Perot Systems — Technical Presentation (June 2002)
54 slides from Perot Systems's technical presentation, Jun 24, 2002
Slide 1: Congestion Management Requirements
Congestion Management Requirements PICA 97 Paul Gribik Perot Systems Corporation
Slide 2: Congestion Management Drivers
Congestion Management Drivers... Market Structure Power Pool Bilateral Transactions Pricing Structure Marginal Cost Average Cost (Uplift) Goals Minimize Costs Minimize Changes
Slide 3: Congestion Management Drivers: Engineering Constraints
.....Congestion Management Drivers Engineering Constraints Line Flow Limits (MVA, MW) Voltage Limits Stability Contingencies Time Frame Forward Markets (Scheduling) Real Time (Dispatch)
Slide 4: Pool
Pool Supplies Loads PX & ISO Schedules, Energy Prices & Transmission Prices
Slide 5: Bilateral Transactions
Bilateral Transactions Supplies PX PX Schedule & Adjustment Prices Loads Bilateral Contract BC Schedule & Adjustment Prices ISO Supplies Loads Final Schedules & Transmission Prices
Slide 6: Marginal Cost Pricing
Marginal Cost Pricing Must produce economically meaningful marginal costs Minimize costs summed over all parties Enforce "hard" constraints A "little" violation can give nonsensical MCs
Slide 7: Average Cost Pricing (Uplift)
Average Cost Pricing (Uplift) No need to produce economically meaningful marginal costs Produce good cost (not necessarily minimum cost) schedules May take into account other goals More flexibility in objective Minimize cost Minimize movement Able to treat "soft" constraints via penalties A "little"
Slide 8: Congestion Management Software for Forward Markets
Congestion Management Software for Forward Markets Constraint Definition ATC Contingency Selection Security Constraints Optimal Power Flow Transmission Costs Marginal Cost of Enforcing Constraints Serving Loads Total Cost of Enforcing Constraints Uplift
Slide 9: Pool Optimal Power Flow (Marginal Cost Transmission Pricing)
Pool Optimal Power Flow (Marginal Cost Transmission Pricing) Objective: Minimize cost of resources Generation Load Reduction Controls: All resources. Constraints: Limits on resources. Enforce transmission constraints. Incorporate power flow model. Security: Contingencies.
Slide 10: Bilateral Transaction OPF (Marginal Cost Transmission Pricing)
Bilateral Transaction OPF (Marginal Cost Transmission Pricing) Objective: Minimize cost of adjusting schedules for all parties (PX and BC) Cost of adjusting schedules is measured by the adjustment prices provided by the parties. Controls: Resources of all parties. Constraints: Movement of a party's
Slide 11: Bilateral Transaction OPF (Transmission Costs as Uplift)
Bilateral Transaction OPF (Transmission Costs as Uplift) Objective: More possibilities Minimize costs for all parties Minimize the movement of the schedules for all parties Weighted sum of minimum movement and minimum cost. Controls: All parties resources. Constraints: Movement of party's schedule l
Slide 12: Ancillary Services
Ancillary Services The PX, ISO or BC parties may wish to use transmission capacity to meet ancillary services requirements: Extend models to take into account cost of AS supplies. Calculate impact of AS schedules on transmission system operation. Charge for effect of AS schedules on transmission sys
Slide 13: Congestion Management Software for Real Time
Congestion Management Software for Real Time Similar requirements to forward markets Simpler network models Transmission Constrained Economic Dispatch replaces OPF BC and PX Options Stick to schedule from forward markets Bid resources for adjustment in real-time Dispatch as a pool Separation would r
Slide 14: Congestion Management and Pricing in Day-Ahead and Hour-Ahead Markets
Congestion Management and Pricing in Day-Ahead and Hour-Ahead Markets Inter-Zonal and Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Slide 15: Contrast of Inter-Zonal and Intra-Zonal Congestion
Contrast of Inter-Zonal and Intra-Zonal Congestion Inter-Zonal Congestion Management Relatively more frequent on any given constraint Global effect Higher cost implications Marginal cost pricing Intra-Zonal Congestion Management Relatively infrequent on any given constraint Local effect Relatively l
Slide 16: Participants & Markets
Participants & Markets Schedule Coordinators (SCs) An SC manages its own "energy forward market" under its own rules. Submit balanced schedules to the ISO. (generation equals load) Compete for access to limited transmission. Inc/dec bids used in adjusting schedules if transmission congested. PX Inde
Slide 17: Overview of Day-Ahead Congestion Management
Overview of Day-Ahead Congestion Management Inter-Zonal Congestion Management & Pricing Intra-Zonal Congestion Management & Pricing Focus of Presentation Schedule Coordinators: Preferred Schedules Inc/Dec Bids Inter-Zonal Congestion? Schedule Coordinators: Revised Schedules Inter-Zonal Congestion Ma
Slide 18: Inter-Zonal Congestion Management
Inter-Zonal Congestion Management
