Slide 1: Users' Group Working group Belgian Grid
Users’ Group Working group Belgian Grid Wednesday, May 17
Slide 2: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 3: Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public consultation
1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public consultation Beslissende elementen inzake de voorziene ontwikkelingen in het tariefdossier 2024-2027 Periode publieke consultatie: 14 februari tot 20 maart ‘23 11 (niet-confidentiële) reacties: - BOP - FEBELIEC - BSTOR - Fluvius - Essenscia - Infrabel
Slide 4: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 5: Access Contract
Access Contract Access Contract 5
Slide 6: Agenda
Agenda • Triggers for modification • Main amendments to contract - Object & general conditions • Main amendments to access contract –Technical Conditions – xBRP • Next steps & timelines • Dutch translation available on May 19th • Feedback from regulators expected June 2nd • Public Consultation to St
Slide 7: Triggers
Triggers • Modifications following Regulator’s questions/objections from previous consultation • Harmonize definitions • Include Multiple BRP Access Contract 7
Slide 8: Main amendments to contract (object & general conditions)
Main amendments to contract (object & general conditions) • 1. Definitions • 4.1 Déclarations & garanties (également au nom de l’UR) => clarify the commitments of different parties (CWaPE) • 6.5 Protection des données à caractère personnel (garantie/diligence du détenteur d’accès lorsqu’il diffuse/c
Slide 9: Definitions
Definitions 1. CDS => reflect dispositions from Regional Texts 2. Code de Bonne Conduite => reflect evolutions of Code de Bonne Conduite 3. Contrat d’Agent de Programme (aka SA) => explain relation between SA & ELIA (used in art 18 & 21) 4. Contrat Elia – Fournisseur => Clarify data exchange between
Slide 10: Multiple BRP & CCMD
Multiple BRP & CCMD Access Contract 10
Slide 11: Flexibility Services that will require a correction model
Flexibility Services that will require a correction model Multiple BRP / Explicit flexibility Energy communities Supplier Consumer Centric Market Design *The terminology ‘CCMD Services’ used in this presentation refers to the possibilities offered to an Energy Service Provider to valorize its flexib
Slide 12: CCMD design in 2023 and 2024
CCMD design in 2023 and 2024 2023 March April May June July August Sept. October November December Design 1.0 (focus 1st go-live TSO connected – end 2023) Go live TSO grid user - Explicit flex Mid sept - Energy communities WG CCMD 22.3 ~ End June – End July Finalize design proposal Submission - Supp
Slide 13: Connection contract
Regulatory framework evolutions required to reflect CCMD design 1.0 MULTIPLE BRPS Today’s discussion Access Contract Connection contract Supplier contract BRP contract ENERGY COMMUNITIES ToE rules Energy community framework EXPLICIT FLEX T&C mFRR T&C aFRR Regulated Non regulated Pre-requisite to go
Slide 14: Access contract - evolutions due to CCMD
Access contract - evolutions due to CCMD Definition of “Delivery Point” Un Point d’Accès ou un point faisant partie des installations de l’Utilisateur de Réseau à partir duquel un service est fourni. Ce point est associé à un ou plusieurs équipement(s) de mesure, selon les modalités précisées dans l
Slide 15: Access contract - evolutions due to CCMD
Access contract - evolutions due to CCMD New article introduced to reflect the current procedure to add an Access Point to the portfolio of an Access Holder to the Delivery Point level Registration of a Delivery Point by the Access Holder Annex 2 adapted accordingly (to reflect the registered DP
Slide 16: Questions?
Questions? Access Contract 16
Slide 17: Thank you
lia Thank you
Slide 18: Backup
“ela Backup Access Contract | 18
Slide 19: Main amendments to access contract - Technical Conditions - xBRP
Main amendments to access contract – Technical Conditions - xBRP • 2.2 Scope of contract • 17.1 Catégories de détenteurs d’accès (adaptations des annexes 3) • 17.4 Procédure pour l’ajout d’un point de livraison (cfr explication détaillée sur multiple BRP) • 20.1 Type de responsable d’équilibre par p
Slide 20: Afstemming Toegangscontract op bepalingen Gedragscode (art. 95)
Afstemming Toegangscontract op bepalingen Gedragscode (art. 95) • Betalingsmodaliteiten: art 12 • Onbetaalde sommen: art 11 en 12 • Vertrouwelijkheid van de commerciële gegevens: art 6 • Bemiddeling en arbitrage: art 15 • Gevaar voor de fysieke integriteit van personen of voor materiële schade: art
Slide 21: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 22: Revision Connection Contract
Revision Connection Contract Status Connection Contract 22
Slide 23: Status Connection Contract
Status Connection Contract - Parts A & B have been revised and submitted based on: - Regulator’s feedback (only part A) - Legislative evolution - Technical reality (mainly part B) - Digitalization - Evolutions of other contracts - Annexes have been updated - ICAROS has been included - Next steps: -
Slide 24: Art 1 Definitions and interpretation
Main triggers: - Alignment new regulation - Consistency Art 1 Definitions and interpretation: - - Scoping extension Stakeholders’/regulators’ input – References to legislation/regulation = as amended from time to time – Extra definitions have been added : Autres Installations de Raccordement, BSP Co
Slide 25: Art 1 Definitions and interpretation (1/3) - Installations
Art 1 Definitions and interpretation (1/3)- Installations Focus on some definitions - Installations Installation Current connection contract: “toute Installation de Raccordement, Installation de l’Utilisateur du Réseau ou lignedirecte” New proposal: « toute Installation de Raccordement, Installation
Slide 26: Définition Installation
Définition “Installation” Installation de Raccordement Ligne directe Installation de l’Utilisateur du Réseau Unité de Production d’Electricité Installation de Stockage d’Energie Status Connection Contract 26
Slide 27: Définitions Installation - Installation de l'Utilisateur du Réseau
Définitions “Installation” – “Installation de l’Utilisateur du Réseau” Installation de Raccordement Installation de l’Utilisateur du Réseau Installation de l’Utilisateur du CDS : CDS Grid User 1: Unité de Production d’Electricité CDS Grid User 2: Installation de Stockage d’Energie CDS Grid User 3 (p
Slide 28: Art 1 Definitions and interpretation (2/3)
Art 1 Definitions and interpretation- (2/3) New definitions Cocontractant: the Grid User (GU) who signs the Contract. Installation de comptage: tout équipement de mesure pour effectuer des comptages. Point de Livraison: Un Point d’Accès ou un point faisant partie des installations de l’Utilisateur d
Slide 29: Art 1 Definitions and interpretation (3/3)
Art 1 Definitions and interpretation (3/3) Raccordement Partagé: le Raccordement partagé par deux Utilisateurs du Réseau, réalisé conformément aux dispositions du Code de Bonne Conduite, aux dispositions correspondantes des autres Règlements Techniques applicables et aux dispositions du présent Cont
Slide 30: Shared connection
Shared connection Normal connection Access point grid user A Access point <> grid user B 150kV Versus 150 kV <> Counters grid One connection point user B Counters grid user A Elia substation Elia substation Public domain Public domain Grid user Grid user Submeter 11 11 11 11 kV kV kV kV Grid user A
Slide 31: Art 1 Interpretations
Art 1 Interpretations -Extended interpretation rule: Priority articles of contract unless specific disposition in Annexe Priority of content Annexe above “schéma uniflaire” Status Connection Contract 31
Slide 32: Art 8.2 State of alert, emergency, blackout
Art 6.1 (old art 5)– Confidential information – Text has been adapted according to numerous remarks – Communication to subcontractors/consultants, subject to same confidentiality obligation Art 8.2 (old art 7.2) - État d’alerte, d’urgence, de panne généralisée (black-out) ou de reconstitution -Addit
