Rovi — Proxy Contest (April 2015)
20 slides from Rovi's proxy contest presentation, Apr 22, 2015
Slide 1: Engaged Capital’s Additional Perspectives on ROVI
Connecting Markets East & West Engaged Capital’s Additional Perspectives on ROVI STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL April 22, 2015 © Nomura
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation is for discussion and general informational purposes only. It does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situation, suitability, or the particular need of any specific person who may receive this presentation, and should not be taken as advice o
Slide 3: By Ignoring the Past, the Board Attempts to Distract From the Incumbents’ Numerous Failings
By Ignoring the Past, the Board Attempts to Distract From the Incumbents’ Numerous Failings Past failings under this Board are extremely relevant to future risk and cannot simply be ignored: Significant stock underperformance over any period of time Approved the acquisition of Sonic which destro
Slide 4: ROVI Continues to Flagrantly Misrepresent its Stock Performance
ROVI Continues to Flagrantly Misrepresent its Stock Performance ROVI conveniently ignores its negative stock performance relative to peers when measured from ANY other date than July 18, 2012 $70.00 $60.00 Does this seem like a reasonable start date? $50.00 $40.00 $30.00 $20.00 $10.00 July 18, 2012
Slide 5: The Board Attempts to Defend Its Performance by Misleading Shareholders
The Board Attempts to Defend Its Performance by Misleading Shareholders ROVI Relative TSR vs. S&P 400 – Relative Returns Measured Daily Starting Jan 1, 2009 50% July 18, 2012 43% decline -- (50%) ROVI Relative TSR (100%) (150%) (200%) (250%) The above graph depicts over 1,500 independent daily measu
Slide 6: The Truth is That ROVI’s Performance Has Been Terrible Over Any Time Period
The Truth is That ROVI’s Performance Has Been Terrible Over Any Time Period – Both Short and Long Term 1 mo. 3 mo. 6 mo. 9 mo. 12 mo. ROVI Total Return (13%) (11%) (3%) (16%) (12%) ROVI Relative Return vs: Russell 2000 (13%) (19%) (17%) (26%) (23%) S&P 400 (12%) (18%) (16%) (26%) (26%) S&P 400 Techn
Slide 7: ROVI’s Depiction of Analyst Sentiment Relies Upon Incorrect Data
ROVI’s Depiction of Analyst Sentiment Relies Upon Incorrect Data ROVI’s data is INCORRECT and depicts a misleading story Real analyst recommendations over time Buy Hold Sell 7% 8% 6% 6% 8% 8% 8% 8% 8% 8% 20% 15% CORRECT data depicts a 46% 50% 44% 44% 46% very different picture 54% 64% 58% 58% 62% 58
Slide 8: The Board Claims ROVI’s New Strategy Is Working Despite Limited Tangible or Quantifiable Evidence
The Board Claims ROVI’s New Strategy Is Working Despite Limited Tangible or Quantifiable Evidence There are numerous indications that ROVI’s new strategy is less successful than the Board claims: Severe stock underperformance indicates shareholders have little confidence ROVI’s new strategy will w
Slide 9: ROVI’s Latest Promises for Future Success Sound Eerily Similar to Past Unfulfilled Promises
ROVI’s Latest Promises for Future Success Sound Eerily Similar to Past Unfulfilled Promises “We’re well positioned to drive growth; you’ll see that. Look, by ourselves, 2011 Analyst Day we think we have a 15% to 20% growth... There are long-term growth 1/7/2011 drivers that are pertinent to the mark
Slide 10: Uninspiring Product Growth, Even When Excluding Underperforming Businesses
Uninspiring Product Growth, Even When Excluding Underperforming Businesses 2011-2015E Product Business Revenue Breakout ($mm) $350 Compound Annual Growth Rate ‘11A – ‘15E $300 $283 $257 Total Product $251 $245 $251 $250 (2.9%) $86 $30 $16 $49 $30 $15 $5 $200 $150 Organic “Core” +3% +6% $215 +3% $222
