Toronto-Dominion Bank · TSX:TD
Toronto-Dominion Bank — TD Economics — COVID-19 Economic Assessment Webcast (April 2020)
31 slides from Toronto-Dominion Bank's conference presentation, Apr 20, 2020
Slide 1: COVID-19 Economic Assessment Webcast
TD Economics COVID-19 Economic Assessment Webcast Monday April 20th, 2020 at 11 AM EST
Slide 2: Global
Global
Slide 3: Global Risks Remain Tilted To The Downside
Global Risks Remain Tilted To The Downside Real GDP, Year/Year % Change 10 8 7.4 6.8 5.8 6 4 3.6 2.9 1.7 2 0 -2 -4 -2.9 -4.4 -6 -6.5 -8 2019 2020 2021 2019 2020 2021 2019 2020 2021 Global Advanced Economies Emerging Markets Source: TD Economics 3
Slide 4: More than 2 Million COVID-19 Cases Worldwide, But There Is Light At The End
More than 2 Million COVID-19 Cases Worldwide, But There Is Light At The End Of The Tunnel More than 2 Million People Have Tested Positive for COVID-19 But the Curve Is Slowly Bending COVID-19 Number of Cases, Thousands Cumulative COVID-19 Cases 2,500 1,000,000 2,000 100,000 1,500 Canada 10,000 Franc
Slide 5: Some European Countries Are Starting to Relax Measures
Some European Countries Are Starting to Relax Measures Austria's Recovery Rate Has Been Consistently Higher While Denmark’s Recovery Rate Has Also Been Close to than Its Death Rate in Recent Weeks 100% Since Beginning April % % Restrictions imposed Restrictions imposed 100 100 80 80 60 60 Recovery R
Slide 6: But Some Asian Economies Are Being Hit by a Second Wave
But Some Asian Economies Are Being Hit by a Second Wave Singapore and Japan Have Seen a Resurgence of Cases as a Second Social Distancing Matters COVID-19 Wave Hits Cumulative Number of COVID-19 Cases, Thousands 10 9 8 0 7 -10 6 Singapore Japan -20 5 4 -30 3 -40 2 -50 1 -60 0 26-Feb 07-Mar 17-Mar 27
Slide 7: Business Activity, Especially The Services Sector, Has Been Hit Hard Globally
Business Activity, Especially The Services Sector, Has Been Hit Hard Globally Record Lows in Services Sector Activity Manufacturing Sector Also Took a Hit Service PMIs Indexes Manufacturing PMIs Indexes 60 56 Australia EZ France 55 54 Germany Japan U.K. 52 50 50 45 48 40 46 Australia Euro Area Franc
Slide 8: Despite the Russian-Saudi Truce, Oil Prices Remain Subdued
Despite the Russian-Saudi Truce, Oil Prices Remain Subdued WTI, USD/Barrel Copper, US¢/lb 70 310 Russian-Saudi price war starts Russian-Saudi ceasefire 60 290 270 50 250 40 230 30 210 20 WTI (LHS) Copper (RHS) 190 10 170 0 150 03-Jan 18-Jan 02-Feb 17-Feb 03-Mar 18-Mar 02-Apr 17-Apr Source: CME, TD E
Slide 9: Emerging Market Economies Are Going Through An Unprecedented Sudden-Stop
Emerging Market Economies Are Going Through An Unprecedented Sudden-Stop Emerging Market Portfolio Flows are in Free Fall Year/Year % Change 2 Equity Flows Debt Flows Total Flows 1 0 -1 -2 2008-09 GFC 2013 Taper Tantrum 2018 EM Sell-off -3 -4 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2018 2020 Source: IIF, TD Econom
Slide 10: But China Is Showing Promising Signs Of Recovery
But China Is Showing Promising Signs Of Recovery China PMI Index 60 55 50 45 40 35 Services PMI Manufacturing PMI 30 25 Mar-19 May-19 Jul-19 Sep-19 Nov-19 Jan-20 Mar-20 Source: CNBS, TD Economics Note: Below 50 = a majority of businesses reported a contraction 10
Slide 11: Unprecedented Fiscal Measures Have Torn Apart The Fiscal Rulebook
Unprecedented Fiscal Measures Have Torn Apart The Fiscal Rulebook, Ending The Age Of Austerity Target Liquidity Solvency Fiscal Spending (% of GDP) 40 • Suspension of mortgage 36% payments, student loans • Cash transfers 35 30 • Tax and social security • Unemployment Households contributions deferra
Slide 12: Central Banks Around The World Have Responded Using Conventional and Unconventional Monetary Tools
Central Banks Around The World Have Responded Using Conventional and Unconventional Monetary Tools - Lowering policy rates Conventional - Adjusting reserve requirements Monetary & - Quantitative easing Regulatory Unconventional - Monetization Measures - Relaxing banks' capital requirements Macroprud
Slide 13: The Global Economy Will Look Drastically Different Once We Get Through This
The Global Economy Will Look Drastically Different Once We Get Through This Global Economy Real Monetary Fiscal External - Monetary policy less effective - Large deficits - Decrease in Potential GDP - Debt sustainability - Weaker currencies - Depletion of central bank tools issues - More exchange ra
Slide 14: Multilateral Institutions Will Play An Increasingly Important Role
Much like Post-war Era, Multilateral Institutions Will Play An Increasingly Important Role ❑ An increasing role of multilateral institutions: ➢IMF (International Monetary Fund) ➢World Bank ➢AIIB (Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank) ➢ADB (Asian Development Bank) ❑ A "Marshall Plan" equivalent to re
Slide 15: United States
