Taubman Centers — Proxy Contest (May 2017)
61 slides from Taubman Centers's proxy contest presentation, May 8, 2017
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement cover
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant Filed by a Party other than the Registrant Check the appropriate box: Preliminary Proxy State
Slide 2: Vote the enclosed WHITE proxy card today: letter to shareholders
VOTE THE ENCLOSED WHITE PROXY CARD TODAY “FOR” TAUBMAN’S DIRECTOR NOMINEES May 5, 2017 Dear Fellow Taubman Shareholder, Over the past 20 years, the knowledge and expertise of the Taubman Board has contributed to Taubman delivering exceptional financial and operational performance and driven sharehol
Slide 3: Shareholder letter continued: engagement and board
comprised of top assets in the U.S. and Asia, we are confident in our plan to drive $150 million to $160 million of NOI growth, at our share, between 2016 and the full year 2019. Taubman Values Shareholder Insights and Input Taubman has been open and responsive to feedback from shareholders, consist
Slide 4: Taubman's candidates are more qualified than Land & Buildings' nominees
Taubman’s Independent Directors Carefully Reviewed Land & Buildings’ Nominees and Determined that Taubman’s Candidates are Significantly More Qualified than Land & Buildings’ Nominees The Taubman Board has been responsive to Land & Buildings’ suggestions and members of the Board had discussions with
Slide 5: Land & Buildings is not a long-term investor
In addition, contrary to Mr. Litt’s claims, Land & Buildings is not a long-term investor in the Company, and has routinely traded in and out of Taubman’s stock, disclosing in its proxy 105 trades since July 31, 2015. Land & Buildings’ trading history is akin to a day trader looking for short-term pr
Slide 6: Right board and strategy to deliver shareholder value
Taubman Has the Right Board and the Right Strategy to Deliver Shareholder Value Now and Over the Long Term The Board is committed to extending Taubman’s track record of strong operational and financial performance. Please refer to the enclosed WHITE proxy card for information on how to vote by telep
Slide 7: Forward-looking statements
For ease of use, references herein to “Taubman Centers,” “Company,” “Taubman” or an operating platform mean Taubman Centers, Inc. and/or one or more of a number of separate, affiliated entities. Business is actually conducted by an affiliated entity rather than Taubman Centers, Inc. itself or the na
Slide 8: Taubman Centers, Inc. Annual Meeting Spring 2017
0 Taubman Centers, Inc. Annual Meeting Investor Presentation Spring 2017
Slide 9: Taubman is a Best-in-Class REIT
1 Development and Capital Allocation Corporate Governance Taubman is a Best-in-Class REIT > Corporate Strategy, Portfolio & Performance Strong and experienced Board of Directors aligned with shareholders Addressing additional misleading statements and baseless claims made by Land & Buildings Unparal
Slide 10: Taubman Centers, Inc. at a glance
2 Taubman Centers, Inc. (NYSE: TCO) Founded in 1950 – 67 years in operation First publicly traded UPREIT – IPO in 1992 Total market capitalization over $10 billion Joined the S&P 400 MidCap Index in January 2011 We own, operate and develop the best retail assets Our portfolio of malls is
Slide 11: We Own, Operate and Develop the Best Retail Assets
3 Beverly Center, Calif. Cherry Creek Shopping Center, Colo. City Creek Center, Utah Dolphin Mall, Fla. Fair Oaks, Va. The Mall at Millenia, Fla. The Mall at Short Hills, N.J. Country Club Plaza, MO. The Gardens on El Paseo, Calif. Great Lakes Crossing Outlets, Mich. Starfield Hanam, South Korea The
Slide 12: The Taubman Strategic Vision
4 The Taubman Strategic Vision Our long-standing vision of owning, operating and developing best-in-class, dynamic destination shopping centers has kept us ahead of the curve in an ever-evolving retail environment Long-standing dedication to creating high productivity experiential destination cent
Slide 13: Owned Properties
