Primo Water — Proxy Contest (April 2023)
20 slides from Primo Water's proxy contest presentation, Apr 13, 2023
Slide 1: Setting the Record Straight
Primo Water Corporation (TSX / NYSE: PRMW) Setting the Record Straight www.PurifyThePrimoBoard.com April 2023
Slide 2: Primo's Claim vs. Shareholder Reality
Section 1 Primo’s Claim “We Believe Our Long-Term Strategy Is Driving Results” Shareholder Reality Long-term TSR Close to Zero Woefully Low Return Underperformance Customer Growth on Invested Capital The Board is resorting to aggressive smear tactics and desperately trying to divert attention from t
Slide 3: PRMW Shares Have Materially Underperformed
Section PRMW Shares Have Materially Underperformed 1 The Company’s Total Shareholder Returns (TSR) have been disappointing, persistently lagging its peers and relevant indices PRMW Relative TSR vs. Peer Groups and Major Benchmarks PRMW vs. 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year Legion-Selected Peers1 (7%) (22%) (83%)
Slide 4: Primo Avoids Discussing TSR Performance
Section Primo Avoids Discussing TSR Performance 1 In its 96-page investor presentation, Primo did not mention 1, 3, or 5-year TSR once – we believe Primo is fully aware that its TSR persistently lags its peers and relevant indices PRMW Share Price (20 Years) $35 $30 $25 PRMW’s share price has gone n
Slide 5: Repeating "Our Strategy Is Working" Doesn't Make It True
Section Repeating “Our Strategy Is Working” Doesn’t Make It True 1 Primo management has reiterated “our strategy is working” multiple times since 2018 and effectively repeats the same message 6 times in its investor presentation, but PRMW’s share price seems to disagree PRMW Share Price (5 Years) 11
Slide 6: Primo Now Claims It Isn't Focused on Customer Growth
Section Primo Now Claims It Isn’t Focused on Customer Growth 1 Primo highlighted “customer growth” on 40 earnings and Investor Day calls every year over the past 10 years but now appears to discard this important KPI Year Management Remarks 4/12/2023 “The decision to rationalize our customer base ha
Slide 7: Primo Seems to Have Invented A New Metric to Obscure Its Growth Problem
Primo Seems to Have Invented A New Metric to Obscure Section 1 Its Growth Problem Primo shows a misleading and inflated “Revenue Per Customer” growth that includes Water Refill and Exchange channels ($9,000-10,000 revenue per customer) in 2020 and 2022 Revenue Per Customer for Core Business Water Di
Slide 8: Primo Avoids Calculating Industry Standard ROIC
Section Primo Avoids Calculating Industry Standard ROIC 1 After years of promising shareholders a 12% ROIC in 2024, Primo has finally admitted it won’t be possible on an industry standard after-tax basis Primo adjustments account for 282%, 104% and 73% of Adj. Net Income in the 3 years shown, respec
Slide 9: Primo's ROIC Has Been Poor and Is Far Behind Peers
Section Primo’s ROIC Has Been Poor and Is Far Behind Peers 2 Primo has a history of generating unacceptably low level of returns Fiscal Year ($mm) 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 … 2024E NOPAT1 $106 $123 $133 $147 $163 $234 Average Invested Capital $2,449 $2,355 $2,535 $2,728 $2,713 $2,680 ROIC2 4.3% 5.2%
Slide 10: Legion Has Highlighted Substantive Value Creation Ideas
Section Legion Has Highlighted Substantive Value Creation Ideas 1 ✓ Drive organic customer ✓ Improve compensation growth in Water Direct plan structure ✓ Drive location growth in ✓ Roll back bylaw changes Water Exchange and board is using against Water Refill shareholders ✓ Rationalize bloated cost
Slide 11: Primo's Entrenchment Tactics Are Costing Shareholders
Section Primo’s Entrenchment Tactics Are Costing Shareholders 1 Primo claims that Legion is responsible for issues to be decided on by the court – the reality is quite the opposite – the legal action brought by Legion can end any day when Primo chooses to give shareholders the opportunity to vote fo
Slide 12: Primo Has Viciously Attacked Nominee Henrik Jelert
Section Primo Has Viciously Attacked Nominee Henrik Jelert 1 Why is Primo so focused on Henrik Jelert? We suspect it is because he understands the depressing reality of Primo’s underperformance and has the requisite skills to help improve the business ▪ Mr. Jelert led ReadyRefresh HOD’s successful t
Slide 13: Appendix
Section 2 APPENDIX 13 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 14: Legion's Nominees Have the Right Mix of Expertise
Section Legion’s Nominees Have the Right Mix of Expertise 1 Legion Nominees: Derek Lewis Tim Hasara Public Board Seasoned beverage operational executive with 35+ Founder, Managing Partner and CIO at Sinnet Capital years of experience at PepsiCo and a recognized with 27+ years of proven investment tr
Slide 15: Legion Partners' Nominee: Derek R. Lewis
Section Legion Partners’ Nominee: Derek R. Lewis 5 We believe that Mr. Lewis’ extensive experience in the beverage industry with significant leadership skills in sales and operations coupled with his experience building development programs for multicultural communities and employees make him a valu
Slide 16: Legion Partners' Nominee: Timothy "Tim" Hasara
Section Legion Partners’ Nominee: Timothy “Tim” Hasara 5 We believe that Mr. Hasara’s extensive successful investment experience of nearly 30 years investing in small cap companies and engaging on key issues around margin improvement, capital allocation and disclosures would make him a valuable asse
Slide 17: Nominee Ready to Serve: Henrik Jelert
Section Nominee Ready to Serve: Henrik Jelert 5 We believe that Mr. Jelert’s experience leading sustainable and significant growth and profitability expansion at Nestlé Waters, coupled with his substantial operational expertise in water delivery would make him a valuable asset to the Board ▪ Henrik
Slide 18: Nominee Ready to Serve: Lori T. Marcus
Section Nominee Ready to Serve: Lori T. Marcus 5 We believe that Ms. Marcus’ public board experience, comprehensive beverage industry experience in marketing including digital and social channels as well as general management along with her executive coaching skills would make her a valuable asset t
Slide 19: Disclaimer – Important Information
Disclaimer – Important Information The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Legion Partners Holdings, LLC and the other participants (collectively, “Legion Partners”) named in the definitive proxy statement filed by Legion Partners with the Securities and Exchange C
Slide 20: CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY