a terrific job.
43:25 Even despite the more recent increases in sales, they've done a very good job of continuing to provide high levels of safe and responsive service out there to our customers. Thanks. Thank you. And our next question comes from next segment of Woodbush Securities. Your line is now open. Thank you. You guys talked about, you know, obviously the near-term impact on unit openings, but could you maybe comment on the pipeline and, you know, medium to longer term, what some of the chaos, you know, across the industry means for, you know, the domestic unit growth rates? You know, we're already starting to hear Much more favorable terms, better site selection, and could that potentially mean a higher unit growth rate, especially domestically, in the medium to longer term for you guys?
44:27 Yeah, Nick, so on unit growth here in the U.S. near term, it really is all about just the slowdown in construction and permitting. in terms of the near-term slowdown in the opening. No fundamental changes as we look out over the medium to long-term in terms of the appetite of franchisees to open stores in the U.S. Stores over the medium and long-term are going to open based on strong unit-level economics, as they always have. Certainly, we are taking a look as we look out through the remainder of the year and into next and trying to assess what incremental opportunities might be available because of some of the changing dynamics in the real estate market and whether or not that means some sites may become available that weren't before or also some opportunities potentially around how we think about lease extensions and rent opportunities It has been a pretty tight real estate market for a while now.
45:36 We don't know exactly how much that's going to open up, but our guess is that it probably does open up a bit as we look out in the medium to long term. Thank you. Thank you. Our next question comes from Peter Slay at BTIG. Your line is now open.
45:55 Great. Thanks for taking the question. I just wanted to ask about the pizza, I guess, landscape right now as you guys see it. I know 50% or so of the category is still run by many of the independents. While you guys are the leaders and you've been taking share, I'm curious to see if anecdotally at least that you guys are seeing any closures in some of the markets or some pressure on the independents. You know, it is still, you know, really early, you know, to tell. Because, you know, we don't know, when we take a look across the restaurant landscape, there are a lot of restaurants out there that are not open.
46:53 We don't know how many of those are temporary and how many of those will turn into permanent closures. I eat at a lot of independent restaurants out there, so I think the last thing any of us in the industry want to see is a lot of independent restaurant closures. We do, you know, here at Domino's, we do believe that we're, you know, a pretty resilient brand, you know, in a time like this. I think the positioning that we have as a delivery and carry-out player has certainly helped us, you know, in the early part of this crisis. And I think will continue to help us because I don't think consumers are going to snap right back to the old patterns and behaviors.
47:46 I think The capability that we're building in contactless delivery and contactless carryout I think are going to continue to be important for many months to come when we think about how this ultimately evolves. As we think about the capabilities that we're putting in place today, it's not just to be competitive in the next couple of months. It really is to set ourselves up in what may end up being the new normal in our industry.
48:18 Thank you very much. Thank you. And our next question comes from Lauren Silverman of Credit Twist. Your line is now open.
48:26 Hi. Thanks for the question. To your point that you just made, do you expect contactless delivery will be something that will be available permanently and then contactless delivery change the economics of the delivery transaction or productivity and turnaround times at all?
48:40 Thank you. So, Lauren, right now contactless delivery is the only Thank you for joining us. that contactless experience in delivery and or in the carryout side of the business.
49:25 As it relates to the economics around contactless, we've just rolled out an innovation we call the pizza pedestal, which is a pretty simple cardboard pedestal so that our delivery experts Thank you for joining us. or however they choose to order from us and that includes some rapid innovation also to make tipping of our delivery experts easier and more prominent in the ordering experience because the last thing that we want to see come out of this is any of our delivery experts to see a decline in income as customers move away from cash transactions and more toward digital and either credit or debit card transactions.
50:48 Great. Thank you. Thank you. And our next question comes from Gregory Frankfort of Bank of America. Your line is now open.
