Walter Energy — Proxy Contest (March 2013)
38 slides from Walter Energy's proxy contest presentation, Mar 26, 2013
Slide 1: Working to Create Lasting Value at Walter Energy
Working to Create Lasting Value at Walter Energy March 2013 CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 2: Table of Contents
Table of Contents • Executive Summary • Change at the Board Level is Urgently Needed • Market Outlook and Opportunity • Path to Strategic, Financial and Operational Turnaround • Director Nominees • About Audley Capital • How to Vote for Needed Change 2 CONFIDENTIAL Note: financial data included in p
Slide 3: Executive Summary
Executive Summary • Walter Energy, a $1.9 billion market cap North American metallurgical coal miner, has seen its share price decline from $130 to $29.45* since July 2011 as operational and financial performance has deteriorated • We believe that poor corporate governance is the root cause of Walte
Slide 4: Change at the Board Level is Urgently Needed
Change at the Board Level is Urgently Needed CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 5: Share price timeline and key events
5 Source : Walter Energy press releases . 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Nov - 10 Mar - 11 Jun - 11 Sep - 11 Dec - 11 Mar - 12 Jun - 12 Sep - 12 Dec - 12 20 Feb 2013 : Walter announces Q4 2012 results: another bad earnings miss 19 Feb 2013: Audley announces proposed new board members for Walter 30 Ju
Slide 6: Underperformance of Walter Energy Compared to Peers and S&P 500
Underperformance of Walter Energy Compared to Peers and S&P 500 6 CONFIDENTIAL 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 01 - Apr - 2011 19 - Aug - 2011 06 - Jan - 2012 25 - May - 2012 12 - Oct - 2012 01 - Mar - 2013 S&P 500 Index US Coal Index Walter Energy
Slide 7: Continually Inaccurate Guidance and Underwhelming Earnings
Continually Inaccurate Guidance and Underwhelming Earnings • Walter Energy again missed consensus earnings estimates when it reported 4Q12 earnings on February 20, 2013 • Walter Energy has missed consensus earnings expectations for seven out of the last nine quarters • 1Q13 earnings guidance will al
Slide 8: Underlying Valuation of Walter Energy Needs to Improve
Underlying Valuation of Walter Energy Needs to Improve • Walter Energy’s Price/net present value ratio has fallen from a peak of over 1.6x during the first quarter of 2011 to the cur ren t 0.6x, vs. the 3 - year average of 0.97x • While this may be endemic in the industry over the last 12 months, Au
Slide 9: Unnecessary Debt Load and Outsized Net Debt / Equity Ratio
Unnecessary Debt Load and Outsized Net Debt / Equity Ratio • Walter Energy’s net debt/stockholders’ equity ratio is 228% - even before the new issuance of high yield debt just announced by the Company • Walter Energy’s peers’ net debt/stockholders’ equity ratios range from 47% to 144% • The majority
Slide 10: High CEO Turnover and a Stagnant Clique of Directors
High CEO Turnover and a Stagnant Clique of Directors • There have been four CEOs over the past five years: − September 2009: Victor P. Patrick appointed CEO − March 2010: Joseph Leonard appointed “interim” CEO; stays on for a full year − April 2011: Keith Calder appointed CEO − September 2011: Walte
Slide 11: Stockholder Input Has Been Ignored
Stockholder Input Has Been Ignored • In July 2011, when Walter Energy shares traded well above $100, Audley Capital sent a letter to the Board urging the Board to initiate a managed sale process to best address the Company’s range of issues and achieve fair value for stockholders • At the time, Audl
Slide 12: Opportunity and Market Outlook
Opportunity and Market Outlook CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 13: Current Share Price Does Not Reflect Value of Assets
Current Share Price Does Not Reflect Value of Assets • WLT quoted on the NYSE and the TSX with a current market cap of approximately $1.8 billion and net debt of $2.3 billion • Acquired Western Coal for C$3.1 billion in November 2010 • Operate eleven active coal mines, a coke plant and a coal bed me
Slide 14: Current Share Price Does Not Reflect Metallurgical Coal Market Recovery
Current Share Price Does Not Reflect Metallurgical Coal Market Recovery • Current share price implies no recovery in the met coal price over the next 4+ years from the current 1Q 2013 contract settle men t price of $165. Audley Capital believes this market view to be incorrect: − The metallurgical c
Slide 15: Trading at a Significant Discount to Net Present Value Based on Coal Price Recovery
Trading at a Significant Discount to Net Present Value Based on Coal Price Recovery Forecasts • We believe that there is a significant discount to fair value in Walter Energy’s stock and the current Board seems to struggl e t o deliver on a plan to fix this • Audley Capital’s proposal to improve the
Slide 16: Now is Not the Time for a Sale of Walter Energy!
