Campus Crest Communities — Proxy Contest (March 2015)
83 slides from Campus Crest Communities's proxy contest presentation, Mar 16, 2015
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement
p15-0941dfan14a.htm DFAN14A 1 of 82 Clinton Group 15-0941 Campus Crest Communities, Inc. 03/16/2015 04:32 PM SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. __) Filed by the Registrant [ ] Filed by a Party other than the Registrant [x] Che
Slide 2: Schedule 14A filing fee information
p15-0941dfan14a.htm 15-0941 Campus 03/16/2015 04:32 PM 2 of 82 Crest Communities, Inc. 4) Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction: 5) Total fee paid: [ ] Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. [ ] Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2)
Slide 3: Campus Crest Communities Must Evolve
Campus Crest Communities Must Evolve March 2015 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies This presentation shall not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Information contained herein is based on data o
Slide 4: Important Information
Important Information CLINTON RELATIONAL OPPORTUNITY MASTER FUND, L.P., CLINTON RELATIONAL OPPORTUNITY, LLC, CLINTON GROUP, INC. AND GEORGE E. HALL (COLLECTIVELY, "CLINTON"), SCOTT R. ARNOLD, RANDALL H. BROWN, WILLIAM A. FINELLI AND RAYMOND MIKULICH (THE "NOMINEES") AND CAMPUS EVOLUTION VILLAGES, LL
Slide 5: Agenda
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 3
Slide 6: An Introduction to Clinton Group and Campus Evolution Villages
An Introduction to Clinton Group and Campus Evolution Villages Clinton Group and Campus Evolution Villages Have Partnered on a Turnaround Plan for Campus Crest Communities, Inc. Clinton Group Campus Evolution Villages • Founded in 1991, Clinton Group is an SEC Registered • Founded in 2011, Campus Ev
Slide 7: Campus Crest Communities Overview
Campus Crest Communities Overview • Campus Crest Communities, Inc. is a self-managed, self- Stock Price Chart and Capitalization administered and vertically-integrated REIT focused on developing, owning and managing student housing $16 (44%) stock properties with three brands: price (25%) stock perf
Slide 8: Executive Summary
Executive Summary • Campus Crest’s common stock has performed poorly for shareholders as measured over any relevant period since the Company’s IPO in October 2010 • Operationally, we believe the Company has failed to execute well on a number of important fronts: – 40% of the Company’s properties are
Slide 9: Our Vision: Pro Forma for a Refreshed Board
Our Vision: Pro Forma for a Refreshed Board • The Board of Directors is reconstituted with Clinton Group’s nominees and two existing Board Members Shareholders • The Company hires Andrew Stark and Evan Denner as Chief Executive Officer and President/Chief Operating Clinton Group Board Nominees Offic
Slide 10: Campus Crest Has Consistently Underperformed Peers
Campus Crest Has Consistently Underperformed Peers Stock Price Performance Lags Peers Same Store Rental Revenue Per Bed Growth Below Peers1 100% 14% Return: 81% Return: 75% 50% Return: 61% 0% Return: (28%) -50% 6% -100% 1% Oct-10 Oct-11 Oct-12 Oct-13 Oct-14 Campus Crest American Campus Communities E
Slide 11: Issues Under Current Leadership
Issues Under Current Leadership We Believe the Board of Directors Has Failed As Fiduciaries to Shareholders Board Responsibility Results The Board has no student housing expertise and limited real estate and REIT expertise and has overseen years of poor execution and what we view as a misguided st
Slide 12: The Path Forward
The Path Forward Our Group Has Identified a Clear Plan to Execute Board Responsibility Plans for the Future Nominees have student housing, REIT, and real estate private equity expertise “Plug and Play” executive team can take over C-suite immediately bringing fully staffed and scalable managemen
Slide 13: Our Nominees' Expertise is More Relevant to Campus Crest
Our Nominees’ Expertise is More Relevant to Campus Crest Existing Board of Directors Daniel Simmons Richard Kahlbaugh Lauro Gonzalez- James McCaughan Denis McGlynn Co-Founder, Harbor Interim CEO and Moreno Partner, New Phase CEO and President, Retirement Chairman, Campus Crest Transformation Advisor
