Hamish Mair
Fund Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC
Replay available
Q3 2024 update. hosted by CT Private Equity Trust (LSE:CTPE) on Investor Meet Company, held 2024-11-28.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/ct-private-equity-trust-plc-ctpe-q3-2024-update
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:01 Good morning or good afternoon as it now is. Everybody, thank you for joining our, presentation on CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST. This is a presentation of the third quarter results, so the three months to the end of September this year, and we will touch on progress in the year to date in the first nine months of the year. So a couple of quick things to mention before I get into the presentation. We have had basically a quiet couple of years in private equity in terms of growth. That followed two very strong years prior to that. We... So far this year, we're basically about flat in terms of NAV.
0:48 We were slightly down in this quarter. Most of that was due to adverse currency movements. We were actually up in underlying terms. And, you know, that is the first three quarters worth. Bear in mind that the third quarter numbers basically are largely based upon June valuations because we have very few September valuations when we compile the number and we still haven't got very many. So the final quarter, which will give the full year outcome, that will be released at the end of March. Next year, we'll essentially have two quarters worth of valuation movements in that in that number. So that's that's worth bearing in mind. But I think we can get, a good sense of how things are going, so far this year.
1:45 I'm just gonna take you through the slides. The presentation should probably take a little bit more than half an hour. It go through fairly quickly to give, maximum time for, questions, afterwards.
2:02 Just to recap, those of you who not familiar with the company, it is a private equity fund of funds with nearly half the portfolio invested directly into private companies through co investments. We focus on the lower mid market buyout sector in Europe with most of the portfolio invested in Continental Europe and in The UK. And we have a small amount in North America. We, as I mentioned, have a significant component in co investments. The target is to get to 50%. We're slightly below that at present. And we like to to back emerging managers. So these are up and coming private equity groups. We think that the alignment of interest between us as investors and they as managers and also with the underlying management is very close in that tier of the market, and that has worked out well for us. The company has been going for over twenty five years.
2:59 We have a very strong track record at or close to the top of our peer group, and I've been involved managing the portfolio throughout that entire period. So just looking at the numbers that we've just announced this morning for the third quarter, as the NAV total return down 1% gives a year to date number of down 0.2, so essentially flat to all intents and purposes. On a twelve month basis, we're actually slightly up 1.7%. Now in the quarter, we had an adverse impact from exchange rate. Essentially, the pound has been strong against both the euro and the dollar, and we have, you know, about 60% of the portfolio is either in euro, shadow euro, or dollar denominated investments. So when the pound is strong, that tends to detract from the sterling NAV.
4:05 And during the third quarter, there was a negative impact of about 1.5%, and there was a negative impact in the first half of about 1%. So you've basically had about a negative two and a half percent impact on the NAV just through currency in the year to date. So if we didn't have that, we would be would be up. And, you know, that that has already reversed slightly in the current quarter, but we're... It remains to be seen where we get to by the end of the year. As I mentioned a minute ago, the third quarter number is largely based on June marks rather than September ones. About 8% would have been September, so the vast majority still based on June.
4:55 And we will, therefore, when we come to the full year, we'll have essentially two quarters worth in one quarter, which is why the final quarter and the the full year evaluation tends to, you know, quite often, there's quite a large movement. I mean, obviously, it depends on what's going on in the underlying portfolio, but it can be quite a big movement. So that's worth bearing in mind. Couple of points to emphasize in these numbers. We had realizations in the third quarter of £42,200,000, which is quite strong. New investments of only 9 0.3, so that's, you know, smaller than usual. The realizations in the year to date are running at £94,500,000, which is up about 75 percent on the equivalent period last year.
5:45 And so, you know, we would expect this year to finish with a very strong outcome in terms of realizations. Now that is a a basically a good thing because there is a there is a reasonable correlation, a good correlation as you'd expect between realizations and NAV growth because exits are generally at a significant premium to the immediate carrying value. So although it doesn't always... The the periods are always coincide precisely if you have strong realizations, you're likely to get strong returns. The dividend is maintained at 7.01. Just to remind remind you, the dividend is paid out in four quarterly payments.
6:31 Each of those is 1% of the average of the previous four quarters NAV. If that number comes up to be a number below the previous dividend, we just maintain the previous dividend. And with this kind of flattish period we've had, that is exactly what we're doing. We're maintaining the previous dividend 7.01p, which means that the, you know, the twelve month dividend is just over 28p, which gives a yield on the current share price comfortably over 6%. So just moving on to some of the events of the quarter and of the year to date. We've made one new commitment, to a new private equity fund, in the quarter. That's inflection enterprise fund six.
