Hamish Mair
Fund Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC
Replay available
CT Private Equity Investment Trust interim update. hosted by CT Private Equity Trust (LSE:CTPE) on Investor Meet Company, held 2024-08-29.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/ct-private-equity-trust-plc-ctpe-ct-private-equity-investment-trust-interim-update
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:01 Morning, everybody. And welcome to the CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC investor presentation. Throughout this recorded presentation, investors will be in listen only mode. Questions are encouraged and they can be submitted at any time using the Q and A tab situated on the right hand corner of your screen. Simply type in your questions and press send. The company may not be in a position to answer every question received during the meeting itself. However, the company can review all questions submitted today and publish responses where it is appropriate to do so. Before we begin, I would like to
0:32 submit the following poll. And I would now like to hand you over to fund manager, Hamish Mayer. Good morning to you. Good morning, everybody, and thank you for joining this presentation on our interim results. It covers the first six months of 2024. So I'm gonna take you through a presentation which covers the the highlights and a little bit of detail, and then we'll open up the discussion for questions. And I'll do my best to answer as many as we have time for. So I've got the slides here. I'll just take you through. So highlights, we basically have seen reasonable growth in NAV in the second quarter of up 2.3%, which gives us a positive number for the first half of the year, up 0.8%.
1:29 It's quite normal for the movement in NAV to be relatively modest one way or the other in the first half of the year. The valuations, there's a time lag in valuations as usual, and so most of these valuations are essentially March numbers. A small number of them are June ones, probably about 15% of June numbers, 85 March numbers. And the March numbers themselves tend not to change that much from the December NAVs because they are compiled literally a few weeks later. Having said that, I will be able to give you an idea of trends within the portfolio, and you can see what's happening. A couple of things to highlight. First of all, we had realizations of 36,300,000 in the second quarter, which is, you know, quite a nice increase from the first quarter and gives us about 53,000,000 or so of realizations in the year to date, which is more than 30% ahead of where we were at the same stage last year.
2:38 And these realizations, in addition to others that have taken place since the the end of June, mean that we've already exceeded the full amount of realizations for 2023, which preserves 60,000,000. So we've seen quite a decent, recovery. And I think that's encouraging because realizations tend to be a nice premium to carrying value, And so strong realizations does tend to correlate ultimately into good growth in NAV. The dividend has been maintained at 7.01, and that will be paid at the end of October. Hasn't gone up because the NAV has not increased sufficiently to bring it up, but hopefully that will happen later in the year.
3:30 Just to remind you, the dividend is based on 1% of the average of the previous four NAVs. And once it's set to that level, even if the NAV growth isn't there, we hold it at the the level of the previous dividend. That's what we're doing at the moment. So you will get that dividend in due course. That means the shares are on quite an attractive yield, about six and a half percent at the moment, which I think is really good value. The co investments are now 44% of the portfolio. It's been sort of creeping up. Long term aim is to get to about 50%, but, obviously, it's a a slight moving feast.
4:18 You know, things are being sold all the time. And so we have to keep in investing to to get it up to that level. But the, you know, the exits are good drivers of NAV growth. So in terms of new investments in the second quarter, we put a £10,000,000 commitment to August Equity Fund six. This is a UK lower mid market buyout fund. We've backed several of their funds. They've been all very strong. So a good strong relationship with them. And we've done one co investment. This is in a new company called AccountIQ, which is a software company. It provides software for accounting purposes, and the deal is led by Acxiom who are a new private equity firm who specialize in software and other sort of technology enabled businesses.
5:15 So couple of words on some of the recent exits. We sold Jollies. We got the money in April. This was flagged earlier in the year because we knew it was coming, and this has been a great success. We've made, one more than four times our money in six years, a 27% IRR. So Jollies does a large format pet retailer. So pet shop, basically. It's the second largest chain in The UK after pets at home, which is the dominant player. This deal was led by Kester Capital, and they took hold of what was essentially, an ex, family company that needed a lot of modernization, a lot of professionalization in terms of its management.
6:02 And they have provided that, and the business has grown substantially. Basically, they have, you know, doubled the profitability and they have nearly doubled the the the state of stores. As a retail business, it's obviously had to cope with the pandemic and and all that sort of thing during the holding period, the cost of living crisis, etcetera. Fortunately, pet shops were allowed to stay open right the way through the pandemic. And, you know, lots of people went off and got dogs and cats, and that has acted to our benefit. The business has been sold to TDR Capital, who actually have a controlling stake in in ASDA.
6:50 So they can see a lot of upside in the business from here, but we've already made four times of money, and it's it's time for us to move on after six years. So great success there. We have also exited Cortrax. Now Cortrax is an energy services company. It does wellbore wellbore plug in abandonment services. So what does that mean? And, basically, you've got oil rigs out in the North Sea and various other provinces. And when you're finished with an oil well, you have to plug the well. There's various bits of equipment you put on top of the the well. This has a degree of counter cyclicality in it and that it is a beneficiary of the decommissioning trend that's going on in parts of the the North Sea.
