Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. · NYSE:CLF

Cleveland-Cliffs — Alpha Natural Resources — Merger or Acquisition (August 2008)

30 slides from Cleveland-Cliffs's merger presentation, Aug 4, 2008

  1. Slide 1: Cliffs Natural Resources Investor Presentation

    Filed by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc Commission File No. 1-8944 Pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act of 1933 and deemed filed pursuant to Rule 14a-12 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Subject Company: Alpha Natural Resources, Inc. Commission File No. 1-32423 CLIFFS NATURAL RESOURCES INVEST

  2. Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995

    “Safe Harbor” Statement under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 A number of the matters discussed in this document that are not historical or current facts deal with potential future circumstances and developments, in particular, information regarding expected synergies resulting

  3. Slide 3: Important Information for Investors and Shareholders

    Important Information for Investors and Shareholders Additional Information and Where to Find It In connection with the proposed transaction, a registration statement on Form S-4 will be filed with the SEC. CLEVELAND- CLIFFS AND ALPHA SHAREHOLDERS ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE REGISTRATION STATEMENT AN

  4. Slide 4: Transaction Highlights

    Transaction Highlights Creates a leading independent supplier of critical raw materials to the robust North American steel industry and a major global player — Core iron ore and met coal businesses strongly correlated Capitalizes on strong outlook for iron ore, metallurgical and thermal coal Shared

  5. Slide 5: Why Alpha?

    Why Alpha? Largest US met coal supplier Strong management team with 20+ years of industry experience Supply/demand metrics in coal market Unique blending and coal optimization capabilities drive meaningful synergy potential Meaningfully increases exposure to export market given infrastructure and sa

  6. Slide 6: Transaction Summary

    Transaction Summary Overview: Cleveland-Cliffs (“CLF”) to acquire 100% of Alpha Natural Resources (“ANR”) for cash and stock 1 Purchase Price: Equity purchase price of approximately $10 billion Premium: Based on Cliffs’ closing price on July 15, 2008, Alpha stockholders would receive a premium of 35

  7. Slide 7: Shared Cultural Commitment to Integrity, Safety & Environment

    Shared Cultural Commitment to Integrity, Safety & Environment Shared core values — Best-in-class safety standards and practices — Both companies recognize that the processing of the earth’s mineral resources must be accomplished in a socially responsible manner Integrated Management and Board struct

  8. Slide 8: The Right Platform – Supplier to the Steel Industry

    The Right Platform – Supplier to the Steel Industry 8

  9. Slide 9: Steel is a Large, Growing, Global Business

    Steel is a Large, Growing, Global Business Steel consumption potential (2007) Approx. 50mm tonnes Overall, China’s steel consumption is three times that of the US 1200 On a per capita basis, however, China Korea only consumes half as much as the US 1000 The US remains a net importer of steel 800 Jap

  10. Slide 10: Robust Steel Demand Drives this Combination

    Robust Steel Demand Drives this Combination Global steel demand (millions of tonnes) 2,000 BRIC cycle CAGR 1995-2015: 4.4% 1,500 Post-oil crisis slow down 1,000 Post World War II reconstruction CAGR 1973-1995: 0.4% and Japanese industrialization CAGR 1950-1973: 5.9% 500 0 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 19

  11. Slide 11: US Steel Industry is Particularly Well-Positioned

    US Steel Industry is Particularly Well-Positioned Dollar vs. Euro ($/€) US steel consumption (millions of tonnes) • Mitigates imports and strengthens exports • US is a net importer 150 1.25 US steel consumption US steel imports 125 1.00 100 75 0.75 50 25 0.50 0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 200

  12. Slide 12: CNR will be the Leading Supplier to the Robust North American Steel Industry

    CNR will be the Leading Supplier to the Robust North American Steel Industry Cliffs Natural Resources will be well-positioned to optimize operations from the combined company’s asset base 1 NA iron ore pellet production US met coal production (%) Coal production mix (million of tons) Met Coal Steam

  13. Slide 13: More Than 80% of Revenue Driven by Steel Industry

    More Than 80% of Revenue Driven by Steel Industry 1 Pro forma revenue & production (2008E) Cliffs North America Steam coal Steam coal Northshore Mining 12.5% 18.2% Hibbing Taconite Met coal Brokered coal 34.0% Met coal United Taconite Empire Wabush Mine 6.7% 23.4% Mine Brokered coal Cliffs Corporate

  14. Slide 14: Strong Iron Ore Trends

    Strong Iron Ore Trends Recently announced iron ore pellet contracts at~ ~ $140/tonne Iron ore prices ($/tonne) 150 Pellets Lump Fines 125 100 75 50 25 0 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008E Source: Tex Reports 14

  15. Slide 15: The Right Time – Coal Fundamentals are Attractive

    The Right Time – Coal Fundamentals are Attractive 15

  16. Slide 16: Strong Coal Pricing Trends

    Strong Coal Pricing Trends Met coal prices ($/tonne) Steam coal prices ($/ton) Alpha recently announced met coal contracts for between ~ ~ $300- Alpha recently announced ~~ 2.7 mt of steam coal contracts for $305/tonne at the port 2008/2009 delivery at ~ ~ $102/ton These contracts are for ~ ~ 3 mt a