Slide 33: Art 8.3 Force Majeure
Art 8.3 – Force Majeure – Clarifications on concepts such as: – processes & communication (f.e. phone + mail confirmation) – New: situation of exceptional risk during which the sudden unavailability of a CDS or Battery is caused – Terms (long force majeure) Status Connection Contract 33
Slide 34: Art 11 Invoicing and payment
Art 11 Invoicing and payment – Reference to annex 7 on the Digital Platform (ex. Invoicing address) – Timing for settlement of credit note: next invoice – In case of electronic invoices: formal notice for late payment also per e-mail – Where can I consult my invoices in EPIC? – Help Center (epic-por
Slide 35: Art 12.1 Consequences of interrupting/ending contract & 12.2 Termination
Art 12.1 Consequences of interrupting/ending contract & 12.2 Contract Termination – Clarification on the conditions for Elia to take initiative in interrupting/stopping a contract (see also full size management) if impact on grid security, reliability and efficiency, – in case of unilateral modifica
Slide 36: Art 12.1 suspension of contract
Main triggers: - Feedback public consultation - Interaction with part B - Experience based Art 12.1 suspension of contract EXISTING CONTRACT NEW TEXT PROPOSAL: additions Right to suspend for Elia and for GU – Clarification on the conditions for Elia to take initiative in suspending a contract (see a
Slide 37: Art 12.2 termination of contract
Main triggers: - Feedback public consultation - Interaction with part B - Experience based - Take into account reality Art 12.2 termination of contract behind the connection EXISTING CONTRACT NEW TEXT PROPOSAL: additions – Resolution – By GU: …+ dismantling agreement – By GU: 3 months notice when co
Slide 38: Art 12.3 Consequences of suspension-termination; Art 12.4 CRM Participation
Art 12.3 Consequences of suspension-termination contract – Specification that suspension/termination can be both partial or total – Specification that cost of interventions in respect of decommissioning in case of suspension/termination is for GU if cause is non-conformity Art 12.4 - CRM Participati
Slide 39: Art 13.3 Boiler plate clauses
Art 13.3 Boiler plate clauses – 13.3 modifications contact persons list: Arrangements with respect to EPIC info exchange – 13.9 priority on existing contracts: limited to historic situations Status Connection Contract 39
Slide 40: Connection Contract - Part B - Conditions Techniques
Connection Contract – Part B – Conditions Techniques Status Connection Contract 40
Slide 41: Art 16 Condition precedent regarding conformity of connection
Art 16 Condition precedent regarding the conformity of a new or modified Connection Art 17.2 Property rights New art 16 /Old art 8: Condition suspensive relative à l’utilisation d’une installation d’un nouveau raccordement ou d’un raccordement modifié Clear description of conditions (conformity) for
Slide 42: Art 18.1 Establishment, modifications, provision, management
Art 18.1/old art 12 Establishment, modifications, provision, Trigger: management -Better distinction between capex and opex -consistency with tariffs Owner of Connection Installations (partly or 100%) in charge of: – Realisation in accordance with the modalities agreed between Parties in the framewo
Slide 43: Art 18.2 Light & Full-size Management
Triggers: - Better distinction between capex and opex Art 18.2/old 12.2 Light & Full-size Management - Experience based - consistency with tariffs – Light : - Monitoring of connection Separate periodic light tariff - Operation ((de-) activation via command of 1st bay, selective (de-)activations via
Slide 44: Art 18.2.3 Designation of party in charge of Full-size management
Art 18.2.3/old 12.2.3 Designation of the party in charge of Full-size management Existing principles remain: -For the first Connection Bay or the other Connection Facilities owned by Elia: Elia responsible full-size management -For the first Connection Bay not owned by Elia: choice for Elia after co
Slide 45: Financial Guarantee & Art 19 Tariffs
Financial Guarantee & Art 19 Tariffs – Financial Guarantee (old art 14) – for new or substantial modification of connection is no longer requested – Tariffs (art 19/old art 13 Redevances): – Art 19.1 determination of tarifs also based on “Installations de comptage” not part of Connection Installatio
Slide 46: Link between the annexes and the core of the contract
Link between the annexes and the core of the contract – General clauses in Annexes moved to the relevant articles – Art 20 - description of the connection: (identification of connection installations, installations of GU and, if and when, third party installations behind connection, which can have i
Slide 47: Art 20 Description of the Connection and Installations
Art 20/ old article 15 Description of the Connection and Installations that may have an influence on the safety, the reliability and/or efficiency of the Elia-Grid and the metering installations Art 20.1: General: new §§: Territorial limitations “Le Point de Raccordement et le Point d’Interface pour
Slide 48: Art 21 Counting and metering
Art 21/ old art. 16 Counting and metering - Art 21.1 Description of Installations de (Sous-) Comptage and method of calculation in Annex 4: MESURES ET COMPTAGES AINSI QU’ÉCHANGE DE DONNÉES Annexe 4bis: INSTALLATIONS DE SOUS-COMPTAGE - Art 21.2 Procedure of DP creation In case of DP different from Ac
Slide 49: Art 22 Conformity of Installations; Art 23 Protection and access
Art 22/ old art 17 Conformity of the Installations Art. 23/old art 18 Protection of and access to the Installations Conformity (art 22) Art 22.2 General - Conformity of Installations of GU and all other Installations with possible impact on Elia Grid (incl Installations of CDS user) - Reference to t
Slide 50: Art 24 Operation and maintenance of Installations
Art 24/ old art 19 Operation and maintenance of Installations that may influence the safety, reliability and/or efficiency of the Elia Grid Art 24.1 General Specific arrangements between the Parties related to operation and maintenance/other interventions of Connection Installations in Annexes 2 and
Slide 51: Art 25 Data Exchange
Art 25/ old art 20 Data Exchange New art 25.2 (Data published by Elia) The data required by the European Transparency Regulation are to be transmitted by the Co-contractor to ELIA for publication by ELIA on the ENTSO-E platform. New 25.3 (Structural Data- Identification Data) The Co-contractor 'Netw
Slide 52: Art 26 Permits
Art 26 Permits/ Old art 21 Article aligned with specific regional legislation and modified content of Connection agreement Status Connection Contract 52
Slide 53: General overview of Annex contents
General overview of Annex contents 1. Description of connection and installations GU : more detailed and restructured 2. Management of connection: general rules moved to core of the contract 3. Maintenance of connection: general rules moved to core of the contract 4. Metering and 4bis sub metering:
Slide 54: Alignment new regulation
Alignment new regulation 2009 =>2023 : new regulation new wording, new references, new definitions, Eg. Netcodes, code of conduct since split of federal grid code, … Compliance with new regulation Eg. technical requirements RFG, DCC, commissioning new/ modified connection or installation GU depe
Slide 55: Annex 3 Specific agreements for maintenance and other interventions
Annex 3 SPECIFIC AGREEMENTS FOR MAINTENANCE AND OTHER INTERVENTIONS ON CONNECTION INSTALLATIONS THAT MAY AFFECT THE SAFETY, RELIABILITY OR EFFICIENCY OF THE ELIA GRID – General rules moved to core of the contract – Indication of « full-size » management responsable per installation – Limits of manag
Slide 56: Annexes 4, 4bis, 5, and 6
Annexes 4, 4bis, 5, and 6 Annex 4: Mesures et comptages ainsi qu’échange de données Annexe 4bis: Installations de sous-comptage Description of Installations de (Sous-) Comptage and method of calculation in Annex 5 Power Quality & 6 Tariffs general rules moved to core of the contract Status Connectio
Slide 57: Annex 7 Terms and timeframes for new connection
Annex 7 : TERMS AND CONDITIONS AND TIMEFRAMES FOR THE INSTALLATION OF A NEW CONNECTION OR SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION OF AN EXISTING CONNECTION, AS WELL AS THE COMMISSIONING OF A POWER GENERATION UNIT – Deadlines: regime already integrated at the occasion of CRM related modifications has been further c
Slide 58: Annex 8 (Plans and diagrams) revised
