UL Solutions Inc. · NYSE:ULS
UL Solutions — Underwriters Laboratories — Technical Presentation (November 2010)
33 slides from UL Solutions's technical presentation, Nov 11, 2010
Slide 1: Functional Safety: What It Is, Why It's Important And How to Comply
Functional Safety: What It Is, Why It’s Important And How to Comply November 11, 2010 Copyright© 1995-2010 Underwriters Laboratories Inc. All rights reserved. No portion of this material may be reprinted in any form without the express written permission of Underwriters Laboratories Inc. or as other
Slide 2: Functional Safety
Functional Safety • Industry experts define: • Functional safety • What it is • Why it’s important • How to comply with standards and regulations • Sponsor: Underwriters Laboratories • Moderator: Gary Mintchell, Automation World, Editor-in-chief Slide 2
Slide 3: Presenters
Presenters Kevin Connelly Thomas Maier Underwriters Laboratories Underwriters Laboratories Industry Manager, Power & Controls, Principal Engineer, Functional Safety Functional Safety Slide 3
Slide 4: Webcast Agenda
Webcast Agenda • Overview of Functional Safety and Safety Assessments: Thomas Maier • Functional Safety Demand Drivers: Kevin Connelly • Common Functional Safety Standards: T. Maier • Functional Safety Program and UL Listing Mark: K. Connelly • Call-to-Action • Live “Question and Answer” Session Sli
Slide 5: What is Functional Safety?
What is Functional Safety? Functional Safety is part of the overall safety of a system that depends on the correct execution of specific functions. Here is the exact definition according to IEC 61508: • “part of the overall safety relating to the EUC and the EUC control system which depends on the c
Slide 6: Why is there something called Functional Safety?
Why is there something called Functional Safety? Functional safety as a property has always existed, of course. Functional Safety, by definition, is not specific to any one technology. But Functional Safety is not only a property, it has evolved into a technical term, and an engineering discipline.
Slide 7: Functional Safety as per IEC 61508
Functional Safety as per IEC 61508 Challenges addressed by IEC 61508 • System safety • => Hazard and Risk Analysis • System and product life-cycle • => Functional Safety Management • Hardware random failures • => Redundancy, diversity, diagnostics, reliability • Systematic failures • => V-model • =>
Slide 8: EUC – E/E/PE System – Subsystems – Elements
EUC – E/E/PE System – Subsystems – Elements IEC 61508 mandates an ”overall” safety approach, could also be referred to as a • System safety approach or • Holistic approach (accounts also for the whole life cycle of a system) The ”system” is in IEC 61508 represented by the ”EUC”, Equipment Under Cont
Slide 9: EUC and EUC Control System
EUC and EUC Control System The ”system” in IEC 61508 terms: EUC Reasonably EUC Control System foreseeable misuse Slide 9
Slide 10: E/E/PE Safety-related System and Risk Reduction
E/E/PE Safety-related System and Risk Reduction EUC (+ EUC control system) poses risk, E/E/PES contributes to reduce risk below a tolerable level IEC 61508-5, Figure A.1 Slide 10
Slide 11: E/E/PE Safety-related System and Risk Reduction
E/E/PE Safety-related System and Risk Reduction EUC (+ EUC control system) poses risk, E/E/PES contributes to reduce risk below a tolerable level Target failure measure => IEC 61508-5, Figure A.1 SIL (SIL1 … SIL4) Slide 11
Slide 12: EUC – EUC Control System – E/E/PE System
EUC – EUC Control System – E/E/PE System E/E/PE Safety-related system EUC EUC E/E/PE Safety-related system EUC Control System Slide 12
Slide 13: E/E/PE System and Subsystems
E/E/PE System and Subsystems In most cases, the FS products certified by UL will be sub-systems of an E/E/PE safety-related system. IEC 61508-4, Figure 3 Slide 13
Slide 14: E/E/PE System and Subsystems
E/E/PE System and Subsystems In most cases, the FS products certified by UL will be sub-systems of an E/E/PE safety-related system. Subsystem (data communication) Subsystem Subsystem (sensors) (actuators) Subsystem (logic unit) IEC 61508-4, Figure 3 Slide 14
Slide 15: Demand Drivers for Functional Safety
Demand Drivers for Functional Safety Why evaluate your product/system for functional safety? • A functional safety assessment determines whether your products meet standards and performance requirements created to protect against potential risks, including injuries and even death. • Compliance is dr
Slide 16: Demand Drivers for Functional Safety
Demand Drivers for Functional Safety Customer Requirements • Customers may demand functional safety evaluation before purchasing equipment Market Acceptance • Having a functional safety certification maintains a product’s competitiveness in the marketplace Legislation • Legislative requirements, suc
Slide 17: Demand Drivers for Functional Safety