7:45 But it's also... It also benefits from new activity. This business has grown quite a bit during the holding period, which is is essentially six years. They bought a significant business in America called Mohawk, which provided access to the the business in the Permian Basin, which is the main sort of oil area in the state. The background has not been that easy for the company because you've had quite a lot of volatility in the oil price, and that has a bearing on levels of activity. But the lead manager here, Buckthorn, who are energy specialists, were able to negotiate a good sale to the large listed company, Xpro, and we made 1.8 times cost, 12% IRR, which in the circumstances is not a bad outcome.
8:41 Interestingly, Xpro was... Is now a listed company in America, but it originally was actually a British private equity backed company. And we were actually invested in it more than twenty five years ago through the cat... One of the candover funds. So it's interesting how things have, turned around. It is now acquiring one of our other businesses. So that was good. We got, mixture of cash and shares, and the shares have been essentially largely sold down now. So we've actually got almost all the cash in. There's about £500,000 left in escrow, which will come out eventually. But, you know, we put it... We're basically out, which is excellent. More recent exit is ATEC. This is also a capital deal.
9:29 ATEC is a small insurance company. They basically insure little caravans and small boats, and this has grown quite impressively in the seven years or so since we invested, grown gross written premium three folds from 25,000,000 to 75,000,000 and significantly increase... Increased profitability as well. And that is against a fairly challenging background for the insurance industry, so another excellent outcome. So we're gonna make five times cost, 28% IRR. In fact, we're actually getting the money today.
10:14 So that has has happened. And that was at a decent premium to the previous carrying value. So that added about 4,000,000 or so to the valuation from this exit alone. So great outcome. Kester Capital have been involved to these exits. They're an emerging private equity firm that we've backed several years ago now. I was gonna say they're young guys from Silver Fleet. Well, they're they're they're younger than me, but, you know, they're maturing now, but they're extremely successful and very happy to be in partnership with them. And we've done a few co investments already and and there are others in the portfolio, and we're happy to be partnered with them going forward.
11:01 So this is the progression of NAV and dividends over the long term. You know, it gradually goes up. Obviously, it's been a little bit quieter in the last year or so, but we are now picking up again. And, you know, the long term picture is that we do tend to go up steadily. And this is the picture over the twenty five years. Some of you probably remember we're celebrating our twenty fifth anniversary this year. I've been involved, right, since the beginning. And over that time period, we have made for our shareholders four times the gains they could have made if they were just investing in the stock market. This really underlines not just the benefits of investing in our shares, but also the benefits of staying invested in the private equity asset class for a long period of time. You can get really powerful compounding returns which deliver, you know, returns which are are basically unavailable in other asset classes. So this is a good way to play private equity in a safe diversified fashion.
12:10 This is just another way of looking at performance over the different time periods and individual years. We've obviously had some really strong years a couple of years ago. It was less it was less strong last year, but hopefully, it's gonna accelerate back towards the longer term trend soon. In terms of outstanding commitments, this is the commitments to funds that we obviously have to have these in order that we keep redeploying capital back into into funds. That's about 206,000,000 of which were 25,000,000 is to funds for the investment period has expired, and we don't expect much of that 25,000,000 to be drawn.
12:58 So the level of outstanding commitments is about about in line with the five year average. It's neither... It's not... Certainly not too high. People always say, oh, what happens if it's all drawn down at once? Well, it won't be because it's spread over dozens of different funds, and any individual commitment is relatively small. And for... Even for that to be drawn, it would require manager to do a whole lot of deals virtually simultaneously, which they just, are not capable of doing. So we forecast drawdowns and realizations, in quite a lot of detail, we always have done throughout our twenty five year life. It's, a way of making sure that the balance sheet is used efficiently.
13:42 This is the debt profile. Currently got debt of about 91,000,000. That... That's actually gone down today with the receipt of the money from the ATEC exits. So we're back down into the the sort of mid seventies now. And, you know, we basically renewed our borrowing facilities in February. So we've got plenty of headroom at 91,000,000. We have about 40,000,000 of headroom. Excuse me. And we can use that, to make new investments. Well, it's likely that debt will decrease a bit from here. It's important to have a decent amount of debt to get the benefits of it. It does enhance shareholder returns because the long term return we expect to make from investments is considerably in excess of the cost of debt even with a higher rate of interest that we'd still expect that to be nicely enhancing.
