GCP Applied Technologies — Proxy Contest (April 2020)
131 slides from GCP Applied Technologies's proxy contest presentation, Apr 30, 2020
Slide 1: Transforming GCP Applied Technologies
Transforming GCP Applied Technologies April 2020
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation and any of the information contained herein (this “Presentation”) is for general informational purposes only and is not complete. Under no circumstances is this Presentation intended to be, nor should it be construed as advice or a recommendation to enter into or conclud
Slide 3: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Executive Summary 4 IV. Creating the Best Board for GCP 108 II. Change is Required at GCP 20 V. Conclusion 120 A. Poor Operating and Financial Performance 21 B. Repeated Missed Expectations 38 Appendix 123 C. Compensation & Governance Concerns 45 A. Marvell 124 B. Darden 128 III
Slide 4: I. Executive Summary
I. Executive Summary STARBOARDAYALUE® 4
Slide 5: GCP Was Created Through a Spinoff from W.R. Grace in February 2016
GCP Was Created Through a Spinoff from W.R. Grace in February 2016 GCP Applied Technologies Inc. (“GCP” or the “Company”) spun-off from W.R. Grace with attractive market share across major product categories. W.R. Grace (2015) Specialty Construction Chemicals (“SCC”) #1 in Cement Additives #2 in Con
Slide 6: GCP's SCC Business Provides Essential Inputs for Concrete and Cement Applications
GCP’s SCC Business Provides Essential Inputs for Concrete and Cement Applications SCC Segment Overview Key Competitors SCC is one of the leading global providers of cement additives and concrete admixtures. The global market for cement additives and concrete admixtures is ~$5 billion. SCC’s pr
Slide 7: GCP's SBM Business Provides Important Protective Functions For Building Structures
GCP’s SBM Business Provides Important Protective Functions For Building Structures SBM Segment Overview Key Competitors SBM provides building materials to the commercial construction, residential construction, and infrastructure end markets. The global market for SBM’s products is ~$5 billion.
Slide 8: GCP Has Disappointed Shareholders Since the Spinoff
GCP Has Disappointed Shareholders Since the Spinoff GCP has had poor financial and stock price performance. GCP Performance Since 2016 Direct Peers(1) (4.9%) Organic Growth Has 5.1% Relative Underperformed (2) Performance 0.2% Direct Peers(1) 13.4% Operating (3.4%) Margin Has Relative Underperformed
Slide 9: Operating Performance Has Deteriorated
Operating Performance Has Deteriorated Since spinning off from W.R. Grace in early 2016, GCP’s operating performance has suffered. Historical Organic Revenue Growth – GCP(1) Historical Organic Revenue Growth – Direct Peers(2) 3.1% 7.0% 2.1% 5.8% Median: 5.3% Median: 0.9% GCP has lagged 4.8% peers ev
Slide 10: Stock Price Performance Has Been Disappointing Due to Deteriorating Operating Performance
Stock Price Performance Has Been Disappointing Due to Deteriorating Operating Performance Since spinning off from W.R. Grace in February 2016, GCP’s share price has significantly underperformed its peers as well as the broader market indices. Summary Returns Stock Price Performance Since Spin-Off(1)
Slide 11: A Closer Look At the Last Two Years Reveals a Slew of Earnings Misses
A Closer Look At the Last Two Years Reveals a Slew of Earnings Misses and Restructuring Announcements Poor stock price performance over the past two years has been due to consistent earnings misses and perpetual restructuring actions.(1) November 6, 2018 June 18, 2019 July 1, 2019 January 13, 2020 J
Slide 12: Change Is Urgently Needed at GCP
Change Is Urgently Needed at GCP Since its spin from W.R. Grace in 2016, GCP has substantially underperformed shareholders’ expectations, its main competitors, the overall market, and its potential. Poor Stock Price Performance Underperformed its Direct Peers by 84% since spinning off from W.R. Gr
Slide 13: We Believe There Is a Plan for Exceptional Value Creation
We Believe There Is a Plan for Exceptional Value Creation Despite years of disappointing performance, we firmly believe an opportunity exists to leverage GCP’s best-in- class assets to create significant value for shareholders. Opportunities Reaccelerate revenue growth − We believe the Company can
Slide 14: Bridge to Driving Improved Results
Bridge to Driving Improved Results We believe that GCP can improve its EBIT margin by ~600 bps on a run rate basis, more than recouping all of the deterioration that has occurred through poor performance over the last few years. We believe there are not only significant cost improvement opportunit
Slide 15: Key Elements of Our Plan
Key Elements of Our Plan Summary of Operational Improvement Opportunities Focus on sales execution and sales force compensation. Revenue Growth Reevaluate pricing model and customer value proposition. (3% - 5% Long-Term Streamline customer service processes to increase accountability and owner
Slide 16: Starboard Has a Long History of Driving Fundamental Improvements at Companies
Starboard Has a Long History of Driving Fundamental Improvements at Companies Starboard has a long history of driving value for shareholders through constructive engagement with public company management teams and boards. Starboard has added or replaced approximately 241 corporate directors on 71
Slide 17: We Have Nominated a Highly Qualified Group of Individuals
We Have Nominated a Highly Qualified Group of Individuals Who Are Uniquely Equipped to Help Govern GCP Collectively, our Board nominees are a powerful group of leading executives, chairmen and directors of well- performing industrial companies with the necessary experience and independence to overse
