Avista Corporation · NYSE:AVA
Avista — Technical Presentation (January 2024)
78 slides from Avista's technical presentation, Jan 30, 2024
Slide 1: 2025 Electric IRP TAC Meeting No. 2 Agenda
2025 Electric Integrated Resource Plan Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 2 Agenda Tuesday, January 30, 2024 Virtual Meeting Topic Time Staff Introductions 8:30 John Lyons How Avista Includes Equity Principles 8:40 Annette Brandon Customer Benefit Indicators 9:30 Annette Brandon Break 10:30 Ho
Slide 2: 2025 IRP TAC 2 Introductions
2025 IRP TAC 2 Introductions John Lyons, Ph.D. Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 2 January 30, 2024
Slide 3: Meeting Guidelines
Meeting Guidelines • IRP team is in office Monday - Wednesday and also available by email, phone and Teams for questions and comments • Stakeholder feedback responses shared with TAC at meetings, in Teams and in Appendix • Working IRP data posted to Teams • Virtual IRP meetings on Teams, in person a
Slide 4: Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders
Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders • Please mute mics unless speaking or asking a question • Raise hand or use the chat box for questions or comments • Respect the pause • Please try not to speak over the presenter or a speaker • Please state your name before commenting for the note taker • This is a pub
Slide 5: Integrated Resource Planning
Integrated Resource Planning The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP): • Required by Idaho and Washington* every other year – Washington now requires IRP every four years and update at two years • Guides resource strategy over the next twenty years • Current and projected load & resource position • Develo
Slide 6: Technical Advisory Committee
Technical Advisory Committee • The public process piece of the IRP – input on what to study, how to study, and review of assumptions and results • Wide range of participants involved in all or parts of the process – Ask questions – Always looking for help with soliciting new TAC members • Open forum
Slide 7: Today's Agenda – Equity Focus
Today’s Agenda – Equity Focus 8:30 Introductions, John Lyons 8:40 How Avista Includes Equity Principles, Annette Brandon 9:30 Customer Benefit Indicators, Annette Brandon 10:30 Break 10:45 How Avista Practices Equity Outcomes, Tamara Bradley 11:30 Equity Planning in the IRP, James Gall 12:00 Adjourn
Slide 8: Equity in Utility Operations
Equity in Utility Operations Annette Brandon Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 2 January 30, 2024
Slide 9: Overview of Equity
Overview of Equity Annette Brandon
Slide 10: Dictionary Definition
Dictionary Definition noun,plural eq·ui·ties. 1. the quality of being fair or impartial; fairness; impartiality: the equity of Solomon. 2. something that is fair and just: The concepts and principles of health equities and inequities are important to society as a whole. 3. the policy or practice of
Slide 11: Equity at Avista
Equity at Avista Focused on fair opportunities and access to resources which contribute to fair, equitable outcome Fairness • A “fair process” is defined as focus on ensuring no group of people share disproportional burden associated with policies, decisions or actions Foundation: Meaningful partici
Slide 12: Evolution of Energy Justice
Evolution of Energy Justice Equitably sharing the benefits and burdens involved in the production and consumption of energy services and Fairness in how people and communities are treated in energy decision- making Environmental Justice 1970-1980 Participation in environmental Decision Making Recogn
Slide 13: Transition to Clean Energy
Transition to Clean Energy Inclusive Process Transparent, understandable MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION Clean Energy for Some Diverse Perspectives Clean Energy for All Avista is Committed to a Clean Energy Future for all of our Cus
Slide 14: Balancing Multiple Objectives
Balancing Multiple Objectives Federal Justice40 Clean Energy Transformation Act Climate Commitment Act Avista Serves Approximately 480,000 WA Customers Electric Natural Gas Electric and Natural Gas Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 7 Energy Advisory Group (EAG)
Slide 15: Regulatory Requirements
7 | = AIVISTA Regulatory Requirements AWISTA
