Echo Therapeutics — Proxy Contest (May 2014)
38 slides from Echo Therapeutics's proxy contest presentation, May 30, 2014
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Information - Echo Therapeutics, Inc.
SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION PROXY STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 14(a) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant [ ] Filed by a Party Other than the Registrant [x] Check the Appropriate Box: [ ] Pre
Slide 2: Platinum issued the following presentation to stockholders
Platinum Management (NY) LLC, together with the other participants named herein (collectively, “Platinum”), has made a definitive filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission of a proxy statement and an accompanying GOLD proxy card to be used to solicit votes for the election of Platinum’s hig
Slide 3: Why Real Change Is Needed Now at Echo Therapeutics
WHY REAL CHANGE IS NEEDED NOW AT ECHO THERAPEUTICS, INC. LET’S END THE ERA OF UNDERPERFORMANCE AT ECHO - VOTE THE GOLD PROXY CARD
Slide 4: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS Pages 3-5 Platinum - Who We Are Pages 6-16 How We Got Here Pages 17-25 — Echo’s Track Record of Underperformance Pages 26-35 —_— Platinum - Our Nominee is Highly Qualified, Our Interests Are Aligned, Do Not Be Misled by Echo Page 36 Conclusion
Slide 5: Platinum Management: Who We Are
PLATINUM MANAGEMENT: WHO WE ARE
Slide 6: Who We Are
WHO WE ARE Platinum is a New York based investment management group with more than $1.3 Billionin assets under management ¢We are the largest stockholder in Echo, owning almost 20% of the Company’s stock -Platinum is a long-term investor having made our first investmentin Echo in 2007. We have inves
Slide 7: Our Pledge to Echo Stockholders
OUR PLEDGE TO ECHO STOCKHOLDERS under a Securities atinum. He is an ished its Purchase Agreement independent director stockholders for too with Echo (“SPA”). fulfilling his fiduciary long. obligations to ALL stockholders. Echois solicitingin favor of Dr. Goldberg.
Slide 8: Platinum: How We Got Here
PLATINUM: How We Got Here
Slide 9: Echo and Its Board Have Lost the Confidence of the Investing Public
ECHO AND ITS BOARD HAVE LOST THE CONFIDENCE OF THE INVESTING PUBLIC We believe Echo suffers from numerous issues that help explain its downward stock spiral. Echo stock closed at an ALL TIME low of $1.58 on May 27, 2014: Failure of Leadership Deficient and Unclear Corporate Strategy Poor Execution S
Slide 10: Background
BACKGROUND Platinum is a long-term investorin Echo, having made our first investmentin 2007. We have invested more than $18.6M into Echo. We believe in the Company and in unlocking its awesome potential. After initially being denied access to speak to the independent members of the Board, the Compan
Slide 11: Platinum's Plan to Unlock Value at Echo
PLATINUM’S PLAN TO UNLOCK VALUE AT ECHO Endless months of Board inaction forced us to publicly announce in 2013 a multi- point plan carefully targeted to address the shortfalls in leadership, strategy, product partnering and financing that have plagued Echo and punished its stockholders through dilu
Slide 12: The Echo Board Rejected Our Proposal
The Echo Board, which collectively owns less than 1% of Echo stock, rejected our proposal Echo’s misaligned Board, in our view, has impaired the Company’s valuatio and has contributed to its underperformance in recent years. 10
Slide 13: How We Got Here
HOW WE GOT HERE ¢On November 20, 2013, we reached out to the Company to set upa call to discussa potential Chinese development partner and an investmentin the Company by Platinum. « Between November 20, 2013 and December 10, 2013, we continued to negotiate a potential transaction with the Company an
Slide 14: How We Got Here
