Buffalo Wild Wings — Proxy Contest (March 2017)
16 slides from Buffalo Wild Wings's proxy contest presentation, Mar 8, 2017
Slide 1: Buffalo Wild Wings March 2017
BUFFALO WILD WINGSMARCH 2017
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DisclAIMER 1 The views expressed in this presentation (the “Presentation”) represent the opinions of Marcato Capital Management LP and/or certain affiliates (“Marcato”) and the investment funds it manages that hold shares in Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. (the “Company”). This Presentation is for informat
Slide 3: Certain information concerning the participants
Certain information concerning the participants 2 Marcato International Master Fund, Ltd. (“Marcato International”) and the other Participants (as defined below) intend to file a preliminary proxy statement and accompanying proxy card with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) to be use
Slide 4: History of management's and the board's lack of skin in the Company
History of management’s & the board’s lack of “skin” in the Company Despite their stated optimism for future long-term value creation, BWLD leadership has not put their money where their mouth is:Not a single executive and only one director on one occasion has ever executed an open-market purchase o
Slide 5: Hundreds of open market sales and only one open market purchase in 13+ years
Open Mkt. Transactions Sales Purchases Current + Recent Insiders 667 1 SENIOR MANAGEMENT Sally Smith 129 – James Schmidt 80 – Judith Shoulak 65 – TENURED DIRECTORS J. Oliver Maggard 48 – James Damian 16 – Michael Johnson – – Jerry Rose – – Cindy Davis – 1 RECENTLY-DEPARTED SENIOR MANAGEMENT Mary Twi
Slide 6: Management and board have sold substantial stock after promoting rosy outlook
“[W]e will continue…to deliver significant value to our shareholders”“We are excited about the value we are creating for our shareholders through our many growth opportunities”“I am confident and excited about the future of Buffalo Wild Wings”– Sally Smith, 2016 Analyst Day 5 management and the boar
Slide 7: 2014 Analyst Day comments versus share sales
6 2014 Analyst Day comments versus share sales “Committed” to driving value… Sally Smith CEO & President James SchmidtCOO Judith ShoulakEVP, N. America Sold 126% of shares owned on 4/2/14Sold 66% of shares initially owned + later grants Sold 105% of shares owned on 4/2/14Sold 53% of shares initially
Slide 8: 2016 Analyst Day comments versus share sales
2016 Analyst Day comments versus share sales Sally Smith CEO & President James SchmidtCOO Judith ShoulakEVP, N. America “[T]he Board and management are focused on maximizing long-term shareholder value”– Sally Smith, 8/16/16 “As we look to the future, we believe we are uniquely positioned as an orga
Slide 9: Top executives have unloaded 92% of all shares granted since IPO
Sally Smith CEO & President James SchmidtCOO Judith ShoulakEVP, N. America 8 In aggregate, BWLD’s top executives have unloaded 92% of all shares they have been granted since IPO Does this behavior reflect alignment of interests with shareholders? Lee Patterson (EVP, North America) Shares sold as a p
Slide 10: BWLD insiders have sold ~80-90% of all stock ever owned
9 BWLD insiders have sold ~80-90% of all stock ever owned Of CEO Sally Smith’s 23 purchases of stock through the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (“ESPP”), she has subsequently sold those shares , and often on the same day Selling record reveals culture among senior leaders of minimizing long-term owner
Slide 11: BWLD employee stock purchase plan exploited by senior management
10 BWLD employee stock purchase plan exploited by senior management Source: Company filings as of 3/6/17.Calculated as the average number of days between purchase and next sale of shares in excess of amounts purchased under the ESPP, by transaction, for Sally Smith, James Schmidt, and Judith Shoulak
Slide 12: Sally Smith's ESPP purchases followed closely by stock sales
11 Sally Smith’s ESPP purchases have been followed very closely by Stock sales… Source: Company filings as of 3/6/17. CEO Sally Smith’s 23 purchases of stock through the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (“ESPP”) have been subsequently sold, on average, just 35 days following the date of purchase, and in
Slide 13: ...as have the ESPP purchases of other senior executives
12 …as have the espp purchases of other senior executives Source: Company filings as of 3/6/17.Note: Shares sold for Judith Shoulak assumed allocated on a “first in, first out” basis. Where shares traded in next sale did not exceed amount in prior purchase, assume excess is allocated to next closest
Slide 14: The plan exists to incentivize long-term behavior
13 The plan exists to incentivize long-term behavior, not to provide a mechanism for lining the pockets of executives Of CEO Sally Smith’s 23 purchases of stock through the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (“ESPP”), she has subsequently sold those shares , and often on the same day Source: Company filin
Slide 15: The board and management team lack an owner's perspective
Total historical purchases:315 shares Open market purchases:Zero sharesESPP purchases:627 shares Cindy Davis DirectorTenure: 2 years Jerry Rose DirectorTenure: 6 years Total historical purchases:Zero shares 14 The board and Management team lack an owner’s perspective Source: Company filings, Bloombe
Slide 16: Lack of alignment with shareholders explains business challenges
We believe the Lack of alignment with shareholders explains business challenges Marcato believes that:The Board of Directors’ and senior executives’ lack of long-term ownership explains recent failures of governance and oversightPoor capital allocation discipline and the severe lack of urgency in na