Slide 16: Washington State Equity Requirements
Washington State Equity Requirements Clean Energy Implementation Plan 2019 Focus on “just transition” Strong Public Participation Customer Benefit Indicators Avista General Rate Case Conditions 2021 “Capital Planning must consider and implement energy justice and its core tenets.” Recognit
Slide 17: Clean Energy Implementation Plan Requirements
Clean Energy Implementation Plan Requirements • Avista will apply Non-Energy Impacts (NEIs) and Customer Benefit Indicators (CBIs) to all resource and program selections in determining its Washington resource strategy • Avista agrees to engage and consult with its applicable advisory groups (IRP Tec
Slide 18: Non-Energy Impact
Non-Energy Impact • Contribution of investments that goes beyond the energy and demand costs Participant Benefits O & M Savings Employee Productivity Increase • Impacts (either positive or negative) can come in Health Benefits Property Value Increase the form of economic, social, environmental, and/
Slide 19: General Rate Case Requirements: Energy Justice Core Tenets
General Rate Case Requirements: Energy Justice Core Tenets “The processes or procedures Avista considers for all capital planning should consider and implement energy justice and its core tenets. The core tenets of energy justice are: recognition, procedural, distribution, restorative. Customers, co
Slide 20: Balancing Requirements – While Keeping Customer at the Center
Balancing Requirements – While Keeping Customer at the Center Federal Justice40 Clean Energy Transformation Act Climate Commitment Act Avista Serves Approximately 480,000 WA Customers Electric Natural Gas Electric and Natural Gas Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 13
Slide 21: Resource and Program Lifecycle Evaluation
Resource and Program lifecycle Evaluation “No action is equity neutral….each action either corrects or perpetuates inequities” Meaningful Participation Identify and Prioritize Execute Evaluate Selection Integrated Resource Financial & Risk Total Company Power Purchase Agreement Planning Operational
Slide 22: Integrated Resource Plans Process and Performance Metrics
Integrated Resource Plans Process and Performance Metrics
Slide 23: Process and Performance Metrics
Process and Performance Metrics People Process Performance • Who has provided • How will my project • How did we do? impact? produce results? • How can we • Have we intentionally • Are there measure? solicited input? alternatives? • Are there patterns? • Can I use feedback? • Am I making data- • Hav
Slide 24: Focus Areas
Focus Areas Who and Where we are focusing our equity efforts: Highly Impacted Communities Vulnerable Populations • Sensitivities: physiological impacts • Socioeconomic: housing, transportation, food and health care access, language barriers Disadvantaged Populations 17
Slide 25: Data Driven Consideration
Data Driven Consideration Directly related to policy goals and the public interest readily available Focused on equitable outcomes Clearly defined, articulated, and understandable Based on dependable, pertinent, available data Allows for comparison or trending Transparent Correlated with utility’s a
Slide 26: CEIP Customer Benefit Indicators
CEIP Customer Benefit Indicators Affordability Energy Security Access to Environmental Community Public Health & Resilience Clean Energy Development Participation in Energy Availability Methods/Modes of Outdoor Air Quality Named Community Employee Diversity Company Programs Outreach & Clean Energy C
Slide 27: Customer Benefit Indicators in IRP
Customer Benefit Indicators in IRP Energy Burden (Affordability/Access to Existing Customer Benefit Indicators: Clean Energy) • 11 of the 31 CBIs are modeled with forecasted Distributed Energy values for each metric over the 20-year planning Resources (Community Development/Energy horizon Resilience
Slide 28: How Metrics are Developed
How Metrics are Developed Benefits Barriers Metrics Utilization • Evaluation of • Factors which limit • How do these • Where will we benefits from participation or benefits correlate utilize metrics? energy or energy access: with energy system: • Clean Energy Plans • Physical Sensitives • Accountabi
Slide 29: Understand Goal