HOW WE GOT HERE On December 10% Echo and Platinum entered into a Securities Purchase Agreement (“SPA”)whereby Platinum invested $5M into Echo. Platinum invested money at ABOVE MARKET PRICES. Platinum fulfilled its contractual obligations. Echo did not. In connection with the SPA, Platinum: + Investe
Slide 15: How We Got Here
HOW WE GOT HERE Platinum was forced to enforce our rights under the SPA by filing a verified complaint with the Court of Seen of the State of Delaware against the Company and members of the Board. pon Deceutber 12 , 2013, Platinum submitted Shepard M. Goldberg as Platinum’s highly qualified Investor
Slide 16: Echo Board's Response to Our Nomination of Shepard Goldberg
WE BELIEVE THE ECHO BOARD’S RESPONSE TO OUR NOMINATION OF SHEPARD M. GOLDBERG IS JUST ANOTHER REASON TO VOTE FOR CHANGE AT ECHO THERAPEUTICS 14
Slide 17: Echo's Recent Actions Violated SEC Rules
WE BELIEVE ECHO’S RECENT ACTIONS VIOLATED SEC RULES Despite the valid nomination of Mr. Shepard Goldberg to Echo’s Board on April 3, 2014, we believe Echo aan SEC Rules by not filing a preliminary proxy statement with the SEC in connection with a proxy contest. Our nomination was publicly disclosed
Slide 18: Echo's Recent Actions Violated SEC Rules
WE BELIEVE ECHO’S RECENT ACTIONS VIOLATED SEC RULES ¢On April 22, Echo announced they would set a new record and meeting date and also said: “In light of Platinum’s decision to move forward with its proxy contest and solicit proxies in connection with Echo’s 2014 Annual Meeting, Echo will be filing
Slide 19: Echo's Track Record of Underperformance
Echo’s Track Record of Underperformance
Slide 20: Echo's Stock Price Has Plunged
ECHO’S STOCK PRICE HAS PLUNGED... --more than 95% over the last three years! Echo 3-Year Return 20.00% -———$$$$$$$$$$_____—____— SUEEEEEEnEnEE 0.00% -20.00% -40,00% 60.00% -80.00% -100.00% “— You have paid the price 18
Slide 21: Echo Stock Has Considerably Underperformed
ECHO STOCK HAS CONSIDERABLY UNDERPERFORMED Echo 3-Year Stock Price vs. CIGS Biotechnology Index & NASDAQ 200.00% 171.1% 150.00% = 100.00% +—— 50.00% + 49.8% —ECTE 0.00% —nNaspaQq | — ics 3520 -50.00% ~ Biotechnology -95.9% RAP Sa a a Ha oP WO a 19
Slide 22: Since Doman Named Interim CEO, Echo Dropped Another 34%
SINCE ROBERT DOMAN WAS NAMED “INTERIM” CEO NINE MONTHS AGO, ECHO HAS DROPPED ANOTHER 34% AND UNDERPERFORMED VS. ALL RELEVANT INDEXES... 20
Slide 23: Doman, Like the Board, Has Been Highly Compensated
.. YET DOMAN, LIKE THE REST OF THE BOARD, HAS BEEN HIGHLY COMPENSATED... ¢ Robert Doman has collected over $300,000 in compensation during the Board’s “search” for a permanent CEO in our estimation. - After initially receiving $2,500 a day for his services, he now continues to collect $8,000 per wee
Slide 24: But Owns Almost No Stock
«. BUT OWNS ALMOST NO STOCK. TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE 1:10 REVERSE STOCK SPLIT, DOMAN HAS ONLY PURCHASED 1,500 SHARES SINCE JOINING THE BOARD! ROBERT DOMAN HAS SPENT JUST $11,961 ON ECHO STOCK... .. AND is trying to make you believe that Platinum’s interests, as an almost 20% stockholder, are not ali
Slide 25: Election of Our Nominee Is Vital to Protecting Your Investment
PLATINUM BELIEVES THE ELECTION OF OUR NOMINEEIS VITAL TO PROTECTING THE FUTURE VALUE OF YOUR INVESTMENT We believe the Echo Board have been poor stewards of your investment: R % te 24 fe 6S < % fe % fe » < % Failure of leadership Deficient or unclear corporate strategy Poor execution Lethargic in se
Slide 26: Echo's Cost of Capital Has Been Excessive
eo ECHO’S COST OF CAPITAL HAS BEEN EXCESSIVE AND ITS EXPENSES ARE OUT OF CONTROL Echo has entered into 6 dilutive financings in the last several years, which have corresponded with a -95% decrease in the stock price. Echo entered into 2 dilutive financings within a span of several months in 2013. Ec
Slide 27: The Echo Board's Interests Are Not Aligned with Stockholders