Now is Not the Time for a Sale of Walter Energy! • Audley Capital believes there is substantial value in Walter Energy that is not reflected by the current share price • Audley Capital believes a sale should be reviewed as part of a series of strategic options when appropriate • NOW IS NOT THE TIME
Slide 17: Path to Strategic, Financial and Operational Turnaround
Path to Strategic, Financial and Operational Turnaround CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 18: Reduce Debt
Reduce Debt • Even before Walter Energy’s new issuance of high yield debt announced on March 22, 2013, the Company was overleveraged with $2.3 billion of debt , and a leverage ratio amongst the highest of its peers • We believe the Company’s debt is unsustainably high and debt reduction is a key sho
Slide 19: Reduce Cost of Debt
Reduce Cost of Debt • We believe that the high yield debt fundraising of $500 million with a 9.875% coupon in November 2012 was ill - timed, very poorly priced, and provided a rich bonus to debt investors at the expense of Walter Energy’s stockholders • The bonds have traded up to a price of $110 vs
Slide 20: Evaluate Alternative Financing Solutions
Evaluate Alternative Financing Solutions • Walter Energy’s latest quarterly results showed interest expense increasing from $30.5 million in third quarter 2012 to $49.6 mi llion in fourth quarter 2012, a 63% increase • When Walter Energy renegotiated debt covenants in the fourth quarter 2012 and iss
Slide 21: In-Depth Review of SG&A and Cost Control
In - Depth Review of SG&A and Cost Control • Based on Audley Capital’s analysis, SG&A costs at the Company are significantly higher than Walter Energy’s U.S. peer group* 21 CONFIDENTIAL Q4 2012 Walter Energy Alpha Natural Arch Coal Peabody ( US$m ) Resources SG&A / Sales 6.0% 3.2% 3.6% 3.3% SG&A / T
Slide 22: Evaluate Coal Marketing Arrangements
Evaluate Coal Marketing Arrangements • Walter Energy’s customers appear to be heavily dependent on the Atlantic Basin, with approximately 48% of sales to Europe Walter Energy 2012A Met Coal Sales by Region South America 15% North America 9% Europe 44% Asia 32% Source: Walter Energy Audley Capital’s
Slide 23: Improve Canadian Operations
Improve Canadian Operations • Given the limited reserve life and high cash cost nature of the Canadian operations, loss making mines should be placed on ca re and maintenance to conserve reserves for better coal markets • Given the limited reserves at Willow Creek, we recommend and agree that the mi
Slide 24: Solicit a Joint Venture Partner for Blue Creek
Solicit a Joint Venture Partner for Blue Creek • With appropriate funding , we understand the Blue Creek property could add between 2mtpa and 3mtpa of hard coking coal production • Analysts estimate the net present value of this project to be in the region of more than $500 million based on a $200/t
Slide 25: Reorganize Assets to Realize Significant Tax Savings
Reorganize Assets to Realize Significant Tax Savings • Walter Energy has substantial energy assets, the value of which, we believe, is not recognized by the market • We believe the Company’s natural gas assets, assuming they generate EBITDA of $20 million, could potentially be worth more than $100 m
Slide 26: Divest Underperforming and Non-Core Assets
Divest Underperforming and Non - Core Assets • We believe that underperforming assets with limited scope for earnings growth, as well non - core assets, should be divested or sp un - off in order to enhance value for Company stockholders • We believe that the result will be a company more focused on
Slide 27: Review All Reserves and Resources, and Upgrade Reserves
Review All Reserves and Resources, and Upgrade Reserves • We believe there are substantial additional reserves and resources of met coal at both the U.S. and Canadian operations that are not reflected in the current reserve and resource statements • Several mines have reserves of less than 20 years
Slide 28: Improve Stockholder Communication to Rebuild Investor Confidence
Improve Stockholder Communication to Rebuild Investor Confidence • We believe Walter Energy’s Board and management have failed to clearly articulate a strategic plan for the Company’s turnaround • We believe that the Board and management have demonstrated little interest in engaging in productive co
Slide 29: Board Nominees
Board Nominees CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 30: Walter Energy Needs New Board Members Who Are Committed to Improving the Company
Walter Energy Needs New Board Members Who Are Committed to Improving the Company 30 CONFIDENTIAL Eddie Scholtz , 59 Mr. Eddie Scholtz has over 40 years of experience in the mining industry, primarily in South America and Africa. During his career he spent 37 ye ars with BHP Billiton, where he held a
Slide 31: Walter Energy Needs New Board Members Who Are Committed to Improving the Company
Walter Energy Needs New Board Members Who Are Committed to Improving the Company 31 CONFIDENTIAL Lawrence Clark, Jr., 41 Mr. Larry Clark recently became President and Chief Executive Officer of JW Resources, Inc., a private operator of thermal coal assets in Central Appalachia, and serves as Managin
Slide 32: Independent, Experienced Board Nominees
Independent, Experienced Board Nominees 32 CONFIDENTIAL Board Nominee Mining Sector Experience Significant Public Company Board Experience Financial / Deal Expertise International Experience Eddie Scholtz • Over 40 years experience in the mining industry, of which 37 years with BHP Billiton • Former
Slide 33: Audley Capital Background Information
Audley Capital Background Information CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 34: Who is Audley Capital?
Who is Audley Capital? • Audley Capital Advisors LLP provides investment advice and services in connection with investment strategies including hedge funds, private equity funds and co - investment vehicles • The firm advises with respect to a series of products including: The Audley European Opport
Slide 35: Audley Capital's Familiarity with Walter Energy
Audley Capital’s Familiarity with Walter Energy • Audley Capital has had a longstanding knowledge of Walter Energy by way of the Western Coal transaction: • Mr. Treger was a non - executive director of Western Coal from December 2007 to September 2010 • Audley was involved in arranging C$30 million
Slide 36: Vote for Needed Change Today!
Vote for Needed Change Today! CONFIDENTIAL
Slide 37: Vote the GOLD Proxy Card to Implement Important Change
Vote the GOLD Proxy Card to Implement Important Change • Vote “For” Audley Capital’s slate of Five Highly - Qualified Director Nominees − They will b ring the needed experience and accountability to Walter Energy’s Board − Each nominee has extensive experience in the metallurgical coal industry on a
Slide 38: Legal Disclaimer
Legal Disclaimer This presentation is for general informational purposes only and is not intended for distribution to or use by any person or ent ity in any jurisdiction where distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation. The views expressed herein represent the o pinions of Audl