April 22, 2021
Translation Purpose Only
For Immediate Release
REIT Issuer
Starts Proceed Investment Corporation
3-1-8 Nihonbashi, Chuo-ku, Tokyo
Kazuya Hiraide, Executive Director
(Security Code: 8979)
Asset Management Company
Starts Asset Management Co., Ltd.
Kazuya Hiraide, Representative Director
Inquiries: Hideki Hamaguchi, General Manager of
Financial Control and Administration Division
TEL. +81-3-6202-0856
Notice Concerning Disposition and Acquisition of Trust Beneficiary Interest in Domestic Real Estate
Starts Proceed Investment Corporation ("Starts Proceed") announces that Starts Asset Management Co., Ltd., to which Starts Proceed entrusts the management of its assets (the "Asset Management Company"), today decided to conduct disposition and acquisition of trust beneficiary interest in domestic real estate (respectively the "Disposition" and the "Acquisition," and collectively the "Transaction"). The details are as follows.
Since the counterparty of the Transaction is an interested party, etc. as defined in the Act on Investment Trusts and Investment Corporations (Act No.198, 1951, as amended (the "Investment Trusts Act")), the Asset Management Company, pursuant to its internal rules, has obtained consent from Starts Proceed to proceed with the transaction based on approval from the board of directors' meeting of Starts Proceed held today.
1. Overview of the Transaction
(1) Assets to Be Disposed Through the Disposition (the "Assets to Be Disposed")
Planned | Amount of | ||||||||||||||||||||
Planned | Planned | Assumed | difference between | ||||||||||||||||||
disposition | |||||||||||||||||||||
Property | contract | disposition | book value | planned disposition | |||||||||||||||||
Property name | Buyer | price | |||||||||||||||||||
No. | conclusion | date | (thousand yen) | price and assumed | |||||||||||||||||
(thousand yen) | |||||||||||||||||||||
date | (Note 1) | (Note 3) | book value | ||||||||||||||||||
(Note 2) | |||||||||||||||||||||
(thousand yen) | |||||||||||||||||||||
C-21 | Proceed Yachiyo | Starts Development | 415,000 | 389,703 | 25,297 | ||||||||||||||||
Midorigaoka I | April 26, | April 26, | |||||||||||||||||||
Corporation | |||||||||||||||||||||
Proceed Yachiyo | 2021 | 2021 | |||||||||||||||||||
C-22 | (Note 4) | 370,500 | 347,257 | 23,243 | |||||||||||||||||
Midorigaoka II | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total | 785,500 | 736,960 | 48,540 |
(Note 1) The settlement method for both properties is scheduled to be settlement of the entire amount on the planned disposition date.
(Note 2) "Planned disposition price" does not include miscellaneous disposition-related expenses, fixed property taxes, city planning taxes, consumption taxes and local consumption taxes.
(Note 3) "Assumed book value" is the book value assumed as of the planned disposition date.
(Note 4) Starts Development Corporation is an interested party, etc. of the Asset Management Company as defined in the Investment Trusts Act. For details, please refer to "5. Overview of Counterparty of the Transaction" below.
1
(2) Asset to Be Acquired Through the Acquisition (the "Asset to Be Acquired")
Planned | |||||||||||||
Property | Property name | Seller | Planned contract | Planned acquisition date | acquisition price | ||||||||
No. | conclusion date | (Note 1) | (thousand yen) | ||||||||||
(Note 2) | |||||||||||||
C-85 | Proceed Nagareyama | Starts Corporation | April 27, 2021 | April 27, 2021 | 1,069,000 | ||||||||
Otakanomori (Note 3) | Inc. (Note 4) |
(Note 1) The settlement method is scheduled to be settlement of the entire amount on the planned acquisition date. The acquisition financing is scheduled to be the funds from the disposition of the Assets to Be Disposed and cash on hand.
(Note 2) "Planned acquisition price" does not include miscellaneous acquisition related expenses, fixed property taxes, city planning taxes, consumption taxes and local consumption taxes.
(Note 3) Although a trust has not been established as of today, it is planned to be established before the Acquisition upon the acquisition by Starts Proceed.
(Note 4) Starts Corporation Inc. is an interested party, etc. of the Asset Management Company as defined in the Investment Trusts Act. For details, please refer to "5. Overview of Counterparty of the Transaction" below.
2
-
Reason for the Transaction
Starts Proceed is promoting an asset replacement strategy to enhance the competitiveness of the portfolio. It conducted a careful examination of its portfolio in terms of management status over the medium to long term as well as individual property characteristics, etc. based on such strategy. As a result, Starts Proceed decided on the Disposition of the Assets to Be Disposed upon comprehensively considering the market trends and the competitiveness of the Assets to Be Disposed as well as the acquisition of the Asset to Be Acquired as an asset replacing the Assets to Be Disposed.
As the properties are 24 years old, the disposition of the Assets to Be Disposed was judged to be ideal at this point in time upon comprehensively taking into account the impacts to NOI caused by maintenance overhead including daily repair work.