Slide 18: This Election Contest Is the Result of Months of Unfruitful Attempts to Work with the Company
This Election Contest Is the Result of 15 Months of Unfruitful Attempts to Work with the Company Starboard has spent the past 15 months attempting to constructively engage with the Board and management to chart a better course for the Company – our efforts have largely been ignored or rebuffed. 11/6
Slide 19: Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today
Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today Starboard has a long history of driving operational, financial, and strategic turnarounds. We believe we have a better plan to create value. We believe we have a superior slate of directors. Vote on Starboard’s WHITE
Slide 20: II. Change Is Required at GCP
II. Change Is Required at GCP 20
Slide 21: A) Poor Operating and Financial Performance
A) Poor Operating and Financial Performance 21
Slide 22: The Company Had High Expectations at the Time of its Spinoff from W.R. Grace
The Company Had High Expectations at the Time of its Spinoff from W.R. Grace Management envisioned the Company as a best-in-class construction chemicals asset benefitting from favorable industry tailwinds with leading market share and defensible competitive advantages. Favorable Industry Tailwinds F
Slide 23: Wall Street Analysts Agreed That the Outlook for GCP Seemed Favorable
Wall Street Analysts Agreed That the Outlook for GCP Seemed Favorable Wall Street analysts broadly agreed with management’s enthusiasm for the business, citing macroeconomic tailwinds and strong market positioning as key positives for the Company. Select Commentary From Wall Street Analysts “GCP wil
Slide 24: While Industry Growth Has Met Expectations, GCP's Growth Has Severely Disappointed
While Industry Growth Has Met Expectations, GCP’s Growth Has Severely Disappointed Over the last four years, global construction growth has broadly tracked expectations, yet GCP’s revenues have fallen far short despite initial claims that its revenues could grow at double the industry growth rates.
Slide 25: Operating Margins in Both Segments Have Eroded Despite Industry Tailwinds
Operating Margins in Both Segments Have Eroded Despite Industry Tailwinds Over the past four years, operating margins have deteriorated in both businesses. 2016 – 2019 Adjusted EBIT Margins(1) ‘16 – ‘19 Adj. Operating Expense as % of Revenue(1)(2) 150bps Margin Erosion 70bps Cost Increase 11.3% 26.1
Slide 26: Despite GCP's Struggles, Its Closest Peers Have Not Faced Similar Challenges
Despite GCP’s Struggles, Its Closest Peers Have Not Faced Similar Challenges While GCP has struggled to improve both revenue growth and operating margins, its direct competitors have fared significantly better. 2015 – 2019 Organic Sales CAGR 2015 – 2019 Change in Adj. EBIT Margin GCP 2016 Investor D
Slide 27: GCP's Closest Peers Seem to Have Enjoyed a Robust Macro Environment
GCP’s Closest Peers Seem to Have Enjoyed a Robust Macro Environment As an example, over the last two years, GCP’s closest peers for the SBM segment have enthusiastically discussed the robust macro environment while GCP has struggled. SBM Peer Commentary(1)(2) GCP Commentary(2) “We’re in the very luc
Slide 28: GCP Has Been in a State of Perpetual Restructurings Since Its IPO
GCP Has Been in a State of Perpetual Restructurings Since Its IPO GCP has announced four restructurings in three years. “We think we're about structured correctly for how we see each one of these markets today…I think Fred and Hudson made the point, we did the restructuring for the spin in front, no
Slide 29: All Four Plans Appear to Be Similar in Scope
All Four Plans Appear to Be Similar in Scope Each of the four restructuring initiatives approved by the Board over the past three years has seemingly had significant overlap in scope, suggesting prior restructurings were either poorly designed or poorly executed. Excerpts From GCP 2019 10-K Regardin
Slide 30: All Four Restructuring Plans Have Failed to Improve Operating Expenses
All Four Restructuring Plans Have Failed to Improve Operating Expenses Despite the four restructuring plans, operating expenses – on both an absolute and relative basis – have not declined. Adjusted Operating Expenses (1) ($ in millions) $296 $293 $283 $273 Operating expense has INCREASED since spin
Slide 31: GCP Has Incurred Significant Costs Associated with Its Restructuring Plans
GCP Has Incurred Significant Costs Associated with Its Restructuring Plans Since 2017, GCP has spent $78 million on restructuring and repositioning activities. GCP has cumulatively spent $38 million on restructuring activities aimed at streamlining product offerings and manufacturing locations, an
Slide 32: Despite Substantial Spend on Restructuring, Operating Income Has Declined
Despite Substantial Spend on Restructuring, Operating Income Has Declined Despite spending $78 million on restructuring and repositioning activities, operating income has declined. Significant payments for consulting services seem to have been ineffective. – Effective consulting projects aim to pr
Slide 33: Lack of Profitability Improvements May Be Due to Atypical Recognition of Cost Savings
We Believe the Lack of Profitability Improvements May Be In Part Due to GCP’s Atypical Recognition of “Cost Savings” GCP claims “cost savings” for the removal of operating expenses in businesses that it exits. We believe this is misleading, because market exits also reduce both revenue and gross pro
Slide 34: The Company's Claim of Improved Profitability in SCC Is Misleading
