Eversource Energy (D/B/A) · NYSE:ES
Eversource Energy (D/B/A) — Eversource Energy — Technical Presentation (November 2023)
77 slides from Eversource Energy (D/B/A)'s technical presentation, Nov 15, 2023
Slide 1: Utilities ESMP Stakeholder Workshops & Technical Sessions
Utilities ESMP Stakeholder Workshops & Technical Sessions Workshop #1 November 15, 2023 9 am – 1 pm ESMP Stakeholder Workshop & Technical Session 11-15-23
Slide 2: Online Interpretation
Online Interpretation 1. We will turn on Interpretation in just a moment. 2. Once you see the Globe logo, click it to select a language. 3. Even if you don’t need interpretation, click the logo and select ENGLISH 4. The choices today are 1. English 2. Spanish 3. European Portuguese 4. Brazilian Port
Slide 3: Welcome & Goals of Two Workshops
Welcome & Goals of Two Workshops • Level set everyone’s understanding of draft ESMPs (including demand forecasts; grid infrastructure needs; stakeholder/community engagement plans, etc.) • Provide initial feedback to utilities • Better equipped to participate in ESMP finalization and implementation
Slide 4: ESMP Topics
ESMP Topics • Today’s Workshop (November 15, 9 am – 1 pm) • What’s an Electric Sector Modernization Plan • Demand Forecasts • Grid Infrastructure Needs • 2nd Workshop (November 28, 1-5 pm) • Ensuring an Equitable and Just Transition to a Clean Energy Future • Stakeholder & Community Engagement • Dem
Slide 5: Agenda
Agenda Time Topic & Description Lead/ Presenter 9:00 Welcome, Overview, and Introductions Facilitators • Agenda; Approach & Ground Rules 9:15 ESMP Overview Unitil 9:30 Demand Forecasts • Facilitators • Overview Presentation (12 minutes) • Eversource • Individual Utility Presentations (18 minutes) •
Slide 6: ESMP Invited Participants - updated
ESMP Invited Participants - updated Organization Representative(s) Organization Representative(s) A Better City Yve Torrie MA Municipal Association Julia Ahlberg Melissa Gonzalez / ACE Sofia Owen Making Opportunity Count (MOC) Shakira Collazo Advanced Energy United Kat Burnham Mass Development Dan R
Slide 7: ESMP Workshops Team
ESMP Workshops Team Utilities Facilitators IT Support & Translators (leads/presenters) Erin Engstrom - lead Eversource Janet Gail Besser Independent Jeff Carpenter Gerhard Walker – Eversource Dr. Jonathan Raab Raab Associates presenter Lavelle Freeman - Eversource presenter Matt Motley - lead Nation
Slide 8: Workshop/Zoom Protocols
Workshop/Zoom Protocols • Participants • Should have their videos on, and their audio muted unless speaking. • When want to ask a question or make a comment, use the raise hand function to get in queue. • All questions and comments should be made verbally--the Q&A function is being disabled; and Cha
Slide 9: Submitting Questions and Feedback
Submitting Questions and Feedback • Submission of our draft plans to the Grid Modernization Advisory Council (GMAC) is an important first step in increasing the transparency and inclusiveness of our infrastructure investment planning process. • We consider our customers, communities, and stakeholder
Slide 10: Workshop Conduct
Workshop Conduct Come prepared to discuss agenda items (by reviewing all background documents disseminated prior to the meeting and conferring with your organization and other colleagues as needed.) Be forthright and communicative about your interests and preferences Be clear, so that everyone under
Slide 11: What is an Electric Sector Modernization Plan?
What is an Electric Sector Modernization Plan? November 13, 2023
Slide 12: What is an Electric Sector Modernization Plan?