Understand Goal: All customers, regardless of circumstance, have access to the energy they need for basic needs as well as social, economic and environmental needs. Energy Social Economic Environmental Physical delivery Inclusive and Job creation, Public health, of power accessible economic growth,
Slide 30: Burdens and Barriers
Burdens and Barriers Affordability • Unemployment or Underemployment • Awareness of Programs • Housing Conditions • Income Disparities • Economic impacts on fossil fuel workers Access • Not easily accessible for all customers due to financing or other accountability structures • Geographic Accessibi
Slide 31: Performance and Process Metrics
Performance and Process Metrics Performance (Lagging) Security & • How will we measure? Affordable Accessible Resiliency • Are customers impacted as intended? • Accountability measurements or patterns Economic & Social, Health, & Process Metrics (Leading) Clean, Community Environmental Sustainable •
Slide 32: Supplemental
7 | = AIVISTA Supplemental AWISTA
Slide 33: Customers with an Energy Burden
26 Customers 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 2024 45,686 2025 46,136 2026 45,361 2027 46,715 2028 47,052 2029 47,385 2030 47,711 2031 48,043 2032 48,383 2033 48,698 2034 47,617 2035 47,923 2036 48,224 Customers with an Energy Burden 2037 48,520 2038 48,810 2039 49,095 2040 49,375 2041 49
Slide 34: Percent of Customers with an Energy Burden
27 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 2024 20.4% 2025 20.4% 2026 19.9% 2027 20.3% 2028 20.3% 2029 20.3% 2030 20.3% 2031 20.3% 2032 20.3% 2033 20.3% 2034 19.7% 2035 19.7% 2036 19.7% 2037 19.7% 2038 19.7% 2039 19.7% 2040 19.7% 2041 19.7% Percent of Customers with an Energy Burden 2042 19.7% 2043 20.2%
Slide 35: Average Excess Energy Burden
Average Excess Energy Burden $2,500 $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 Average excess burden per household Inflation adjusted excess burden per household (2024 $) 28
Slide 36: Total MWh of DERs in Named Communities
29 MWh 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 2016 21,872 2017 20,141 2018 18,455 2019 18,179 2020 21,822 2021 15,049 2022 17,506 2024 20,569 2025 21,544 actual forecast 2026 22,519 2027 23,513 2028 24,459 2029 25,440 2030 26,796 2031 27,879 2032 28,956 2033 30,092 2034 30,195 2035 30,455
Slide 37: Total MWh Capability of Storage DER in Named Communities
Total MWh Capability of Storage DER in Named Communities 8.0 actual forecast 7.0 7.2 6.7 6.0 6.3 6.3 5.9 5.9 5.0 5.5 5.1 MWh 4.7 4.0 4.3 3.9 3.0 3.5 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 2.0 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2
Slide 38: Annual Named Community Investment vs. Benefits
Annual Named Community Investment vs. Benefits $50 $45 Annual Utility Benefits $40 Annual NEI Benefits $35 Annual Investment $30 Millions $25 $20 $15 $10 $5 $0 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 31
Slide 39: Planning Margin: Resource Percent Above Peak Load
32 Resource Percent Above Peak Load 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% 0% 5% 2016 28% 18% 2017 33% 23% 2018 45% 17% 2019 42% 27% 2020 46% 25% 31% Planning Margin 2021 10% 2022 13% 15% 2024 39% 31% 2025 38% actual forecast 35% 2026 33% 29% 2027 29% 26% 2028 29% 26% 2029 28% 25% 2030 28% 25% 2031 27%
Slide 40: Percent of Load Generation in Washington State
33 Percent of Load 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 0% 2016 78% 2017 79% 2018 84% 2019 80% 2020 78% 2021 83% actual 2022 82% 2024 92% 2025 95% forecast 2026 101% 2027 90% to Avista Transmission 2028 90% 2029 88% 2030 94% 2031 93% 2032 85% 2033 85% 2034 80% 2035 80% 2036 79% 2037 79% 2038 77% 2039 76% 2040 75% 2
Slide 41: Washington Air Emissions
34 Metric Tons Metric Tons 0 1 2 3 4 5 4.1 2016 100 200 300 400 500 0 1.5 2017 2016 425.6 2018 2017 379.2 1.7 1.6 423.3 2019 2018 1.4 2019 396.2 2020 2020 365.1 2021 2021 417.9 2022 2022 416.9 2024 2024 422 2025 2025 392 2026 2026 345 2027 2027 310 2028 2028 291 2029 2029 279 2030 2030 313 2031 2031
Slide 42: Greenhouse Gas Emissions (Washington Share)
35 Metric Tons (Millions) - 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2016 1.7 2.5 1.8 1.7 2017 1.8 1.8 2018 1.7 2.0 2019 1.8 1.7 2020 1.6 1.9 2021 1.8 2.0 2022 1.8 1.9 2024 1.4 1.8 2025 actual forecast 1.4 1.0 2026 0.9 0.6 2027 0.6 0.6 2028 0.7 0.6 2029 0.7 0.6 2030 0.6 0.5 2031 0.6 0.5 2032 0.5 0.5 2033 0.5 0.5 2034 0.6 0.