50:56 Hey, Rich. Thanks for the question. Just first of all, clarification. Did you say China is running positively in recent weeks? I wasn't clear with, I guess, that description. And then In the U.S., are you seeing any differences regionally or urban versus suburban that are standing out in terms of how customers are using the brand or sales trends? Thanks.
51:17 Sure, Greg. So on China, we did see a pattern early on in the pandemic where China sales were pressured, but we have seen positive sales in China and improvements, in the latter part of the first quarter and here into the early weeks of the second quarter. I've got to tell you, I am incredibly proud of our team in China. Much of what we are doing across our 17,000 store footprint was based on innovations around contactless delivery that our team in China brought forward. So really, really proud of not only their business performance but also How they've contributed to our system.
52:32 There are certain places that have been significant hotspots for COVID-19. We've seen some places peak and start to level out while others ramp up. Most certainly, those have impacted some of the trends in our business performance in those geographies. As we sit here on the 23rd of April, it's still an evolving situation in many of the communities that we serve. There's also some very significant differences, as I'm sure you all are aware, just in terms of how states and local municipalities have responded to the crisis and what restrictions they have put in place in terms of what business can be conducted and what customers can do in terms of travel and other things in those states.
53:25 Thank you. Thank you. And our next question comes from David Tarantino of Bayard. Your line is now open.
53:33 Hi. Good morning. I hope everyone's doing well. My question, Rich, is on the international business. Really kind of two parts to it. First is related to how they're managing through or the ones that are seeing large or widespread closures, how they're managing through this from a financial perspective. And do you see Any signs of stress in the system related to that? And then secondly, and relatedly, is just the outlook for unit growth internationally with all the stress that appears to be occurring in the system, do you think we'll see a moderation for a time being as they work through this?
54:20 Yeah, David, on the first part of your question, Going into this, we're really fortunate to be in a place where we've got a significant amount of our international business that is managed by publicly traded master franchisees who came into this crisis with very strong financial positions. Relative to perhaps some other brands, strong ability to weather a crisis like this. Now that said, most certainly when in a country when you have to close all of your stores or close some substantial number or even some places as Jeff described, our stores are open but with very limited trading hours or very limited service methods. You know, those do result in significant, you know, declines in retail sales, you know, for a period of time.
55:23 Our master franchisees are, you know, doing all the things that you would expect them to do. You know, they're prioritizing first and foremost the safety of their team members and their customers, but they're also taking, you know, the appropriate steps to manage cash appropriately and to manage, you know, Make sure that they're being mindful of the liquidity in their operations. They're also working really hard to get those stores reopened. And we've already seen a couple of large international markets, Spain and France would be two, where we were completely closed for a period of time but have begun to reopen stores in each of those countries. We're staying very actively in touch with those international master franchisees and talking with them daily about their financial position.
56:22 We'll continue to do so as we work together through the course of this crisis. The second part of your question around unit growth, most certainly in the near term we will see an impact on unit growth. Much as I described in the U.S. where there are construction delays and there are The same holds true in many of the international markets. And then certainly in some of those markets that have been under more pressure where we've had a significant number of store closures or the entire market shuttered, certainly that results in some near-term slowdown in store growth there. But over the long term, I come back to what I always talk about. Thank you for joining us. We'll be right back.
57:32 across the globe. As you know, we've got a lot of share growth opportunity outside the U.S., and we've got well-capitalized and well-managed master franchisees who are going to be eager to get back after that as this subsides. Thank you. And our next question comes from James Rutherford of Stevens & Company. Your line is open.
57:59 Thanks for taking the question. Just one from me. I'm curious, Jeff, if you can share how much of the U.S. sales mix prior to COVID-19 was related to large group orders for parties, events, meetings, and the like. And I ask that because I assume those occasions have gone down dramatically, which makes the improvement in your other kinds of orders more impressive to drive that 7% comp here in the first four weeks of the second quarter.
