Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — presentatie harris dellas
44 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's investor presentation, Oct 28, 2005
Slide 1: On the new Keynesian model
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks On the new Keynesian model Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas1 1 Department of Economics University of Bern October 28, 2005 Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 2: The new Keynesian model as a standard specification
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 3: The new Keynesian model has many limitations
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). I But it has many important limitations. Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 4: Limitations: inflation and output dynamics
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). I But it has many important limitations. I It cannot produce plausible inflation and output dynamics following Fabrice Collard and Harr
Slide 5: Limitations: monetary shock response
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). I But it has many important limitations. I It cannot produce plausible inflation and output dynamics following I a monetary shock: The
Slide 6: Limitations: supply shock response
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). I But it has many important limitations. I It cannot produce plausible inflation and output dynamics following I a monetary shock: The
Slide 7: Limitations: inflation persistence
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model is ”[. . . ] the closest thing there is to a standard specification... ” (McCallum). I But it has many important limitations. I It cannot produce plausible inflation and output dynamics following I a monetary shock: The
Slide 8: Liquidity effect following a monetary shock
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I It cannot generate a liquidity effect following a monetary shock (Gali, 2003). Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 9: Acceleration hypothesis
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I It cannot generate a liquidity effect following a monetary shock (Gali, 2003). I It is inconsistent with the acceleration hypothesis (the positive relation between economic activity and the change in the inflation rate, Mankiw and Reis, 2002).
Slide 10: Serial correlation in inflation forecast errors
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I It cannot generate a liquidity effect following a monetary shock (Gali, 2003). I It is inconsistent with the acceleration hypothesis (the positive relation between economic activity and the change in the inflation rate, Mankiw and Reis, 2002).
Slide 11: Fixes: sluggish real adjustments
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Fixes Maintain rational expectations I Introduce sluggish real adjustments Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 12: Fixes: habit formation and adjustment costs
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Fixes Maintain rational expectations I Introduce sluggish real adjustments I Habit formation, adjustment costs on investment, variable capital utilization, firm specific capital,.. as in Christiano et al, 2004, 2005. It does not work. No inertia
Slide 13: Fixes: predetermined expenditure
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Fixes Maintain rational expectations I Introduce sluggish real adjustments I Habit formation, adjustment costs on investment, variable capital utilization, firm specific capital,.. as in Christiano et al, 2004, 2005. It does not work. No inertia
Slide 14: Fixes: sticky information
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Fixes Maintain rational expectations I Introduce sluggish real adjustments I Habit formation, adjustment costs on investment, variable capital utilization, firm specific capital,.. as in Christiano et al, 2004, 2005. It does not work. No inertia
Slide 15: Price rigidity, full rationality: real rigidities
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Price rigidity, full rationality. Adding real rigidities to the basic NK model Investment Adjustment Costs Output Inflation Rate Nominal Interest Rate Real Interest Rate 1.5 1 10 200 Basis Points Basis Points 1 0.5 0 0 % dev. % dev. 0.5 0
Slide 16: Price rigidity: combined effect of real rigidities
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Price rigidity, full rationality. Combined effect of real rigidities All rigidities Output Inflation Rate Nominal Interest Rate Real Interest Rate 2 1 20 200 Basis Points Basis Points 1 0.5 0 0 % dev. % dev. 0 0 −20 −200 −1 −0.5 −40 −400
Slide 17: Wage rigidity, full rationality: real rigidities
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Wage rigidity, full rationality. Real rigidities Investment Adjustment Costs Output Inflation Rate Nominal Interest Rate Real Interest Rate 2 1 20 0 Basis Points Basis Points 0.5 % dev. % dev. 1 0 −200 0 0 −0.5 −20 −400 10 20 10 20 10 20
Slide 18: Alleged impulse responses in the Mankiw-Reis model
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Alleged Impulse Response Functions to a Money Shock in the Mankiw-Reis model (c) Money Supply Shock Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 19: Impulse response to a money shock (N = 4)
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Impulse Response Function to a Money Shock (N = 4) Output Inflation Nominal Interest Rate 6 1.5 0.15 S.I. S.P. 4 I.S.P. 1 0.1 % dev. % dev. % dev. 2 0.5 0.05 0 0 0 −2 −0.5 −0.05 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Quarters
Slide 20: Mankiw-Reis model with real rigidities
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: Impulse Response Functions in the Mankiw-Reis model: The case of real rigidities, N=4 Output Inflation Nominal Interest Rate 1 0.6 0.1 0.05 0.4 0.5 0 % dev. 0.2 −0.05 0 0 S.I. −0.1 S.P. −0.5 −0.2 −0.15 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Qua
Slide 21: Drop rational expectations: myopic price setting
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Drop rational expectations I Myopic price setting, price indexation schemes. A fraction of the population adjusts prices in a backward looking or myopic way (Gali and Gertler, 1999, Christiano, Eichenbaum and Evans, 2005). Fabrice Collard and Har
