MutualFirst Financial — Merger or Acquisition (October 2017)
12 slides from MutualFirst Financial's merger presentation, Oct 4, 2017
Slide 1: MutualFirst Financial Partners with BloomBank
© Mutual First Gi Financial Inc. BloomBank LOCAL DECISIONS © TAILORED SOLUTIONS MutualFirst Financial Partners with BloomBank Expanding Our Indiana Community Banking Presence OCTOBER 4, 2017 SYMBOL: MFSF
Slide 2: Forward Looking Statement
8) Forward Looking Statement ‘This communication contains forward-looking statements” within the meaning ofthe Private Securities Litigation Reform Actof 1995. These statements include, but are not limitedto, expectations or predictions offuture financial or business performance, conditions relating
Slide 3: MutualFirst Financial Today
MutualFirst Financial Today ° “MFSF” Nasdaq Global Market * $290 million Market Capitalization * Russell 2000 Index nN) MutualBank Today * $1.6 billion in Assets * $1.2 billion in Gross Loans & Deposits * 27 Full-Service Financial Centers « 426 Employees
Slide 4: BloomBank Overview
8) BloomBank Overview Se 4. 1 Tak Company Profile = Headquartered in Bloomfield, IN, BloomBank (holding | = =) company — Universal Bancorp) operates 13 branches in attractive Central and Southern Indiana banking markets = Founded in 1873, BloomBank has been operated by five generations of the Barkle
Slide 5: BloomBank Markets
Os) BloomBank Markets Attractive Markets Deposit Market Share — Counties of Operation") = Greater Indianapolis MSA = wa Bia aoe . fank ti’? Institution (State) Branches (Smm)___{%) * Geographic Coverage a JPMorgan Chase Bank NA (OH) 3 37231488 = Greenwood and Carmel offices 7 siriiniiileia fo 5G 383
Slide 6: Transaction Overview
w 2 Os) Transaction Overview Consideration & Purchase Price Valuation Multiples Required Approvals MutualFirst Financial, Inc. (“MFSF”) to acquire 100% of Universal Bancorp BloomBank will be merged into MutualBank Exchange Ratio: 15.600 MFSF shares and $250.00 in cash >) Consideration: 1,185,538 sha
Slide 7: Compelling Strategic Partnership
Os) Compelling Strategic Partnership oO ice | growth attributes Siatose * Low-cost Central and Southern Indiana deposit franchise, provides strong margin expansion with ability to deploy excess deposits Value Leverages existing MFSF operating platform and back-office support Ability to leverage Bloo
Slide 8: Key Transaction Assumptions
Os) Key Transaction Assumptions Cost Savings Expected non-interest expense savings of approximately 25%, with 100% of synergies being realized by 2019 Revenue Enhancements None included in pro forma projections Merger-Related Expenses Approximately $3.3 million after-tax (approx. 5.0% of announced d
Slide 9: Comprehensive Due Diligence Process
Os) Comprehensive Due Diligence Process v Comprehensive due diligence encompassing all areas of BloomBank’s operations and financial results v “Bottoms-up” cost saves analysis performed by MFSF management team, with the assistance of BloomBank management team V Senior executives from across both org
Slide 10: Pro Forma Impact
8) Pro Forma Impact Dollars in millions except per share amounts 6/30/17 6/30/17 MFSF Universal 6/30/2017 Stand-Alone Stand-Alone Pro Forma’) 1,575.9 402.5 1,979.0 1,180.7 266.6 1446.4 1,173.0 323.4 1496.4 Borrowings. 240.2 35.0 265.6 Total Equity. 1463 435 189.6 Tangible Common Equity. 144.3 416 16
Slide 11: Summary
Os) Summary Y Pro forma assets of $2.0 billion Y Consistent with articulated business plan and shareholder value proposition v Strategic acquisition that enhances franchise through logical extension into adjacent Central and Southern Indiana markets VY Clear execution pathway v Compelling transactio
Slide 12: MutualFirst Financial Partners with BloomBank
© Mutual First Gi Financial Inc. BloomBank LOCAL DECISIONS © TAILORED SOLUTIONS MutualFirst Financial Partners with BloomBank Expanding Our Indiana Community Banking Presence OCTOBER 4, 2017 SYMBOL: MFSF
Mutualfirst Financial — Merger or Acquisition (October 2017) on 6ix