Slide 14: Our Group's Intended Executive Team is Far Superior
We Believe Our Group’s Intended Executive Team is Far Superior Clinton Group’s Proposed Executive Leadership Student Housing Acquisitions / REIT Development Operations Andrew Stark Capital Markets Evan Denner CEO, Campus Evolution Villages Chief Investment Officer, Campus Evolution Villages Former M
Slide 15: Agenda: The Case for Change
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 13
Slide 16: Underperformance Against Peers Since IPO
Underperformance Against Peers Since IPO • Management and the Board have a record of poor shareholder returns • CCG’s stock price has materially underperformed both the broader REIT index and its direct student housing peers since the Company's October 2010 IPO 100% Return: 81% Return: 75% 50% Retur
Slide 17: Underperformance Against Peers In Every Period
Underperformance Against Peers In Every Period 1-Year Performance 2-Year Performance 3-Year Performance 17% 24% 30% 24% 1% 12% -20% -20% -37% CCG ACC EDR CCG ACC EDR CCG ACC EDR 4-Year Performance Performance Since IPO 73% 81% 53% 61% -33% -28% CCG ACC EDR Source: CapitalIQ. CCG ACC EDR Note: Stock
Slide 18: CCG Has Consistently Underperformed Peers on Key Financial Metrics
CCG Has Consistently Underperformed Peers on Key Financial Metrics Rental Revenue per Bed (2 Yr CAGR)1 AFFO Growth (2 Yr CAGR) 1 EBITDA Margin (2014) 14% 38% 48% 42% 37% 24% 6% 9% 1% CCG ACC EDR CCG ACC EDR CCG ACC EDR Bad Debt Expense % of Rental Revenue (2014) SG&A % of Rental Revenue (2014) Debt
Slide 19: Performance Has Continued to Lag in Recent Quarters
Performance Has Continued to Lag in Recent Quarters • We believe a lack of real estate and student housing operating experience at Campus Crest continues to show in the Company’s recent performance • Financial metrics have continued to deteriorate after the management turnover • We believe field man
Slide 20: A History of Missing Guidance and Consensus Estimates
A History of Missing Guidance and Consensus Estimates Management Continually Reduces Guidance A History of Missing Consensus Estimates • Campus Crest has missed annual FFO guidance every • Campus Crest started missing consensus estimates in FY year since 2011, beginning immediately after the IPO 201
Slide 21: IPO Case Study – Poor Showing Right out of the Box
IPO Case Study – Poor Showing Right out of the Box…And Four Years Later the Company Is Still Underperforming First Quarter as a Public Co. Resulted in Disappointment Equity Market Reaction • On March 1, 2011 CCG reported its first quarter as a public (26%) stock company, resulting in negative analys
Slide 22: 40% of Campus Crest's Properties Are Below 90% Occupancy
40% of Campus Crest’s Properties Are Below 90% Occupancy • The trend in occupancy year over year has not been positive “As you would likely agree, and I don’t want to sound too cliché here, but running a Occupancy Y/Y student housing REIT isn’t rocket science…” Property Primary University Year Units
Slide 23: Disastrous Reputation in Many Markets: Arrests
We Believe Campus Crest has a Disastrous Reputation in Many Markets Abundance of Negative Press Speaks to CCG’s Mismanagement Arrests at The Grove (AZ Daily Sun, 12/24/14) Flagstaff • FPD to The Grove: Clean up your act – Flagstaff, AZ: “Throughout 2013 and the fourth quarter of 2014, several attemp
Slide 24: Disastrous Reputation in Many Markets: Construction Delays
We Believe Campus Crest has a Disastrous Reputation in Many Markets Abundance of Negative Press Speaks to CCG’s Mismanagement Construction Delays (WLKY, 8/25/14) • UofL 'extremely disappointed' in The Grove delays (WLKY, 8/25/14) – Louisville, KY: “The new complex, The Grove, was expected to be read
Slide 25: Examples of Poor Site Selection
Examples of Poor Site Selection The Grove – Lawrence, KS The Grove – Columbia, MO • 3 miles from University of Kansas campus • 2.5 miles from University of Missouri campus – 2014 Occupancy Rate: 74% – 2014 Occupancy Rate: 73% occupancy rate The Grove – Clarksville, TN The Grove – Las Cruces, NM • 1.