Slide 22: Drop rational expectations: adaptive expectations
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Drop rational expectations I Myopic price setting, price indexation schemes. A fraction of the population adjusts prices in a backward looking or myopic way (Gali and Gertler, 1999, Christiano, Eichenbaum and Evans, 2005). I Adaptive expectations
Slide 23: Phillips curve with lagged inflation
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Drop rational expectations I Myopic price setting, price indexation schemes. A fraction of the population adjusts prices in a backward looking or myopic way (Gali and Gertler, 1999, Christiano, Eichenbaum and Evans, 2005). I Adaptive expectations
Slide 24: Problem with CEE indexation assumption
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Drop rational expectations I Myopic price setting, price indexation schemes. A fraction of the population adjusts prices in a backward looking or myopic way (Gali and Gertler, 1999, Christiano, Eichenbaum and Evans, 2005). I Adaptive expectations
Slide 25: Alternative solution: imperfect information and gradual learning
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks We propose an alternative solution that is plausible, intellectually satisfying and seems to work. Imperfect information and gradual learning: The shocks are not observed. The agents gradually learn the true state of the economy (using the Kalman
Slide 26: The household
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks The household Preferences ∞ " 1−σm # νm νh X τ Mt+τ 1+σ Et β log(ct+τ − ϑct+τ −1 ) + − h h (1) τ =0 1 − σm Pt+τ 1 + σh t+τ The budget constraint Et Bt+1 Qt + Mt + Pt (ct + it + a(ut )kt ) = Bt + Mt−1 + Pt zt ut kt + Wt ht + Ωt + Πt (2 Capital acc
Slide 27: Goods: final sector
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I Goods: Final sector Z 1 θ1 θ Yt = Xt (i) di (4) 0 The final good may be used for consumption — private or public— and investment purposes. Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 28: Intermediate goods
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks I Goods: Final sector Z 1 θ1 Yt = Xt (i)θ di (4) 0 The final good may be used for consumption — private or public— and investment purposes. I Intermediate goods Xt (i) = At Kt (i)α ht (i)1−α (5) Intermediate goods producers are monopolistically c
Slide 29: Pricing and the monetary authorities
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Pricing: Optimizing firms: Standard maximization of expected profits The non-optimizing firms may: I Keep their prices perfectly constant until they get a call (our model) I Adjust price according to a backward indexation scheme (CEE) Pit = ξt Pi
Slide 30: Calibration
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Table: Calibration Discount factor β 0.988 Habit persistence ϑ 0.650 Inverse labor supply elasticity σh 1.000 Money demand elasticity σm 10.500 Capital elasticity of intermediate output α 0.281 Parameter of markup θ 0.850 Depreciation rate δ 0.02
Slide 31: Shocks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Table: Shocks ρ σ Technology 0.9500 0.0042 Fiscal 0.9684 0.0104 Money supply 0.5000 0.0017 For mis–measured variable x xt? = xtT + ξt E (ξt ) = 0 for all t; E (ξt εa,t ) = E (ξt εg ,t ) = 0; and 2 σξ if t = k E (ξt ξk ) = 0 Otherwise Fabrice Coll
Slide 32: Informational issues
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Informational issues I Knowledge of the aggregate state of the economy matters for the agents. I The specification of information satisfies two principles. I First, it does not allow agents to immediately infer the true state of the economy based
Slide 33: Calibrating the variance of the noise
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Calibrate the variance of the noise by matching the first 8 periods in the IRF of inflation to a money shock in the CEE model. Table: Volatility of noise Rt πt πt−1 πt−2 µt µt−1 µt−2 2.23045e-4 3.1301e-3 1.5707e-3 7.8817e-4 8.2173e-3 4.1161e-3 2.
Slide 34: Are these values plausible?
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Are these values plausible? I BEA: SD of the difference between announced and revised values for GDP deflator is 0.48% (1999-2003). I Coenen, Levin and Wieland, 2005: Mean absolute revision for the GDP price deflator of 0.11% and 0.14% one and tw
Slide 35: IRF to a money supply shock: perfect information
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Figure: IRF to a money supply shock (a) Perfect Information Output Inflation 4 1 0.8 3 0.6 % dev. % dev. 2 0.4 1 0.2 0 0 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Nominal Interest Rate Real Interest Rate 0.1 0 0.08 −0.2 0.06 −0.4 % dev. % dev. 0.04
Slide 36: Imperfect information vs the CEE model
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks (b) Imperfect Information vs the CEE model Inflation Rate Output 0.8 4 CEE 0.6 Perf. Info 3 Imp. Info. 0.4 2 % dev. % dev. 0.2 1 0 0 −0.2 −1 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Nominal Interest Rate Real Interest Rate 40 100 20 0 Basis Points
Slide 37: HP moments
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Table: HP moments Var. Std Rel. Std ρ(·, y ) ρ(1) Std Rel. Std ρ(·, y ) ρ(1) Data Standard NK (no indexation) y 1.49 1.00 1.00 0.88 1.35 1.00 1.00 0.87 c 0.80 0.54 0.86 0.87 0.21 0.16 0.86 0.88 i 6.03 4.04 0.92 0.83 4.12 3.06 0.94 0.90 h 1.88 1.2
Slide 38: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. Fabrice Collard and Harris Dellas On the new Keynesian model
Slide 39: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Slide 40: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Slide 41: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Slide 42: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Slide 43: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Slide 44: Concluding remarks
Introduction The model The results Concluding remarks Concluding remarks I The new Keynesian model has important empirical limitations. I Existing, suggested solutions are either conceptually unsatisfactory (do not adhere to rational expectations), empirically tenuous (inconsistent with pricing beha
Banque Nationale De Belgique — presentatie harris dellas on 6ix