Vail Resorts, Inc. · NYSE:MTN
Vail Resorts — Proxy Contest (November 2026)
52 slides from Vail Resorts's proxy contest presentation, Nov 12, 2026
Slide 1: Restoring Accountability at Vail Resorts
Restoring Accountability at Vail Resorts Presentation to ISS by Gregory S. Meyer, CFA Independent nominee for the Board of Directors of Vail Resorts, Inc. (NYSE: MTN) 2026 Annual Meeting of Stockholders | Presented to ISS November 12, 2026
Slide 2: Important information
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Important information This presentation is solicitation material of Gregory S. Meyer in connection with the 2026 Annual Meeting of Stockholders of Vai l Resorts, Inc. Stockholders are urged to read Mr. Meyer's definitive
Slide 3: Executive summary: one seat, one focused change
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Executive summary: one seat, one focused change 1 Five years of value destruction Over five years to June 17, 2026, Vail's total return was −50%, 14th of 15 among its proxy peers, while the Russell Midcap rose 49%. 2 Erod
Slide 4: The case for change
01 The case for change Shareholder returns, operating returns, the balance sheet and the guest experience are all moving the wrong way
Slide 5: 1-year total return: Vail vs. Russell Midcap
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting 1 - year total return: Vail −10.9% vs. +22.2% for the Russell Midcap Total return • June 17, 2025 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −10.9% • Dow Jones U.S. Travel & Leisure: −0.4% • Russell Midcap: +22.2% • Vail trailed its industr
Slide 6: 3-year total return: Vail vs. indices
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting 3 - year total return: Vail −39.3% while its industry index rose 33.1% and the Russell Midcap 56.2% Total return • June 16, 2023 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −39.3% (−15.3% a year) • Dow Jones U.S. Travel & Leisure: +33.1% (+1
Slide 7: 5-year total return: Vail lost half its value
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting 5 - year total return: Vail lost half its value while its benchmarks rose 33% to 49% Total return • June 17, 2021 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −50.1% (−13.0% a year) • Dow Jones U.S. Travel & Leisure: +33.4% (+5.9% a year) • R
Slide 8: Peer group comparison, 1 year: Vail ranks 14th of 15
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group comparison, 1 year: Vail ranks 14th of 15, trailing the peer median by 26 points 1 - year total return • June 17, 2025 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −10.9% • Peer median: +15.4% • Vail ranks 14th of 15 • Vail trailed
Slide 9: Peer group comparison, 3 years: Vail ranks last
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group comparison, 3 years: Vail ranks last of 15, trailing the peer median by 42 points 3 - year total return • June 16, 2023 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −39.3% • Peer median: +3.2% • Vail ranks last of 15 • Vail trailed
Slide 10: Peer group comparison, 5 years: Vail ranks 14th
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group comparison, 5 years: Vail ranks 14th of 15, trailing the peer median by 46 points 5 - year total return • June 17, 2021 – June 17, 2026 • Vail: −50.1% • Peer median: −4.4% • Vail ranks 14th of 15 • Vail trailed
Slide 11: $1.4 billion deployed since FY2022, Resort EBITDA down 11%
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting $1.4 billion deployed since FY2022, yet Resort EBITDA is down 11% What it shows • ~$1.4B of capex and acquisitions, FY2022 – FY2026 • Resort Reported EBITDA fell from $837M to $746M over 5 yrs • Resort EBITDA margin fell
Slide 12: Returns and margins have fallen on every measure
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Returns and margins have fallen on every measure Return on invested capital 14.0% → 9.0% Down ~36%, FY2022 – FY2026 Return on assets 5.9% → 3.0% Down ~48% Free cash flow margin 20.5% → 8.7% Down 11.8 points Operating marg
Slide 13: Leverage is rising as cash generation falls
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Leverage is rising as cash generation falls Net debt / EBITDA: 2.0x → 3.9x Net debt / free cash flow: 3.1x → 11.8x 13
Slide 14: $1.74 billion maturity wall in FY2030
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting A $1.74 billion maturity wall in FY2030 calls for capital - markets expertise on the board Why it matters • ~55% of Vail's debt comes due in a single fiscal year • That is ~7x FY2026 free cash flow • Refinancing terms wil
Slide 15: Pass units have fallen three seasons in a row
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Pass units have fallen three seasons in a row, and the decline is accelerating What it shows • 2026/27 pass units down 12% year over year (through Sept 18, 2026) • 15% below the 2023/24 peak • Pass sales dollars now falli
Slide 16: Guests see crowding management says has not worsened
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Guests see the crowding that management says has not worsened The disconnect • CEO Rob Katz told the WSJ (Mar 2026) that crowding has not worsened • Guest reports and photos across Park City and other resorts say otherwis