Slide 26: Subpar Construction Not Uncommon at Newly Completed Properties
Subpar Construction Not Uncommon at Newly Completed Properties CCG’s Poor New Development History Marred With Cases of Shoddy Construction and Delayed Move-ins • The Grove Apartments Denton: Improper construction leads to three injured in balcony collapse – In September, 2011 three individuals were
Slide 27: Campus Crest's Bad Debt Policy was Non-Existent
Campus Crest’s Bad Debt Policy was “Non-Existent”1 The Company was not Mindful of a Key Cost Driver: Bad Debt Expense • “But the issue is, is we got lax, to be honest with you, over the summer with these renewals and was very focused on leasing new people” – Robert M. Dann, Former Chief Operating Of
Slide 28: Development Cost Overruns
Development Cost Overruns “We acknowledge that our past focus on outside development activity has placed an increased strain on our balance sheet, our ongoing operations and our ability to execute.” – Ted Rollins, Q2 2014 Earnings Call • In 2014, announced impairments were proof that management had
Slide 29: Zealous External Growth Agenda Resulted in Unforced Operational Errors
Our View: Zealous External Growth Agenda Resulted in Unforced Operational Errors Focus on Development Left No One to Mind the Operations in an Operating-Intensive Business • Delayed development deliveries resulted in students having nowhere to live – Montreal, QC, Louisville, KY, Grand Forks, ND, Or
Slide 30: An Investment Gone Wrong: evo Montreal
An Investment Gone Wrong: evo Montreal Campus Crest Overpaid for a Bad Deal Management Admits to Poor Execution • The initial investment of $38mm was impaired to • “Montreal has not met our expectations and clearly has $16mm and is now carried at $10mm been -- had disappointing leasing results.” – S
Slide 31: Ill-Conceived Copper Beech Acquisition
A Look Closer: Ill-Conceived Copper Beech Acquisition We Believe the Deal Structure is an Indication of Poor Capital Allocation • Initial deal was announced in February 2013 as a two-stage acquisition: – Stage 1: CCG to acquire 48% stake in Copper Beech for $262mm (financed through an equity offerin
Slide 32: Balance Sheet Mess
Balance Sheet Mess Our View: Unsustainable and Irresponsible Capital Structure • Poor capital allocation decisions have left shareholders with a Balance Sheet with Debt / EBITDA of 15.4x, a meaningful competitive disadvantage to peers • Significant lack of capital markets expertise on the current Bo
Slide 33: Lavish and Unnecessary Corporate Overhead
Lavish and Unnecessary Corporate Overhead Campus Crest SG&A (as % of Sales) is 3x and 2x that of Peers Cumulative Compensation to NEOs (Dollars) 15% 17,234,920 13% 13% 10% 10,249,054 8% 5% 5% 5,436,467 3% 3% 3,548,100 0% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2010 2011 2012 2013 CCG EDR ACC The Board oversaw comp
Slide 34: Corporate Headquarters Construction Indicative of Spending Priorities
