UL Solutions Inc. · NYSE:ULS
UL Solutions — Underwriters Laboratories — Technical Presentation (2011)
58 slides from UL Solutions's technical presentation, Dec 28, 2011
Slide 1: Lead Free PCB Surface Finishes in Compliance with UL
Lead Free PCB Surface Finishes in Compliance with UL Presented by Crystal Vanderpan Underwriters Laboratories, Inc.
Slide 2: Crystal Vanderpan
Crystal Vanderpan • Principal Engineer for Printed Circuit Technologies • Joined UL in 1995 • Technical rep to UL STP for PCB and CCL standards • Subcommittee chairman ASTM D09.07 Electrical and Electronic Insulating Materials • Active in IEC TC15, Insulating Materials Specifications, TC91 Printed B
Slide 3: Lead Free Topics
Lead Free Topics • Legislation • PWB Industry Research and Testing • Material Choices and Processing • Tin Whiskers • UL Requirements – PWB and End Product • Recognition Options • Restricted Substance Compliance Solutions(RSCS)
Slide 4: Lead Free Movement
Lead Free Movement • Communication up/down the supply chain is key. • Switching to Lead Free involves the OEM, EMS, Assembler and PWB Fabricator, – to determine if Lead Free is the appropriate direction for the product.
Slide 5: Lead Absorption is Unhealthy
Lead Absorption is Unhealthy • Adversely affects human health – central and peripheral nervous system, – digestive tract, – blood production, – blood vessels, and – metabolism
Slide 6: Large Volumes of Waste
Large Volumes of Waste • Electronic waste increases 5% each year – New technology developments – Short product life cycles • Major source of hazardous substances to contaminate soil and ground water – Heavy metals – Organic pollutants
Slide 7: Legislation
Legislation • To help protect human health and decrease electronic waste, the EU adopted two Directives – WEEE (Waste from Electrical and Electronic Equipment) – RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances in Electrical and Electronic Equipment) • Similar legislation also adopted in – China, Japan, an
Slide 8: WEEE Directive
WEEE Directive Waste from Electrical and Electronic Equipment
Slide 9: WEEE Directive
WEEE Directive • Published February 2003 • Developed to – Reduce electronic waste levels – Encourage resource recovery – Mandates Product Recycle/Reuse/Recovery up to 85% • Deadline December 31, 2006
Slide 10: RoHS Directive
RoHS Directive Restriction of Hazardous Substances in Electrical and Electronic Equipment (Not Just Lead!)
Slide 11: RoHS Directive
RoHS Directive • Developed to – Support WEEE – Eliminate hazardous substances during the disposal and recycling of electronic waste – Restrict Substances in “Homogeneous Materials” • Deadline July 1, 2006
Slide 12: RoHS Directive: Restricted Substances
RoHS Directive • Restricted Substances • Cadmium • Hexavalent Chromium • Lead and Mercury & Their Compounds • Brominated Flame Retardants – Polybrominated Biphenyl (PBB) – Polybrominated Diphenyl Ether (PBDE) • Exempt Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA)
Slide 13: RS Common Uses
RS Common Uses Table reprinted from ERA Technology Report on “Possible Compliance Approaches for Directive 2002/95/EC (The RoHS Directive)”, April 2004
Slide 14: Electronic Equipment Affected by WEEE & RoHS
Electronic Equipment Affected by WEEE & RoHS • Large and small • Currently RoHS exempt appliances – Medical Devices • Tools – Monitoring and Control Instruments • IT Equipment • Telecommunications Equipment • Lighting • Toys • Sports equipment
Slide 15: Industry Research and Testing
Industry Research and Testing • Lead Free solder alloys used for over 10 years • Research in early 90s concentrated on – Alternate alloys – Assessment of basic properties such as • Toxicity, wetting and strength behavior
Slide 16: Industry Research and Testing
Industry Research and Testing • Recent research focusing on – Recommending standard alternate alloy – Additional properties such as • Fatigue, production behavior, and process optimization
Slide 17: Summary of Industry Research
Summary of Industry Research List of projects and summary available on the Electronics Industries Alliance (EIA) website. – Access thru http://leadfree.ipc.org/ website
Slide 18: Lead Free Material Choices
Lead Free Material Choices • Each material must be evaluated for its benefits and challenges. – Immersion finishes (Gold, Silver and Tin) – Electroless Nickel-Immersion Gold (ENIG) – Organic Solderability Protectants (OSP) – Tin-Silver-Copper (SAC) alloy pastes – HASL non-lead containing – Tin/Coppe
Slide 19: Lead Free Standard Material
Lead Free Standard Material • Majority of the electronic industry associations recommending: – SAC (Tin-Silver-Copper) alloys for reflow processing – SnCu for wave solder processing
Slide 20: Processing Temperatures
Processing Temperatures • Lead Free materials require 30°C to 45°C higher melting temperatures when compared to tin-lead solder. Soldering Material Melting Points and Associated Solder Pot Temperatures Solder Pot Material Melting Range (°C) Temperature (°C) Sn-Pb 183 – 188 250 Sn-Cu (99.3Sn/0.7Cu) 2
Slide 21: Higher Temperatures
Higher Temperatures • Create problems in the PWB – Delamination and warping – Thermal shock induced cracks – Damage to the components, such as • Plastic connectors, relays, LEDs, electrolytic and ceramic capacitors, etc.