Slide 43: Eastern Washington Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Eastern Washington Greenhouse Gas Emissions 12.0 actual forecast 10.0 8.0 Million Metric Tons 6.0 4.0 2.0 - 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 Agriculture Transportation Residential & Commer
Slide 44: How Avista Practices Equitable Outcomes
How Avista Practices Equitable Outcomes Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 2 January 30, 2024
Slide 45: Evolution of Utility Industry
Evolution of Utility Industry Safe Reliable Affordable Clean Equitable 1880 1920 2020 1900 1990 2
Slide 46: Equity Advisory Group
Equity Advisory Group • Est. in Spring of 2021 • Significant input on our CEIP • Ongoing monthly sessions • 11/38 CEIP Conditions • Oversee 500k of the Named Communities Investment Fund 3
Slide 47: Additional Advisory Groups
Additional Advisory Groups • Energy Assistance Advisory Group (EAAG) • Energy Efficiency Advisory Group (EEAG) • Distribution Planning Advisory Group (D-PAG) 4
Slide 48: CEIP Public Participation Strategy
CEIP Public Participation Strategy • The Plan outlines barriers to participation in programs and services, strategies for reducing those barriers, and tools for increasing participation. • Filed May 1, 2023 • Utility Language Strategy 5
Slide 49: Other Initiatives
Other Initiatives Capital Planning Federal/State Grants Supplier/Employee Diversity 6
Slide 50: CEIP Customer Benefit Indicators
CEIP Customer Benefit Indicators Affordability Energy Security Access to Environmental Community Public Health & Resilience Clean Energy Development Participation in Energy Availability Methods/Modes of Outdoor Air Quality Named Community Employee Diversity Company Programs Outreach & Clean Energy C
Slide 51: Affordability Initiative
Affordability Initiative How Bill Assistance is Increasing Customer Affordability & Promoting Equity Kelsey Solberg, Energy Program Manager 8
Slide 52: Alignment to CEIP
Alignment to CEIP Customer Benefit Indicators Affordability Energy Security & Access to Environmental Community Public Health Resilience Clean Energy Development Participation in Energy Availability Methods/Modes of Outdoor Air Quality Named Community Employee Diversity Company Outreach & Clean Ener
Slide 53: Bill Assistance & Affordability
Bill Assistance & Affordability What is bill assistance? Energy Burden is High energy burden= Bill assistance aims the percentage of >6% to reduce the energy household income burden of limited- Severe energy that goes towards income households burden= >10% energy costs Most forms of bill assistance
Slide 54: Bill Assistance at Avista: Goals & Purpose
Bill Assistance at Avista: Goals & Purpose Increase Affordability Address Past-Due Balances Provide Support During Hardships Educate on Energy Conservation 11
Slide 55: Washington Low-Income Rate Assistance Program (LIRAP)
Washington Low-Income Rate Assistance Program (LIRAP) At-a-glance Eligibility Zero to greater of 200% FPL or 80% AMI Bill Discount Affordability Discount Tier 1: Discount Tier 2: Discount Tier 3: Discount Tier 4: Discount Tier 5: Zero to 5% FPL 6 to 50% FPL 51 to 100% FPL 101 to 150% FPL 151%, Great
Slide 56: Increasing Affordability: My Energy Discount
Increasing Affordability Introducing My Energy Discount Nearly 18,000 customers who Discounts are based on self- Jointly administered between received income-qualifying declared monthly or annual Avista and agencies means assistance were auto-enrolled income more avenues for access in October 2023 P
Slide 57: Addressing Past-Due Balances: Washington Customer Arrears
Addressing Past-Due Balances Washington Customer Arrears 29,170 customers with past due balances totaling $6.3M Average Past-Due Balance: $216 14 Washington customers as of December 31, 2023
Slide 58: Addressing Past-Due Balances
Addressing Past-Due Balances Avista’s LIRAP arrearage assistance is comprised of two unique programs Each program has distinct eligibility criteria and benefit amounts, and are intended to provide relief for income-qualified, residential customers who have unmanageable past-due balances (arrears) on
Slide 59: Program Enrollment Snapshot
Program Enrollment Snapshot My Energy Discount: 28,044 Active Participants Arrearage Forgiveness Program: 351 Recipients (Oct-Dec 2023) Arrearage Management Program: 662 Active Participants 16 Data provided as of 12/31/23
Slide 60: Washington 2023 Saturation Rate
2023 Saturation Rate Washington Number of Eligible Customers 129,266 Percentage Receiving Assistance 24% Pre-Covid (2017-19) 3-year Average 15% Saturation Rate equals the percentage of estimated eligible customers who are receiving any form of bill assistance. Data is reviewed and 17 updated quarter
Slide 61: Equity in Program Design
Equity in Program Design Program features designed with equity in mind Discount percentages Multi-lingual Increased readability Removing barriers designed to resources on the of Avista website, with self-attestation of specifically address web, through customer letters, household income differential