The Company’s Claim of “Improved Profitability” in SCC Is Misleading The Company would like to claim credit for improving SCC’s margins, but it has “improved margins” from 2018 – 2019 by shaving ~$64 million off the topline, and operating profit is still much lower than at spinoff. The Company Wants
Slide 35: Recent Improvements in SCC's Margins Have Not Been Driven by Fundamental Operational Improvements
Recent Improvements in SCC’s Margins Have Not Been Driven by Fundamental Operational Improvements While Adjusted EBIT margins for the SCC segment seem to have improved over the last twelve months, improvements have been driven by a reduction in revenue from exiting unprofitable geographies. While
Slide 36: In Addition, Total Company Profits Have Continued to Decline
In Addition, Total Company Profits Have Continued to Decline While the Company would like to take credit for recent improvements in SCC, total Company revenue continues to decline due to troubling performance in SBM and lack of corporate cost discipline. While SCC Adj. EBIT Improved in 2019… … SBM A
Slide 37: The Company's Capital Deployment Strategy Has Not Been Effective
The Company’s Capital Deployment Strategy Has Not Been Effective Despite spending an increasing percentage of revenue on capital expenditures, the Company’s investments have not led to better results. Capital Expenditures Organic Revenue Growth $55 $57 2016 Investor Day Target: 6% Annual Growth(1) $
Slide 38: B) Repeated Missed Expectations
B) Repeated Missed Expectations 38
Slide 39: GCP's Results Have Consistently Missed Expectations
GCP’s Results Have Consistently Missed Expectations The Company has failed to execute against its growth targets – both organic and inorganic. 2016 Investor Day Revenue Growth Targets Organic Growth Has Failed to Meet Expectations(1) (Annual Organic Revenue Growth) Management Target: 6.0%(2) 3.1% 2.
Slide 40: Wall Street Analysts Have Grown Increasingly Disillusioned with the Company's Outlook
As a Result, Wall Street Analysts Have Grown Increasingly Disillusioned with the Company’s Outlook While Wall Street analysts initially subscribed to management’s long-term revenue growth outlook, forward estimates have declined substantially over the past few years. Wall Street Analyst Estimates Fo
Slide 41: GCP's Operating Expense and EBIT Margins Have Also Continually Missed Expectations
GCP’s Operating Expense and EBIT Margins Have Also Continually Missed Expectations The Company has failed to execute against its cost reduction and Adjusted EBIT margin targets. Adjusted SG&A Expense Ratio Has Increased (1) (SG&A Expense as % of Total Revenue) 26.1% “If you take the SG&A for this ye
Slide 42: Both Business Segments Have Also Significantly Missed Expectations
Both Business Segments Have Also Significantly Missed Expectations GCP is operating at ~500 bps of underperformance in both its SCC and SBM segments. SCC – Adjusted EBIT Margin vs. Management Target SBM – Adjusted EBIT Margin vs. Management Target 2016 Management Target: 15% 27.0% 2016 Management Ta
Slide 43: The Company Has a Long History of Downward Revisions and Misses
The Company Has a Long History of Downward Revisions and Misses EPS Adj. EBIT Adj. Free Cash Flow Revenue Growth(2) 25% Decline 23% Decline 9% Decline 10% Decline $1.14 $70 $70 0.0% $0.92 $0.92 $136 2019 $0.81 $115 $115 $50 $50 (2.0%) (7.0%) $1.03 $102 $127 $55 $50 $0.75 $0.75 (9.0%) (9.9%) $100 $10
Slide 44: Shareholder Confidence Has Been Further Eroded by Constant Revenue and Earnings Misses
Shareholder Confidence Has Been Further Eroded by Constant Revenue and Earnings Misses Even with perpetual negative guidance revisions, GCP has still managed to constantly miss Wall Street estimates, which has left shareholders incredibly frustrated. GCP’s consistent track record of missing earnin
Slide 45: C) Compensation & Governance Concerns
C) Compensation & Governance Concerns 45
Slide 46: Proxy Advisors Have Highlighted the Disparity Between Performance and Pay Relative to Peers
Proxy Advisors Have Highlighted the Disparity Between Performance and Pay Relative to Peers Both ISS and Glass Lewis, the two most influential shareholder advisory firms, have noted that the Board has granted the CEO top quartile pay despite bottom quartile performance relative to peers. Excerpt Fro
Slide 47: The Board Has Approved an Aspirational Peer Set Further Inflating Compensation
The Board Has Approved an Aspirational Peer Set Further Inflating Compensation We believe the Board has done a poor job of selecting benchmarks for compensation, resulting in compensation levels that are likely inappropriate for the Company’s size. Excerpt from GCP’s 2020 Definitive Proxy GCP is amo
Slide 48: The Board Has Not Held Management Accountable for Poor Performance
The Board Has Not Held Management Accountable for Poor Performance The Board has continued to lower operating targets in response to management’s poor performance. Management’s annual incentive compensation is measured against Board-determined revenue, adjusted EBIT, and adjusted free cash flow ta
Slide 49: Only Under Extreme Pressure Did the Board Take Action to Change Leadership
Only Under Extreme Pressure Did the Board Take Action to Change Leadership Unfortunately, even then, we believe the Board continued to protect the outgoing CEO. 1 2/1/2019 3 7/1/2019: 5 12/3/2019: In July 2019, following a four-month failed sales In December 2019, just five months after Starboard Va
Slide 50: Concerns About Motivations for Appointing Greg Poling Executive Chairman