Slide 22: Reflow Temperature Profile
Reflow Temperature Profile • Modifications required to – Prevent damage from higher temperatures – Wetting and solder joint formation problems – Overheating the assembly and components
Slide 23: Lead Free Reflow Temperature Profile
Lead Free Reflow Temperature Profile • Typical profile includes – Ramp rate of 0.5°C to 1.5°C per minute – Soak zone just below liquidous point to achieve a uniform temperature in the assembly – Spike up to peak melting point with minimum exposure to higher melting temperature
Slide 24: Typical Lead Free Reflow Profile
Typical Lead Free Reflow Profile 300 Peak Temp. 250 235 - 255°C Temperature (°C) 200 150 Reflow Zone Ramp Rate Soak Zone time above 217°C 0.5 - 1.5°C 120 sec. Max. 100 45 - 75 sec. 50 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 Time (seconds)
Slide 25: Lead Free Labeling
Lead Free Labeling • Identify Lead Free throughout assembly process – Board finishes – Components – Assembly solders • Identification is critical for reliable rework – Melting points of alternate finishes – Possibility of mixing alternate finishes
Slide 26: Tin Whiskers
Tin Whiskers • Common in pure tin and high tin content alloys (used as Lead Free surface finishes) • Create electrical shorts in high density circuitry
Slide 27: Tin Whiskers
Tin Whiskers • Caused by compressive stress in the build up plating • Stress will increase with time due to an intermetallic layer between tin and other metals • Whiskers more than 400 microns in length unusual
Slide 28: Tin Whisker Mitigation
Tin Whisker Mitigation • To relieve compressive stress – Nickel undercoat barrier – Annealing or reflow of tin plating – Additive to create tin alloy (such as bismuth or silver) • Risk free decision – Do not use pure or high content tin plating
Slide 29: Tin Whisker Accelerated Test
Tin Whisker Accelerated Test • No consensus exists on accelerated reliability test for whisker growth • The US (NEMI), Japan (JIETA), and Europe (NPL) are actively working together to develop acceptable global solutions
Slide 30: End Product UL Certification Program
End Product UL Certification Program • Based on PWB Recognized with – Flammability Rating – Maximum Operating Temperature (MOT) • Switch to Lead Free may not impact end product certification – Assuming PWB used with appropriate Recognized ratings
Slide 31: PWB UL Certification Program
PWB UL Certification Program • Monitors – Materials – Manufacturing process – Solder Limits – Maximum Operating Temperature – Flammability
Slide 32: Materials
Materials • Switch to Halogen Free – Not required for FR-4 boards • TBBPA is exempt in RoHS – Not required for PTFE boards • No Bromine or Chlorine content • High melting point (342°C)
Slide 33: Manufacturing Process
Manufacturing Process • Monitoring includes – Board surface finishes – Maximum temperature and exposure times • Process description includes “Solder” – Currently intended as tin/lead solder – Alternate Lead Free solders described by material constituents
Slide 34: Lead Free Plating Materials
Lead Free Plating Materials • Do not require testing to add – if UL Recognized process includes plating • Immersion finishes (Gold, Silver and Tin) • Electroless Nickel-Immersion Gold (ENIG) • Organic Solderability Protectants (OSP) – and • Solder limits are above Leadfree temperatures for assembler
Slide 35: Lead Free Materials
Lead Free Materials • No Silver Migration testing required – Immersion Silver – SAC alloys • Metal Finishes Data Acquisition task group (3-11g) researched using both Telcordia and UL test methods.