In addition, the decision was made to acquire the Asset to Be Acquired based on the asset management targets and policies provided in the Articles of Incorporation of Starts Proceed on the judgment that it is an asset featuring a combination of younger property age, profitability, growth potential and stability as outlined in "3. Description of the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired (2) Description of the Asset to Be Acquired Area/Property characteristics" below. - Description of the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired
- Description of the Assets to Be Disposed C-21: Proceed Yachiyo Midorigaoka I
Overview of specified asset | Overview of leasing (as of March 31, 2021) | ||||
Type of specified asset | Trust beneficiary interest | Total number of tenants | 1 | ||
Use | Rental housing | Number of leased units | 27 (27) | ||
Planned disposition price | 415,000 thousand yen | (Total number of leasable units) | |||
2-9 Midorigaoka, | Number of leased parking units | ||||
Location (Address) | (Total number of leasable parking | 31 (32) | |||
Yachiyo-shi, Chiba | |||||
units) | |||||
PM Company / ML Company | Starts Amenity Corporation | Leased floor area | 1,805.76 m2 | ||
Master lease type | Pass-through | Total leasable floor area | 1,805.76 m2 | ||
Trustee | Resona Bank, Limited | Annual rent revenue | 29,912 thousand yen | ||
Period of trust agreement | From: May 2, 2006 | Security and guarantee deposits, etc. | 2,608 thousand yen | ||
To: April 30, 2026 | Occupancy rate | 100.0% | |||
Ownership form | Proprietorship | Overview of appraisal report | |||
Site area | 2,378.67 m2 | Appraiser | Asset Research Inc. | ||
Zoning | Category 1 low-rise | Date of appraisal | October 31, 2020 | ||
Land | exclusive residential district | ||||
Building-to-land | 60% | Appraisal value | 386,000 thousand yen | ||
ratio | |||||
Floor-area ratio | 100% | Overview of building condition evaluation report | |||
Ownership form | Proprietorship | Evaluation company | Japan Constructive | ||
Inspect Association | |||||
Structure | Reinforced concrete | Date of evaluation | October 2018 | ||
structure with flat roof / 3F | |||||
Building | |||||
Construction | February 12, 1997 | Building replacement value | 348,500 thousand yen | ||
completion date | |||||
Total floor area | 1,854.26 m2 | Long-term repair costs (12 years) | 10,362 thousand yen | ||
Use | Apartment complex | PML (Date of evaluation: November 2020) | 6.9% |
Collateral
None
Special notations / Status of the property
(structure and other matters that have significant impact on the price of the investment property)
1. The original building-to-land ratio of the property is 50%. However, due to mitigation measures regarding corner lots, it is set at 60%.
Remarks
10-minute walk from Yachiyo-Midorigaoka Station on the Toyo Rapid Railway Line
3
C-22: Proceed Yachiyo Midorigaoka II
Overview of specified asset | Overview of leasing (as of March 31, 2021) | ||||
Type of specified asset | Trust beneficiary interest | Total number of tenants | 1 | ||
Use | Rental housing | Number of leased units | 23 (24) | ||
Planned disposition price | 370,500 thousand yen | (Total number of leasable units) | |||
2-8-2 Midorigaoka, | Number of leased parking units | ||||
Location (Address) | (Total number of leasable parking | 27 (31) | |||
Yachiyo-shi, Chiba | |||||
units) | |||||
PM Company / ML Company | Starts Amenity Corporation | Leased floor area | 1,538.24 m2 | ||
Master lease type | Pass-through | Total leasable floor area | 1,605.12 m2 | ||
Trustee | Resona Bank, Limited | Annual rent revenue | 25,596 thousand yen | ||
Period of trust agreement | From: May 2, 2006 | Security and guarantee deposits, etc. | 2,638 thousand yen | ||
To: April 30, 2026 | Occupancy rate | 95.8% | |||
Ownership form | Proprietorship | Overview of appraisal report | |||
Site area | 2,328.81 m2 | Appraiser | Asset Research Inc. | ||
Zoning | Category 1 low-rise exclusive | Date of appraisal | October 31, 2020 | ||
Land | residential district | ||||
Building-to-land | 60% | Appraisal value | 348,000 thousand yen | ||
ratio | |||||
Floor-area ratio | 100% | Overview of building condition evaluation report | |||
Ownership form | Proprietorship | Evaluation company | Japan Constructive | ||
Inspect Association | |||||
Structure | Reinforced concrete | Date of evaluation | October 2018 | ||
structure with flat roof / 3F | |||||
Building | |||||
Construction | February 12, 1997 | Building replacement value | 309,020 thousand yen | ||
completion date | |||||
Total floor area | 1,655.29 m2 | Long-term repair costs (12 years) | 8,782 thousand yen | ||
Use | Apartment complex | PML (Date of evaluation: November 2020) | 6.9% |
Collateral
None
Special notations / Status of the property
(structure and other matters that have significant impact on the price of the investment property)
1. The original building-to-land ratio of the property is 50%. However, due to mitigation measures regarding corner lots, it is set at 60%.
Remarks
10-minute walk from Yachiyo-Midorigaoka Station on the Toyo Rapid Railway Line
4
(2) Description of the Asset to Be Acquired
C-85: Proceed Nagareyama Otakanomori
Overview of specified asset | Overview of leasing (as of March 31, 2021) | ||||
Type of specified asset | Trust beneficiary interest | Total number of tenants | 1 | ||
Use | Rental housing | Number of leased units | 50 (50) | ||
Planned acquisition price | 1,069,000 thousand yen | (Total number of leasable units) | |||
1-2-3 Otakanomorikita, | Number of leased parking units | ||||
Location (Address) | (Total number of leasable parking | 0 (0) | |||
Nagareyama-shi, Chiba | |||||
units) | |||||
PM Company / ML Company | Starts Amenity Corporation | Leased floor area | 1,730.96 m2 | ||
Master lease type | Pass-through | Total leasable floor area | 1,730.96 m2 | ||
Trustee | Starts Trust Co., Ltd. | Annual rent revenue | 64,397 thousand yen | ||
Period of trust agreement | From: April 27, 2021 | Security and guarantee deposits, etc. | 13,032 thousand yen | ||
To: April 30, 2051 | Occupancy rate | 100.0% | |||
Ownership form | Proprietorship | Overview of appraisal report | |||
(co-ownership) | |||||
Site area | 4,200.00 m2 | Appraiser | Chuo Real Estate | ||
Appraisal Co., Ltd. | |||||
Land | |||||
Zoning | Commercial district | Date of appraisal | March 1, 2021 | ||
Building-to-land | 100% | Appraisal value | 1,100,000 thousand yen | ||
ratio | |||||
Floor-area ratio | 400% | Overview of building condition evaluation report | |||
Ownership form | Sectional ownership | Evaluation company | Tokio Marine & Nichido | ||
Risk Consulting Co., Ltd. | |||||
Structure | Reinforced concrete | Date of evaluation | March 2021 | ||
structure with flat roof / 14F | |||||
Construction | February 4, 2020 | Building replacement value | 559,462 thousand yen | ||
completion date | |||||
Total floor area | 1,641.62 m2 | Long-term repair costs (12 years) | 5,671 thousand yen | ||
Building Use | Apartment complex and | PML (Date of evaluation: March 2021) | 0.1% | ||
retail | |||||
Building designer | Nikken Housing System | ||||
Ltd. | |||||
Starts Construction and | |||||
Constructor | Asset Management Co., | ||||
Ltd. |
Building inspector | The Building Center of |
Japan | |
Collateral | |
None | |
Special notations / Status of the property | |
(structure and other matters that have significant impactm on the price of the investment property) |
1. The building-to-land ratio of the property is essentially 80% as it stands in a commercial district. However, due to the mitigation measures for fireproof buildings in fire-prevention districts and mitigation measures for corner lots, it is set at 100%.