Slide 19: Highlights of the Inter-Zonal Congestion Management Approach
Highlights of the Inter-Zonal Congestion Management Approach Schedule Coordinators: Each SC manages its own energy forward market. Any trades across SCs are arranged by the participants. The SCs compete for transmission on a level playing field. Transmission is comparably priced for all SCs. The ISO
Slide 20: The Phase I Filing on Congestion Management
The Phase I Filing on Congestion Management The ISO adjusts SCs' schedules when congestion exists: The ISO reschedules the SCs to maximize the economic utilization of transmission. "The ISO may ... adjust the scheduled ... generation based on the price bids, and then only as required to relieve cong
Slide 21: Marginal Cost Goals
Marginal Cost Goals The ISO must be able to develop accurate marginal costs when congestion exists. Locational Marginal Costs (Zonal or Nodal) Economic cost of an SC serving an increment of load at a location. Marginal Cost for Transmission Paths Economic cost of an increment of flow on a path. Marg
Slide 22: Guidelines
Guidelines Seemingly conflicting requirements: To produce accurate marginal costs, the rescheduling must find a minimum cost schedule. If we stop at an arbitrary point short short of an optimal solution, the marginal cost information may produce pricing anomalies. A small amount of congestion must n
Slide 23: Inter-Zonal Congestion Management
Inter-Zonal Congestion Management Objective: Minimize cost over all SCs. Cost of revising schedules is measured by the inc/dec bids provided by the SCs. Controls: Resources of all SCs in all zones. Constraints: Keep each SC's generation in balance with its load. The ISO does not impose trades betwee
Slide 24: Power Flow Model
Power Flow Model Use a linear DC power flow model for Inter-Zonal Congestion Management: Real power balance at each node. MW flow limits on zonal interfaces. Model losses outside of the power flow model by using multipliers.
Slide 25: Results
Results Each SC's forward energy market is cleared. The ISO's inter-zonal transmission forward market is cleared: The ISO allocates congested inter-zonal transmission to the most cost effective SCs. The ISO does not run an energy forward market. The ISO does not arrange energy trades. The SCs arrang
Slide 26: Bidding Options for an SC
Bidding Options for an SC An SC has several transmission bidding options: If it has resources on both sides of an interface: It can bid its incs/decs for those resources. The ISO will calculate the value of interface capacity to the SC. If it has resources on only one side of an interface and wants
Slide 27: Information Produced
Information Produced Schedules for each SC Marginal costs for each SC Marginal cost of an SC serving an increment of load at a node. Zonal marginal cost for each SC Weighted average of the SC's nodal marginal costs for the nodes in a zone. Inter-zonal interface constraint shadow costs Marginal value
Slide 28: Marginal Costs for SCs
Marginal Costs for SCs Marginal costs depend upon the SC: The schedule coordinators' energy forward markets are kept separate. Therefore, the marginal cost at a node or a zone will vary by SC. Differences between marginal costs at any two nodes (zones) do not depend upon the SC. Since congestion cha
Slide 29: Example
Example A B G1=700 MWh @ $10/MWh G2=0 MWh @ $20/MWh D1=100 MWh D2=600 MWh G3=700 MWh @ $30/MWh G4=0 MWh @ $60/MWh D3=100 MWh D4=600 MWh Schedule Coordinator 1 Schedule Coordinator 2 1000 MWh Flow Limit Actual Flow 1200 MWh Scheduled Flow: 600 MWh Scheduled Flow: 600 MWh SCs preferred schedules: Each
Slide 30: Rescheduling to Alleviate Inter-Zonal Congestion
Rescheduling to Alleviate Inter-Zonal Congestion A B G1=500 MWh @ $10/MWh G2=200 MWh @ $20/MWh D1=100 MWh D2=600 MWh G3=700 MWh @ $30/MWh G4=0 MWh @ $60/MWh D3=100 MWh D4=600 MWh Schedule Coordinator 1 Schedule Coordinator 2 1000 MWh Flow Limit Actual Flow 1000 MWh Scheduled Flow: 400 MWh Scheduled
Slide 31: Marginal Costs for Example
Marginal Costs for Example Marginal costs Increment D1 by 1 MWh, G1 increases 1 MWh SC1's marginal cost at A is $10/MWh Increment D2 by 1 MWh, G2 increases 1 MWh SC1's marginal cost at B is $20/MWh Increment D3 by 1 MWh, G3 increases 1 MWh SC2's marginal cost at A is $30/MWh Increment D4 by 1 MWh, G
Slide 32: Payments to be Calculated
Payments to be Calculated Inter-zonal congestion charges that the ISO collects from the SCs SCs pay for using congested inter-zonal transmission. SCs are not paid for adjusting their generation to relieve inter- zonal congestion. Adjusting an SC's schedule will affect the congestion charges that it
Slide 33: Calculating Congestion Charges the ISO Collects
Calculating Congestion Charges the ISO Collects Different ways to calculate the congestion charge to an SC:
Slide 34: Defining Zonal Marginal Costs
Defining Zonal Marginal Costs A schedule coordinator's zonal marginal costs are defined as a weighted averages of the SC's nodal marginal costs. Selection of weighting factors is important.