Slide 17: Only one Vail resort ranks in SKI Magazine's top 10
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Only one Vail resort ranks in SKI Magazine's top 10, East or West Vail resorts in the top 10 East + top 10 West 1 of 20 Whistler only, for the second year in a row Vail Mountain's ranking, year over year #12 → #24 The fla
Slide 18: Top Western resorts take the rival Ikon Pass
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting 8 of SKI's top 10 Western resorts take the rival Ikon Pass; Vail owns just 1 #9 Grand Targhee is on neither pass. Source: Samantha Berman, "The Top 30 Ski Resorts in the West 2027," SKI Magazine, Nov 5, 20 26. Pass affili
Slide 19: A $408,000 wage dispute became a 12-day strike
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting A $408,000 wage dispute became a 12 - day holiday strike at Vail's largest U.S. resort Cost of the patrollers' $2/hr ask ~$408K / yr 204 patrollers × $2 × ~1,000 hours Strike at Park City, Dec 27, 2024 – Jan 8, 2025 12 da
Slide 20: Vail in 2026 looks like Blockbuster in 2005
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Vail in 2026 looks like Blockbuster in 2005 20
Slide 21: Board accountability: why Peter Vaughn's seat
02 Board accountability: why Peter Vaughn's seat The director whose stated expertise matches Vail's weakest areas
Slide 22: Vaughn oversees the areas where performance has deteriorated
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Vail's own proxy identifies Mr. Vaughn as the director responsible for overseeing the very areas where performance has deteriorated Vail's own description of Peter A. Vaughn "His deep expertise in brand management and eng
Slide 23: Thirteen years on the board, no open-market share purchases
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Thirteen years on the board, key oversight roles, and no open - market share purchases 13 years Director since 2013; has served throughout under Chairperson Katz N&G Chair Chairs Nominating & Governance since Dec 2024; th
Slide 24: Nominating chair left a shareholder's outreach unanswered
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Governance/Communication Concern: As Nominating chair, Mr. Vaughn left a shareholder's outreach unanswered The record • 9/3/26: Meyer messages Mr. Vaughn on LinkedIn about the open seat, one day after Vail announced its d
Slide 25: International expansion: Swiss acquisitions at rich multiples
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting International expansion: Swiss acquisitions at rich multiples, results still undisclosed The issue • Controlling stakes in Andermatt - Sedrun (2022) and Crans - Montana (2024), approved while Mr. Vaughn served on the boar
Slide 26: Marketing has erased each mountain's distinct character
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Marketing has erased the distinct character of each mountain What should happen • Standardize the back end: systems, purchasing, data • Keep the guest - facing identity of each mountain distinct: Stowe should not feel lik
Slide 27: Why Gregory S. Meyer
03 Why Gregory S. Meyer An independent guest, experienced operator and financial professional with his own capital at stake
Slide 28: Meyer sought to engage and offered to settle
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Meyer sought to engage before nominating and offered to settle; the Vail board declined Sept 2 Vail announces a search for a new independent director Sept 3 Meyer writes to N&G Chair Vaughn; no reply Sept 10 Meyer deliver
Slide 29: Meyer adds skills the Vaughn seat lacks
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Meyer adds skills the Vaughn seat lacks Skills Meyer adds • Deep operating experience in leisure businesses with fixed capacity and variable demand • Fixed - income and capital - markets expertise, ahead of the FY2030 mat
Slide 30: Meyer vs. Oasis Nominees
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Meyer vs. Oasis Nominees 30 Skills and experience Meyer brings that neither Robert A. Chapek nor M. Ashton Hudson has Skill / experience Gregory S. Meyer Robert A. Chapek M. Ashton Hudson Fixed - income and debt capital m
Slide 31: Skin in the game: Meyer's open-market purchases
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Skin in the game: Meyer bought 13x more stock in the market than all independent directors combined in ten years 31
Slide 32: Meyer knows Vail's mountains as a guest
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Meyer knows Vail's mountains as a guest: 3.77 million vertical feet and 3,097 lift rides 32
Slide 33: Meyer's financial, operating and governance credentials
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Meyer has the financial, operating and governance credentials for a balance sheet under pressure Capital markets • Fixed income trading, Lehman Brothers (1995 – 2000) • Capital markets associate, Merrill Lynch (1994 – 95)
Slide 34: Demand outruns fixed capacity
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting A rainy Saturday with new hits and a holiday powder day are the same problem: demand outruns fixed capacity Same structure: capacity is set in advance and can't flex, while weather and the calendar decide demand. Meyer sp
Slide 35: Keep the strategy. Fix the execution.