58:27 Yeah, James, thanks for the question. You know, we're trying to be as transparent as we can and have given you guys a peek into the consumer behavior, at least during the first, you know, four weeks of Q2 here. But, you know, the insights aren't any more fancy than kind of we laid it out already. You can imagine that people that used to get around television to watch, you know, your favorite sporting event, those orders aren't there. If you are ordering and you're sheltered in a home with your family and Those orders are larger because you might be looking for some leftovers for the next couple days. If you had an occasion that you'd buy pizza for the folks that you work with in an office building, those occasions are gone. So it really is no more complicated than that, although I will still tell you it is early in this crisis.
59:13 We just don't know how that consumer behavior will ebb and flow as we continue through this and get out of this. But what I can tell you as Rich just alluded to is we believe that the global pizza industry is super resilient. People are going to want to eat pizza before, during, and after this crisis and there's no one better positioned with our franchise partners around the world to hopefully fill that demand than we do. So we'll be there for all the occasions. We'll continue to morph our standard operating procedures as Rich talked about to make sure that we give the consumers what they want now and in the future, again, being vertically integrated in tech, having real innovative business partners around the world give us a huge advantage versus a lot of the other competitors in the industry.
1:00:03 So we feel like if anybody can get it done, we can get it done, and we're going to continue to put, you know, our customers first, our team members safe in all that we do. Okay, thank you. And our next question comes from John Glass of Morgan Stanley. Your line is now open.
1:00:22 Thanks very much. How many of the customer visits you're seeing recently are coming from new customers or lapsed users? And what are you doing to maybe capitalize on that opportunity to get new customers? Are you incenting them to sign up in the loyalty program in a different way? And maybe any metrics around that loyalty growth during this period of time would be helpful. Thanks.
1:00:42 Sure, John. We absolutely are seeing... An uptick in new customers. I'll talk about it on a couple of dimensions. I am sure that we are seeing some folks trying us for the first time or trying us again. Just given the availability of restaurants and food types out there, we're getting a shot with some customers that maybe weren't doing business with us before. Also, what we're seeing is we are getting new customers Digital customers as well. The digital percentage of our business has ticked up pretty significantly in the last several weeks. I think I reported to you for the fourth quarter we touched 70% digital.
1:01:34 In recent weeks we're running 75% and we've had at least one week where we were over 80% digital. So that's also another Thank you for joining us. John, but certainly we're seeing some opportunities with customers that we didn't have in the previous couple of months leading up to COVID-19.
1:02:29 Thank you. Thank you. And our next question comes from Chris Carl of RBC Capital Markets. Your line is now open.
1:02:38 Hi, thanks for taking the question. I wanted to ask about aggregators and specifically, you know, any updated thoughts on how the current environment will shift the competitive dynamic and delivery. So with the rising demand for off-premise here, is there any more opportunity for Domino's to highlight its value positioning, especially in a more pressured macro environment?
1:03:03 Sure, Chris. Well, one thing I can tell you is, in the current environment we're operating in, I am so glad that we are not on these aggregator platforms as Domino's. When I think about what matters to our customers, the trust in knowing how that food, where it was prepared and who delivered it to them, It certainly comforts me to know that it is our uniformed and trained Domino's delivery experts that are bringing the food to the door in a time like this. I'm also very glad that we've made the decision over time to continue to own that customer relationship on the front end, particularly now that we're talking about a run rate of 75% plus digital.
1:03:55 Thank you for joining us. and many of them through the aggregators. This is going to be a very dynamic environment as we look over the months ahead and ultimately to all learn what ultimately sticks in terms of these changes in customer behavior because my guess is customers don't immediately go back to what they were doing before.
1:04:41 In that environment, we're staying focused on the things that We're also remaining very focused on service. One of the things that is happening right now across the Domino's U.S. business is the very aggressive hiring. of additional delivery experts. The labor market has been incredibly tight for a couple of years. As that has loosened up in recent weeks, we've just since announcing our effort to hire 10,000 team members in the U.S. Our corporate store business has hired 2,500 people in that limited period of time. and that is really a key element of how we continue to provide great service to our customers during this time and then staying out on the forefront of safety through all of these contactless methods through the enhanced cleaning of our stores.