What is an Electric Sector Modernization Plan? is an ESMP important to the EDCs, customers and the Commonwealth? What is an Electric Sector Modernization Plan (ESMP)? • An ESMP is a comprehensive plan designed to ensure the electric system is capable of supporting the state’s climate goals • Massach
Slide 13: Support the Transition to a Cleaner Energy Future
Support the Transition to a Cleaner Energy Future Plans are designed to support the Commonwealth’s climate goals • Today’s electric system not prepared for the level of electrification and interconnection of DERs identified in the CECP • Support the Commonwealth’s pathway to decarbonization with the
Slide 14: ESMP Plan Contents
ESMP Plan Contents Consistent format between EDCs to make ESMPs easier to follow Chapter Title/Subject Description Provides a summary of the report and approach to ensuring/enabling a just transition to 1 Executive Summary a clean energy future Compliance with the EDC Requirements Provides a link be
Slide 15: ESMP Development and Review Process
ESMP Development and Review Process Steps to ensure stakeholder engagement and feedback on the ESMP Grid Modernization Advisory Council (GMAC) • The GMAC is charged with reviewing and providing recommendations to EDCs including those from its Equity Working Group • Actively engaged in providing feed
Slide 16: Grid Modernization Advisory Council
Grid Modernization Advisory Council Who are the members of the Grid Modernization Advisory Council as appointed by the Governor? GMAC members include representatives from a wide array of organizations and interests Commissioner Elizabeth Mahony (Chair) Kathryn Cox-Arslan - New Leaf Energy MA Departm
Slide 17: Forecasting Overview
Forecasting Overview GMAC Technical Session #1 Dr. Gerhard Walker, Manager Advanced Forecasting and Modeling
Slide 18: Forecasting Overview
Forecasting Overview Why do we Forecast? To understand future demand and service needs so Utilities must forecast because infrastructure takes that we can identify and provide orderly, economic years to plan, site, and build investment, including expansion of equipment and facilities § Transmission
Slide 19: Forecasting Overview – How do we Forecast
Forecasting Overview – How do we Forecast General Framework Planning Horizon (Chapter 5) Long Demand Assessment (Chapter 8) Identification Funding Siting Construction yyyy Headroom – newly added Design/Evaluation Permitting % - Electrification Objective Headroom Forecasting leverages existing DER fo
Slide 20: Forecasting Overview – How Do We Forecast
Forecasting Overview – How Do We Forecast Final reported peak 90/10 weather adjustment Small Solar Generation at time of peak Large Solar Historic, Generation satellite-based at time of weather data to Reported peak calculate non- Transfer Weather Any other metered solar Normalized Correction genera
Slide 21: Econometric Trend Load Model
Forecasting Overview – How Do We Forecast Energy Climate Efficiency EV Demand Res. Growth Existing DER Adoption Forecast Forecasted propensity Step model based on Climate impact Loads customer cluster with probability Permanent Econometric Trend Load Model Forecasted classifications of future Load T
Slide 22: Annual Forecasting Process
Forecasting Overview Release Official Forecast Annual Forecasting Process March September January March ber ber il il r e st July y e st July y y obe Ma Ma Apr Apr uar Jun Jun u u Aug Aug em em r Oct Feb Nov Dec Year 1 Continuous Monitoring of key parameters § Annual Forecast Reports Created Annuall
Slide 23: Scenario Sensitivities in the ESMP
Forecasting Overview Scenario Sensitivity Scenario Sensitivities in the ESMP Remaining Capacity Gap after Proposed Infrastructure Forecasted Long Term Capacity Need Chapter 6 2050 10-year Electric Forecasted Reliability Short Term 10 – year capacity Plan § The 5- and 10- year Forecasts are based on
Slide 24: Achieving Our Commonwealth's Climate Goals – National Grid Electric Load Forecast
Achieving Our Commonwealth’s Climate Goals National Grid Electric Load Forecast ESMP Technical Conference November 15, 2023
