Replay available

CT Private Equity Trust (LSE:CTPE) — Investor Presentation

Investor Presentation hosted by CT Private Equity Trust (LSE:CTPE) on Investor Meet Company, held 2023-11-27.

Mon, November 27, 2023 at 6:00 AMendedReplay
CT Private Equity Trust (LSE:CTPE) — Investor Presentation
Company
CT Private Equity Trust PLC (LSE:CTPE)
Date
Mon, Nov 27, 2023, 6:00 AM ET
Replay
Watch the replay on this page · 58 min

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/ct-private-equity-trust-plc-ctpe-investor-presentation

Replay

Transcript

Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.

0:00 Good morning and welcome to the CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC investor presentation. Throughout this recorded presentation, investors will be in listen only mode. Questions are encouraged and can be submitted at any time by the Q and A tab situated in the right hand corner of your screen. Simply type in your questions and press send. The company may not be in a position to answer every question it received during the meeting itself. However, the company will review your questions submitted today and publish responses where it's appropriate to do so. Before we begin, I'd like to submit the following poll. I'd now like to hand you over to fund manager, Hamish Meyer. Good morning to you, sir.

0:31 Good morning, everybody, and welcome to this third quarter results presentation for CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST. I'm gonna take you through a number of slides covering developments in the last quarter and the year to date, and we should have some time for questions at the end of that. So just looking quickly at the executive summary for the third quarter. So we have recorded a positive return in the third quarter of 3.3%, which means that for the first nine months of the year, we're up 0.9%. Now, that doesn't sound like a huge amount, but considering that we have had a number of very strong years, we had always expected a quieter year this year.

1:23 That said, it's not unusual by this stage of the year to have quite a a small, return with the final quarter typically being a more significant quarter in terms of overall return. But, the good news is that we are positive. We're going through what I would term a bit of a year of adjustment after some very strong increases in NAV, strong realizations, and quite a lot of underlying activity. There's still plenty of activity, but it's moderated a bit from the the peak levels of the last couple of years. We are still making plenty of new investments. We invested 24,000,000 in the third quarter. We're also harvesting a number as well, 14,000,000 realizations in the third quarter. This is a very similar number to what was achieved in the second quarter.

2:17 We'll come on to this in a minute, but we are running about 30% down in terms of exit... Compared to last year, which was a very strong year. So that is not, in itself particularly surprising, and it... It's not, a bad thing. We're still running at a significant, the higher level than was achieved in the years prior to COVID. So, pretty healthy, two way activity. We've announced a dividend of 7.01p, which is the same as was paid at the end of October, but that will be paid at the end of January. Just to remind, to remind you that the dividend is paid at 1% of the average of the previous four quarters NAV.

3:04 And if, that calculation leads to a number which is below the last dividend paid, we maintain the last dividend. So in other words, the dividend is on an upwards only trajectory, and it follows the long term growth of the NAV. This dividend has been in place, for well over a decade. It's a substantial dividend. It's highly predictable, and it has grown in line with NAV. At the current level of the share price, this is actually a very substantial yield. It's just under 6%, and you obviously get capital gain on top of that income. Currently standing at 45.4% of the portfolio invested in co investments, so that's directly into private companies.

3:53 The aim is to be around about 50%. It takes time to get there because as we make investments, we're also selling investments. So it's been gradually creeping up, but we're on track to get to, you know, 50% or thereabouts. Doesn't matter if it's slightly more or slightly less. We're trying to achieve a balance between the fund element of the portfolio and the co investment element to the portfolio. So we made five new investments in the third quarter of this year, three fund positions and two co investments on the fund positions. We invested $5,000,000 into The US fund purpose brands. Now what they do is invest into consumer franchises, a range of different types of of company.

4:44 They basically invest in things like yoga yoga companies, you know, franchises for yoga. They invest in in other things where they're basically you know, training children with the the sort of... It's like a kind of crammer for children. They do pet type things, you know, sort of doggy daycare and various other types of consumer franchise. Most of them are originating in The US. There's another one where they actually... People go and get cooled down in a sort of cryotherapy.

5:31 So they basically identify these various trends and they invest into these franchises across North America. It sounds quite interesting, and it it actually is, and it's demonstrated really good growth. The second one is Torquest six. This is a more conventional mid market buyout fund in Canada. It's the leading... One of the leading mid market buyout funds in Canada run by a chap called Brent, Beldsberg, who I've met a number of times and who is one of the leading figures within Canadian private equity. We've committed, 10,000,000 Canadian, which is about 6,000,000 sterling. And then lastly, we've put £10,000,000 into the inflection partnership. Three fund inflection are are basically the the leading mid market buyout company in The UK. They also do minority investment as well as majority investment, and this is the third fund in that area where they are, you know, equally as strong as they are in in majority buyouts. So just backing that relationship. It's an important relationship to to us inflection.