Corporate Headquarters Construction Indicative of Spending Priorities • We believe that the buildout of the corporate headquarters in Charlotte totaled approximately $3mm Luxurious Reception Areas and Executive Suites Five Star Amenities Source: Lam Studios, Inc. website. Globally Diversified Invest
Slide 35: Examples of Lavish Corporate Expenditure
Examples of Lavish Corporate Expenditure “Look, I can tell you this. We were not aware of the Teslas and the Maserati.” – Rick Kahlbaugh, Q3 2014 Earnings Call 2013 Tesla S; Property of the Company, used by former EVP 2014 Maserati Ghibli; Property of the Company, used by former COO Source: Stock ph
Slide 36: Outstanding Litigation
Outstanding Litigation We Believe Outstanding Lawsuits Point to a Negligent and Unresponsive Board and Management Team Balcony collapse in The Grove Denton • CCG was named in a lawsuit in Austin, Texas in July 2012 regarding the collapse of a balcony at The Grove Denton • Three residents fell from t
Slide 37: Management's Goals and Results On Its Own Scorecard
Management’s Goals and Results On Its Own Scorecard “Our goal as a public REIT is pretty straightforward. We need to maximize our economic occupancy, control our expenses, delever our balance sheet and derisk our business model. We're not student housing developers. We're financials stewards and cap
Slide 38: Intertwined Relationships among CCG's Fiduciaries
Intertwined Relationships among CCG’s Fiduciaries Ted Rollins served on Fortegra’s Board of Directors Cumulative Compensation: $519,544 Stock Value at Sale: $600,000 Richard Kahlbaugh Kahlbaugh previously CEO and Chairman of Fortegra Ted W. Rollins Interim CEO, Cumulative Compensation: $3,416,656 Fo
Slide 39: CEO's Investment Firm Bid for Kahlbaugh's Company
In August 2011, Campus Crest’s CEO, Ted Rollins’, Investment Firm Bid for Rick Kahlbaugh’s Company Company Policies August 25, 2011 “For purposes of this Code, a “conflict of interest” occurs when an individual’s private interest interferes, or appears from the …to acquire 100% of the stock of persp
Slide 40: Other Questions for the Board of Directors
Other Questions for the Board of Directors Appointed to the Board of Directors in April 2013. 2014 Annual Meeting Results: 27% Withheld, Running Unopposed Did not stand for election in 2013. 2013 Annual Meeting Results: Received $134,400 in compensation from CCG in 21% Withheld, Running Unopposed 20
Slide 41: Many Independent Views Agree with Us
Many Independent Views Agree with Us Analysts Supportive of Clinton and CEV, while Insiders Acknowledge Underwhelming Corporate Governance Analyst Commentary Analyst Ratings • “CCG’s public market existence has been a resounding failure.. However, a number of private operators likely possess the ski
Slide 42: Current Board Has Purchased Only $8,846 of CCG Stock Since the IPO
Current Board Has Purchased Only $8,846 of CCG Stock Since the IPO • Open market stock purchases by the current Board total only $8,846 vs. our nominees have already purchased over $150,000 of CCG stock in the open market • Board compensation has increased 70% since 2010 – yet the stock is down 44%
Slide 43: Where Has the Board Oversight Been?