United States
Slide 16: Prolonged Return to "Normal" Level of Activity
Prolonged Return to "Normal" Level of Activity Forecast Level of Real GDP (LHS) 20,000 $Billions % 18 Unemployment Rate (RHS) 16 19,000 14 12 18,000 10 8 17,000 6 16,000 4 2 15,000 0 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 2019 2020 2021 2022 Source: TD Economics: Forecasts as of April 20th, 2020 16
Slide 17: Biggest Job Losses Seen in Lower-Paid Sectors
Biggest Job Losses Seen in Lower-Paid Sectors March Job Gains/Losses (Thous.) Average Weekly Earnings, $ (Jan. 2020) Leisure & hospitality -459 Retail trade -46 -24 Below Average Weekly Earnings Other services Education & health svs -76 -5 Transportation & warehousing -18 Private Sector Average $975
Slide 18: CARES Act Provides Material Assistance, More to Come
CARES Act Provides Material Assistance, More to Come Estimates for Measures in the CARES Act, $Billions Tax Breaks, 300 Individual Rebates, 290 Unemployment Health & Various Benefits, Federal Spending, 260 324 Paychek Protection Plan, 366 Grants to State & Local Govt and Industries, Loans & Loan Gua
Slide 19: Paths Back to "Normal" Will Vary by Region
Paths Back to "Normal" Will Vary by Region Confirmed COVID-19 Cases per 100,000 People as of April 17th 2020, Log 10,000 1,000 New York New Jersey D.C. CT Massachusetts DE GA Pennsylvania MD WA Florida 100 NH California SC VA Texas ME NC WV 10 - 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 2019 Real GDP, $ Bil
Slide 20: Canada
Canada
Slide 21: Service Sector Nature of Shock Means A Lasting Mark
Service Sector Nature of Shock Means A Lasting Mark Index, 2018 = 100 Key Industries Likely To Feel Hit of COVID-19 115 GDP Pre-Crisis Potential Level March 2020 Job 110 Share of GDP Losse, Thsds Post Crisis Potential Level 105 Education 5.3% -125.4 100 Retail ex. Essentials 3.3% -207.5* 95 Food Ser
Slide 22: Demand+Supply Shocks Hammer Canadian Oil Producers
Demand+Supply Shocks Hammer Canadian Oil Producers 70 USD per Barrel 60 50 40 30 20 WTI WCS 10 0 Jan-19 Apr-19 Jul-19 Oct-19 Jan-20 Apr-20 Source: Bloomberg, TD Economics 22
Slide 23: Bank of Canada Working To Keep Liquidity Flowing
Bank of Canada Working To Keep Liquidity Flowing FRA-OIS Spread, Basis Points 80 70 ❑ 100bp of inter-meeting cuts 60 ❑ Quantitative easing ($5bn/month) 50 40 ❑ Easing of collateral policies and concentration limits 30 ❑ Purchases of CMBs, BAs, provincial bills 20 10 0 Jan-19 Apr-19 Jul-19 Oct-19 Jan
Slide 24: Housing Entering A Stasis Period
Housing Entering A Stasis Period Sales Took A Dive.. But Markets Still Tight 115 Index, 2017 = 100 80 Ratio of Sales to New Listings 110 70 Seller's Market 105 100 60 95 50 Balanced Market 90 85 40 80 Buyer's Market 30 75 70 20 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Source: CREA, TD Econo
Slide 25: Government Keeps Building The Bridge
Government Keeps Building The Bridge Measures for Households Measures for Business • Canada Emergency Response Benefit: $2k/month • $40bn in SME credit via BDC and EDC for those who lost income ($24bn) • Temporary 75% wage subsidy, to max payment • Doubling the GST tax credit at a one-time cost of p
Slide 26: What We'll Be Watching
What We'll Be Watching ❑ U.S. Developments ❑ Traditional Economy: ➢ Electricity usage (daily) ➢ Railway Carloadings (weekly) ❑ Service Sector: ➢ CFIB's new bi-weekly indicator ➢ HH sentiment indicators, such as Bloomberg-Nanos (weekly) ➢ Other interesting indicators (OpenTable, Google location repor
Slide 27: Financial
Financial
Slide 28: Equity Markets In Context
Equity Markets In Context Recessions Non-Recessions Peak-to-trough, %, Number of days Between Peak-to-trough, %, Number of days Between Closing Value Peak and Trough Closing Value Peak and Trough 1929 -86.2 1026 1933-1935 Sell Off -33.9 604 1937 -54.5 386 1945 -6.9 19 1962 Sell Off -28.0 196 1948 -2
Slide 29: Corporate Debt
Corporate Debt AAA AA Spread off US-10Y, % 50 A BBB 45 BB B 40 35 CCC 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 -5 1997 1999 2002 2004 2007 2009 2012 2015 2017 2020 Source: ICE/BAML, FRB, TD Economics 29
Slide 30: The Road Forward
The Road Forward ❑ Phase 1: ➢Action: Liquidity injections by central banks ➢Goal: Keep the financial system intact ➢Signal of Success: Low funding rates and lower financial market volatility ❑ Phase 2: ➢Action: Keep policy rates and bond yields low ➢Goal: Enable the economy to accelerate out of the
Slide 31: Website: economics.td.com Twitter: @TD_Economics
This concludes our webcast. Thank you for joining us. Website: economics.td.com Twitter: @TD_Economics This report is provided by TD Economics for customers of TD Bank Group. It is for information purposes only and may not be appropriate for other purposes. The report does not provide material infor
TD Economics — COVID-19 Economic Assessment Webcast (April 2020) on 6ix