2. Site area indicates the area of the entire site, and the percentage of co-ownership interest (right of site) in proprietorship is 173,186/1,616,791.
Remarks
2-minute walk from Nagareyama-Otakanomori Station on the Tsukuba Express Line and Tobu Urban Park Line
Area/Property characteristics
The Nagareyama Otakanomori area where the Asset to Be Acquired is located is approximately 25 minutes from Akihabara Station via the Tsukuba Express rapid train and offers direct access to the stations of Kashiwa, Funabashi, and Omiya via the Tobu Urban Park Line. In addition, the area has become livelier and more convenient with the development of shopping centers and hotels after large-scale land readjustment projects were completed around the station, and further concentration of residential and commercial facilities can be expected in the area as development of large apartments is also in progress. The Asset to Be Acquired is directly connected to the station via a pedestrian deck and is installed with bathroom dehumidifiers and bidet toilets. It also offers free Wi-Fi, and plans for the property were made to enable users to live with comfort and convenience.
5
[Explanation]
- "Type of specified asset" indicates the type as a specified asset, such as trust beneficiary interests, real estate, etc. "Use" is indicated in accordance with the stated categories in "Part I. Fund Information, Item 1. Situation of the Fund, 2. Investment Policies, (1) Investment Policies, 3) Portfolio Construction Policies" set out in the Securities Report.
- "Planned disposition price" and "Planned acquisition price" indicate the amount (transaction price stated in the trust beneficiary interest transaction agreement, etc.) excluding the various expenses (real estate transaction brokerage fee, etc.) required for the disposition and acquisition of the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired.
- "PM Company / ML Company" indicates the property management company that has concluded a property management agreement and the master lease company that has concluded a master lease agreement, agreements that are effective as of today for each property, or indicates the property management company that is scheduled to conclude a property management agreement and the master lease company that is scheduled to conclude a master lease agreement at the time of acquisition by Starts Proceed. For "Master lease type," "Pass-through" is indicated for a master lease in which the trustee and the master lease company has agreed that the master lease company pays the same amount as the rent stated in the sublease agreement concluded between the master lease company and the end tenant to the trustee.
- "Trustee" indicates the trustee or planned trustee at the time of disposition or acquisition by Starts Proceed. As to "Period of trust agreement," the starting date is the effective date of the trust agreement that is effective as of today (for trust agreement that is scheduled to be concluded, the scheduled effective date is indicated), and the ending date is the termination date of the trust agreement that is scheduled to be agreed (including agreement for amendments) between the parties of the trust agreement on the same date as acquisition by Starts Proceed.
- Concerning the description of "Land" and "Building"
- "Site area," "Structure," "Construction completion date" and "Total floor area" are in accordance with information described in the certificate of entry in real estate registration. For properties that have annex buildings, the annex buildings are not included in "Total floor area." However, it may be different if the description has been found incorrect as a result of investigation.
- "Zoning" indicates the type of zoning district classified in accordance with Article 8, Paragraph 1, Item 1 of the City Planning Act (Act No. 100 of 1968, as amended).
- "Building-to-landratio" is the ratio of the building area of the building to the site area as stipulated in Article 53 of the Building Standards Act (Act No. 201 of 1950, as amended; the "Building Standards Act") and indicates the maximum figures stipulated in the city plan in accordance with the zoning, etc. Pursuant to Article 53, Paragraph 3 or Paragraph 5 of the Building Standards Act, corner lots in a block and fireproof buildings, etc. in fire prevention districts may be subject to mitigation of building-to-land ratio or may not be subject to building-to-land ratio restriction itself. There are cases in which separate restrictions, mitigations, etc. may apply in accordance with the Building Standards Act or other administrative laws and regulations. In such cases, figures after application of such restrictions, mitigations, etc. are indicated.
- "Floor-arearatio" is the ratio of the total floor area of the building to the site area as stipulated in Article 52 of the Building Standards Act and indicates the maximum figures stipulated in the city plan in accordance with the zoning, etc. Pursuant to Article 52, Paragraph 2 or Paragraph 9 of the Building Standards Act, restrictions due to frontage road width rules or mitigations due to specified road rules may apply in some cases. There are cases in which separate restrictions, mitigations, etc. may apply in accordance with the Building Standards Act or other administrative laws and regulations. In such cases, figures after application of such restrictions, mitigations, etc. are indicated.
- If more than one zoning exists for one property, pursuant to Article 53, Paragraph 2 or Article 52, Paragraph 7 of the Building Standards Act, "Building-to- land ratio" and "Floor-area ratio" indicate the weighted average figures in accordance with the size of area of each zoning that are on the design drawing / completion drawing, etc. from the time of construction.
- Companies contracted for building design, construction and inspection are listed by name of the companies at the time of design, construction and
inspection of the Asset to Be Acquired.
