Kona Grill — Proxy Contest (April 2010)
27 slides from Kona Grill's proxy contest presentation, Apr 15, 2010
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Definitive Additional Materials - Kona Grill, Inc.
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than the Registrant x Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy
Slide 2: Schedule 14A filing fee information
(4) Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction: (5) Total fee paid: ¨ Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. ¨ Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the p
Slide 3: Letter to Fellow Shareholders of Kona Grill
April 15, 2010 To Our Fellow Shareholders of Kona Grill: We are writing to you regarding the upcoming 2010 Annual Meeting of Shareholders of Kona Grill, Inc. (NasdaqGM: KONA)(the “Company”) scheduled to be held on Wednesday, April 28, 2010. At the Annual Meeting, you have two slates of candidates fo
Slide 4: Nominee backgrounds: Thomas Lynch and Craig Miller
• Thomas Lynch. Mr. Lynch is an accomplished investor with a deep financial understanding of the restaurant industry. Mr. Lynch has a successful two decade track record of investing, having founded both Mill Road Capital and Lazard Capital Partners. Previously, he was a member of the private equity
Slide 5: Appointment of a Director to the Vacant 7th Board Seat
2. Appointment of a Director to the Vacant 7th Board Seat. We believe the Company and its shareholders are best served if the Board of Directors has substantial restaurant operation experience, restaurant board experience, and public company board experience. Therefore, we believe that the 7th Board
Slide 6: Excerpts of Presentation to RiskMetrics Group by Mill Road Capital
Excerpts of Presentation to RiskMetrics Group by Mill Road Capital, L.P. 2010 Annual Meeting of Shareholders of Kona Grill, Inc. April 8, 2010
Slide 7: Notice to Shareholders
Notice to Shareholders All stockholders of Kona Grill, Inc. are advised to read Mill Road's definitive proxy statement because it contains important information, including information relating to the participants in the solicitation of proxies in support of Mill Road's nominees for use at the 2010 a
Slide 8: Summary
Summary Comparison of Slates – There are 3 required areas of experience for Nominees: • Restaurant Operating • Restaurant Board • Public Company Board – Company’s Nominees lack all 3 – MillRoad’sNominees have an abundance of experiencein all 3 Poor governance at Board with consistent pattern of self
Slide 9: Mill Road Capital
Mill Road Capital Mill Road Capital: $250 million private investment fund based in Greenwich, CT Background: – Core group of former Blackstone professionals – Successful track record of public and private investing – Long-term focus with 12 year commitment from our investors Investment Strategy: – E
Slide 10: Situation Summary
Situation Summary Annual Meeting of Shareholders: April 28, 2010 Kona Grill’s Board of Directors – Staggered board with 3 classes – Board seats: 7 – Board seats filled: 6 – Class up for election has 3 seats Slate of Nominees – Company nominated 3 incumbent directors for re-election – Mill Road nomin
Slide 11: Kona Grill Board of Directors
Kona Grill Board of Directors Kona’s non-employee directors have no other – Restaurant Operating Experience – Restaurant Board Experience – Public Board Experience Relevant Experience (Non-Kona) Restaurant Public Name Background Operating Board Board Douglas Hipskind Gaia Leasing (commercial leasing
Slide 12: Kona Grill Board - Common Denominator
Kona Grill Board –Common Denominator This Board is a holdover from when Kona was private Kona is headquartered in Scottsdale, AZ and the first two units were in Arizona 4 of 5 outside directors are from Minnesota The former CEO, Marcus Jundt, is also from Minnesota Kona Common Director Shares Name A
Slide 13: Mill Road Nominees
Mill Road Nominees Mill Road’s nominees have extensive experience in each of the following critical areas: – Restaurant Operations – Restaurant Board of Directors – Public Company Board of Directors The Nominees – Larry Harris – Thomas Lynch – Craig Miller Relationship of the Nominees – All 3 Nomine
Slide 14: Nominee: Larry Harris
Nominee: Larry Harris Headline: 30+ Year Track Record of Operational Success in Restaurants Selected Restaurant Experience: – CEO, Chairman of Board and a Partner of Food ManagementPartners (10+ years) • Buffalo Wild Wings –franchisee (27 units open, 5 in development, 22 committed) • Zio’s Italian K
