First Foundation Inc.

First Foundation — Proxy Contest (June 2023)

30 slides from First Foundation's proxy contest presentation, Jun 8, 2023

  1. Slide 1: A New Foundation for First Foundation: The Case for Replacing John Hakopian with Allison Ball

    A New Foundation for First Foundation: The Case for Replacing John Hakopian with Allison Ball June 2023

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer

    Disclaimer The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Driver Management Company LLC and the other participants named in the proxy solicitation (collectively, “Driver,” the “Driver Group” or “we”) and are based on publicly available information with respect to First Fo

  3. Slide 3: Executive Summary

    Executive Summary Electing Ms. Ball is a necessary, and targeted, first step to rebuilding the broken foundation at First Foundation First Foundation’s Board has Overseen a Failed Strategy Our nominee, Ms. Allison Ball, will introduce an Resulting in Shocking Value Destruction independent, fresh, pe

  4. Slide 4: Table of Contents

    The Case for Change Table of Allison Ball Will Bring Needed Contents Independent Perspective to the Board Appendix PAGE | 4

  5. Slide 5: First Foundation's 1, 3 and 5 Year TSR Speaks for Itself

    First Foundation’s 1, 3 and 5 Year TSR Speaks for Itself Total Shareholder Return1 -6,029 bps Difference -7,975 bps Difference -6,972 bps Difference 1 Note: Data per S&P Capital IQ, unless noted otherwise. Peer data is median for selected peer group. TSR is for periods ended June 6, 2023. a) First F

  6. Slide 6: First Foundation's Profitability Has Declined Dramatically Compared to Peers

    First Foundation’s Profitability Has Declined Dramatically Compared to Peers Return on Average Assets % A Dramatic Drop in Profitability PAGE | 6

  7. Slide 7: First Foundation Has Performed Disproportionally Worse Than Peers in a Rising Rate Environment

    First Foundation Has Performed Disproportionally Worse — And by a Large Margin — Than Peers in a Rising Rate Environment FFWM Was Unprepared for Higher Interest Rates Description Q32021 Q42021 Q12022 Q22022 Q32022 Q42022 Q12023 ISS Peers 3.13 3.03 3.01 3.25 3.55 3.69 3.48 Glass Lewis Peers 3.25 3.16

  8. Slide 8: The Prior Tightening Cycle Should Have Alerted First Foundation to Rising Rate Risks

    The Prior Tightening Cycle Should Have Alerted First Foundation to the Risks of a Rising Rate Environment First Foundation Has Experienced Dramatic Net Interest Margin Compression Compared to Peers First Foundation was on notice of the risks of a rising rate environment. In fact, 7 of 10 incumbent d

  9. Slide 9: The Prior Tightening Cycle Should Have Alerted First Foundation to Rising Rate Risks

    The Prior Tightening Cycle Should Have Alerted First Foundation to the Risks of a Rising Rate Environment First Foundation’s Cost of Deposits Have Increased Rapidly and Materially Compared to Peers Cost of Deposits/Fed Funds Effective Rate % First Foundation was on notice of the risks of a rising ra

  10. Slide 10: First Foundation is an Outlier in Terms of Multifamily Exposure

    First Foundation is an Outlier in Terms of Multifamily Exposure Multifamily loans are primarily fixed rate. Thus, in a rising rate environment, their value declines precipitously 2 “Banks with high levels of mortgages may be “Historical evidence demonstrates that financial particularly impacted as t

  11. Slide 11: Deposit Concentration Creates Known Liquidity Risk

    Deposit Concentration Creates Known Liquidity Risk First Foundation’s 10-K has included a risk factor warning of the liquidity risk posed by its reliance on a small handful of depositors since going public in 2013 From First Foundation’s 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022: “Our high concentra

  12. Slide 12: Troubling Trends with the Management Team

    Troubling Trends with the Management Team Bleak performance led to a management team exodus …And those who remain appear highly distracted from in 2022… what should be their “day jobs” at First Foundation Faced with a record of underperformance that CEO Kavanaugh’s outside business activities: saw F

  13. Slide 13: First Foundation's Entrenchment Playbook

    First Foundation’s Entrenchment Playbook • Driver delivered its notice of nomination to First Foundation on December 30, 2023, the day the nomination window opened; First Foundation notified Driver that it was rejecting the notice of nomination on February 22, 2023, fifty-four (54) days after receip

  14. Slide 14: The Board's Shocking Abdication of Its Fiduciary Duty to Oversee the Director Nomination Process

    The Board’s Shocking Abdication of Its Fiduciary Duty to Oversee the Director Nomination Process The Board undertook a shocking and unprecedented effort to entrench itself by completely abdicating its responsibility for the director nomination process to the management team and its advisors In a com

  15. Slide 15: A "Behind-the-Scenes" Bullying Campaign

    A “Behind-the-Scenes” Bullying Campaign First Foundation Hired Multiple “Opposition Research” Firms in a Futile Attempt to “Find Something Spicy” to Discredit Allison Ball as Part of a Larger Plan to Harass and Intimidate Driver’s Nominees First Foundation hired 3 separate firms to conduct Excerpts