Slide 35: Congestion Revenues the ISO Pays
Congestion Revenues the ISO Pays We can calculate the congestion revenue due to a TO or a TCC holder: To balance congestion charges and congestion revenue:
Slide 36: Total Revenue Equivalence
Total Revenue Equivalence Total congestion charges collected by the ISO will equal congestion revenue using the recommended OPF model:
Slide 37: Preferred Schedules & Inc/Dec Bids
Preferred Schedules & Inc/Dec Bids 1 3 2 P1SC1 = 80 @ $5/MWh Flow = 40 MWh Flow limit = 100 MWh Reactance = 0.00002 Flow = 40 MWh Flow limit = 50 MW Reactance = 0.00002 Flow = 160 MWh Flow limit = 100 MW Reactance = 0.00001 P1SC2 = 120 @ $11/MWh 2i P2iSC1 = 0 @ $10/MWh P2iSC2 =0 @ $17/MWh P3SC1 = 0
Slide 38: Relieving Inter-Zonal Congestion
Relieving Inter-Zonal Congestion 1 3 2 P1SC1 = 0 @ $5/MWh Flow = 0 MWh Flow limit = 100 MWh Shadow Cost = $0/MWh Flow = 50 MWh Flow limit = 50 MW Shadow Cost = $4/MWh Flow = 100 MWh Flow limit = 100 MW Shadow Cost = $19/MWh MC1SC1 = $4/MWh MC1SC2 = $11/MWh MC2SC1 = $10/MWh MC2SC2 = $17/MWh MC3SC1 =
Slide 39: Inter-Zonal Congestion Payments
Inter-Zonal Congestion Payments SC1 to ISO Marginal CostZone 3 x 80 - Marginal CostZone 1 x 0 - - Marginal CostZone 2 x 30 - Marginal CostZone 3 x 50 = $300 SC2 to ISO Marginal CostZone 3 x 120 - Marginal CostZone 1 x 100 - - Marginal CostZone 2 x 20 - Marginal CostZone 3 x 0 = $1800 ISO to TCC on I
Slide 40: Marginal Cost Question
Marginal Cost Question To better understand the marginal costs, let's look at the marginal cost for Schedule Coordinator 1 at node 1: The cost of SC1's generator at node 1 is $5/MWh. The marginal cost for SC1 at bus 1 is $4/MWh. Why?
Slide 41: Marginal Costs after Relieving Inter-Zonal Congestion
Marginal Costs after Relieving Inter- Zonal Congestion 1 3 2 P1SC1 = 0 @ $5/MWh Flow = 0 MWh Flow limit = 100 MWh Shadow Cost = $0/MWh Flow = 50 MWh Flow limit = 50 MW Shadow Cost = $4/MWh Flow = 100 MWh Flow limit = 100 MW Shadow Cost = $19/MWh MC1SC1 = $4/MWh MC1SC2 = $11/MWh MC2SC1 = $10/MWh MC2S
Slide 42: One Possible Response to Incrementing Demand
One Possible Response to Incrementing Demand Let us add 1 MWh of demand for SC1 at node 1. Simple response would be for SC1 to increase its generation at node 1: P1SC1 changed from 0 to 1 MWh. Cost to SC1: SC1's costs increase by $5. SC2 does not change its generation: SC2's costs do not change. Tot
Slide 43: Optimal Response to Increased Load at Node with SCs Kept Separate
Optimal Response to Increased Load at Node 1 with SC's kept Separate SC1 could increase its generation at node 2 to serve the load at node 1: P2SC1 changed from 30 to 31 MWh. Cost to SC1 is $10. Because SC1 increased its generation at node 2, more transmission is available for SC2 to use to lower it
Slide 44: Why would SC1 Do This?
