Portland General Electric Co · NYSE:POR

Portland General Electric — Technical Presentation (November 2016)

122 slides from Portland General Electric's technical presentation, Nov 16, 2016

  1. Slide 1: Integrated Resource Planning Round Table 16-4

    Integrated Resource Planning Round Table 16-4 November 16, 2016

  2. Slide 2: Meeting Logistics

    Meeting Logistics Local Participants:  World Trade Center facility  Wireless internet access  Sign-in sheets Virtual Participants:  Ask questions via ‘chat’ feature  Meeting will stay open during breaks, but will be muted  Electronic version of presentation: portlandgeneral.com/irp >> Integrat

  3. Slide 3: Safety Moment: Ladder Safety

    Safety Moment Check that the ladder is on secure and level ground. Ladder Safety Space the ladder 1 foot away from the wall for every 4 feet high it reaches. Stay centered between rails and do not overreach. For roof access, extend the ladder at least 3 feet above the roof. Keep the ladder clear of

  4. Slide 4: Today's Roundtable Topics

    Today’s Roundtable Topics 9:00a Start 9:00a Welcome / Safety Moment 9:15a 2016 IRP Process Overview 10:00a 2016 IRP Document 10:30a Break (15 minutes) 10:45a IRP Results 11:45a RFP 12:15p Lunch (30 minutes) 12:45p Market Discussion 1:15p Technology Discussion 1:45p Break (15 minutes) if needed 2:00p

  5. Slide 5: 2016 IRP Process Overview

    2016 IRP Process Overview Franco Albi

  6. Slide 6: Stakeholder Engagement

    Stakeholder Engagement PGE values your engagement 2016 IRP included robust information sharing and stakeholder input  Nine round tables (public meetings)  Two public meetings with the OPUC Commissioners  Responses to over 100 parking lot questions (from meetings) PGE’s mission Be a company our cu

  7. Slide 7: Continuing commitment to clean energy

    Continuing commitment to clean energy Current actions avoid ~1.8 million tons of CO2 per year, increasing to ~10.2 million avoided tons per year in 2040 • Leader in energy efficiency, demand response, smart grid, energy storage • PGE runs #1 renewable power program • Further reducing CO2 by upgradin

  8. Slide 8: Sustainability

    Sustainability People  Safety is a core principle  Investing in our communities Woven into the  Engaging with stakeholders fabric of PGE’s values are the sustainability pillars of People, Planet Planet, and  Increasing renewables  Reducing emissions Performance  Protecting wildlife habitat Per

  9. Slide 9: 2016 IRP Approach

    2016 IRP Approach Incorporate changing policy  Federal Clean Power Plan  Western Energy Imbalance Market Continuous  Oregon Clean Electricity Plan (SB 1547) improvement and evolution Commitment to rigorous analysis through the  Load Forecast methodology 2016 IRP  Resource Adequacy methodology 

  10. Slide 10: 2016 Integrated Resource Plan

    2016 Integrated Resource Plan Three integrated components to deliver sustainability Wind, Solar, Hydro, Biomass, Geothermal Energy Optimizing Capacity Management Cost-effective Energy Efficiency Increasing Renewable Demand Response Expansion Technology Integration 10

  11. Slide 11: Energy Management

    Energy Management PGE’s 2016 IRP targets greater Energy Energy Efficiency Efficiency and Demand Response 11

  12. Slide 12: Renewable Expansion

    Renewable Expansion PGE’s 2016 IRP recommends substantially exceeding 2020 RPS targets based on economics and risk reduction 12

  13. Slide 13: Technology Integration

    Technology Integration Biglow Canyon Wind Farm 450 MW PGE’s 2016 IRP 0 MW integrates technology to Flexible Capacity 4000 MW accelerate a PGE’s 2016 IRP Action Plan reliable,  add the right resources affordable  in the right quantity transition  at the right time 0 MW Energy Storage 50 MW - 50 MW

  14. Slide 14: Reducing CO2

    Reducing CO2 PGE’s 2016 IRP forecasts CO2 reductions consistent with SB 1547 estimates 14

  15. Slide 15: Executive Summary: Keys

    Executive Summary Load Need Keys 1. Energy Efficiency and Demand Response are foundational 2. Production Tax Credits can reduce costs to customers 3. Acquisition of flexible resources maintains reliability 4. Integrated portfolios perform relatively better 15

  16. Slide 16: 2016 IRP Document Overview

    2016 IRP Document Overview Franco Albi Elaine Hart

  17. Slide 17: Exploring the IRP – Downloading

    Exploring the IRP – Downloading www.portlandgeneral.com/irp SCROLL DOWN TO 2016 IRP 17