1:05:59 We've changed from operational audits to safety awareness visits during this time so We believe all of those actions will continue to position us well as we move forward through this crisis and into the time period beyond. Great. Thank you. Thank you. And our next question comes from Katherine Fogarty of Goldman Sachs. Your line is now open.
1:06:29 Great. Thank you. Thanks for the question. I was wondering if you could comment. You mentioned a little bit about the 10,000 delivery expert hiring. If you could give a number of how many the whole system has hired and if you've seen any change in turnover, either positive or negative, at the stores given the current environment. and on that point, you know, wanted to get your thoughts on how you view, you know, your benefit package and the fact that you employ your drivers as a competitive advantage used to be the aggregators. Thank you.
1:07:04 Sure, Katie. So, you know, on the 10,000 folks that we're trying to hire across the system, we don't have perfect visibility into our franchisee hiring because, you know, that really is – Their team members to hire and to train. But what I can tell you from the conversations that we have is that the applicant volume has increased significantly since we began that effort. Unfortunately, we just saw another 4.5 million file for unemployment this morning. Unfortunately, There are a lot of people out there that are out of work right now.
1:07:49 And I am certain that that is contributing to the increased applicant flow that's coming into our stores. As I think about what our value proposition is relative to someone working in the gig economy, I think now in an environment where so many people are losing their jobs, Having a set schedule and having a job, getting a W-2 from Domino's or from one of Domino's franchisees I think is probably valued probably more than it has been in quite a long time. We've tried to make a very strong commitment to our corporate store team members. That's drivers and everybody in the store with enhanced bonuses.
1:08:46 Over a 10-week period, as folks work through this crisis, we've enhanced our sick pay benefits during that time as well. So we are also looking for opportunities here in the near term, but then also over the long term, to continue to make that a very attractive employment opportunity. And then finally, we've talked about it so many times, well over 90% of our U.S. franchisees started off as delivery drivers or folks working inside the stores That's a career opportunity that is out there that just isn't available in the gig economy.
1:09:24 Thank you. My question around turnover, are you seeing turnover go up, be flat, or go down in stores? Maybe if you can just comment on your company's stores here.
1:09:36 Katie, we haven't seen any major shifts in turnover. It's still a really short period. Thank you. And our next question comes from Alton Stumpf of Longbow Research. Your line is now open. Thank you. Most of the questions I haven't asked, but just to follow up on the last couple of your answers, Rich, is there an opportunity to
1:10:11 on the labor cost front for savings here, given the fact that they're obviously, to your point, an awful lot of people, especially in the restaurant industry, that are looking for work currently. Is that an opportunity potentially for you guys and or your franchisees to bring the average cost down a little bit on the labor front?
1:10:27 Hey, all of this, Rich, we're going to ask you to, your line was breaking up a little bit. If you could just slow down just a little bit and repeat that question. We just want to make sure, I think Jeff and I heard about 60% of it.
1:10:40 Oh, okay, sorry about that. I was just asking if there is an opportunity on a kind of labor cost front to save money given the fact that there obviously are a lot of people, to your point, especially in the restaurant industry that are looking for work currently.
1:10:53 Yeah, Alton, thanks for repeating that. You know, I want to be very clear and we want to be very clear that this crisis is not a time Thank you for joining us. Thank you. And our next question comes from John Ivanko, J.P. Morgan. Your line is now open. and John Ivanco. If your line is on mute, please unmute.
1:12:06 And again, our next question comes from John Ivanco of JPMorgan. Our next question comes from John Tower of Wells Fargo. Your line is now open.
