NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:NWE
NorthWestern Energy — Corporate Update (October 2022)
40 slides from NorthWestern Energy's corporate update, Oct 6, 2022
Slide 1: October ETAC Meeting Agenda
October ETAC Meeting Agenda July 13, 2022 Item Lead Start Time End Time Kickoff and Introductions S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:00 9:10 IRP Draft Document Overview S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:10 9:30 D. Millar, B. Mauch Model Results 9:30 10:30 Ascend Analytics Open Comments / Responses S. Schmitt 10:30
Slide 2: IRP Status and Timeline
IRP Status and Timeline Oct 6, 2022 - Draft document provided to ETAC Nov 7, 2022 – Final Comments due from ETAC Dec 15, 2022 – Final IRP delivered to the Montana PSC Jan – Feb, 2023 – Public meetings
Slide 3: The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement
The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement • Balance reliability, affordability, and sustainability • Identify NorthWestern’s capacity and energy position and determine the least-cost resources to meet future requirements • Supply planning must follow rules set forth in Montana Law • M
Slide 4: IRP Draft Document Chapters – Volume 1
IRP Draft Document Chapters – Volume 1* 1. Executive Summary 2. Planning and Process History 3. Regional Outlook 4. Energy and Environmental Policy 5. Load Service Requirement 6. Existing Resource Portfolio 7. Transmission System 8. Resource Planning Analysis 9. Emerging Technologies 10. Action Plan
Slide 5: Major Themes in 2022 Plan
Major Themes in 2022 Plan 1. Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability. 2. Achieving Resource Adequacy with short-term contracts and executing on Yellowstone. 3. Participating in the WRAP program for reliability and regional coordination. 4. Markets assessments – impacts of joining an
Slide 6: Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability
Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability The 2022 Plan shows • NorthWestern is long on energy and short on capacity • Adoption of QFs and retirements is a major uncertainty in the portfolio • No fossil fuel resource procurements after 2035 • Long-duration energy storage (8 hours +) m
Slide 7: Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position
Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position Winter Summer The Addition of Yellowstone County Generating Station will not be sufficient to meet NorthWestern’s planning reserve margin
Slide 8: Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position (Winter)
Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position (Winter) NWE ELCC WRAP ELCC The Addition of Yellowstone County Generating Station will not be sufficient to meet NorthWestern’s planning reserve margin
Slide 9: Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position (Summer)
Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position (Summer) NWE ELCC WRAP ELCC The Addition of Yellowstone County Generating Station will not be sufficient to meet NorthWestern’s planning reserve margin
Slide 10: Load Growth
Load Growth • NorthWestern expects annual load growth at 0.3% inclusive of DSM and NEM • Peak demand will also increase at 0.3% per year • Winter peaks will be slightly higher than summer peaks Annual Energy Annual Winter and Summer Peak Demand
Slide 11: Regional Outlook
Regional Outlook The Pacific Northwest faces tightening supply driven mainly from coal retirements • The Northwest Power Conversation Council estimates as much as 2800 MW of capacity will be needed by 2024 • NorthWestern’s reliance on markets for energy imports is risky going forward
Slide 12: Western Resource Adequacy Program (WRAP)
Western Resource Adequacy Program (WRAP) • NorthWestern’s participation in the WRAP benefits customers through increased resource adequacy from pooling of resources across WRAP participants • NorthWestern plans to enter the binding phase of the WRAP beginning in 2025 • WRAP includes a forward showin
Slide 13: Modeling Results
r hh 1 1 1001 111101 9 0 200101 00 0 01% Modeling Results 0 00010 101 0008 01100 011 0 NorthWestern Energy Delivering a Bright Future
Slide 14: Commodity Price Forecasts
Commodity Price Forecasts Natural Gas Power $14 $12 AECO Gas Price ($/MMBNTU) $160.00 $10 $8 $140.00 Mid-C Power Price ($nom/MWh) $6 $120.00 $4 $100.00 $2 $80.00 $0 2023 2026 2029 2032 2035 2038 2041 $60.00 Hub Forward Price Hub Price Forecast $40.00 14 $20.00 12 CIG Gas Price ($/MMBNTU) $- 10 2017
Slide 15: Scenario Approach – Core Cases
Scenario Approach – Core Cases • Four capacity expansion runs with various Colstrip retirement dates 1. 12/31/2042 (base case) 2. 12/31/2035 3. 12/31/2030 4. 12/31/2025 5. Joint Environmental Group Recommended Resources with 2025 Colstrip retirement • Includes ½ of qualifying facilities (QFs) in que
Slide 16: ARS Results – Core Scenarios
ARS Results – Core Scenarios Model selects • Pumped-hydro and natural gas generation pre-2035 • Thermal resources are not allowed after 2035 • Post 2035, 4-hr storage is selected • Colstrip replacements are combination of pumped hydro and gas peakers
Slide 17: ARS Results – SMR and Environmental Scenarios
ARS Results – SMR and Environmental Scenarios Model selects • SMR additions reduce the amount of gas and storage requirements • Environmental model requires a lot of storage to maintain resource adequacy
Slide 18: Total Supply Cost Breakdown
Total Supply Cost Breakdown • Annual costs are discounted Base Case Scenaio Annual Portfolio Costs and summed to get the net 800 present value 600 Total Costs (Million $) • Market sales are added as a 400 negative cost 200 0 • Sub-hourly Revenue includes -200 potential W-EIM real-time -400 revenue f
Slide 19: Total Supply Costs – Core Scenarios (Half QFs)
Total Supply Costs – Core Scenarios (Half QFs) Core Scenarios Total Cost 2023-2043 Scenario Total Cost % above Base Case 12 ($ Billions) 10 8 Base Case $4.07 - Total Costs (Billion $) 6 $5.85 $4.36 $4.53 $4.56 Colstrip 2035 $4.14 2% 4 $4.07 $4.14 $4.20 2 Colstrip 2030 $4.36 7% 0 -2 Colstrip 2025 $4.