7:19 Those of you who follow the company will know that we have a a number of investments with inflection, both funds and co investments. We've been backing them for over twenty years. They are the sort of doyen, if you like, of the mid market in private equity in The UK and increasingly in Europe. Very successful firm, very strong returns, and we will continue backing them as long as they continue to deliver great returns. They've got about... They've got three sub franchises if you like. So there's the main buyout fund business, and they will make investments up to about 400,000,000 in in the... In those companies. So, you know, proper mid sized companies.
8:04 They've also got a partnership capital fund where they will invest in minority positions. I mean, they don't... They will still have a high degree of control, but they typically have less than 50% of the equity. And that franchise has worked well for them. And then they have the enterprise funds. So the enterprise funds are looking at companies where the the enterprise value of the companies is between 50 and 150,000,000, which is very close to our own sweet spot for our entire portfolio. And it's also where inflection started out from, and they've got a very strong record there. So very pleased to be backing them again. Just recapping on the major exits that we've had in the year to date. Some of these I've mentioned in prior quarters, so I'll just re, you know, restate it briefly. So Jollies, which is a pet shop chain, it's a large format pet retailer. It's the second largest behind pets at home.
9:04 This is a deal that we invested in alongside Kester Capital in 2018. It has grown very nicely over that period. It had various things to cope with. I mean, it had COVID, but that turned out to be a good thing for pet shops because they were allowed to stay open all the way through COVID. They've modernized this business where they bought it. When they bought it, it was a previous family business run by was run by its finance director who bought the business. And there were a lot of professionalization measures that Kester were able to implement, you know, centralized buying, which amazingly hadn't happened before, plus a new third party distribution system and various other improvements to the state of stores. And in fact, they increased the number of stores from 60 to a 100 of the the holding period.
10:04 And the business is growing very nicely over that period, and we made over four times cost and a 27 IRR when it was sold, and we got the money in April this year. So, you know, in some ways, a bit of a a traditional company, you know, chain of stores, but growing very well, modernized very nicely. It was bought by TDR Capital, by the way, who own a significant stake in ASD. So they'll probably do something with ASD. Second exit here is Cortrax. This is a deal led by Buckthorn, who are energy specialists. Cortrax is an Aberdeen based business that is in the oil services sector.
10:51 Specifically, it's wellbore cleanup plug and abandonment technology. What does that mean? It's basically a technical piece of equipment that goes on top of the wells. It caps off the wells, controls pressure, that kind of thing. There's an element of counter cyclicality here because as oil wells are decommissioned, particularly the North Sea, you do actually need their technology to do that safely, But you also need it when you are doing new exploration. And they, during the holding period, acquired an American business called Mohawk, which allowed them to expand significantly into the American, you know, Permian Basin, the major oil presence there... Oil province there.
11:38 This was acquired through the sale. It was sold to Xpro, which is a, listed, New York listed, oil services company. It used to be a British company. We actually backed this many years ago through Candover, but it's now a much, much bigger business. And they bought it, and most of the consideration was in shares. Those shares have now been sold down. The final return, 1.7 times cost and an IRR of 11%, which is a bit suboptimal for us, but it's not a bad return considering the volatility in that sector over the holding period with quite big fluctuations in in the oil price. So we'd regard this as a reasonable outcome. Third major exit was ATEC. ATEC is an insurance company. It's a it's a broker, but it also has its own managing general agent.
12:35 So they they place underwriting with a panel of insurers. They specialize in a niche of the market, which is caravans, small boats, beach huts. And that's a very sticky business because once somebody has got the the insurance insurance for their boat or their caravan, they tend not to sort of shop around in the way they might do with, you know, car insurance. This business has been, again, very professionalized under Kester Capital, You know, the various portals, the route to market, the digitalization of it has all taken place, it's grown very nicely. The gross written premiums have gone from under 25,000,000 to 75,000,000 during the whole period, which is seven years.
13:26 And its profitability has essentially gone up fourfold during the holding period. It's now been sold to Powerwind. We've got the money in September. Not allowed to tell you exactly how much we got, although you could probably work it out by looking at our r n s statement, but it's, comfortable for four times cost. So that's a great great outcome. This is the chart just showing you the long term progression of our NAV and the cumulative dividends, you know, which has been pretty good. Obviously, it's been, relatively quiet in the last year or so, but the long term trend, which we think will be resumed fairly soon, is is very positive. And this is the share price and NAV over the entire company's existence. We've been going for twenty five years. We had our twenty fifth anniversary earlier in the year complete with a sort of party at the stock exchange where we got to press the closing bell or buzzer. It's a buzzer, actually, which is which is good fun.
14:36 Important point is if you look at the returns here compared to the stock market, that's the all share index, which is the gray dotted line. You know, it's miles in excess of what you would achieve in the stock market over that twenty five year period. The gains that you would have made had you bought our shares and held them, are over four times what you would have made if you just invested in the all share index. And therein, lies the the argument behind investing in private equity and staying in private equity. There's still gap between the share price and the NAV total return. Now that gap is wider than it usually is, and I would suggest that's a good opportunity for those of you looking to add to your holdings, you know, because that gap will narrow.
15:30 Looking at five year fund performance of various statistics here, which shows you that, as I said earlier, you've had some pretty punchy, years in '22 and '21, much quieter in the last couple of years. But, hopefully, that will change once we get through this phase of adjustment that's taken place in, the private equity world. Private equity world is still growing, by the way, and we're still making positive returns. We we we have not gone x growth far from it. This is the outstanding undrawn commitments. Now we need to make these to make sure that we can maintain a fully invested portfolio, but the commitment level is very comfortable. It's bang on the five year average at 39% of of NAV, so nothing out out of the ordinary here.
16:25 And debt has come down a bit. We had about 90,000,000 of debt last quarter, but it's now gone down to 70,000,000. We think we're in a very sort of comfortable zone. It's about 12.6% geared at the moment. Typically, we're sitting between about 1020%. If it's up towards 20, that's on the high side and it tends to be temporary and we bring it down. If it's below 10, it's a bit low and therefore not, gonna make much of a contri... Contribution to returns. So current, range is is fine. We've got more than half our revolving credit facility available, to use. You need to keep a bit of headroom in it, obviously, but we've got plenty of of scope there.
17:15 I mean, the... Just going back to that. I mean, the the long term argument is that the returns that we expect to make by investing in private equity are going to be far in excess of the cost of debt even with debt at a higher price than it has been for a while.
17:33 This is the... Just the investments in 2024 to date. I'm not going to go through all of these individually, but they are, you know, diverse by geography and sector and lead manager. We're always renewing the portfolio. These are some of the recent co investments which I will just touch on. Some of you have heard of a few of these before, so I won't labor the details. Cyclomedia is... It's a Dutch based company that essentially maps areas using a a lidar technology, and the maps are used by generally local authorities for the purposes of local taxation.
18:20 So business rates, that kind of thing. Started in Holland, moved into Germany, moved into The US. And, you know, it is essentially a unique proposition, and it's growing nicely. The deal is led by Volpe, whom we've invested with for many years, and it's got off to a good start. We've been in it for over a year, and it's it's nicely up already. This one is, UTMACO, which is led by the German house SGT Capital. This is provides security tokens and cybersecurity services. So this is a strongly growing market, as you can imagine, growing at double digits. And they already have a five to 10% global market share, which is growing.
19:10 So that's one of the devices that they're on the on the side, and this has also got off to a good start. This is another, you know, quite a technology theme here, actually, but this is... That's, you know, the world we live in. I mean, technology is omnipresent. This is, BrainCube. This is a software company. It provides software for manufacturing processes. So had... Already has a blue chip list of clients. It's a French company. It... What... The the software essentially improves the manufacturing process. It makes things, you know, faster, less waste, less waste, less energy usage, that kind of thing. The deal is led by Scottish Equity Partners, the Growth Equity Investors. We know them very well, obviously, because they're based in Glasgow, and, I've been backing them since 1996.
20:07 So we've got a very good idea of their capabilities and, really confident that this will work well for them. And then, Educare EdTech, which is, led by the Spanish group, Orica Capital. This is an online, training company, essentially. It provides professional qualifications, master's degrees online, largely to the Spanish speaking world. It's obviously started in Spain, but a lot of its customers are in Latin America. This was bought quite a low price for this type of company. We got in at below seven times EV to EBITDA, which is sort of unheard of for this type of business, but mainly because Oracle had a good, you know, local angle on it.
20:59 And so that's also doing well. Then we've got, accounts IQ. This is accounting software for smaller and medium sized companies. It's a bit like Sage, but much smaller and probably more sophisticated. And this deal was brought to us by Acxiom. So Acxiom are an emerging manager that we've been backing for the last couple of years. Their their team come from inflection and from HG Capital, one or two other places, and they specialize in software and technology enabled businesses. And this one is the first deal we've done with them. So plenty of opportunities for for new deals. We see a very good flow of co investments.
21:55 This is the... This is actually the realizations in the year to date. You can see the the multiples in the IRRs and the sectors are very diverse sectors, different countries, different lead houses. Quite a strong technology oriented theme. We don't apologize for that. This is where people invest in private equity these days. These are mature businesses that are all, you know, profitable, good revenue growth, profits growth. This is not sort of, you know, loss making venture capital funded solely by their equity. These are these are real businesses. And therefore, people want to buy them, and therefore, we make we make good returns. And there's a few more of them on this page.
