Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — presentatie harrigan
26 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's investor presentation, Oct 5, 2012
Slide 1: Export Prices of U.S. Firms
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export Prices of U.S. Firms James Harrigan½ Xiangjun Ma¾ Victor Shlychkov ½ University of Virginia, Sciences Po, and NBER ¾ University of International Business and Economics (UIBE) National Bank of Belgium,
Slide 2: Export price heterogeneity
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity Lots of product-level evidence shows that traded goods prices vary tremendously For a given importing country, across source countries for imports (Schott 2004) For a given exportin
Slide 3: Export price heterogeneity
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity Why would product-level export prices vary across destinations? Arithmetically, some mix of composition (different firm market shares in different destinations) and price discrimina
Slide 4: Summary of our findings
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity Summary of our findings Data: U.S. firm-level exports, manufacturing firm characteristics, country characteristics Focus on firm×product export prices across export destinations Cor
Slide 5: Implications for trade theory
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity Implications for trade theory Composition explanation based on models of heterogeneous firms where stronger firms charge higher prices than weaker firms, instead of lower. Consisten
Slide 6: Implications for measurement of international prices
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity Implications for measurement of international prices Recent macro models incorporate extensive margin of trade (Ghironi and Melitz 2005, Feenstra, Obstfled, Russ 2009). Implications
Slide 7: Data
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Data U.S. firm-level HS10 exports in 2002 Confidential, analyzed at Census Research Data Center in New York and North Carolina Data pioneered by Bernard, Jensen, Schott (2005), Bernard, Jensen, Redding, Schot
Slide 8: How much export price variation?
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions How much export price variation? Within HS10 product codes exported by U.S. firms in 2002, how much price variation? standard deviation of log prices across firms and destinations = 1.52 With normality, impli
Slide 9: How much export price variation?
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions How much export price variation? How much of variation due to variance across firms? standard deviation of log prices within firms, across destinations = 0.71 With normality, implies 90-10 ratio = 6. Most of
Slide 10: What is a product?
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions What is a product? examples of HS10 product categories 8703.10.50.30 Golf carts 8708.30.50.20 Brake drums 8501.10.60.20 Small electric motors, alternating current 9006.53.01.10 35mm film cameras, with built i
Slide 11: Export price decomposition across destinations
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price decomposition across destinations Average price of product exported to destination d , a quantity-weighted average of prices charged by all Nd firms f that export to d , qfd p̄d = ∑N f =½ wfd pfd
Slide 12: Export price decomposition across destinations
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price decomposition across destinations Difference in average prices between destination d and the world average for any good is N N N p̄d − p̄ = ∑ (pfd − p̄f )w̄f + ∑ (wfd − w̄f )p̄f + ∑ (wfd − w̄f )(
Slide 13: Export price decomposition across destinations
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price decomposition across destinations Data U.S. firm-level HS10 exports in 2002 Confidential, analyzed at Census Research Data Center in New York and North Carolina Data pioneered by Bernard, Jensen,
Slide 14: Export price decomposition across destinations
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price decomposition across destinations Quantiles Percentile Price Discrimination Market Share Interaction 0.05 -0.416 -0.552 -1.680 0.10 -0.053 -0.003 -0.528 0.25 0.000 0.575 -0.003 0.50 0.000 1.000 0
Slide 15: Export price decomposition across destinations
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price decomposition across destinations James Harrigan, Xiangjun Ma, Victor Shlychkov University of Virginia, Sciences Po, and NBER, University of International Business and Economics (UIBE) Export Pri
Slide 16: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Firms enter a market if it is profitable. Conditional on observables, positive demand shock leads to Greater probability of entry Higher price Consistent estimati
Slide 17: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Reduced form export volume equation, estimated across firms f and destinations d yifd = [, α¾i + δ Xd + uifd ] yifd is sales of product i by firm f in destination
Slide 18: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Fixed effects price equations, pooled across firms f destinations d products i , errors clustered by destination, selection correction term ûifd from export volu
Slide 19: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Country level data Trade costs: kilometers from Chicago to capital city of importer Market size: real GDP, real GDP per worker Remoteness: motivated by CES price
Slide 20: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Product fixed effects/product×firm fixed effects, all countries, OLS with/without selection correction. Standard errors clustered at the country level appear in p
Slide 21: Destination Market Characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Destination Market Characteristics Simple OLS Selection Correction Product FE Firm-Product FE Product FE Firm-Product FE 1<km≤4,000 0.326*** 0.386*** 0.204 0.261** (0.111) (0.093) (0.133) (0.105) 4,000<km≤7,8
Slide 22: Export prices and destination characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and destination characteristics Four other studies estimate effects of distance on firm-level export prices. How do our results compare? log distance United States 0.168*** (0.021) China 0.010**
Slide 23: Export prices and firm characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and firm characteristics Reduced form export volume equation yifd = [, α¾i + δ½i Xd + δ¾i Xf + uifd ] Product fixed effects pifd = α½i + β Xd + β Xf + γ ûifd + εifd Destination-product fixed ef
Slide 24: Export prices and firm characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export prices and firm characteristics Firm level data 2002 Census of Manufactures. value of shipments, employment, production and nonproduction workers, cost of materials, 6-digit NAICS. Annual Survey of Man
Slide 25: Firm Characteristics
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Firm Characteristics Simple OLS Selection Correction log TFP 0.342*** 0.350*** (0.048) (0.048) log S/L 0.162*** 0.163*** (0.011) (0.011) log K/L -0.072*** -0.083*** (0.011) (0.011) log total employment -0.007
Slide 26: Export price heterogeneity: conclusions
Motivation Price Decomposition Destination Characteristics Firm Characteristics Conclusions Export price heterogeneity: conclusions First to analyze firm-level data on export pricing decisions of U.S. exporters. Three-stage panel Tobit estimator to control for firm selection into different export ma