Slide 25: Econometric base load forecast and demand assessment
Econometric base load forecast and demand assessment Base load removes impact of solar, storage, energy efficiency, demand response, heat pumps, electric vehicles Summer Peak Load Winter Peak Load Long-term demand assessment Long-term demand assessment 10-year forecast 10-year forecast Note: Seasona
Slide 26: Add impact of PV, EE, DR, storage, consistent with state goals
Add impact of PV, EE, DR, storage, consistent with state goals Net load with DERs Summer Peak Load Winter Peak Load Long-term demand assessment Long-term demand assessment 10-year forecast 10-year forecast Note: Seasonal peak hours will change due to adoptions of different DERs
Slide 27: Add impact of beneficial electrification consistent with state goals
Add impact of beneficial electrification consistent with state goals Net load with DERs and beneficial electrification Summer Peak Load Winter Peak Load Long-term demand assessment Long-term demand assessment 10-year forecast 10-year forecast Note: Seasonal peak hours will change due to adoptions of
Slide 28: Summary of Forecasted Growth
Summary of Forecasted Growth Net load projected to grow by 35% through 2034 and 131% by 2022 2050. Driven by growth in beneficial electrification. PV installed capacity projected 2034 to double by 2034 and more than triple by 2050, however does not directly contribute to peak hour because of shift t
Slide 29: Generate 2000+ scenarios to show uncertainty
Generate 2000+ scenarios to show uncertainty Summer Peak Load Winter Peak Load
Slide 30: Load Forecasting and Demand Assessment
Load Forecasting and Demand Assessment
Slide 31: 5- and 10-Year Demand Forecast
5- and 10-Year Demand Forecast Chapter 5 – 5 and 10 Year Forecast Assumptions in Forecast • Base load weather normalized using weighted temperature humidity index • Large known spot/step loads added • Energy Efficiency (EE) – assumes past history of EE continues • Distributed Energy Resources (DER)
Slide 32: Load Adders
Load Adders What assumptions add to the Base Load Forecast? Large Spot Loads Electric Vehicles Electrification Assumptions: Assumptions: Assumptions: • Known (or relatively certain) new • Separate 10 year EV forecast are • Adoption assumption: spot loads are added to the forecast added into the Base
Slide 33: Load Reducers
Load Reducers What assumptions reduce to the Base Load Forecast? Energy Efficiency Distributed Energy Resources Volt-Var Optimization (VVO) Assumptions: Assumptions: Assumptions: • Mass Save Energy Efficiency Plan • Separate 10 year DER forecast are • Anticipated reduction in current • Past energy e
Slide 34: 5- and 10-Year Demand Forecast
5- and 10-Year Demand Forecast Chapter 5 – 5 and 10 Year Forecast
Slide 35: Demand Assessment
Demand Assessment Demand Assessment designed to support State’s decarbonization goals. Assumptions: • Demand assessment supports our share of the State’s goals • Common assumptions • Load Forecast and Demand Assessment • Assessment does not consider changes in building codes • Demand response of hea
Slide 36: Demand Assessment
Demand Assessment Demand Assessment designed to support State’s decarbonization goals. State Scaled Company Sector Description Units Units Units Benchmark Benchmark Forecast Transportation Sector (Note 2) Light-Duty EV 5,000,000 46,976 vehicles 52,841 vehicles Medium/Heavy Duty EV 353,000 3,316 vehi
Slide 37: Forecasting Results – Eversource
Forecasting Results – Eversource GMAC Technical Session #1 Dr. Gerhard Walker, Manager Advanced Forecasting and Modeling
Slide 38: Chapter 5: 5- and 10-Year Forecast
Chapter 5: 5- and 10-Year Forecast Chapter 5 describes the load forecasting process and the forecast for the next 5 and 10 years. Over the next 10 years, the system will see significant load growth due to step loads and electrification. 7.4 GW Peak Load +20% System Wide 2.8 GW Peak Solar
Slide 39: Chapter 5 – 5- and 10-Year Forecast
Chapter 5 – 5- and 10-Year Forecast Step loads comprise the largest demand increase across the territory over the next 10 years. Step Loads represent large new customer additions such as high rises, labs, or fast charging stations • 833 MW of Step Loads • 796 MW in the next 5 years across Individual
