Avista Corporation · NYSE:AVA
Avista — Technical Presentation (May 2024)
37 slides from Avista's technical presentation, May 21, 2024
Slide 1: 2025 Electric IRP TAC Meeting No. 7 Agenda
2025 Electric Integrated Resource Plan Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 7 Agenda Tuesday, May 21, 2024 Virtual Meeting – 8:30 am to 10:00 am PTZ Topic Staff Introductions John Lyons Variable Energy Resource Study Clint Kalich Portfolio/Market Scenarios James Gall ____________________________
Slide 2: 2025 IRP TAC 7 Introductions
2025 IRP TAC 7 Introductions John Lyons, Ph.D. Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 7 May 21, 2024
Slide 3: Today's Agenda
Today’s Agenda Introductions, John Lyons Variable Energy Resource Study, Clint Kalich Portfolio/Market Scenarios, James Gall 2
Slide 4: Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule
Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 8: June 4, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o Load & Resource Balance and Methodology o Loss of Load Probability Study o New Resources Options Costs and Assumptions • TAC 9: June 18, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o IRP Generation Option Transmission Planning Studi
Slide 5: Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule
Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 11: July 30, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o Preferred Resource Strategy Results o Portfolio Scenario Analysis o LOLP Study Results • TAC 12: August 13, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o Preferred Resource Strategy Results (continued) o Portfolio Scenario Analysi
Slide 6: Avista Variable Energy Resource Integration Study Update
Avista Variable Energy Resource Integration Study Update Clint Kalich Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 7 May 21, 2024
Slide 7: Table 18: Integration Costs for Base Scenarios
Table 18: Integration Costs for Base Scenarios Wind Wind System Forecast Cost Cost Te ~ ‘Columbia Basin 100 MW o% 1% ($275 5.0% Wind's Natura SSS es Diversified Mix 400 MW 20% em 665 12.1% B ] e Diversified Mix 600 MW 30% &% 16.1% Table 24: Effect on Integration Cost of Short-Term Liquid Markets 10-
Slide 8: Differences Between Traditional Resources and VERs
Differences Between Traditional Resources and VERs Traditional Resources Variable Energy Resources • Gas, coal, hydro, and biomass • Fuel supply subject to the weather • Reliable and known fuel supply • Geographical dispersion may help *** • Responsive to operator direction • Wind fuel supply issues
Slide 9: Loading Profiles (as % of Daily Maximum Loading)
Loading Profiles (as % of Daily Maximum Loading) January 1, 2024 (5-Minute Data) 4
Slide 10: Comparing Predictability of Load, Wind, and Solar
Comparing Predictability of Load, Wind, and Solar January 1, 2023, through April 30, 2024 (Hourly T-1 vs. Actual Data) 5
Slide 11: Ancillary Services
Ancillary Services • What are ancillary services? – capacity services matching real-time variance between load & generation • Why do we need ancillary services? – customer load variation – VER forecast error – forced outages • How do we supply ancillary services? – (generally) “hold back” generator
Slide 12: Ancillaries as They Pertain to VERs (Solar, Wind)
Ancillaries as They Pertain to VERs (Solar, Wind) various Spinning Reserves are procured to cover NW reserve-sharing agreement for load and forced outages Also carry operating reserves (spin/non-spin)! 7
Slide 13: Ancillaries as They Pertain to VERs (Solar, Wind)
Ancillaries as They Pertain to VERs (Solar, Wind) Key Concepts • Integration costs are driven primarily by the need to hold higher levels of reserves • Higher reserve levels are needed because of large variability and uncertainty of VER production • Higher reserve levels means de-optimizing system o
Slide 14: VER Integration Study Scope
VER Integration Study Scope Purpose and Overview • What’s included in the study? – consumptive capacity and its costs – impacts of EIM (”fast”) markets – potential future portfolio VER buildouts – sensitivity scenarios • What’s not included in the study? – alternative capacity resources (e.g., batte
Slide 15: VER Integration Study
VER Integration Study Purpose and Overview • Consistent application supporting varying analyses – Integrated Resource Planning – resource acquisition processes (e.g., RFP) – transmission rates – PURPA avoided cost calculations • Define “Consumptive Capacity” associated with incremental variable ener
Slide 16: VER Integration Study Timeline
VER Integration Study Timeline Timelines have slipped a bit X X * ancillary services covered in later slide ** excludes variation from forced outages that affect all resources 11 *** but estimating this savings is difficult given varying methods employed
Slide 17: VER Buildout Scenarios
VER Buildout Scenarios Locations Based on Past Proposals • Three VER portfolios • Solar, Wind, 50/50* • Four VER penetrations • 400, 800, 1500, 2500 MW * 50/50 mix created based on nameplate capacity (e.g., 200 MW solar, 200 MW wind) 12