14:42 Shareholders aren't expecting us to run with piles of cash, you know, a sort of piggy bank approach. I mean, you want us to invest your capital
14:55 in private equity, and that's what we do. So we try and maximize the efficiency of the balance sheet. The portfolio we have is a good portfolio against which to borrow because it's very well diversified, it's got lots of good quality companies in it, and the banks, therefore, are very comfortable lending. In terms of new investments in this year to date, just to recap, we did the AGUITY TRUST human investment fund earlier in the year. Achillitas, we've backed them many times before both through funds and co investments. We've got a strong track record. We also backed Corin Environmental Fund. This is a fund focusing on clean energy, and it is run by Gary.
15:47 Used to be at Scottish Equity Partners where he ran the environmental energies fund, which was a big success. And so we've backed him in this new fund. We've also backed Medrise. This is a health care fund run by Archimed who are French based life sciences investor who are very successful, and we've had a number of good deals from them. August Equity, I mentioned a minute ago. This is us backing the latest in a series of August Equity mid market funds, all of which have been pretty strong. And then lastly, we've done accounts IQ, which is the new software investment, which I'll talk about in more detail in a second. Just a couple of... A few slides on recent co investments. I won't talk through these in elaborate detail, but just touch on the high points to give you an idea of the kind of things that are in our portfolio.
16:43 These these have co investments done in the course of the last twelve months or so. So this is Cyclomedia.
16:49 So this company basically maps built up areas, produces these maps for... Principally for the use of local authorities who use them for the purposes of local taxation. They... That that little car there has a a sort of LIDAR system on the roof, and it basically scans all these properties, and you can get very detailed maps produced. And the business started in The Netherlands. It's pushed out into Germany, into The US as well. Volpe, who the lead on this, have been in the deal for over five years, and therefore, they know it inside out, and they're having a second shot at it. They brought us in as a a co investor. So we've got very high visibility of the the business we're buying and the the strength of the proposition. So we're optimistic that we'll make a good return over the next three or four years.
17:50 Next one is due to macro, which we went into last year. This is a cybersecurity company. They make special sort of tamper proof tokens and, you know, for a range of range of industries. They they have a... Between about five and ten percent market share already.
18:15 That market is is growing rapidly. You know, it's growing at sort of double digits, and they... And their share is growing into that growing market. So this business has got off to a really good start. So it's it's up already after a year. So, hopefully, make about three and a half times our money over three years or so, which should be great. Next one is BrainCube. This is a software company that provides provides software to improve the efficiency of manufacturing processes across quite a wide range of sectors. Allows them... The the companies to refine their systems or process to reduce cost, reduce energy, maximize productivity.
19:08 Already has a really interesting range of customers. SEP generally invest in The UK, but they do invest outside The UK. So this is in France. Actually, it's in the which is in Central France. And, again, you know, this is a growing market and where they already have decent market shares, they should be taken on quite a bit further with the help of, Scottish Equity Partners.
19:38 Educare EdTech is a deal led by Spanish firm, Oracle, and we've been tracking Oracle for a while. This space is an online education company. So they essentially run university courses for people in... Largely in the Spanish speaking world. It started in started in Spain, pushed into Latin America, quite high growth sector. We managed to get in at a relatively low price. 8.3 times EBITDA is is low for this type of business. So we're optimistic about how that will go. And then we've got AccountIQ, which is the new co investment I mentioned earlier. So this is accounting software software as a service.
20:30 It is for sort of medium sized companies. It's a more modern solution than some of the the sort of Sage type things that people typically have or companies typically have, and it fits in quite quickly. It's quite easy to install. So Acxiom are the lead here. They specialize in software and technology enabled companies. And this is one of their their first deals in the process and as a co investor alongside the fund. The Acxiom guys are pretty experienced. You know, they're they're quite young, but sort of driven classic emerging managers, sort of people that we like to back. We know some of them from their previous firms, which is important.
21:19 It gives you confidence in what they can achieve. So I hope to make about three times the money on this one. So quite a few realizations in 2024 to date. You can see the numbers on the right hand side. It's very attractive multiples of of cost and good, you know, nicely positive IRRs. I mean, anything above about 25% IRR is a is a pretty good outcome,
21:48 and most of these are are comfortably above that. You know, this has continued on. It's actually picked up quite nicely in the second quarter, as I mentioned earlier. And, also, we're making new investments, so plenty of drawdowns. These are across a range of different geographies. You could see that in The UK and different European countries and also some in North America, different lead managers. So you're getting all this diversification by, you know, sector, geography, lead manager. And as a lot of you probably heard me mention before, diversification is absolutely critical. It's the only practical way of reducing the naturally high risk involved in private equity down to moderate levels.
