Engelhard Corp

Engelhard — Proxy Contest (May 2006)

32 slides from Engelhard's proxy contest presentation, May 11, 2006

  1. Slide 1: The BASF Offer: Superior value and certainty for Engelhard shareholders

  2. Slide 2: Important Information

    Teer Corea BASF curently intends to solicit proxies for use at Engelhars's 2006 annual meeting of stockholders, ot at any adjournment or postponement thereof, to vote in favor of BASF's nominees identified in the revised preliminary proxy statement on Schedule 14A fled wth the U.S. Securtios and Exc

  3. Slide 3: $38 in cash for 100% of Engelhard shares

    + $38 in cash for 100% of Engelhard shares * Highest bid Engelhard received in a “robust” sales process * No financing risk + All regulatory approvals obtained * Shareholders receive cash within days of Annual Meeting

  4. Slide 4: Cash for only 20% of Engelhard shares

    * Cash for only 20% of Engelhard shares * 80% of shares subject to substantial downside in the stub company + Up to $1.5 billion in new debt (more than double current leverage)

  5. Slide 5: The Annual Meeting is a referendum on certainty

    The Annual Meeting is a referendum on the certainty of BASF’s all cash offer vs. the risk of Engelhard’s highly leveraged recapitalization and 20% share buyback. A vote for BASF’s nominees is a vote in favor of BASF’s all cash offer.

  6. Slide 6: Do you believe that Engelhard can ...

    Do you believe that Engelhard can ... +... deliver on a plan based on growth assumptions far in excess of historical performance and analysts’ expectations? ... fealize and sustain $15 million in annual cost savings in excess of those assumed in current business plan? +... operate the required busin

  7. Slide 7: Extensive due diligence validated BASF's $38 per share offer

    Extensive due diligence validated =<; BASF’s $38 per share offer Teer Corea BASF Due Diligence Process Four week review of electronic data room March/April 2006 Fulkday management presentation March 29, 2006 Numerous expert break-out sessions and MarehApril 2006 conference calls with Engelhard manag

  8. Slide 8: Unrealistic assumptions underpin Engelhard's strategic plan

    Unrealistic assumptions underpin = <=, Engelhard’s strategic plan CAGR of Key Financial Metrics actus Resuts | Arevet [Engst cae 2005-08! 05-105" Revenue (4%) 2% Operating Earnings: Environmental Technologies 1% 10% Process Technologies 3% 6% Appearance & Performance Technologies (4%) 11% Materials

  9. Slide 9: Diluted EPS

    ‘Source: Diluted EPS. $4.50 $4.22) $4.00 $3.50 sano 2001-2005 CAGR: 47% a Aes 808 soma S131 2001 2002 + 2003-2004 ©2005-2006. «2007-2008 «20092010 Diluted EPS for Fiscal Years Ending 12131 3 through 2005 from Engelhard's Annual Report on Form 10-K and thereater from Engelhard'e recapitalization plan

  10. Slide 10: Engelhard's pro forma EPS calculation relies on an understated number of diluted shares

    Engelhard’s pro forma EPS calculation relies =) :.=> on an understated number of diluted shares $280 $250 $2.40 $230 $220 $2.10 $2.00 $1.90 $1.80 Note $255 $2.49 So Cor) s248 Goo) $241 ($0.52) $0.49 201 Wal —Addtonsl Reve Cont SewogeErgshurcs eevee Aduted Pro Incrovend—AdntndPr0 onsoraue Exponee Buy

  11. Slide 11: Engelhard's EPS is highly sensitive to changes in underlying assumptions

    Engelhard’s EPS is highly sensitive to “=>, changes in underlying assumptions EPS Impact | EPS impact Value Driver Sensitivity impac impact Pre-Recap\) | Post-Recap' EBIT margin development (percentage point ——-$0.33 decrease Realization of cost savings $16 million -$0.09 not achieved Natural gas pr

  12. Slide 12: Post recapitalization share price highly sensitive to EPS deviations

    Post recapitalization share price ==> highly sensitive to EPS deviations Teer Corea A $0.10 reduction in pro forma EPS results in a lower blended value of at least $1 per Engelhard share Blended Pro Forma Value) $1.90 $200 $2.10 $2.20 $2.30 $241 $2.48 g 20 2784 2882 2979 3077 3175 3282 3350 ae 13% 2

  13. Slide 13: EPS accretion only achievable through unsubstantiated cost savings

    EPS accretion only achievable through -5s| unsubstantiated cost savings + Engelhard’s recapitalization plan is dilutive to EPS if the recently forecasted incremental annual cost savings of $15 million do not materialize * The forecasted incremental annual cost savings appear convenient under the cir

  14. Slide 14: Shift to highly leveraged environment leaves no margin for error

    Shift to highly leveraged environment =): leaves no margin for error * Post recapitalization, Engelhard’s leverage would be nearly twice that of key competitors in the precious metal based catalyst business * Engelhard shifts from low risk (A3/A- rated) to a high risk leveraged environment (low BBB

  15. Slide 15: Shift to highly leveraged environment leaves no margin for error

    Shift to highly leveraged environment =): -=| leaves no margin for error + Unclear that Engelhard will be able to secure permanent financing at Engelhard’s assumed interest rates - Ina rising interest rate environment - Hybrid securities potentially rated below investment grade - Bridge financing of

  16. Slide 16: A drop below investment grade would have a serious operational impact

    A drop below investment grade would have a serious operational impact on Engelhard + Impairs ability to procure metals for clients (an important service rendered by its chief competitors) via its Materials Services business unit - Greater counterparty risk - Increased financing costs - Potential col