6:40 Excuse me. Two co investments. First one is, an Internet of Things software company. Haven't got the name here, and there's a reason for that because the deal has not yet been publicly disclosed. But what it does is it provides software for industrial machinery, which allows people to operate the factories more efficiently. It's a very large blue chip customer base. It's based in a town in the middle of a country that is quite close to The UK, but on the other side of the channel. And the deal itself is led by Scottish Equity Partners whom we have been backing in various funds and co investments since 1996.

7:27 And then the second co investment is UTMACO, which is a cybersecurity and data intelligence company. What they do is provide tamper proof tokens and various other types of security for critical infrastructure. It's a German company. That is a sector that is growing quite strongly, and they have a strong market position within it. This is the long term progression of the NAV with the cumulative dividends in the light blue. You know, we're... We continue to be on an upward trajectory, as I mentioned, and you can see the share price total return and the NAV total return. There's obviously a gap at the moment because the discount is relatively wide, but the long term picture is that that gap will close itself.

8:23 We expect that to happen at some point. And this is just another way of looking at, the same information. We're on an... A rising trend. We've had a number of strong years recently. This year is obviously not over. We've just had the first nine months of it, and so, you know, we're optimistic of further progress this year. In terms of outstanding commitments and net asset value, people like to track this. The the short summary is that commitments are pretty normal, very close to the long term average at just over 40% of net assets, 215,000,000, but 27,000,000 of that is to, funds where the, investment period has expired, and therefore, little of that will actually be be drawn.

9:20 Net debt analysis, the debt has gone up a bit, 74,500,000, but it's still within the comfortable range. We are in discussions with our bank to extend our borrowing facility. It doesn't actually expire until the middle of next year, but we typically arrange for it to be extended well before the expiry date, and we expect to achieve that quite soon. I think all the discussions we've had so far are very positive and constructive, so it's just a matter of following through their internal processes, which we're in the process of doing now. So we've got plenty of headroom to take advantage of opportunities as they arise. We do believe in the benefits of of gearing. We've got a very well diversified portfolio, which gives us a good platform against which to borrow.

10:11 And we expect that the returns that we make from investment will be far far in excess of the cost of borrowing. And that remains the case even though borrowing costs have gone up significantly in the last year or so. This is the list of new investments through 2023 so far. I'm not gonna talk about all of them individually, but you can see that there's a wide variety of different companies, different geographies, different lead managers, thus maintaining the diversification that we aim for, but also giving us the opportunity of making excellent returns through these particular investments. And that has, you know, continues on right the way through. I've got a couple... A few slides on the more recent co investments. Will literally give a couple of sentences on each. There's more detail on the slides that you can consult at your leisure. The first one here is Asbury Carbons. This is a graphite company that mills graphite into special flakes, and there's a very wide range of industrial applications for that. This is an old family controlled company that's been acquired by Mill Rock Capital where, you know, the business is substantial and it's got a lot of potential, but it's probably been a bit under managed.

11:31 And Millrock have bought in at five and a half times EBITDA, which is a a very attractive price for this scale of business. And they have a a transformation plan which they're in the midst of implementing. And we expect to make a, you know, a good handsome return here over the next few years. Excuse me. The next one is STARTRACK. This is led by August Equity, a long standing, partner of ours, and we've been investing with for the best part of twenty years. STARTRAC is a software company. It provides software for speed cameras, catch people who've been speeding. I had a few qualms about making this investment because I do think they can be a bit overzealous with these things, but I got over those qualms and we made the investment.

12:22 And it actually is a very big contributor to increasing road safety and catching the bad guys. And, basically, the the technology not only allows the processing of the speeding tickets quickly and efficiently, but it also it also can detect people that are using their mobile phone whilst driving, which is obviously an offense. It is used by most of the police forces in England and Wales, and the ones that don't currently use it will start using it. And there... There's more capability that's being added to the software. It's got a small amount of international business, which they're going to grow substantially over the years. So there's good prospects here.

13:16 Next one is another software company also led by August Equity, ONE Touch. This provides software to the care industry. So both the care companies who can plan their routers and monitor their care plans and monitor the timing and billing and all that sort of thing, but also the customers, the clients, and their families have an app that they can see who's who's coming in to see their relative and when and what are they actually doing and all that sort of thing. Sounds all very sort of commonsensical, but nobody has actually done such an integrated, app before. And this company started in Ireland. It's moved into The UK. It's growing quite significantly. There there is a real need for this type of thing.