1:12:18 Great. Hopefully you can hear me okay. Just a couple quick ones from me. You know, ad budgets are down across the restaurant space as a whole. but also all the advertising dollars seem to be pivoting towards this off-premise or delivery channel. So can you talk about how you're managing through communicating to consumers that your value is there and frankly breaking through to consumers in this time when everybody seems to be focused on this one channel and then just pivoting to the U.S. unit growth. I'm curious if you could talk about, you know, you mentioned the health of the franchise community is very strong coming into this crisis and we're taking a pause right now but is there any reason to believe that you can't ramp growth faster on the back end particularly if rents are going to be lower and or you see some independent store closures at the end of this whole crisis?
1:13:11 Thank you.
1:13:13 Hey, thanks, John. You know, on your first question around the advertising spin out there in the market, you know, Thank you for having me. Thank you for joining us. Most certainly, all of the spend out there, while some of it's come down overall, it really is focused on the delivery channel. We've just got to continue to invest against it. We've got to continue to talk about value, to talk about service, to talk about safely serving our customers.
1:14:36 I am really proud of our advertising team. They have pivoted so quickly and and if you look back over the last six weeks or so they've produced about an ad a week and normally we go through a much more prolonged cycle to produce advertising so we're trying to stay very nimble and we've just got a terrific team that's making that happen for us. And then your second part of your question was around U.S. unit growth. We're certainly assessing what the back end of the crisis opportunity might be Ultimately, as I talk about all the time, the unit growth is going to be driven by the cash-on-cash returns at the unit level and how our franchisees view the economics.
1:15:22 I can tell you that for our corporate store business, I would love to accelerate and go even faster. And if there are opportunities to do that, we are most certainly going to. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you. And our next question comes from John Isenco of Jamie Morgan. Your line has been opened.
1:15:43 Hi, Greg. Can you hear me? We can, John. All right. Excellent. Thank you for that. Okay. First, a clarification and then a follow-up on the theme we've been talking about. First, you mentioned increased transaction size a number of different times. I mean, can you comment on same-store transactions and delivery, same-store transactions and carryout? I mean, it does sound like we got some outsized ticket gain. Just wanted to see what was happening in terms of transaction count.
1:16:09 Thank you very much. Well, now an order is kind of more than an order because people are looking to put some stuff in their Ziploc bag. So, again, it's early. We're giving you as much as we can, trying to be as transparent as we can. But it's larger orders is what we're seeing so far, and we're happy to get that to you in a safe, contactless way.
1:16:57 Yeah, definitely, and it would make sense to amortize some delivery fees as well. So that would make sense from many different perspectives. Secondly, we have an economic situation that many of us would have never anticipated where a number of people will make more money on unemployment for four months being at home than they would actually working in a lot of different cases. I wanted to ask this from two perspectives. One, if you are seeing a pickup from a consumer perspective and maybe the type of consumer that would be, Hey, John, it's Rich. On the first part of the question,
1:17:57 Really too early and would be hard to tell. I suspect that the stimulus that was just released out there is probably having more impact than the unemployment benefits thus far that you just described in terms of money going into consumers' pockets, which they could choose to spend with us or with others. And then The second part of your question around does it make it harder to hire folks, we tried to lean into that a bit. As we mentioned a couple of times earlier, for 10 weeks in our corporate stores and in our supply chain business, we've got bonuses for our hourly team members and also for our store managers as well.
1:18:50 We've done that first and foremost to say thank you to them for continuing to serve our customers in what is a relatively crazy time. But also we recognize that we've got to continue to earn their loyalty to work for us as there are other alternatives potentially out there as you described. So haven't seen... Any pullback there? And as I mentioned earlier, we've actually seen a very significant increase in applicant flow because even with those near-term unemployment benefits, I think a lot of folks are looking beyond that and into August and September and the months beyond the expiration of those benefits.
1:19:35 And I think I want to make sure that they've got a job when they get to that point in time.