  18. Slide 18: Exploring the IRP – Structure

    Exploring the IRP – Structure 2 Volumes 13 Chapters 5 Parts 17 Appendices Volume I. Main Volume II. Appendices 0. Executive Summary A. Guideline Compliance 1. Planning History B. Order Compliance Planning I.C. Public ProcessHistory Agendas and 2. IRP Public Process D. Existing Resources IRP Process

  19. Slide 19: Exploring the IRP – Navigation

    Exploring the IRP – Navigation Search Side BarFunctionality Navigation (CTRL+F) 19

  20. Slide 20: Exploring the IRP – Chapter Navigation

    Exploring the IRP – Chapter Navigation 6.3.1Deman d Response PotentiaI A detailed discussion of PGE's current firm and non-firm DR programs is available in Appendix I. I Demand Response Programs.I 6 .3.1 Dema nd Response Potential As a result of the growing interest from stakeholders. other regional

  21. Slide 21: Exploring the IRP – Figure/Table Navigation

    Exploring the IRP – Figure/Table Navigation Figures Rgure 3·IO'Clmil tea~stea strearmows •••• ••• • •• • • ••••• ••• ••• • •••• •••••• • ••• • •••••• • • • • •••.• ••• ••• •• •••• •• • •••• 76 Agurw 3-n ormt11 ao,.,st9<1 PGE enGtgy r11QJvemcints • ••••••• • •••.••.•••••••••••••••.• • , •••••••• . •

  22. Slide 22: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O FIGURE 0-6: Portfolio 3 output summary Portfolio 3: Efficient Capacity 2021 MW• 3500 This portfolio is equivalent to Portfolio 2 - RPS Wind 2 018 . w ith a portion or the generic capacity in Energy Position (Reference case) 300 2021 replaced by a resource with higher f

  23. Slide 23: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O TABLE 0-4: Portfolio 3 cumulative resource additions, capacity (MW) Resource 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 ... 2025 ... 2030 ... 2035 ... 2040 Energy Effie ien cy 16 61 104 144 180 297 404 490 571 DSG 4 9 13 17 22 30 39 48 57 DR 26 29 31 69 77 162 187 198 198 CVR 0.4 0.9 1.

  24. Slide 24: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O FIGURE O-s: Portfolio 3 cumulative resource additions, capacity (MW) MW 6,000 5,000 4,000 - - • DSG + DR + CVR Energy Efficiency Biomass • Geothermal 3,000 Solar 2,000 - - - ~ MT Wind - • PNWWind 1,000 2017 - ---- 2018 - T 2019 1 2020 - -1 2021 2025 2030 2035 2040 Effi

  25. Slide 25: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O ;;ort and General '/ Electric FIGURE 0 -6: Portfo lio 3 output summary MWa 3500 Energy Position {Reference Case) 300 3000 281 _ M arket Position 518 • Biomass/Biagas 2500 277 ] • Geot hermal 2000 Sola r 1500 1000 - - • Wind • Hydro Natu ral Gas •Coal - - Energy Efficie

  26. Slide 26: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O Reliability hrs/yr 600 3.0 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 500 •••• • • • • 2.5 400 2.0 300 1. 1.5 200 1.0 100 0.5 0.0 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 . . . 2025 . . . 2030 . . . 2035 . . . 2040 EUE (MWh/yr) • Tai1Var90 Shortage (MW) • LOLE (hrs/yr) 26

  27. Slide 27: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O Cost 8 Reference Cost, $31.328 7 6 V) C1' ~ 5 ~ ~ ~ u.. 4 0 ~ C1' ~ 3 E ~ z 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "1' .. o .. o.. ..... l/) ~ o .. 0 00 .. .. o0 .. q 0 CJ) ~ o .. o .. o .. o .. o .. o .. o ... N CY> "1' l/)

  28. Slide 28: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O million tons C02 Carbon (Reference Case) 10.0 9.0 8.0 7.0 •• •• 6.0 •• •• •• •• 5.0 •• •• •• •• •• •• 4.0 •• •• 3.0 2.0 1.0 --------------------------- 0.0 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 . . . 2025 . . . 2030 . . . 2035 . . . 2040 - - - Avo ided Emissions Portfolio Emissions

  29. Slide 29: Exploring the IRP – Appendix O

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix O MWa RPS 2,000 RECs Generated ,,,,,. Unbundled REC purch. - 4 - • RPS Obligation 1,500 -- ~-;a- ,,,, -· -· 1,000 ,,- 500 .. _.. __ _·-·-- -~ -- 0 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 ••••••••••••• • •••••••••••••••• 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 ... 2025 . . . 2030 ... 2035 ... 2040 REC Bank

