Commonwealth Bank of Australia · ASX:CBA
Commonwealth Bank of Australia — Investor Day (December 2006)
129 slides from Commonwealth Bank of Australia's investor day presentation, Dec 8, 2006
Slide 1: CBA Risk Management Briefing
Michael Blythe Chief Economist Mick Leonard Chief Risk Officer Financial & Risk Management Jim Evans Executive General Manager Risk Management & Compliance Wealth Management David Grafton Executive General Manager Credit Risk Management Retail Banking Services Paul Riordan Executive General Manager
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer The material that follows is a presentation of general background information about the Bank’s activities current at the date of the presentation, 8 December 2006. It is information given in summary form and does not purport to be complete. It is not intended to be relied upon as advice t
Slide 3: Agenda
Agenda Introduction – Mick Leonard Economic Update – Michael Blythe Overview – Mick Leonard Insurance Risk – Jim Evans Retail Credit Risk – David Grafton Market Risk – Paul Riordan Panel Questions 33
Slide 4: 44
44
Slide 5: Michael Blythe, Chief Economist
Michael Blythe Chief Economist 55
Slide 6: Other Key Information Notes
Other Key Information Notes 66
Slide 7: Key Drivers: Strong Income & Spending
Key Drivers: Strong Income & Spending Index TERMS OF TRADE Index CAPACITY MEASURES % % 120 120 12 86 Capacity utilisatio n* (rhs) 105 105 9 83 90 90 6 80 Unemp- 75 75 3 loyment 77 rate (lhs) *Source: ACCI-WBC & NAB Business Surveys 60 60 0 74 Sep-59 Sep-68 Sep-77 Sep-86 Sep-95 Sep-04 Sep-79 Sep-85 S
Slide 8: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 8
Slide 9: Key Outcomes
Key Outcomes Squaring the circle AUS TRALIA: NET LENDING BY S ECTO R % (% o f GDP) % 8 16 From a savings-investment perspective, the 4 H o us eho lds (lhs ) 12 terms of trade boom encouraged global 0 8 investors to lend us more and allowed -4 4 government to become a net lender as well. -8 0 The
Slide 10: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 10
Slide 11: Household Strain – Debt
Household Strain – Debt Paying the piper CREDIT CARD INDICATORS %pa DEBT & HOUSE SALES Ann % (rolling annual average) % ch 50 -3.0 50 50 H/hold interest payments (% of income, inverted) (adv 2 qtrs, rhs) 45 45 20 -1.0 Repayments (% of balances) 40 40 -10 1.0 35 35 Balances "Sales" (% of limits) acti
Slide 12: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 12
Slide 13: Household Strain – Interest Rates
Household Strain – Interest Rates Consumer Insurance - Part 1 FIXED RATE LOANS % MORTGAGE RATES % (% of total) (w gtd by lender type's share of aprovals) 30 30 9% 150 bpts Source: RBA Standard variable rate (lhs) 20 20 6 100 Average rate paid by new borrowers (lhs) 10 10 3 50 Discount (rhs) 0 0 0 0
Slide 14: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 14
Slide 15: Household Strain – Interest Rates
Household Strain – Interest Rates Consumer Insurance - Part 2 $ bn PRINCIPAL REPAYMENTS $ bn HOUSING EQUITY WITHDRAWAL (cum ulative ove rpaym e nt) $bn $bn 25 25 1500 1500 Cumulative increase in dwelling wealth 20 20 1200 1200 Cumulative 15 15 Cumulative 900 rise in housing 900 housing debt equity w
Slide 16: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 16
Slide 17: Housing
Housing Demography is Destiny HOUSING INDICATORS VACANCY RATES & RENTS %pa $ bn %pa % 75 17.0 8.0 0.0 *Source: REIA New Vacancy lending 6.4 rate* 1.0 (rhs) (adv 3 qtrs, 50 14.8 inverse, rhs) 4.8 2.0 25 12.5 3.2 3.0 0 10.3 1.6 Rents 4.0 Cancellations (lhs) (lhs) -25 8.0 0.0 5.0 Jul-02 Jul-03 Jul-04 J
Slide 18: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 18
Slide 19: Commodity Price Bust?
Commodity Price Bust? What Goes Up Must Come Down? COMMODITY PRICE FORECASTS CHINA Index Index % % (RBA Non-Rural Index, USD) (share of w orld GDP) 260 260 40 40 Source: RBA, Jun'06 Sep'06 Access Economics 30 30 M ar 203 '06 203 Dec'05 20 20 Jun'05 147 M ar'05 147 Sep'05 10 10 Actual Dec'04 Source:
Slide 20: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 20
Slide 21: Interest Rates
Interest Rates One and Done [again?] CASH RATE & UNEMPLOYMENT WORLD ASSET PERFORMANCE AND ppts ppts (change over past year) %pts GDP GROWTH % y/y 2.0 -2 6.0 Cash IMF (f) rate (lhs) 40 Wo rld GDP 5.0 0.9 -1 (RHS) 20 4.0 -0.3 0 0 3.0 -1.4 1 Unemployment rate -20 2.0 (adv 3 mnths, inverse, rhs) Glo bal
Slide 22: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 22
Slide 23: Credit Markets
Credit Markets As Good as it Gets? WORLD S&I FLOWS (exc USA) SPREAD TO SWAP (5yr) % % bp bp (% of GDP) 28 28 150 150 BBB Spectrum 100 100 26 26 A Savings 50 50 24 24 0 AA 0 Spectrum 22 22 -50 -50 Investment Co mmo nwealth Source: IM F Source: CBA Spectrum bo nds 20 20 -100 -100 1984 1987 1990 1993 1
Slide 24: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 24
Slide 25: Our View
Our View Global growth momentum to continue US is slowing but Japan and Asia to absorb any slack; Underlying commodity price outlook still favourable; Period of low interest rates and excess global liquidity over; Background conditions favour a repricing of risk. Australia retains momentum a
Slide 26: Disclosure and Disclaimer
DISCLOSURE AND DISCLAIMER The Bank and the US Broker-dealer are affiliates under common control. The Bank and certain of its affiliates transact and seek to transact business with some of the companies covered in the Bank’s research reports. As a result, investors should be aware that the Bank may h
Slide 27: General: This report is published solely for informational purposes
For U.S. Investors: Commonwealth Australia Securities LLC (“US broker-dealer”) is a wholly owned, but non-guaranteed, subsidiary of the Bank, organized under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA, with limited liability. The US broker-dealer is not authorized to engage in the underwriting of securi
Slide 28: 28
28 28
Slide 29: Mick Leonard, Chief Risk Officer
Mick Leonard Chief Risk Officer 29 29
Slide 30: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 30
Slide 31: Our Risks
Our Risks Credit Risk Operational and Compliance Risk Insurance Risk Market Risk Economic Capital - 30 June 2006 31 31
Slide 32: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 32
Slide 33: Today
Today Risk Management as a strategic and operational advantage Looking forward Maximising investment in Risk Management 33 33
Slide 34: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 34
Slide 35: A Strategic and Operational Advantage
A Strategic and Operational Advantage Our strengths: People Identification & Measurement Pricing for risk Tools Processes Our philosophy: Together we deliver optimal customer outcomes 35 35
Slide 36: Notes
Notes Clear Risk Appetite Single Accountability, Shared Oversight Business managed for profitable growth to optimise Bank earnings Maintain adequate | Shareholder Returns & Risk Adjusted Returns used as basis for internal hurdle _ of Credit Loss Provisions apital Requirements _ AA Del gpl @ Regulato
Slide 37: How We Manage Risk Bank-Wide
How We Manage Risk Bank-Wide Strategy Risk Appetite/Tolerance Bank Culture Governance Bank Culture Policy & Guidelines Methodology & Measurement Process Identification Assessment Management Assurance People Resourcing Systems Monitoring & Reporting Independent Review 37 37
Slide 38: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 38
Slide 39: Looking Forward
Looking Forward 1 Mortgage Product Balances – A$154.5bn 2 Personal Lending Balances - $16.8b Investm ent Personal Home Loan Loans 35% 23% Credit Cards 42% Owner Occupied 55% Margin Loans Line of Credit 35% 10% 3 High Quality Commercial Assets¹ 4 Top 20 Corporate Assets - Jun 06 A$M A BBB- 100 BBB- A
Slide 40: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 40
Slide 41: Low Bad Debts and Well Provisioned
Low Bad Debts and Well Provisioned 1 Gross Impaired to Risk Weighted 2 Asset Provisions Assets 2100 550 500 1.2% 1800 450 1500 400 1.0% 350 1200 300 A$M % % to RWA 0.8% 900 250 200 0.6% 600 150 100 300 0.4% 50 0 0 0.2% Jun-96 Jun-97 Jun-98 Jun-99 Jun 00* Jun-01 Jun-02 Jun-03 Jun-04 Jun-05 Jun-06 0.0
Slide 42: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 42
Slide 43: Key Indicators
Key Indicators 1 Property Cycle & CBA Writeoffs 2 Mortgage Rates & CBA Writeoffs 3 Unemployment & CBA Writeoffs 5 120 5 18 5 CBA Mortgage CBA Mortgage CBA Mortgage 11 Write-offs (LHS) 100 Write-offs (LHS) Write-offs (LHS) 4 4 15 4 10 80 Basis Points Basis Points Basis Points 3 3 12 3 Unemployment %
Slide 44: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 44
Slide 45: Monitoring Sensitivities
Monitoring Sensitivities Retail unsecured Automobile Industry, including Auto parts Grape growing Property developers Some aspects of agriculture Discretionary Retail 45 45
Slide 46: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 46
Slide 47: Managing Sensitivities
Managing Sensitivities Stress Test the Portfolio Internal an event driven approach i.e. a worst case economic downturn, to assess the impact on the portfolio of exceptional but plausible large loss events specific parameters based on a hybrid between historical experience and a hypothetical futu
Slide 48: Other Key Information Notes
Other Key Information Notes 48 48
Slide 49: Maximising Investment in Risk
Maximising Investment in Risk Approach: Anti Money Laundering Optimise business outcomes versus compliance Benefits: AIFRS Package & price our products more competitively Optimise capital Improved processes & systems Better decisions that reflects risk Basel II Improved risk awareness Su
Slide 50: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 50
Slide 51: Key Messages
Key Messages Strategic & Operational Advantage Bank-wide Reduced Volatility Predictable Earnings Investment Delivering Business Growth Together we deliver optimal customer outcomes 51 51
Slide 52: 52
52 52
Slide 53: Jim Evans, Executive General Manager
Jim Evans Executive General Manager Risk Management & Compliance Wealth Management 53 53
Slide 54: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 54
Slide 55: Today
Today About our business What we do How we manage risk Risk Management cycle How we complement the Bank’s products and services 55 55
Slide 56: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 56
Slide 57: About Our Business
About Our Business Life insurance – in force premium market share 14.0% 800 12.0% 700 600 10.0% 500 8.0% 400 6.0% 300 4.0% 200 2.0% 100 0.0% 0 CBA NAB ING/ANZ Tower AXA AMP IFP Market share IFP A$M (LHS) (RHS) Source: Data per Plan For Life as at 30 June 2006. CMLA Life assets as at Oct 06 $22.6 bn
Slide 58: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 58
Slide 59: What We Do
What We Do Insurance businesses offer products that are promises to pay The promise is either event based or time based Examples are losses that arise from accident, weather, earthquakes For people these can be sickness, disability, temporary loss of income or time based, being superannuatio
Slide 60: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 60
Slide 61: How We Manage Risk
How We Manage Risk Governance processes Risk management cycle Specifying the problem Developing the solution Monitoring the experience 61 61
Slide 62: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 62
Slide 63: Governance Process
Governance Process Majority of Independent Directors Appropriate committee structures and members superannuation trustees – majority of independents Board and committee charters create agenda completeness. 63 63
Slide 64: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 64
Slide 65: Risk Management Cycle
Risk Management Cycle Insurers pool risks to consistently achieve required return on capital. A three stage risk management process is adopted where risks are constantly monitored (and new ones identified) with future assumptions revised in light of past experience. The Commercial Environment
Slide 66: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 66
Slide 67: Developing the Solution
Developing the Solution Example: Home & Content Insurance Underwriting risk Anti-selection risk Concentration risk Interest rate risk Reinsurance credit risk 67 67
Slide 68: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 68
Slide 69: Monitoring the Experience
Monitoring the Experience Example: Home & Content Insurance Regular monitoring identifies where & why actual experience differs from expected: New Business Sales Sales Conversion & Retention Exposure Claims Capital Refine solutions (products) to enhance growth & market share 69 69
Slide 70: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 70
Slide 71: How we Complement the Bank's Products and Services
How we Complement the Bank’s Products and Services What is different about insurance? Evolution of time (Create wealth) Event risk (Protect wealth) Products are designed to enhance people’s lifestyles through either: Wealth creation (Superannuation) Wealth protection (Insuring assets) Compleme
Slide 72: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 72
Slide 73: Key Messages
Key Messages Insurance businesses offer products that are promises Governance processes are critical Quality risk management is vital So that we can create and protect people’s wealth The resulting benefits are J Quality products J Competitive pricing J Risk adjusted returns Reduce volatilit
Slide 74: 74
74 74
Slide 75: David Grafton, Executive General Manager
David Grafton Executive General Manager Credit Risk Management and Analytics Retail Banking Services 75 75
Slide 76: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 76
Slide 77: Today
Today What is happening in: Retail Credit Risk Management Retail Credit Portfolios What are the improvements driving performance? The benefits 77 77
Slide 78: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 78
Slide 79: What is Happening in Retail Credit Risk Management?
What is Happening in Retail Credit Risk Management? Considerable investment in improving capability Talented team of scale and capability All credit scorecards rebuilt and range of new ones implemented New parameterised credit risk management software systems 79 79
Slide 80: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 80
Slide 81: Centre of Excellence
Centre of Excellence Small Business Automation International [NZ, China, Indonesia] Group Security [fraud] Group Risk Management [Basel models] Leveraging capabilities across the Bank 81 81
Slide 82: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 82
Slide 83: Credit Portfolio: Results from Improved Capability – Personal Loans
Credit Portfolio: Results from Improved Capability – Personal Loans Months On Book 2 Months On Book 3 Months On Book 6 Fundings ($K) Reduced Implemented Approval Rate New Scorecard by raising Implemented Net Cutoff Closed internet channel Servicing and Fraud to Non-Existing Scorecard Scorecard Cut %
Slide 84: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 84
Slide 85: Credit Cards - Recent Improvements
Credit Cards - Recent Improvements 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 Note: one-off Note: one-off 30 30 30 debt sales debt Dec sales ’05Dec – Feb ’05‘06 – Feb ‘06 Bad debt expense trend Arrears trend 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 Oct05 Nov05 Dec05 Jan06 Feb06 Mar06 Apr06 May06 Jun06 Jul06 Aug06
Slide 86: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 86
Slide 87: Home Loans - In Great Shape
Home Loans - In Great Shape 14 1.20 30 30 12 30 30 arrears trends 30 30 30 30 30 30 1.00 30 10 30 30 30 8 0.80 trend and 6 expense 0.60 expense Arrears trend 4 debt 2 90 0.40 debt 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 Bad Bad Sep05 Oct05 Nov05 Dec05 Jan06 Feb06 Mar06 Apr06 May06 Jun06 Jul06 Aug06 S
Slide 88: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 88
Slide 89: Home Loans - Dispelling Two Myths
Home Loans - Dispelling Two Myths (1) owner occupied loans perform much better than investment loans Owner Occupier and Investment Home Loans 30+ days and 90+ days Arrears (by accounts) JU 04 JU 06 JU 05 AP 04 AP 05 AP 06 FE 4 FE 5 FE 6 SE 03 D 03 D 04 SE 05 D 05 SE 06 M 4 M 5 AU 5 M 6 M 4 SE 04 M 5
Slide 90: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 90
Slide 91: Home Loans – Dispelling Two Myths
Home Loans – Dispelling Two Myths (2) third party introduced loans perform much worse than branch originated loans Third Party Banking and Branch Originated Loans 30+ days and 90+ days Arrears (by accounts) MAY04 MAY05 MAY06 MAR04 MAR05 OCT03 JAN04 JAN05 AUG05 OCT05 NOV05 MAR06 NOV03 AUG04 OCT04 NOV
Slide 92: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 92
Slide 93: Home Loans – Low Doc
Home Loans – Low Doc Low doc loans less than 1% of portfolio Less than 4% of monthly new business written Arrears 2-3 times higher Risk of loss with insurer not with CBA Low doc loans capped at 80% LVR Customer pays for LMI 60-80% LVR Bank pays for insuring 0-60% LVR Pricing for insu
Slide 94: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 94
Slide 95: Home Loan Portfolio – Stress Tested
Home Loan Portfolio – Stress Tested Market Value Stress PD Stress Factor EL ($m) 1 2 4 6 0% 10.3 14.1 20.1 24.8 10% 27.3 38.4 56.7 70.6 20% 58.6 84.8 128.6 161.8 30% 103.6 153.1 236.4 299.4 Note: PD = Probability of Default EL = expected loss ($m) Under current conditions, 1 year HL expected loss
Slide 96: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 96
Slide 97: What are the Improvements Driving Performance?
What are the Improvements Driving Performance? Instant and better retail credit decisions via new decisioning software, new models and CommSee Completely rebuilt all retail credit decisioning models and implemented in last 2 years Using Basel II for business advantage Leveraged competitive a
Slide 98: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 98
Slide 99: The Benefits
The Benefits Better credit models – mean better credit decisions Better credit decisions – mean reduced bad debt &/or increased business volumes Tools in place to optimise return for risk Financial benefits – currently well over $100m over life of loans booked through new scorecards Balance
Slide 100: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 100
Slide 101: Key Messages
Key Messages Created new capability for the Retail Bank Leveraging these capabilities across the CBA Improvements providing better consumer credit decisions Better customer & shareholder outcomes 101 101
Slide 102: 102
102 102
Slide 103: Paul Riordan – Market Risk
Paul Riordan Business Development & Risk Management Premium Business Services Market Risk 103 103
Slide 104: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 104
Slide 105: Today
Today Governance & Execution Poachers turned Gamekeepers Key Metrics 105 105
Slide 106: Other Key Information Notes
Other Key Information Notes 106 106
Slide 107: Independent Assurance
Governance Framework Market Risk (MR) Operational Risk (Op Risk) & Audit Compliance Op Risk Policies & Board Level MR Appetite and Policies Compliance Standards Approvals, ratification, Independent Assurance Approvals, ratification, Mgt monitoring, oversight monitoring, oversight Committees as per C
Slide 108: Other Key Information Notes
Other Key Information Notes 108 108
Slide 109: Key Principles
Key Principles Clear Accountabilities & Authorities Segregation of Duties and Effective Limit Framework Transparency & Escalation Control Culture & Resourcing Robust Risk Measurement Accountability, Transparency & No Surprises 109 109
Slide 110: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 110
Slide 111: Poachers Turned Gamekeepers
Poachers Turned Gamekeepers Market Risk team led by market-savvy former trading professionals A mix of skills and experience aligned with both current risk concentrations and growth opportunities Physical co-location of risk teams with the business Allows deep understanding of business strat
Slide 112: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 112
Slide 113: Snapshot - Key Market Risk Metrics
Snapshot - Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk Relative to Total Equity Value at Risk: Component analysis by Bank Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) Value at Risk: Comparison of VaR/Adjusted Common Equity Ratio Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) 25 Value at Risk Relativ
Slide 114: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 114
Slide 115: Key Market Risk Metrics
Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk Relative to Total Equity 60 Value at Risk Relative Value at to Total Risk: Equity Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) 60 50 50 (basis of total equity) 40 30 2002 2005 2006 20 10 0 h c s hs re arns UBS e pac AG A B Z t ig G y an se In nc er CB NA uiss Value at Risk
Slide 116: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 116
Slide 117: Key Market Risk Metrics
Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk: Component analysis by Bank 10.00 Value at Risk Relative Value at to Total Risk: Equity Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) 9.00 60 50 40 (basis of total equity) 2002 30 2005 2006 8.00 20 10 0 Value at Risk ($mio AUD) AB Z h BA W c tpac AG y Mer thers org Lync ga
Slide 118: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 118
Slide 119: Key Market Risk Metrics
Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) 25 Value at Risk Relative to Total Equity Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Day) 60 50 40 (basis of total equity) 2002 30 2005 2006 20 20 10 0 B Z c AG A ch W c dit ns
Slide 120: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 120
Slide 121: Key Market Risk Metrics VaR/ACE
Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk: Comparison of VaR/Adjusted Common Equity Ratio 0.14% 0.12% CBA (reported) 0.10% CBA (CS diversified) NAB VaR/ACE 0.08% Westpac ANZ 0.06% 0.04% 0.02% 0.00% CBA (reported) CBA (CS NAB Westpac ANZ diversified) Source: Derived from data in each bank's annual report
Slide 122: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 122
Slide 123: Snapshot - Key Market Risk Metrics
Snapshot - Key Market Risk Metrics Value at Risk Relative to Total Equity Value at Risk: Component analysis by Bank In Line With Market Peers Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99% , One Day) Value at Risk: Comparison of VaR/Adjusted Common Equity Ratio Value at Risk: Comparison by Bank (99%, One Da
Slide 124: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 124
Slide 125: Key Messages
Key Messages Robust governance framework Experienced hands-on oversight Strong risk culture VaR in line with domestic competitors (after adjusting for credit spread) and conservative by international standards Reported VaR not telling the whole story Comprehensive non-VaR controls in pla
Slide 126: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 126
Slide 127: To be Australia's finest financial services organisation
To be Australia’s finest financial services organisation through excelling in customer service 127 127
Slide 128: Notes
Notes ConmonwealthBank oy 128
Slide 129: Panel Questions
Panel Questions Michael Blythe Mick Leonard Jim Evans David Grafton Paul Riordan 129 129
Commonwealth Bank of Australia — Investor Day (December 2006) on 6ix