1:19:41 It definitely makes sense. Rich, maybe it was a couple quarters ago, maybe the second quarter of 2019, we talked about delivery service times and just overall delivery metrics. I think you touched on it a number of different times this call, but on an apples-to-apples basis, where are we in terms of delivery metrics at this point, time to household order accuracy, things that are not necessarily health and safety related, but just the old-fashioned core of the way you guys used to measure yourself.
1:20:12 Thank you so much for joining us. Thank you for joining us. We'll be right back. and we and a lot of our franchisees are still working really hard to figure out those new patterns and make sure we've got delivery driver schedules balanced appropriately against them.
1:21:13 What I can tell you is the system is very focused on service. We're making some improvements there and we are bringing safety to the forefront does not mean that we're not also focused on those service times because we do know that's going to be a critical way that we'll continue to grow our business and compete against the aggregators. Thank you. And our next question comes from Jeffrey Bernstein of Barclays. Your line is now open.
1:21:44 Great. Thank you very much. Rich, you talked about your prepared remarks, the independence and the existential crisis the industry is facing today. and obviously in the impact of the future. So it seems like you would have good insights into more of the independent side of things as each of your franchisees in many ways is more of a mom and pop. But your comps are clearly solidly positive. So I'm just wondering how you think about the independents' survival with comps down significantly, whether it's within Pizza or just thinking more broadly as a restaurant CEO, the ability for them to keep their doors open for an extended period and kind of survival. I'll stay fairly brief on that. Restaurant business is a tough business. There are a lot of restaurants out there that were
1:22:46 Thank you for joining us. Certainly, as someone who's been in the restaurant industry for a long time and someone who loves to eat out, I sure hope independents survive because I think all of us want to be able to go to an independent restaurant.
1:23:33 We want to be able to go to a Domino's Pizza. We want to be able to go to an independent restaurant as well. Thank you. And our next question comes from Andrew Charles of Powell, and your line is now open.
1:23:47 Great, thanks. Most of my questions have been asked, but, Rich, I totally understand the fluidity of upcoming development that leads you to suspend the two- to three-year outlook. But just to be clear, is the target for 25,000 global locations by 2025 still on the table, just given your continued optimism around the long term and the potential for the unit development to be made up kind of past the next two to three years?
1:24:09 Andrew, thank you for asking that question. Absolutely, I still have great optimism around our 25,000 store target. The brand came into this crisis in a very healthy place with strong growth momentum. We're going to work our way through this, but I still have a ton of optimism about the long-term health and growth of Dominus Pizza. Thank you. And ladies and gentlemen, this does conclude our question and answer session. I would now like to turn the call back over to Rich Allison for any closing remarks.
1:24:47 Thank you. And listen, thanks everyone for joining us on the call this morning. You know, it's an incredibly dynamic time, you know, in our business and across the industry. But, you know, if I could leave you with one thing this morning, it is that, you know, I and our management team and our franchisees at Domino's Pizza have a great deal of optimism around the future of our brand. One of the things that I've had a front row seat to for the last six weeks or so is the incredible resiliency, the incredible innovative spirit, the hustle, the passion of our Domino's Pizza franchisees and team members around the world. So while a difficult time for all of us, I sit here today never more optimistic about this great brand.
1:25:40 So again, I appreciate you being with us. And Jeff and I look forward to speaking with you in July as we will then discuss our second quarter of 2020 results. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.
Follow Domino's Pizza Inc into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Executive Officer
Analyst at Oppenheimer & Co.
Analyst at Guggenheim
Analyst at C4
Analyst at Bernstein
Analyst at Jefferies
Analyst at BTIG
Analyst at Credit Twist
Analyst at Longbow Research
Analyst at Bank of America
Analyst at Bayard
Analyst at Stevens & Company
Analyst at Morgan Stanley
Analyst at RBC Capital Markets
Analyst at J.P. Morgan
Analyst at Barclays
Analyst at Powell