  30. Slide 30: IRP Results

    IRP Results Robert Brown

  31. Slide 31: Portfolio Analysis Findings – RPS timing

    Portfolio Analysis Findings – RPS timing Subset of portfolios RPS Wind 2018 (100% PTC) performance is robust across futures relative to delayed physical Cost relative to compliance lowest cost portfolio within subset of portfolios 31 31

  32. Slide 32: Portfolio Analysis Findings – Banked and Unbundled RECs

    Portfolio Analysis Findings – Banked and Unbundled RECs 100% PTC RPS procurement (Efficient Capacity 2021 portfolio) is lowest cost across futures relative to reliance on REC bank or reliance on unbundled RECs 32 32

  33. Slide 33: Portfolio Analysis Findings – RPS resource type

    Portfolio Analysis Findings – RPS resource type Modeled wind resources are lower cost than other renewable resource options 33 33

  34. Slide 34: Portfolio Analysis Findings – Diverse Wind

    Portfolio Analysis Findings – Diverse Wind Diverse Wind Wind 2018 2021 $ 31,652 $ 31,178 Benefit of Montana wind is robust across futures Findings suggest a transmission budget of approximately $65 per kW-year for a 42% capacity factor Montana wind resource 34

  35. Slide 35: Portfolio Analysis Findings – Efficient versus low capital cost capacity

    Portfolio Analysis Findings – Efficient versus low capital cost capacity RPS Wind 2018 Efficient Capacity 2021 $ 31,504 $ 31,319 Meeting remaining capacity needs with efficient capacity resources is lower cost than meeting capacity needs with low capital cost (lower efficiency) capacity resources ac

  36. Slide 36: Portfolio Scoring Metrics

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics PGE’s IRP seeks least cost, least risk portfolios. For each portfolio, PGE measures: Cost – 50 %  Expected portfolio cost Risk – 50%  Severity – the magnitude of most expensive outcomes  Variability – the distribution of expensive outcomes  Risk Durability – the likelih

  37. Slide 37: Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Cost

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Cost Cost Portfolio Value Score 1. Net Present Value of Revenue Requirement (NPVRR) Efficient Capacity 31,319 100 2021 Weight 50% RPS Wind 2018 31,504 92 Risk 2. Severity 3. Variability 4. Durability Across Futures Wind 2018 31,652 86 Weight 16.7% 16.7% 16.7% Wind 2018 +

  38. Slide 38: Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Severity

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Severity Cost Portfolio Value Score 1. Net Present Value of Revenue Requirement (NPVRR) Efficient Capacity 38,369 100 2021 Weight 50% Wind 2018 Long 38,492 94 Risk 2. Severity 3. Variability 4. Durability Across Futures RPS Wind 2018 38,509 93 Weight 16.7% 16.7% 16.7% Win

  39. Slide 39: Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Variability

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Variability Cost Portfolio Value Score 1. Net Present Value of Revenue Requirement (NPVRR) Wind 2018 Long 3,654 100 Weight 50% Wind 2018 + High EE 3,678 89 Risk 2. Severity 3. Variability 4. Durability Across Futures Efficient Capacity 3,720 70 2021 + High EE Weight 16.7%

  40. Slide 40: Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Durability Across Futures

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Durability Across Futures Cost Portfolio Value Score 1. Net Present Value of Revenue Requirement (NPVRR) RPS Wind 2018 100% 100 Weight 50% Efficient Capacity 100% 100 Risk 2021 2. Severity 3. Variability 4. Durability Across Futures Wind 2018 74% 87 Weight 16.7% 16.7% 16.

  41. Slide 41: Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Results

    Portfolio Scoring Metrics – Results Metric Weighting 50% 16.7% 16.7% 16.7% = 100% Draft Cost Severity Variability Durability Weighted Rank Rank Portfolio Name Score Score Score Score Score 1 1 Efficient Capacity 2021 100 100 0 100 83 3 2 Wind 2018 Long 77 94 100 63 81 2 3 RPS Wind 2018 92 93 7 100 8

  42. Slide 42: Composition of Top Four Portfolios

    Composition of Top Four Portfolios RPS 2018: 100% PTC wind (175 MWa), RPS Wind 2018: 100% PTC wind (175 MWa) + compliance, resource adequacy with generic 2021 wind (213 MWa), RPS compliance, capacity resource adequacy with generic capacity Efficient Capacity 2021: 100% PTC wind Wind 2018 Long: 100%