We Have Concerns About the Board's Motivations for Appointing Greg Poling Executive Chairman of the Company Randy Dearth had previously been the CEO of a public company and Messrs. Dearth and Poling had overlapped at GCP for almost one year, providing adequate time to transition by the time Mr. Dear
Slide 51: We Question Whether the Compensation Consultants Are Truly Independent
We Question Whether the Compensation Consultants Are Truly Independent Willis Towers Watson (“Willis”), an independent consulting firm, is a trusted advisor to the Board’s compensation committee on management pay. However, Willis also collects significant fees from the Company for other services at
Slide 52: Concerns With the Company's Corporate Governance Practices
We Also Have Concerns With the Company’s Corporate Governance Practices GCP has a number of shareholder-unfriendly governance provisions. GCP’s Board Claims to be Committed to “Best-in-Class Governance Practices” (Excerpt from 2020 Definitive Proxy) Despite a commitment to “best-in-class governanc
Slide 53: The Current Board Has Significant Interlocks and Lacks Relevant Industry Experience
The Current Board Has Significant Interlocks and Lacks Relevant Industry Experience We believe there are multiple director interlocks and connections that suggest personal relationships, potential conflicts of interest, and a lack of true independence among board members. We believe the GCP Board
Slide 54: Consolidation of Power on GCP's Board Among Three Directors
There Is a Consolidation of Power on GCP’s Board Among Three Directors with Clear Interconnections We question whether Elizabeth Mora, Janice Henry and Gerald Colella – three directors that have monopolized leadership positions on GCP’s Board – are truly capable of acting independently given strong
Slide 55: Two Current Directors Served on the Cleveland-Cliffs Board Together
Two Current Directors Served on the Cleveland-Cliffs Board Together Janice Henry and James Kirsch have a long history together, as evidenced by their time on the Board of Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF), where they faced intense investor criticism. Shortly after Mr. Kirsch was voted off by shareholders, Ms.
Slide 56: New Nominee, John McPherson, Was a Direct Report of a Current GCP Board Member
New Nominee, John McPherson, Was a Direct Report of a Current GCP Board Member Mr. Shepherd served as Vulcan’s Vice Chairman, while Mr. McPherson was CFO. We think this former direct report relationship presents Danny Shepherd John McPherson another potential conflict of interest. GCP Director since
Slide 57: John McPherson Has Direct Ties to the Private Equity Owner of a Key GCP Competitor
John McPherson Has Direct Ties to the Private Equity Owner of a Key GCP Competitor Lone Star Funds is acquiring BASF’s Construction Chemicals business – a key GCP competitor – and is also a 69% owner of Forterra, where John McPherson is Vice Chairman. Owns 69.3% of Common Shares Acquisition announce
Slide 58: John McPherson Has Direct Ties to Private Equity Owner of Key Competitor (Cont'd.)
John McPherson Has Direct Ties to the Private Equity Owner of a Key GCP Competitor (Cont’d.) Mr. McPherson also has a long history with Chris Meyer, the Chairman of Forterra, and a Senior Managing Director at Lone Star responsible for leading all acquisitions in North America. Mr. Meyer is a Senior
Slide 59: New Nominee, Armand Lauzon, Lacks Direct Industry Experience
New Nominee, Armand Lauzon, Lacks Direct Industry Experience and Has Never Been on a Public Board Armand Lauzon lacks construction and specialty chemicals expertise. We do not believe the second nominee, Armand Lauzon, is a good fit for GCP’s board. Mr. Lauzon has no relevant direct construction
Slide 60: III. We Have a Better Plan
Ill. We Have a Better Plan STARBOARDAYALUE® 60
Slide 61: GCP Has Underperformed Peers Since Spinning Off From W.R. Grace
GCP Has Underperformed Peers Since Spinning Off From W.R. Grace Despite a favorable industry backdrop and possessing an enviable portfolio of high quality products, GCP has lagged peers on both revenue growth and profitability over the past few years. Construction Industry Trends Have Been Favorable
Slide 62: Opportunities to Significantly Improve Revenue Growth and Margins
We Believe There Are Opportunities to Significantly Improve Revenue Growth and Margins We believe that GCP can improve its EBIT margin by ~600bps on a run rate basis, more than recouping all of the deterioration that has occurred through poor performance over the last few years. We believe there a
Slide 63: Specific Operational Improvement Opportunities at GCP
We Believe There Are Specific Operational Improvement Opportunities at GCP Summary of Operational Improvement Opportunities Restructure sales force compensation to include product-specific quotas, payouts for meeting both revenue and profitability metrics, and uncap bonus payments to incentivize h
Slide 64: A. Revenue Improvement Plan
A. Revenue Improvement Plan 64
Slide 65: GCP Has Lost Market Share in Key Geographies
GCP Has Lost Market Share in Key Geographies Since spinning off from W.R. Grace, we believe GCP has lost market share to competitors. While competitors have managed to grow through a combination of organic efforts and acquisitions, GCP has had the opposite trajectory, with sales declining outside
Slide 66: Immediate Steps to Better Execute Its Revenue Strategy
We Believe There Are Immediate Steps the Company Can Take to Better Execute Its Revenue Strategy We believe the current sales force compensation structure leads to suboptimal short-term and long-term outcomes for the Company. Based on conversations with former employees, we believe bonus payments
Slide 67: Immediate Steps to Better Execute Its Revenue Strategy (Cont'd.)