Slide 11: ROVI’s Account of Its Search Process is Simply False
ROVI’s Account of Its Search Process is Simply False ROVI’s Claim “Our Board augmentation process began well before Engaged Capital made any demands regarding new directors. In March 2014, as a result of an intense period of restructuring, realignment and deep strategic review that took place well
Slide 12: Actual Timeline of Events
Actual Timeline of Events Mar. 2014: Aug. 2014: Aug. – Sep. 2014: Oct. 2014: Nov. 2014: EC initially EC reiterates EC introduces EC expresses ROVI extends raises subject of need for new several frustration with nominating adding directors directors and candidates to ROVI’s lack of deadline after to
Slide 13: The Board’s Account of Its Search Process is Simply False
The Board’s Account of Its Search Process is Simply False ROVI’s Claim Reality “During the formal search process to augment the Board in ROVI’s timeline of events is factually wrong and misleading 2014, the Company learned of Engaged Capital’s desire to In its proxy, ROVI admits it did not
Slide 14: ROVI’s Settlement Proposal Was NOT Reasonable
ROVI’s Settlement Proposal Was NOT Reasonable ROVI’s Claim Reality “ROVI recently made a good faith settlement offer to ROVI’s settlement offer was NOT reasonable Engaged Capital, offering to further augment the Board with Offered to ADD one of our nominees and ADD another two new director
Slide 15: Influence Disproportionate to Ownership Stake?
Influence Disproportionate to Ownership Stake? The Board claims we seek influence disproportionate to our ownership position, however, the current directors collectively own only ~0.2% of ROVI ROVI Shares Owned 550,000 All Incumbent Directors1 178,557 Board Engaged Capital Engaged Capital owns ~3x
Slide 16: Engaged Capital Has Successfully Initiated Over 75 Value Creation Initiatives in the Last 2.5 Years
Engaged Capital Has Successfully Initiated Over 75 Value Creation Initiatives in the Last 2.5 Years Improved Investor Communication 10 Portfolio Companies Improved Corporate Governance 10 Portfolio Companies Improved Corporate Strategy 8 Portfolio Companies Change in Board Composition 8 Portfolio Co
Slide 17: Engaged Capital’s Returns Speak For Themselves
Engaged Capital’s Returns Speak For Themselves Return of Core Positions Since Launch1 50% 44% 44% 45% 42% 40% 38% 37% 35% 35% 33% 30% 25% Return on Investment 20% 15% 15% 10% 5% 0% (5%) (4%) (10%) OPLK TKR AVAV HAR SIMG PRXL ESL DST VOLC 1 0.95 0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0
Slide 18: Overview of Board Nominees Operating Experience
Overview of Board Nominees Operating Experience David Lockwood Raghu Rau Divested TVWorks business to Comcast and As a Director and CEO of SeaChange, sold Cox Communications as CEO of Liberate multiscreen video to MSOs globally, including Relationships with MSOs Comcast and Liberty Global SVP
Slide 19: David Lockwood – Relevant Experience and Track Record of Success
David Lockwood – Relevant Experience and Track Record of Success David Lockwood has a track record of success while serving as an operating executive Energy Solutions1 Liberate2 InterTrust3 $5.00 $5 $4.15 $5 +108% $4.00 $4 +156% $4 $3.00 $3 $3 +30% $2.00 $1.62 $2 $1.00 $2 $1 $0.00 $1 Assumed CEO Rol
Slide 20: Raghu Rau - Relevant Experience and Track Record of Success
Raghu Rau - Relevant Experience and Track Record of Success SeaChange International Aviat Networks1 MicroTune $16 7/15/10: Appointed as a Director 10/20/14: Steps Aviat Networks Outperformance down as CEO 200 +21% over Dragonwave $3.00 $14 4/30/12: Named and Director +57% over Ceragon Permanent CEO