22:37 And so this diversification is renewed constantly as the funds in our portfolio
22:45 draw down. This is distributions and draw downs, longer term trend. It's just there for information. There's obviously a... You know, there is a close correlation between distributions and drawdowns. You know, when one side picks up, the other side tends to pick up as well. And looking at the largest underlying holdings, mean, some of these have now been sold. ATEC obviously has been sold, so as as, Cortrax. The others, none of these are immediately about to exit. I mean, Sigma and TWMA have got exit plans. Probably won't be achieved by the end of the year, but maybe not that much later. I...
23:31 And some of the others are earlier in the holding period. Aurora, which is a payments,
23:38 system... Digital payments, provider in The States is... Has got a a couple more years at least to run. Weirdfish has got a new, chief executive. He's doing a good job, but he needs a bit longer to be able to maximize value there. And Contained Air Solutions, which is the fume cabinet manufacturer has just done a couple of significant add on
24:05 acquisitions, which need time to integrate. So that will be another couple of years as well. And then seek... Cyclomedia and Newtomac are are still... You know, these are new deals. We've only been in them for a year, so there'll there'll be another two to three years holds there. But these businesses are all in pretty good shape. Hofie, that's what we used to call San Siro. This is the second leg, if you like, of our funeral services company in Italy where it already made sort of eight times our money. We've held on to 25% of the of the original investment in the sort of second stage of that. So we're optimistic that that will go well,
24:45 but we'll need to be in it for another year or two. In terms of the spread of the portfolio geography, 42% in The UK. The UK is always our largest market. It's our home market. It's the biggest private equity market in Europe,
25:02 and it's quite... You know, it's a deep market. Most of the rest of the money is invested in Continental Europe, although we have about 17% in The States. We always have had a bit in The States. That's the the biggest and deepest private equity market globally, and we have got some good links there. So we will maintain that that representation. The portfolio has always got a maturing element that's coming through, and this fuels the realizations. I mean, half the portfolio is more than four years old, which is, you know, the typical investment thesis for one of these companies is normally a four or five year... Is based around a four or five year hold. And, so when they're in the third or fourth year, this is... You know, they start to turn their minds towards exits and start planning.
25:54 And, we always have realizations coming through. I mean, it fluctuates a bit in volume, but, you know, we we don't have completely dry patches at all. We always have some things coming through, and that does drive, growth in NAV.
26:11 The portfolio is not particularly highly valued. In fact, it's actually quite inexpensive compared to most of our peers. The weighted average EV to EBITDA, you know, enterprise value essentially to cash flow is 11 times. That's down a little bit over the course of the last twelve months.
26:33 And the weighted average entry price, the price of which these companies were bought on average is 8.7 times. So that... They've been rerated a bit as as the holdings have matured as... Which is kind of what you'd expect. It's not very highly geared. Debt to EBITDA is 3.1 times. I mean, that's that's been about that level for for some time. So, yes, there is gearing here. I mean, they are largely management buyouts, you know, are based around using a combination of equity and debt to buy the businesses, but the gearing is not is not high. In terms of sectoral split, we've got significant exposures to health care and information technology. Now these are both sectors, displaying very robust long term growth. Those are quite large broad sectors. So, you know, that includes information technology, includes software and services as well as hardware, but it's mainly software.
27:35 Health care includes, you know, everything from sort of drug discovery through to care companies through to, you know, contract research organizations and medical devices companies, all sorts of different things there, most of which have got quite an exciting story to tell. So just to conclude, the portfolio is very resilient. This growth in NAV has started in the first half of this year. Pretty confident we'll see good growth in the second half.
28:10 As I mentioned, we have got new borrowing facilities in place, which give us plenty of headroom and firepower, allows us to nicely gear the portfolio and enhance returns for shareholders. There's plenty of opportunities to invest into new deals, co investments, and funds. Quite often, you find after there's been a bit of an economic slowdown, it's actually a very good time to invest. So we we see, you know, literally hundreds of opportunities, and we will take a few of them, you know, carefully.
28:47 We are seeing encouraging signs of recovery in m and a, a clear improvement in the second quarter, and that seems to have continued into this current quarter. The uplift on on exits in 2024 to date is 35% above previous carrying value. So that compares to 29% in 2023 and thirty six percent in 2022.
29:12 So that's a pretty healthy number, and, you know, that bodes well for NAV growth. Plenty of people want to invest into private equity. Fundraising for private equity has been tougher this year, but there's a lot of so called dry powder, lots of capital that's just been waiting to be deployed, and we, can see that being, spent over the next few years.
29:34 And so, you know, we're confident looking forward. We think we'll grow shareholder value the remainder of this year and well beyond that and keep up the long term record of, you know, impressive growth. So that's the end of the formal bit of the presentation. So I'm happy to to take some questions now.