  17. Slide 17: Highly unlikely that Engelhard will trade at multiples comparable to its peers

    Highly unlikely that Engelhard will trade —):=>, at multiples comparable to its peers Engelhard’s share price has trailed its peers and relevant indices over an extended period of time Engelhard’s mix of businesses has less attractive long term prospects relative to relevant peers Engelhard’s multip

  18. Slide 18: Share Price Total Return

    Share Price Total Return ___ S&P 500 Specialty Chemicals — sap 500 — Engelhard — Umicore os sranis9s wanes 111212000 41212002 41212004 4219008 — Johnson Matthey ‘Source: Facset fo share prices (1/2/1996 - 12/90/2005), Sloomberg fr total tus

  19. Slide 19: Engelhard's business mix does not support a higher rating

    Engelhard’s business mix does not —):=>, support a higher rating A substantial portion of Engelhard’s earnings (20% of EBIT in 2005) are from lower margin and more volatile Appearance and Performance Technologies Johnson Matthey Engelhard 20054 EBIT 20054 EBIT Margin= 19.7% Margin = 9.0% [Comparable

  20. Slide 20: BASF's offer represents full value

    =_:.<>, BASF’s offer represents full value Teer Corea 2007 Comparable Companies Analysis”) Pre-Announcement December 30, 2005 As of April 21, 20060 A ‘ een ee oy | | 123% 189% 36x! 73x eax | uncore atx 139% 185 16x vetnson [III += vetnson I 105 Ox Matthey 16.0% Matthey 11.2% 1.2% 78x are E venste A

  21. Slide 21: BASF's $38 cash offer gives shareholders superior value and certainty today

    BASF's $38 cash offer for 100% of the shares gives Engelhard shareholders superior value and certainty today Engelhard’s recapitalization plan is risky and its value is uncertain BASF has nominated five candidates for election to Engelhard’s Board of Directors to help facilitate BASF’s tender offer

  22. Slide 22: Maximize the value of your shares

    Maximize the value of your shares by voting for BASF’s nominees and tendering your shares into BASF’s offer

  23. Slide 23: Appendix

    Appendix

  24. Slide 24: Internal risks and uncertainties

    eo Internal risks and uncertainties: 1, The Company's ability to achieve and execute intemal business plans 2, The success ofreseorch and development activities and the speed wth which regulatory authorizations and product launches may be achieved 3, Manufacturing dificuties, property loss, or casua

  25. Slide 25: External risks, uncertainties and changes in market conditions (cont'd)

    External risks, uncertainties and changes in market conditions: (cont'd) 9, The impact of increased employee benefit costs andor the resultant impact on employee relations and human resources: 10, Higher interest ates 11, Changes in foreign currency exchange rates 12. Geographic expansions may not d

  26. Slide 26: Increased debt and higher interest expense

    expense Engelhard’s calculations'") based on December 2005 figures, 2006 higher debt numbers Increased debt and higher interest not on March Actual Estimated Post Pro Forma. 31-Dec-2005 (31-Mar-2006 Bridge Loan Recapitalization Binnie Dest fate ours | ote fo amt | note _ate ge | 0st _ nate ofan ‘Sha

  27. Slide 27: Engelhard year-on-year operating cash flow has declined

    Ea Engelhard year-on-year operating cash <eeei flow has declined Net Income $234.2 $235.5 $238.2 DD&A 127.7 128.7 132.4 Net Change in Assets/Liabilities 58.9 (25.5) (95.6) Other (14.8) (15.4) (16.9) Net Operating Cash Flow $406.0 = $323.4 © $258.1 Capex (113.6) (123.2) (141.6) Acquisitions (1.0) (68

  28. Slide 28: Precedent transactions for new platforms support BASF's view of limited synergies

    Precedent transactions for new platforms ==>, support BASF’s view of limited synergies Teer Corea Sy of Target + _Apt04 ~ No overap, acquisition of polyolefin catalyst division ‘iver lao atari ce sutace HAs + Oct04— Lite ovetap, acquisition ofa division ome = ea ap aa 2 Crompton (wie (NS. 1% + Jun.9

  29. Slide 29: Base Case

    Base Case 2007E EPS (VBVE/S) $2.49" Dilsted Shares OFS (mm) coz} Implied Net nome (4) 003 EBfoctve Tax Rate 24% impled ProTaxEamings GM) $4004 ‘Starting point or Engeharcts 20078 EPS cacubton 1292 milion Diluted Shares Income $9043 Shares OFS (mm) ili2zi 2007 EPS (VRIES) $249 Diluted Shares O/S (men

  30. Slide 30: EPS sensitivity calculations

    1 Percentage Point Decrease in 2007€ E81 Margin” No Cost Savings Realizot PreTaxEaings (60) $004 Preax Earrings 60) 004 Less 1% Change n BIT Marin CITED Lees conswingsreate CTE Adjusted Prax Earnings 6m) $364 AduedPreTac rings om) cori texte Ta Rate 2% tect Tar Rate 2% Imgeg Net ncome (4) 52632 inpi

  31. Slide 31: Blended value calculation

    =):=> Blended value calculation Teer Corea Blendod Values to Shareholders per Engelhard's Recapitalization Plan. Implied Multiples for Stub Company x 20% Proforma x793%Stub _ Blended 2007E PIE «2007E PIE —00KE_—=2007E roptchase Repurchase, ShaePrce Value“ Value (241 EPS) (82.49 EPS) EVIEBITOA EVEBIT

  32. Slide 32: Searchable text section of graphics shown above

    Searchable text section of graphics shown above The BASF Offer: Superior value and certainty for Engelhard shareholders May 2006 [LOGO] [GRAPHIC] [LOGO] BASF currently intends to solicit proxies for use at Engelhard’s 2006 annual meeting of stockholders, or at any adjournment or postponement thereof

Engelhard — Proxy Contest (May 2006) on 6ix