Slide 40: Long Term Forecast: Electric Heating and Vehicles Dominate System Load
Chapter 8 Long Term Forecast Electric Heating and Vehicles Dominate System Load Base Load Step Loads Transportation Heating 18 16 15.3 GW Peak Load 14 12 +150% System Wide Gigawatts (GW) 10 8.2 GW Peak Solar 8 6 4 2 0 Current Base 2028 2033 2035 2040 2045 2050 Load Winter Peak Transition reduces Bas
Slide 41: Chapter 8 – Long Term Demand Assessment
Chapter 8 – Long Term Demand Assessment 2050 Forecast by Sub-Region (with existing sub-stations) Metro West Sub-Region 4.9 GW Peak Load (+142%) 1.3 GW Peak Solar Metro Sub-Region 5.0 GW Peak Load (+190%) 0.1 GW Peak Solar Southern Sub-Region 3.8 GW Peak Load (+171%) 2.0 GW Peak Solar Western Sub-Reg
Slide 42: 2050 Load Projection
2050 Load Projection Comparison of Projected Load and Proposed Capacity Additions Eversource Territory Forecast and Capacity Plan Proposal 16.0 GW 14.0 12.7 12.7 12.7 12.0 11.5 10.3 10.0 8.0 8.2 8.0 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 Today 2028 2033 2035 2040 2045 2050 Driven By Known Step Loads Current Peak Base Load
Slide 43: 2050 DER Projections
2050 DER Projections Comparison of Projected Solar and Proposed Hosting Capacity Additions Aggregated Bulk Station Hosting Capacity after the 5-year Plan 9.00 8.00 8.20 7.00 6.00 5.75 5.75 5.75 5.75 5.00 4.60 4.32 5.08 GW 4.00 3.00 2.00 2.21 1.71 1.00 1.07 0.53 0.00 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 In
Slide 44: Breakouts to Develop Clarifying Questions on Demand Forecasts
Breakouts to Develop Clarifying Questions on Demand Forecasts 1. Once in break-outs, everyone should simultaneously use the Chat function to write down one question you’d like to ask a utility/the utilities on their demand forecast(s). (4 min) 2. Once everyone has written down their question, move d
Slide 45: Break-Out Affinity Groups (#1 and #2)
Break-Out Affinity Groups (#1 and # 2) - updated #1 CBO/EJC #2 DG/DER/EV Developers EDF Jolette Westbrook Advanced Energy United Kat Burnham ACE Sofia Owen NECEC Tim Snyder Making Opportunity Melissa Gonzalez Nexamp Brandon Bowles Count (MOC) United Way of North Kory Eng Mass Solar Mark Sandeen Cent
Slide 46: Break Out Affinity Groups (#3 and #4)
Break Out Affinity Groups (#3 and #4) - updated #3 Housing/Large #4 Users/Business Labor/Workforce/Muni /State/Quasi-State Agencies WMA Economic Develop Rick Sullivan IBEW Mike Monahan Council North Central MA Chamber Fitchburg Housing Authority Doug Bushman Roy Nascimento of Commerce A Better City
Slide 47: Clarifying Questions (and Responses) on Demand Forecasts
Clarifying Questions (and Responses) on Demand Forecasts • Round-robin Q&A with: • Each break-out group asks one of their top questions • Keep going around as time allows • Avoid questions that another group already essentially asked • Direct question at: • The lead-off presenter • An individual uti
Slide 48: Stakeholder Discussion and Feedback on Demand Forecasts
Stakeholder Discussion and Feedback on Demand Forecasts • Initial thoughts and feedback on the utilities’ ESMP-related demand forecasts • Raise hands to get in queue • Be clear about whether providing feedback to an individual utility or all the utilities • Be succinct so that everyone can provide t
Slide 49: BREAK (11:00 TO 11:15 AM)
BREAK (11:00 TO 11:15 AM) ESMP Stakeholder Workshop & Technical Session 11-15-23
Slide 50: Grid Infrastructure Needs
Grid Infrastructure Needs National Grid 1
Slide 51: Grid Infrastructure – Current State
Grid Infrastructure – Current State Transmission lines carry electricity long distances at high voltage levels (e.g., 69 kV, 115 kV, 345 kV) Substation Transformers step voltage down to lower voltages safer for local distribution (e.g., 15 kV, 5 kV) Distribution Lines or Feeders carry power overhead
Slide 52: Grid Infrastructure by the Numbers