6. Concerning the description of "Overview of leasing"
- For all Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired, a master lease agreement with Starts Amenity Corporation as a lessee and a sublessor is concluded or scheduled to be concluded among Starts Proceed, the trustee and Starts Amenity Corporation at the time of disposition or acquisition by Starts Proceed. Thus "Total number of tenants" indicates the number with the master lease company as a tenant as of now or after the acquisition.
- "Number of leased units (Total number of leasable units)," "Leased floor area," "Total leasable floor area," "Annual rent revenue" and "Security and guarantee deposits, etc." are indicated in accordance with the same standards as the description of notes for the table illustrated in "Part I. Fund Information, Item 1. Situation of the Fund, 5. Management Status, (2) Investment Assets, 3) Other Major Investment Assets, (iv) Overview of Leasing Status, a. Overview of Leasing Status" set out in the Securities Report. "Number of leased parking units (Total number of leasable parking units)" is indicated in accordance with the same standards as the description of notes at the beginning of "Part I. Fund Information, Item 1. Situation of the Fund, 5. Management Status, (2) Investment Assets, 3) Other Major Investment Assets, (vi) Individual Overview of Real Estate in Trust for Acquired Assets" set out in the Securities Report.
- "Occupancy rate" is the ratio of leased floor area to each tenant to the total leasable floor area of each property and is rounded off to the first decimal place.
7. "Overview of appraisal report" describes the content indicated in the appraisal report prepared for the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired.
8. Concerning the description of "Overview of building condition evaluation report"
- Contents described in the building condition evaluation report and the seismic risk evaluation report that were prepared for the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired are provided.
- "Building replacement value" is the total amount of appropriate costs required assuming to reconstruct the subject building on the date of evaluation.
- "Long-termrepair costs" is the total amount of expected long-term repair costs (12 years) based on the building condition evaluation report.
- Figures of "PML" are the figures in the report prepared by Tokio Marine & Nichido Risk Consulting Co., Ltd. "PML" represents the probable maximum loss that the subject facility or group of facilities may suffer from an earthquake with a 10% probability of exceedance in 50 years (earthquake
corresponding to a 475-year return period) by expressing the amount of physical loss corresponding to a 90% non-exceedance probability in the event of such earthquake as a percentage of the building replacement value.
- "Collateral" describes the existence/non-existence of collateral as on the date of disposition and acquisition of the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired.
- Concerning the description of "Special notations / Status of the property (structure and other matters that have significant impact on the price of the investment property)"
- In principle, it describes (1) the rights of third parties other than the tenants housed in the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired and restrictions, etc. based on such rights, and (2) restrictions, etc. from administrative laws and regulations related to the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired, as of today. In case a specific description refers to fact situations as on the date of disposition and acquisition by Starts Proceed, description is made based on future prediction that is as rational as possible as of today.
- When the type of a specified asset that Starts Proceed is acquiring is trust beneficiary interest, description of "acquired by Starts Proceed" also refers to acquisition by Starts Proceed through trust beneficiary interest. In such cases, legal owner or right holder of the real estate that is the trust asset of the trust
beneficiary interest is the trustee, and Starts Proceed acquires the trust beneficiary interest.
11. "Area/Property characteristics" is based on the description on the appraisal report, market report, etc. prepared for the Asset to Be Acquired.
6
4. Overview of Appraisal Report of the Assets to Be Disposed and Asset to Be Acquired
(1) Overview of Appraisal Report of the Assets to Be Disposed
Property name | Proceed Yachiyo Midorigaoka I | ||||
Appraisal value | 386,000 thousand yen | ||||
Appraiser | Asset Research Inc. | ||||
Date of appraisal | October 31, 2020 | ||||
(Unit: thousand yen) | |||||
Item | Amount | Details | |||
Income approach value | 386,000 | Estimated by relating income approach value based on direct | |||
capitalization method and value based on DCF method | |||||
Value based on direct capitalization | 391,000 | Assessed by returning net income (NCF) that is stable over the medium to | |||
method | long term by capitalization rate | ||||
Operating revenue | 30,819 | - | |||
Assessed gross income that is stable over the medium to long term, taking | |||||
Effective gross income | 32,530 | into account rent based on the current lease agreement, new rent assumed | |||
when the property is newly leased, etc. | |||||
Assessed by taking into account the current lease agreement conditions | |||||
Vacancy loss, etc. | 1,711 | and setting an occupancy rate (vacancy rate) that is stable over the | |||
medium to long term | |||||
Operating expenses | 6,109 | - | |||
Maintenance expenses | 764 | Assessed based on current terms and conditions of the agreement, past | |||
results of the property and that of similar properties | |||||
Utility expenses | 408 | Assessed based on current terms and conditions of the agreement, past | |||
results of the property and that of similar properties | |||||
Repair expenses: Recorded 30% of the levelled amount of the estimate in | |||||
Repair expenses | 389 | the engineering report. Expenses to restore original state: Assessed taking | |||
into account the levels, actual results and turnover rates of similar | |||||
properties | |||||
PM fees | 894 | Assessed based on the current agreement, the level of similar properties, etc. | |||
Tenant solicitation expenses, | 741 | Assessed based on the current agreement | |||
etc. | |||||
Taxes and public dues | 2,821 | Assessed based on actual results considering fluctuation rate, age | |||
depreciation, etc. | |||||
Non-life insurance fees | 80 | Recorded actual amount based on non-life insurance policy, etc. | |||
Other expenses | 12 | Assessed based on past results | |||
Net operating income (NOI) | 24,710 | - | |||
Gain on management of | Assessed by multiplying the amount which is obtained by subtracting | ||||
income from lump-sum | 22 | vacancy loss equivalent from the amount of security deposit, etc. by yield | |||
payment | at 1.0% | ||||
Capital expenditures | 864 | Recorded the average of accumulated total amount of renewal expenses | |||
for facilities, etc. over the past 12 years stated in the engineering report | |||||
Net income (NCF) | 23,868 | ||||
Capitalization rate | 6.1% | Assessed by reflecting fluctuation risks of profit and principal, etc. into | |||
the discount rate | |||||
Value of earnings calculated by | 385,000 | - | |||
discounted cash flow (DCF) method | |||||
Assessed based on the basis yield comprehensively taking into account | |||||
Discount rate | 5.8% | market trends, etc. after considering risk factors of regional | |||
factors/individual characteristics of the property | |||||
Assessed based on capitalization rate taking into account future | |||||
Terminal capitalization rate | 6.2% | unpredictability of fluctuation in net income, future deterioration of | |||
buildings and sales risks | |||||
Cost method value | 648,000 | - | |||
Land ratio | 61.0% | - | |||
Building ratio | 39.0% | - | |||
Other items considered by real estate appraisal agent upon appraisal
Since demand for the property comes mostly from investors emphasizing profitability, appraisal value was determined based on income approach value using cost method value only as reference.