Where Has the Board Oversight Been? Key Strategic Questions Campus Crest Strategic Repositioning, Page 8 (11/4/14) • Heavy board involvement in creation of investment strategy – How did the Company operate previously? – Why has nobody on the Board resigned? – Status of CEO search? • Reconstituted in
Slide 44: Agenda: Our Plan is Progress
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 42
Slide 45: Campus Evolution Villages - Mission Statement
Campus Evolution Villages - Mission Statement • Campus Evolution Villages – A New “BRAND” of Student Housing Company • CEV’s Philosophy: – More than heads-in-beds, deliver an experience to all constituents (residents, parents and universities) – Make a positive impact on our residents every day – Fr
Slide 46: We Can Provide the Total Solution
Our View: We Can Provide the Total Solution Corporate Vision: To make Campus Crest a Dominant Player in the Student Housing Industry C-Suite Executives and a Board with Cohesive, Plug and Play Scalable Student Significant and Proven Student Housing Housing Management Team with Hands- and Real Estate
Slide 47: We Are Prepared to Take Action to Fix Campus Crest
We Are Prepared to Take Action to Fix Campus Crest The Principals of Campus Evolution Are Excited About the Opportunity at Campus Crest Andrew Stark CEO, Campus Evolution Villages Evan Denner Former Managing Director, Cantor Fitzgerald Chief Investment Officer, Campus Evolution Villages Instrumental
Slide 48: Plug and Play Executives and Senior Management Team
Plug and Play Executives and Senior Management Team Andrew Stark Evan Denner • Over 25 years of hands-on real estate experience • Lead Campus Evolution Villages, a change agent and a veteran in the student housing business and leader in the student housing sector, from • Lead Campus Evolution Villag
Slide 49: Our Vision: Pro Forma for a Refreshed Board
Our Vision: Pro Forma for a Refreshed Board • The Board of Directors is reconstituted with Clinton Group’s nominees and two existing Board Members Shareholders • The Company hires Andrew Stark and Evan Denner as Chief Executive Officer and President/Chief Operating Clinton Group Board Nominees Offic
Slide 50: Campus Evolution Villages - A Snapshot
Campus Evolution Villages - A Snapshot • Founded in 2011 by Evan Denner and Andrew Stark – Stark had been involved in student housing business at its infancy as part of team that worked with ACC prior to IPO – Denner has significant capital markets experience, corporate acquisition experience, and p
Slide 51: Campus Evolution: Superior Operating Metrics vs. Campus Crest
Campus Evolution: Superior Operating Metrics vs. Campus Crest • We believe Campus Evolution Villages’ operating metrics are meaningfully superior to those of Campus Crest • We believe CEV’s highly experienced management team with proven track record of turning around underperforming properties is th
Slide 52: Campus Evolution: Case Studies
Campus Evolution: Case Studies 924 Bed Property 674 Bed Property Background / Initiatives Background / Initiatives • Purchased the property in December 2012 at 82% occupancy • Originally managed asset on behalf of a third party client • Replaced the entire on-site management team and subsequently pu
Slide 53: Plug and Play Executives
Plug and Play Executives • Management team experienced in leasing, day-to-day operations management • Strong brand culture and philosophy in place – Consistent messaging to all constituents (residents, parents and universities) o We believe this drives revenue, occupancy, minimizes concessions, incr
Slide 54: Campus Evolution Villages - Management Philosophy
Campus Evolution Villages - Management Philosophy Campus Evolution Villages Employees We Strive to Address the Desires of Stakeholders: Students, Parents and Universities Students • Well-Maintained, Fully Furnished apartments – “home away from home” • Proximity to Campus • Activity Programs and Supp
Slide 55: Immediate Operating Focus
Immediate Operating Focus Implementation of Leasing and Marketing Program University outreach (presidents, deans, housing, ESL, Community outreach athletics, clubs, university organizations) o Prospective local vendor marketing partners Full implementation of on-line leasing program o Local ta