Slide 18: VER Profiles and Forecasts
VER Profiles and Forecasts Dee dddddddddddddddddddddddddd 13
Slide 19: Reserve Calculations
14 Reserve Calculations * Reserve levels are determined by taking a statistical confidence interval of “errors” that represent unanticipated variability or uncertainty contributed to the system by VERs * Reserve calculations identify the MW level of reserves required to 95-99% of variability and unc
Slide 20: EIM and Reserves
EIM and Reserves * The Western EIM facilitates procurement of flexible ramping capacity to address variability that may occur in real-time dispatch “+ The application of flexible ramping capacity serves to reduce the level of Load Following and Forecast Error reserves held within the Avista BAA foot
Slide 21: EIM and Reserves
EIM and Reserves Dee • For the VER integration study, we reduced consultant-calculated load following and forecast error reserves by 50% to reflect benefits of EIM diversity 16
Slide 22: Study Methodology
Study Methodology • 2021 actual system conditions with ADSS software – Hydro conditions, outages, fuel prices • Run Avista system portfolio with and without VER – 2 VER condition scenarios: without new VER, with new VER – 5 VER addition scenarios: 400, 800,1500, 2500 MW – 3 VER mix scenarios: all so
Slide 23: Removing Commodity Energy Value from Study
Removing Commodity Energy Value from Study Two cases include the same energy amounts to avoid biasing results • “Without VER” scenarios – input monthly 12x24 energy shape – no incremental reserves – emulates a firm contract delivery of same energy quantity as With VER • “With VER” scenarios – input
Slide 24: Preliminary Study Results – Average Costs
Preliminary Study Results – Average Costs Integration Cost ($/kW-mo) Integration Cost ($/MWh) Changeset Base High Low Base High Low Existing 0.16 0.23 0.11 0.78 1.11 0.53 5050 400 0.05 0.15 0.03 0.20 0.66 0.11 5050 800 0.12 0.24 0.08 0.50 1.00 0.34 5050 1500 0.33 0.64 0.21 1.53 3.00 1.00 5050 2500 0
Slide 25: Preliminary Study Results – Marginal Costs
Preliminary Study Results – Marginal Costs Integration Cost ($/kW-mo) Integration Cost ($/MWh) Changeset Base High Low Base High Low Existing - - - - - - 5050 400 (0.03) 0.10 (0.03) (0.13) 0.39 (0.13) 5050 800 0.11 0.24 0.07 0.42 0.97 0.28 5050 1500 0.36 0.72 0.23 1.66 3.33 1.08 5050 2500 0.62 0.91
Slide 26: Next Steps
Next Steps • Finalize study results • Generate final study report • Use in future IRPs/RFPs/transmission tariff 21
Slide 27: VER Study Uses in the 2025 IRP
VER Study Uses in the 2025 IRP • Integration Cost ($/kW-month) included as a resource cost (slide 18) • Reliability modeling will include a “Flex Ramp” adjusted for EIM benefits reserve determined by this study (slide 15) • Capacity expansion modeling will include a small incremental flexible capaci
Slide 28: Questions?
Questions? 23
Slide 29: 2025 IRP Market Scenario Update (DRAFT)
2025 IRP Market Scenario Update (DRAFT) James Gall Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 7 May 21, 2024
Slide 30: Market Scenario Update
Market Scenario Update • Expected Case (Deterministic/Stochastic) • Low Natural Gas Prices • High Natural Gas Prices • No Washington Climate Commitment Act 2
Slide 31: Henry Hub Natural Gas Prices
Henry Hub Natural Gas Prices $14.00 Expected Case Uses 95th percentile of stochastic study $12.00 Low Natural Gas Price Scenario High Natural Gas Price Scenario $10.00 $7.20/dth $ Per Dekatherm $8.00 $5.01/dth $6.00 $3.86/dth $4.00 Uses 25th percentile of stochastic study $2.00 $0.00 2026 2027 2028
Slide 32: Electric Price Forecast – Mid-Columbia (Washington Delivery)
Electric Price Forecast Mid-Columbia (Washington Delivery) $80.00 $70.00 $60.00 $50.00 $ per MWh $40.00 $30.00 Deterministic ($45.45) Low NG Prices ($41.52) $20.00 High NG Prices ($52.89) $10.00 No CCA ($40.85) $0.00 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 204
Slide 33: Electric Price Forecast – Mid-Columbia (Non-Washington Delivery)
Electric Price Forecast Mid-Columbia (Non-Washington Delivery) $80.00 $70.00 $60.00 $50.00 $ per MWh $40.00 $30.00 Deterministic ($44.37) $20.00 Low NG Prices ($40.41) High NG Prices ($51.86) $10.00 No CCA ($40.26) $0.00 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041
Slide 34: 2025 IRP Load Forecast
2025 IRP Load Forecast
Slide 35: System End Use Changes in Load Forecast
System End Use Changes in Load Forecast Annual Average Load Growth/Decay Rate Annual Average Load Change Between 2045 and 2024 Between 2045 and 2024 Process -1.03% Lighting -22 Lighting -0.93% Generation -11 Motors -0.73% Motors -8 Ventilation -0.72% Ventilation -8 Water Heating -0.47% Water Heating
Slide 36: Energy Forecast
Energy Forecast 0.81% AAGR 1.08% AAGR 0.31% AAGR 8
Slide 37: Peak Forecast (Forecast is 1-in-2 Weather Event)
Peak Forecast (Forecast is 1-in-2 Weather Event) 1.02% Winter AAGR 1.10% Summer AAGR 9