7
Property name | Proceed Yachiyo Midorigaoka II | ||||
Appraisal value | 348,000 thousand yen | ||||
Appraiser | Asset Research Inc. | ||||
Date of appraisal | October 31, 2020 | ||||
(Unit: thousand yen) | |||||
Item | Amount | Details | |||
Income approach value | 348,000 | Estimated by relating income approach value based on direct | |||
capitalization method and value based on DCF method | |||||
Value based on direct capitalization | 352,000 | Assessed by returning net income (NCF) that is stable over the medium to | |||
method | long term by capitalization rate | ||||
Operating revenue | 27,572 | - | |||
Assessed gross income that is stable over the medium to long term, taking | |||||
Effective gross income | 29,114 | into account rent based on the current lease agreement, new rent assumed | |||
when the property is newly leased, etc. | |||||
Assessed by taking into account the current lease agreement conditions | |||||
Vacancy loss, etc. | 1,542 | and setting an occupancy rate (vacancy rate) that is stable over the | |||
medium to long term | |||||
Operating expenses | 5,415 | - | |||
Maintenance expenses | 710 | Assessed based on current terms and conditions of the agreement, past | |||
results of the property and that of similar properties | |||||
Utility expenses | 228 | Assessed based on current terms and conditions of the agreement, past | |||
results of the property and that of similar properties | |||||
Repair expenses: Recorded 30% of the levelled amount of the estimate in | |||||
Repair expenses | 346 | the engineering report. Expenses to restore original state: Assessed taking | |||
into account the levels, actual results and turnover rates of similar | |||||
properties. | |||||
PM fees | 801 | Assessed based on the current agreement, the level of similar properties, | |||
etc. | |||||
Tenant solicitation expenses, | 659 | Assessed based on the current agreement | |||
etc. | |||||
Taxes and public dues | 2,588 | Assessed based on actual results considering fluctuation rate, age | |||
depreciation, etc. | |||||
Non-life insurance fees | 71 | Recorded actual amount based on non-life insurance policy, etc. | |||
Other expenses | 12 | Assessed based on past results | |||
Net operating income (NOI) | 22,157 | - | |||
Gain on management of | Assessed by multiplying the amount which is obtained by subtracting | ||||
income from lump-sum | 20 | vacancy loss equivalent from the amount of security deposit, etc. by yield | |||
payment | at 1.0% | ||||
Capital expenditures | 732 | Recorded the average of accumulated total amount of renewal expenses | |||
for facilities, etc. over the past 12 years stated in the engineering report | |||||
Net income (NCF) | 21,445 | ||||
Capitalization rate | 6.1% | Assessed by reflecting fluctuation risks of profit and principal, etc. into | |||
the discount rate | |||||
Value of earnings calculated by | 347,000 | - | |||
discounted cash flow (DCF) method | |||||
Assessed based on the basis yield comprehensively taking into account | |||||
Discount rate | 5.8% | market trends, etc. after considering risk factors of regional | |||
factors/individual characteristics of the property | |||||
Assessed based on capitalization rate taking into account future | |||||
Terminal capitalization rate | 6.2% | unpredictability of fluctuation in net income, future deterioration of | |||
buildings and sales risks | |||||
Cost method value | 607,000 | - | |||
Land ratio | 62.6% | - | |||
Building ratio | 37.4% | - |
Other items considered by real estate appraisal agent upon appraisal
Since demand for the property comes mostly from investors emphasizing profitability, appraisal value was determined based on income approach value using cost method value only as reference.