Slide 20: Total Supply Costs – Full QFs Sensitivity Cases
Total Supply Costs – Full QFs Sensitivity Cases Scenario Total Cost % above Base Case Full QF Scenarios Total Cost 2023-2043 ($ Billions) 12 10 Base Case $4.17 - 8 Total Costs (Billion $) 6 $6.05 3% 4 $4.17 $4.30 $4.43 $4.66 $4.54 $4.21 Colstrip 2035 $4.30 2 0 Colstrip 2030 $4.43 6% -2 -4 Colstrip 2
Slide 21: Total Supply Costs – Carbon Cost Sensitivity Cases
Total Supply Costs – Carbon Cost Sensitivity Cases Total Cost for Scenarios with Carbon Costs 2023-2043 Scenario Total Cost % above Base Case 8 ($ Billions) 6 $5.14 Base Case $4.77 - Total Costs (Billion $) $4.77 $4.79 $4.95 $5.05 $4.85 4 2 Colstrip 2035 $4.79 0.5% 0 Colstrip 2030 $4.95 4% -2 -4 Col
Slide 22: Colstrip Operations
Colstrip Operations • Colstrip is a must-run Base Case Scenario Colstrip Generation resource 0.9 • NorthWestern’s share is 60 0.8 MW must run and 162 MW of 0.7 Capacity Factor 0.6 dispatchable capacity 0.5 • If Colstrip is operated with no 0.4 0.3 must run constraint, the 0.2 capacity factor would d
Slide 23: Total Supply Costs – Colstrip Must-Run and Economic Dispatch
Total Supply Costs – Colstrip Must-Run and Economic Dispatch Scenario Colstrip MR Colstrip ED Base Case $4.07 $4.06 Colstrip 2035 $4.14 $4.13 Colstrip 2030 $4.36 $4.35 Colstrip 2025 $4.53 $4.53 SMR 2030 $4.56 $4.55 SMR 2035 $4.20 $4.19
Slide 24: Resource Adequacy Results
Resource Adequacy Results 2030 2035 Scenario Unserved Unserved LOLH LOLH Energy Energy (hrs) (hrs) (MWh) (MWh) Base 4.9 0.3 4.4 0.2 2035 Colstrip Retirement 68.6 2.8 154.2 2.6 Core 2030 Colstrip Retirement 0 0 117 2.4 Assumptions 2025 Colstrip Retirement 3.2 0.2 144.2 2.5 SMR in 2030 0 0 21.8 0.6 SM
Slide 25: Energy Position - Base Case
Energy Position - Base Case Energy Position with All QFs New Resources • NWE is projected to be long on 15 QF Resources (Million MWh) energy for several years if all QFs Generation Existing Resources 10 are built Load 5 • New resources are needed for capacity, but also add to the - 2023 2027 2031 20
Slide 26: Carbon Emissions - Base Case
Carbon Emissions - Base Case • The Base Scenario emissions drop from over 3 million tons in 2023 to 2 million tons in 2029 due to the retirements of CELP and YELP and lower capacity factors for natural gas plants • After 2029, emissions remain at 2 million tons with Colstrip providing the majority o
Slide 27: Carbon Emissions - Core Scenarios
Carbon Emissions - Core Scenarios • The overall emissions for the core scenarios depends on the retirement assumption of Colstrip • The Joint Environmental Scenario provides the greatest carbon reduction
Slide 28: Carbon Emissions and Cost
Carbon Emissions and Cost CO2 Emissions • Colstrip 2025 retirements Avoided Relative to NPV Cost Relative Cost per Ton of CO2 Scenario to Base Case Avoided provide the greatest the Base Case ($ Million) ($/Metric Ton) (MMT) emissions savings Colstrip 2035 3.42 205.06 59.97 • The Colstrip 2025 Retire
Slide 29: Key Take-aways from Resource Planning Modeling
Key Take-aways from Resource Planning Modeling • NorthWestern is “long” energy but “short” capacity in all modeled cases • This long position increases for every added QF • Model favors adding 100 – 300 MW long-duration storage to manage the “energy long” position. • We limit the long energy positio
Slide 30: Action Plan