14:04 And, you know, I think they've got good growth trajectory in front of them.

14:11 Next one is cargo groups. So what they do is they refurbish, mainly social housing, by making them more energy efficient, putting insulation in, putting heat pumps in, various other things like that, different types of heaters. And this company started in Wales. It's led by a young, very impressive entrepreneur who is moving the business into the neighboring counties in England. A lot of this spend is underpinned by government money, making sure that these... The social housing sector is, you know, as sustainable, and there's a lot of money going into that. Obviously, there are key criteria which have to be met in order to get contracts from the social housing sector, but Carter know what they're doing, and, you know, they will grow quite well over the few...

15:10 Next few years. Cycle Media, completely different company. Again, this is based in The Netherlands. It's, basically a system where they map they map towns and cities. They produce these maps of the property, which are then used by local authorities generally for the purposes of taxation. They... That car there, the driver in that car, and as a sort of laser imaging device on top, which basically maps everything as they drive past it, and then they produce these intricate maps, which then allow the local authorities to work at how much they should charge people and the the rates and things like that.

16:02 Started in in The Netherlands. It's been moved into the neighboring countries like Germany and France, now into The USA. We've known this company for a number of years. Volpe invested some years ago, and it's now been offered as a co investment for the next stage in its growth. So that's looking pretty good, actually. And then Utamaco, which I mentioned earlier, is this security... Cybersecurity company provides various pieces of hardware and software, which allow businesses to make their products as secure as possible. For obvious reasons, that is a a strong growth market, but they already have a significant share. They've got between 510% global market share, and it is it is growing quite nicely in the sort of low teens German company.

17:00 Germans are good at engineering as we all know, and this is, growing very nicely. So these are the realizations so far this year. I'm not gonna talk about them individually, but you can see the outcomes are good on the right hand side, good money multiples and IRRs. You know, there are occasionally ones which aren't so good, but, you know, for example, the bottom PD and MS, which is an inflection exit 1.1 times 1%, doesn't look that exciting. But bearing in mind that that company was once held at 0.1 times, it's a pretty good outcome. There's plenty of others which have got IRRs up in the, you know, the twenties and thirties and well beyond that. Different types of company transfective reagents or gene therapy on the one hand, wine drums, logistics providers on the other. So deliberately...

17:54 We, you know, we create a deliberately well diversified portfolio, and that means that you can have exits taking place all the time because, you know, there's always somebody wanting to get involved in these high growth businesses. And that, you know, has continued well throughout this year. We've also been redeploying the money back into new investments. I've talked about the recent co investments, but there's several others that happened earlier in the year, and they're summarized here.

18:26 And that continues all the way through. A lot of these businesses have got quite a strong technology slant to them, and that is, you know, because we see good long term secular growth there and so do our private equity partners who, you know, are putting the deals together. This is a long term picture of distributions and drawdowns. Obviously, it's like... It does fluctuate. There are... There is a cycle to things, and we've had quite an active period. In recent years, we're going through a slightly less active period now. That's entirely to be expected. This is not a slump very far from it. It's just a a sort of slower period, and they'll... That will be followed by a more active period, fairly soon, I think.

19:19 On the largest underlying holdings, just a couple of things to highlight. Sigma, the electrical components company, they lead on that are trying to sell this. It'll probably be sold later next year. Coretrax, wellbore cleanup company led by Buckthorn, We expect that will be exited in the first half of next year. Jollies is also in a sale process, and TWMA will probably sell later next year. So the... That's the top four. You know, there's a good chance that this time next year, none of those will be in the portfolio. Aurora is a a more recent investment, so that's still growing quite well. San Siro is the the sort of residual position from that holding, which we sold three quarters of last year and made, you know, nine times our money.

20:14 That's going fine. ATEC is an insurance company that provides insurance for sort of caravans and boats and things. That is also they're also exploring exit options there. Amethyst radiotherapy is still growing. Cyclomedia, I've just mentioned, has just gone into the portfolio. And AccuVein has been in the portfolio for a while. Still got a bit of progress to make before it becomes a immediate sale candidate, but it's... It is growing quite well. So quite a few things to watch out for there. And when we have realizations, it does tend to drive NAV growth because typically they are exiting at a good premium to the latest carrying value. The portfolio is well diversified by geography.