22:44 We're obviously rejuvenating the portfolio all the time. Lots of new companies going in to the portfolio. Again, these often have a sort of information technology or healthcare angle, but not all of them. I mean, you know, we've got restaurants, chains, and other things connected to the consumer and industrial sectors. But there's there's a lot of software
23:09 and and health care because collectively, these two sectors account for about half the portfolio and has been a a good driver of growth and gains for us. This is the long term pattern of distributions and drawdowns. You can see we we actually have a lot more distributions and drawdowns this quarter, which, you know, is basically a good thing. But you can see how that fits into the long term pattern. The co investment element, we can control directly. We didn't actually do any co investments in the last quarter, so that did help in terms of the balance sheet. On the largest underlying holdings, a couple of things to watch out for Sigma, which is an US based electronic components company with that. We expect this... That to get out of that this in 2025, actually.
24:03 So that is, has been in the portfolio for a while, but, it's going reasonably well. New entrant at number two is OHI. This is a helicopter company in Brazil. We we have this through Sterling Square. We've been in it for quite a long time. It's quite a large company, which is reasonably successful. They've been trying to sell it for ages. And it's proving hard to sell, not because there's something wrong with the business, but just because buying helicopter companies that service the oil industry is not everybody's cup of tea at the moment. And the alternative of doing a listing in Brazil, as you can imagine, is quite difficult thing to achieve, and it does need the right market conditions, which they aren't... Which aren't present at the moment.
24:52 Number three is Weirdfish, our clothing company.
24:57 Some of you may have been at our Capital Markets Day in October where we had David Butler, who's the new chief executive presenting on this one. So this business is growing quite nicely. We may be able to exit this next year. I'm not sure, but that's a possibility, which should be good. TWMA, this processes,
25:19 drill cuttings from oil rigs. This suffered a bit during during COVID. It was difficult to mobilize their equipment and get get it out to the various different provinces. So it's it's still at one times cost, but I think Buckthorn are trying hard to sell that at a premium hopefully, next year. The fifth one is San Siro or Hofi, which is our funeral homes business in Italy, which we are largely out of. We sold three quarters of it. We've held on to a quarter. So this this, you know, quarter is still worth 10,000,000. I mean, we've made, you know, eight times our money already on the original deal. So that's going that's going pretty well. Aurora Payments is American payments company led by Corsair, which is still quite early in the holding period. We've still got a bit of work to do there, but it's it's going okay.
26:17 UTMACO and Cyclomedia, I've mentioned to you. Ninth is CyberHawk, which is our Livingston based drone company, which has been doing really well, building out its its client base mainly in the energy sector. And we're optimistic that that will be able to be exited in 2025. And then we have Breeze, which is the... Essentially makes a sophisticated fume cabinet. That's still in a buildup phase. Still quite early in the holding period. So lots of interesting things there. The top 10 holdings only account for about 20% of the portfolio. So lots of other things well below these, which have got great prospects as well.
27:05 In terms of the, geographic and vintage year split, this hasn't changed significantly. 42% in The UK. This is a far higher exposure to The UK than any of our peers. Most of them hardly got anything in The UK. I'm I'm talking about the fund of fund peers, and we still think there's a lot to go for in The UK. It's a good thing. Hopefully, Rachel Rachel Reeve is listening to this and noting it that there are people that already do put a lot of their money into the home market, and we're one of them. Most of the rest is in Continental Europe, although we have a significant 17% position in in The States because we've got some excellent relationships and investments there.
27:55 In terms of vintage year, we have a, you know, steadily maturing portfolio. More than half the portfolio is over four years old, 60% over three years old. The usual investment thesis is around a four year hold. Normally, in in actual fact, it turns out to be a wee bit longer than that. But after three or four years, you are preparing a company for sale. So the proportion that's over three or four years old is a proxy for your stock of future realizations, and we've got plenty coming down the track. In terms of the,
28:34 valuation, it's on an enterprise value to EBITDA basis 11 times. Again, this is quite a lot lower than our peer peer group, many of them are much, much higher than that. And the entry enterprise value to EBITDA of the current portfolio is about 8.7 times, which is in line with our long term average. And it is actually a really good... If you can buy a business, a good quality growing mid market buyout in Europe now at 8.7 times, you're doing pretty well.