Action Plan 1. Participate in the ongoing development of the WRAP program 2. Push for the completion of Yellowstone 3. Continue to monitor the need for an RFP, evaluate Opportunity Resources, and track QF development while maintaining a resource adequate portfolio 4. Continue to evaluate the future
Slide 31: Appendix
Appendix NorthWestern Energy Delivering a Bright Future
Slide 32: Technology Cost Forecasts
Technology Cost Forecasts • Major market disruption and inflationary pressures on all energy technologies • Supply chain bottlenecks • Fundamental changes in supply and demand for clean energy raw materials • Commerce Department investigation into the solar panel tariff evasion • Approach to current
Slide 33: Candidate resource list
Candidate resource list Technology/Fuel Resource Size Wind 50 MW Solar 50 MW Renewable Solar Storage hybrid 50 MW Wind Storage hybrid 50 MW Stand Alone Storage 25 MW (4- hour) Stand Alone Storage Storage 25 MW (8-hour) Pumped Hydro 100 MW (9 - hour storage) Aeroderivative gas turbine 50 MW Natural G
Slide 34: Montana Wind
Montana Wind $1,784 $1,784 WIND - 100 MW (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,784 $1,800 $1,719 • With near term $1,623 $1,600 $1,654 inflation, wind is $1,589 $1,524 $1,784/kW $1,400 $1,459 $1,395$1,381 ($44/MWh) through $1,367$1,353 $1,339$1,325 $1,311$1,297 2025. CAPEX ($/kW) $1,283$1,269 $1,255$1,241 $1,2
Slide 35: Montana Solar
Montana Solar SOLAR - 100 MW (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,700 $1,605 $1,605 $1,605 • With near term $1,500 $1,460 $1,520 inflation, solar is $1,436 $1,605/kW $1,300 $1,351 $1,266 ($60/MWh) through 2025. CAPEX ($/kW) $1,181 $1,100 $1,096$1,086$1,077$1,067 $1,057$1,047$1,038$1,028 $1,018$1,008$998 $989
Slide 36: Lithium Ion Battery – 4 Hour Duration
Lithium Ion Battery – 4 Hour Duration BESS - Li-Ion - 4-Hr (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,800 $1,496 $1,645 $1,645 $1,645 • With near term $1,600 inflation, BESS is $1,516 $1,400 $1,461 $1,407 $1,645/kW through $1,352 $1,298 2025. $1,243$1,228$1,212 • Declines to CAPEX ($/kW) $1,200 $1,197$1,181$1,166 $
Slide 37: Gas Fired Power Plants
Gas Fired Power Plants Gas Resources (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,700 $1,611 • Gas fired power $1,600 $1,557 $1,547 plants increase due to $1,495 Aeroderivative Turbines inflation but decline $1,500 $1,523 Reciprocating $1,491 modestly in cost Engines CAPEX ($/kW) $1,400 Combined Cycle $1,300 $1,200 C
Slide 38: Geothermal and Pumped Hydro
Geothermal and Pumped Hydro NREL ATB (CONS) + MKT ADJ (NOMINAL$) $4,000 $3,656 • Geothermal can Geothermal produce 24-7 clean $3,500 energy, however they $3,000 are expensive and $3,238 Pumped Hydro “Clean firm” non- must be located in $2,500 nuclear resources geologically specific CAPEX ($/KW) $2,0
Slide 39: New Website
New Website • Supply Planning Website: • https://www.northwesternenergy.com/about-us/gas-electric/electric-supply- resource-procurement-plan • Please sign up for the email distribution list: • https://lp.constantcontactpages.com/su/XE0SdNG • Submit portfolio requests and other feedback via the new f
Slide 40: NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting
NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting August 4, 2021 Thank you. 40
NorthWestern Energy Group — Corporate Update (October 2022) on 6ix