Why would SC1 Do This?... SC1 is not being altruistic. To see this, let's calculate SC1's costs before incrementing the load at node 1: Generation Costs: Sum of (Generation Cost * Generation) 0 MWh * $5/MWh + 30 MWh * $10/MWh + 50 MWh * $20/MWh = $1300. Congestion Costs: Sum of (Zonal Marginal Cost
Slide 45: Why would SC1 Do This? (continued)
.....Why would SC1 Do This? Now, lets calculate SC1's costs after incrementing the load at node 1: Generation Costs: Sum of (Generation Cost * Generation) 0 MWh * $5/MWh + 31 MWh * $10/MWh + 50 MWh * $20/MWh = $1310. Congestion Costs: Sum of (Zonal Marginal Cost * Net Load in Zone) (1 - 0) * $4/MWh
Slide 46: Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Slide 47: ISO Energy Purchases and Sales for Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
ISO Energy Purchases and Sales for Intra-Zonal Congestion Management The ISO may buy energy from one SC and sell it to another in managing intra-zonal congestion: Intra-zonal congestion management charges are based on actual costs, not marginal costs. No need to drive to minimum cost solution to be
Slide 48: Goals of Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Goals of Intra-Zonal Congestion Management In adjusting the scheduled resources in a zone, balance two objectives: Keep the shift in the schedules needed to alleviate intra- zonal congestion small. Use the most cost-effective resources. To relieve intra-zonal congestion in a zone, use the resources
Slide 49: Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Intra-Zonal Congestion Management The ISO may impose trades between SCs. Objective: Minimize the movement of the schedules for all SCs. Weight the movement by factors based on the inc/decs bid. Controls: All SCs' resources in the single zone addressed. Constraints: Movement of SC schedules limited t
Slide 50: Information Produced
Information Produced Schedules for each SC. Payments and charges for each SC for intra-zonal congestion management: An SC is paid for increased generation (or load management) at inc price bid for the resource. An SC is charged for energy to replace reduced generation at the dec price bid for the re
Slide 51: Network Power Flow for Intra-Zonal Congestion Management
Network Power Flow for Intra-Zonal Congestion Management Intra-zonal constraints may be more complex than inter-zonal MW flow limits: Modeling of VAR flows or amperes. Bus voltage problems. Use an AC power flow model. No impact on marginal costs calculated in inter-zonal CM. Does not affect basis of
Slide 52: Intra-Zonal CM Effect on Inter-Zonal Payments
Intra-Zonal CM Effect on Inter-Zonal Payments In relieving intra-zonal congestion, flows between zones may be affected for a variety of reasons. Payments by the SCs to the ISO for inter-zonal congestion will be based on the inter-zonal schedules and marginal costs: The schedules and marginal costs t
Slide 53: Relieving Intra-Zonal Congestion
Relieving Intra-Zonal Congestion 1 3 2 P1SC1 = 0 @ $5/MWh P1SC2 = 100 @ $11/MWh 2i P2iSC1 = 30 @ $10/MWh P2iSC2 =20 @ $17/MWh P3SC1 = 0 @ $20/MWh P3SC2 = 0 @ $35/MWh 3i P3iSC1 = 0 @ $35/MWh P3iSC2 = 50 @ $30/MWh D3iSC1 = 80 D3iSC2 = 120 Zone 2 Zone 3 Flow = 150 MWh Flow limit = 150 MW P3SC1 reduced
Slide 54: Intra-Zonal Congestion Payments
Intra-Zonal Congestion Payments SC1 pays the ISO to replace its generation reduced in Zone 3 (Reduction in P3SC1)*(Decremental Cost of P3SC1) = (50-0)*20 = $1000 ISO pays the SC2 for generation over its inter-zonal schedule generation in Zone 3 (Increase in P3iSC2)*(Incremental Cost of P3iSC2) = (50