  43. Slide 43: Exploring the IRP – Appendix L

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix L L1 • NPVRR summary L2 • General Portfolio Conclusions • Comparison across L3 portfolios considered for the Action Plan • Comparison across L4 portfolios considered for the Renewable Portfolio Implementation Plan 43

  44. Slide 44: Exploring the IRP – Appendix L

    Exploring the IRP – Appendix L Figure 1-8: Relative NPVRR of portfolios considered for the Action Plan Subset of portfolios Cost relative to lowest cost portfolio within subset of portfolios 44

  45. Slide 45: RFP Development

    RFP Development Jimmy Lindsay

  46. Slide 46: PGE Goals

    PGE Goals 2016 IRP Action Plan  Demand-Side Actions − 176 MW of Energy Efficiency − 69-77 MW of Demand Response − CVR deployment  Supply-Side Actions − 175 MWa of renewable additions (equivalent to 515 MW of PNW wind) − 375-550 MW of dispatchable capacity − Up to 400 MW of annual capacity products

  47. Slide 47: Near Term Need for Independent Evaluator

    Near Term Need for Independent Evaluator  PGE seeks an independent evaluator to facilitate RFP RFP design to be design developed in  Guideline 6 calls for IE participation in RFP development parallel with IRP − “The utility will consult with the IE in preparing the RFPs…” acknowledgement  PGE see

  48. Slide 48: Schedule of IE RFP Development

    Schedule of IE RFP Development Guideline 5:  Commission Staff, with input from the utility and interested, non-bidding parties, will recommend an IE to the Commission, which will then select or approve an IE for the RFP. IE RFP schedule: 2016/2017 Milestone 2011 IE RFP Proposed IE RFP IE RFP-Prewor

  49. Slide 49: IE Applicant Pool

    IE Applicant Pool Independent evaluators to be invited to participate in IE RFP include, but are not limited to: Candidate Independent Evaluators E3 Thorndike Landing EnerVision, Inc Vantage Consulting Global Energy Concepts Accion Group, LLC. Boston Pacific Company, Inc. ICF International KEMA Inc.

  50. Slide 50: IE RFP Scope Summary and Next Steps

    IE RFP Scope Summary and Next Steps Important elements of proposed IE RFP  Technical capability  Experience with regulatory process  Experience in previous utility independent evaluator / monitor roles  Electronic bidding platform  Reasonable price PGE proposes to issue IE RFP year end 2016 Pro

  51. Slide 51: RFP Schedule

    RFP Schedule ‘17 Q1 ‘17 Q2 ’17 Q3 RFP Design IE RFP IE RFP Docket RFP RFP Stakeholder Engagement Submit Final IRP Acknowledgement Order Draft RFP ‘17 Q4 ‘18 Q1 ‘18 Q2 ’18 Q3 RFP Scoring OPUC Process RFP Acknowledgement Notice to Proceed Order 51

  52. Slide 52: Market Discussion

    Market Discussion Kate von Reis Baron

  53. Slide 53: Market discussion

    Market discussion • Capacity and Energy • Energy Position • Previous IRPs focused primarily on meeting energy need • In PGE’s 2016 IRP, the energy position is treated as a risk assessed through scenario analysis, not as a resource need • Capacity and Reliability • The region is transitioning to bein

  54. Slide 54: PGE Capacity and Energy

    PGE Capacity and Energy Reliability Requirements Economic Dispatch RECAP modeling RECAP reliability model, PGE system determines AURORA model, WECC dispatch capacity needed 30+ years of hourly load/weather to meet reliability Average load/weather data, capturing peak excursions obligations Unconstra

  55. Slide 55: IRP Energy Position

    IRP Energy Position With few exceptions, all portfolios maintain a net open position to the energy market Portfolio 3: Efficient Capacity 2021 55

  56. Slide 56: IRP Energy Position – Year 2025

    IRP Energy Position – Year 2025 PGE reduces power costs with economic energy purchases and sales. Net market purchases vary across season and time of day. • Portfolio 2 meets remaining capacity need ( after EE, DR, RPS, DSG) with Generic Capacity (low fixed costs, higher variable costs). PGE’s 2025

  57. Slide 57: IRP Energy Position – Year 2025

    IRP Energy Position – Year 2025 PGE reduces power costs with economic energy purchases and sales. Net market purchases vary across season and time of day. • Portfolio 2 meets remaining capacity need ( after EE, DR, RPS, DSG) with Generic Capacity (low fixed costs, higher variable costs). PGE’s 2025