Annex 8 (Plans and diagrams) revised – Centralization of all plans & diagrams in this Annex. Status Connection & Access Contract 59
Slide 59: Annex 9: Modalities of Shared Connection
Annex 9: Modalities of Shared Connection – In accordance with the provisions of the Code of Conduct and, where applicable, the Regional Technical Regulations, an agreement shall be entered into between the GU’s sharing the Connection, setting forth the rights and obligations of each GU with respect
Slide 60: Annex 10 Offshore
Annex 10 Offshore – Formalization of an already informally used Annex – More generic concept of « Offshore installation » rather than « island » or « platform » – No « right of way » (servitude) for 3rd parties on Elia’s offshore installations Status Connection Contract 61
Slide 61: Necessary changes for ICAROS
Necessary changes for ICAROS Status Connection Contract 62
Slide 62: Context - Designation of OPA and Scheduling Agent (SA)
Context - Designation of the Outage Planning Agent (OPA) and Scheduling Agent (SA) ― Regulatory framework is not ‘aligned’ regarding who is responsible to appoint OPA and SA Article OPA/SA appointed by SOGL 89 and 110 Asset Owner Reglement Federal + Vlaams Grid User ― Asset and Asset owner need to b
Slide 63: Modifications to Connection Contract
Modifications to Connection Contract List of Technical Facilities and Asset Owners ― List of all (sPGM, PPM, Demand facilities) Technical Facilities ― Clear identification and formalization of the role of the Asset owner per Technical Facility, identification of the Asset owner (the Grid User of a
Slide 64: Thank you
lia Thank you
Slide 65: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 66: Roadmap to publication of Hosting Capacity Maps
Roadmap to publication of Hosting Capacity Maps WG Belgian Grid 17/05/2023 R. Devolder, N. Bragard, J. Sprooten
Slide 67: Agenda
Agenda 1. Planning and milestones 2. Recap of Stakeholder comments received 3. Proposed hosting capacity map • an interactive tool • assumptions & methodology • disclaimers 4. Conclusion & next steps Hosting Capacity Maps 68
Slide 68: Planning and milestones
Planning and milestones WG Belgian Grid – Annual publication of WG Belgian Grid – 07/12/2023 – Hosting Capacity Maps 16/02/2023 – Presentation & 1st stakeholder publication of workshop: WG Belgian Grid – Hosting Capacity Identification of needs, 17/05/2023 – Maps relevant hypotheses & 2st stakeholde
Slide 69: Agenda
Agenda 1. Planning and milestones 2. Recap of Stakeholder comments received 3. Proposed hosting capacity map • an interactive tool • assumptions & methodology • disclaimers 4. Conclusion & next steps Hosting Capacity Maps 70
Slide 70: Recap of Stakeholder comments received
Recap of Stakeholder comments received Overall, we see indeed that such a digital map would be very useful, even if the main bottleneck for larger projects are related to permits, connection is often also a big hurdle for project developers. Comments/remarks: • The map should not cause large project
Slide 71: Agenda
Agenda 1. Planning and milestones 2. Recap of Stakeholder comments received 3. Proposed hosting capacity map • an interactive tool • assumptions & methodology • disclaimers 4. Conclusion & next steps Hosting Capacity Maps 72
Slide 72: Proposed hosting capacity map - an interactive tool
Proposed hosting capacity map - an interactive tool Dynamic map based on user input: • Mock-up showing the outcome of a selection • Target year: 2026 or 2031 • Type grid user (new connection): o Load Flat profile (production & o Generation consumption equally likely at all times) o Batteries o Solar
Slide 73: Assumptions & methodology (1/4)
Proposed hosting capacity map - Assumptions & methodology (1/4) • The hosting capacity takes into account future reservations & foreseen evolutions of the development plans The displayed hosting capacity needs to be available until 2034 (if necessary Elia will propose new investments in future dev
Slide 74: Assumptions & methodology (2/4)
Proposed hosting capacity map - Assumptions & methodology (2/4) • A reference context is defined based on the expected situations of the electrical system in future years. It is built on the basis of : Reference context contains the planned evolution of the electrical network the capacities reserved