Slide 15: Nominee: Thomas Lynch
Nominee: Thomas Lynch Headline: Long-Term Investor with Significant Board Experience at Top Restaurant Performer Select Experience: – Founder & Senior Managing Director of Mill Road Capital (6+ years) – Founder & Senior Managing Director of Lazard Capital Partners (~3 years) – Managing Director of T
Slide 16: Nominee: Craig Miller
Nominee: Craig Miller Headline: 35+Year Career as Top Tier Restaurant Operator with Public, Restaurant Board Experience Selected Restaurant Experience: – President, CEO & Chairman of Ruth’s Chris Steak House (4+ years) – President, CEO of UNO Restaurants (Pizzeria Uno) (~20 years) – VP of Darden Res
Slide 17: Comparison of Slates
Comparison of Slates A summary comparison of relevant experience in the key areas illustrates the superior slate put forward by Mill Road Relevant Experience (Non-Kona) Restaurant Public Name Operating Board Board Douglas Hipskind None None None Anthony Winczewski Mark Zesbaugh Lawrence Harris Buffa
Slide 18: Governance Deficit
Governance Deficit Kona Grill has a set of policies that are inconsistent with good corporate governance Policy Examples – Staggered board – Plurality voting for directors – Shareholders do not have cumulative voting rights in elections – Shareholders can not call a special meeting – Shareholders ma
Slide 19: Governance Deficit: Culture of Self-Dealing
Governance Deficit: Culture of Self-Dealing The Board of Kona Grill has a consistent track record of self- dealing Key examples – In December 2008, the Board approved a financing in a non-competitive process for the sale of stock representing ~15% of the Company to the Chairman/CEO’s father at an ~2
Slide 20: Kona Grill Operational Performance
Kona Grill Operational Performance Compared to similar price points competitors, Kona has significantly under- performed along 2 key metrics: – Same-Store Sales Growth (SSS) – Unit Profitability (Rest. Operating Margin) 1 Year Change 3 Year Change Average Check (1) Rest. Op. Rest. Op. Restaurant Con
Slide 21: Kona Grill vs. RA Sushi
Kona Grill vs. RA Sushi Kona has materially under-performed its closest comparable, RA Sushi, even though it is less geographically exposed to the financial crisis… Kona Grill RA Sushi Difference Average Check : Food Check $16.35 $13.89 $2.46 Alcohol 7.55 7.16 0.39 Total Average Check $23.90 $21.05
Slide 22: Kona Grill New Unit Performance
Kona Grill New Unit Performance The decline in new unit revenue has resulted in Return on Invested Capital (ROI) significantly below targeted levels New Units All figures $mm, unless otherwise noted Targeted Q3 2009 Q4 2009 New Units (#) 5 6 New Units as % of Total 23% 26% Annual Revenue $4.5 $2.9 $
Slide 23: Kona Grill Stock Price Performance
Kona Grill Stock Price Performance Kona’s stock price performance significantly lags its peer group over all relevant time periods except the last year Stock Price Performance Over/(Under) Peer Group, defined by Performance vs. Time Period KONA 10-K (1) MRC (2) 10-K (1) MRC (2) Since IPO (Since 8/16
Slide 24: Stock Price Performance - Last Year Adjusted
Kona GrillStock Price Performance – Last Year Adjusted Although the Company Kona vs. Peer Group -- Last Year outperformed its peers over the last year by 22%-35%, 300% Mill Road Expression there is an extraordinary event of Interest 250% in this period th On May 18 , 2009, Mill Road 200% made a publ
Slide 25: Why Has Relative Performance Been So Poor?
Why Has Relative Performance Been So Poor? Lack of Restaurant Operating Experience – CEO’s • Marcus Jundt: no restaurant operating background • Mark Bartholomay: experience primarily in business development and franchising – Board of Directors Management Turnover – In the last 8 years, Kona has had
Slide 26: Mill Road Capital - Leadership Plan for Kona Grill
Mill Road Capital –Leadership Plan for Kona Grill Operating Performance – New CEO in place – can be successful with proper support structure – Focus on operations to improve customer experience • Elevate quality of raw protein inputs • Improve consistency of in-store execution • Increase training Le
Slide 27: Summary
Summary Comparison of Slates – There are 3 required areas of experience for Nominees: • Restaurant Operating • Restaurant Board • Public Company Board – Company’s Nominees lack all 3 – Mill Road’s Nominees have an abundance of experience in all 3 Poor governance at Board with consistent pattern of s