  58. Slide 58: Capacity Types in the IRP

    Capacity Types in the IRP Hour Ahead - Constrained Spot Market Purchases -> RECAP Annual - Short-Term Purchases -> Generic Capacity e.g., ‘Front Office Transactions’, call options, block purchases backed by physical resources Lead Time (logarithmic) Year Ahead - Mid-Term Purchases -> Generic Capacit

  59. Slide 59: Market Capacity

    Market Capacity Market Capacity Capacity Open Position (unsecured capacity) • PGE considers “market” capacity to be short and mid-term capacity • In addition to the market capacity contracts for existing resources opportunities in PGE’s action plan, executed through bilateral the IRP capacity needs

  60. Slide 60: Meeting Capacity Needs

    Meeting Capacity Needs Resources that can contribute to meeting capacity need include: • Additional EE and DR Sustainable and Reliable • RPS resources • Hydro resources • Energy storage • Natural gas resources • Contracts • Seasonal capacity • Block purchases • Tolling agreements 60

  61. Slide 61: Regional reliability and supply adequacy

    Regional reliability and supply adequacy Capacity (MW) Study Analysis LOLP needed to meet Observations Year Vintage 5% LOLP Early estimate (BPA INC/DEC only) 2021 2015 8.3% (unstated) Loss of Boardman and Centralia 1 (~1,330 MW) 2021 loads lower than last year’s forecast (~1,500 aMW) but winter peak

  62. Slide 62: Regional Capacity

    Regional Capacity If region has several uncommitted physical resources with firm delivery options to PGE, PGE may receive: ● Multiple bids for mid-term and seasonal capacity products ● Competitive bid pricing If region has a small number of uncommitted physical resources with firm delivery options t

  63. Slide 63: Technology Discussion

    Technology Discussion Rick Tetzloff

  64. Slide 64: Technology Discussion

    Technology Discussion Main topics • Bolstering renewables with flexibility • Evolution of technology • Emission profiles Key learnings • How generating facilities (of all types) are economically dispatched • How substantial renewable expansion has fundamentally changed how electrical systems are ope

  65. Slide 65: Western US Generation Mix is Changing

    Western US Generation Mix is Changing Changing Generation Mix • WECC capacity … 15+ GW offline by 2025; coal, gas & nuclear • WECC generation … 56,000+ GWh need to be replaced based on 2015 generation • Shifting US resource mix … • Retirements: coal (92 GW) oil/gas steam turbines (35 GW) old gas tur

  66. Slide 66: 2015 New Capacity Additions in US

    2015 New Capacity Additions in US The US is rapidly adding renewables Total Capacity Installed in 2015: 18,400 MWs Biomass Wind 2% new flexible 45% generation is Solar also being 17% added to Gas accelerate this Hydro Combined Geothermal 0% transition Cycle 1% 27% Gas, Steam/ Gas, Simple Other Cycle

  67. Slide 67: Dispatch Dynamics – Northwest Power Pool Today

    Dispatch Dynamics Northwest Power Pool – Today Low variable cost units Min Avg. Peak first to dispatch Demand Demand Demand Variable nature of renewables resources requires flexible on- demand generation to Marginal Cost ($/MWh) Oil / integrate Gas SC / Biomass Coal and gas compete based on fuel pri

  68. Slide 68: Dispatch Dynamics – Northwest Power Pool Future

    Dispatch Dynamics Northwest Power Pool – Future Coal retirements Min Avg. Peak Demand Demand Demand T&D infrastructure may be needed for greater variable resource integration Marginal Cost ($/MWh) Oil / Flexibility needed to Gas SC/ integrate supply from Biomass variable resources Coal Gas CC Energy

  69. Slide 69: Dispatch Dynamics for Two Different Days

    Dispatch Dynamics for Two Different Days High Renewables Capacity Factor; Low Demand Day Temperate Spring Day Historic 2013-15 US Capacity Min Avg. Peak Factors by Unit Type – (EIA) Demand Demand Demand Marginal Cost ($/MWh) Nuclear 90-92% Coal 55-61% Oil / Gas CCGT 48-56% Gas SC/ Biomass Hydro 36-3

  70. Slide 70: Grids can handle more Renewables

    Grids can handle more Renewables Flexibility and forecasting improvements are needed Enablers of renewables Challenges for integration Demand response Lack of transmission Renewable forecasting Lack of control area cooperation Flexible fleet Unobservable and uncontrollable Faster quick starts distri

  71. Slide 71: Evolution of Gas Turbine Flexibility (GE)

    Evolution of Gas Turbine Flexibility (GE) Flexibility driven by physical and digital improvements 346 MW 50 MW/min 30% TD 7HA.02 Gas Turbine MW Output 280 MW 50 MW/min 250 MW 25% TD 40 MW/min 40% TD 7HA.01 7F 241 MW 40 MW/min 44% TD 216 MW 40 MW/min 188 MW 45% TD 188 MW 172 MW 30 MW/min 35 MW/min 14