Grid Infrastructure by the Numbers Eversource National Grid Unitil State-Wide Planning 4 6 1 11 Subregions Substations 172 178 15 365 Miles 20,700 18,500 522 39,722 Distribution Miles Overhead 11,500 13,500 454 25,454 Miles Underground 9,200 5,000 68 14,268 Poles 500,000 720,000 19,100 1,239,100 Dis
Slide 53: Substations - Key Component
Substations - Key Component • Substations link the transmission system to the distribution system, and eventually the end users Protection Incoming – our customers & Control Transmission Room Line (e.g. 115 kV) • They convert power utilizing power transformers that do not move or rotate • Substation
Slide 54: Grid Infrastructure – Planning Process
Grid Infrastructure – Planning Process • The EDCs have formal planning processes that are generally consistent across all three Companies • Forecast identifies projected demand • Planning Criteria establishes thresholds for acceptable behavior (EDC-specific) • Recommendations (infrastructure and oth
Slide 55: Grid Infrastructure
Grid Infrastructure November 13, 2023
Slide 56: Grid Infrastructure Estimates
Grid Infrastructure Estimates Estimated change in grid infrastructure from 2025-2050 2025-2050 2025-2050 2025-2029 2030-2039 2040-2050 Existing Total Increase % Increase Estimate Estimate Estimate Estimate Estimate Substations 15 16 16 19 4 27% Miles Distribution 522 530 550 570 48 9% Miles Overhead
Slide 57: Capacity Expansion 2025-2030
Capacity Expansion 2025-2030 Projects identified to address capacity constraints (ESMP Section 6) Lunenburg Substation Expansion - 2026 New South Lunenburg Substation - 2030 Constraints Constraints 2025 - Lunenburg Regulator Loading 2030 – 08/09 Loading N-1 Condition 2026 – Lunenburg Transformer Loa
Slide 58: Capacity Expansion 2031-2039
Capacity Expansion 2031-2039 Projects identified to address capacity constraints (ESMP Section 9) 1. Establish 2nd Circuit at Rindge Road – 2035 2. Replace Princeton Road 50T2 Transformer – 2035 3. Townsend Substation Capacity Additions – 2036 4. Install New Circuit and Split Circuit 22W1 – 2036 3 5
Slide 59: Capacity Expansion 2040-2050
Capacity Expansion 2040-2050 Projects identified to address capacity constraints (ESMP Section 9) 1. 01 and 02 Line Capacity Additions – 2040 2. Summer Street Substation Capacity Additions – 2040 3. Construction New Lunenburg/Summer Street Supply – 2042 4. Beech Street Tap Substation – 2042 10 5. Ne
Slide 60: Eversource Grid Infrastructure Investments
Eversource Grid Infrastructure Investments GMAC Technical Session #1 Lavelle Freeman, Director Distribution System Planning 11/15/2023
Slide 61: Current Grid Can't Support Clean Energy Transition
Current Grid Can’t Support Clean Energy Transition A D D IT ION A L IN F R A S T R U C T U R E N E E D E D With existing 10-Year Capital Plan and Bulk Distribution Substations as clean 2050 solution set, system peak capacity 18 energy hubs, are critical elements of the deficiency remains at 2.7 GW c
Slide 62: 10 Year Infrastructure Plan – Major Capital Projects
10 Year Infrastructure Plan – Major Capital Projects 2030 2035 2025 Somerville Substation Expansion Silver Substation Upgrade New Saxonville/Natick Substation Clinton 21S Substation Transformer Upgrade Plainfield Substation Upgrade New Charlestown/Somerville Substation Franconia Substation Upgrade L
Slide 63: 5-10 Year and 2050 Plan: DER Hosting Capacity Needs and Solutions
5-10 Year and 2050 Plan: DER Hosting Capacity Needs and Solutions With existing 10 Year Capital and CIP Plans, solar hosting capacity (substation level) deficiency remains at ~2.4 GW • As of 2023, total DER hosting capacity is ~3.5GW with installed solar generation of ~1.5GW • Over the next 10-years
Slide 64: Major Capital Projects in the 10-Year Plan
Major Capital Projects in the 10-Year Plan Metro West Region 4 new stations 4 station upgrades Metro Boston Region Western Region 7 new stations 2 new stations 4 station upgrades 10 station upgrades Southern Region 4 new stations § 17 new substations (14 Load, 3 CIPs) 7 station upgrades § 26 substat
Slide 65: Projected Bulk Substation Capacity Deficiencies in EMA to Reach 2050 Goal