21:04 The largest element is in The UK market. No surprise there. That is our market. It's also the largest private equity market in Europe by some way. We have... Most of the rest of the portfolio is invested in Continental Europe, but there is a significant amount, 17% in The USA. That's always been the case. We have got a range of strong connections there, and we have continued to back our partners there, where they continue to succeed. The, vintage of the portfolio, it's well seasoned. So 60% is over three years old, 50% over four years old. A typical investment is structured over a four or five year holding period. So when you get into the three or four year zone, you're starting to plan exit. So the reason we monitor this element is it's a good proxy for the maturing part of the portfolio from which the exits will be derived in the in the near term.

22:08 If we had a very small amount of mature investments, then you would see you'd see a corresponding small amount of real... Realizations. But we invest every year in order to maintain that seasoning, if you like, in the portfolio. In terms of the valuation, it's not particularly high, compared to our peer group. It's only 11.6 times an enterprise value to EBITDA, which is is basically a pretty stable kind of number over recent quarters. It's at sort of higher end of normal if you look over the long term, but it's not particularly stretched.

22:50 And the enterprise to EBITDA... Enterprise value to EBITDA entry value 8.7 times is slightly above the long term average, but only slightly. And in terms of debt to EBITDA, 3.1 times, this is quite modest gearing. I mean, all these deals are are geared. Most of them are, well, almost all of them are geared, but they they start paying down debt once the deal starts. And so, you know, we're not particularly highly geared. And hence, although interest rates have gone up, you know, there isn't immediate sort of strain across the portfolio. I mean, there are one or two instances, but literally one or two. And so we're not particularly vulnerable to higher interest rates.

23:38 This is the exposure by sector. You can see the information technology and health care are big sectors for us. Think it's about 45% if you add those two together. I mentioned earlier about the secular growth in these these areas, the digitalization of society, the use of software more and more, but also health care, new equipment, new treatments growing. Quite often, they themselves actually will have a software component to them. And this has been a long term feature in this portfolio to have significant exposure in these two sectors. I don't make any apology for that. These are where our investment partners see best long term growth.

24:28 And if they can capture that at a reasonable price, then we should make excellent returns. We've also got better consumer, business services, industrials, consumer discretionary. You know, it's an area that's been under more pressure. I mean, it's not it's not crisis stricken or anything like that, but, you know, there's a bit more pressure there, you know, for obvious reasons with sluggish economic growth. But most of these businesses are proving to be quite resilient, which brings me to the conclusion where I've mentioned resilience here. I mean, that's deliberate. We are not seeing wide scale deterioration of fundamentals, quite the opposite fundamentals.

25:17 The underlying companies remain good. They have sort of all come through COVID very well. They're dealing with all the other shocks, And, you know, we're up year to date, and I wouldn't be surprised if we were up further in the final quarter of the year. We talked about the strong exposure in information technology and health care, which, you know, that growth trend that we see there isn't going to reverse itself anytime soon. And given the long term nature of our investment horizon, then, you know, we will continue to build value there. There's plenty of deal flow, new funds, and co investments. It's excellent. We just have to be selective. We can't do everything. We obviously...

26:04 In terms of co investing, we're probably doing about 10% of the the sort of proper deals that we're shown. And, you know, there's still good value to be found in the lower mid market. We've seen some moderation in pricing, which is good from an investment point of view. And we will selectively take those opportunities to lay the foundation for future asset growth. Realizations are down a bit on last year. They're about 70% of 2022 levels, but they're up on the pre COVID period. Exits are being achieved at good premiums to previous carrying value so far in 2023. It's about 30%. It's a bit below the level in 2022, but only just and we're not statistically significant reduction.

26:53 So as things are sold, so it will boost NAV. We will get some more access, I think, between now and the year end. And because of all that, we expect that we will continue to grow value for shareholders of the medium and longer term. There are a couple of appendices in here, which just show the discount over the last five years or so and the long... And the returns as the peer group. So, essentially, we do well compared to our peer group in terms of returns and discount. So I'm now going to stop and basically answer some of the questions.

27:42 Perfect. Hamish, thank you very much for your presentation. Ladies and gentlemen, please do continue to submit your questions just by using the q and a tab, is situated on the top right hand corner of your screen. Just while Hamish takes a few moments to view those questions that have been submitted today, I'd like to remind you that recording of this presentation along with a copy of the slides and the published q and a can be accessed via your investor dashboard. Hamish, as you can see, we've received a number of questions throughout today's presentation. If I could just ask you to read out those questions and give responses to what is appropriate to do so, I'll pick up from you at the end. Okay. Somebody's asked, what is your view on the FCA con... Consultation on private assets valuation? Do you think closer supervision is required? Well, the answer to that is that we're already pretty closely closely supervised.