  72. Slide 72: Flexibility Characteristics

    Flexibility Characteristics Next generation plants have increased flexibility Highly Highly Highly Flexible Flexible Conventional Flexible Combined Simple Cycle Combined Recips Cycle Frame CTG Cycle 12 units F/G/H/J F/G/H/J Class Class Cold Startup Times (to full load) 5-9 hr <10 min 2.75 – 3.5 hr 1

  73. Slide 73: Technology Providers

    Technology Providers All technology providers are focused on flexibility 73

  74. Slide 74: Mitsubishi M501JAC Fast Gas Turbine

    Mitsubishi M501JAC Fast Gas Turbine Mitsubishi Fast-Start Concept  10-minute Fast Start capability  Highest Efficiency in GT or CC Fast series  Largest Capacity in GT or CC Fast series Quick Start and Flexible Operation  Faster MW on/off the grid  Lower Start Up Emissions  Renewables support 7

  75. Slide 75: Siemens Co-start Combined Cycle Technology

    Siemens Co-startTM Combined Cycle Technology ; ; rt and General ~/ Electric High Efficiency Low Cost of Generation High Flexibility Low GHG Production The performance of a Combined Cycle The speed and flexibility of a simple cycle 75 Restricted © Siemens AG 2016. All rights reserved

  76. Slide 76: Siemens Flex-Plants

    Siemens Flex-Plants Bloom berg Siemens Powers El Segundo Energy Center with Second Flex-Plant in the U.S.A. "Flex-plants wjtb fast start tecbnglggy are an environmentally friendly solution to seamlessly integrating renewable power into the grid. As a result of this project, the El Segundo Energy Cen

  77. Slide 77: Emissions - Coal vs Natural Gas

    Emissions - Coal vs Natural Gas Emissions - Coal vs Natural Gas Combined Cycle 3.5 3 2.5 .c s ~ 2 ...... -.. .Q Ill I Coal (BN) c - - - - - - -- NGCC 0 'iii 1.5 .!a E w 1 0.5 77 co NOx 502 PM

  78. Slide 78: Additional Information

    Additional Information White Papers • Black & Veatch –2014 STRATEGIC DIRECTIONS: U.S. ELECTRIC INDUSTRY POWER GENERATION: NATURAL GAS AND RENEWABLES ARE A PERFECT PAIR • NBER: Bridging the Gap: Do Fast Reacting Fossil Technologies Facilitate Renewable Energy Diffusion? • JISEA: Pathways to Decarboni

  79. Slide 79: Smart Grid Report

    Smart Grid Report Brian Spak

  80. Slide 80: Our Strategic Approach

    Our Strategic Approach PGE will advance the intelligent and integrated operation of our grid by leveraging technologies that deliver customer value and system benefits in a changing landscape Model & Monitor: leverage industry & customer trends, data, policies, and system modeling, to plan ahead by

  81. Slide 81: Distribution System Evolution

    Distribution System Evolution Customer Adoption DER Optimization PGE High DER penetration, Today Self-healing, automated systems to realize maximum value of DERs DER Penetration DER Integration Moderate DER penetration, Enable additional value from distributed assets Grid Modernization & Pilots Low

  82. Slide 82: Current Landscape

    Current Landscape 79 MWDC 717 MW PV on distribution system Wind Generation 13 MW / 107 MW 1.25 MWh Enabled Demand Response & Available Energy Storage Dispatchable Standby Generation 7,000 865 EVs in service territory Public EV Charging Stations 2,600 75 / 0.48 Integrated Customer Devices Reliability

  83. Slide 83: One View of the Future

    One View of the Future 79 Over 220 MWDC 717 Over 2,000 MW PV on distribution system Wind Generation 13 / 107 250 MW / 150 MW 1.25 100 MWh Enabled Demand Response & Available Energy Storage Dispatchable Standby Generation 7,000 200,000 865 6,500 EVs in service territory Public EV Charging Stations 2,

  84. Slide 84: Spotlight: Residential Storage Demonstration Project

    Spotlight: Key Features • 25 kWh residential Residential Storage battery in a single family home in Demonstration Project Milwaukie, OR Demonstrates how customer-sited storage can provide • Aquion (salt-water backup power, peak shifting and grid services. During based) battery outages, the battery-i