30:01 Great. Thanks, Hamish. Hopefully, everyone can hear me. And I'll first go through just the pre submitted questions. But, obviously, we'd be delighted if more people can submit more as they've heard the slides and heard points. But, yeah, there are some interesting ones, which you have alluded to in some respect. But the first one is, related to the AGM presentation. You showed NAV growth of 2.8% for the fiscal year, but you also show revenues and EBITDA of the underlying portfolio companies grew by seventeen percent and twenty nine percent respectively. Shouldn't the NAV growth be closer to the EBITDA growth? And does the discrepancy mean that multiples contracted?
30:45 Yes. I mean, growth in EBITDA is not the same as growth in earnings per share. But if you're getting good growth in EBITDA, you would expect there to be, you know, healthy growth in equity. I mean, there are a couple things to be aware of. The the valuation multiple did go down actually over 2023. It went from 11.6 times down to 11 times. So, you know, the the profits growth was, you know, not gonna be fully reflected in NAV when they they... You know, the multiples are going down. So that does happen from time to time. And then you've also got other things like, you know, interest costs gone up.
31:36 You also paid down, debt repayment, which means it isn't it isn't a simple relationship between EBITDA growth and NEV growth. But, you know, basically, you're not going to get NEV growth unless you've got decent growth in EBITDA, but it's not as mechanistic a relationship as you would get if if you're looking at earnings per share growth, which isn't really a statistic that you can derive from a private equity portfolio.
32:08 So that's that one. Apologies. Yes. Thank you. That makes sense. Now onto undrawn commitments, which are around 40% of net assets in line with five year averages. But shouldn't this ratio decline with increasing proportion of the portfolio invested in co investments?
32:29 Not necessarily. I mean, we are, you know, we are gradually increasing the proportion in co investments, you know, up to about 50%. And, you know, our outstanding undrawn commitments are roughly 200,000,000. You know, 50% of the portfolio is is essentially, you know, 250,000,000.
32:54 The... These commitments are drawn down over, you know, four or five years. So we do have to keep it at a reasonable level in order to keep redeploying back into funds and not start of, you know, having an inefficient balance sheet piling up cash. So we we monitor the level of commitments because, you know, we have covenants and things that we have to keep an eye on. We obviously don't want to get it into such a kind of high number
33:25 that it, you know, frightens people. It's nowhere near that level at the moment. So, I mean, this is likely to be at or around this level or slightly higher for the foreseeable future. Okay. Then there's also a pre submitted question about UTMACO, and they're referencing a a recent presentation where you stated you were able to invest eighteen months after the deal was agreed, effectively reducing the entry multiple. And they just want to know how does that work, and why would you be able to participate in the deal eighteen months later? Yeah. That's because the the general partner was keen for us to come in as a co investor. I mean, the the position that they held was probably larger than they were comfortable holding just because of the size of their their fund.
34:15 This type of thing does happen. So, you know, the the general partner is essentially warehousing the deal for, in this case, eighteen months. During that period, the profits have grown,
34:28 and they bring us in at the original cost price. So it means we're getting in at, you know, a lower multiple than they went in on. But it makes sense for them because they they needed to sell down part of it because it was above their natural holding size. This situation does occur from time to time, but it's quite rare. I mean, it's a good situation. It's it's one of the inefficiencies that you sometimes find in the private equity market, which act in our favor. And, you know, it gives you a really good start for the investment. And if an investment starts well, that is a big part of, you know, a big part of its long term success.
35:10 Yeah. That's interesting. Related to the primary commitments in q one, and it stated that they were all to funds that range between 100 to 375,000,000 in size. And the comment is those fund sizes sound quite small. Is this representative for the whole portfolio? What's the average fund size that you invest in or with? Yeah. So, like, I mean, the... You know, maybe maybe it sounds small, but £3,375,000,000 fund isn't really a small fund. I mean, obviously, if you read the Feet and it's all about Blackstone raising billions and billions, you might think they're small, but these are decent sized funds. I mean, we are a mid market specialist, so we are typically investing in funds that are between $105,100,000,000 pounds or euros in scale.
36:02 We will occasionally be in funds that are bigger than that, you know, might be over 1,000,000,000, but that is the exception. You know, they're very well rehearsed arguments in favor of the mid market. You know, you grow more rapidly from a smaller base. The mid market generally offers companies on lower entry prices, which, you know, there's an inverse correlation between entry price and return, unsurprisingly. And, you know, there are lots of interesting pure plays across the content of Europe and further afield. Lots of really interesting businesses which have got strong growth. We're getting involved earlier in in the growth story. They are... These companies are of a size where they have got good quality management, focused management.