5 Owned Properties 1 Beverly Center Los Angeles, Calif. 2 Cherry Creek Shopping Center Denver, Colo. 3 CityOn.Xi’an Xi’an, China 4 CityOn.Zhengzhou Zhengzhou, China 5 City Creek Center Salt Lake City, Utah 6 Country Club Plaza Kansas City, Mo. 7 Dolphin Mall Miami, Fla. 8 Fair Oaks Fairfax, Va. 9 Th
Slide 14: Portfolio averages between A+ and A quality
6 Taubman’s portfolio(1) of malls averages between A+ and A quality Long-Standing Focus on Highest End of Mall Quality Spectrum Note: (1) Grades are based on sales per square foot. Mall value is based on sales productivity, size, quality and other factors. Taubman excludes The Mall of San Juan, City
Slide 15: Unparalleled anchor quality drives mall visitation
7 Anchors are a critical factor in assessing mall quality Strong anchors attract both retailers and customers Taubman’s portfolio is well-positioned; containing the largest concentration of high quality anchors Better Fashion Anchors Total Traditional Dept. Stores Greatest Exposure to Superior
Slide 16: Proactive management of retailer mix leads to sales growth
8 Over the last 10 years, we have proactively increased the footprint of new retailers throughout our portfolio, replacing formerly prominent tenants The information below highlights a sample of tenants indicative of change within our tenant base over the last 10 years The evolution of Taubman
Slide 17: We target and attract cutting-edge brands
9 We Target and Attract Cutting-Edge Brands Brands that have chosen a Taubman center as their first U.S. Mall location “Online” retailers that are now tenants in Taubman Centers
Slide 18: Industry-leading results in rent and sales per square foot
10 Average Rent per Square Foot(2) Sales per Square Foot(1) Our Focus on Owning, Operating and Developing the Best Malls Has Yielded Industry-Leading Results Note: (1) As of 31-Dec-2016. Typically excludes all non-comparable centers, anchors, temporary tenants and 10,000+ sf tenants. (2) As of 31-De
Slide 19: Industry-leading sales productivity and NOI growth
11 $437 $581 2005 2016 $417 $630 2005 2016 $450 $614 2005 2016 $508 $792 2005 2016 Our Portfolio Has Consistently Delivered Industry-Leading Sales Productivity and Strong NOI Growth Note: (1) Indexed from base year of 2005 as 100%, and grown each year by GSA same-Property NOI growth rates to achieve
Slide 20: Top 10 performer over the past 20 years
12 Rank Company Total Return Total Compounded Annualized Return 1 1,945% 2 1,833% 3 1,807% 4 1,599% 5 1,571% 6 1,517% 7 1,414% 8 1,374% 9 1,269% 10 1,251% In the Entire Public REIT Universe, Taubman is a Top 10 Performer Over the Past 20 Years Source: KeyBanc Capital Markets: The Leaderboard; market
Slide 21: Value created for shareholders versus similarly tenured CEOs
13 20-Year Total Shareholder Return(1) Rank Company CEO (Tenure Yrs) Total Return Total Compounded Annualized Return 1 Robert Taubman (~27) 1,517 % 2 David Simon (~22) 1,414 % 3 Alan Miller (~31) 1,251 % 4 B. Francis Saul II (~24) 1,159 % 5 Arthur Coppola (~24) 887 % 6 Gary Shiffman (~23) 854 % 7 Ri
Slide 22: Recent and long-term performance versus mall peers
14 0.0 % 7.9 % 11.3 % 12.1 % 14.5 % 17.3 % 20-Year 10-Year 5-Year Recent and Long-Term Performance Compares Favorably with Regional Mall Peers Land & Buildings’ focus on our 5-year underperformance is misleading and selective Source: KeyBanc Capital Markets: The Leaderboard; market data as of 31-Dec
Slide 23: Resilience through the Great Recession
15 2007-2011 (5-Year) Leverage (Net Debt / Enterprise Value) 2012-2016 (5-Year) 2007-2016 (10-Year) Resilience Through the Great Recession While Peers Faced Substantial Challenges Source: KeyBanc Capital Markets: The Leaderboard, CapIQ, SNL, market data as of 31-Dec-2016 Land & Buildings has highlig
Slide 24: Rewarding our shareholders: dividend per share
16 $1.29 $1.54 $1.66 $1.66 $1.68 $1.76 $1.85 $2.00 $2.16 $2.26 $2.38 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Over 60 RMZ-listed REITs cut their dividend during the recession; our dividend grew… Rewarding Our Shareholders We have a cycle-tested management team that showed superior fina
Slide 25: Only high quality mall REIT not to cut dividends