Projected Bulk Substation Capacity Deficiencies in EMA to Reach 2050 Goal (Metro Boston, Metro West, Southeast) • With existing 10-Year Capital Plan and planned substation additions and upgrades beyond 2035, Eastern Massachusetts system peak capacity deficiency remains at 3.3 GW (1.7 GW in Metro Wes
Slide 66: Proposed ESMP Investments Over 10 Years
Proposed ESMP Investments Over 10 Years ~$11B planned distribution system investments to provide safe and reliable service to customers and enable clean energy advancement $12.1B $960M new capital expenses (proposed) ESMP TOTAL COST over the next decade
Slide 67: National Grid Infrastructure Investments
National Grid Infrastructure Investments National Grid 1
Slide 68: What our network looks like and what it enables today
What our network looks like and what it enables today National Grid
Slide 69: Building an electric system to support a doubling of electric demand
To deliver on the Commonwealth’s climate goals, we will build an electric system that can support a doubling of electric demand Our State’s 20 GW 20 GW 10 GW 5M 3M electric decarbonized Goals by 2050 of solar of offshore wind of energy storage vehicles buildings National Grid
Slide 70: We must build out network infrastructure significantly
We must build out network infrastructure significantly to support this forecasted load growth To address projected asset overloads resulting from Existing & Future ESMP Substations forecasted load growth and to increase system capacity, the following investments were proposed*: In the next 5 2030-20
Slide 71: The ESMP requires investment of $2.4bn over the next five years
The ESMP requires investment of $2.4bn over the next five years with Network Investments leading the way …enabling We’ll build key electrification infrastructure… This work will Upgrade 10 enable 1 GW of substations, beneficial construct 3 new electrification and substations, and DER hosting execute
Slide 72: Breakouts to Develop Clarifying Questions on Grid Infrastructure Needs
Breakouts to Develop Clarifying Questions on Grid Infrastructure Needs 1. Once in break-outs, everyone should simultaneously use the Chat function to write down one question you’d like to ask a utility/the utilities on their grid infrastructure needs. (4 min) 2. Once everyone has written down their
Slide 73: Break-Out Affinity Groups (#1 and #2)
Break-Out Affinity Groups (#1 and # 2) - updated #1 CBO/EJC #2 DG/DER/EV Developers EDF Jolette Westbrook Advanced Energy United Kat Burnham ACE Sofia Owen NECEC Tim Snyder Making Opportunity Melissa Gonzalez Nexamp Brandon Bowles Count (MOC) United Way of North Kory Eng Mass Solar Mark Sandeen Cent
Slide 74: Break Out Affinity Groups (#3 and #4)
Break Out Affinity Groups (#3 and #4) - updated #3 Housing/Large #4 Users/Business Labor/Workforce/Muni /State/Quasi-State Agencies WMA Economic Develop Rick Sullivan IBEW Mike Monahan Council North Central MA Chamber Fitchburg Housing Authority Doug Bushman Roy Nascimento of Commerce A Better City
Slide 75: Clarifying Questions (and Responses) on Grid Infrastructure Needs
Clarifying Questions (and Responses) on Grid Infrastructure Needs • Round-robin Q&A with: • Each break-out group asks one of their top questions • Keep going around as time allows • Avoid questions that another group already essentially asked • Direct question at: • The lead-off presenter • An indiv
Slide 76: Stakeholder Discussion and Feedback on Grid Infrastructure Needs
Stakeholder Discussion and Feedback on Grid Infrastructure Needs • Initial thoughts and feedback on the utilities ESMP-related grid infrastructure needs • Raise hands to get in queue • Be clear about whether providing feedback to an individual utility or all the utilities • Be succinct so that every
Slide 77: Wrap Up and Next Steps
Wrap Up and Next Steps • Recap & Feedback • Stakeholder Workshop #2 topics • Ensuring an Equitable and Just Transition to a Clean Energy Future • Stakeholder and Community Engagement • Demand Forecasts and Grid Infrastructure : Additional feedback • Proposed Approach to Second Workshop • Panels on E
Eversource Energy — Technical Presentation (November 2023) on 6ix