29:06 Not very, heavily indebted, just over three times debt to EBITDA. So underneath all these holdings, you don't have lots of precarious gearing. I mean, you do have some gearing because they're managed from buyouts, but it's not particularly high. So the, you know, the capital structures are not risky. This is the sectoral split. As I mentioned earlier, nearly half the portfolio is in health care and information technology, but we have got significant amount in consumer discretionary industrials business services as you'd expect. The portfolio is deliberately well diversified because private equity is naturally risky, and the only reliable way of reducing that inherently high risk down to moderate levels is through building and holding a well diversified portfolio, and that's exactly what we have here.
30:03 So to conclude, the portfolio is broadly based. It's very resilient. Nearly half the portfolio was in these long term growth sectors of information technology and health care. We're seeing excellent deal flow, and then most of it's at good prices. Pricing has moderated a bit recently. You tend to get this when you have a quiet phase. And if you're having a quiet phase, which we did have until about, you know, out of this year, it means that buyers and sellers are not coming together because prices haven't adjusted. Pricing is now adjusting, and hence, we're seeing big increase in realizations. We're up, you know,
30:48 by three quarters on last year, and that we'd expect to continue into the final quarter. We've got plenty of borrowing facilities in in place, which allows us to to take opportunities whether they're... Whether or not they're funded by realizations, more capacity. We've got better covenants.
31:11 So we're in a good position to continue to build the foundations for future growth. And, you know, with this big uplift in exits, very healthy, and there's a good uplift on on exit over the the previous carrying value. It's 22% on a weighted average basis year to date in 2024. It's a little bit below the premium last year, but I think that will build as we go further into the year. Lots of people want to invest in private equity. It's an excellent long term asset class. It's got a very strong record of delivering returns and indeed our company has as well. And as we come to the end of 2024, look into 2025, you know, we are very confident we'll continue to grow value for shareholders in the short and medium term and longer term as well.
32:07 So that's the end of the formal presentation. I think we're about thirty five minutes in, so we've got a bit of time for questions. Yes. Hamish, thank you. It's Peter Brown here from the Investment Trust sales team. We've got a few questions coming. We'll try and run through them as quick as we can, but obviously give some good, thorough answers as well. The first one was a pre submitted question regarding the discount. You did mention it and the fact that it's a very good opportunity to buy assets at a depressed share price.
32:42 But there's a little bit of disappointment from from shareholders that the share price hasn't moved up in line with NAB. What are we doing about the discount, and and can we get that tighter in the in the near future? Yeah. Well, people are saying what about... I mean, I actually can't magically magically
33:00 eliminate the discount just by by thinking about it. We basically need to encourage new buyers of the shares and pointing out the conspicuous value that there is there at the moment is one of the things that we're doing. We're upping our marketing, our PR. I mean, target market, wealth managers, and other forms of retail investor. But we also appeal to institutions as well. The discount should narrow as NAV growth picks up again. We've done some buybacks. We've been quite active buying back earlier in the year when the discount was about this level. We're not going to use tons of the company's capital to do buybacks because that would have an impact on the balance sheet, but we will where we think it's going to be helpful to the share price. For example, if there's a big loose line of stock coming out, we will have used our buyback powers to do that. It also... It gives a nice enhancement to NAV, but the amounts of money involved are quite small. So, basically, encouraging new buyers for the shares is the most constructive thing we can do. You know, I don't believe there are, you know, clever discount
34:24 protection mechanisms that work over the long term. It's very much my ambition to make sure this company is much better rated. We we have been at a premium in the past, not not often, but a couple of times in the company's life. And I... My sort of sincere ambition is to get us up there again so that we can actually issue stock. And once you get into a position where you're at a premium, you can issue stock. You can tend to...
34:52 You know, the other side of it is you can tend to buy back quite regularly and maintain that premium rating. None of my peers are on a premium rating. I mean, most of them are on at least the same type of discount that that we're on. Typically, we've had a narrower discount than the peers because our dividend is is much better and probably more reliable than theirs. And so, you know, I think we're we're slightly anomalously cheap at the moment. Well, we're significantly cheap, but we're anomalously cheap compared to some of the others. Yeah. Thanks. I agree. I think that the sector itself is on quite a big discount, and it's difficult to stand out from the crowd. But going back to the NAV, we've got a shareholder here that's happy with the steady dividend but keen to see improvements in NAV growth and new investments.
35:38 Obviously, you mentioned about the last twelve, eighteen months being a fairly stable but unremarkable period for that. What steps are planned to boost the capital growth and NAV performance? Yeah. As realizations pick up, and we've seen them begin to pick up quite stronger this year, that will drive NAV growth. I mean, doesn't necessarily happen immediately, but it will it will drive it. Underlying profitability of the companies ultimately comes through. And we don't have the numbers for the first nine months of the year, but from the presentations I've been at, underlying profitable... Profitability growth is good. I mean, it is, you know, it is very robust. It has been all the way through. So ultimately, that will exert itself and you'll see NEV growth and and therefore, you know, share price growth will come through.
