Stillwater Mining — Proxy Contest (April 2013)
41 slides from Stillwater Mining's proxy contest presentation, Apr 9, 2013
Slide 1: Enhancing Stockholder Value at Stillwater Mining Company
I N FRASTRUCTURE | A G I L I T Y | E X P E R T I S E Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies This presentation shall not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities . Information contained herein is based on
Slide 2: Important Information About This Solicitation
Page 1 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Important Information About This Solicitation CLINTON RELATIONAL OPPORTUNITY MASTER FUND, L.P., CLINTON MAGNOLIA MASTER FUND, LTD., CLINTON SPOTLIGHT MASTER FUND, L.P., CLINTON RETAIL OPPORTUNITY PAR
Slide 3: I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees
Page 2 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value V Questions for Incumbent Directors
Slide 4: Stillwater Mining Company Overview
Page 3 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Stillwater Mining Company Overview ▪ Largest miner of Platinum Group Metals (PGMs) in North America (and only producer in the US) - Produces over 500,000 ounces of palladium and other PGMs per year -
Slide 5: Stillwater Has Performed Poorly Under This Board
Page 4 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies $6.00 $10.00 $14.00 $18.00 $22.00 $26.00 Stillwater Has Performed Poorly Under This Board ▪ Hallmarks of underperformance are objective and clear : – Since start of CEO tenure, PGM basket price is up
Slide 6: This Board Is to Blame for Stockholders Losing Billions
Page 5 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies This Board Is to Blame for Stockholders Losing Billions ▪ Controlling stockholder announced its intention to sell in April 2010 ▪ The incumbent Board then made many decisions that destroyed value : –
Slide 7: Stockholders Should Empanel a New Board
Page 6 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Stockholders Should Empanel a New Board ▪ A new, independent and qualified Board can help solve the Company’s issues – We do not believe the directors who created the issues can be relied upon to sol
Slide 8: Clinton Group Nominees Have Decades of Relevant Experience
Page 7 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Patrice Merrin Former Mining CEO, Board Chairman Gov. Brian Schweitzer Regulations, Worker Relations and Montana Seth Gardner Private Equity Investor Auto Experience Dr. Charles Engles Former SWC CEO
Slide 9: I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees
Page 8 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value V Questions for Incumbent Directors
Slide 10: Value Destruction Despite Flat Metals Prices
Page 9 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% Feb-01 Feb-02 Feb-03 Feb-04 Feb-05 Feb-06 Feb-07 Feb-08 Feb-09 Feb-10 Feb-11 Feb-12 Feb-13 SWC Basket Price Value Destruction Despite Flat Metals Prices Despite 21 m
Slide 11: Stockholders Have Suffered Over the Long Term
Page 10 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies $0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 Cash Costs Per Ounce Stockholders Have Suffered Over the Long Term Source: Capital IQ and Company filings. (1) Represents proven and probable reserves divided by annual p
Slide 12: Judging Performance On the Incumbent's Own Scorecard
Page 11 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Judging Performance On the Incumbent’s Own Scorecard All the key performance metrics previously cited by the Company are declining Source: Company filings and investor presentation dated March 2011.
Slide 13: Recent Board Decisions Have Destroyed Value
Page 12 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies ▪ Discovered error in Marathon due diligence model that overstated the property’s resources ▪ “Palladium metal content was overestimated.” ( 1) ▪ Addition of Peregrine introduced multi - billion cap
Slide 14: Strategy Shift Was Unwelcome and Led to Stockholders Selling
Page 13 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Strategy Shift Was Unwelcome and Led to Stockholders Selling “[W]e are creating a leading mid - cap diversified mining company with a strong financial profile and a robust growth pipeline across att
Slide 15: Marathon Acquisition
Page 14 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies $0.00 $1.00 $2.00 $3.00 $4.00 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 May-10 Sep-10 “Management believes the effect is likely to be some deterioration in both the project economics and in the estimate of proven
Slide 16: Peregrine Acquisition
Page 15 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies $0.25 $0.75 $1.25 $1.75 $2.25 $2.75 $3.25 $7.00 $9.00 $11.00 $13.00 $15.00 $17.00 $19.00 $21.00 $23.00 $25.00 ▪ In July 2011, Stillwater announced the acquisition of Peregrine, an undeveloped copper
Slide 17: Investor Reaction to Peregrine Acquisition
Page 16 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies “ This foray into another continent to buy a different kind of metal that is far from developed and pay a high price -- it raises a lot of question marks …It’s a disappointment . ” – Federated Inves
Slide 18: Costs Are Bloated And Untied To Productivity
Page 17 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies $100 $140 $180 $220 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 $ ('000s) Costs Are Bloated And Untied To Productivity Director Compensation Source: Company filings. G&A Marketing Spending CEO Compensation N
Slide 19: Marketing Spend and Palladium Alliance
Page 18 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Celebrity Endorsements Paid For By Stillwater (4) Rose McGowan Kelly Osbourne Pamela Anderson Ounces of Palladium Jewelry Sold Vs. Marketing Spend (3) ▪ Stillwater set up the Palladium Alliance Inte
Slide 20: Dilutive Convertible Bond Issuance
