Argonaut Group Inc

Argonaut — KBW Insurance Conference 2007

34 slides from Argonaut's conference presentation, Sep 5, 2007

  1. Slide 1: KBW Insurance Conference

    7) Group, KBW Insurance Conference September 4, 2007

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements

    rd —=— Looking Statements This presentation contains “forward-looking statements’ which are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. The forward-looking statements are based on the Company's current expectations and beliefs concerning futur

  3. Slide 3: The Argo Group Story

    Vee = —— The Argo Group Story Dpse son The Company e Argo Group is an international specialty underwriter of property/casualty insurance focused on niche markets The Objective e To maintain our profitable growth record as we integrate our largest business combination to date The Strategy e Apply our

  4. Slide 4: Agenda

    rs AGENDA Growing an International Specialty Underwriter Successful Three Business Business Model Units Specialty underwriter in niche markets

  5. Slide 5: Argo Group Today

    i i Argo Group Today e Specialty underwriter in attractive niche areas of property, casualty insurance and reinsurance e Headquarters: Bermuda — operates in 50 states and internationally e Market Cap over $1B e Three ongoing business segments - Excess and Surplus Lines (E&S) — Select Markets — Inter

  6. Slide 6: Four-step growth strategy

    he 3. Expand position — organically — selective acquisitions 1. Target attractive niche markets 4, Results: Growth in premiums and earnings 2. Develop leading, differentiated positions

  7. Slide 7: 1. Attractive Niche Markets

    - teres 1. ATTRACTIVE NICHE MARKETS A Different Type of Approach Sustained, profitable organic growth Disciplined underwriting Market leadership in a reasonable time frame Higher margin, return

  8. Slide 8: 2. Develop Leadership Positions

    rs \ is a. 2. DEVELOP LEADERSHIP POSITIONS Examples of Leadership Positions P/C insurance for independent grocery stores Workers’ compensation for coal mines in Pennsylvania and Maryland Insurance for retail fabricare industry Commercial insurance for small / medium public entities E&S market positi

  9. Slide 9: 3. Expand Position

    ie \ Shares -8 3. EXPAND POSITION A Solid Record of Disciplined Growth 2006 Revenues* “Argonaut Group Only New Businesses Last Six Years Businesses acquired: * Colony ¢ Rockwood Assets acquired: © Interstate ‘Grocers * Coregis Fulcrum New businesses launched: © Public Entity Argonaut Specialty Organ

  10. Slide 10: 4. Results: Growth

    i om 4. RESULTS: GROWTH An Impressive Growth Record... Gross Written Premiums* Total Assets* $1.2B $3.7B CAGR _— $1.9B $272M 2001 2006 2001 “Argonaut Group Results Only

  11. Slide 11: Continuing Improvement in Profitability

    Pree 4. RESULTS: GROWTH ... With Continuing Improvement in Profitability Combined Ratio 104% *97% *96% 94% 2003 2004 2005 2006 + Exclusive of losses from hurricane activity ‘Argonaut Group Results Only

  12. Slide 12: Agenda

    i NN AGENDA Growing an International Specialty Underwriter Three Business niche markets

  13. Slide 13: Three Growth Platforms

    i i Three Growth Platforms Argo Group. INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS, LTO, Excess & Surplus Lines* Select Markets* International Specialty GWP $762M GWP $392M New Bermuda- © Operating Income © Operating Income based platform up 77% up 33% "Argonaut Group ~ 2006 Results

  14. Slide 14: Three Growth Platforms: Excess & Surplus Lines

    i ao ——— Three Growth Platforms 7) are Group, Excess & Surplus Lines* GWP $762M © Operating Income up 77% "Argonaut Group ~ 2006 Results

  15. Slide 15: Excess & Surplus Lines: Largest and Most Profitable Segment

    2. am = Excess & Surplus Lines: Largest and Most Profitable Segment Status @ Combined ratio of 88.9% e Colony & Argonaut Specialty Competitive advantages e Excellent infrastructure e Underwriting expertise e Controlled distribution Rated ‘A’ (Excellent) by A.M. Best Pre-Tax Operating Income (sm) $10

  16. Slide 16: Three Growth Platforms: Select Markets

    BAX zi oe. ——— = Three Growth Platforms | Select Markets* GWP $392M © Operating Income up 33% "Argonaut Group ~ 2006 Results

  17. Slide 17: Select Markets: Consistently Profitable Segment

    ee. Select Markets: ie Consistently Profitable Segment Status @ Combined ratio of 89.4% e Primarily retail-driven Competitive advantages e Expertise in niche markets — grocery stores — mining operations — laundry & dry cleaners — small/medium-size public entities Pre-Tax Operating Income (sm) $50 $3