36:31 We're always laying foundations for growth. So at any given point in time, you've got quite a bit of new investment in the portfolio. Now that takes time to deliver, you know, growth in any fee, but it does come through. And if you look at our long term record, you can see that it has come through very steadily over the twenty five years. So, you know, be patient and, you know, we will deliver. And staying on an NAV theme, a question comes in. What explains the discrepancy between EBITDA growth and NAV growth? Shouldn't the NAV grow in line with EBITDA growth? Well, it would it would if the if the valuation multiple was completely stable all the time. You know, it has been under a bit of pressure in the last couple of years.
37:19 So that's one of the reasons where you may get a bit of a a discrepancy. But, you know, over... Yeah. Over the long term, you will get NAV growth, is, you know, is closely correlated with EBITDA growth. It won't be exactly the same, but it'll be closely correlated.
37:41 And our companies are delivering good EBITDA growth. So this is why I'm confident about the the medium term. We can't go very far without talking about UK budget, unfortunately, possibly. But do you believe the government's decision to increase employer national contribution... National insurance contributions from April 2025 will impact the value of much of UK part of the portfolio? I don't think it will impact much of The UK portfolio. There are individual companies where it's it's more significant, particularly those that employ a lot of people. So we have got quite a few companies that are in the sort of the care sector.
38:24 Sensitivity to wages and inflation, etcetera, is one of the things that we consider when we go into these businesses. I mean, what will happen is that they've they've all had their costs go up quite significantly. And so they will have to pass that on in increased prices or or fees that they charge, which may end up being inflationary for the economy. But, you know, that will be their their natural reaction. And to the extent that the end customer is the the state, which is in some of these companies, you know, the the the government's just making a rod for its own back. I mean, it's pushing up costs, they're pushing up minimum wages. And, you know, those wages are then...
39:13 You know, a lot of them are having to be paid by the public sector. So it's a bit of a circular trip. Many of our companies have got very substantial margins, particularly in the software area, and they don't have much in the way of employees. So without sounding like I'm saying I'm alright, Jack, I mean, it is not... It... It's not a it's not a good thing, this, but it's not a disaster far from it. We've got a well diversified portfolio.
39:42 I mean, it's not... I mean, as anybody who's been, you know, following current affairs for the last few weeks will know that there's been a big backlash from industry over this because they weren't anticipating it.
39:54 And it's quite a blunt instrument. It's... It it adds to the cost of every organization that employs people. It's not a it's not a tax on profits because this is just adding to costs, which is which is actually, all things being equal, reducing profits. So, obviously, if I'd been the chancellor of the exchequer, I would have found other ways of raising the money, but, fortunately, I'm not. You've got enough in your plate with your day job, I think. Could you give some market commentary, please? Where do you think the best opportunities are at the moment? Is it primary, secondary, or co investments? Well, I mean, there are opportunities right the way across that. We tend to find that the secondary market, which we are quite active in because we have two separate secondaries fund, is quite cyclical.
40:45 You know, the the price that you can achieve does fluctuate a bit.
40:52 I think it's improving in secondaries. Actually, I've seen some quite interesting pricing being offered. Co investments, we see a steady stream of opportunities as we do in primaries. We're in a a stage in the cycle where we've come out or we are coming out of a kind of... It wasn't really a recession, but it was a kind of weak period. Okay. The the last quarter's GDP growth in The UK wasn't brilliant. But before that, it was quite obvious we were having a recovery. And when you invest in the wake of a
41:31 week period, you tend to you tend to buy quite well, and that opportunity will persist for a bit. And then, you know, those businesses grow into a sort of strengthening economic background. And so I think now over the next year or eighteen months will be a really good time to be making new investments.
41:54 Lovely. There's a question about the Capital Markets Day that you mentioned. Is there a recording available? If you missed it, I think I could probably ask you on the web... It's on the website. Exactly. There are certain snippets on the website. So certainly go to the CT PRIVATE in Columbia three imaging's website, and there'll be quite a few videos there. There won't be the the full session because it's about two and a half hours long, but there's certainly material can... They've been put on the website for you.
42:21 Yeah. I would... I'd encourage you to look at that because apart from me rabbiting on, you get to hear from the management of some of the underlying companies, and you also get to hear from a number of the other members of my team. You mentioned private equity as a sector invests more and more in technology. Is that a function of the available opportunities, or is that a risk of herd mentality? Oh, good question. I don't think it's herd mentality. I think it's just because technology is becoming, you know, perennial and pervasive across the, you know, the economy in the modern world. We saw a lot of, you know, acceleration of the digitalization of society during COVID for obvious reasons.
