Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — Technical Presentation (February 2018)
22 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's technical presentation, Feb 1, 2018
Slide 1: The role of non-performing loans in the transmission of monetary policy
The role of non-performing loans in the transmission of monetary policy Sebastian Bredl, Deutsche Bundesbank Disclaimer: This presentation represents the authors‘ personal opinions and does not necessarily reflect the views of the Deutsche Bundesbank or its staff. MPC-WS; 01.02.2018
Slide 2: Research Question and Motivation
Research Question and Motivation o High stock of Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) considered to be one of the most pressing problems in the European (and Euro area) banking system (see for instance recent discussion on the regulatory treatment of NPLs or ESRB (2017)). o „…high NPLs also impair monetary t
Slide 3: Potential channels through which NPLs might influence lending behavior
Potential channels through which NPLs might influence lending behavior o NPLs might be considered an indicator for „anticipated falls in capital“ (Hernando and Villanueva, 2014); (net NPLs). o NPLs might induce investors to demand higher risk premia for providing funds to the bank; either due to fur
Slide 4: Data I
Data I o Data sources: • IMIR-data: information on lending rates • CSDB: information on single bank bonds, used to generate indicator for cost of market funding on the single bank level. • SNL (S&P Global Market Intelligence) / Bankscope (ORBIS Bank Focus): Information on NPLs, LL-reserves, regulato
Slide 5: Data II
Data II o IMIR: SNL / Bankscope: CSDB: Banking group Parent company Subsidiary Foreign Branch Subsidiary o Costs of market funding for parent company are considered to be equivalent to costs for entire banking group. MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 5
Slide 6: Data III
Data III Single Banks (IMIR units) Banking Groups Sub- Parent Non- Non- sidiaries Vulner- Vul- Total Com- vulner- Total vulner- / Bran- able** nerable panies able* able*** ches 2010 81 45 36 48 33 57 35 22 2011 99 52 47 60 39 65 40 25 2012 115 62 53 66 49 73 45 28 2013 121 64 57 73 48 77 49 28 2014
Slide 7: Results Lending rates I (without Funding Costs)
Results Lending rates I (without Funding Costs) Dependent variable: Lending rate (loans to NFCs) Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 LendingRate (-1) 0.343 *** 0.536 *** 0.562 *** 0.429 *** 0.553 *** 0.812 *** Gross_NPL_TA (-1) 0.037 *** 0.026 *** 0.035 *** 0.038 *** 0.009 -0
Slide 8: Results Lending rates II (without Funding Costs)
Results Lending rates II (without Funding Costs) Dependent variable: Lending rate (loans to NFCs) Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 Lending-Rate (-1) 0.340 *** 0.526 *** 0.606 *** 0.424 *** 0.537 *** 0.761 *** Net_NPL_TA (-1) 0.070 *** 0.051 *** 0.058 *** 0.158 *** 0.063 **
Slide 9: Model with Funding Costs vs. Model without Funding Costs
Model with Funding Costs vs. Model without Funding Costs • Net NPLs (effect of mean increase between 2009 and 2015; including interaction term, OIS-rate=sample mean) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 9
Slide 10: Robustness (Model including Funding Costs) I
Robustness (Model including Funding Costs) I • Results for Coefficients referring to net NPLs and LL reserves largely robust to alternative model specifications. Including provisons over Leverage Ratio instead of Modell Benchmark Loan rate spread gross loans for single bank Tier 1 Net_NPL _ LL_Res_
Slide 11: Robustness (Model including Funding Costs) II
Robustness (Model including Funding Costs) II • Net NPLs and LL reserves highly correlated, however results not overly sensitive to variations of the sample (Year * country FE) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 11
Slide 12: Conclusion
Conclusion o In most specifications positive association between net NPLs and lending rates; LL-reserves tend to offset impact of net NPLs -> NPLs seem to be less relevant when adequately provisioned. o Funding Costs do barely affect relation between net NPLs and lending rates -> fits into “anticipa
Slide 13: Annex I: NPLs, Loan Loss Reserves, Provisions and Capital
Annex I: NPLs, Loan Loss Reserves, Provisions and Capital Asset side Profit and Loss Liability side Loan Capital 100 100 Turns to NPL Gross NPL Capital 60 Net NPL 60 40 Loan Loss 40 Loan Loss Reserves Provisions MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 13
Slide 14: Annex II: Results Lending rates III (without Funding Costs)
Annex II: Results Lending rates III (without Funding Costs) • Effect net NPLs (effect of mean increase between 2009 and 2015; OIS- rate=sample mean) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 14
Slide 15: Annex III: Results Lending rates IV (without Funding Costs)
Annex III: Results Lending rates IV (without Funding Costs) • Effect net NPLs + LL Reserves (effect of mean increase between 2009 and 2015; Assumption: Coverage Ratio=45%; including interaction term, OIS-rate=sample mean) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 15
Slide 16: Annex IV; Results Funding Costs I
Annex IV; Results Funding Costs I Dependent variable: Yield-to-maturity (YTM)_Spread Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 YTM-Spread (-1) 0.269 *** 0.904 *** 0.808 *** 0.240 *** 0.669 *** 0.624 *** Gross_NPL_TA (-1) 0.094 *** 0.087 *** 0.023 ** 0.057 *** 0.075 ** 0.071 ** 0.02
Slide 17: Annex V; Results Funding Costs II
Annex V; Results Funding Costs II Dependent variable: Yield-to-maturity (YTM)_Spread Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 YTM-Spread (-1) 0.257 *** 0.887 *** 0.789 *** 0.225 *** 0.672 *** 0.640 *** Net_NPL_TA (-1) -0.015 -0.014 -0.004 0.044 -0.092 ** -0.089 ** -0.025 -0.015 LL
Slide 18: Annex VI: Results Lending Rates (with Funding Costs) I
Annex VI: Results Lending Rates (with Funding Costs) I Dependent variable: Lending rate (loans to NFCs) Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 LendingRate (-1) 0.343 *** 0.540 *** 0.559 *** 0.433 *** 0.544 *** 0.772 *** Gross_NPL_TA (-1) 0.037 *** 0.026 *** 0.028 *** 0.026 ** 0.
Slide 19: Annex VII: Results Lending Rates (with Funding Costs) II
Annex VII: Results Lending Rates (with Funding Costs) II Dependent variable: Lending rate (loans to NFCs) Sys Sys Sys Sys FE_1 FE_2 FE_1 FE_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 GMM_1 GMM_2 Lending-Rate (-1) 0.340 *** 0.532 *** 0.565 *** 0.427 *** 0.529 *** 0.740 *** Net_NPL_TA (-1) 0.071 *** 0.051 *** 0.054 *** 0.099 ** 0
Slide 20: Annex VIII: Model with Funding Costs vs. Model without Funding Costs
Annex VIII: Model with Funding Costs vs. Model without Funding Costs • LL Reserves (effect of mean increase between 2009 and 2015; including interaction term, OIS-rate=sample mean) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 20
Slide 21: Annex IX: Related Literature
Annex IX: Related Literature o Recent findings based on IMIR-data suggest that NPLs affect markup of lending rates over MP-rates after controlling for capital (Albertazzi et al., 2016). o However, NPLs do not seem to strongly affect pass-through of MP- rates or MP-shocks in the case of standard MP-m
Slide 22: Annex X: Robustness (Model including Funding Costs)
Annex X: Robustness (Model including Funding Costs) • Net NPLs and LL reserves highly correlated, however results not overly sensitive to variations of the sample (Macro vars) MPC-WS; 01.02.2018 Page 22
Banque Nationale De Belgique — Technical Presentation (February 2018) on 6ix