28:29 The valuation here is a director's valuation. There's an independent board of directors that approves the valuation. But before I can even show it to the directors, we have to go through an internal committee, which is called the valuation and pricing committee, which is composed of senior people within my organization who are not involved directly in private equity or they're not in the private equity chain of command, if you like, which gives them independence. And, you know, they provide a lot of scrutiny over the valuations. The, valuations are are, compiled according to something called international private equity valuation guidelines or their equivalent because that doesn't actually, pertain in North America, although they do have an equivalent, system there.

29:18 And it's a naturally conservative methodology. Now we can prove this because when when exits take place, they are almost always at a significant premium to the most recent carrying value. And this isn't this isn't just a, you know, something happens occasionally. It happens all the time. I mean, we... I think we're to the last 149 exits, and it was over 300,000,000 worth of proceeds. It's in our r and s statement. And, you know, that was a a premium to the the latest carrying value of well over 30% on average. So the idea that the valuations are somehow, you know, too high is just not borne out by any of the evidence. In fact, you can argue that the valuations are are too low. And given that we tend to sit on a big discount to asset value when it will... A significant discount with, you know, at the higher end of the normal range at the moment, you can argue there's a double discount.

30:28 So I would say that we we are subject to quite a close degree of supervision. I think what the FCA and others would have to say is we'll have to explain to us what what case is there to answer before they, you know, conclude on this.

30:51 So that's one thing. Now that somebody else said, interested to hear how much cash in reserve the trust holds and how that compares to the expected dividend payout. Also, what are your thoughts on economic downturn and exit strategies options for underlying funds worsening and therefore distributions is paid to the fund... Paid to the trust drying up. So we don't we don't hold cash in reserve because we think that you as shareholders would like us to invest the money. You can hold the cash in the building society or a bank account yourself. So when you give us money, it's our job to invest it for you and make the the portfolio efficiently invested. We do make sure that we have enough capacity either through cash or borrowing facilities to meet commitments as they are drawn down, and we manage that carefully. There is a big spreadsheet that allows us to do this. We have done this successfully since 1999.

31:48 I've been involved all the way through. We're celebrating our twenty fifth anniversary next spring. There will be some events which, hopefully, many of you will be involved in. So we, you know, we've run this so that we don't run out of money. And importantly, we run it so that we can always pay the dividend. That is a very high priority for us. Economic, downturn, yes, we're in a a sort of more sluggish period. Obviously, we're not actually in recession despite this recession being much heralded. It still hasn't actually materialized in The UK, although one or two of the European countries are technically in recession. That makes it harder to make money, but it doesn't make it impossible.

32:35 It makes it harder to achieve exits, but exits are still being achieved. Even if you go back to the very worst situation I've seen in my career, was in the great financial crisis in about 2009. People were still selling companies and still buying companies. It never dries up completely. We've obviously gotta keep an eye on that. Distributions do not dry up completely. The one thing we can control quite carefully is how much money we spend on new investments, particularly co investments. And so we do moderate that when we think that the realizations are are, you know, turning out to be below where we originally expected. So this... The short answer is, you know, trust us to manage your money carefully, we will not run out of money.

33:28 Somebody asks that, we state that inflection is European mid market minority buyout fund. It says how the minority buyouts different from the majority buyouts apart from the ownership stake. Are the economics different? Is it not better to have majority stakes so the manager can control the management of the company? Yeah. That last comment is generally correct. But when inflection invest as a minority, they typically have many of the rights of control that you would achieve if you were making a majority investment. So they will have a shareholders agreement that will allow them to have a considerable say on things like exit, timing of exit.

34:14 So the the minority investing is not that different from majority investing. What it does do is it does open up quite a lot more opportunities for them to invest because a lot of company owners will be deterred from bringing in a private equity firm if they think they're going to be completely in control. But the reality is that the private equity firms often bring lots of extra strengths to that business, and so it makes a lot of sense. The the proof is in the pudding. If they can... If it's actually... Can invest as a minority and still achieve good access within a reasonable time frame and and make, similar returns, then it's worth doing. And that is exactly what has happened. So they've they've they've proven that their abilities in majority investing, the skills they've developed there are applicable in minority investing.

35:12 And so that's why we've backed them there. Somebody's asked for the Star Trek. Does it benefit from you, Les? And they've said, just kidding. Well, I'm not a 100% sure about that, but it probably does, which is another sort of ethical quandary for us. But there you go. Somebody has said, what impact does mister mayor think large labor majority in The UK next year will have will have on the company's investment process?