43:10 We also saw, the importance of good health, and health care was highlighted during that period as well. So that probably gave a bit of an impetus, but it was really an impetus to something that was already going on because private equity likes to invest in sectors that offer, you know, secular growth, you know, where there's a trend that lasts more than a few years, and you can see you can see it going forward because,
43:38 even if you can't predict it really accurately within a year or two, if you're over a five or ten year period, some of these trends are very clear. So provided you don't overpay badly, you'll probably do quite well. So... And also, I think private equity has become more clued up in terms of the technologies. The expertise across the sector is quite a lot deeper. I mean, in the old days, the classic private equity guy saw himself as a bit of a natural deal doer. You know, they just thought they were naturally geniuses at negotiating deals. Now that, you know, it's only one part of the the skills that you require. Actually, knowing and understanding technologies and the dynamics of technology oriented companies is, in my view, you know, just as important as being able to decide whether something is cheap or not.
44:42 And, you know, a lot of these companies that we go into... I mean, some of them are so complicated that you really have to spend a lot of time trying to work out what they actually do. And I have a simple rule, which is if I don't understand how they make money or my team can't understand it and explain it to me, then we won't invest in it. Unfortunately, I've got some quite clever people in the team, so they're generally able to do that and to articulate the opportunities. So I think we'll see more. And not necessarily a bigger percentage, but we will see a, you know, many more technology oriented businesses coming into the portfolio over the years. Okay. Just a couple of questions on dividends. Obviously, we're we're proud of the dividend, and it's a big part of why someone should own this trust. I'll merge two questions together.
45:32 If realization... Realizations dried up, would you use gearing to fund dividends? And the second question is, can the current dividends be maintained over the next three to five years? Yes. The dividends can be maintained. The dividend is set at a level that we are very confident we can we can pay under just about any foreseeable circumstances. So it costs us £20,000,000 a year. The portfolio is over 500,000,000 in gross terms. So, you know, it's gonna generate a lot more than £20,000,000 a year and, you know, a bit more to cover our expenses. So we've set it at 4% because we believe that's a level that we can maintain, you know, come hell or high water, really.
46:24 So the situation you're asking about, you know, if we if we had, you know, less than 10... Less 20,000,000 of realizations, would we use
46:34 gearing to pay the dividend? Well, the answer is probably yes, but I think it's a very unlikely situation for us to to be in. If we are in that situation, that would mean that we have probably mismanaged the company and we don't intend to to start doing that now. What was the other bit of the question, Peter?
46:58 Well, I think you've answered it. Would you use would you use gearing and is Yeah. It's it's definitely sustainable. It's been set at a sustainable level. When we put that dividend policy in back in 2012, we, you know, we looked at different ways of allowing our shareholders to benefit from the realizations that we would we would always have coming through. We could have done tender offers. We could have done, you know, irregular special dividends. We could have said we'll distribute a set proportion of realizations. The problem with those things, apart from being quite complicated, they were quite difficult to make... It's quite difficult to make sure that all shareholders benefited from them. And also, the amount that we were going to distribute would be very difficult to predict.
47:50 Even I would find it difficult to predict one quarter to the next what the exact realization total would be. But with our current dividend policy, at any given point in time, you're only missing one piece of information, which is the final quarter's NAV. And even if you don't know that, you know for sure that the dividend will be at least the the level it was in the previous quarter. So it's highly predictable. And and, basically, you know, our investors like that. They can predict. They know that they're gonna get their their quarterly check and and, they know the minimum size of that check.
48:33 Two questions that I'm gonna merge together, but bizarrely, they sort of counteract each other. One is, equity markets has been very strong... Have been very strong this year. Why have private equity funds struggled to grow NAVs in this environment? And the second part is, what explains the long term outperformance of private equity in your opinion? Is it likely to continue well into the next step? Well, the long term performance of private equity is because it's a... You know, it's got a very strong alignment between investors and management. And when you've got that alignment of interest, it tends to to work, you know. So the the the management of the companies, you know, who know about running these companies, they they benefit when when there's growth.
49:24 The private equity managers benefit. The underlying investors, us, and you also benefit.
49:32 They they do their research upfront. You know, it's a very research intensive. They're operating in a market where the information they're gathering is not public, so they have a natural advantage over anyone else. And, you know, the the the trick in private equity is to find out information that other people... Well, it's to find information other people don't have and then to, you know, draw conclusions from that information that other people haven't yet drawn.