17 $1.97 $2.01 $2.02 $2.02 $2.02 $2.08 $2.18 $2.40 $2.60 $2.80 $3.04 $3.36 $3.60 $2.70 $2.60 $3.30 $4.10 $4.65 $5.15 $6.05 $6.50 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 $1.70 $1.78 $1.87 $1.97 $2.06 $2.14 $2.22 $2.32 $2.48 $2.63 $2.75
Slide 26: Strong track record of recycling capital for growth
18 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 - 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 1992 1997 2002 2007 2012 (2014) 2016 D ol la rs in m ill io ns O w ned and O perating M alls Total Market Cap Equity Market Cap Number Owned and Operating Malls Strong Track Record of Recycling Capital for Growth As of year-
Slide 27: Mall sector is the most undervalued among REIT sectors
19 The Mall Sector is the Most Undervalued Among All Major REIT Sectors; While Undervalued, TCO Remains In Line with Peers… Source: NAVs per Green Street Advisors as of 31-Dec-2016 REIT Industry Premium/(Discount) to Net Asset Value (NAV) Mall Sector Premium/(Discount) to Net Asset Value (NAV) 21.0
Slide 28: Consistently traded at a premium to peers
20 …However, We Have Consistently Traded At A Premium to Our Peers 10-Year Forward FFO Multiple Despite our current discount to NAV, we have long traded at a premium to our closest peers reflecting the market’s recognition of the quality of our assets and our track record of outperformance Source: B
Slide 29: Taubman is a Best-in-Class REIT
21 Top 10 performing REIT over the last 20 years Trophy quality, market dominant retail assets Development and Capital Allocation Unparalleled value creation from development through market cycles Commitment to disciplined balance sheet and capital allocation Corporate Governance Taubman is a Best-i
Slide 30: Long-term approach to optimize capital allocation
22 Long-Term Approach to Optimize Capital Allocation Historically, we have been an active developer – while still taking advantage of all capital allocation options Execution Time Less than 1 Year 5-10+ Years Po te nt ia l L on g- Te rm Va lu e Cr ea ti on High Low Acquire Redevelop Develop/Build Bu
Slide 31: Capital allocation: board-driven process with hurdle rates
23 Capital Allocation: A Board-Driven Process with Disciplined Hurdle Rates The Five “Gates” Investment returns greater than hurdle rate Sufficient specialty store opportunity Entitle site Anchor/tenant interest in site Identify market/site Allocate Capital Hurdle Rates: Levered IRRs Taubman weighte
Slide 32: Smart development at attractive yields
24 Taubman’s Cornerstone: Smart Development at Attractive Yields Taubman Developments (1992-2016) Our U.S. developments have created immense value(1) Nearly $5 billion of net value has been created on a total capital investment of about $3.8 billion The levered and unlevered IRRs on all developm
Slide 33: Most productive developed assets recognized by equity research
25 Asset Location GSA Estimated Sales per Square Foot(1) GSA Quality Ranking(1) Year Completed The Mall at Millenia Orlando, FL $1,345 A++ 2002 Dolphin Mall Miami, FL $935 A+ 2001 International Plaza Tampa, FL $925 A+ 2001 The Mall at University Town Center Sarasota, FL $900 A 2014 City Creek Center
Slide 34: Taubman Asia strategy
26 Taubman Asia – Strategy Identify our preferred markets Second-tier cities in China; South Korea Build a team Now operating with a tested, comprehensive Taubman Asia team with employees and skills in all disciplines Select strategic partners Wangfujing, one of the oldest and largest departme
Slide 35: Developments in Asia on track to meet expectations
27 Developments in Asia on Track to Meet Our Expectations Asset Date Opened % Leased On Budget Open On-Time Positioned to Create Substantial Value CityOn.Xi'an – Xi'an, China Apr-2016 100% CityOn.Zhengzhou – Zhengzhou, China Mar-2017 100% Starfield Hanam – Hanam, South Korea Sept-2016 100% Source: C
Slide 36: Lowest cost and longest term debt in mall REIT sector
28 W ei gh te d A ve ra ge In te re st R at e Weighted Average Debt Maturity Most efficient debt pricing Cost of capital advantage Lowest Cost and Longest Term Debt in U.S. Mall REIT Sector D ol la rs in $ M M Debt Maturities by Year (as of 12/31/2016, in millions at our share)1 Note: (1) Maturi
Slide 37: Taubman is a Best-in-Class REIT
29 Unparalleled value creation from development through market cycles Commitment to disciplined balance sheet and capital allocation Development and Capital Allocation Corporate Governance Taubman is a Best-in-Class REIT > Strong and experienced Board of Directors aligned with shareholders Addressin
Slide 38: Longstanding commitment to enhancing corporate governance
30 Years of continuous improvements reflect our commitment to strong governance practices and responsiveness to shareholders We Have A Longstanding Commitment to Enhancing Corporate Governance Practices 2013 2015 2012 2014 2016 Increased independence of the Board by appointing two independent dire
Slide 39: Governance steps mischaracterized by Land & Buildings
31 Our Recent Proactive Steps to Improve Corporate Governance Have Been Mischaracterized by Land & Buildings Added Cia Buckley Marakovits to the Board; an independent, highly regarded, industry-leading businesswoman Appointed Mike Ullman to newly created role of Lead Director with significant ov
Slide 40: Series B shares align voting and economic interests: myth vs fact
32 The Series B Shares Ensure Voting Interests in TCO Are Aligned with the Economic Interests in the Operating Partnership Series B shares can be accumulated/bought to hold a disproportionate number of votes Series B shares generally cannot be traded separately from the OP units, and have liquidatio
Slide 41: Our margins are in line with peers given our size
33 Our Margins are In Line with Peers Given Our Size Note: (1) See appendix regarding reconciliations of Consolidated EBITDA and Consolidated NOI to Net Income. Source: Public filings Mall Peers 2016 Consolidated EBITDA Margin vs Consolidated Revenues ($ in 000’s)(1) Mall Peers 2016 Consolidated EBI
Slide 42: G&A as a percentage of gross asset value in line with similar REITs
34 0.60 % 0.51 % 0.49 % 0.45 % 0.39 % 0.37 % 0.33 % 0.32 % 0.31 % 0.29 % 0.27 % 0.19 % 0.19 % BRX ARE INVH DRE DDR TCO O AIV VER UDR FRT MAA EXR Average: 0.36 % $14.6B $13.7B $13.0B $12.3B $12.7B $14.3B $16.1B $12.7B $16.8B $16.4B $12.9B $16.3B $14.0B GSA GAV Mall Average: 0.42 % A Mall Average: 0.2
Slide 43: G&A practices consistent with peers
35 What We Don’t Do What We Do Our G&A Practices Are Consistent with Peers and Have Been Taken Out of Context by Land & Buildings Allow shareholders to pay for executives’ personal use of the corporate jet Compensate our executives with personal use corporate jet perks as some of our peers do
Slide 44: Effective and transparent compensation policy
36 Strong emphasis on pay for performance, including relative total shareholder return Balance between long-term and short-term incentives with significant performance-based weighting Approved by a fully independent Board committee using a third-party independent consultant Robust stock owne
Slide 45: Strong and respected board with right mix of skills
37 Strong and Respected Board With Right Mix of Skills and Experience Strong Board with a balanced mix of skills, experience and in-depth Company knowledge Experience across a wide range of industries, including real estate Given Taubman’s focus on high-end malls, the Board has, from day one,
Slide 46: Engaged, experienced and skills-driven board
38 An Engaged, Experienced and Skills-Driven Board Current and Past Affiliations Bio Robert S. Taubman CEO (Chair, Exec. Comm.) Chairman of the Board (2001-present), President and Chief Executive Officer at Taubman and the Manager (1990-present), Director at Taubman (1992-present) Director at Co
Slide 47: Engaged, experienced and skills-driven board (continued)
39 An Engaged, Experienced and Skills-Driven Board Current and Past Affiliations Bio Independent Director and Douglas Dillon Professor of Government at Harvard’s Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs (1995- present) Director at Joule Unlimited (Joule Biotechnologies) (2009-present)
Slide 48: Contested board members far more qualified than L&B nominees
40 Taubman’s Contested Board Members are Far More Qualified than Land & Buildings’ Nominees – The Choice is Clear Stronger Candidates? Senior Leadership Experience Business Entrepreneurship and Transactional Experience Financial and Accounting Experience Real Estate Experienc
