Certara, Inc. · NASDAQ:CERT

Certara — Technical Presentation (August 2014)

29 slides from Certara's technical presentation, Aug 11, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Remarkable Predictions using Template CoMFA

    Remarkable Predictions using Template CoMFA Richard D. Cramer August 11, 2014

  2. Slide 2: True Predictions for a random half of ChEMBL's facXa

    True Predictions: for a random half of ChEMBL’s facXa .. from a single CoMFA model SDEP = 1.14 n = 1907 © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  3. Slide 3: Diversity of ChEMBL factorXa structures

    Diversity of ChEMBL factorXa structures Twenty random structures 267 publications 1339 “reduced skeletons” >100 assay protocols © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  4. Slide 4: Template CoMFA blends 3D-QSAR setup approaches

    Template CoMFA blends 3D-QSAR setup approaches By using overlaid 2D Test Set 3D templates 3D structures (from (Predictions!) X-ray, pharmacophore, ??) as templates Template CoMFA 2D Training Set Aligned (3D) CoMFA Training Set model Cramer, R. D.; Wendt, B. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2014, 54, 660-671. ©

  5. Slide 5: The factor Xa experimental data

    The factor Xa experimental data From bindingdb From ChEMBL 12 templates (.pdb references) Goal: 270 training SAR Predict ChEMBL (analogs of the (3900+ usable) templates) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 5

  6. Slide 6: factorXa predictions (training set = bindingdb SAR)

    factorXa predictions (with training set = bindingdb SAR) Cramer, R. D.; Wendt, B. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2014, 54, 660-671. bindingDB 12 .pdb 270 2D SAR q2=.577 / SDEP=.86 Goal: Predict ChEMBL SDEP = 1.74 (3900+ usable) Not so good! © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  7. Slide 7: Factor Xa (training set = random half of ChEMBL)

    Factor Xa (with training set = random half of ChEMBL) bindingDB 12 .pdb ChEMBL Training Set => CoMFA model (q2=.381/ sdep =1.15) SDEP = 1.14 n = 1907 Test Set © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  8. Slide 8: A second target: Checkpoint kinase predictions

    A second target: Checkpoint kinase 1 predictions SDEP=1.46 SDEP=1.14 Training set from bindingdb SAR Training set = half ChEMBL But a third target, carbonic anhydrase II, did not work (no model from ChEMBL) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  9. Slide 9: Template CoMFA has very broad scope

    Template CoMFA has very broad scope All 74 targets in bindingdb.org referencing more than one .pdb Cramer, R. D. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2014, DOI: 10.1021/ci500230a. © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  10. Slide 10: What might this unexpected prediction success mean?

    What might this unexpected prediction success mean? Very surprising! bindingDB 12 .pdb Training Set => CoMFA model (q2=.381 / sdep =1.15) SDEP = 1.14 ChEMBL n = 1907 Not surprising .. but.. Test Set Representative of “all small mol space”? © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  11. Slide 11: Fundamentals of Template CoMFA

    Fundamentals of Template CoMFA • Theory: The primary cause of potency differences among (non-covalently acting) ligands is steric and electrostatic field differences. • Observation: When the goal is an informative comparison of ligand field differences, increasing ligand shape similarity seems at le

  12. Slide 12: Many templates – how is the one best match chosen?

    Many templates – how is the one “best match” chosen? • “Best match” == best “anchor bond” pairing – The best anchor bond pairing maximizes the size of anchor-bond-rooted branches having “similar” atoms – To be considered, a possible anchor bond must be “interesting” – The “best match” search is exha

  13. Slide 13: Factor Xa inhibitors having .pdb references in bindingdb (2D)

    Factor Xa inhibitors having .pdb references in bindingdb (2D) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  14. Slide 14: The only 3D info: the overlaid factor Xa templates

    The only 3D info: the 12 overlaid factor Xa templates © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  15. Slide 15: .pdb Template #10 with some ChEMBL homologues (2D)

    .pdb Template #10 with some ChEMBL homologues (2D) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 15