Slide 75: Assumptions & methodology (3/4)
Proposed hosting capacity map - Assumptions & methodology (3/4) • The transmission system is a network infrastructure which is of common interest (societal interest) • In order to reach this objective, Elia is entitled to propose connections for grid users which are inline with an harmonious develop
Slide 76: Assumptions & methodology (4/4)
Proposed hosting capacity map - Assumptions & methodology (4/4) • LV load and generation evolution • The hosting capacity of generation and storage is reduced at local level by the expected evolution of low voltage distribution-connected PV which do not require a capacity reservation • => A % share
Slide 77: Proposed hosting capacity map - Disclaimers
Proposed hosting capacity map - Disclaimers • Scope: This map visualizes an approximation of the hosting capacity for Elia grid capacities < 300MW. • Higher capacities cannot be estimated without location-specific detailed analysis • Connections on low voltage grids are possible, regardless of the h
Slide 78: Agenda
Agenda 1. Planning and milestones 2. Recap of Stakeholder comments received 3. Proposed hosting capacity map • an interactive tool • assumptions & methodology • disclaimers 4. Conclusion & next steps Hosting Capacity Maps 79
Slide 79: Conclusion & next steps
Conclusion & next steps • Elia will continue the development of the hosting capacity map • The hosting capacity map will be presented & published during the WG Belgian Grid of 07/12/2023 • A feedback session will be organized in 2024 in the WG Belgian Grid to identify improvements for the next yearl
Slide 80: Thank you.
Thank you.
Slide 81: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 82: Voltage service - Incentive
Voltage service - Incentive 17/05/2023
Slide 83: MVAr service incentive - Summary
MVAr service incentive – Summary Context and goals of the incentive • Following entry into force of the new design in 2020, some return of experience is available • This study intends to analyze further possible design improvements for the voltage and reactive power control service in order to: • Op
Slide 84: MVAr service incentive - Review and recommendations for design optimisations
MVAr service incentive – Review and recommendations for design optimisations 1. Continuous activation control for manual and automatic 6. Communication with Elia activation 1. The current communication is done via Revolt and is limited in the type of messages that can be sent. 2. Penalties 2. Invest
Slide 85: MVAr service incentive - Planning
MVAr service incentive– Planning Indicative timeline: Submission of Workshop with market parties on needs of the study to improvements 2nd workshop with market parties about the CREG BG proposal of improvements Dec 23 March 21 End of June 1. Identification of design Jan 1 – Mar 31 improvements and E
Slide 86: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex
Slide 87: Cost benefit analysis on Requirements for generators 1-25 MW
Cost benefit analysis on Requirements for generators applicable on existing and new generating units between 1 and 25 MW Belgian Grid 17/05/2023 | N. Bragard, O. Bronckart, C. Hoedenaeken, S. Temtem
Slide 88: Agenda
Agenda 1. Objectives of the incentive 2. High level methodology 3. Planning and milestones 89
Slide 89: Objective of the incentive
Objective of the incentive The objective of the incentive is to : • Identify the differences between the prescriptions applicable to existing and new PGMs between 1 and 25 MW (not included) and connected to Elia grid (Belgium). • Perform a cost-benefit analysis : • Focused on the PGMs with a power b
Slide 90: Agenda
Agenda 1. Objective of the incentive 2. High level methodology 3. Planning and milestones 91
Slide 91: Requirements applicable to new PGMs between 1 and 25 MW
What are the requirements applicable to new PGMs between 1 and 25 MW ? Types of requirements for new PGMs type B: 1) Data questionnaire & models 2) Internal compliance proof (RGIE) & protection scheme 3) Voltage & frequency requirements 4) Real-time information / Telecom requirements 5) Balancing/Co
Slide 92: Comparison with requirements applicable to existing PGMs