THE ECHO BOARD’S INTERESTS ARE ALIGNED WITH STOCKHOLDERS OT Pct. Of Echo Director Common Stock Owned* Common Stock 2013 Compensation Robert Doman 4,700 0.04% $ 204,40. Vincent Enright 28,200 0.2456 $ 85,39 James Smith 22,900 0.19% $ 86,29 William Grieco 38,200 0.32% $ 88,382 Echo Total 94,000 0.79%
Slide 28: Our Nominee Is Highly Qualified; Our Interests Are Aligned
PLATINUM : ¢ Our Nominee is Highly Qualified ¢ Our Interests are Aligned with al Stockholders DO NOT BE MISLED BY ECHO
Slide 29: Our Nominee, Shepard M. Goldberg, Will Be a Voice of Reason
OUR NOMINEE, SHEPARD M. GOLDBERG, WILL BE A MUCH NEEDED VOICE OF REASON IN THE BOARD ROOM AND WILL REPRESENT THE INTERESTS OF ALL ECHO STOCKHOLDERS -Entrepreneur who has been successful in multiple industries: Information Technologies, Biotech, Heating Industry Products and Swimming Pool Industry Pr
Slide 30: Our Nominee Will Add Significant Value to the Board
WE ARE CONFIDENT OUR NOMINEE WILL ADD SIGNIFICANT VALUE TO THE BOARD AND WILL REPRESENT THE INTERESTS OF ALL STOCKHOLDERS Shepard M. Goldberg ¢Is an accomplished businessman with a broad range of business experiences and insight «Is an advocate for the interests of all stockholders, and will forcefu
Slide 31: A Leading Analyst Agrees with Platinum
LIFETECH CAPITALNOTE 4/24/14 What this Means to Investors: “We believe that Platinum, as Echo’s largest shareholder, is more closely aligned with shareholder interests than current management. The severe decline in stock price, the need to developa GEN2 system in order to begin U.S. trials and a pla
Slide 32: Analyst Also Says Proxy Battle Is Last Chance for Investors
ANALYST ALSO SAYS... “PROXY BATTLE IS LAST CHANCE FOR INVESTORS ON MAY 28tH LIFETECH CAPITALALSO STATED, “Echo Board Remains Tone-Deaf: We note with some irony that after a disastrous 2 years where Echo’s stock declined 95% due to multiple poorly executed financings, including an incredibly ill-time
Slide 33: Platinum's Immediate Goals in Restoring Value to Echo
PLATINUM’S IMMEDIATE GOALS IN RESTORING VALUE TO ECHO Immediately find a new and permanent CEO. We publicly urged this Board to find a new CEO back in August of 2013, which they acknowledged was underway. Nine months later there is still no CEO. And, in fact, only two months ago, Echo admitted to ha
Slide 34: Echo's Misleading Proxy Campaign
We believein an effort to mislead shareholders, Echo has called into question the veracity and truthfulness of many of our ideas and statements and would have stockholders believe that we have not been genuine in our concerns. Nothing could be further from the truth! WE BELIEVE THE ECHO BOARD’S MISL
Slide 35: Do Not Be Misled by Echo!
DO NOT BE MISLED BY ECHO! ecHoclam = [Rear “THE PLATINUMGROUP WANTS YOUTO Exactly. We are a long-term committed investor in BELIEVE THAT ITS GOAL IS TO Echo having made our first investmentin the Company MAXIMIZE VALUE FOR ALL in 2007. Since then we have invested more than STOCKHOLDERS” $18.6M into
Slide 36: Do Not Be Misled by Echo!
DO NOT BE MISLED BY ECHO! ECHO CLAIM ‘THE PLATINUM GROUP WANTS YOU TO BELIEVE THAT IT HAS PROVIDED IDEAS TO ECHO THAT COULD UNLOCK VALUE FOR STOCKHOLDERS.” “THE PLATINUM GROUP WANTS YOU TO BELIEVE THAT ITS INTERESTS ARE FULLY ALIGNED WITH THE INTERESTS OF ALL OTHER STOCKHOLDERS” Yes, we haye. The re
Slide 37: Do Not Be Misled by Echo!
DO NOT BE MISLED BY ECHO! ECHO CLAIM “On that date, [June 10, 2013], as outlinedin the Platinum Group's proxy, members of the Platinum Group sold a totalof 121,041 shares, or 30% of the shares traded that day. Those members of the Platinum Group made sixty (60) separatetrades, including numerous sma
Slide 38: Conclusion
CONCLUSION LET’S END THE ERA OF UNDERPERFORMANCE AT ECHO THERAPEUTICS. WE URGE ALL ECHO STOCKHOLDERS TO VOTE THE GOLD PROXY CARD FOR REAL CHANGE NOW AT ECHO THERAPEUTICS. THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. 36