Slide 56: Immediate Operating Focus (continued)
Immediate Operating Focus (continued) Asset by Asset Review Physical plant Composition of residents Revenue growth analysis Competitive place in the market Knowledge and ability of property Cost containment analysis Proximity to campus management NOI growth analysis Status of unive
Slide 57: Immediate Operating Focus (continued)
Immediate Operating Focus (continued) Reduction in Corporate Expenses Recognize savings from personnel consolidation Create and implement centralized systems Implement cost controls, policies, and procedures at both Trim all “luxury” fat such as multiple planes, automobiles, corporate and pr
Slide 58: Restoration of Growth Profile
Restoration of Growth Profile Our Group Has A Plan to Restore the Growth Profile of the Company • Growth will return as a priority to the Company upon our Group’s Option to Buy Campus Evolution Villages Owned Assets stabilization of the business • Potential acquisition of Campus Evolution’s Manageme
Slide 59: Untangling the Balance Sheet Mess
Untangling the Balance Sheet Mess Our Group Has A Plan to Rehabilitate the Balance Sheet • Our Group would seek to bring capital partners to the table to Create Rehabilitation JV for Troubled Properties monetize underutilized and undeveloped assets to raise cash and Investors reduce debt – Campus Cr
Slide 60: Critical Timing is Now
Critical Timing is Now We are Confident that Our Group Is Equipped to Take On the Challenges Today • Preleasing season moving on without what we view as proper management and know-how to maximize leasing while minimizing concessions and avoid filling beds with the wrong residents • We believe the ma
Slide 61: 100+ Day Plan – Ensuring Progress and a Seamless Handoff
100+ Day Plan – Ensuring Progress and a Seamless Handoff May 2015 June 2015 July 2015 August 2015 M T W T F M T W T F M T W T F M T W T F 27 28 29 30 1 1 2 3 4 5 29 30 1 2 3 27 28 29 30 31 4 5 6 7 8 8 9 10 11 12 6 7 8 9 10 3 4 5 6 7 11 12 13 14 15 15 16 17 18 19 13 14 15 16 17 10 11 12 13 14 18 19 2
Slide 62: Agenda: Significant Value Destruction in Management's Current Plan
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 60
Slide 63: A Recap of the Company's Current Plan
A Recap of the Company’s Current Plan • On November 4, 2014, Campus Crest disclosed the following turnaround plan at the NAREIT conference Our Observations How credible is a promise of enhanced corporate governance? At the time this was composed, was there no desire to institute a CEO with student h
Slide 64: Board's Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value
We Believe the Board’s Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value Stated Intent Board Action/Results to Date Our Group’s Observations Enhance Corporate • CCG hired Korn Ferry to • No directors have been added Governance search for REIT-experienced • Korn Ferry and FPL were only hired after directors Cl
Slide 65: Board's Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value
We Believe the Board’s Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value Stated Intent Board Action/Results to Date Our Group’s Observations Focus on Operational • Q4 2014 FFO results were • Management does not have the experience or a Excellence $0.05 per share versus plan to turn around the Company’s operat
Slide 66: Board's Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value
We Believe the Board’s Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value Stated Intent Board Action/Results to Date Our Group’s Observations Adjust Dividend Policy • Reduced dividend by 45% • Payout ratio is still greater than 100% • Announce a sustainable dividend policy based upon • Did CCG cut the dividend
Slide 67: Board's Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value
We Believe the Board’s Actions Have Continued to Destroy Value After the resignations of Ted Rollins and Donnie Bobbitt, the current Board of Directors has free reign of the Company Stated Intent Board Action to Date Our Group’s Observations • Discontinued internal • Only student housing REIT we are
Slide 68: In the Meantime, Who is Running the Company?