36:53 They've been carefully selected by private equity. And so the the fund size is a function of our mid market focus. We're not doing sort of tiny little deals. You know, the average size of a company that goes into our portfolio is an enterprise value of around about a £100,000,000. So, you know, it's not the corner shop. I mean, it's a decent sized business. It's probably got, you know, 10 or 12,000,000 of of of profits. They're generally a bit on the small side to go to the stock market,
37:28 but sometimes they will exit to the stock market. More often, they will exit to being sold to bigger private equity funds. So we like there to be big funds around, but we're not gonna back them. We sell to them rather than invest with them.
37:44 Great. Moving on to dividends. There's been a few people ask about this. There's a... I think David and Andrew, just to name a few. Are they ask? They're asking essentially, is the dividend level sustainable? They reference the AIC next generation status of dividend hero, meaning that you've passed ten years of consecutive growth in dividend. But to reach a full dividend here, you you would have to provide twenty years of consecutive growth. So they're just asking, you know, how sustainable is the dividend? Are you looking at a thirteenth year of growth? Yep. The dividend is set at a level that we are confident is sustainable, and we're also perfectly well aware of our dividend hero status and don't want to lose it.
38:32 So it is likely that we will have an increase in the thirteenth year. And, hopefully, every year thereafter because, you know, the... It does it does have these flat periods, but it does basically track the growth in NAV. So as long as the company's growing, the dividend should be growing. Yeah. Exactly. It's that formulaic approach. So it is very much determined by the NAV, but it it is struck at, at a level that it will not fall from. At least that's the the, commitment by the board currently. Yep. Then moving on to the discounts because that's coming up a bit. Andrew's asking, what is your feeling on the trust discounts to NAV in the sector, and how are these evolving? It still looks a bit wide.
39:21 And it kinda tying in with another team that's coming through in the questions about interest rates. Do you feel like now, for example, with the... A change of of interest rate environment that might help boost the the discount and share price?
39:38 Well, I mean, discount, I mean, we think sort of is uncomfortably wide. And, you know, basically, we have to try and encourage as many people as possible to buy the shares to to tighten that discount, bring it in, ultimately get to a premium.
39:56 The valuation methodology is naturally conservative. We can see that realizations are typically at 30% plus premium to meet it carrying value, and there have been lots and lots of realizations over the years. So it's it's very much, proven that there... There's nothing wrong with the valuation methodology. So the discounts in our sector tend to be a function of the general attitude in the market towards risk. So when the market is in a kind of risk on, frame of mind, the discounts tend to contract. And when they're in the risk off frame of mind, they tend to widen out a bit, and they've widened out a bit recently. I mean, over the long term, it provides a brilliant opportunity for people to buy in, you know, basically buying the portfolio at two thirds of its actual value.
40:50 And, you know, that value is likely to grow as as it realizes over time and as the underlying companies grow. You know, there... There's no sort of easy answer to reducing the discount. You know, some people think, well, why don't we buy back loads of shares? That will help. Well, it's... It, you know, doesn't necessarily provide a permanent solution. In fact, there's a little evidence that it does too. It does enhance NAV a little bit, but there's a limit to how much, you can buy back without, you know, diverting a lot of your precious capital away from new investments or from paying the dividend or paying the interest or whatever. So you have to... That all has to be weighed up carefully, which is what we do.
41:36 But, you know, the the best way of narrowing the discount is to build the demand for the shares. So me doing presentations like this and going around and seeing people all around the country and everywhere else and persuading them that this is a really good vehicle to give you exposure to a strong performing asset class, which will deliver superb returns for you over the long term.
42:02 So I've just gotta get that message across accompanied by, you know, all our different salespeople and our brokers and everybody else. There's no, you know, easy solution to discount. It is likely that discounts are likely are likely to get significantly narrower because we're now going into, you know, a better environment as you can tell from my statement.
42:31 Yeah. And maybe it's question about interest rates as well, whether that Yeah. Is gonna make difference into long term returns. So interest rates have been, you know, for fifteen years until a couple years ago, were at abnormally low levels. We were always expecting it to return to more normal levels, which we're at now. The private equity investors are generally, you know, experienced people. They always thought that they were going to see higher, you know, more realistic rates of interest. And when they do deals, they very much had in mind that there would be a reversion to normal rates of interest, and that has now actually happened. I mean, the immediate effect of it is it will push or it has pushed down prices a bit, and we've seen some of that adjustment.
43:18 But, you know, that throws up, you know, good opportunities for investment. But... And the and the adjustment does tend to be gradual. So it's perfectly feasible to continue to make strong returns. I mean, the private equity required return. You know, I did made my first private equity investments in the early nineteen nineties. I read the investment papers. They will say, you know, our target return is 36%.
