Aon plc · NYSE:AON
Aon — Technical Presentation (October 2015)
29 slides from Aon's technical presentation, Oct 14, 2015
Slide 1: Retirement and Investment Webinar Series
Retirement and Investment Webinar Series October 14, 2015 Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment
Slide 2: Year-End Retirement Planning—Financial Issues and Opportunities
Year-End Retirement Planning— Financial Issues and Opportunities • Joan Boughton • Eric Keener • Dan McFall • Alan Parikh • Brian Walker Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment
Slide 3: Agenda
Agenda Slide Section 1 Spot Rate Approach to Measuring Benefit Cost Section 2 Case Study: AT&T Section 3 Retirement Age Trends Section 4 Longevity Trends and Other Assumptions Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 3
Slide 4: Spot Rate Approach to Measuring Benefit Cost
Spot Rate Approach to Measuring Benefit Cost Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 4
Slide 5: Alternative Approaches for Measuring Benefit Cost
Alternative Approaches for Measuring Benefit Cost Traditional Approach Spot Rate Approach (Used by AT&T, calling it “full yield curve” approach) Plan sponsors using a corporate bond Alternative concept evolved at yield curve approach to measure their Aon Hewitt over past several years, benefit o
Slide 6: Determining Interest Cost: Comparing Two Yield Curve Approaches
Determining Interest Cost: Comparing Two Yield Curve Approaches Traditional Approach Aggregated Discount Rate of 4.33% Spot Rate Approach2 Observations on Spot $600 PBO-Weighted Average 6.0% Rate Approach Interest Cost Rate of 3.62% With upward sloping yield $500 5.0% curve, spot rate method reduc
Slide 7: Plan Sponsor Considerations
Plan Sponsor Considerations In discussions with the Big Four auditing firms in September 2015, the SEC Staff indicated that: They would not object to: – Use of the spot rate approach SEC – Treating a change in approach as a change in estimate applied prospectively Perspective Companies should di
Slide 8: Back Testing Analysis of Interest Cost Shows Volatility
Back Testing Analysis of Interest Cost Shows Volatility ABC Retirement Plan ($1B PBO) Estimated Reduction in Interest Cost Relative to Traditional Approach 10 9 Curve Flattened 8 Inverted Treasury 2004–2006 7 Curve 12/31/2006 Flat Corporate Bond Curve 6 12/31/08 5 4 $ Millions 3 2 1 0 Reduction in I
Slide 9: Prevalence of Inverted Yield Curve
Prevalence of Inverted Yield Curve Frequent question when considering changes to the Spot Rate Interest Cost: “How often does the yield curve invert?” Treasury curve AA corporate bond curve Inverted ~19% of days since Inverted ~9% of days since 1973 1962 but only rarely since the early 1980s Aon Hew
Slide 10: Spot Rate Interest Cost Sensitivity Analysis
Spot Rate Interest Cost Sensitivity Analysis Real issue for plan sponsors might not be inverted yield curves, but just changes in the slope of the yield curve from measurement date to measurement date Changes in slope of yield curve can lead to additional volatility for future year-over-year expen
Slide 11: Considerations in Adopting the Yield Curve Alternative
Considerations in Adopting the Yield Curve Alternative Potential Concerns Potentially higher expense if corporate bond yield curve becomes inverted Increased year-over-year volatility as yield curve changes Need to weigh – May be more difficult to budget pension expense, creating more variance b
Slide 12: Bond Matching Models
Bond Matching Models SEC has not provided their views related to bond matching model Aon Hewitt believes that the bond matching approach and the full yield curve approach are fundamentally the same since follow from same accounting guidance: – Select individual spot discount rates with respect t
Slide 13: Case Study: AT&T
Case Study: AT&T Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 13
Slide 14: Case Study: AT&T Inc.
