PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (May 2019)
18 slides from PDC Energy's proxy contest presentation, May 15, 2019
Slide 1: Setting the Record Straight on PDC's Underperformance
Setting the Record Straight on PDC’s Underperformance May 14, 2019
Slide 2: Performance since Bart Brookman's appointment as CEO
2 Since Bart Brookman’s Appointment to CEO in January of 2015: • Cumulative net income (loss): ($560) million • Cumulative impairments: $924 million • Cumulative net cash flow: negative $1.63 billion • Board metrics achieved: 10 of 21 • Cumulative executive compensation 2 : $55.7 million • Average b
Slide 3: Wattenberg: PDC is a Peer Performer in a Mature Basin
3 PDC’s well performance has been above average in a maturing basin, driven largely by quality of acreage. Wattenberg: PDC is a Peer Performer in a Mature Basin 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 NBL COP EOG PDCE XOG SRCI APC BCEI HPR WLL IP90 boe /d per 1,000ft IP90 boe/d per 1,000ft (20:1 gas oil ratio) Sourc
Slide 4: Delaware: Well Costs Don't Correlate to PDC Claims
4 PDC claims it has driven material efficiencies in its Delaware Basin operations. However, well costs have escalated and remain materially above peers. Actual Well Costs 2 PDC Presentation 1 Delaware: Well Costs Don’t Correlate to PDC Claims 1) From PDC’s presentation filed on 5/14/19. 2) Based on
Slide 5: Delaware: PDC Well Underperformance v Kimmeridge Well Performance
5 PDC claims it “has significantly improved upon Kimmeridge's Delaware operations.” These claims are ‘substantiated’ by one well. A comparison using the full dataset tells a completely different story. Kimmeridge Analysis: All Wells 2 PDC Analysis: Cherry Picked Well 1 Delaware: PDC Well Underperfor
Slide 6: Delaware: PDC Well Performance v Peers
6 PDC claims that its “wells perform favorably relative to other Delaware Basin operators”. PDC’s data reflects a 6:1 gas oil ratio. Adjusting this ratio to 20:1 properly reflects the relative economics between oil and gas production and shows that PDC’s wells have been performing below the basin av
Slide 7: Delaware: Third Party Data Confirms PDC Has an Underperforming Asset Team
7 A recent RS Energy report suggests that PDC’s average (Delaware - only) NPV/well in 2018 was $3M, materially less than offset wells which averaged nearly $7M. This equates to $124M of lost value in 2018 based on the 31 wells PDC drilled during the year. It also represents 5% of PDC’s current marke
Slide 8: Disappearing Delaware Locations: Net -334 on a MRL Basis
8 • As of 2017 PDC claimed to have 540 locations on a MRL lateral basis. • Taking into account 2017 TILs and the write down of 40 Culberson locations, this was revised to 490 (YE 2017 inventory), or 690 including the “additional inventory” which was subject “to a higher degree of uncertainty as they
Slide 9: Impairments Do Represent Value Destruction
9 PDC claims that “impairments do not reflect value destruction”. Kimmeridge believes impairments reflect real cash losses to investors as is reflected in equity performance. Impairments Do Represent Value Destruction $162 $172 $457 $916 $924 ($2,000) ($1,500) ($1,000) ($500) $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 2
Slide 10: Recycle Ratio: Flattering Numbers with Inflated PUDs
10 PDC’s interpretation of recycle ratio includes proven undeveloped (“PUD”) reserves. Kimmeridge excludes PUD reserves because the capital to develop these reserves has not yet been deployed. Kimmeridge Recycle Ratio – PD reserves only 2 PDC Recycle Ratio - includes PUD reserves 1 Recycle Ratio: Fl
Slide 11: Overstating PUD Reserves v Peers to Flatter Metrics
11 PDC books PUD reserves aggressively compared to its internally defined peer group. This has the effect of increasing PDC’s recycle ratio projection. Kimmeridge’s recycle ratio utilizing PD reserves serves as a better apples - to - apples comparison, and a reflection of the real cost of reserve ad
Slide 12: PDC's Ever Changing Peer Group – 30 in 5 Years
12 Source: PDC’s proxy statements filed during the Period. PDC has a history of adjusting its peer group and comparing itself to companies that end up filing for bankruptcy. PDC’s Ever Changing Peer Group – 30 in 5 Years = delisted and/or entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy = new peer FANG removal due to
Slide 13: SG&A: Kimmeridge Proposed Reductions are in line With Peers
13 CDEV and SRCI, the most direct peers to PDC, are both materially below trend on employees and costs. Benchmarking to these peers in 2018 implied an $80M reduction in SG&A. Kimmeridge Proposed G&A Based on Peers 2 PDC Chart 1 PDC Key assumptions 2018 DJ Production 84.0 2018 Implied DJ G&A $64.2 Us
Slide 14: No Accountability: PDC's Constantly Changing Metrics
14 PDC’s ever - changing metrics, inability to meet targets and lack of accountability, have been factors in the company’s underperformance. No Accountability 1 PDC Metrics: Board and Presentations 1 • Production growth • Cost structure vs budget • Drilling feet per day • Average completion costs •
Slide 15: PDC's Self Serving Claim is Misguided
15 Kimmeridge is more aligned with current shareholders than PDC’s management team and board of directors. Kimmeridge Alignment PDC Alignment • Management and the Board own approximately 1% of PDC’s equity • Management continues to benefit irrespective of share price performance and operational unde
Slide 16: A New Board for a New Business Model
16 • Kimmeridge is nominating three directors for PDC’s eight - person board at the Company’s 2019 annual shareholder meeting. • Kimmeridge’s candidates have extensive experience as investors and asset owners. • Kimmeridge currently owns 5.1% of PDC. Kimmeridge’s position is unhedged and does not us
Slide 17: Kimmeridge's Director Nominees
17 Kimmeridge’s Director Nominees: GOLD
Slide 18: The views expressed in this presentation represent the opinions of Kimmeridge Energy Management Company,
18 The views expressed in this presentation represent the opinions of Kimmeridge Energy Management Company, LLC and its principa ls and affiliates (Kimmeridge) including certain privately offered investment funds sponsored or advised by Kimmeridge that own shares of common stock of PD C E nergy, Inc