Slide 36: Lead Free Solder Materials
Lead Free Solder Materials • Industry Standards – Tin-Silver-Copper (SAC) alloy pastes – HASL non-lead containing • Tin/Copper • Tin/Silver
Slide 37: Leadfree Solder Processing
Leadfree Solder Processing • Require higher temperatures than tin/lead – SAC (260°C –270°C) – Sn-Ag (265°C – 275°C) – Sn-Cu (270°C – 280°C) • Affect both PWB and Assemblers
Slide 38: Solder Limits
Solder Limits • Represent maximum temperature and exposure time during the assembly process • Simulated on PWB samples through the thermal shock test – Designed to evaluate the physical fatigue of boards exposed to the anticipated assembly soldering temperatures (Solder Limits) • 288°C for 10 second
Slide 39: Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation
Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation • Testing required for higher temperature and exposure times – Manufacturing process – Soldering process
Slide 40: Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation
Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation • Required testing includes – Flammability – Conductor adhesion (Bond Strength) – Delamination and blistering
Slide 41: Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation
Lead Free PWB UL Evaluation • Time to complete evaluation with testing – 4 weeks (10 day conditioning) or – 12 weeks (56 day conditioning)
Slide 42: Options for Quicker UL Evaluation
Options for Quicker UL Evaluation • Evaluation time may be minimized – Submit request as early as possible – Notify UL of PWB manufacturer’s shipping date – Verify sample construction and preparation before submitting samples
Slide 43: Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont'd)
Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont’d) • Request appropriate manufacturing process description – Use UL FUS Procedure description pages to show modifications to • Materials • Processing temperatures and times
Slide 44: Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont'd)
Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont’d) • Request appropriate manufacturing process description – Test to the maximum temperatures and times including tolerances • (ie. 275 ± 5°C, test 280°C)
Slide 45: Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont'd)
Options for Quicker UL Evaluation (cont’d) • Request appropriate manufacturing process description – Test for multiple solder limits to reflect the assembly reflow process • Example: 180°C/120 sec, 217°C/100 sec, 265°C/20 sec, cool to room temp.
Slide 46: UL | RSCS for RoHS
UL | RSCS for RoHS RESTRICTED SUBSTANCES COMPLIANCE SOLUTIONS
Slide 47: Unclear Rules and Regulations
Different Limits are Standards Don’t Set in Different Exist Countries Methods of Testing Tracking Regulations Are not uniformly Around the Globe Accepted around Is a Challenge World Unclear Rules and Regulations Quality is Low, No Harmonization Quality Control is Exists Missing Some Companies are So
Slide 48: UL's Restricted Systems Compliance Solution
UL’s Restricted Systems Compliance Solution A single program meeting the needs of OEMs, thereby eliminating the need for suppliers to participate in multiple programs! OEM OEM OEM OEM OEM Regulators UL RSCS Team Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplier Supplie
Slide 49: Online Database (demo)
Edit View Favorites Tools Help = *k + % > OL @| Qsearch GiFavorites @Media B| Br SM ess [@htip://pla com/rsvp/index Go Links Product Type Select a Product All zr Category: Enter Desired levels (parts per million) empty entries will be ignored Lead: < [ppm Cadmium: < ppm Mecury: < ppm Total Chromium:
Slide 50: Online Database (demo)
le Edit View Favorites Tools Help Back vy 9 » O 2 | Qsearch Favorites PMedia S| Br S Hy S idress [@intip /{plastics.ul.com/rsvp/index.asp | @Go |Links >| (@) Restricted Substance Compliance Solutions Product Type Select a Product All = Category: Enter Desired levels (paul ‘Color Concentrates Lead: |
Slide 51: Online Database (demo)
Restricted Substance Compliance Solu rosoft Internet Ex le Edit View Favorites Tools Help ns Prototype - M rer provided by Underwriters Laboratories Back v % yO | Qsearch GiFavorites @mMedia B| de SM ~ SF ; Adress [@ http: /plastics.ul.com/rsvp/index.asp = eG @) Restricted Substance ee Solutions | N
Slide 52: Online Database (demo)
aL view Favunies Huu FIP y >» OF B| Qsearch GiFavorites @Media S| hy SMr S ‘ss fa http: //plastics.ul.com/rsvp/index.asp_ Restricted Substance Compliance Solutions C Vy h Soe ee Printed Wiring Boards » Enter Desired levels (parts per million) empty entries will be ignored Lead: < [1000 ppm Cadmium:
Slide 53: Online Database (demo)
4 Restricted Substance Compliance Solutions Prototype - Microsoft Internet Explorer provided by Underwriters Labi File Edit View Favorites Tools Help Back y > + Ol @| QSearch GiFavorites @Media ame Address [@ http: //plastics.ul.com/rsvp/index.asp @) Restricted Substance Compliance Solutions ny h AA
Slide 54: Lead Free Summary
Lead Free Summary • “Solder” no longer a term for only tin/lead • Tin whisker accelerated test still needed • Two Lead Free solders recommended as Standard by industry • Unique part designations requested by industry
Slide 55: To Test or Not to Test?
To Test or Not to Test? • Plating additions may not require testing • Higher temperatures may damage PWB and components – Flammability, Delamination and Conductor Adhesion to be re-evaluated by UL • Implementing suggested actions will help expedite UL evaluation process
Slide 56: Questions
Questions
Slide 57: Thank You!
T lenoomes lied _I Thank You!
Slide 58: Lunchtime
Underwriters Laboratories — Technical Presentation (2011) on 6ix