In the Meantime, Who is Running the Company? “Yes, I do plan to stay involved and I am sorry if I was not clear about that issue. The Existing Executive Leadership BOD would like me to serve as the permanent Chair and CEO for the next 5 or so years. After that, I am riding off into the sunset.” - Ri
Slide 69: Plan to Execute – Existing Team
Plan to Execute – Existing Team Improving Restoring Operations Growth Implemented improvement in both hiring and training the property level staff Proactive approach to identifying a pipeline of qualified candidates Created operational excellence group Begun best practice review of Copper Be
Slide 70: Plan to Execute – Our Prospective Team
Plan to Execute – Our Prospective Team Improving Restoring Operations Growth ↑ Implement leasing and marketing program ↑ Current acquisition of Campus Evolution’s Management Company • University outreach/ community outreach • Full implementation of online leasing • Adds over 10,000 beds • Adopt CRM
Slide 71: Chairman Rick Kahlbaugh – The Fortegra Experience
Chairman Rick Kahlbaugh – The Fortegra Experience Rick Led Fortegra Down a Very Similar Path – Ultimate Demise Was Sale to Tiptree Financial • Lead Independent Director • Chairman, CEO Role IPO - • Executive Chairman and Interim CEO Present • Currently Non-Executive Chairman? Stock Price • IPO Price
Slide 72: Executive Team Comparison
Executive Team Comparison The Broader Campus Evolution Team Has Deep Student Housing, Real Estate Operating and Capital Markets Experience Campus Evolution Team Current Campus Crest Team Andrew Stark Evan Denner Richard Kahlbaugh • CEO, Campus Aaron Halfacre • Chief Investment Officer, • Interim CEO
Slide 73: Agenda: Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 71
Slide 74: Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders
Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders Existing Paradigm Underperforming Management Terminated Executive Team Strategic Alternatives, i.e. Poor Property-Level w/o Alternative Leadership Operations “Sell the Company” Failed Vertical Integration Exited Development Years of Value Destruct
Slide 75: Ensuring a Fair Transaction with Campus Evolution Villages
Ensuring a Fair Transaction with Campus Evolution Villages Hiring the Executive Team Purchasing the Management Company • Our nominees have negotiated and vetted the • Our nominees have negotiated and vetted the parameters of executive contracts for Andrew initial parameters to acquire Campus Evoluti
Slide 76: Ensuring Fair Transactions in the Future
Ensuring Fair Transactions in the Future Board of Directors Special Committee (Comprised of Independent Directors) Evaluating JV Opportunities or a Purchase of Campus Evolution Villages’ Owned Properties • The Special Committee will evaluate the feasibility • Any JV transactions with Campus Evolutio
Slide 77: Why this is NOT Simply a Hostile Takeover Without Paying a Premium
Why this is NOT Simply a Hostile Takeover Without Paying a Premium • Our activities are in the spirit of improving the operations of the Company and ensuring a corporate governance and executive leadership structure built for the long-term • Clinton Group is bearing significant expense to pursue thi
Slide 78: Proposed Corporate Governance Changes
Proposed Corporate Governance Changes • Our nominees are committed to seeking the following corporate governance changes: • Extensive stock ownership guidelines (open market purchases) for all directors and officers commensurate with annual compensation and tenure • Removal of directors for any reas
Slide 79: Agenda: Conclusion
I Executive Summary II The Case for Change III Our Plan is Progress IV Significant Value Destruction in Management’s Current Plan V Ensuring our Objectivity Post Annual Meeting VI Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 77
Slide 80: Conclusion
Conclusion • Simply put, we believe our nominees would constitute a better Board of Directors, and our plan to bring in the management of Campus Evolution Villages is far superior to the Company’s current interim management • The management team of Campus Evolution Villages is poised, capable and ex
Slide 81: Words of Encouragement from Our Peers in Student Housing
Words of Encouragement from Our Peers in Student Housing “Andrew, good luck with your proxy on Campus Crest. For the last year or so have always thought Campus Crest was poorly managed and ripe for a take over. Nobody else had the "stomach" / "guts" to take it on when I raised it with them. I think
Slide 82: Contact Information
Contact Information Clinton Group Corporate Office: 601 Lexington Avenue 51st Floor New York, New York 10022 Contacts: Joseph A. De Perio, Senior Portfolio Manager Tel: +1 (212) 825 0400 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 80
Slide 83: Disclaimers
Disclaimers CLINTON DOES NOT ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS. THIS PRESENTATION DOES NOT RECOMMEND THE PURCHASE OR SALE OF ANY SECURITY. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES IS THIS PRESENTATION TO BE USED OR CONSIDERED AS AN OFFER TO SELL OR A SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER BUY ANY SECURITY. THE PARTICI
Campus Crest Communities — Proxy Contest (March 2015) on 6ix