Page 19 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies ▪ On October 12, 2012, Stillwater issued $396.75 million of 1.75% convertible bonds that mature in 2032 – Bonds contain an atypical feature which allows investors to receive additional shares upon c
Slide 21: Executive Compensation Is Excessive and Untied to Performance
Page 20 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies -$100 $0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600 $700 $800 $900 -$2,000 $0 $2,000 $4,000 $6,000 $8,000 $10,000 $12,000 EBITDA ($ mms) Enterprise Value ($ mms) 2012 Peers 2012 Stillwater 2011 Peers 2011 Stillw
Slide 22: I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees
Page 21 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value V Questions for Incumbent Directors
Slide 23: Credentials of Independent Nominees and Existing Directors
Page 22 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Credentials of Independent Nominees and Existing Directors The Nominees are well - qualified to align Stillwater with stockholders’ interests Source: Company filings. Independent Nominees Existing I
Slide 24: Dr. Charles Engles
Page 23 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Dr. Charles Engles Dr . Engles is currently an independent consultant. Since May 2012, he has served as Senior Director of PatentBridge LLC, an intellectual property brokerage firm. Since October 20
Slide 25: Mick McMullen
Page 24 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Mick McMullen Mr . McMullen currently serves as a Principal at MRI Advisory AG, a private company focusing on the development of metal and min era ls projects in the Americas, Europe and Africa. Sin
Slide 26: Patrice Merrin
Page 25 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Patrice Merrin Ms . Merrin is currently Chairman of the Board of Directors of CML HealthCare, Inc., a leading provider of private laboratory te sti ng services, as well as a member of the Nominating
Slide 27: Seth Gardner
Page 26 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Seth Gardner Seth Gardner formerly served as the founding Executive Director of the Center for Financial Excellence at Duke University’s Fuqua Sch ool of Business in Durham, North Carolina from 2009
Slide 28: Michael McNamara
Page 27 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Michael McNamara In January 2013, Mr. McNamara joined Dominick & Dominick LLC, a wealth management and investment services firm, where he is a Managing Director of natural resources investment banki
Slide 29: Governor Brian Schweitzer
Page 28 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Governor Brian Schweitzer Mr . Schweitzer most recently served as Governor of Montana, from January 5, 2005 to January 7, 2013. Gov. Schweitzer maintained on e of the highest approval ratings among
Slide 30: Gregory Taxin
Page 29 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Gregory Taxin Greg Taxin is a Managing Director of the Clinton Group, where he has served since June 2012. Prior to joining Clinton, Mr. Taxin w as the Managing Member of Spotlight Advisors (and its
Slide 31: I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees
Page 30 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value V Questions for Incumbent Directors
Slide 32: Plan Going Forward
Page 31 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Plan Going Forward ▪ End d iversification s trategy ▪ Evaluate Marathon and Altar from a fresh p erspective Board Responsibility Previous Decisions The New Direction (1) ▪ Return Stillwater to a pur
Slide 33: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
Page 32 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active o versight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change End Diversification Strategy and E
Slide 34: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
Page 33 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active o versight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change Consider Pricing Collars and Off -
Slide 35: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
Page 34 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active o versight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change Evaluate and Optimize Capital Stru
Slide 36: I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees
Page 35 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I Executive Summary II Stillwater’s Record of Underperformance III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value V Questions for Incumbent Directors
Slide 37: Questions for Incumbent Directors
Page 36 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Questions for Incumbent Directors ▪ As recently as November 2012 you indicated your desire to do more acquisitions and “establish a broader operating base” somew her e “around the world.” (1) You di
Slide 38: Questions for Incumbent Directors
Page 37 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Questions for Incumbent Directors ▪ You have described the “Palladium Alliance International” as a “industry trade group” to which the Company makes “contributions .” ( 1) The Company has said the A
Slide 39: Questions for Incumbent Directors
Page 38 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Questions for Incumbent Directors ▪ In calculating your executive pay, you use a “scorecard” approach to evaluating management. Because stock price has not been a f act or, in 2012 you paid the CEO
Slide 40: Contact Information
Page 39 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Contact Information Clinton Group Corporate Office: 601 Lexington Avenue 51tst Floor New York, New York 10022 Contacts: Gregory P. Taxin, Managing Director Tel: +1 (212) 825 0400
Slide 41: Disclaimers
Page 40 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Disclaimers CLINTON DOES NOT ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS . THIS PRESENTATION DOES NOT RECOMMEND THE PURCHASE OR SALE OF ANY SECURITY . UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES IS THIS PRESENTATION