  16. Slide 16: .pdb Template #10 with some ChEMBL homologues (3D)

    .pdb Template #10 with some ChEMBL homologues (3D) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 16

  17. Slide 17: ChEMBL Non-homologues aligned to .pdb Template #10 (2D)

    ChEMBL Non-homologues aligned to .pdb Template #10 (2D) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 17

  18. Slide 18: ChEMBL Non-homologues aligned to .pdb Template #10 (3D)

    ChEMBL Non-homologues aligned to .pdb Template #10 (3D) © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 18

  19. Slide 19: What might this capability be good for?

    What might this capability be good for? 1. Are so many training set structures needed? 2. Is there any way to put confidence limits around an individual prediction? 3. But crystal structures are not available for many important biological targets? © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  20. Slide 20: Much smaller (random) training sets do seem useful

    1. Much smaller (random) training sets do seem useful CoMFA stats (ntrng) nTrng nPred ratio SDEP #Cmp q2 SDEP r2 s 1908 1907 1x 1.14 9 0.405 1.13 0.630 0.89 954 2861 3x 1.22 12 0.337 1.20 0.796 0.67 477 3338 7x 1.30 10 0.336 1.22 0.856 0.57 239 3565 15x 1.30 2 0.190 1.31 0.522 1.00 © Copyright 2014

  21. Slide 21: Confidence limits can be tightened with similarity metrics

    2. Confidence limits can be tightened with similarity metrics • Suppose the following project situation (using facXa) – Actual pI50 > 8.65 (one SD > mean pI50) must be avoided – Proposal: if predicted pI50 > 7.2 (mean pI50), no test needed – What is the error rate (false negative)? • Suppose a predi

  22. Slide 22: No X-ray structures?

    3. No X-ray structures? • Ligand-based approaches (pharmacophoric &/or shape) • The pharmacophoric “elephant in the room” – Enormous configurational search space – Criteria for a correct pharmacophore are mostly subjective • A possible objective criterion for a correct pharmacophore ? – obtaining a

  23. Slide 23: Integration of Structure- and Ligand-based Design (chk1)

    Integration of Structure- and Ligand-based Design (chk1) Steric Contours Electrostatic Contours Color coded by electrostatic potential Receptor pocket surfaces © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved. 23

  24. Slide 24: Template CoMFA Attributes

    Template CoMFA Attributes (.. implicit in talk content !!) • TC is a ligand alignment protocol for classical CoMFA that: – As input, only uses 3D template(s) and 2D SAR table, thus providing: • Fast and convenient throughput • Objectively determined models • Application of crystallographic and/or ph

  25. Slide 25: Thanks to everyone who helped!

    Thanks to everyone who helped! • Bernd Wendt for “bleeding edge” trials and feedback • Supervisors who have kept paying me -- mostly to pursue this topomer/self-similarity thing (for over twenty years now) – John McAlister – Jim Hopkins – Dan Weiner – Jim Mahan • Our next speaker – whose dissatisfac

  26. Slide 26: Template CoMFA References

    Template CoMFA References • Cramer, R. D. Template CoMFA applied to 114 Biological Targets. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2014, DOI: 10.1021/ci500230a. • Wendt, B.; Cramer, R. D. Challenging the Gold Standard for 3D-QSAR: Template CoMFA versus X-ray Alignment. J. Comp.-Aided Drug Design, 2014 , accepted. • C

  27. Slide 27: Why is pure shape similarity so productive?

    Why is pure shape similarity so productive? pIC50 Assay should -H 7.2 F be constant.. -F 7.9 The only possible cause of this pIC50 difference is the difference in the fields surrounding F => H – any docking pose change from that field difference is only mechanistic and can be ignored for QSAR purpos

  28. Slide 28: Another random sample of ten training set structures

    Another random sample of ten training set structures .. suppose you only needed to align each of these ten structures to one of those twelve templates .. © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

  29. Slide 29: Template CoMFA Alignments of these 10 Random structures

    Template CoMFA Alignments of these 10 Random structures © Copyright 2014 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.

Certara — Technical Presentation (August 2014) on 6ix