Case Study: AT&T Inc. Background Historically AT&T used the traditional approach to determine Service Cost and Interest Cost for its pension and OPEB plans First adopter of AT&T applies mark-to-market accounting such the spot rate that gains and losses are recognized in the approach in Q4 curren
Slide 15: Retirement Age Trends
Retirement Age Trends Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 15
Slide 16: Longevity and Retirement Age Assumptions
Longevity and Retirement Age Assumptions Longer life Later retirement expectancy ages Steady increases in life expectancy Notable increase in retirement age Advances in treatment of heart since 2000 disease and cancer, public health Social Security changes, decline in improvements, smoking c
Slide 17: Actual Retirement Ages Have Increased
Actual Retirement Ages Have Increased Since 2005, the average age at which people retire has increased by about 1.4 years Sharp rise in people waiting until age 65-69 to retire (20.6% in 2005 to 33.5% in 2013) 66 Average Age at Retirement 65.4 Aon Hewitt believes 65 that retirement ages will con
Slide 18: Key Drivers of Rising Retirement Ages
Key Drivers of Rising Retirement Ages Retirement Demographic Structural Social Security income shifts shifts shortfalls Full eligibility age Decline in DB and Some industries Improved health rising to 67 by 2027, retiree medical struggling to retain status from 65 in 2002 and coverage worker
Slide 19: Traditional Retirement Triggers are Disappearing
Traditional Retirement “Triggers” are Disappearing Defined Contribution Triggers Less Likely to Drive Behavior than DB Value of Retirement Benefit 65 – Normal Retirement 62 – Unreduced Value of Retirement Benefit as % Pay Defined Benefit Defined Contribution 70.5 – Required Minimum 55 – Early Distri
Slide 20: Why Retirement Age Assumptions Matter
Why Retirement Age Assumptions Matter Typical Impact Greater Assumed Longevity Rising Assumed Retirement Ages Accounting Higher pension expense Lower pension expense Higher balance sheet liability Lower balance sheet liability Cash No impact until IRS revises Lower required contributions
Slide 21: Will Retirement Ages Continue to Rise?
Will Retirement Ages Continue to Rise? Questions for Plan Sponsors Are a greater proportion of Workforce employees working to Dynamics 65 or even later? Has this trend continued or even accelerated in the past Plan Are you experiencing few years? Design labor shortages in key functions as the
Slide 22: Longevity Trends and Other Assumptions
Longevity Trends and Other Assumptions Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 22
Slide 23: SOA Issues Updated Mortality Improvement Assumptions
SOA Issues Updated Mortality Improvement Assumptions On October 8, 2015 the Society of Actuaries (SOA) released updated mortality improvement assumptions for retirement plans (MP-2015) Reflects additional data that Social Security Administration has released since prior assumptions (MP-2014) wer
Slide 24: Actual Mortality Improvement Can Be Very Volatile from Year to Year
Actual Mortality Improvement Can Be Very Volatile from Year to Year Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 24
Slide 25: Updated Mortality Improvement Assumptions – Next Steps for Plan Sponsors
Updated Mortality Improvement Assumptions – Next Steps for Plan Sponsors Plan sponsors should consider reflecting new data in 2015 year-end disclosures and 2016 expense – Could use MP-2015 or an alternative assumption If reflect new data this year, auditors may expect Key Takeaways annual update
Slide 26: Other Assumption Considerations
Other Assumption Considerations Continued trend toward lower rates For typical plan, up EROA ~35 bp YTD @ 9/30 Yield curves have Consider explicit steepened assumptions for active alpha AHIC develops Discount Active based on buy- Rates Alpha rated manager performance Medical Trend In rec
Slide 27: Questions and Answers
Questions and Answers Email retirement@aonhewitt.com with questions for our speakers. Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment 27
Slide 28: Speaker Biographies
Speaker Biographies Joan is an actuary and Partner at the firm, co-leading Aon Hewitt’s national Retirement Joan Boughton Strategy and Design / IDEA team. She consults on HR and retirement strategy, design, implementation, administration, communication, financing, and ongoing plan management. Eric i
Slide 29: About Aon Hewitt
About Aon Hewitt Aon Hewitt empowers organizations and individuals to secure a better future through innovative talent, retirement and health solutions. We advise, design and execute a wide range of solutions that enable clients to cultivate talent to drive organizational and personal performance an