43:45 And, you know, this this is papers I'm reading in the early nineteen nineties. Papers I read now, they say our target return is 36% and have done all the way through or or whatever, 30 something percent. So it's an absolute return asset class. So they are looking to make those sort of returns, and there's a price that they will have to pay
44:09 in order to make those returns. When interest rates go up, that price will go down a bit, and then they'll invest at that lower price. And if everything goes according to plan, they will they will make those returns. Now, obviously, it doesn't always go according to plan for every single investment. Otherwise, our NEV growth would be 30 something percent over twenty five years, per annum, and nobody achieves that. But it is feasible to achieve a return in in the mid teens or better, and the best funds do achieve that. And we are in that category. So I think, you know,
44:47 interest rates having gone up is something that we have to adapt to. Obviously, these are management buyouts. Half the capital structure is debt. So the the cost of capital will have gone up, And therefore, the acceptable entry price, all things being equal, which they never are, will have gone down a bit. And... But there will be plenty of dealing at that new level.
45:18 Yeah. That's very interesting and good food for thought. Maybe touching on Rosita's question. Sorry if there's background noise. What would be your wish list from the budget? Have you heard anything yet that makes you hopeful? So maybe commenting on The UK politics. Yeah. So I think a lot of you who follow this will see that the Labour Party have been threatening to increase on carried interest in private equity. And if they if they moved it from the current rate, which is 28% up to the full income tax rate, which in our case in Scotland is 48%. It's 45% the rest of The UK, but we have the privilege in Scotland of paying extra tax.
46:07 That would be disastrous. I mean, if it... If they increased it from 28 to 48%, it's quite likely they'll increase it by a smaller amount. We are actually... They're in the so called consultation phase at the moment. So me and many others in the sector are saying to them, you know, this is actually going to be quite damaging to the sector if you do... You know, if the worst case scenario unfolds. Similarly, if they put up capital gains tax significantly, that will act as a break on enterprising activity. I mean, there aren't very many people pay capital gains tax, but the people that do are the people that tend to be driving the economy forward.
46:58 So I think if the government are serious about being pro growth, pro enterprise, they need to, you know, not introduce measures that actually blunt enterprise and therefore blunt growth.
47:14 So, you know, we we would hope that some of the the worst case things that have been trailed don't actually happen. That would be a a win for us because there's a lot of concern in the sector.
47:34 Okay. Fingers crossed. Maybe another different angle now. David's asking what benefit does the trust get from being managed by the CT group. Maybe I can even just comment from the sales, marketing, and other ancillary services. It's part of such a vast, corporation that has that economies of scale. First and foremost, you know, you get highly experienced and and talented people. Obviously, not referring to myself there, but, you know, in company secretary services, marketing, press relations as well, and then that ability to negotiate with third parties on other services and and marketing opportunities.
48:25 As James mentioned earlier, you know, just trying to get the message out there as much as possible. So being part of a range of nine investment trusts where we have around £10,000,000,000 worth of assets under management, it makes us a very attractive partner for for various other entities to work with us, and then that gives CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST another platform with which they would be able to to voice their message to a broader audience. But I'll hand over to Hamish Moore from the investment perspective. Yeah. I mean, we're we're a relatively self contained autonomous unit within Columbia Threat Needle Investments, but we do benefit from being within the larger group because all the ancillary functions and support function, including including distribution and marketing are provided for us. So we can concentrate on on basically investing money and in raising money. We actually have to do a lot of the fundraising ourselves because it's quite specialized activity.
49:33 And, ultimately, we should get access to the the wider Ameriprise network and channels. So, I mean, that takes time to come through. We discuss it with our our bosses in America on a regular basis. And, you know, eventually, we will be able to expand our client base in... Into the wider Ameriprise network and channels. So, you know, that is a... That's a big thing. You know, we we have... You you know, we've good contacts in America already, but these are supplemented by people that we're introduced to by our our colleagues over there. You know, it's it's a pretty sort of benign relationship.
50:20 I mean, obviously, all big financial institutions, you know, come with a certain amount of, you know, bureaucracy. And we had that before in the Bank of Montreal and to some extent within f and c, but you get benefits from that bureaucracy. You know, you have good processes, systems, rigor, you know, things that shareholders can take confidence in. There's a lot of there's a lot of sort of checks and balances in in these systems. But, I mean, the key thing is that we retain the autonomy that we need to make money for our shareholders. Yep. Mike has asked a question on the topic of gearing. So could you please clarify the gearing of the trust versus the exposure the trust has to its underlying investments burdened by debt?
51:12 So I suppose just commenting on the gearing in the context of the the wider portfolio's leverage through the underlying. Yeah. So, I mean, the the comp... The the company is currently geared about 15%, and it's it's going down a bit, which is within its kind of normal range. Underlying businesses are about 30% geared. 30% of their enterprise value is debt.