  18. Slide 18: Group's Six-Month Results

    Group’s Six-Month Results Gross Written Premium $ 564M $ 528M Net Earned Premium $ 416M $ 400M Total Revenue $ 476M $ 453M Underwriting Income $ 24M * $ 20M Net Investment Income $57M $ 50M Operating Income $74M*" -$ ~63M * Excludes approximately $10.2 million (pre-tax) of non-cash compensation expe

  19. Slide 19: Three Growth Platforms: International Specialty

    BN ao ——— Three Growth Platforms 7) Group, International Specialty ¢ New Bermuda- based platform "Argonaut Group ~ 2006 Results

  20. Slide 20: Acquisition and Creation of Peleus

    Acquisition and Creation of Peleus Immediate Strengths ° A-rating by AM. Best e Appointed Andrew Carrier as Peleus president — Proven record of leadership — Built diversified books of business e Utilize established infrastructure e Well positioned for January 1, 2008 renewals

  21. Slide 21: Combined Business Mix

    BN Combined Business Mix Sd) Pgonauit Group @direes Specialty Insurance International Specialty e Excess & Surplus Lines e Select Markets Quota share reinsurance of business partners e Property reinsurance ~15% | « Prospective insurance opportunities

  22. Slide 22: Pro Forma Combined Balance Sheet

    Argonaut Group, agp argo Groun Assets Acquired Pro Forma’) Investment Portfolio $2,613.1 $1,009.6 $3,622.7 Total Assets 3,849.5 1,168.7 5,005.4 Reserves 2113.4 425.3 2,537.4 Stockholders’ Equity 860.2 476.1 1,304.7 Indebtedness 144.3 167.1 368.50) Total Capital 1,004.5 643.2 1,673.2 Book Value Per S

  23. Slide 23: Minimal Sub-prime Exposure

    Minimal Sub-prime Exposure Total Argo Group Investment Portfolio - $3.6 billion e Sub-prime/Alt-A Exposure only 2.5% of total portfolio * Total exposure approx. $94 million + 46% Alt-A / 54% Sub-prime * 99% are AAA or AA rated = < $1 million A rated = None rated below A * 34% are 2006 Vintage, all A

  24. Slide 24: A Perfect Strategic Fit

    Vee —— A Perfect Strategic Fit KA New business lines > enhances product offering and diversification KA Strengthens competitive position vs. specialty underwriters KA Financial flexibility > more effective capital management KA Increased capacity to grow

  25. Slide 25: Agenda

    i AGENDA = Growing an International Specialty Underwriter Decen JArgo Group, Growth and Profitability

  26. Slide 26: Four-step growth strategy

    3. Expand position — organically — selective acquisitions 1. Target attractive niche markets 4. Results: Growth in premiums and earnings 2. Develop leading, differentiated positions

  27. Slide 27: Capital Deployment Strategy

    Vee a. = Capital Deployment Strategy — Next 18 Months e Deploy capital opportunistically across all three segments — M&A — International Specialty — Reduce reliance on third-party reinsurance e Selective acquisitions of books of business and companies e Reduce capital related to legacy businesses

  28. Slide 28: Our Focus: Continuing to Improve ROE

    Our Focus: Continuing to Improve ROE 13.3% 13.3% 2004 2005 2006 Goal gorau roup Rests Ony fA s

  29. Slide 29: In Summary

    IN SUMMARY A Stronger and Better Positioned Specialty Underwriter e Proven and successful business model — impressive growth, profitability and strong cash flow e Acquisition creates powerful competitive force in specialty lines market - Bermuda platform advantages, further diversified mix, position

  30. Slide 30: Thank you

    7) Group, KBW Insurance Conference Thank you

  31. Slide 31: Addendum

    7) Group, KBW Insurance Conference Addendum

  32. Slide 32: Acquisition and Creation of Peleus: Transaction Highlights

    Acquisition and Creation of Peleus Transaction Highlights Structure e Reverse merger of Argonaut into PXRE e Each Argonaut share exchanged for 6.484 shares of PXRE $57M one-time pre-closing dividend to Argonaut shareholders Ownership e Shareholders: 73% Argonaut, 27% PXRE New Business Lines e New Be

  33. Slide 33: Attractive to All Shareholders

    Attractive to All Shareholders Accretive Accretive to market price to book value 16% per share 18% per share Percentages calculated on date of merger agreement

  34. Slide 34: Thank you!

    7) Group, Thank you!

Argonaut Group — KBW Insurance Conference 2007 on 6ix