We Believe There Are Immediate Steps the Company Can Take to Better Execute Its Revenue Strategy (Cont’d.) We believe the current order placement and fulfilment system undermines hard-earned customer relationships and leads to unnecessary errors. Based on conversations with former employees, we be
Slide 68: SCC Opportunity to Increase Sales by Cross-Selling into More Geographies
Longer-Term, We Believe SCC Has an Opportunity to Increase Sales by Cross-Selling into More Geographies GCP highlights ten brand names for ready mix concrete on their website, yet only four seem to have global presence. While GCP has ten brands serving the ready mix concrete industry in the U.S.,
Slide 69: SBM Should Consider Tiering Its Product Offerings in APAC
We Also Believe SBM Should Consider Tiering Its Product Offerings to Increase Market Share in APAC We believe GCP should consider tiering its product offerings for APAC, where the Company’s product specifications may exceed customer requirements. Based on conversations with former employees, we be
Slide 70: Augmenting Organic Growth with Prudent Acquisitions
We Believe the Company Should Consider Augmenting Organic Growth with Prudent Acquisitions We believe the Company should consider utilizing acquisitions to fill gaps in regional presence or product portfolio. Sika, which is considered best-in-class in the industry, has benefitted from a discipline
Slide 71: B. Gross Margin Plan
B. Gross Margin Plan STARBOARDAYALUE® 71
Slide 72: GCP's Gross Margins Have Deteriorated Over Time
GCP’s Gross Margins Have Deteriorated Over Time Since spinning-off from W.R. Grace, GCP’s gross margins have steadily deteriorated, particularly in the Company’s more profitable SBM segment. We believe GCP has opportunities to improve gross margins by improving manufacturing practices, simplifying
Slide 73: Opportunity to Improve Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM
We Believe There Is an Opportunity to Improve Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM We believe most of SBM’s products are manufactured in the U.S. and Western Europe before being shipped to local markets, resulting in higher labor and shipping costs. Based on conversations with former employees, we belie
Slide 74: Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM (Cont'd.): DE NEEF
We Believe There is an Opportunity to Improve Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM (Cont’d.) Based on interviews with former employees, as a case study, we highlight an opportunity with DE NEEF, a water proofing injection solution that is highly popular in Europe with significant global demand potential.
Slide 75: Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM (Cont'd.)
We Believe There is an Opportunity to Improve Supply Chain Efficiency in SBM (Cont’d.) Similar to supply chain inefficiencies with DE NEEF, we believe other similar inefficiencies exist within SBM. Since spin off, the SBM segment has not had any local manufacturing presence in Latin America, leadi
Slide 76: Product Development Process Drives Operational Inefficiencies
GCP’s Product Development Process Drives Operational Inefficiencies That Pressure Gross Margins We believe inefficiencies in the product development process increase product costs by driving ineffective market positioning and negatively impacting procurement, supply-chain, manufacturing, and researc
Slide 77: Proposed Product Development Process
GCP’s Product Development Process Drives Operational Inefficiencies That Pressure Gross Margins (Cont’d.) Below, we propose a more efficient product development process that we believe will free up R&D resources, and improve efficiencies in procurement, supply chain, and manufacturing. Proposed Prod
Slide 78: Opportunity to Reduce Sole-Sourced Raw Materials
GCP’s Product Development Process Drives Operational Inefficiencies That Pressure Gross Margins (Cont’d.) We believe there is an opportunity to significantly reduce the volume of sole-sourced raw materials purchased each year. While Company policy dictates every raw material is required to have th
Slide 79: C. SG&A and R&D Improvement Plan
C. SG&A and R&D Improvement Plan 79
Slide 80: SG&A Improvement Plan
SG&A Improvement Plan STARBOARDAYALUE® 80
Slide 81: Opportunity To Streamline SG&A
We Believe There is an Opportunity To Streamline SG&A We believe there is a path to not only streamline SG&A expenses, but also reallocate resources to create a more efficient and effective organization. Despite announcing four restructuring plans over the last three years, GCP’s SG&A expense rati
Slide 82: Opportunities to Reorganize Corporate Headcount
There are Opportunities to Reorganize Corporate Headcount We believe the Company may have too many managerial staff within key support functions. Our diligence suggests that the Company’s ratio of line-level employees to managers in key support functions may be significantly lower than best-in-cla
Slide 83: Greater Decentralization of Business Unit Functions
There Are Opportunities For Greater Decentralization of Business Unit Functions We believe there needs to be greater decentralization of business unit functions to create greater accountability and drive further SG&A efficiencies. Based on interviews with former employees, we believe the Company h
Slide 84: Opportunities to Automate Customer Support
There Are Opportunities to Automate Customer Support to Improve Productivity We believe the Company should consider automating portions of the customer support experience in order to improve productivity, reduce costs, and increase customer satisfaction. GCP Customer Service System Competitor Custom
Slide 85: R&D Improvement Plan
R&D Improvement Plan STARBOARDAYALUE® 85.
