Tennessee Valley Authority · NYSE:TVC
Tennessee Valley Authority — SETAC North America 31st Annual Meeting (November 2010)
32 slides from Tennessee Valley Authority's conference presentation, November 2010
Slide 1: Generating Meaningful Environmental Data in the Midst of an Emergency Response
Generating Meaningful Environmental Data in the Midst of an Emergency Response SETAC North America 31st Annual Meeting Portland, Oregon | November 2010 Presented by: Dennis Callaghan, Director of Information Technologies/Principal Environmental Standards, Inc. Co-authors: William J. Rogers Ph.D, Nei
Slide 2: Agenda
Agenda Client Background/ Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) Project Background/ Event Facts Environmental Standards’ Involvement Project Accomplishments Activities, Challenges, and Notes of Interest Conclusions 2
Slide 3: TVA Kingston Fossil Plant
TVA Kingston Fossil Plant Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) Kingston Fossil Plant 1.7-GW coal-burning power plant Bordered by three rivers – Emory, Clinch, Tennessee Harriman, TN Containment ponds June 2007 3
Slide 4: Project Background/Event Facts
Project Background/Event Facts December 22, 2008, shortly before 1 AM Ash dike of 84-acre containment pond ruptured 5.4 million cubic yards of fly ash into the Emory River 1.1 Billion Gallons Impacted over 300 December 23, 2008 acres 4
Slide 5: Challenges? Chaos
Challenges? Many challenges in the initial response but chief is Chaos 5
Slide 6: Incident Command
Incident Command TVA sample collection and environmental management in action within hours Sample collection begins with minimal documentation Regulatory agencies arrive Incident Command System (ICS) set up within days 6
Slide 7: Decision-Making
Decision-Making Rapid decision-making but still, chaos ensues “Who is in charge” in spite of ICS and team efforts Command hierarchy is not obvious at the bottom TVA environmental specialists rotate in on weekly basis but have substantial responsibilities elsewhere 7
Slide 8: Field Sample Collection
Field Sample Collection Few trained TVA field sample collectors Previous downsizing by TVA and elimination of Field Manual No Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) applicable to specific project collection activities Samplers still did a fair job on field custody records and some field logbooks No co
Slide 9: Data Management
Data Management TVA IT staff rotated members on-site to manage Scribe Access™ and implement data reasonableness rules It becomes obvious that assistance is needed (NOW!) and there were needs for longer term Planning Staffing Niche consulting expertise 9
Slide 10: Environmental Standards' Involvement
Environmental Standards’ Involvement Contracted January 21, 2009 - One month after event Provided Observations and concerns Global and specific recommendations Initiated immediate actions to assist 10
Slide 11: Immediate Observations
Immediate Observations Amazing effort from TVA personnel Sustainable? Plans - Lack of overall QA plan (high priority) DM tools and process Very manual TVA personnel need to return to pre-December 22 roles and have project structure put into place 11
Slide 12: Immediate Concerns
Immediate Concerns Concern about integrity and quality of data Initially lab data Need bulletproof, legally defensible data Sampling issues Laboratory issues Data issues Crisis management December 22, 2008 to ? 12
Slide 13: Global Recommendations
Global Recommendations Move away from Crisis to Project Management Overall program/process Sampling Point of Contact Chemistry Point of Contact Data Point of Contact Step back and reassess Roles and responsibilities Business process/supporting functionality Vendors/assist procurement 13
Slide 14: Specific Recommendations
Specific Recommendations Initial steps Develop overall QA Plan document Transition from existing business process – day 1 forward Insert quality system, oversight for lab services Real time data assessment of current data Assume sampling oversight and training Implement data management process Asses
Slide 15: Immediate Actions: Data Management
Immediate Actions: Data Management Implement a full cycle Data Management Process Implement an Enterprise Level Data Management System Automating to maximum extent Sample planning Correctness / completeness checking Automated data review - verification Data validation support Web Reporting (Self Ser
Slide 16: Immediate Actions: Quality Management
Immediate Actions: Quality Management Quality Assurance Plan - even though approval was months in coming Review/Add Laboratories Time, quality, cost – pick two Capable of electronic data deliverables 16
Slide 17: Immediate Actions: Laboratories