04 Keep the strategy. Fix the execution. Constructive, non - disruptive, commercially practical ideas
Slide 36: We support the strategy; the problem is execution
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting We support the strategy; the problem is execution Keep • The owner - operator model • The Epic Pass ecosystem • Investment in the guest experience Fix • Drive growth from the core assets: yield, throughput, ancillary reve
Slide 37: Add a digital moat to Vail's physical one
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Add a digital moat to Vail's physical one The app is only scratching the surface • Order food from the chairlift • Connect skiers of similar ability • Report maintenance issues in real time (SeeClickFix - style) • Leaderb
Slide 38: Pricing for a K-shaped economy
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Pricing for a K - shaped economy: premium yield at the top, accessible entry at the bottom 38
Slide 39: Automated retail can grow ancillary revenue
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Proven automated retail can grow ancillary revenue and shorten dining queues 1 Cashierless coolers and food lanes Guests scan an Epic Pass or card, take what they want and go 2 AI, weight sensors and cameras Determine wha
Slide 40: Smart lockers can take labor out of ski rental
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Smart lockers can take labor out of ski rental and speed up pickup Automating last - mile gear pickup and drop - off • Labor, both overhead and variable, is the largest share of rental cost in Vail's own breakdown of gear
Slide 41: Strategy map: every team member should know where they fit
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Strategy map: every Vail team member should know where they fit 41 Strategy map proposed by Gregory S. Meyer (balanced scorecard framework). Arrows show cause and effect: each layer drives the on e above it. Measures in i
Slide 42: Vote the GOLD card FOR Gregory S. Meyer
Vote the GOLD card FOR Gregory S. Meyer and WITHHOLD on Peter A. Vaughn One seat. Independent oversight of execution, the brand and the balance sheet. https://icomproxy.com/mtn/ | Materials free of charge at www.sec.gov
Slide 43: Appendix
A Appendix Supporting charts, full biography and sources
Slide 44: Peer group total returns, 1 year: FactSet detail
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group total returns, 1 year: FactSet detail 44 Total return with dividends reinvested, through June 17, 2026, the last trading day before press reports that Oasis was consi der ing a proxy contest. Peer group as defi
Slide 45: Peer group total returns, 3 years: FactSet detail
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group total returns, 3 years: FactSet detail 45 Total return with dividends reinvested, through June 17, 2026, the last trading day before press reports that Oasis was consi der ing a proxy contest. Peer group as def
Slide 46: Peer group total returns, 5 years: FactSet detail
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Peer Group total returns, 5 years: FactSet detail 46 Total return with dividends reinvested, through June 17, 2026, the last trading day before press reports that Oasis was consi der ing a proxy contest. Peer group as def
Slide 47: Return on invested capital fell ~36%
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Return on invested capital fell ~36%, FY2022 – FY2026 47
Slide 48: Return on assets fell ~48%
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Return on assets fell ~48%, FY2022 – FY2026 48
Slide 49: Free cash flow margin fell 11.8 points
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Free cash flow margin fell 11.8 points, FY2022 – FY2026 49
Slide 50: Operating margin fell 9.0 points
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Operating margin fell 9.0 points, FY2022 – FY2026 50
Slide 51: Gregory S. Meyer: experience
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Gregory S. Meyer: experience Detail Role Years Private investment fund President, Tribeca Capital Management LLC 2019 – present Automated retail; 1,000+ locations in 45 states CEO and Director, Xpress Retail LLC 2011 – 20
Slide 52: Sources
Gregory S. Meyer, CFA | Presentation to ISS | Vail Resorts 2026 Annual Meeting Sources • Vail Resorts, Inc.: Forms 10 - K FY2022 – FY2026; quarterly earnings releases; 2026 preliminary and definitive proxy statements; For m 8 - K dated Oct 16, 2026 • Gregory S. Meyer: preliminary proxy statement fil