Chiquita Brands International Inc
Chiquita Brands International — Proxy Contest (September 2014)
28 slides from Chiquita Brands International's proxy contest presentation, Sep 23, 2014
Slide 1: Cutrale-Safra Proposal to Acquire Chiquita Brands International: Shareholder Presentation
CUTRALE-SAFRA PROPOSAL TO ACQUIRE CHIQUITA BRANDS INTERNATIONAL: SHAREHOLDER PRESENTATION SEPTEMBER 2014
Slide 2: The Cutrale-Safra Proposal Is Superior and Preserves Chiquita Shareholders' Optionality
THE CUTRALE-SAFRA PROPOSAL IS SUPERIOR AND PRESERVES CHIQUITA SHAREHOLDERS’ OPTIONALITY 1 Cash certain, highly compelling premium and record high multiple: The Cutrale-Safra proposal is all cash and represents a 29% premium to CQB’s unaffected closing price(1). At 11.8x, the proposal offers Chiquita
Slide 3: Chiquita Shareholders Should Vote the GOLD Card
CHIQUITA SHAREHOLDERS SHOULD: Vote the GOLD card to have the opportunity to realize superior value for your Chiquita shares Vote AGAINST the Fyffes transaction proposal and the related Fyffes proposals Vote FOR an adjournment proposal brought by Chiquita at the October 3 Special Meeting, which adjou
Slide 4: 1. Cash certain, highly compelling premium and record high multiple
1. Cash certain, highly compelling premium and record high multiple
Slide 5: Cutrale and Safra Group: Natural Owners of Chiquita
CUTRALE AND SAFRA GROUP: NATURAL OWNERS OF CHIQUITA Cutrale Group Global leader in orange juice processing, accounting for over one-third of the $5 billion orange juice market Global business operations include oranges, apples, peaches, lemons and soybeans Expertise and experience across fruit and j
Slide 6: $13.00 Per Share Represents an Attractive Premium Compared to Public Precedents
$13.00 PER SHARE REPRESENTS AN ATTRACTIVE PREMIUM COMPARED TO OTHER PUBLIC PRECEDENTS Parameters Time period: January 1, 1999 - August 26, 2014 Transaction enterprise value: $750 mm - $1.5 bn / all-cash Total transactions screened(1): 331 PREMIUM VS. UNAFFECTED PRICE Cutrale-Safra Proposal 29.2% 23.
Slide 7: The Cutrale-Safra Proposal Provides a Record High Multiple
THE CUTRALE-SAFRA PROPOSAL PROVIDES A RECORD HIGH MULTIPLE The Cutrale-Safra proposal has the highest comparable transaction multiple for an acquisition of this scale in the fresh produce sector The Cutrale-Safra proposal provides an 11.8x multiple of Chiquita’s last twelve months reported Adjusted
Slide 8: $13.00 Per Share Is a Superior Price on a Standalone Basis
$13.00 PER SHARE IS AN UNQUESTIONABLY SUPERIOR AND COMPELLING PRICE FOR CHIQUITA ON A STANDALONE BASIS 1 $10.84: Unaffected price prior to announcement of Fyffes combination (3/7/14) 2 $10.06: Unaffected price prior to announcement of Cutrale-Safra proposal (8/8/14) 1 2 $13.00 Offer Price per share
Slide 9: 2. Risk free option to explore best offer
2. Risk free option to explore best offer
Slide 10: The Adjournment Proposal Preserves Optionality for Chiquita Shareholders
THE ADJOURNMENT PROPOSAL PRESERVES OPTIONALITY FOR CHIQUITA SHAREHOLDERSCutrale-Safra will support Chiquita’s motion for adjournment at the October 3 Special Meeting so long as the adjournment will be for 14 days or 21 days, at Chiquita’s option, except that the adjournment will be for 21 days if Cu
Slide 11: 3. Superior to the proposed Fyffes combination
3. Superior to the proposed Fyffes combination
Slide 12: Chiquita Management's 2014E Sales Estimates Imply Optimistic Second Half Results
CHIQUITA MANAGEMENT’S 2014E SALES ESTIMATES IMPLY HIGHLY OPTIMISTIC SECOND HALF RESULTS . . . CHIQUITA 2014E SALES BRIDGE ($ in millions) $762 $826 $1,588 $1,637 $3,225 Q1 Q2 H1 2014A Required H2 Performance 2014E sales forecast HISTORICAL H2 SALES ($ in millions) $1,503 $1,444 $1,451 $1,473 11% $1,
Slide 13: Second Half EBITDA Estimates Deviate Sharply from Historical Results
. . . AND SECOND HALF EBITDA ESTIMATES DEVIATE SHARPLY FROM HISTORICAL RESULTS AS WELL CHIQUITA 2014E EBITDA BRIDGE ($ in millions) $23 $62 $85 $55 $140 Q1 Q2 H1 2014A Required H2 Performance 2014E EBITDA forecast HISTORICAL H2 EBITDA AND MARGINS ($ in millions) $26 $19 $0 $22 $55 1.7% 1.3% 0.0% 1.5
Slide 14: Grounding Fyffes' 2016E EBITDA Estimates in Reality
GROUNDING FYFFES’ 2016E EBITDA ESTIMATES IN REALITY AS PRESENTED IN FYFFES INVESTOR PRESENTATION DATED 9/17/14 ($ in millions) $140 $15 $20 $62 $40 $20 $21 $318 Chiquita 2014E EBITDA Chiquita Gulf Shipping Savings Salad Business Improvement Fyffes 2014E EBITDA Synergies New Synergies Announced Organ
Slide 15: Illustrative PV Future Share Price Analysis - Reality
ILLUSTRATIVE PV FUTURE SHARE PRICE ANALYSIS - REALITY Analysis presented in Fyffes investor presentation dated 9/17/14 re-run with historically grounded Chiquita 2014E EBITDA of $130 million and reasonable EV/EBITDA multiples $13.00 PV of share price requires a 8.6x blended LTM EBITDA multiple, ~27%
Slide 16: Chiquita Has Frequently Missed Wall Street Expectations
CHIQUITA HAS FREQUENTLY MISSED WALL STREET EXPECTATIONS WALL STREET EBITDA ESTIMATES VERSUS ACTUAL ($ in millions) Actual 31% below consensus $207 $195 $138 2011 Actual 54% below consensus $145 $156 $70 2012 Actual 27% below consensus $154 $171 $118 2013 Janney Montgomery Scott BB&T Capital Markets
Slide 17: Proposal Provides a Significant Premium to Market Value of the Fyffes Combination
CUTRALE-SAFRA PROPOSAL PROVIDES A SIGNIFICANT PREMIUM TO THE MARKET VALUE OF THE PROPOSED FYFFES COMBINATION $15.00 $14.00 $13.00 $12.00 $11.00 $10.00 $9.00 Mar-14 Apr-14 May-14 Jul-14 Aug-14 Sep-14 Trading price affected by Chiquita-Fyffes proposal 4/29/2014: Market reacts negatively to new disclos
Slide 18: A Closer Look at the Premium Paid to Fyffes
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE PREMIUM PAID TO FYFFES ILLUSTRATIVE ANALYSIS AS PER GOLDMAN SACHS FAIRNESS OPINION (1) (US$ in millions) Low High Illustrative Chiquita DCF value indications $491 $653 Illustrative Fyffes DCF value indications 367 424 Total synergies value indications 222 254 Total combined DCF
Slide 19: A Faulty Sale Process Destructive to Shareholder Value
A FAULTY SALE PROCESS DESTRUCTIVE TO SHAREHOLDER VALUE Chiquita’s Board proposes to pay Fyffes shareholders a significant premium to allow Fyffes management to manage the combined business Market reaction demonstrates investors believe Fyffes received a bargain Neither Cutrale nor Safra was ever con
Slide 20: 4. Proposed Fyffes combination dilutes Chiquita production capability and creates shareholder risk
4. Proposed Fyffes combination dilutes Chiquita production capability, concentrates sales in harder markets and otherwise creates shareholder risk
Slide 21: Fyffes Combination Dilutes Chiquita Production Capability and Creates Shareholder Risk
PROPOSED FYFFES COMBINATION DILUTES CHIQUITA PRODUCTION CAPABILITY, CONCENTRATES SALES IN HARDER MARKETS AND OTHERWISE CREATES SHAREHOLDER RISK CHIQUITA HISTORICALLY HAS TRADED AT A PREMIUM MULTIPLE VS. FYFFES, BUT THEIR COMBINATION WOULD ERODE THIS ADVANTAGE QUICKLY 1 Dilution of Chiquita productio
Slide 22: Market Share Drives Shareholder Value
MARKET SHARE DRIVES SHAREHOLDER VALUE Multinational trading companies, and in particular the three largest banana traders (Chiquita, Dole and Fresh Del Monte), have historically played a major role in the international banana trade Their influence over the banana trade has diminished since they dive
Slide 23: Land Ownership Is a Key Component of Banana Valuation
LAND OWNERSHIP IS A KEY COMPONENT OF BANANA VALUATION EV/EBITDA(1): 5.8x Sourced 62% Owned Production 38% 4.5x Sourced 100% 6.4x Sourced 59% Owned Production 41% ChiquitaFyffes Owned Production 23% Sourced 77% 6.4x(1) Sourced 53% Owned Production 47% Chiquita’s major competitors have varying degree
Slide 24: Fyffes Is Disadvantaged as a Middleman, as Reflected in Its Trading Multiple
1 FYFFES IS DISADVANTAGED AS A MIDDLEMAN, AS REFLECTED IN ITS TRADING MULTIPLE Fyffes used to own plantations in Jamaica, Belize and the Windward Islands, but withdrew from most banana production and switched to purchasing its bananas through contracts with producers, becoming a middleman Since that
Slide 25: Exposure to European Volatility
2 EXPOSURE TO EUROPEAN VOLATILITY The North American market provides more stable and predictable revenue compared to the European markets as Chiquita points out: “In North America, we most often sell bananas and related services under one-year contracts to national and regional grocery retailers. Th
Slide 26: Conclusion
Conclusion
Slide 27: The Cutrale-Safra Proposal Is Superior and Preserves Optionality
THE CUTRALE-SAFRA PROPOSAL IS SUPERIOR AND PRESERVES CHIQUITA SHAREHOLDERS’ OPTIONALITY 1 Cash certain, highly compelling premium and record high multiple for the sector 2 Risk free option to explore best offer 3 Unquestionably superior to the proposed Fyffes combination 4 Proposed Fyffes combinatio
Slide 28: Important Disclosure Information
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURE INFORMATION Cavendish Global Limited and Cavendish Acquisition Corporation, which are jointly owned by an affiliate of the Cutrale Group, Burlingtown UK LTD (“Burlingtown”), and an affiliate of the Safra Group, Erichton Investments Ltd. (“Erichton” and, together with Burlingtown
Chiquita Brands International — Proxy Contest (September 2014) on 6ix