35:45 So this this is obviously somebody who thinks he can predict the future in terms of the electoral cycle. I think we're about probably a year away from a general election. The labor party, I think, if they win the election, we'd be sort of well advised to try and sort of make sure that the private equity sector actually is is healthy, and it's a big success story for The UK. I know that there's quite a lot of lobbying has been taken place trying to explain to Rachel Reeve and others the benefits of private equity and that they shouldn't just be viewed as a potential source of of tax income because if they if they do too much of that, then they will they will drive a section of the business overseas. And that is exactly what will happen if they follow through on some of their, you know, the more more aggressive of their tax proposals.

36:49 You know, I think private equity has built up in Britain over the last several decades over governments of different persuasions. It has proved itself resilience through all sorts of different challenges, and I expect it will continue to to prove resilient no matter what happens. Somebody's asked that the entry multiple for Cardo is very low. Well, it's growing very rapidly. It's... It was sourced by Buckthorn. I've been working on this business for a long time, and, you know, they they basically have negotiated an excellent deal there.

37:37 I mean, it's... Because it's growing very rapidly, the actual multiple looks, you know, very low, but that is a good thing. Basically, it's down to the skill of of Buckthorn. Somebody's asked, what is the average revenue and the average EBITDA growth of the portfolio? Now we don't have the numbers for this year yet, but last year, it was... EBITDA growth, I think, was about 22%, and revenue growth was a bit more than that. So there was a little bit of margin, contraction. I don't know what it will be for this year, but I I think it will still be pretty handsome, actually. You know, mid teens and above, I would be expected.

38:29 I would expect... Somebody said, conscious of the key man risks surrounding Hamish's management of trust. Any comment on how this is being managed or planned with the team? Well, this is not a one man band. Obviously, I do lead the team, but I have nine people in my team, including several directors. They're all direct... They're indirectly involved in in the trust. So, you know, I am 57. I'm not gonna do this forever, but I will do it for a few more years. And there are plenty of people more than capable of taking over from me in in due course. So, obviously, my superiors within Columbia Threadneedle do discuss this kind of thing with me. So I think the shareholders need to be confident that whatever happens, this company will continue to be managed successfully in the way that it has been for the last twenty five years.

39:29 Somebody's asked, has anything changed day to day since your manager has been taken over by Columbia Threadneedle? No. Because we run a largely autonomous business within Columbia Threadneedle in the same way that we did within the Bank of Montreal. And before that, f and c. So in terms of the day to day way that we make investments, there has been no change. There are obviously new systems and things that we have to be... Come familiar with within Columbia Thread Needle and, you know, we've got a different owner, but that doesn't really affect the day to day management. Somebody's asked about proportion of the portfolio is the EV to EBITDA valuation of 11.6 times calculated. I don't have the exact percentage, but it's most of the portfolio, and it includes both fund and co investments. It's the vast majority of the portfolio.

40:33 What else? Somebody's asked how Sigma's carrying value derived as shown on the slide was a multiple of of earnings. I haven't got the exact multiple in front of me, but, it's a fairly straightforward way of calculating it. Somebody said some of your peers have high... Been highlighting the opportunity in secondary funds and manager led secondaries at the moment. Secondaries are only 0.1% of the portfolio. Would you expect this to grow over time? Well, I mean, we basically do take part in secondaries. We have two secondaries funds, and these are are generally looking in the lower mid market.

41:19 It depends how you classify secondary. Some people call what we would describe as co investments also secondary, so we're probably understating our exposure to secondaries. There are, there are good opportunities in secondaries. It does fluctuate a bit. We basically have a high, threshold return, which we have to be confident can be achieved before we do a secondary. It's the same as for co investments. It's a 25% net IRR, which means that, we're quite often outbid by bigger secondaries funds. But when we do deal, we tend to make good returns. So our long term returns from secondaries as a business are good. They're in the high twenties. They're very similar to the returns that we achieve from co investments.

42:12 So the answer is where we where we can find a secondary that actually fits the portfolio and it meets the return criteria, it will go into the portfolio. We don't have a specific arbitrary target. And the final bit of the question is, would we expect this proportion to grow over time? And the answer to that is yes. Somebody has mentioned... You mentioned the exits drive NAV growth of the trust. How much of the NAV growth is normally driven by exits in percentage terms? Now it does vary from year to year, but it's a it's a... I would say the way to look at it is the exit premium, if you like, over carrying value is typically a significant minority of the NAV growth in any given year.

43:05 So there is a good correlation. It's not a perfect correlation, but there's a good correlation between this... The the size and proportion of exits and NAV growth. In other words, if we're having a strong exit experience, then we're likely to have good NAV growth. The converse is not always true. So you can actually get any good NAV growth where exits are more modest. But in general, lots of exits is good for NAV growth. Someone said, any comments on the pre 2014 investment still held? Well, these are... There's a tail. It always will be a tail. The ones that, show up in the, table there, I they still got value. So they, you know, they will probably be sold, and, we'll get some money back for them.