  16. Slide 16: Scott Kavanaugh's Delight When He "Knifes" Ms. Flores' Candidacy

    Scott Kavanaugh’s Delight When He “Knifes” Ms. Flores’ Candidacy We believe this communication from Scott Kavanaugh, the CEO, encapsulates the lack of civility, decorum and fiduciary duty at the top of the Company and boardroom’s leadership • While Messrs. Kavanaugh and Packles discussed “looking fo

  17. Slide 17: An Entrenched Board with a "Founders First, Stockholders Last" Mentality

    An Entrenched Board with a “Founders First, Stockholders Last” Mentality • Half of the Board is either members of management or joined the Board through acquisitions of their predecessor companies • Weaponized the advance notice bylaws to deny Driver its fundamental right to nominate shareholders •

  18. Slide 18: Ms. Ball's Promise of a New Foundation for First Foundation

    Ms. Ball’s Promise of a New Foundation for First Foundation Our nominee, Ms. Ball, brings necessary expertise to the boardroom to help protect shareholders from the risks of the past and chart a new path for long-term growth Historic FFWM Risks Key Board Capabilities Ms. Ball Mr. Hakopian  Lack of

  19. Slide 19: Table of Contents

    The Case for Change Table of Allison Ball Will Bring Needed Contents Independent Perspective to the Board Appendix PAGE | 19

  20. Slide 20: Allison Ball Will Add an Independent Voice and Bring Relevant Expertise

    Allison Ball Will Add an Independent Voice and Bring Relevant Expertise to an Insider Dominated Board Ms. Ball Brings a Wealth of Independent ALLISON BALL Ms. Ball brings a track record as a successful Expertise to Rebuild the Foundation executive, advisor and investor across a diverse Independent v

  21. Slide 21: Allison Ball: A Seasoned Leader Who Will Introduce Effective Common-Sense Oversight

    Allison Ball: A Seasoned Leader Who Will Introduce Effective, Common-Sense Oversight in the Boardroom ALLISON BALL Ms. Ball, a highly Ms. Ball will ask the tough questions that the incumbent Board and accomplished management team should have been focused on for years, such as… professional, will bri

  22. Slide 22: Troubling Lack of Board Independence Has Empowered the "Yes Men Echo Chamber"

    Troubling Lack of Board Independence has Empowered the “Yes Men Echo Chamber” and Resulted in Shockingly Weak Performance It is troubling that a community bank Board so highly concentrated with insiders (50% of the incumbent directors are either current executives or received their positions through

  23. Slide 23: Third Management Director John Hakopian Is Redundant and Should be Replaced

    First Foundation’s Third Management Director, John Hakopian, Is Redundant as a Board Member and Should be Replaced by an Independent Director Diverse Work Experience Expertise in Technology Board Committee Eligibility Board & Shareholder Impact √ √ √ √ Allison Ball Allison Ball Allison Ball Allison

  24. Slide 24: Vote FOR Ms. Ball

    Vote FOR Ms. Ball Electing Ms. Ball is a necessary, and targeted, first step to rebuilding the broken foundation at First Foundation  Ms. Ball’s exceptional career at Meta (f/k/a Facebook), Hanover Investment Management and Goldman Sachs introduces a high-quality candidate with a richly diverse exp

  25. Slide 25: Table of Contents

    The Case for Change Table of Allison Ball Will Bring Needed Contents Independent Perspective to the Board Appendix PAGE | 25

  26. Slide 26: First Foundation Makes Every Effort to Block Nominations

    First Foundation Makes Every Effort to Block Nominations… Allison Ball and Lila Flores nominated Nomination Driver Mgmt. for election to the Board of First Foundation Driver Mgmt. Period closes requests by Driver Mgmt. through official notice of submits with no further nomination nomination sent alo

  27. Slide 27: First Foundation Makes Every Effort to Block Nominations (Continued)

    First Foundation Makes Every Effort to Block Nominations (Continued) First Foundation Begins Harassment Campaign Ms. Flores, due to Driver brings an action in and sends six harassing letters to Ms. Flores’ husband ongoing harassment, the Delaware Court of over 26 days, gratuitously copying the named

  28. Slide 28: First Foundation Has Already Abandoned These Claims in Litigation

    First Foundation Has Already Abandoned These Claims in Litigation . . . First Foundation’s Tired Claims Reality Ms. Ball was serving as Chief Marketing Officer of Grata in her capacity as a Partner at Accelerated Advisory Group, LLC pursuant Ms. Ball failed to disclose her role as Chief Product Offi

  29. Slide 29: First Foundation Continues to Repeat Spurious Claims About Ms. Ball Regardless of the Facts

    First Foundation Continues to Repeat Spurious Claims About Ms. Ball Regardless of the Facts Ms. Ball Has Never Been an Employee of Grata PAGE | 29

  30. Slide 30: Any Claims that Ms. Ball Failed to Disclose her Role as COO of Driver Are Patently False

    Any Claims that Ms. Ball Failed to Disclose her Role as COO of Driver (Which Is Not Related to Driver Management) Are Patently False PAGE | 30

First Foundation — Proxy Contest (June 2023) on 6ix