Slide 86: Opportunity to Improve Research & Development Productivity
We Believe There is an Opportunity to Improve Research & Development Productivity R&D Spending vs. Direct Peers(1)(2) R&D (% of Sales) '15 - '19 Average GCP 5 Year Average: SIKA 5 Year Average: SGO 5 Year Average: CSL 5 Year Average: 1.8% 2.8% 1.1% 1.3% GCP spends roughly 2.9% 3.0% 2.9% 2.7% 2.5% in
Slide 87: GCP's Peers Have a Better Return on Their R&D Budgets
GCP’s Peers Have a Better Return on Their R&D Budgets R&D Productivity vs. Direct Peers(1) Metric: New Organic Sales Growth Generated per R&D Dollar GCP 5 Year Average: 0.6x Sika 5 Year Average: 1.7x SGO 5 Year Average: 2.6x CSL 5 Year Average: 2.8x 4.9x 4.1x 4.0x 3.3x 2.5x 2.7x 2.3x 2.0x 2.2x 2.2x
Slide 88: GCP Has Missed Out on Significant White Space to Drive Organic Growth
We Believe GCP Has Missed Out on Significant White Space to Drive Organic Growth We believe GCP can drive growth by proactively focusing on its R&D Strategy. Innovation Is Critical To Growth in Specialty Building Products(1)(2) “By 2023 the company aims to generate 25% of sales with “We generate
Slide 89: GCP Needs to Balance Investments in SCC and SBM
We Believe GCP Needs to Balance Investments in SCC and SBM According to our research, GCP has a significant R&D and capital expenditure imbalance between its SCC and SBM businesses. GCP’s Current R&D Prioritizes SCC GCP Should Allocate Greater Resources to SBM GCP deploys an outsized amount of its
Slide 90: The Company Has Underinvested in SBM
The Company Has Underinvested in SBM Since 2015, there have been no company-developed additions to the SBM product portfolio despite consistent R&D spending – the only additions have come through M&A. 2015 SBM Product Portfolio 2019 SBM Product Portfolio Sterling Lloyd Acquisition Halex Acquisition
Slide 91: SCC Has Overwhelmingly Monopolized GCP's R&D Dialogue
SCC Has Overwhelmingly Monopolized GCP’s R&D Dialogue Since Its Spin Off During the Analyst Teach-In before spinning off, GCP highlighted several SCC products that were in the test market phase, but didn’t mention new SBM products. Innovations Highlighted During GCP 2016 Analyst Teach-In Specialty B
Slide 92: GCP Would Benefit from a Review of Its Investment Strategy
We Believe GCP Would Benefit from a Review of Its Investment Strategy In light of GCP’s declining margins and capitulating market exits, we are concerned that the Company may be overextending its reach in select competitive markets and underinvesting in differentiated SBM categories. The Company Has
Slide 93: Peers Have Focused on Replicating PREPRUFE
While GCP Has Underinvested in Its SBM Business, Peers Have Focused on Replicating PREPRUFE GCP’s outsized focus on its SCC segment has resulted in fewer innovations in its SBM segment, at a time when competitors have gone after its core product. Product Pioneer Competitive Launches of PREPRUFE “Kno
Slide 94: GCP is Lagging in New Product Innovation in Its SBM Business
GCP is Lagging in New Product Innovation in Its SBM Business GCP’s outsized focus on its SCC segment has resulted in fewer innovations in its SBM segment, which plays in a market that values and rewards new product roll outs. GCP’s Category Creators Timeline Specialty Building Materials Products Spe
Slide 95: Sika Has Taken Market Share by Continuously Launching New Products
GCP Peer Sika Has Taken Market Share by Focusing on Continuously Launching New Products We believe GCP needs to adopt a more aggressive approach to product innovation in its SBM segment. Sika is a perfect example of how GCP can win by listening to its customers and delivering on innovation. Sika Has
Slide 96: Board That Would Demand Urgency and Direction in Innovation
We Believe GCP Would Benefit From a Board That Would Demand Urgency and Direction in Innovation The building products business is competitive, and innovation is key. GCP cannot rely on incremental improvements every few years. GCP Claims It Is Rolling Out New Products… …But We Don’t Believe the Comp
Slide 97: GCP Needs a Market-Driven, Data-Based Long Term R&D Strategy
GCP Needs a Market-Driven, Data-Based Long Term R&D Strategy We believe that GCP’s organizational problems have resulted in a broken R&D process that is failing to deliver category creators and lagging peers in new sales productivity. The role of marketing is to understand competitive landscapes a
Slide 98: GCP's Capital Deployment in SCC Requires a Fresh Perspective
We Believe GCP’s Capital Deployment in SCC Also Requires a Fresh Perspective We believe that within SCC, GCP has potentially placed an outsized development focus on Verifi. Considering Verifi has existed in one form or another over the last 10 years, we believe an objective ROI-based evaluation is c
Slide 99: Verifi is Not a New Technology
Verifi is Not a New Technology & Requires Management to be Thoughtful About Investing While GCP touts Verifi as a new area for growth, the business has existed for almost a decade. The business’ long and complicated history within both W.R. Grace and GCP requires careful examination. Verifi Timeline