  85. Slide 85: Spotlight: Flex Pricing Pilot

    Spotlight: Flex Pricing Pilot Evaluating system impacts and customer satisfaction of three program types: time of use, peak time rebates, and  Launched behavioral demand response. summer 2016  3,800 customers enrolled on peak time rebates & time of use  6 events called 2016 Smart Grid Report | Po

  86. Slide 86: Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards

    Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards  Smart thermostat demand response pilot  Launched Nest’s first winter program in 2015  2,600 Nest thermostats enrolled  Average 0.8-kW/customer demand response achieved in Summer 2016 with 10 events called Photo Attribution: Nest.com 2016 Smart Grid Report | Portland

  87. Slide 87: Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards Event

    Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards Rush Hour Rewards Event: July 29, 2016 5 Event Details: 4 • 95-degree day Average kW per Home • System Peak 3,536-MW (5pm) 3 2 1 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Hour Beginning Metered kW Baseline 2016 Smart Grid Report | Portland General E

  88. Slide 88: Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards Event

    Spotlight: Rush Hour Rewards Rush Hour Rewards Event: July 29, 2016 5 Event Details: Reduced Cooling Load 4 • 95-degree day Average kW per Home • System Peak 3,536-MW (5pm) 3 • 0.79-kWavg reduction per customer • 1,500 participants 2 • 1-MW total demand reduction 1 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

  89. Slide 89: Transportation Electrification Preliminary Pilot Portfolio

    Transportation Electrification Preliminary Pilot Portfolio Electric Mass Outreach Community Research Transit 2.0 & Charging & Education Infrastructure Development 2016 Smart Grid Report | Portland General Electric 89

  90. Slide 90: OPUC Staff 2016 Smart Grid Report Actions

    1. Provide results of the cost effectiveness evaluation of the Energy Partner Pilot 2. Provide copies of new or updated DSM and DER marketing material with next report. 3. Stakeholder process to compare cost- OPUC Staff effectiveness methodologies across all current and future DER and DSM efforts. 2

  91. Slide 91: Questions?

    Questions? 2016 Smart Grid Report | Portland General Electric 91

  92. Slide 92: Next Steps

    Next Steps Franco Albi

  93. Slide 93: Ongoing IRP Engagement

    Ongoing IRP Engagement Continuous dialogue and development Active • Inclusive and accessible process Engagement • Meaningful and practical dialogue Build • Information sharing and education Knowledge • Lines of communication open continuously Understand • Develop opportunities Perspective • Identify

  94. Slide 94: 2016 IRP RFP Design Timelines

    Timelines Aligned processes enable transparent communication Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 2017 ‘17 Q2 ’17 Q3 ‘17 Q4 2016 RPIP Commission Process RPIP PGE File Final Commission PGE File 2016 RPIP Public Meeting 2018 RPIP 2016 IRP 2016 IRP Development Draft Review 2016 IRP Commission Process Distribute Dra

  95. Slide 95: 2016 IRP and Development Timelines

    2016 IRP and Development Timelines Parallel OPUC procedure and IRP development Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun ‘17 Q3 ’17 Q4 2016 IRP Commission Process 2016 IRP PGE Files Stakeholder PGE Reply Stakeholder PGE Reply Staff OPUC 2016 IRP Comments Comments Comments Comments Memo Order Nov 15 Jan 24 Mar

  96. Slide 96: 2017 Roundtable Topics

    2017 Roundtable Topics Continuous dialogue increases value PGE is seeking your input to improve our 2017 roundtable discussions • Presentation topics • Areas of discussion • Meeting format • Communication suggestions 96

  97. Slide 97: Thank You!

    Thank You! Feedback welcome 24/7 at:  https://www.portlandgeneral.com/forms/ pge-stakeholder-feedback  www.portlandgeneral.com/irp  irp@pgn.com 97

  98. Slide 98: 2016 IRP Feedback Roundup

    2016 IRP Feedback Roundup

  99. Slide 99: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed For stakeholder questions, provide a General Passing the mic was cumbersome. stationary microphone at a podium or mics at 4/13/2015 each table. Update schedule slides to account for automation. Plan to revise and post updated Pro

  100. Slide 100: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Load Forecast For future discussion, how is the ETO PGE to address questions about EE projection 7/15/15 and Methodology forecast in later years developed? in the future. Refer to April 2nd Slide 31. 7/16/15 Comment on in‐fill vs

  101. Slide 101: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is engaging the ETO on a number of DR programs, particularly with Energy Partner and the smart thermostat pilot. Our current plan is to How is PGE using the convergence of EE only attribute incremental demand reductions Deman

  102. Slide 102: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Would PGE provide a copy of the DR study, Demand along with the assumptions (particularly PGE uploaded the final report to 02/16/16 Response materials supporting the basis for electric portlandgeneral.com heating load control)? R

