Firstmerit Corp

Firstmerit — Proxy Contest (March 2012)

20 slides from Firstmerit's proxy contest presentation, Mar 29, 2012

  1. Slide 1: Management Say-on-Pay Proposal Presentation

    EXHIBIT 99.1 FirstMerit Corporation Management Say-on-Pay Proposal Presentation March 29, 2012

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statement Disclosure

    Forward-Looking Statement Disclosure This presentation contains forward-looking statements relating to present or future trends or factors affecting the banking industry, and specifically the financial condition and results of operations, including without limitation, statements relating to the earn

  3. Slide 3: Explanatory Note

    Explanatory Note This presentation was prepared by the Corporation on behalf of its Board of Directors (the “Board”) for use by those employees of the Corporation authorized to communicate with shareholders of the Corporation pursuant to its internal policies. The members of the Board may have an in

  4. Slide 4: Management Say-on-Pay Proposal

    Management Say-on-Pay Proposal • Say-on-pay analysis by certain proxy advisors seems to reach the wrong conclusion on vote recommendation because it fails to take into account performance criteria that are specific to our industry, our organization structure, and our business strategy in particular.

  5. Slide 5: Strength of Underlying Corporate Performance

    Strength of Underlying Corporate Performance • 51 consecutive quarters of profitability as of fourth quarter, 2011 • Full year 2011 net income of $120 mm, up 16% from 2010 $1.10 per diluted share Return on total average assets of 0.82% Return on average shareholders’ equity of 7.72% • 2011 total com

  6. Slide 6: Short-Term RTSR vs. Underlying Corporate Performance

    Short-Term RTSR vs. Underlying Corporate Performance • The proxy advisors’ methodology disregards the relative strength of our stock price at the beginning of the 3-year RTSR measurement period. More importantly, the methodology ignores our continued superior performance against key corporate metric

  7. Slide 7: History of Superior Performance Continued in 2011

    History of Superior Performance Continued in 2011….. Critical Financial Performance Metrics Relative to Peer Averages 2010 2011 FirstMerit Peers FirstMerit Peers Return on average 7.82% 1.66% 7.72% 5.07% shareholders’ equity Return on total 0.76% 0.17% 0.82% 0.60% average assets Net charge-offs/ 1.2

  8. Slide 8: Following Historical Trends

    …..Following Historical Trends Critical Financial Performance Metrics Relative to Peer Averages 2008 2009 FirstMerit Peers FirstMerit Peers Return on average 12.76% 2.53% 8.09% -1.78% shareholders’ equity Return on total 1.13% 0.19% 0.76% -0.25% average assets Net charge-offs/ 0.68% 0.83% 1.22% 1.88

  9. Slide 9: Superior Relative Stock Performance Throughout Financial Crisis

    Superior Relative Stock Performance Throughout Financial Crisis Four-Year Total Shareholder Return 12/31/07-12/30/11 -8.1% -48.1% -50.9% -60.0% FMER Peers KBW Bank Index S&P Diversified Financials Source: Bloomberg Financial Peer Group Includes: Associated Banc-Corp, Citizens Republic, Bancorp, F.N.

  10. Slide 10: Superior Relative Stock Performance Over Longer Term

    Superior Relative Stock Performance Over Longer Term Ten Year Total Shareholder Return 12/31/01-12/30/11 -11.3% -38.6% - 46.5% -58.1% FMER KBW Bank Index S&P Diversified Financials Peers Source: Bloomberg Financial Peer Group Includes: Associated Banc-Corp, Citizens Republic, Bancorp, F.N.B. Corpora

  11. Slide 11: Successful Execution of Strategic Initiatives

    Successful Execution of Strategic Initiatives • Successful Execution of Chicago Strategy— We successfully increased our growth and footprint in greater Chicago: Increasing our Chicago-area commercial loan production by over 120% from 2010 Significant increases in our greater Chicago non-covered loan

  12. Slide 12: Successful Execution of Strategic Initiatives (cont'd.)

    Successful Execution of Strategic Initiatives (cont’d.) • Dynamic Market Response — We continued to enhance our ability to react to market changes in the wake of the recent financial crisis: Increasing our customers’use of electronic banking statements Developing a comprehensive e-mail and online ma

  13. Slide 13: Peer Group Disparity

    Peer Group Disparity • FirstMerit Peer Group: Developed with the assistance of our independent compensation consultant to benchmark CEO compensation Consists of 11 regional banking institutions carefully selected to (1) include companies against which we compete for executive talent, based on asset

  14. Slide 14: Peer Group Disparity (cont'd.)

    Peer Group Disparity (cont’d.) Proxy Advisory Peer Group vs. FirstMerit Peer Group • Generally far from Akron, OH • Near Akron, OH • We don’t recruit talent from • Represents the region from all over the United States which we draw talent 14

  15. Slide 15: 2011 Short-Term Incentive Compensation Program

    2011 Short-Term Incentive Compensation Program • As described in detail in our proxy, we re-designed our annual incentive compensation program (ICP) in 2011 to more effectively align pay and performance, while retrospectively taking into account the effect of unsettled financial services markets, ge

  16. Slide 16: 2011 Long-Term Equity Based Grants

    2011 Long-Term Equity Based Grants • Our equity based program is focused on providing a direct line of sight for participants to the link between their performance and pay and the long-term success of our company, while balancing the expectations of multiple constituencies -- shareholders,bank regul

  17. Slide 17: Impact of Year-over-Year Change in Compensation Value

    Impact of Year-over-Year Change in Compensation Value • Proxy advisor analysis of CEO pay compared to peers did not account for all factors • The proxy advisors’ methodology for evaluating the reasonableness of CEO pay compared to peers seems to reach the wrong conclusion when considering the unique

  18. Slide 18: Important Facts about Excise Tax Gross-Up

    Important Facts about Excise Tax Gross-Up • Proxy advisory firms expressed concerns that 280G gross-up provisions could result in substantial increases in termination payments to executives or could encourage executives to enter into corporate transactions that are not in a company’s best interests

  19. Slide 19: Robust Succession Planning Process in Place

    Robust Succession Planning Process in Place • Proxy advisors have not taken into account the following facts regarding our succession planning: Our current organization structure does NOT include a Chief Operating Officer by design and thus creates a high compensation ratio to other named executives

  20. Slide 20: Contacts for Discussion

    Contacts for Discussion • Tom O’Malley – SVP, Director of Investor Relations & Corporate Communication • Judy Steiner – Executive Vice President, Risk Management, Corporate Secretary and General Counsel 20

Firstmerit — Proxy Contest (March 2012) on 6ix