Slide 100: Grace and GCP Disagreed on Verifi's Market Viability
Grace and GCP Disagreed on Verifi’s Market Viability Grace Tried to Commercialize VERIFI But Gave Up… …Six Years Later GCP is Still Trying to Make it Work “We are repositioning our Verifi process control technology business. “Verify is a new marketplace…We have a head start in this market. Market ad
Slide 101: D. Board Engagement Plan
D. Board Engagement Plan STARBOARDAYALUE” 101
Slide 102: Starboard Has an Actionable Plan to Improve GCP's Operations
Starboard Has an Actionable Plan to Improve GCP’s Operations After Years of Underperformance 1 Reaccelerate Revenue Growth Redesign sales compensation plans and restructure customer service organization. Diversify product portfolio into international markets. Augment organic growth opportuni
Slide 103: Lay the Foundation For Executing Our Plan Within the First 100 Days
We Intend to Lay the Foundation For Executing Our Plan Within the First 100 Days This group of director nominees has already begun to put together a 100-day plan to ensure that the Board can work quickly and seamlessly with management to lay the foundations for executing our longer-term strategic in
Slide 104: 100-Day Plan: Reaccelerate Revenue Growth
100-Day Plan: Reaccelerate Revenue Growth 1 Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Assess Current Product Portfolio & Markets Initiate detailed market research and metrics-based financial analysis of each GCP business line Identify strategy to defend and grow market share in leadership categories (Bu
Slide 105: 100-Day Plan: Improve Gross Margins
100-Day Plan: Improve Gross Margins 2 Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Assess Manufacturing Footprint Analyze facility footprint and capacity utilization, along with customer density points and transportation costs to market Devise optimal manufacuturing footprint with long-term product portfol
Slide 106: 100-Day Plan: Improve SG&A Expense Structure
100-Day Plan: Improve SG&A Expense Structure 3 Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Review G&A Headcount By Department Analyze and develop spans / layers Benchmark against specialty chemicals and construction peers Identify opportunities to consolidate, outsource, or re-engineer operations to maxim
Slide 107: 100-Day Plan: Improve R&D Productivity
100-Day Plan: Improve R&D Productivity 4 Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Assess GCP's Current R&D Organization Assess GCP's R&D budget and resource allocation Assess GCP's team structure and project processes Evaluate GCP's R&D metrics and project accountability Identify Long-Term R&D Strategy
Slide 108: IV. Creating the Best Board for GCP
IV. Creating the Best Board for GCP 108
Slide 109: Starboard Has a Methodical Process to Identify High-Quality Board Members
Starboard Has a Methodical Process to Identify High- Quality Board Members Starboard has a long history of identifying high-quality board members, having added or replaced 237 corporate directors on 68 boards. Starboard uses the following criteria to evaluate potential directors: – Industry Releva
Slide 110: Overview of Starboard Director Nominees
Overview of Starboard Director Nominees We have compiled a diverse slate of experienced and knowledgeable industry experts who we believe could propel GCP forward. Our highly-qualified nominees have range of experiences that complement each other. Collectively, they are industry- leading experts o
Slide 111: Our Director Nominees Are More Qualified to Guide a Turnaround at GCP
We Believe our Director Nominees Are More Qualified to Guide a Turnaround at GCP We have compiled a diverse slate of experienced industry experts who can propel GCP forward. Starboard Nominees Construction / Prior Public C-Level / President Turnaround Chemicals Company Board Diversity Experience Exp
Slide 112: Our Nominees: Kevin W. Brown
Our Nominees: Kevin W. Brown We believe that Mr. Brown’s extensive industry and chemicals experience coupled with his operational expertise would make him a valuable addition to the Board. Mr. Brown previously served as the Executive Vice President of Manufacturing & Refining at LyondellBasell Ind
Slide 113: Our Nominees: Peter A. Feld
Our Nominees: Peter A. Feld We believe that Mr. Feld’s extensive knowledge of the capital markets, corporate finance, and public company governance practices as a result of his investment experience, together with his significant public company board experience, would make him a valuable asset to th
Slide 114: Our Nominees: Janet P. Giesselman
Our Nominees: Janet P. Giesselman We believe that Ms. Giesselman’s significant leadership experience as a senior executive in the specialty chemicals industry and her expertise in growth strategies and innovation, as well as her service on a number of public company boards would make her a valuable