  103. Slide 103: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is willing to host detailed modeling Can there be discussions about the Clean discussions; we look forward to receiving Futures Power Plan and mass vs. rate‐based detailed feedback regarding the specific 12/17/15 modeling? as

  104. Slide 104: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The definition is dependent on the What is PGE's definition of dependable particular capacity assessment question. hydro capacity or what does it mean in this PGE presented an overview of the PRM Study 12/17/15 context? What meth

  105. Slide 105: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can PGE provide clarification on the net The plant capacities were discussed in the PRM Study 12/17/15 capacities used in winter and summer? 12/17/15 Public meeting. As in the 2013 IRP, the PRM Study models Why does DSM not chang

  106. Slide 106: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Is PGE going to treat Carty as an existing Yes. PGE’s correspondence with EPA Clean Power resource? Can PGE provide the regarding Carty is ongoing. PGE is willing to 12/17/15 Plan correspondence between PGE and EPA share the lett

  107. Slide 107: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can the report be provided to Yes. The report will be included in the 2016 Climate Study Est. 7/29/2016 stakeholders? IRP. Is the study providing information about plant cooling requirements? Transmission No. The focus of the rep

  108. Slide 108: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE forecasted commercial energy growth rate of 0.9% (presented at the June 2015 load forecast workshop, slide 14) reflects growth in secondary delivery voltage service, of which small commercial (defined Commercial growth rate a

  109. Slide 109: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE tracks economic indicators such as the unemployment rate, unemployment claims, employment levels and growth by industry sector and building permits for the state of Oregon and counties within PGE service territory. PGE’s sour

  110. Slide 110: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE collaborates with the Energy Trust to increase customer awareness and participation in Energy Trust small to mid‐sized commercial energy efficiency programs through outreach and marketing activities. PGE has a three outreach

  111. Slide 111: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed How has PGE focused on the smaller commercial customer group to realize PGE primarily focuses on lighting projects in Energy potential in conservation through lighting the activities described below due to the 03/09/16 Conservati

  112. Slide 112: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Energy Trust and PGE are co‐marketing the Rush Hour Rewards program with the Energy Trust’s smart thermostat rebates. Both parties are providing links to the other’s websites/enrollment portals. Energy Trust promotes Rush You men

  113. Slide 113: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The uncertainty lies in the opt‐in components, in particular time‐of‐use rates without a peak time rebate component. Preliminary results of initial enrollment show that signing up customers on these rates can be tough and often r

  114. Slide 114: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE’s year 1 evaluation is available upon request. The final year 2 report will be provided to staff along with our annual report 4/29/16. Please share your evaluation of the Energy In general, participants in Energy Partner are

  115. Slide 115: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed What does “identifying the system benefit The evaluation will identify both the benefit of targeted peak energy usage both in terms of average peak reductions Integrated Grid education….” mean? Does it mean (our planning estimate

  116. Slide 116: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The biggest component that differentiates the high case form the others is the default time‐variant rates. We have received If the High Case programs are cost feedback from several stakeholders (most effective, listing the barrie

  117. Slide 117: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE presented data from RECAP runs for 2025 and 2030 in the 03/09/2016 meeting Slide 89 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015) states (Roundtable #16‐1). The presentation also that generalizations will be made for capacity included capacit

  118. Slide 118: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE discussed this issue in the 12/17/2015 Public Meeting and the 03/09/2016 Round Slide 91 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015), Table. It is on the list to investigate for the Please add energy efficiency to this list of next IRP cycle

  119. Slide 119: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is studying 2021, 2025, and 2030 for Generally, why study 2021 for ELCC and resource adequacy and renewable capacity Futures & 2025 for portfolio coverage? Why the contribution. Resource portfolio cross‐ 05/16/2016 Portfolios

  120. Slide 120: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE’s portfolio creation process was generally described verbally rather than illustrated visually, and did not consider How was this portfolio creation process factors such as ELCC or attempt make Futures & illustrated in the pa

  121. Slide 121: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Please describe the methodology used in Futures & determining the Capacity needs vs the PGE needs more information to address this 05/09/2016 Portfolios market needs for slides 99 and 100 (Public question. Meeting, 12/17/2015). P

  122. Slide 122: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Futures & Please provide an exploration of how SB The May 16, 2016 presentation will address 05/16/2016 Portfolios 1547 affects resource choices near‐term. this feedback. Discuss how later RPS obligations (2025; Futures & 2030; 2

Portland General Electric — Technical Presentation (November 2016) on 6ix