  17. Slide 17: Favorable Met Coal Outlook

    Favorable Met Coal Outlook Demand driven by strong expected continued growth in global steel production—both domestically and abroad — Weak dollar and availability of iron and met coal favorable for US production outlook — US is swing supplier for export met coal markets to meet global demand Greate

  18. Slide 18: Favorable Met Coal Outlook

    Favorable Met Coal Outlook Few substitutes for coking coal Global seaborne met coal supply / demand (millions of tonnes) Import Demand Export Supply -10 — Scarcity of high quality met coal -2 225 +12 219 — Limitations on use of PCI & semi-soft coal in -3 217 215 blast furnaces 205 204 201 +3 193 Lar

  19. Slide 19: Demand Shifted as China Became Net Importer of Met Coal in 2007

    Demand Shifted as China Became Net Importer of Met Coal in 2007 As China grew, its met coal exports and imports shifted by nearly 17 million tonnes Imports/exports balance (millions of tonnes) Exports Imports 14 12 10 2002 net 8 exports: 2007 net 6 13.0 imports: 4 2 3.7 0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20

  20. Slide 20: Strong Demand for Met Coal is Expected to Continue

    Strong Demand for Met Coal is Expected to Continue New battery construction outside of China creating 52 million tonnes of incremental met coal demand Estimated new met coal demand from announced coke batteries (ex-China) (million of tonnes) 16 14.7 14 11.2 12 9.5 10 8 6.6 5.7 6 4 2.9 1.4 2 0 2004 2

  21. Slide 21: Coal is Well Positioned in US Energy Market

    Coal is Well Positioned in US Energy Market 1 Natural gas prices near historic highs ($/mm Btu) US coal production² (mm short tons) • YTD 2008, US coal production is up 0.7% $15 1,200 1,163 1,147 1,150 1,150 1,128 1,133 $12 1,112 1,094 1,100 1,072 $9 $9.33 Average: $7.07 1,050 $6 1,000 950 $3 2003 2

  22. Slide 22: Attractive Steam Coal Fundamentals

    Attractive Steam Coal Fundamentals China factor Global seaborne steam coal supply / demand (millions of tonnes) -22 -7 — Power supplies tight Import Demand -14 Export Supply +14 507 +31 502 — Domestic prices capped 495 484 485 479 473 471 — Export volumes limited by quotas 465 442 Country-specific e

  23. Slide 23: Value Creation

    Value Creation ~~ CLIFFS

  24. Slide 24: History of Successful and Well-Timed Investments

    History of Successful and Well-Timed Investments Cleveland-Cliffs share price performance ($) $150 Portman Ltd Acquisition PinnOak Resources Acquisition • January 11, 2005] Launched all-cash offer for Portman • July 31, 2007] Acquired PinnOak Ltd, a Western Australia-based iron ore producer & a key

  25. Slide 25: Successful and Well-Timed International Investments in Fast Growing Regions

    Successful and Well-Timed International Investments in Fast Growing Regions Cliffs Asia Pacific International highlights Cliffs Latin America Portman stake provides crucial Portman Cockatoo Island access to the Asian market Production expected to reach 8 million tonnes in 2008 and has over 90 Sonoma

  26. Slide 26: Alpha's Pro Forma Contribution Accelerates in '09 and Beyond with the Strong Met Coal Outlook

    Alpha’s Pro Forma Contribution Accelerates in ’09 and Beyond with the Strong Met Coal Outlook 1,2 2 Pro forma EBITDA ($ billion) Financial multiples 5 Cleveland-Cliffs 4 3 — 2009E EBITDA ~ ~ $2.75bn 2 — EV/2009E EBITDA³ ~ ~ 4.6x 1 0 Alpha Natural Resources 2007A 2008E 2009E 2 — 2009E EBITDA~ $1.95bn

  27. Slide 27: Undervalued Relative to Large-Cap Iron Ore, Coal and Diversified Peers

    Undervalued Relative to Large-Cap Iron Ore, Coal and Diversified Peers Firm Value / 2009E EBITDA vs. Peers 10x Iron Ore / Diversified Coal 8.7x 8.6x 7.7x 8x 7.3x 6.5x 6x 5.4x 5.3x 5.2x 4.8x 4x 2x 0x Peabody Fortescue CONSOL Arch Coal Rio Tinto Xstrata BHP Vale Pro forma Cliffs Natural Source: FactSe

  28. Slide 28: Strong Financial Position

    Strong Financial Position Pro forma 2008E Pro forma 2009E Financials Revenue ~ ~ $6.5bn ~ $10.2bn ~ EBITDA ~ $1.9bn ~ ~ $4.7bn ~ Margin (%) ~ 28% ~ ~ 47% Leverage Total debt ~ $2.1bn ~ ~ $1.9bn Debt/EBITDA ~ ~1.2x ~ 0.4x Estimated annual synergies of ~ $200 million beginning in 2010 Source: Manageme

  29. Slide 29: Transaction Highlights

    Transaction Highlights Creates a leading independent supplier of critical raw materials to the robust North American steel industry and a major global player — Core iron ore and met coal businesses strongly correlated Capitalizes on strong outlook for iron ore, metallurgical and thermal coal Shared

  30. Slide 30: Cliffs Natural Resources

    CLIFFS NATURAL RESOURCES INVESTOR PRESENTATION AUGUST 2008

Alpha Natural Resources — Merger or Acquisition (August 2008) on 6ix