Demand Drivers for Functional Safety Regulations • Some regulatory bodies, such as OSHA, require or encourage functional safety evaluation Trade Unions • Some unions require or encourage functional safety certified products in the workplace Insurance companies • Insurers may require a functional saf
Slide 18: Common Functional Safety Standards
Common Functional Safety Standards Standards play a key role in the Functional Safety evaluation and certification process. Important to specify a published standard and safety rating for testing and evaluation: • Safety Integrated Level (SIL) for IEC and EN standards • Performance Level (PL) for IS
Slide 19: Common Functional Safety Standards
Common Functional Safety Standards • IEC 61508 Safety Related Systems (SIL) • IEC 62061 Safety Related Systems specifically for machinery (SIL Claim Limit) • IEC 61511 Safety Related Systems specifically for process sector equipment (SIL) • IEC 61800-5-2 Safety Related Systems specifically for power
Slide 20: SIL vs. PL: IEC 62061
SIL vs. PL: IEC 62061 For safety-related control systems in machine applications, there exist two sector specific standards, IEC 62061 and ISO 13849-1: IEC 62061: “SRECS” • Derived from IEC 61508, defines safety integrity in terms of SIL. • Applies also to subsystems of a SRECS, (“SIL Claim Limits”)
Slide 21: SIL vs. PL: ISO 13849-1
SIL vs. PL: ISO 13849-1 ISO 13849-1: “SRP/CS” • Enhances predecessor EN 954-1 with IEC 61508 principles: • Quantitative approach to risk reduction • Addresses systematic failure avoidance • Self contained. Refers to IEC 61508-3 only for PL e and “Full Variability languages (FVL)” and if there is no
Slide 22: SIL and PL: Compatible and Merging Together
SIL and PL: Compatible and Merging Together New ISO/TR 23849 (also published as IEC/TR 62061-1): • Recognizes compatibility with respect to risk reduction • SRP/CS can be integrated in SRECS and vice versa • Differences in Functional Safety Management • Standards to be merged. 3, 4, 5 years? Perfo
Slide 23: UL Functional Safety Mark Program
UL Functional Safety Program Announcing the new UL Functional Safety Mark Program Slide 23
Slide 24: UL Deliverables
UL Functional Safety Program UL Deliverables: • Advisory Services • Functional Safety Listing Mark • Functional Safety Component Recognition Mark • Informative test reports • 3-year Functional Safety Certificate • Type examination reports Slide 24
Slide 25: Functional Safety Certification Process
Functional Safety Certification Process • Kick-off Meeting • Pre-audit and Initial Assessment • Certification Audit • Review Current Functional Safety Management System • Follow-up Surveillance Slide 25
Slide 26: Functional Safety Certification Process
Functional Safety Certification Process Slide 26
Slide 27: Certification Process: Kick-off Meeting
Functional Safety Certification Process Kick-off Meeting • Most effective during the product design phase • Collaborate to ensure that the features required by the specified standard are included in the initial design • Understand the consequence of choices being made • Discuss prototyping • Discuss
Slide 28: Certification Process: Pre-audit and Initial Assessment
Functional Safety Certification Process Pre-audit and Initial Assessment • Increase the probability of success of the certification audit • UL engineers perform onsite GAP analysis • Customer receives concept evaluation report with detailed action items • Continue review of Functional Safety Managem
Slide 29: Certification Process: Certification Audit
Functional Safety Certification Process Certification Audit • UL audits the system’s compliance with the designated standard and functional safety rating • Evaluation of documentation • Functional Safety Management System verified • Product is certified Slide 29
Slide 30: Certification Process: Follow-up Surveillance (FUS)
Functional Safety Certification Process Follow-up Surveillance (FUS) • Quarterly surveillance to verify that the protective functions of the product match the UL report • UL conducts an audit of the functional safety management system once every three years Slide 30
Slide 31: UL Advisory Services
UL Advisory Services As part of the Functional Safety Certification program, UL offers Advisory Services to: • Calculate or verify SIL, PL, class, etc. • Develop validation plans • Develop FMEA and FMEDA Analysis • Draft Functional Safety Management and Integrated Test Plans • Create a Safety Manual
Slide 32: Call-to-Action
Call-to-Action For more information, download the whitepaper: “UL Functional Safety Mark Program” found at www.ul.com/functionalsafety and located under “Additional Resources” at the bottom of page. Slide 32
Slide 33: Questions?
Questions? Kevin Connelly Thomas Maier Underwriters Laboratories Underwriters Laboratories Industry Manager, Power & Controls, Principal Engineer, Functional Safety Functional Safety Slide 33
Underwriters Laboratories — Technical Presentation (November 2010) on 6ix