Slide 115: Our Nominees: Andrew M. Ross
Our Nominees: Andrew M. Ross We believe that Mr. Ross brings extensive senior leadership roles at family-owned, private equity sponsored and publicly-owned companies in addition to significant operational experience in the industrials space. Mr. Ross previously served as President of the Pigments
Slide 116: Our Nominees: Linda J. Welty
Our Nominees: Linda J. Welty We believe that Ms. Welty’s extensive global industrial experience, including her C-suite executive leadership roles in the chemical, natural resource and energy industries, will allow Ms. Welty to provide strategic, financial and corporate governance insight, making her
Slide 117: Our Nominees: Rob H. Yanker
Our Nominees: Rob H. Yanker We believe that Mr. Yanker’s significant managerial and operational expertise gained from his extensive experience advising and consulting for senior management teams, together with his public board experience, well qualifies him to serve as a director of the Company. M
Slide 118: Our Nominees: Clay H. Kiefaber
Our Nominees: Clay H. Kiefaber We believe that Mr. Kiefaber’s substantive experience from serving in a variety of senior executive positions as well as his industry specific knowledge makes him a valuable asset to the Board. Mr. Kiefaber previously served as CEO and President of Colfax. Prior to C
Slide 119: Our Nominees: Marran H. Ogilvie
Our Nominees: Marran H. Ogilvie We believe that Ms. Ogilvie’s substantial business experience and financial background coupled with her extensive experience serving as a director of public companies make her a valuable addition to the Board. Ms. Ogilvie is an experienced public board experience.
Slide 120: V. Conclusion
V. Conclusion STARBOARDAYALUE™ 120
Slide 121: Opportunity to Create Substantial Value at GCP
We Believe There is an Opportunity to Create Substantial Value at GCP GCP shareholders deserve a Board that will demand accountability and excellence from the Company. GCP spun off from W.R. Grace in February 2016 with attractive market share across major product categories. Despite a favorable
Slide 122: Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today
Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today Starboard has a long history of driving operational, financial, and strategic turnarounds. We believe we have a better plan to create value. We believe we have a superior slate of directors. Vote on Starboard’s WHITE
Slide 123: Appendix
Appendix STARBOARDAYJALUE” a 123
Slide 124: A) Marvell
A) Marvell STARBOARDAYJALUE™ a 124
Slide 125: Starboard Successfully Reconstituted a Majority of Marvell's Board
Starboard Successfully Reconstituted a Majority of Marvell’s Board That Guided the Company to a Turnaround On April 27, 2016, Starboard agreed to a settlement with Marvell. As a result of the settlement, Marvell’s Board dramatically changed. The settlement originally added 5 new directors and 3 mo
Slide 126: Marvell's Reconstituted Board Drove Improvements in Operating and Financial Performance
Marvell’s Reconstituted Board Drove Improvements in Operating and Financial Performance The new Board empowered Marvell to improve its operations and profitability after years of underperformance. Marvell Before Board was Reconstituted Marvell After Board was Reconstituted Net Revenue Net Revenue $3
Slide 127: Marvell's Share Price Outperformed Peers Once the Board was Reconstituted
Marvell’s Share Price Outperformed Peers Once the Board was Reconstituted Marvell’s share price performed significantly better once the Board was reconstituted than in the three years prior.(1) 3-Year Stock Price Performance Prior to Board Reconstitution(2) 3-Year Stock Price Performance After Board
Slide 128: B) Darden
B) Darden STARBOARDAYJALUE™ 128
Slide 129: Starboard Successfully Reconstituted Darden's Board
Starboard Successfully Reconstituted Darden’s Board, Which Positioned the Company For a Turnaround On October 10, 2014, Darden’s shareholders elected all 12 Starboard-nominated directors to Darden's Board of Directors. Starboard nominated a full slate of 12 highly-qualified director candidates to
Slide 130: Darden's Reconstituted Board Drove Dramatically Improved Operational Performance
Darden’s Reconstituted Board Drove Dramatically Improved Operational Performance The new Board empowered Darden to improve its operations and profitability after years of underperformance. Darden Before Board was Reconstituted Darden After Board was Reconstituted Same-Store-Sales Same-Store-Sales 0.
Slide 131: Darden's Share Price Outperformed the Broader Index
Darden’s Share Price Outperformed the Broader Index Once the Board Was Reconstituted Darden’s share price outperformed the broader index once the Board was reconstituted, as compared to the three years prior.(1) 3-Year Stock Price Performance Prior to Board Reconstitution(2) 3-Year Stock Price Perfo
GCP Applied Technologies — Proxy Contest (April 2020) on 6ix