Airgas — Proxy Contest (November 2010)
16 slides from Airgas's proxy contest presentation, Nov 29, 2010
Slide 1: Fundamentals of Shareholder Value
Fundamentals of Shareholder Value November 26, 2010
Slide 2: Important Information
1 IMPORTANT INFORMATION This presentation does not constitute an offer to buy or solicitation of an offer to sell any securities. In response to the tender offer commenced by Air Products Distribution, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Air Products and Chemicals, Inc., Airgas has filed a solicitati
Slide 3: Our View of Valuation
2 On November 23, 2010, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed the Chancery Court ruling on Air Products’ January Meeting By-Law amendment As such, there will not be an Airgas shareholder meeting on January 18, 2011 Value has always been and remains the most important issue Our Board of Directors has s
Slide 4: Analysts' Estimates are Consistent With Our Guidance and Mid-Term Goals
3 Consensus estimate for FY2011 EPS is $3.29, near the high end of our $3.22 - $3.32 guidance range(1). Our guidance includes $0.11 of incremental SAP implementation expense. Consensus estimate for CY2011 EPS is $3.68 Consensus estimate for CY2012 EPS is $4.16, comparable to our $4.20+ goal. Our goa
Slide 5: Our Historical Multiples Support Our View that the Current Offer Represents Little to No Premium
4 Our 5-year median next-twelve-months (NTM) P/E multiple, prior to Air Products’ offer, was 16.7x, which includes the negative impact of the recession During the same 5-year period, in periods of modest economic growth – similar to the current environment – we traded at 17.7x NTM EPS Our Historical
Slide 6: Peer Multiples Support Our View that the Current Offer Represents Little to No Premium
5 Peer Multiples Support Our View that the Current Offer Represents Little to No Premium Our peers are currently trading near or above their respective 5-year average multiples (1) The 1 month average NTM EPS multiples through Nov 26, 2010, for industrial distributors Fastenal, WW Grainger, and MSC
Slide 7: Premiums in Comparable Transactions in 2H2010 Exceed 30% Over Unaffected Stock Price
6 Premiums in Comparable Transactions in 2H2010 – Post-Recession – Exceed 30% Over Unaffected Stock Price Note: Comprised of deals with U.S. or Canadian targets since June 30, 2010 larger than $1 billion. Excludes: asset sales; mergers of equals; financial institutions; related party transactions; f
Slide 8: An Acquisition of Airgas Would Be Highly Accretive to Air Products
Note: Based on publicly available research estimates, calendarized to Air Products’ September year end, as of November 26, 2010, and Air Products investor presentation dated February 5, 2010. Cost of debt assumed to be 4.55% at $65.50 per share and 5.05% at $78.00 per share. Assumes $250 million of
Slide 9: Air Products Timed its Offer in the Trough of the Economic Cycle
See attached reconciliations of non-GAAP measures. Source: FactSet as of November 26, 2010. 8 Air Products Timed its Offer in the Trough of the Economic Cycle Consensus EPS Estimate for Year Ending Mar-11 Represents Record Earnings (2) (2) Pre-Offer All-Time High Closing Stock Price $64.72 Initial P
Slide 10: Peer Equity Performance Has Improved Significantly Since the Initial Public Bid
9 Peer Equity Performance Has Improved Significantly, in Excess of the Market, Since the Initial Public Bid Driven by expansion of multiples and earnings Source: FactSet as of November 26, 2010. Closing Stock Prices Indexed to 2/4/10 NTM EPS Multiples Since 2/4/10 11.0x 12.0x 13.0x 14.0x 15.0x 16.0x
Slide 11: Consensus Economic Outlook: Steady U.S. Growth
Source: Bloomberg consensus estimates as of November 26, 2010. 10 U.S. GDP Growth European GDP Growth U.S. Unemployment Consensus Economic Outlook: Steady U.S. Growth 2.7% 1.9% 0.0% (2.6%) 2.7% 2.5% 3.1% 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010E 2011E 2012E 4.6% 4.6% 5.8% 9.3% 9.6% 9.3% 8.7% 2006 2007 2008 2009 201
Slide 12: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 13: Airgas Historical Forward Multiples vs. GDP Growth
Airgas Historical Forward Multiples vs. GDP Growth Price / NTM EPS: EV / NTM EBITDA: February 4, 2010 Proposal Q-o-Q GDP Growth Airgas Multiple February 4, 2010 Proposal Source: FactSet as of November 26, 2010. (1) Represents 5 years of data prior to February 4, 2010. EV/NTM EBITDA Multiple GDP Grow
Slide 14: Airgas Historical Forward Multiples vs. ISM Index
Airgas Historical Forward Multiples vs. ISM Index February 4, 2010 Proposal ISM Index Airgas Multiple February 4, 2010 Proposal EV/NTM EBITDA Multiple ISM Index Price/NTM EPS Multiple ISM Index Source: FactSet as of November 26, 2010. (1) Represents 5 years of data prior to February 4, 2010. 13 Pric
Slide 15: Non-GAAP Reconciliations: Last-Twelve-Months Adjusted EPS
14 Non-GAAP Reconciliations Last-Twelve-Months (LTM) Adjusted EPS The Company believes that adjusted earnings per diluted share above provide investors meaningful insight into the Company's earnings trend without the impact of debt extinguishment charges, multi-employer pension plan withdrawal charg
Slide 16: Non-GAAP Reconciliations: Fiscal 2011 EPS Guidance
15 Non-GAAP Reconciliations Fiscal 2011 EPS Guidance Guidance for adjusted earnings per diluted share excludes debt extinguishment charges, multi-employer pension plan withdrawal charges, and costs and charges related to the unsolicited takeover attempt. Adjustments to earnings per diluted share gui