CBIZ, Inc. · NYSE:CBZ
CBIZ — Investor Presentation (July 2011)
39 slides from CBIZ's investor presentation, Jul 20, 2011
Slide 1: Don't Be Held Captive: Go Captive to Manage Your Risk and Expenses
Don’t Be Held Captive: Go Captive to Manage Your Risk and Expenses Presented by Stuart Anolik, Esq. Managing Director, CBIZ MHM, LLC.
Slide 2: Strategic Edge Series
Strategic Edge Series • Seven Core Principles to Maximize the Value of Your Business During Its Life and Upon its Sale – May 18th • Creative Compensation Strategies to Maintain Morale and Retain Talent – June 22nd • Don’t Be Held Captive: Go Captive to Manage Your Risk and Expenses – July 20th • Fed
Slide 3: Agenda
Agenda 1. Introduction to Captive Insurance 2. Why CBIZ 3. Tax Issues Related to Captive Insurance 4. Opportunities
Slide 4: Definition of a Captive
Definition of a Captive “An insurance company owned and controlled by its policy holders.”
Slide 5: Captive Illustration
Captive Illustration Owner Premiums Operating Business Captive Insurance (“Insured”) Company (“Captive”) Insurance Policies
Slide 6: CBIZ MHM Captive Insurance Services
CBIZ MHM Captive Insurance Services CBIZ MHM is uniquely qualified to provide “turn-key” consulting services in regard to captive insurance as a result of its expertise in (i) accounting and tax for captive insurance companies through its Financial Services group and (ii) property and casualty insur
Slide 7: Captive Benefits
Captive Benefits •Reduced Insurance Costs: •Retention of underwriting profits •Claims Settlement •Casualty premiums are deductible •Self-insurance is funded with after-tax dollars. •Risk Management: •Customized coverages. •Not available in commercial markets •Overly expensive •Claims Management •Wea
Slide 8: How Does Captive Insurance work?
How Does Captive Insurance work? Independent actuary determines premiums Independent actuary underwrites coverages Generally, casualty premiums are tax deductible Owner directs investments Insured submits claims to captive Captive controls claims management and settlement Owner retains underwriting
Slide 9: Examples of Non Traditional Risks
Examples of Non Traditional Risks Accounts Receivable Loss of key customer Administrative actions Loss of key employee Business interruption Loss of key supplier Deductibles/Exclusions Mold Earthquake Product recalls/warranty Intellectual Property Subcontractor default Litigation expenses Terrorism
Slide 10: Tax Implications
Tax Implications • Insurance companies, including Stand Alone Captives – Anticipated loss reserves (subject to certain discounts) allowed as a deduction against underwriting income and investment income • Small P&C Companies – Have up to $1,200,000 Premiums. Are taxed on investment income and NOT un
Slide 11: Key Issue: Premium Deductibility
Key Issue: Premium Deductibility Treas. Reg. Section 1.162-1(a): Business expenses deductible from gross income included the ordinary and necessary expenditures directly connected with the taxpayer’s trade or business. Among the items included in business expenses are advertising and other selling
Slide 12: Risk Shifting and Distribution
Risk Shifting and Distribution • Risk Shifting- the transfer of the risk to separate party • Risk Distribution- enough independent risks are being pooled to invoke the “actuarial law of large numbers” (e.g., spread risk among a large group)
Slide 13: Risk Shifting
Risk Shifting • Risk shifting occurs if a person facing the possibility of an economic loss transfers some or all of the financial consequences of the potential loss to the insurer, such that a loss by the insured does not affect the insured because the loss is offset by the insurance payment • IRS
Slide 14: Risk Distribution
Risk Distribution Pooling of Premiums – Risk distribution entails a pooling of premiums, so that a potential insured is not in significant part paying for its own risks – When a company “insures” unrelated risks, the arrangement constitutes insurance if a significant percentage of unrelated risks ex
Slide 15: IRS's Historical Position - The Economic Family Doctrine
IRS’s Historical Position - The Economic Family Doctrine • Rev. Rul. 77-316, IRS position that risk shifting and distribution do not exist in the context of a single economic family (i.e., parent-subsidiary) • Exception: In Rev. Rul. 78-338, the IRS conceded that sufficient risk shifting and distrib
Slide 16: Revenue Ruling 2002-89 Unrelated Risk Ruling
Revenue Ruling 2002-89 Unrelated Risk Ruling • Single parent captive otherwise properly formed and operated (adequate capital, no parent guarantees, loan backs, etc.) • Not “insurance” if 90% of risks/premiums come from the parent • “Insurance” if less than 50% come from the parent and the remainder
Slide 17: Revenue Ruling 2002-90 IRS Sibling Ruling
Revenue Ruling 2002-90 IRS Sibling Ruling • Single parent captive otherwise properly formed and operated (adequate capital, no parent guarantees, loan backs, etc.) • Insures 12 domestic subs - parent a holding company; no sub accounts for less than 5% or over 15% of total risk/premium • “Insurance”
Slide 18: Revenue Ruling 2002-91 – Group Captive Ruling
Revenue Ruling 2002-91 – Group Captive Ruling Facts: • Industry group liability captive; exact number of participants not specified • No member owns over 15%; has over 15% of vote; or accounts for over 15% of risk/premium; implies 7 equal owners OK • No assessments or refunds IRS Holding: Captive co
Slide 19: Revenue Ruling 2005-40
Revenue Ruling 2005-40 • In Ruling 2005-40, the IRS gave four situations showing specific examples of what did or did not represent insurance – In situation 1, the IRS said there was no insurance if there is only one insured – The same is true if there are two insureds - - one of which has at least
Slide 20: Caveats
Caveats The captive must still establish: • Presence of risk distribution • That the captive should be respected as a separate and distinct taxable entity, i.e., it is not a sham
Slide 21: Non-Sham Status
Non-Sham Status • Insurance status continues to require respect for the captive as an entity separate and distinct from its economic family: – Valid non-tax business purpose – Adequate capitalization – No parental support agreements – Limited loan backs of captive assets to parent or affiliates (“ci
Slide 22: Notice 2005-49
Notice 2005-49 • In Notice 2005–49, the IRS asked for public comment on: “the circumstances under which qualification of an arrangement between related parties as insurance may be affected by a loan back of the amounts paid as ‘premiums’.”