43:59 If they didn't have value, they wouldn't show up in the, in the tail. Yeah. Somebody says Thomas b, he said, how does your due diligence process differ from... For co investments to primary investments? Do have enough resources to keep track in co investments? Well, we certainly have enough resources to keep track of co investments. We're not leading these deals, but we we do very detailed due diligence before we invest. We meet the companies. We meet the lead managers. We have access to all the information that the lead managers have in about a third of the situations. We're observers on the board of the companies. We've got about 50 co investments at any given point in time. And with my team of nine people, that is a a viable number.

44:49 I couldn't run with 50 direct investments with a team of that size. But, obviously, we're we're investing in partnership and alongside the lead managers. And we have done over a 100 co investments since 2003. We've sold more than half of them. The returns are excellent. They're in the high twenties in terms of IRR. So I think our system is is working pretty well. Somebody said, what would you say is your competitive advantage compared to Pantheon or Harborfest with much larger teams and larger AUM? Well, if you look at their portfolios, they are very, very diverse, literally thousands of underlying companies instead of hundreds. So you're getting in each of these funds as more of a by the market approach, whereas we are more concentrated, albeit we maintain substantial diversification.

45:51 We are more UK oriented than either of them. We're also look more lower mid market oriented, and we also favor so called emerging managers, which has been a good strategy for us over the last twenty years. So these are key differentiating features, which I think do give us a competitive advantage. If you look at long term returns, they are, you know, they are at or better than either of those funds. What else?

46:32 Do I have an aim for where you expect the share price to be in the future? Well, it depends how far into the future. I mean, the the NAV is roughly £7. So I'd like I'd like the share price to be well over £7 at some point within the reasonably near future.

46:48 I think in the short term, getting back above £5, I think, is a very achievable objective. And then, you know, move on up six, seven, eight pounds. We've managed this on a long term basis. I mean, it's it's doubling every, you know, four or five years. So I think that's a a decent term aim to look at.

47:21 Somebody's asked whether we should convert to a long term asset fund. We're not considering that at the moment. Many respects, long term asset funds are effectively trying to achieve many of the things that investment trusts already achieve. There's an element of reinvention of the wheel going on here. So... And I don't think that would lead to the removal of the discount. Just turning it into a long term asset fund would not immediately remove the discount. I mean, long term asset funds will probably not be very liquid. They'll have some sort of liquidity, but they won't be anywhere near as liquid as a investment trust with a diverse shareholder base, market makers, brokers covering it. So I don't think that is something that's on the horizon.

48:21 Somebody said, how many years will the trust carry on for? Will there ever be a winding up vote, especially as the NAV is over $6.80 with a share price of 460? Well, it's a permanent capital vehicle, so it doesn't have a continuation vote, And nobody's ever asked for a continuation vote. We run it on a permanent basis. Now, clearly, we want the share price to be more reflective of the net asset value. The best way to do that is for me to create new buyers to explain what we're doing to encourage people to buy in. There's a brilliant opportunity to buy in at the moment when you've got such a a substantial discount. We are not going to put the company into to run off or anything like that.

49:10 That isn't what our shareholders want. And, you know, we're providing a good combination of strong capital growth plus a very handsome and growing dividend. It provides a brilliant opportunity for people who would otherwise not be able to become involved in private equity to gain a consistent exposure, and to get, returns that are well in excess of what they would achieve in the stock market generally. If you look at the long... And if you do this at the last ten years, the share price total return is about eight percentage points per annum better each year, ten years, than you could have achieved in the stock market, which is a huge premium.

50:00 And that doesn't happen by accident. It happens because we've built a, you know, high quality, well diversified portfolio because my team are very experienced in finding these investments. And as long as people are confident that we can continue to do that, we'll keep this this company going.

50:20 Right. I think we are getting quite close. There's one more... I'll just take this last question. If EBITDA is growing mid teens, but NAV is up a few percentage points, does that mean that valuation multiples are revised downwards? Well, there is a little bit of there's a little bit of softening of multiples, so that is correct, but long term trend is in terms of NAV growth will still be upwards.

50:51 Somebody's asked, how can you attract new investors, especially when stupid rules about total expense ratios are deterring previous investors to see my... You see such trust as dear. I'm aware of the the large private members bill. Let's hope it happens. However, more new investors will raise prices and reduce discounts. We are new shareholders, I would should add, but there are fewer and fewer managers like us out there, it seems. Yeah. I think the the way that costs are presented is an issue. I had the discussion with the chief executive of the AIC on this last week, And they they... And we don't think that the way things are presented is fair, particularly if you add in the the fees attributable to underlying funds.