Comparison with requirements applicable to existing PGMs between 1 and 25 MW ? Requirements applicable Comparison table to existing units Selection of requirements to be analysed via the CBA: - Requirements already applicable to existing PGMs : out of scope - Requirements applicable only for new PGM
Slide 93: Number of existing and new PGMs between 1 and 25 MW
Number of existing and new PGMs between 1 and 25 MW Amount of existing vs new PGMs (#) 24 112 From a pragmatic point of view: - Elia communicated requirements for new PGMs as from 27/04/2019 (date of publication Amount of existing vs new PGMs (MW) of federal grid code) at federal and regional level
Slide 94: Focus on the existing PGMs between 1 and 25 MW
Focus on the existing PGMs between 1 and 25 MW Repartition per type of existing PGMs Repartition SPGM vs PPM for existing and new PGMs 95
Slide 95: Comparison of requirements type B PGM
Comparison of requirements type B PGM Categories of requirements for PGMs: 1) Data questionnaire & models 2) Internal compliance proof (RGIE) & protection scheme More stringent or new 3) Voltage & frequency requirements 4) Information exchange / Telecom requirements Less stringent 5) Balancing/conge
Slide 96: Summary of the gap analysis of the requirements
Summary of the gap analysis of the requirements Category of requirements Sub category GAP analysis Remark Eligible for incentive Data questionnaire Small changes Category 1 Data questionnaire & Models Models More stringent X RGIE Identical Annex 1 : Icc max More stringent Not in the scope : DCC Cate
Slide 97: CBA: Qualitative assessment
CBA: Qualitative assessment Benefits evaluation (Expert view) 3 ways to sort the requirements : I) 4 technical families of requirements : • Voltage • Frequency • Current Expert view Benefit classification • Other classification as 2 MUST = High MUST / NICE to HAVE benefit II) 2 operational system st
Slide 98: CBA: Qualitative assessment
CBA : Qualitative assessment Benefits evaluation (Expert view) 4 technical families of requirements : • Frequency : lack of performance or robustness in terms of frequency requirements might endanger the security of the whole synchronous area and can expose the system to black-out MUST for the sys
Slide 99: CBA: Qualitative assessment
CBA : Qualitative assessment Benefits evaluation (Expert view) Criteria : at least 2 MUST = High benefit Frequency vs voltage vs Normal state vs Emergency Be robust vs give robustness current Impact/benefit Sub category GAP analysis Eligible for incentive Classification Benefit Classification Benefi
Slide 100: CBA: Qualitative assessment - cost evaluation
CBA : Qualitative assessment Cost evaluation (Expert view) Costs Criteria : Sub category GAP analysis Eligible for incentive - low = minor adjustments (settings) Models More stringent X LOW - medium = replacement of some elements of Rate of change of frequency (ROCOF) More stringent X LOW LFSM-O Mor
Slide 101: CBA: Qualitative results
CBA : Qualitative results Frequency vs voltage vs Normal state vs Emergency Be robust vs give robustness current Impact/benefit Costs Results of the CBA Sub category GAP analysis Classification Benefit Classification Benefit Classification Benefit Models More stringent Other Nice to have Normal Nice
Slide 102: Agenda
Agenda 1. Objectives 2. High level methodology 3. Planning and milestones 103
Slide 103: Planning and milestones
Planning and milestones • Phase 1 : Preparation of work – Elia • Inventory of existing and new PGMs between 1 & 25 MW • Comparison or the requirements applicable to existing and new PGMs • First evaluation of the requirements in terms of benefits for the grid and selection of candidate requirements
Slide 104: Planning and milestones
Planning and milestones WG Belgian Grid – WG Belgian Grid – 07/12/2023 – WG Belgian Grid – Presentation of 16/02/2023 – 17/05/2023 – the conclusions 1st stakeholder 2st stakeholder workshop: Workshop with market workshop: 23/12/23 Presentation of the parties to be planned Presentation of Submission
Slide 105: Thank you.
Thank you.
Slide 106: Agenda
Agenda 1. Tariff proposal 2024-2027: results of public 4. Incentives consultation 4.1. Hosting capacity maps 2. Access contract: main modifications 4.2. Incentive MVAr 4.3. Incentive CBA: Cost benefit analysis on 3. Connection contract: main modifications Requirements for Generators applicable on ex