8
(2) Overview of Appraisal Report of the Asset to Be Acquired
Property name | Proceed Nagareyama Otakanomori | ||||
Appraisal value | 1,100,000 thousand yen | ||||
Appraiser | Chuo Real Estate Appraisal Co., Ltd. | ||||
Date of appraisal | March 1, 2021 | ||||
(Unit: thousand yen) | |||||
Item | Amount | Details | |||
Determined by emphasizing income approach value obtained through the | |||||
Income approach value | 1,100,000 | DCF method while also relating value based on direct capitalization | |||
method | |||||
Value based on direct capitalization | 1,100,000 | Assessed by returning net income (NCF) that is stable over the medium to | |||
method | long term by capitalization rate | ||||
Operating revenue | 64,559 | - | |||
Assessed gross income that is stable over the medium to long term, | |||||
Effective gross income | 66,397 | considering the building lease agreement, profitability of the property, | |||
etc. and taking into account new rent assumed when the property is newly | |||||
leased, etc. | |||||
Assessed after setting an occupancy rate (vacancy rate) that is stable over | |||||
Vacancy loss, etc. | 1,838 | the medium to long term, taking into account past occupancy results, etc. | |||
of the property and similar properties | |||||
Operating expenses | 17,206 | - | |||
Maintenance expenses | 0 | Not recorded as it is included in management expenses | |||
Utility expenses | 0 | Not recorded as it is included in management expenses | |||
Repair expenses | 1,064 | Assessed based on the engineering report, past results, etc. | |||
PM fees | 1,870 | Assessed based on the business entrustment agreement | |||
Tenant solicitation expenses, | 1,997 | Assessed based on the business entrustment agreement and past results | |||
etc. | |||||
Taxes and public dues | 5,423 | Assessed based on the most recent actual amount, etc. | |||
Non-life insurance fees | 118 | Recorded estimated amount | |||
Other expenses | 6,734 | Assessed based on past results | |||
Net operating income (NOI) | 47,353 | - | |||
Gain on management of | |||||
income from lump-sum | 93 | Assessed assuming management yield at 1.0% | |||
payment | |||||
Capital expenditures | 0 | Separate recording is judged to be unnecessary due to the recording of | |||
reserve fund for repairs | |||||
Net income (NCF) | 47,446 | - | |||
Assessed based on the basis yield comprehensively taking into account | |||||
Capitalization rate | 4.3% | transaction yield of similar properties within the same supply and demand | |||
zone, risks from individuality/regional factors of the property, etc. | |||||
Value of earnings calculated by | 1,100,000 | - | |||
discounted cash flow (DCF) method | |||||
Discount rate | 4.1% | Assessed based on capitalization rate reflecting current economic growth | |||
rate, market trends outlook, etc. | |||||
Assessed based on capitalization rate taking into account risk premiums | |||||
Terminal capitalization rate | 4.5% | such as price fall risk due to deterioration from aging, market fluctuation | |||
risk, etc. | |||||
Cost method value | 924,000 | - | |||
Land ratio | 34.5% | - | |||
Building ratio | 65.5% | - |
Other items considered by real estate appraisal agent upon appraisal
Since demand for the property comes mostly from investors emphasizing profitability, appraisal value was determined based on income approach value using cost method value only as reference.
9
5. Overview of Counterparty of the Transaction
(1) Overview of Buyer (as of March 31, 2020)
Name
Location
Representative
Main business activities
Capital
Established
Net assets
Total assets
Major shareholder and shareholding ratio
Relationship with Starts Proceed and the Asset Management Company
The company is a subsidiary whose shares issued and outstanding are wholly owned by Starts Corporation Inc., the parent company of the Asset Management Company. Accordingly, the company falls within the scope of an interested party, etc. as defined in the Investment Trusts Act.
There is no personnel relationship to report concerning Starts Proceed and the Asset Management
Company with the company.
The company has concluded a pipeline support agreement with the Asset Management Company and has been providing the Asset Management Company with property information, warehousing function, etc. Starts Proceed acquired three properties (3,093 million yen) from the company in the fiscal period ended October 2020.
The company does not fall within the scope of a related party of Starts Proceed. The company is a fellow subsidiary of the Asset Management Company under the same parent company as described above and thus falls within the scope of a related party of the Asset Management Company.
(2) Overview of Seller (as of March 31, 2020)
Name | Starts Corporation Inc. |
Location | 3-4-10 Nihonbashi, Chuo-ku, Tokyo |
Representative | Kazuo Isozaki, President |
Main business activities | Holding company of Starts Group |
Capital | 11,039 million yen |
Established | September 30, 1972 |
Net assets | 52,507 million yen |
Total assets | 145,581 million yen |
Major shareholder and | K.K. Toyosu (20.73%) |
shareholding ratio | Custody Bank of Japan, Ltd. (12.15%) |
Relationship with Starts Proceed and the Asset Management Company
The company is the parent company owning all shares issued and outstanding of the Asset Management Company. Accordingly, the company falls within the scope of an interested party, etc. as defined in the Investment Trusts Act.
A director of the company also serves as an auditor of the Asset Management Company.
The company has concluded a pipeline support agreement with the Asset Management Company and has been providing the Asset Management Company with property information, warehousing function, etc. The company falls within the scope of a related party of Starts Proceed. The company is the parent company of the Asset Management Company as described above and thus falls within the scope of a related party of the Asset Management Company.
6. Transaction with Interested Parties of the Transaction
Starts Development Corporation, the buyer of the Assets to Be Disposed, Starts Corporation Inc., the seller of the Asset to Be Acquired, Starts Amenity Corporation, to which master lease and property management after the acquisition of the Asset to Be Acquired are planned to be entrusted, Starts Pitat House Co., Ltd., to which leasing business of the property management is subcontracted, and Starts Trust Co., Ltd., to which trust services of the Asset to Be Acquired are planned to be entrusted, each fall within the scope of an interested party, etc. of the Asset Management Company as defined in the Investment Trusts Act. Accordingly, all transactions have been determined after following appropriate procedures based on the internal rules of the Asset Management Company and pursuant to standards stipulated by laws and regulations.
10
Overview of Planned Company Entrusted with Master Lease and Property Management (as of March 31, 2020)
Name | Starts Amenity Corporation |
Location | 8-4-3 Ichinoe, Edogawa-ku, Tokyo |
Representative | Manabu Nakamatsu, President |
Main business | Real estate management and operation, construction, interior finishing and other businesses |
activities | |
Capital | 350 million yen |
Established | April 1, 1985 |
The company is a subsidiary whose shares issued and outstanding are wholly owned by Starts | |
Corporation Inc., the parent company of the Asset Management Company. Accordingly, the company | |
falls within the scope of an interested party, etc. as defined in the Investment Trusts Act. | |
There is no personal relationship to report concerning Starts Proceed and the Asset Management | |
Relationship with | Company with the company. |
Starts Proceed and | The company is leasing all properties excluding one of the assets acquired in a lump based on the |
the Asset Management | master lease agreement. The company has concluded a pipeline support agreement with the Asset |
Company | Management Company and has been providing the Asset Management Company with property |
information, warehousing function and such. | |
The company does not fall within the scope of a related party of Starts Proceed. The company is a | |
fellow subsidiary of the Asset Management Company under the same parent company as described | |
above and thus falls within the scope of a related party of the Asset Management Company. |
Overview of Planned Company Entrusted with Trust Services (as of March 31, 2020)
Name | Starts Trust Co., Ltd. |
Location | 3-1-8 Nihonbashi, Chuo-ku, Tokyo |
Representative | Sadao Watanabe, President |
Main business | Trust services, purchase/sales of trust beneficiary interest in real estate, purchase/sales and leasing |
activities | agent and brokerage, etc. of real estate |
Capital | 300 million yen |
Established | September 3, 2009 |
The company is a subsidiary whose shares issued and outstanding are wholly owned by Starts | |
Corporation Inc., the parent company of the Asset Management Company. Accordingly, the company | |
Relationship with | falls within the scope of an interested party, etc. as defined in the Investment Trusts Act. |
Starts Proceed and | There is no personal relationship to report concerning Starts Proceed and the Asset Management |
the Asset Management | Company with the company. |
Company | The company does not fall within the scope of a related party of Starts Proceed. The company is a |
fellow subsidiary of the Asset Management Company under the same parent company as described | |
above and thus falls within the scope of a related party of the Asset Management Company. |
- Overview of Brokerage Not applicable.