51:38 Bit less, actually, 25, which is not particularly high. So these are, you you know, know, these are management buyers, so they do have debt on their capital structure. It's one of the ways we can make strong returns, but we're not we're not particularly highly geared or or, you know, we're not immune to higher interest rates, but it's it's not a threatening level. Far from it. I'm just looking at some of the questions. Somebody's asking if we've new venture capital type investments. Yeah. Was gonna ask that next question. Companies. It's about 4% of the overall portfolio, so it's a small amount. Mhmm. We've always had a little bit, but we are mainly mid market buyouts.
52:21 There's another question about, you know, buying back shares. Well, we bought back 1.7% of our share capital in the first half of the year, which is more than most people have done. And we will weigh up the merits of buying back shares versus using the capital for new investments or paying dividends or paying down debt or whatever. I mean, it's it's, you know, it's not a straightforward equation of saying, well, you know, if you do buy back the shares now, you make an immediate, you know, handsome and certain return. Because if you do too much buying back, you know, you will actually end up over gearing the company. And although you might have enhanced the NAV, it's, you know, unlikely to enhance the share price. Just as I said earlier, there's no magic bullet to getting the discount down, and you cannot just do it by buying back lots of your shares.
53:17 It doesn't work. I mean, Pantheon have tried it. It hasn't made much difference. They... Incidentally, they they had not actually paid a dividend at all. We have distributed a lot of capital to... I think it's about a 136,000,000 over the last ten years to shareholders via via dividend. And, you know, that is one of the reasons for for typically our discount has been narrower than our peer group, and I expect to get back to that better rating than the peer group quite soon. And do you have time for one or two more? Yes. This year, I think it's just a couple more there. Maybe Jens' question about the manager led secondaries and GC opportunities there at the moment. Yeah. We do invest in some of these. Yeah.
54:07 We we do see some of these. I mean, not that many of them, but, that we do. But, I mean, we appraise them in the way that would appraise any, you know, co investment or secondary. I mean, we will not deal in a co investment or a secondary unless we're sure we can do a 25% net IRR, which is quite a high hurdle. So a lot of things will fall down at that stage in the analysis when we look at the returns.
54:31 But, yes, we will do some of these. And then maybe lastly, before I summarize with some closing remarks, do you have a view on the university spinouts in The UK, and do you get involved in those at all? Interesting question. I happen to chair the university spin out fund of Edinburgh University, which is called Old College Capital. So I do know about this now. Most of these businesses are at too early stage to be included in this portfolio, but, it is a very interesting sector. There's there's gonna be some great successes. I mean, our our Edinburgh portfolio is about... There's 30 something companies. We've already had one
55:16 big exit made about seven times our money on that, and there's several others that will come through. It is it is quite risky activity. And, basically, venture capital is is a difficult place to make money, generally.
55:33 We favor mid market buyers because the returns are generally better and it's lower risk. It doesn't it doesn't mean that we wouldn't... We'd never do any venture capital, but we wouldn't probably do any of this sort of seed stages... Seed stage activity, which is what university spinouts tend to be. Having said that, we do have a position in Northern Gritstone, which does university spinouts from the universities of Manchester, Sheffield, and Leeds. And the manager there of that fund is somebody we've known for a long period of time, so we're pretty confident that they can do that well. It's a really interesting sector, university spinouts. There aren't that many universities that have done it successfully, but Edinburgh is one of them.
56:21 Unfortunately, members of the public can't get access to that yet because we don't have a vehicle that is is available.
56:29 Who knows? We might have one in the future. Thanks so much for answering all these questions. Do want to just say a few closing remarks? Yes. Think, you know, we've had a good start to the year. I think the the market is clearly showing some signs of improvement. I mean, you know, things are not booming yet, but they are definitely... They have definitely improved. We are seeing plenty of new good investments, places to deploy our capital, and we are also now see... Seeing the the flow of realizations picking up nicely, and these are closely correlated with growth in NAV.
57:16 So looking forward, you know, we've still got large part of the year to run. We can't have complete visibility on how things are going to pan out, but we do have confidence that we will be able to, you know, grow the NAV between now and the end of the year. So I think there've been a lot of focus on the discount. The discount provides a brilliant buying opportunity. And, you know, I would encourage those of you who are interested and have the capital to take that opportunity whilst it exists. Thank you very much for your attention, and, hopefully, I've answered most of those questions. And Fantastic. Thanks again for joining. Fantastic. Hamish, Christine, thank you once again for updating investors today.
58:04 Could I please ask investors not to close this session as you will now be automatically redirected to provide your feedback and order that the board can better understand your views and expectations. This will only take a few moments to complete, and I'm sure will be greatly valued by the company. On behalf of the management team of CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC, we would like to thank you for attending
58:24 today's presentation, and good afternoon to you all. Hi.
Follow CT Private Equity Trust PLC into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Fund Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC
Investment Trust Sales Manager at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC
Head of Investment Trusts at CT PRIVATE EQUITY TRUST PLC