Immediate Actions: Laboratories Laboratory site visits EDD specifications in contract Data deliverables (Level I, Level IV) Helping engineers understand that the typical laboratory cannot provide 24-hour turn- around-time for extended periods 17
Slide 18: Immediate Actions: Field Oversight
Immediate Actions: Field Oversight Review Field Sampling Plans Sample crew training – an iterative process made more complex by rapid addition and removal of field crew It was easy to implement good field practices and adhere to draft SOPs as they were being developed based on previous practice and
Slide 19: Policy on Plans: Utility before Approval
Policy on Plans: Utility before Approval Developments were so rapid Forced to implement plans and procedures in draft form and then wait for: Later approval Or re-write of documents months later to determine final official copy Information to Support Analytical Requests could have been better 19
Slide 20: Accomplishments
Accomplishments Develop and support a business process that minimizes time from sample collection to release from “Never” to 6 business days (5 days at lab, 1 day at Environmental Standards), while ensuring that data were releasable. These checks include: Rapid reasonability check Completeness Corre
Slide 21: Activities & Challenges: Technical Tasks
Activities & Challenges Technical Tasks Prepare Technical Requirements and RFP for the Procurement of Laboratories Assess comparability of inter-laboratory data Establish a document management system Establish a Long Term Sample Retain Trailer Program Establish a Rugged Laboratory PE Program Support
Slide 22: Activities
Activities TVA collected data for many reasons – Community Outreach, Worker Safety, Spill Investigation, Characterization, and Delineation, Regulatory Compliance, Waste Characterization, and many special studies 310 Ash samples 1686 Biota samples (Amphibians, Birds, Fish, Mammals, Vegetation, etc.)
Slide 23: Interesting things along the way…
Interesting things along the way… Dry-weight versus wet-weight versus as received reporting Laboratories don’t always follow the published method or their own SOP…let me count the ways Lead contamination – weights used for surface water sampling points were sources of contamination Defensible (truly
Slide 24: Interesting things along the way…
Interesting things along the way… A number of different types of custody seals can be easily removed and reattached without it looking like sample were tampered with Using disposable in line 0.45 micron filters, although expensive, saves time, money and minimize the potential of contamination from e
Slide 25: Interesting things along the way…
Interesting things along the way… Catching snapping turtles is tricky business 25
Slide 26: Meaningful Information from Data
Meaningful Information from Data Three Golden Rules of Gathering Meaningful Information 1. Within most commercial laboratory settings, there is no difference between one sample and the next in terms of the levels of importance and care applied 2. Gathering truly important information requires attent
Slide 27: Conclusions
Conclusions Every Emergency Response starts off on the wrong foot…and behind in data reporting Emergency Response requires a different type of project planning and implementation – optimize for speed while appropriately adding control Labs and consultants that are nearest and dearest to the organiza
Slide 28: Conclusions (Cont.)
Conclusions (Cont.) Plans, Processes, and Partners Things to contemplate that should help Have “on the shelf” Quality Assurance Plan Data Management Plan Record Retention Plans Framework for SOPs Making it up on the fly during the emergency response is too hard. 28
Slide 29: Conclusions (Cont.)
Conclusions (Cont.) If that doesn't work….more things to contemplate that should help Difficult to staff an emergency response with internal personnel who already have jobs Have Relationships/Partners “on the shelf” as well Quality and Data Management Field Sampling Analytical Laboratories Data Inte
Slide 30: Conclusions (Cont.)
Conclusions (Cont.) One cannot do enough to reduce chaos! Until formal plans are in place, consider using an Analytical Request Form (ARF) in the early going! Easy to implement Collects information on Reason for sample / data collection What test / analytical sensitivities are desired Who receives r
Slide 31: Conclusions (Cont.)
Conclusions (Cont.) Why harp on Quality Assurance and Data Management? In the end all you have is data… 31
Slide 32: Contact
Contact “Setting the Standards for Innovative Environmental Solutions” Dennis P. Callaghan Environmental Standards, Inc. 1140 Valley Forge Road P.O. Box 810 Valley Forge, PA 19482 610.935.5577 solutions@envstd.com www.envstd.com 32
Tennessee Valley Authority — SETAC North America 31st Annual Meeting (November 2010) on 6ix