Slide 23: Notice 2005-49
Notice 2005-49 • The comments state that if each of these four factors are present in a loan back, there is insurance (if insurance otherwise exists): – Bona fide indebtedness (enforceable; reasonable terms and rates; appropriate security) – Permitted or approved by the regulators – Sufficient liqui
Slide 24: Notice 2005-49
Notice 2005-49 • If less than all four factors are present, the comments state that the facts and circumstances must be reviewed to determine if the investment function undermines the essence of insurance
Slide 25: Cell Company Structure
Cell Company Structure POOLED LAYER - CORE CAPITAL Cell A Cell B Cell C Cell D
Slide 26: Cell Captives-Revenue Ruling 2008-8
Cell Captives-Revenue Ruling 2008-8 IRS guidance of when a cell of a protected cell company can enter into a transaction which is treated as insurance for federal income tax purposes, and when amounts paid to these cells is deductible as “insurance premiums” under Section 162. Example 1: X, a corp
Slide 27: Cell Captives-Revenue Ruling 2008-8
Cell Captives-Revenue Ruling 2008-8 Example 2: Y, a corporation, owns all stock of Cell Y, as well as all the stock of 12 subsidiaries. (Mirrors facts of Rev. Rul. 2002-90). The 12 subs have a significant volume of independent, homogenous risks, insured into Cell Y. No sub has coverage for less than
Slide 28: Captive Insurance Companies – IRS Notice 2008-19
Captive Insurance Companies – IRS Notice 2008-19 Notice 2008-19 requests comments on further guidance to address issues that arise if those arrangements do constitute insurance The Notice provides guidance that would address (a) when a cell of a Protected Cell Company is treated as an insurance
Slide 29: IRS Notice 2008-19
IRS Notice 2008-19 Effect of insurance company treatment at the cell level under the proposed rule: • Any tax elections that are available by reason of a cell’s status as an insurance company would be made by the cell; • The cell would be required to receive an employer identification number (EIN) i
Slide 30: Internal Revenue Bulletin: 2010-45 - Series LLC
Internal Revenue Bulletin: 2010-45 - November 8, 2010 - Series LLC IRS issued proposed regulations regarding the classification for Federal tax purposes of a series of a domestic series limited liability company (LLC), a cell of a domestic cell company, or a foreign series or cell that conducts an i
Slide 31: Foreign Captives
Foreign Captives • A Foreign Captive pays US Income Taxes. – Sec. 953(c)(3)(C) and(d) election • If the Captive is an offshore domiciled insurance company a Sec. 953(d) election to be taxed as a US Insurance Company may be made. It has these advantages: – Captive is NOT a Controlled Foreign Corporat
Slide 32: Estate Planning Opportunities
Estate Planning Opportunities • Initial Presumptions: – The fundamental presumption in captive insurance planning is that the client has substantial non-tax insurance needs that can be satisfied by a captive without regard to any potential tax benefits. – Thus, captives must serve a valid business p
Slide 33: Estate Planning Opportunities
Estate Planning Opportunities Family Creates and funds Dynasty trust Trust Client Independent Trustee Build up in value benefits trust. Unused Trustee uses trust funds reserves can be to create and capitalize distributed to trust as captive as sole owner dividends. Captive Client Company Pays premiu
Slide 34: Estate Planning Opportunities
Estate Planning Opportunities • Potential Transfer Tax Benefits: – Reasonable premiums paid by the insured to the captive should not create gift, estate or GST tax exposure to the insured’s owner. • The premiums, however, must constitute full and adequate consideration for insurance coverage (e.g.,
Slide 35: Why CBIZ
Why CBIZ • CBIZ MHM has both the insurance expertise through its Employee Services (which includes our Property and Casualty professionals as well as the tax and accounting expertise to provide clients with fully integrated and seamless captive insurance services that are truly “turn-key” • Courtney
Slide 36: Summary/Key Takeaways
Summary/Key Takeaways • Captive insurance solutions provides mid sized companies the benefits of maintaining underwriting profit in its group, control over risk management matters, control over claims management, thus creating potential significant savings in its costs of insurance • Captive insuran
Slide 37: Questions?
ea a) QUESTIONS?
Slide 38: CBIZ MHM, LLC Contacts
CBIZ MHM, LLC Contacts Stuart Anolik Managing Director 301.951.3636 sanolik@cbiz.com
Slide 39: Thank You
Sy OMI - Bx Thank You ° « our business is growing yours