FBL Financial — Proxy Contest (April 2021)
7 slides from FBL Financial's proxy contest presentation, Apr 13, 2021
Slide 1: Deal Offers No Premium
INVESTOR PRESENTATION Deal Offers No Premium VOTE AGAINST ADOPTING THE PROPOSED MERGER April 2021 Supplemental Materials CAPITAL RETURNS
Slide 2: Important Information
Important Information Disclaimer The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Capital Returns Management, LLC and its affiliates (collectively, “Capital Returns”) and are based on publicly available information with respect to FBL Financial Group, Inc. (the “Company”).
Slide 3: FBL Stock To Trade at $56 Without Deal
FBL Stock To Trade at $56 Without Deal Life Insurer Stocks Have Risen Dramatically Since FBL Undisturbed Date S5Life Insurance Index • S&P Life Index has increased 50% since 9/3/20 • FBL undisturbed 9/3/20 closing price was $37.25 • Implied FBL stock price today of $56 Public US Life Insurers • Life
Slide 4: S5LIFE Insurer Index Performance v. FBL
S5LIFE Insurer Index Performance v. FBL April 12, 2021 September 3, 2020 Price Appreciation S5Life Insurer Index Members Closing Price Closing Price (9/3/2020 – 4/12/2021) Aflac Inc $52.44 $36.94 42.0% Globe Life Inc $100.80 $81.85 23.2% Unum Group $28.58 $18.39 55.4% MetLife Inc $62.66 $38.20 64.0%
Slide 5: US Life Insurer Stock Performance v. FBL
US Life Insurer Stock Performance v. FBL April 12, 2021 September 3, 2020 Price Appreciation Name Closing Price Closing Price (9/3/2020 – 4/12/2021) Aflac Inc $52.44 $36.94 42.0% American Equity Life $31.24 $23.88 30.8% Ameriprise $245.67 $156.34 57.1% Athene $50.80 $35.50 43.1% Brighthouse $46.72 $
Slide 6: Life Stocks with Strong Correlation to FBL
Life Stocks with Strong Correlation to FBL April 12, 2021 September 3, 2020 Price Appreciation Closing Price Closing Price (9/3/2020 – 4/12/2021) American Equity Life $31.24 $23.88 30.8% Ameriprise $245.67 $156.34 57.1% Brighthouse $46.65 $30.55 52.7% CNO $25.48 $16.78 51.8% Globe Life Inc $100.80 $
Slide 7: Deal Offers No Premium to Shareholders
Deal Offers No Premium to Shareholders $56 is where FBL shares would trade without a transaction Life insurer stocks have rallied 50% since FBPCIC made its first offer Adjusted for peer appreciation since September 3, 2020, the transaction price is in- line with FBL’s implied price Limited d