50:02 And then to do that consistently. And you provide capital to management buyouts. So, you know, quite often, the the, you know, the key determinant of whose capital they receive is the management team of the underlying company. And they've got a very strong eye on not just the price of that capital, but also, you know, what comes with that capital, the expertise that comes with it. Because, you know, if you are inflection, you know, you've done dozens of deals, and the management of those companies have all made good money personally, a management team will will see that and they will think, you know, I should have the money from inflection because they'll bring expertise that will allow me to grow this business rapidly, and I'll make a good capital gain for myself.
50:54 And so they will not necessarily source the cheapest capital. The cheapest capital might come from some faceless bank who've got no expertise. And so if they need help growing the business, they won't be able to give them any help. They'll just be asking them for, you know, the interest payments. So so private equity is capital that comes with expertise. And if you are good at private equity, you will be able to win deals where you are not offering the cheapest capital. In other words, you'll be you'll be getting in at a good price. And if you do this often enough, you have a sustainable advantage over other people, which is why there's persistence of performance in private equity, which is very rare in other asset classes.
51:48 So you've got inefficiency, expertise that goes alongside the capital. Very few companies as a proportion of all companies actually receive receive private equity. So there's a massive sort of sifting exercise. There's a cherry picking exercise that goes on. And that's why private equity outperforms, and and it will continue to outperform. And our company is one of the ways that you can get that exposure immediately and simply just by buying shares. Oh, shit. I'm getting close to the hour now, so I think we'll make this the final question, but it's quite an interesting one, I think. 10% of the portfolio value is 2016 vintage or older. Can you speak a little about the kinds of investments in this bracket and why exits haven't been made to take this? Yep.
52:35 So funny enough, not every investment that we invest in works out a 100% according to plan. So sometimes, they're... They have to have a second or third plan. And that sort of older part of the of the portfolio, that's normally what that is. It's normally where the original plan, which should be based around a a four or five year hold, has not been implemented for whatever reason. It doesn't necessarily mean the company has been a complete failure. It may just mean that things have taken longer than expected.
53:14 And so, you know, they can have... They they they regroup, they replan. Where there is actually value in the... In in our valuation, it means that these are these are live businesses and whether it's, you know, good good prospects. Now we did an analysis. I can't think of all the details in my head, we did an analysis looking at, you know, the the old... The sort of ramp, if you like, the older bit of the portfolio.
53:47 What happened to that? Did it actually ultimately become realized? And what were the returns from that bit of the portfolio? And the interesting thing is that most of these companies were returned with nice positive returns. The the the IRRs were were lower than, you know, the core part of the portfolio, but they weren't bad. You know, they were they were quite reasonable. They were in, you know, they were in the sort of teams. So that is definitely worth, you know, managing and and hanging on to. If the companies were were real kind of dross, which I think is probably what you're thinking, we we wouldn't be... They wouldn't have any significant value that would have been written down. So there are companies and funds that have a sort of, you know, late period blossoming.
54:38 And that's that's what that bit of evaluation represents. Lovely. Okay. Thank you, Hamish. And thank you everyone for your questions. We will get around to answering all questions that haven't been asked on the website. So check-in for the next twenty eight... Forty eight hours, and I hope you can answer the questions that haven't been asked today. But, Hamish, if I can just ask you for some final comments on the trust... Yeah. I think,
55:04 you know, we've had a period of adjustment in the private equity market in the last couple of years. I think we're we're coming to the end of that now. We're seeing good signs with the increasing flow of realizations. At the same time, we see a good flow of new opportunities to invest. So I think we're getting into a period where, you know, normal service will be resumed in 2025.
55:32 We're excited about it. I think the opportunities for people to add to their holdings now are obvious. One of the points I didn't make earlier was that when the market goes into a kind of risk off mode, discounts and private equity trusts tend to widen. When the market goes into a risk on mode, they they narrow and narrow quite significantly. And that also tends to coincide with upswing in realizations and pushing forward in NAV. There's some evidence that that risk on attitude has has taken root in America already, and what happens in America tends to spill over, to here. So I think, that's something else that's worth bearing in mind. But, the fundamentals of this business are strong, and we're sure it will continue to deliver growth for many years to come. Thanks very much indeed for your time, and thanks for your questions.
56:37 Hey, Mitch, Peter. Thank you for updating investors today. Could I please ask investors not to close this session? As you know, we automatically redirected to provide your feedback in order that the management team can better understand your views and expectations. This will only take a few moments to complete, but some should be greatly valued by the company. On behalf of the management team of CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC, we'd like to thank you for attending today's presentation, and good afternoon to you all.
Follow CT Private Equity Trust PLC into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Fund Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC
Investment Trust Sales Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC