Avista Corporation · NYSE:AVA

Avista — Technical Presentation (December 2021)

116 slides from Avista's technical presentation, Dec 8, 2021

  1. Slide 1: 2023 Electric IRP TAC Meeting No. 1 Agenda

    2023 Electric Integrated Resource Plan Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 Agenda Wednesday, December 8, 2021 Virtual Meeting Topic Time Staff Introductions 9:00 John Lyons 2021 Action Item Review 9:10 John Lyons Summer 2021 Heat Event 9:45 Resource Adequacy James Gall Feeder Outages David Th

  2. Slide 2: 2023 IRP Introduction

    2023 IRP Introduction 2023 Avista Electric IRP TAC 1 – December 8, 2021 John Lyons, Ph.D. Senior Resource Policy Analyst

  3. Slide 3: Meeting Guidelines

    Meeting Guidelines • IRP team is still working remotely and is available by email and phone for questions and comments • Stakeholder feedback form • Responses shared with TAC at meetings, by email and in Appendix • Would a form and/or section on the web site be helpful? • Other IRP data posted to we

  4. Slide 4: Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders

    Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders • Please mute mics unless speaking or asking a question • Raise hand or use the chat box for questions or comments • Respect the pause • Please try not to speak over the presenter or a speaker • Please state your name before commenting for the note taker • This is a pub

  5. Slide 5: Integrated Resource Planning

    Integrated Resource Planning The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP): • Required by Idaho and Washington* every other year • Washington now requires IRP every four years and update at two years • Guides resource strategy over the next twenty + years • Current and projected load & resource position • Reso

  6. Slide 6: Technical Advisory Committee

    Technical Advisory Committee • The public process piece of the IRP – input on what to study, how to study, and review of assumptions and results • Wide range of participants involved in all or parts of the process • Ask questions • Always looking for help with soliciting new TAC members • Open forum

  7. Slide 7: Today's TAC Agenda

    Today’s TAC Agenda 12:30 – Resource Adequacy Program Impact to 9:00 – Introductions, Lyons IRP, Brutocao 9:10 – 2021 Action Item Review, 1:00 – IRP Resource Adequacy/Resiliency Lyons Planning, Gall 1:45 – Break 9:45 – Summer 2021 Heat Event, Gall and Thompson 2:00 – TAC Survey Results and Discussion

  8. Slide 8: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review 2023 Avista Electric IRP TAC 1, December 8, 2021 – TAC 1 John Lyons, Ph.D. – Senior Resource Policy Analyst

  9. Slide 9: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review • Investigate and potentially hire a consultant to develop both a hydro and load forecast to include a shift in climate in the Inland Northwest. This analysis would include a range in new hydro conditions and temperatures so the Company can utilize the new forecast for re

  10. Slide 10: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review • Investigate streamlining the IRP modeling process to integrate the resource dispatch, resource selection and reliability verification functions. • With the RAP progressing, the need for reliability verification functions may not be necessary. • Avista is evaluating Plex

  11. Slide 11: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review • Determine how to best implement the Washington Commission’s strong encouragement under WAC 480-100-620 (3) regarding distribution energy resource planning as a separate process or in conjunction with the 2025 IRP. • This is an area of ongoing work that will be shared wi

  12. Slide 12: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review • Avista will conduct an existing resource market potential to estimate the amount and timing of existing resources available through 2045. • Avista is conducting an all-source RFP in Q1 2022 to identify resources through 2030. • Avista will study resource opportunities b

  13. Slide 13: 2021 IRP Action Item Review

    2021 IRP Action Item Review • Avista will partner with a third-party consultant to identify non-energy impacts that have not historically been quantified for both energy efficiency and supply side resources. • DNV was awarded a contract to study these impacts and will present their draft report at t

  14. Slide 14: 2021 Heatwave Loads & Resources

    2021 Heatwave Loads & Resources Avista, Electric Technical Advisory Committee December 8th, 2021 – TAC 1 James Gall, Electric IRP Manager

  15. Slide 15: Regional Temperatures

    Regional Temperatures 2 Data from NOAA. Updated with data through July 1, 2021. Graphic used with permission from the PNUCC

  16. Slide 16: Pacific Northwest Loads vs Temperature

    Pacific Northwest Loads vs Temperature Tuesday Temp data from NOAA, population weighted regional average (SEA .40; PDX .24; BOI .12; GEG .11, BIL .07, EUG .05) Load data from EIA 930; 12 NW BA coincident loads (AVA, BPA, CHPD, DOPD, GCPD, IPC, NWE, PACW, PGE, PSE, SCL, TWPR) 3 Graphics used with per

  17. Slide 17: NW vs California Loads

    NW vs California Loads July 2006 heat event 2020 CAISO outages 2021 NW heatwave Northwest temp data from NOAA, population weighted regional average (SEA .40; PDX .24; BOI .12; GEG .11, BIL .07, EUG .05) California temp data from NOAA, roughly weighted average (LA (USC), SAN, SMF, FAT, SJC) 4 Graphic

  18. Slide 18: Spokane Historical Hottest Days

    Spokane Historical Hottest Days (Avg High & Low Daily Temperature) 95 90 30-Year Average (83.7) 91 89 90 88 87 85 Tempertaure 80 75 Prior Locations Current Temperature Location Downtown & Felts Field (Spokane Airport) 70 65 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 Note:

  19. Slide 19: Avista Peak Loads in Perspective

    Avista Peak Loads in Perspective 6

  20. Slide 20: Avista Hourly Loads

    Balancing Authority Avista Hourly Loads Area Load- 2,381 MW (Tues- 29th - HE 17) 2,500 120 Spokane Airport High 100 2,000 80 Temperature Megawatts 1,500 Spokane 60 Airport Low 1,000 Native Load- 1,889 MW 40 (Wed- 30th - HE 18) 500 Real $49/ $42/ $37/ $128/ $46/ $42/ $25/ 20 time MWh MWh MWh MWh MWh

  21. Slide 21: Load vs Variable Energy Production

    Load vs Variable Energy Production Peak Load Hour VER: 26 MW or 9.7% of Capacity 500 2,000 Wind Solar Load Net Load 450 1,800 400 1,600 Variable Energy Resources (MW) 350 1,400 300 1,200 Load (MW) 250 1,000 200 800 150 600 100 400 50 200 0 0 25- 26- 27- 28- 29- 30- 1- Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jul 8

  22. Slide 22: Summer Peak Load Forecast Implications

    Summer Peak Load Forecast Implications • Actual peak load was 92 MW higher (5%) then fundamental forecast given the actual temperature. • Avista will move to a 30-year average hottest day for summer peak load forecasting. • Improve peak load forecast techniques. 9

  23. Slide 23: Heat Event - Emergency Operating Plan

    Heat Event- Emergency Operating Plan June 28 – July 1, 2021 2023 Electric IRP – TAC 1 December 8, 2021 David Thompson, System Planning Engineer

  24. Slide 24: Event Overview

    EOP Overview June 25 — July 1, 2021 Event Overview Customer Conservation Request 12:59 PM 35MW load shed Initiated Rolling Plan 2:30 PM 10:00 AM Status Outage Load Balancing No Touch Mode initiated Record System Peak 12:00 PM 4:52 PM Mobile at SUN 8:30 AM Maintenance Outages Restored Lind Repairs In

  25. Slide 25: Temperature Metrics

    Temperature Metrics High Temperature (°F) Low Temperature (°F) Date Forecast Actual Forecast Actual Monday, 6/28 108 105* 73 76 Tuesday, 6/29 110 109* 74 77 Wednesday, 6/30 108 104 74 78 Thursday, 7/1 106 94 73 73 • Record high daily temperatures forecasted by National Weather Service • Expected sig

  26. Slide 26: Balancing Authority Area Peak

    Balancing Authority Area Peak June 28 2,285 MW June 29 2,381 MW June 30 2,358 MW New peak load is 6% increase over prior record. 4

  27. Slide 27: Summer Challenges

    Summer Challenges • Equipment capacity ratings are typically reduced with increasing ambient temperatures • Cooling systems can adjust capacity ratings 5

  28. Slide 28: Heat EOP Performance-Distribution Transformers

    Heat EOP Performance-Distribution Transformers • Operating limits are monitored for equipment protection • 201 transformers in 140 substations throughout Avista’s service territory • Minor alarm at 80°C (176°F), monitored for continued safe operation • Major alarm at 115°C (239°F), transformer to be

  29. Slide 29: Northeast 115/13kV Transformer 2

    Northeast 115/13kV Transformer 2 • 9:50 a.m. - Transferred ROS12F1 Monday, June 28 feeder to Northeast • 10:18 a.m. – 80% loading • 1:32 p.m. – minor alarm at 96% • 1:41 p.m. – major alarm, dropped customers • Investigation found three cooling fans nonfunctional 7

  30. Slide 30: Sunset 115/13kV Transformer 2

    Sunset 115/13kV Transformer 2 • 1:44 p.m. – reached 80% Monday, June 28 • 4:12 p.m. – major alarm at 89%, dropped customers on SUN12F2 • 5:30 p.m. – restored SUN12F2 • 7:47 p.m. – major alarm, dropped SUN12F1 • Mobile Substation 4 used to energize SUN12F2, required 4-hour outage 8

  31. Slide 31: Heat EOP Performance-Distribution Feeders

    Heat EOP Performance-Distribution Feeders • Operating limits are monitored for equipment protection • 369 distribution feeders connecting substations to customer load • Operation at 80% of limit initiates notification • Operation at 100% of limit requires unloading Operating Limit June 28 June 29 Ju

  32. Slide 32: Transferring Load

    Transferring Load Timestamp Switching Notice Load Transfer Action 6/24, 7:18 a.m. CDA 21-56 HUE142 to HUE1411 6/28, 8:30 a.m. SPD 21-92 COB12F2 to MEA12F3 6/28, 9:30 a.m. CDA 21-57 PRA222 to PF212 6/28, 9:50 a.m. SPD 21-91 ROS12F1 to NE12F1 • Move load from heavily loaded 6/28, 11:30 a.m. SPD 21-93

  33. Slide 33: Feeder Balancing

    Feeder Balancing Feeder June 28 June 29 June 30 3HT12F2 -- 4 -- 3HT12F4 -- 4 -- BEA12F5 -- -- 1 BKR12F1 -- 1 -- DAL131 3 -- -- F&C12F1 -- 1 1 F&C12F2 2 -- -- F&C12F4 -- -- 1 IDR253 -- -- 1 L&S12F4 -- 1 -- LMR1530 -- 1 -- NE12F1 -- 2 -- PRA221 -- 1 -- Total 5 15 4 11

  34. Slide 34: Customer Engagement

    Customer Engagement • Demand response conservation requests • Commercial customer reduced 35MW on Monday afternoon • Two high schools • College campus • Local water district 12

  35. Slide 35: Heat EOP Performance-Transmission System

    Heat EOP Performance-Transmission System • Equipment issues • Three 230kV breakers • One 230/115kV transformer • Next issue would pose significant outage challenges • No impacts to customers 13

  36. Slide 36: Rathdrum Station

    Rathdrum Station • Breaker R-403 • Cabinet – Rathdrum transmission line • Failed bushing • Monday 4:47 a.m. until Friday • Breaker R-400 • Beacon – Rathdrum transmission line • Leaking bushing • Wednesday 9:05 a.m. until Thursday • Additional device failure would likely cause transmission outage 14

  37. Slide 37: Beacon Station

    Beacon Station • Breaker R-432 • Beacon – Boulder transmission line • Failed bushing • Monday 11:39 p.m. until Tuesday 5:13 p.m. • Beacon 230/115kV Transformer 2 • Multiple major alarms on Tuesday but operating at 80% of capacity • Cooling fan bank loss of power 15

  38. Slide 38: Heat EOP Summary

    Heat EOP Summary • 31 protective events caused customer outages • 16,029 customer outages on Monday, June 28 • 5,523 customers with outages on Tuesday, June 29 • 603 customers with outages on Wednesday, June 30 • Customer outages regions • South Lewiston area • Greater Spokane area 16

  39. Slide 39: Recommendation Summary

    Recommendation Summary Capacity Mitigation Distribution System Feeder Balancing Operational Major Equipment Planning Program Planning Utilization Assessment 17

  40. Slide 40: Q&A Thank You

    Q&A Thank You 18

  41. Slide 41: Western Resource Adequacy Program

    WESTERN RESOURCE ADEQUACY PROGRAM AVISTA TAC MEETING DECEMBER 8, 2021 1 NWPP

  42. Slide 42: Agenda

    AGENDA » Overview » Timeline » Participation » Design Framework » Governance » Costs and Benefits » Next Steps 2 NWPP

  43. Slide 43: Overview

    » The WRAP is a regional capacity program › Similar programs are available across North America › Significant effort to build organizational structure necessary to administer program › Capacity will improve reliability in most expedient OVERVIEW manner » Not building a market – relying on current bi

  44. Slide 44: Benefits

    » RELIABILITY › Ensure sufficient generation and transmission resources are installed and committed to reliably serve demand, during stressed grid and market conditions, with a high degree of confidence BENEFITS » COST SAVINGS › Unlock the benefits of diversity in supply and demand in a safe and equ

  45. Slide 45: Project Timeline

    PROJECT TIMELINE Stage Stage Stage Stage 0 1 2 3 Binding Forward Interim Program Non-Binding Binding Forward Showing + Full Forward Showing Showing Program Operational Program Program Started Summer 2020 Fully functional by 2024 Phase 1 Phase 2A Phase 3A Phase 3B Information Preliminary Phase 2B Imp

  46. Slide 46: Program Participation

    PROGRAM PARTICIPATION – Participation open to Load Responsible Entities (LREs) – both in and outside current NWPP footprint – Voluntary entry (absent any contractual or other regulatory requirements), followed by obligation to comply – Participants decide how they will meet the program resource requ

  47. Slide 47: Initial Phase 3A Participants

    INITIAL PHASE 3A PARTICIPANTS APS AVANGRID AVISTA BLACK HILLS BPA CALPINE CHELAN PUD CLATSKANIE PUD DOUGLAS PUD EWEB GRANT PUD IDAHO POWER NORTHWESTERN NV ENERGY PACIFICORP PGE POWEREX PSE SRP SCL SHELL SNOHOMISH PUD TACOMA POWER TEA 7 NWPP TID

  48. Slide 48: Phase 3A - Nonbinding Trial

    PHASE 3A – NONBINDING TRIAL – Phase 3A began Oct 1 – Runs through Dec 2022 – 25 Participants so far – Approximately 70,000 MWs of peak season load – Data collected for participating entities on Nov 8 – No penalty for non-compliance – First forward showing for Winter 2022-2023 on May 15, 2022 – Secon

  49. Slide 49: Program Framework

    PROGRAM FRAMEWORK TWO TIME HORIZONS AFTER FORWARD SHOWING OPERATIONAL SEASON THE FACT 1 and 3 Years Prior 7 Months Prior 3-5 Months Prior 6 Days Prior Present Multi-Year LOLE Assessment Portfolio Deadline Cure Period Rolling Daily Sharing Event Entities contract to PO verifies all Assessment Settlem

  50. Slide 50: Forward Showing

    FORWARD SHOWING BALANCING LOADS AND RESOURCES DEMAND SIDE SUPPLY SIDE Calculate: “PURE” CAPACITY Calculate: “PURE” CAPACITY AVAILABLE NEEDED BASED ON: BASED ON: › Total Supply, de-rated and qualified as follows: › P50 LOAD FORECAST + Wind and solar – ELCC › Contingency Reserves + Thermals – UCAP Run

  51. Slide 51: Two Binding Seasons

    TWO BINDING SEASONS Binding/ Compliance Season Duration Cure Period Advisory Showing Date Winter Binding Nov-March 15 March 31 June 1 – July 31 Summer Binding June-Sept 15 October 31 Jan 1 – Feb 28 (of prior year) Spring Advisory April-May N/A N/A Fall Advisory October N/A N/A Program Operator will

  52. Slide 52: Operational Program

    OPERATIONAL PROGRAM – Need ability to access diversity in real-time – PO monitors participants needs 5-7 days in advance – Day ahead assessment › Participants with unplanned conditions may be eligible for next day assistance › Participants with planned extra capacity asked to hold back – Operating d

  53. Slide 53: Proposed Approach Governance

    PROPOSED APPROACH » NWPP governing authority – “Public Utility” » Independent Board of Directors (BOD) › Once the initial structure of the board and program is established, the board has authority to approve budgets; provide direction and set priorities › Proposed governance preserves structures and

  54. Slide 54: Proposed Approach Governance

    PROPOSED APPROACH » State Officials Committee (SOC) – meeting through end of year to refine the role of this committee » Nominating Committee (NC) – the members of the BOD will be selected by a NC comprised of multi- sector representatives. » Program Review Committee (PRC) – future GOVERNANCE change

  55. Slide 55: Next Steps

    NEXT STEPS Phase 3A – Non-binding Program (October 2021-December 2022) » Non-Binding Forward Showing Program › Determine regional PRM and resource capacity credits in Q1 2022 › Perform two Forward Showings: Winter 2022/23, Summer 2023 » Preparation for later phases › Prepare for FERC filing (filing

  56. Slide 56: Questions

    QUESTIONS Northwest Power Pool (nwpp.org) 16 NWPP

  57. Slide 57: Resource Adequacy Program Impact to IRP

    Resource Adequacy Program Impact to IRP Avista, Electric IRP – TAC Meeting 1 December 8th, 2021 Michael Brutocao, Natural Gas Analyst

  58. Slide 58: Planning Reserve Margin

    Planning Reserve Margin Summer Winter • 2021 IRP method: ~14.6% • 2021 IRP method: ~24.6% • Planning Margin (7%) + Operating • Planning Margin (16%) + Reserves + Regulation Operating Reserves + Regulation • RAP: ~13% • RAP: ~18% • Planning Margin (12%) + • Planning Margin (16%) + Operating Reserves

  59. Slide 59: Obligations - RAP

    Obligations – RAP • Peak Load • System Sales • Demand Response (-) • Regulation • Operating Reserves for BA Load (only non-native load) • Avista Operating Reserves

  60. Slide 60: Rights - RAP

    Rights – RAP Thermal Hydro Variable • Power Deal Purchases Generation Generation Generation • Thermal Generation UCAP ICAP Additional • Hydro Generation UCAP Capacity Generation Capability Available Nameplate Capacity • Variable Generation Actual Generation • Small Power (QF, PURPA) QCC ELCC QCC • S

  61. Slide 61: Calculating Net Position - RAP

    Calculating Net Position – RAP Planning Margin Rights Operating Reserves (load) Power Deal Purchases Operating Reserves (generation) Coal Resource Capability Wood x Qualified Capacity Contribution Wind Net Capability Solar Obligations CCCT Peak Native Load Peaker Power Deal Sales Spokane Capacity Se

  62. Slide 62: 2021 IRP Net Position with RAP Changes

    2021 IRP Net Position with RAP Changes 600 600 400 400 200 200 Megawatts Megawatts 0 0 (200) (200) (400) (400) (600) (600) (800) (800) 2024 2031 2038 2045 2022 2023 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 RAP (January) 2021 IRP (January) RAP (August)

  63. Slide 63: Conclusions

    Conclusions • Participating utilities will use the same methodology for resource adequacy on determination • Lower capacity requirements using RAP should lower customer cost • RAP will result in additional market risk due to regional ELCCs for variable resources and storage

  64. Slide 64: Resource Adequacy & Resiliency

    Resource Adequacy & Resiliency Avista, Electric Technical Advisory Committee December 8th, 2021 – TAC 1 James Gall, Electric IRP Manager

  65. Slide 65: Resource Adequacy (RA)

    Resource Adequacy (RA) • In the simplest terms, RA is just a regulatory construct developed to ensure that there will be sufficient resources available to serve electric demand under all but the most extreme conditions. – Gridworks • The result is a utility must plan for a certain “Planning Margin”

  66. Slide 66: NERC Defines Reliability

    NERC Defines Reliability The NERC defines reliability of the bulk electric system via two main responsibilities – adequacy and security. Adequacy is defined as “the ability of the bulk power system to supply the aggregate electrical demand and energy requirements of the customers at all times (e.g.,

  67. Slide 67: Past IRP's Resource Adequacy Considerations

    Past IRP’s Resource Adequacy Considerations • Planning margin requirements • Loss of load probability studies • Annual energy acquisition targets • Resource peak credit estimates • Largest single contingency 4

  68. Slide 68: Resiliency

    Resiliency Resiliency Area’s of Concern • Resilience is generally defined as increasing the ability of the power system to prevent or mitigate the Generation Transmission impact of unusual or catastrophic events (e.g., storms, fires, earthquakes, cyber and physical attacks). - Finster, M., Phillips,

  69. Slide 69: Resiliency Risks

    Resiliency Risks Extreme weather Wind, Snow, and Ice Flooding (drought, heat, rainfall, Load wind, etc.) Cyber Security, Civil Permafrost and Land Wildfires Unrest, Terrorism Movement Supply Chain & Funding Organizational Silos Personnel . Hall, P., Vanderbeck, R., and Triano, M. (May 2019) Electric

  70. Slide 70: Past IRP's Resiliency Considerations

    Past IRP’s Resiliency Considerations • Critical water planning (10th percentile) • Fuel supply limitations • Fuel price risk • Weather protections included in resource costs • Modeling weather related generation constraints • Transmission interconnection requirements • Non-energy impacts for energy

  71. Slide 71: Resource Adequacy & Resiliency Changes for the 2023 IRP

    Resource Adequacy & Resiliency Changes for the 2023 IRP • Resource acquisition will target monthly & seasonal Resource Adequacy Program targets • Use RA Qualified Capacity Credits (QCC) for each existing and potential resource • Use RA required planning margin • Ensure Avista has energy resources to

  72. Slide 72: Resiliency Group Discussion

    Resiliency Group Discussion • What resiliency topics should be evaluated • Should we conduct resiliency related scenario analysis and what should we in the IRP vs other planning forums? change in the plan based on the results? • What level of resiliency should utilities plan • Include resiliency cre

  73. Slide 73: Technical Advisory Committee Participant Survey

    Technical Advisory Committee Participant Survey 2023 Electric IRP First Technical Advisory Committee Meeting, December 8, 2021 Lori Hermanson, Senior Power Supply Analyst

  74. Slide 74: Why are you involved in the IRP process?

    Why are you involved in the IRP process? • Majority of participants are non- customers from government entities • Many are customers • One wants to drive solar 2

  75. Slide 75: Would two IRP tracts be better?

    Would two IRP tracts (i.e. informative vs. technical) be better? 3

  76. Slide 76: Which tract would you prefer to participate in?

    Which tract would you prefer to participate in? • 88% prefer to participate in technical or both technical and informative 4

  77. Slide 77: Preference for meeting occurrence and length

    What is your preference for meeting occurrence and length? • 69% prefer approximately 8 meetings per IRP with meetings no more than 3-4 hours in length 5

  78. Slide 78: What topics would you like to discuss?

    What topics would you like to discuss? • Customer partnerships – local resource options (DR, • Nuclear power to replace coal (long- EE, DER, electrification) term, low-cost) instead of wind or solar; • Resource adequacy* use natural gas for peaking not energy • Regional area network vulnerability an

  79. Slide 79: What additional supporting data would you like to see?

    What additional supporting data would you like to see? • Balance was right – a strength of the 2021 IRP • Chart of portfolio with annual operating costs and risk profile of each resource strategy – shows customers’ risk exposure • Updated climate modeling • Refined resource adequacy considerations t

  80. Slide 80: Preferences to engage customers

    What are your preferences to engage customers? • Majority prefer the website or informational presentations to engage customers • Improved website that explains the issues and steps instead of text and links • Newspaper articles • Input from actual customers not outside environmental groups since cu

  81. Slide 81: What did you like about the 2021 IRP Process?

    What did you like about the 2021 IRP Process? • Process was complete and detailed. Appreciated how Avista endeavored to implement the WA clean energy law and meet Idaho policy expectations (challenging!) • Increased transparency; amount of data and presentations for varying levels of technical exper

  82. Slide 82: What improvements would you like to see?

    What improvements would you like to see? • Stop assuming Idahoans want methane gas plants. We want reliable, affordable energy. • Focus on providing low cost, reliable power from sources that have a long-term stable cost outlook. Natural gas costs driven up as its used to firm wind/solar. Should be

  83. Slide 83: Washington State Clean Energy Implementation Plan Customer Benefit Indicators

    Washington State Clean Energy Implementation Plan Customer Benefit Indicators December 8, 2021 – 2023 Electric IRP TAC 1 Annette Brandon

  84. Slide 84: Clean Energy Transformation: IRP to CEIP

    Clean Energy Transformation IRP to CEIP Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) 20+ year resource planning identifying customer future resource needs • Lowest reasonable cost of resource mix including societal benefits • Maintain and protect safety, reliable operation and balancing of electric system Integra

  85. Slide 85: Public Participation Inputs

    Public Participation Inputs Identify Named Benefits/Barriers “Equity Customer Benefit Indicators CEIP Communities Areas” Highly Impacted Communities Benefits of Clean Energy Measurable Resource Mix Vulnerable Populations Prioritization Accountable Lowest Reasonable Cost Barriers to Participation Res

  86. Slide 86: Highly Impacted Communities and Vulnerable Populations

    Highly Impacted Communities and Vulnerable Populations (“Named Communities”) Who is most Impacted? Total represents 47 areas or 32% of total Washington Service Territory. • Highly Impacted Communities • Designated by DOH EAG identified additional • 34 Census Tracts (25%) characteristics for vulnerab

  87. Slide 87: Benefits of Clean Energy Transition

    Benefits of Clean Energy Transition Utilities must consider input from advisory group members (including equity advisory group), and customers to meet requirement that all customers benefit from the transition to clean energy through: Equity • Equitable distribution of energy and nonenergy benefits

  88. Slide 88: Developing Customer Benefit Indicators

    Developing Customer Benefit Indicators – From 86 touchpoints to 12 Final ▪ How could the transition to clean energy benefit (or unintentionally harm) customers? ▪ Affordability ▪ Environmental ▪ Access to clean energy ▪ Energy security, resiliency ▪ Community/economic development ▪ Health and well-b

  89. Slide 89: Prioritizing Customer Benefit Indicators

    Prioritizing Customer Benefit Indicators • Communication Power • To what extent is the indicator easily understandable by a broad audience? • Proxy Power • Which are critically tied to everyone benefiting equitably from the transition to clean energy? (“Data Herd”) • Data Power • Which are most able

  90. Slide 90: Customer Benefit Indicators

    Customer Benefit Indicators Customer Benefit Indicator (CBI) – is an attribute, either quantitative or qualitative of a resource or related distribution investment associated with customer benefits Customer Benefit Indicators CBIs are measurement tools for evaluating progress towards ensuring custom

  91. Slide 91: Directly Related IRP CBIs

    Directly Related IRP CBIs Number of Households With High Energy Energy Burden by All Customers and Named Communities Burden Percent of Energy Efficiency, Non-Emitting, Renewable Energy in Named Community Clean Energy Named Communities Energy Availability Resource Adequacy Planning Margin Percent of

  92. Slide 92: Number of Households with High Energy Burden

    Number of Households with High Energy Burden The goal is to reduce the number of customers, especially in Named Communities, with an energy burden of six percent or more. BASELINE METRIC Energy burdened Households Average excess Lowest Reasonable Cost households as a Energy Burdened burden per Count

  93. Slide 93: Named Community Clean Energy

    Named Community Clean Energy The Named Community Clean Energy CBI concentrates on the percent of non-emitting or clean energy resources, including distributed generation or energy efficiency in Named Communities. Percent of Non-Emitting/Renewable Energy in Named Communities Power Supply Contribution

  94. Slide 94: Energy Availability

    Energy Availability Avista’s resource Planning Margin is a measure of resource adequacy indicating the level of customer exposure to resource outages or market reliance. Resource Adequacy Planning Margin 12

  95. Slide 95: Energy Generation Location - Energy Security

    Energy Generation Location – Energy Security As part of Named Community development, Avista will track the amount of clean generation and energy efficiency in its annual system resource mix. The benefits associated with this metric will provide economic opportunities to these communities and a more

  96. Slide 96: Outdoor Air Quality

    Outdoor Air Quality Avista will monitor Avista-specific Plant Air Emissions on a locational basis. Avista Plant Air Emissions 14

  97. Slide 97: Greenhouse Gas Emissions

    Greenhouse Gas Emissions Avista will monitor the greenhouse gas emissions from Avista resources and how it interacts with the wholesale market. Renewable Energy Projects will contribute to the overall reduction in Regional GHG as we move towards 2030. Avista-specific GHG 15

  98. Slide 98: CBIs and Resource Selection

    CBIs and Resource Selection CBIs must be incorporated into resource selection and program prioritization in order to ensure customers are benefitting from the transition to clean energy. Used to prioritize programs Energy Efficiency Focus on impacts to Named Communities Will be used in development o

  99. Slide 99: CBIs and Resource Selection

    CBIs and Resource Selection IRP Portfolio Analysis and Preferred Portfolio must consider: • Lowest Reasonable Cost • Include cost-effective, reliable and feasible conservation How to incorporate CBIs into this mix? and efficiency resources and distributed energy sources Prioritization • Consider acq

  100. Slide 100: CBIs Indirectly Related to the IRP

    CBI’s Indirectly Related to the IRP Participation in weatherization programs and energy assistance programs (State and Participation in Company Programs Named Community statistic) Number of outreach contacts Availability of Methods/Modes of Outreach & Communication Number of marketing impressions Nu

  101. Slide 101: How will the IRP address CBIs?

    How will the IRP address CBI’s? • Directly related IRP CBI’s will be quantitatively forecasted in the IRP. • including of non-energy impacts and transitioning to 100% clean energy by 2045 may improve these indicators • Indirectly related IRP CBI’s will be qualitatively discussed in the IRP. • In the

  102. Slide 102: CBI List

    CBI List Participation in Energy Efficiency and Weatherization (“other”) Participation in Company Programs Saturation Rate for Energy Assistance Programs Number of Households With High Energy Burden Energy Burden by All Customers and Named Communities Number of Outreach Contacts Availability of Meth

  103. Slide 103: 2023 IRP Draft Work Plan

    2023 IRP Draft Work Plan 2023 Electric IRP TAC 1 – December 8, 2021 John Lyons, Ph.D. – Senior Resource Policy Analyst

  104. Slide 104: 2023 IRP Work Plan

    2023 IRP Work Plan • IRP regulations require an IRP to be filed in Idaho on April 1, 2023, and a progress report in Washington on January 1, 2023. • Avista will ask Commissions to extend the filings to June 1, 2023, to allow for the completion of the 2022 All-Source RFP which will fundamentally chan

  105. Slide 105: 2023 IRP Work Plan - Modeling

    2023 IRP Work Plan – Modeling • Use Aurora for electric market prices, resource valuation and Monte-Carlo style risk analyses of the electric marketplace. • Aurora modeling results will be used to select the PRS and alternative scenario portfolios using Avista’s proprietary PRiSM model. • Qualitativ

  106. Slide 106: Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule

    Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 1 (Wednesday, December 8, 2021): 2021 IRP Action Item Review, Summer 2021 Heat Event Review, NWPP Resource Adequacy Program Overview, Resource Adequacy Program Impact to the IRP, IRP Resource Adequacy/Resiliency Planning Discussion, TAC Survey Results a

  107. Slide 107: Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule

    Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 4 (Late July 2022): Conservation Potential Assessment (AEG), Demand Response Potential Assessment (AEG), energy efficiency inclusion of Social Cost of Greenhouse Gas (WA only) • TAC 5 (Early August 2022): IRP transmission planning studies, distribution

  108. Slide 108: Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule

    Tentative 2023 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • Technical Modeling Workshop (October 2022): PRiSM model overview, risk assessment overview (Plexos or ARAM), and Washington use of electricity modeling • TAC 8 (February 2023): Wholesale market scenario results, RFP update, jurisdictional allocation update,

  109. Slide 109: Tentative 2023 Draft Electric IRP Timeline

    Tentative 2023 Draft Electric IRP Timeline Task Target Date Update and finalize energy & peak forecast May 2022 Transmission & distribution studies complete June 2022 Identify Avista’s supply resource options July 2022 Finalize demand response options July 2022 Finalize energy efficiency options Jul

  110. Slide 110: Tentative 2023 IRP Writing Tasks

    Tentative 2023 IRP Writing Tasks Writing Tasks Target Date File 2023 IRP Work Plan January 1, 2022 Washington Partial Progress Report January 1, 2023 External draft released to the TAC March 17, 2023 Public Comments from TAC due May 12, 2023 Final IRP submission to Commissions and TAC June 1, 2023 8

  111. Slide 111: Tentative 2023 Electric IRP Timeline - Public Data Releases

    Tentative 2023 Electric IRP Timeline – Public Data Releases Task Targeted Release Peak & Energy Load Forecast June 2022 Supply Side Resource Options July 2022 Energy Efficiency Potential Study July 2022 Demand Response Potential Study July 2022 Transmission Interconnect Costs July 2022 Wholesale Nat

  112. Slide 112: 2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline 1. Executive Summary 2. Introduction, Stakeholder Involvement, and Process Changes 3. Economic and Load Forecast • Economic Conditions • Avista Energy & Peak Load Forecasts • Load Forecast Scenarios 4. Existing Supply Resources • Avista Resources • Contractual Resourc

  113. Slide 113: 2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline 5. Long-Term Position • Regional Capacity Requirements • Energy Planning Requirements • Reserves and Flexibility Assessment 6. Transmission Planning & Distribution • Overview of Avista’s Transmission System • Future Upgrades and Interconnections • Transmission Constru

  114. Slide 114: 2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline 7. Distributed Energy Resources • Energy efficiency potential • Demand response potential • Supply side resource options • Named Community Actions 8. Supply Side Resource Options • New Resource Options • Avista Plant Upgrades • Non-Energy Impacts 12

  115. Slide 115: 2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline 9. Market Analysis • Wholesale Natural Gas Market Price Forecast • Wholesale Electric Market Price Forecast • Scenario Analysis 10. Preferred Resource Strategy • Preferred Resource Strategy • Market Exposure Analysis • Avoided Cost • Customer Benefit Indicator Impact

  116. Slide 116: 2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2023 Electric IRP Draft Outline 9. Portfolio Scenarios • Portfolio Scenarios • Market Scenario Impacts 10. Action Plan 14

Avista — Technical Presentation (December 2021) on 6ix