- Status of Parties Related to the Acquisition of the Asset to Be Acquired
Property | Property | Current owner | Previous owner | |||||||
No. | name | |||||||||
(Land) | Other than one with a | |||||||||
Name | Starts Corporation Inc. | Name | relationship of special | |||||||
interest |
Proceed
C-85 Nagareyama
Otakanomori
Relationship | Please refer to "5. Overview of |
with related | Counterparty of the Transaction" |
parties | above |
Acquisition | Property developed by the current |
background and | |
owner | |
reason, etc. |
Acquisition price Omitted as the current owner's ownership exceeds one year
Acquisition | (Land) | February 1, | 2019 |
period | (Building) February 4, | 2020 | |
Relationship with related parties
Acquisition background and reason, etc.
Acquisition
price
Acquisition
period
-
-
-
-
11
9. Future Outlook
Because the impact on the management status for the fiscal period ending April 2021 (November 1, 2020 to April 30, 2021) and the fiscal period ending October 2021 (May 1, 2021 to October 31, 2021) announced on December 15, 2020 is minimal, there will be no revisions to the management status forecast.
[Attachment 1] Portfolio List After the Transaction
[Attachment 2] Photos and Map of the Asset to Be Acquired
- Distribution: Kabuto Club, Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism Press Club, and Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism Press Club for Construction Publications
- Starts Proceed website:https://www.sp-inv.co.jp/en/
12
[Attachment] Portfolio List After the Disposition
Acquisition price | ||||||||||||||
Property | Property name | Acquisition price | Investment | |||||||||||
share | ||||||||||||||
No. | ||||||||||||||
(thousand yen) | ||||||||||||||
(%) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 1) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 2) | ||||||||||||||
C-1 | Proceed Ichikawa | 1,076,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
C-2 | Proceed Toyocho | 646,700 | 0.7 | |||||||||||
C-3 | Proceed Kasai | 688,700 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-4 | Proceed Sangenjaya | 555,900 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-5 | Proceed Mizue | 602,600 | 0.7 | |||||||||||
C-6 | Proceed Funabashi Miyamoto | 419,900 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-7 | Proceed Minamikasai | 303,500 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-9 | Proceed Gyotoku | 315,600 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-10 | Proceed Makuharihongo | 279,300 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-11 | Proceed Minamigyotoku | 287,300 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-12 | Proceed Makuharihongo 2 | 223,400 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-14 | Proceed Funabori | 226,100 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-15 | Proceed Takenozuka | 169,400 | 0.2 | |||||||||||
C-16 | Proceed Sengendai 2 | 86,700 | 0.1 | |||||||||||
C-17 | Proceed Shoto | 937,400 | 1.1 | |||||||||||
C-18 | Proceed Sangubashi | 497,600 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-19 | Proceed Urayasu | 431,400 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-20 | Proceed Shinkoiwa | 465,200 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-23 | Proceed Toritsudaigaku | 790,400 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
C-24 | Proceed Toritsudaigaku 2 | 772,200 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
C-25 | Proceed Honjoazumabashi | 339,800 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-26 | Proceed Meguro Aobadai | 466,700 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-27 | Proceed Suginami Miyamae | 454,900 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-28 | Proceed Ryogoku | 443,900 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-29 | Proceed Mita | 1,537,200 | 1.7 | |||||||||||
C-30 | Proceed Nakanoshimbashi | 638,800 | 0.7 | |||||||||||
C-31 | Proceed Kameido | 339,000 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-32 | Proceed Takadanobaba | 223,700 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-33 | Proceed Shinkoenji | 742,100 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-34 | Proceed Koenjiminami | 277,400 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-35 | Proceed Hasune | 284,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-36 | Proceed Oimachi | 944,000 | 1.1 | |||||||||||
C-37 | Proceed Jujo | 533,000 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-38 | Proceed Hakuraku | 241,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-39 | Proceed Shinmaruko | 635,000 | 0.7 | |||||||||||
C-40 | Proceed Motoyawata | 307,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-41 | Proceed Nishiarai | 5,172,000 | 5.9 | |||||||||||
C-42 | Proceed Chofu | 460,500 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-43 | Proceed TX Rokucho | 156,800 | 0.2 | |||||||||||
C-44 | Proceed Nakagawara | 1,141,000 | 1.3 | |||||||||||
C-45 | Proceed Oizumigakuen | 268,300 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-46 | Proceed Chitosekarasuyama | 289,600 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-47 | Proceed Mitaka | 477,200 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-48 | Proceed Kashiwa Est | 732,000 | 0.8 |
13
Acquisition price | ||||||||||||||
Property | Property name | Acquisition price | Investment | |||||||||||
share | ||||||||||||||
No. | ||||||||||||||
(thousand yen) | ||||||||||||||
(%) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 1) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 2) | ||||||||||||||