Slide 49: Land & Buildings' claims of family domination are false
41 Land & Buildings’ Claims of “Family Domination” Are False “Nepotism” – FALSE “Family Dominated Board” – FALSE “Refusal to Engage with Unaffiliated Shareholders” – FALSE “Self-Dealing” – FALSE “Excess Compensation to Family Members” – FALSE “Family Votes Are In Excess of Economic Interest” – FALSE
Slide 50: Jonathan Litt has consistently failed to understand Taubman's story
42 $0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 Jan-1999 Jan-2000 Jan-2001 Jan-2002 Jan-2003 Jan-2004 Jan-2005 Jan-2006 Jan-2007 Neutral Outperform Sell / UnderperformSh ar e Pr ic e( 4) Jonathan Litt Has Consistently Failed to Understand Taubman’s Story Average 12 Month Stock Price Performance Following the Date
Slide 51: Charles Elson has failed to create shareholder value as director
43 (100)% (50)% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 250% 300% Sep-1996 Oct-1998 Nov-2000 Dec-2002 Sunbeam Corp. Peers S&P 500 22.4 % 28.9 % (99.9)% (1) (100)% 0% 100% 200% 300% 400% 500% Sep-2004 Nov-2008 Jan-2013 Apr-2017 Healthsouth Corp Peers S&P 500 333.1% 178.6% 92.3% (1) Served on the board for ~2 years,
Slide 52: He does not understand our share structure
44 …And He Clearly Does Not Understand Our Share Structure 1 share | 1 unit | 1 vote ✔ Charles Elson Land & Buildings Nominee “And I think this Board, given its structure and its practices, is not doing its job, in my view, effectively as the kind of oversight vehicle you want. Why? Number 1 – you h
Slide 53: Track record of superior value creation
45 Taubman’s Track Record of Superior Value Creation The Taubman family is aligned with shareholders through the one share, one unit, one vote structure We have a strong and experienced Board of Directors with a diverse mix of skills and expertise We have a tested development track record thro
Slide 54: Vote the Taubman White Card FOR
46 Taubman Has and Expects to Continue to Deliver Superior Results Vote the Taubman White Card FOR Performance in the top 10 percentile of REITs over the last 20 years Long-standing focus on best-in-class, dynamic retail destination centers Positioned to realize significant value from recent develop
Slide 55: 47
47
Slide 56: Appendix
48 Appendix
Slide 57: TRG current ownership and voting structure
49 Taubman Realty Group (TRG) Current Ownership and Voting Structure Publicly Traded Entity The Taubman Realty Group Limited Partnership (TRG) Operating Partnership Taubman Centers, Inc. Public REIT (NYSE : TCO) Unit-Holders (Includes Taubman family) Economic Ownership(1): Voting Interest(2): 29.3%
Slide 58: TRG historical ownership and voting structure
50 Taubman Realty Group (TRG – Operating Partnership) Historical Ownership and Voting Structure E co no m ic In te re st V ot in g In te re st The 1998 Restructuring In the company’s 1998 restructuring, GM Pension Trusts (GMPT) exchanged its 37.2% partnership interest in the operating partnership
Slide 59: Reconciliations to non-GAAP measures: Taubman Centers
51 Reconciliations to Non-GAAP Measures – Taubman Centers CORE NOI GROWTH: RECONCILIATION OF NET INCOME TO NET OPERATING INCOME 1 (in millions of dollars; amounts may not add due to rounding) Year ended 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 57.4 95.1 116.2 (8.1) (79.2) 102.3 28
Slide 60: Reconciliations to non-GAAP measures: TCO and peers
52 Reconciliations to Non-GAAP Measures – TCO and Peers Year ended 2016 Net income $ 77 Merger & restructuring costs 30 Depreciation and amortization 281 Impairment loss 22 Interest expense 136 Gain on extinguishment of debt, net (35) Income and other taxes 2 (Income) / loss from unconsolidated enti
Slide 61: Forward-looking language and non-GAAP measures
53 Forward-Looking Language and Non-GAAP Measures For ease of use, references in this presentation to “Taubman Centers,” “company,” “Taubman” or an operating platform mean Taubman Centers, Inc. and/or one or more of a number of separate affiliated entities. Business is actually conducted by an affil