51:38 It basically just makes us look really expensive. The actual management fees, either fees that we are paid, are not particularly high. It's not a particularly unreasonable, expense when you consider what the returns are. And bear in mind, all the returns I'm talking about are net returns. That's after all these fees and expenses. I mean, that premium I just mentioned, eight percent per annum over ten years above the stock market. That's after all these fees fees and expenses. The the bill going through the house laws led by Baroness Altman is to try and remove, think, some or all of the requirements of the AIFMD, which was after all a piece of European legislation, and, to disapply it to investment trust. Now those of you who follow this will probably remember that, originally, the investment trust sector lobbied hard for the AIFMD not to apply to investment trusts because a lot of the things that were supposedly beneficial from the AIFMD were already being achieved by investment trust through their independent boards and other things. And so if that legislation goes through, I think it will probably be beneficial. I mean, it may not go through. I think it's difficult for a private member's bill to actually get through, you know, as law even if it's being piloted by a, you know, a very experienced person,

53:09 which in the case of Rosal, then it is. So we'll see what happens. I think there will will probably be some movement on those regulations at some point.

53:23 Somebody said, do you think the returns in new investments are better than the return available buying CTPE shares back on the current discount? Now those of you who read the RNS will see my detailed views on this. So I think that, there is quite a big difference between buying back your own shares and investing into new investments. The principal one being that buying back is an immediate, one off boost, but you cannot keep doing it, because, you know, you will basically shrink. And as you shrink your asset base, you've still got, commitments, debts, etcetera, which can improve the... Or can increase the risk profile rather of the company, which may actually affect the share price. So a lot of people think that buying back is a way of automatically improving the share price, but it doesn't necessarily work like that.

54:20 You know, we are trying to maintain long term returns and a long term dividend, and we see plenty of opportunities where we can invest the money and make these returns year in, year out. We will buy back when we think it is clearly beneficial for the company. You know, for example, if the the share price is being hammered by some loose stock around, and we have done that Historically, in fact, we we stood in the market a few weeks ago and we're prepared to buy back. In the end, it wasn't actually required, but the price bounced quite strongly on the back of that. We will do that in consultation with our brokers. I think a lot of people have focused on what Pantheon has been doing recently.

55:05 A couple of fundamental differences between ourselves and Pantheon, the principal one is that they haven't paid a dividend before, whereas we pay 4% per annum out every year. So they've done a a moderate sized buyback, and the discount is still just as wide, I think, as as ours is despite having done that buyback. So I don't think buybacks on their own are a panacea. They have their place, but the whole issue of capital allocation, I've actually discussed in my r and s statement. So I think it's fairly clear what my view is on that. Okay. I don't see any other questions coming up. You've covered just about everything. Perfect. Yeah.

55:52 I think you actually managed to address all the questions from investors. And, of course, the company will review all the questions submitted today and publish those responses out on the investor meet company platform. But just before redirecting investors to provide you with their feedback, which is particularly important to you, Hamish, could I just ask you for a few closing comments? Yes. We we are in a a year of transition, but it is not a year of stagnation far from it. We expect to make further growth in NAV before the end of the year. The portfolio is proving resilient. It's very well diversified. There's lots of new companies entering it, and lots of culminating exit... Exits are also happening, albeit at slightly lower proportions than in the last year or two.

56:40 Dividend is very handsome. There's a great opportunity, as I mentioned, to get involved in the shares. Private equity is a long term asset class. It's one of the most long term asset classes you can be involved in. It has delivered over the entire twenty five years of this company's history, and there's no reason why if we stick to our process and invest diligently and manage the capital of the company successfully, why we cannot continue to grow well into the future. Thanks very much for the support of all of you. Thanks for your questions. And, obviously, we're available at any time, to elaborate on more of these. And if any of you want to come and see us at our AGM, you'd be more than welcome, which will be in the in the spring.

57:34 Perfect. Thank you very much, everybody. Perfect. Hamish, thank you once again for updating investors today. Could I please ask investors not to close this session as you'll now be automatically redirected to provide your feedback in order that the management team can better understand your views and expectations? This loan take a few moments to complete, but I'm sure it'll be greatly valued by the company. On behalf of the management team of CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC, we'd like to thank you for attending today's presentation, and good afternoon to you all.

Follow CT Private Equity Trust PLC into a list and get an email when it puts out news.

Latest news releases

Companies on this call

Speakers

Hamish Mair

Fund Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC

Peter Brown

Investment Trust Sales Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC

More from CT Private Equity Trust PLC