C-49 | Proceed Kashiwa Nord | 689,000 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-50 | Proceed Gyotokuekimae | 331,000 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-51 | Proceed Funabashi Honcho | 531,700 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-52 | Proceed Nishikawaguchi | 881,000 | 1.0 | |||||||||||
C-53 | Proceed Gumyoji | 552,000 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-54 | Proceed Tsurugamine | 356,000 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-55 | Proceed Sagamiotsuka | 234,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-56 | Proceed Shinozaki 2 | 913,300 | 1.0 | |||||||||||
C-57 | Proceed Kashiwa Trois | 537,100 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-58 | Proceed Shinozaki Tower | 1,564,000 | 1.8 | |||||||||||
C-59 | Proceed Tobu Nerima | 422,000 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
C-60 | Proceed Yukigaya | 323,000 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-61 | Proceed Ichikawa Minami | 687,000 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-62 | Proceed Ichikawa Myoden | 498,000 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
C-63 | Proceed Fujisawa Kugenuma | 729,000 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-64 | Proceed Nihonbashi-horidomecho | 1,485,800 | 1.7 | |||||||||||
C-65 | Proceed TX Nagareyama Central Park | 979,700 | 1.1 | |||||||||||
C-66 | Proceed Gyotoku 2 | 830,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
C-67 | Proceed Nishikasai | 875,600 | 1.0 | |||||||||||
C-68 | Proceed Kasai 2 | 750,000 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
C-69 | Proceed Nihonbashi Honcho | 2,449,000 | 2.8 | |||||||||||
C-70 | Proceed Nishi Shinjuku | 2,549,000 | 2.9 | |||||||||||
C-71 | Proceed Unoki | 917,000 | 1.0 | |||||||||||
C-72 | Proceed Minamigyotoku 2 | 1,080,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
C-73 | Proceed CO-Z East Building | 1,830,000 | 2.1 | |||||||||||
C-74 | Proceed CO-Z West Building | 971,000 | 1.1 | |||||||||||
C-75 | Proceed Shin Yokohama | 4,330,000 | 4.9 | |||||||||||
C-76 | Life Support Residence Funaboriekimae | 380,000 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
C-77 | Proceed Kinshicho | 2,140,000 | 2.4 | |||||||||||
C-78 | Proceed K2 | 1,170,000 | 1.3 | |||||||||||
C-79 | Proceed K3 Annex | 283,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-80 | Proceed K5 | 269,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
C-81 | Proceed Ichikawa Myoden II | 800,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
C-82 | The Parkhabio Yokohama Yamate | 3,047,000 | 3.5 | |||||||||||
C-83 | Proceed Monzennakacho | 1,240,000 | 1.4 | |||||||||||
C-84 | Proceed Maihama | 1,029,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
C-85 | Proceed Nagareyama Otakanomori | 1,069,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
Tokyo metropolitan area major cites subtotal | 66,602,400 | 75.5 | ||||||||||||
G-8 | Proceed Taikodori | 403,400 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
G-11 | Proceed Honamicho | 275,000 | 0.3 | |||||||||||
G-13 | Proceed Shinsakae | 792,500 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
G-14 | Proceed Chiyoda | 309,300 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
G-15 | Proceed Fukuoka Takamiya | 453,600 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
G-17 | Proceed Kanayama | 1,022,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
G-18 | Proceed Fukiage | 499,000 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
G-19 | Proceed Toyota | 219,000 | 0.2 |
14
Acquisition price | ||||||||||||||
Property | Property name | Acquisition price | Investment | |||||||||||
share | ||||||||||||||
No. | ||||||||||||||
(thousand yen) | ||||||||||||||
(%) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 1) | ||||||||||||||
(Note 2) | ||||||||||||||
G-21 | Proceed Nishitenma | 880,000 | 1.0 | |||||||||||
G-22 | Proceed Kobemotomachi | 780,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
G-23 | Group Home Tanoshii Ie Taisho | 158,000 | 0.2 | |||||||||||
G-24 | Proceed Kanayama 2 | 2,040,400 | 2.3 | |||||||||||
G-25 | Proceed Aratamabashi | 2,129,600 | 2.4 | |||||||||||
G-26 | Proceed Bentencho | 2,170,000 | 2.5 | |||||||||||
G-27 | Proceed Nagaikoendori | 1,070,000 | 1.2 | |||||||||||
G-30 | Proceed Hyogoekimaedori | 1,670,000 | 1.9 | |||||||||||
G-31 | Proceed Mizuho | 535,000 | 0.6 | |||||||||||
G-32 | Proceed Osu | 831,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
G-33 | Proceed Sendai Kozurushinden | 698,000 | 0.8 | |||||||||||
G-34 | Proceed Sendai Kamisugi | 1,560,000 | 1.8 | |||||||||||
G-35 | Proceed Kanayama 3 | 770,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
Cabinet order designated cities subtotal | 19,265,800 | 21.8 | ||||||||||||
R-2 | Proceed Mito | 383,700 | 0.4 | |||||||||||
R-3 | Proceed Mito 2 | 416,900 | 0.5 | |||||||||||
R-4 | Proceed Tsukuba Gakuentoshi | 775,600 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
R-5 | Proceed Mito 3 | 824,000 | 0.9 | |||||||||||
Regional area major cities subtotal | 2,400,200 | 2.7 | ||||||||||||
Portfolio total | 88,268,400 | 100.0 |
(Note 1) "Acquisition price" under "Acquisition price" is the transaction price stated in the trust beneficiary interest transaction agreement, etc. (excluding the various expenses, such as real estate transaction brokerage fee, required for the acquisition of the assets acquired).
(Note 2) "Investment share" under "Acquisition price" is the ratio of acquisition price of the assets acquired or the Asset to Be Acquired to the total acquisition price, and is rounded off to the first decimal place.
15
[Attachment 2] Photos and Map of the Asset to Be Acquired (C-85) Proceed Nagareyama Otakanomori
Location (Address): 1-2-3 Otakanomorikita, Nagareyama-shi, Chiba
Proceed Nagareyama
Otakanomori
16