Slide 62: Named Communities Investment Fund
Named Communities Investment Fund Kristine Meyer, Avista Foundation Executive Director Ana Matthews, Sr. Energy Efficiency Program Manager 19
Slide 63: Avista's Named Communities
Avista’s Named Communities Specific Target and Actions for ensuring that all customers are benefiting from the transition to clean energy the equitable distribution of energy and nonenergy benefits and reduction of burdens to Vulnerable Populations and Highly Impacted Communities (Named Communities)
Slide 64: Named Communities Investment Fund
Named Communities Investment Fund $2M $1M Supplement Energy Investments in Specific Action dedicated to the Efficiency Distribution Resiliency equitable distribution of energy and non-energy benefits and reduction in burdens to Named $1M Communities $500,000 Incentives & Grants Outreach & for cust
Slide 65: Energy Efficiency NCIF
Energy Efficiency NCIF The cleanest energy is the energy that is never used. 40% or up to $2M Supplement and support energy efficiency efforts targeted to Named Communities Health & Safety for Community Identified Multifamily Building Manufactured & Mobile Projects Split Incentive Homes Named Commun
Slide 66: Equity in Practice: Outreach & Engagement
Equity in Practice: Outreach & Engagement Multiple avenues to learn about and apply for NCIF Online Applications Existing Community Informational Sessions Enhancement to Relationships virtual and in-person company programs and projects
Slide 67: NCIF Process
NCIF Process Advisory Support/Guidance Confer with assembled advisory groups For entities that have a clean for equity, energy efficiency and energy idea and need support for assistance, etc. for guidance in program developing their concept to design and implementation. fruition. Engage customers th
Slide 68: Factors for NCIF Consideration: Equity Assured
Factors for NCIF Consideration: Equity Assured Customer Benefit Implementation Plan Equity Advisory Group Equity Indicators Specific Actions Initiatives Affordability (1) Participation in Company Community Identified Project Energy Efficiency in Named Programs Communities Access to Clean Energ
Slide 69: 2023 Commitments & Funding: Equity Outcomes
2023 Commitments & Funding: Equity Outcomes Energy Efficiency Spokane Tribe reservation energy audits Lincoln County Fairgrounds lighting Malden homes weatherization KW Energy Duct Sealing for manufactured and mobile home in Stevens, Ferry and Pend Oreille counties Walnut Corners affordable housing
Slide 70: Thank you!
Thank you! AVISTA
Slide 71: Equity Planning in the 2023 IRP
Equity Planning in the 2023 IRP James Gall Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 2 January 30, 2024
Slide 72: Equity Related Items included in 2023 IRP Modeling
Equity Related Items included in 2023 IRP Modeling • Energy Efficiency • Named Community Investment Fund (NCIF) • Customer Benefit Indicators (CBIs) • Resource Non-Energy Impacts (NEIs) • Social Cost of Greenhouse Gas • Maximum Customer Benefit Scenario 2
Slide 73: Energy Efficiency
Energy Efficiency • Split energy efficiency measures between “low-income” and non-low income • Low-income includes higher NEI values where applicable • Low-income measures can use a different cost value • 2025 IRP will explore using named community potential rather then low- income How impacts the p
Slide 74: Named Community Investment Fund (NCIF)
Named Community Investment Fund (NCIF) • Model must select $2 million (+) of the least cost, non-cost-effective energy efficiency per year – Increases energy efficiency targets – Shows possible future programs • Model must “spend” $400,000 per year on incremental Distributed Energy Resources (DERs),
Slide 75: Non-Energy Impacts
Non-Energy Impacts • Quantification of indirect and social impacts of resource decisions not included in resource costs • DNV conducted the study for the 2023 IRP for resource selection if quantitative values are known or estimated • DNV qualitatively identified costs for other impacts How impacts t
Slide 76: Non-Energy Impacts in IRP
Non-Energy Impacts in IRP Supply-Side Resources Demand-Side Resources* IRP Resource Selection Content Here Public Health You can simply impress your Income & Health audience and add a unique zing Economic Develop. (income) • Not all NEIs are able to be PM2.5, and appeal SO2, to your NOx Presentation
Slide 77: Resource Acquisition Equity Considerations
Resource Acquisition Equity Considerations • Resources are required to go through rigorous public process to be permitted • RFP Resource selection includes – NEIs in economic analysis – Resources are selected based on scoring matrix including • Customer Energy Impact (cost): 40% • Risk Management (c
Slide 78: Maximum Customer Benefit Scenario
Maximum Customer Benefit Scenario • Required in Washington IRP rules • 2023 IRP included the following assumptions – In-state/connected renewables requirement (i.e. no Montana wind) – No ammonia/power to gas CTs (fuel cell allowed) – Lowering of excess energy burden required via community solar – No